NINGNING NEW G5 - time after time vocal showcase 

Will*

@@TolemeHernandez ?

Right

theres no improvement here tho

@@udebrl yes there is-

HAHAHAHAHA!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I’ll check it outt

@@izonexbae we want now ryan, it's must be done in 1 sec!!!😍😘

@@slaypa hahaahah

Yes..please do this

I swear I heard taeyeon do a whistle or falsetto

Definitely Wendy’s imo, though both strained Wendy seemed more balanced while Ningning was kinda shrill and sounded pretty shouty

ofc wendy, she's a better singer and has been training for years in the industry

ningning has more ease bc her tessitura seems to be higher than wendy's

Ningning for me. I am a singer too and I can tell from her tone that she had really great technique with her voice and she probably has even wider range than Wendy. Even Ningning's.low notes are perfection compared to Wendy. If its low registers, Ningning and Taeyeon sounds so good on lows like really lows. Wendy is good at high notes. But Ningning, Taeyeon and BoA can fo her high notes too So if I rank SM's main vocals. 1. Taeyeon 2. Wendy, Ningning and Boa I put them all in 2nd cuz they are all so good its just they have their own strengths and weaknesses. Taeyeon is on another level of a vocalist.

@@Jesus-bq4gz not really, wendy is really chesty but hers was more balanced and ningning's was shrill, you can hear it in the recording footage that she sounded screamy (ning2)

She did hit G#5 pre debut update a Bb5

she hit a G#5 before

@@julusmalcolm OMG GIMME THE LINK

@@fantanyam3815 ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-4Ynbqn4zpFo.html and ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-tKkQiiurUgU.html

C+

After this... ningning will be B-

@João Gabriel Rodrigues Souza no one knows, Ningning may or may not improve

@@oyooo3395 she's too light to be B-, if she gets rid of her lighter approach then yes B-

She has more tho? ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-Wmjzi0eBRjs.html

@@izonexbae that's it??..poor ningning

@@TolemeHernandez she sung quite alot no? She has E5’s around 2-3 G5’s and has a full chorus

@@izonexbae don't bother explaining it's useless, she's clearly a hater

it doesnt sound messy at all lol, you‘re a lily and haewon stan. yall always discredit ningning

Exactly Like the lows at the beginning are just chef kiss The way she use almost everything in this song, low, mix, upper, runs🤞🏾such a queen

Ning is particularly really good at low notes even better than Wendy among SM main vocals. Ningning and Taeyeon is soooo good at low notes, like really low. Wendy is good but she excels on high notes but overall, they are all good its just Taeyeon is the best vocalist not just in SM but all of Kpop. just facts. Next wil be Wendy, BoA, Ningning ,Bada,Luna

@@danissegomez7953 definitely not Wendy support goes lower then ningnings,ningings goes as far as g3/g#3 where’s her e3 to f3 are relaxed or sometimes to shallow

@@danissegomez7953 lol it sounds like u don’t know a lot because in terms of who excels more in there lower register it’s Wendy she’s has the best lows out of all the female idols under sm

@@xxharaaaaa_03 ningning is consistent with f#3/g3

she had in predebut with a G#5, she has a Bb5 now too in salty&sweet

I’ll check it out, any timestamps in particular?

@@izonexbae yeah i mean only Taeyeon & Winter part is challenging there!

@@izonexbae yo at the end of Priority, I heard a whistle note at the background possibly sang by Taeyeon. But then again I was ascending heaven with their vocals, I might have fantasize it.