honestly obi wan would win, since obi wans form is defensive he uses alot of his agility to his advantage. Shout out darth vader though best movie villain
Personally, I think Vader would win because he’s just that much more powerful. Even though Obi- Wan would put up a good fight, Vader is still a better duelist
@@Hi-yk5os I disagree, of course your opinion will remain yours and I respect it, because Vader mastered all forms of lightsaber combat. Also Anakin was considered the greatest warrior in the Republic and was already on par with Kenobi in terms of dueling then, Darth Vader mastered dueling meaning that if Anakin=Obi Wan then Vader>Obi Wan. Finally in the novelisation Obi Wan himself believes that Anakin would kill him. Even if Darth Vader and Kenobi are equal in terms of dueling skill, it doesn’t make up for the huge difference in strength, durability and power between the two. Obviously I respect your opinion
@@tjk5006 I think the force power difference in the end is what gives Vader a huge edge and not the Dueling cuz Luke once said Jedis will always be the better duelists than Sith cuz „ration beats emotion“ but in terms of force Sith will always have the edge so if we take the force strength differences away I actually think Obi beats him like he did in Kenobi series Vaders immense power in the force tho would be too much for Obi Wan in a battle with force powers in consideration
I think some characters are underestimated here, like Savage Oppress and some Inquisitors and (as much as I hate the character and the sequels) Snoke. But a good edit nonetheless
Nice edit! Vader wins, Kenobi always had an advantage against him. On mustafar knightfall Vader was conflicted. On obi wan Kenobi series Kenobi was amped in the end.
Pre-Prime Vader literally beat Prime Obi Wan in ANH on the Death Star. Alot of Obi Wan stans use the "he gave up" argument, even though he gave up only when he knew that he couldnt defeat Vader in a canon novel If this is ROTJ Vader, he realistically no diffs Kenobi. For the sake of a funner fight, I would say that Vader still wins but with mid diff
Some Kenobi simps are so goofy and annoying. Especially when Kenobi is compared to Kylo. Prime Kylo easily no diffs the overwanked dude. Unless he has high ground
@@TheEgyptianGamerGeek lol yeah keep dreaming. You could have been more plausible if you at least said redeemed Ben solo. Kylo ren is fodder dueling wise, at least compared to kenobi, and in the force he’s not strong enough to ragdoll Kenobi (since even ANH Vader couldn’t do it, and I doubt that kylo ren is more powerful than ANH Vader lolz). Redeemed Ben solo is debatable tho.
@@SWScalingEdits Says the ignorant Kenobi stan who doesn’t know anything about Kylo! No he isn’t fodder clearly you didn’t read the Kylo comics. TROS Kylo can easily be scaled to Post ANH Vader who one shots PT. Redeemed Ben can be scaled to ESB Vader. You just underestimate Kylo just cause the ST weren’t that good or cause of Rey. Rey is the fodder cause she needed amp to beat Kylo in TFA. Plus huge amp to defeat Dyad Sidious who is literally >>>>> OT. Also Kylo was trained by Prime Luke Skywalker who became a way superior duelist than Overwanked Kenobi. Stop overrating Kenobi. Yes Kenobi is a great Jedi Master but he loses so badly to Prime Vader, Luke and Kylo. Cope. Read Kylo comics. You call yourself scaling edits yet you posted nothing so you keep dreaming ignorant. I grew up wth the PT but I’m not a biased ignorant idiot like you who overwanks Anakin or Kenobi just cause “MuH chosen one!” “Muh high ground” despite that Kenobi only beats Kylo if he has “high ground” or in Live action. But mid/high diff for Kenobi in live action imo. The ability to speak does not make you intelligent.
@@SWScalingEdits Also ANH Vader literally beat Kenobi. Kenobi only won because KFV/MFV was hindered or arrogant and in KS he was amped. Again. You keep dreaming, you’re probably one of those stans who thinks Kenobi beats Luke. Also the lowest you can scale Kylo is around Senate Yoda to MFV tier or KS Vader. Highest is Post ANH Vader.
Hold, up. In your edit Cal vs Kit, you gave win to Cal, why then now Kit has higher diff, I think they both should have mid-high diff, but still goated edit
Vader throughout his time as a sith lord has masterd all 7 forms of lightsaber combat and achieved 80% of Palpatine's power he even created his own lightsaber form which was the mix of Soresu, Makashi, and Djem So just the fact that Obi Wan was Vaders master dosen't change the fact that Vader was much stronger and a better duelist
@@dmitrysteinsapir2185 yes but as I said obiwan is wise and has more experience and he can control his self but vader Depends on strength of rage and hate he could destroy any sith lord except Palpatine because Palpatine is the dark side of the Current empire he knew much more then vader but jedi depend on wisdom and patience like yoda and mace
@@willisstillhere8846if prime Yoda is rots Yoda, then kenobi should be winning like mid-high diff due to scaling, feats and statements. Prime Vader wins pretty easily, yes. I don’t know about Ben solo. I don’t honestly know where he scales.
