Тёмный

Oldest Pyramid in the WORLD Discovered in India? | Ahichhatra and the Mahabharata 

World of Antiquity
Подписаться 228 тыс.
Просмотров 59 тыс.
50% 1

The stone step pyramid of Djoser, the king of Egypt, at Saqqara, is regarded as the oldest known pyramid in the world. But Praveen Mohan has argued that a terraced monument in Ahichhatra, Uttar Pradesh, India, is the oldest. Dr. Miano looks at the evidence to see if this claim is supported by the archaeological evidence. Find out which pyramid is older, and what the date of the Ahicchatra temple is.
After viewing, come back to the notes here for further information.
►DOWNLOAD Professor Miano's free e-booklet: "Why Ancient History Matters":
mailchi.mp/a402112ea4db/why-a...
►SUBSCRIBE to the World of Antiquity RU-vid Channel for great travel videos about ancient ruins and ancient history museums.
► SUPPORT THIS CHANNEL
Supporters get access to behind-the-scenes videos, early-release videos, course discounts and more! / worldofantiquity
Image credit: Archaeological Survey of India, Bhuvan Vikrana, Laxshmi Greaves, Wikimedia Commons.
On Ahichhatra:
www.livehistoryindia.com/hist...
On Temple 1:
kalashtsp.in/pdf/issue/vol_no...
On North Indian temple architecture in general:
orca.cf.ac.uk/87038/1/2015Grea...
On art at Ahichhatra:
ijasos.ocerintjournals.org/tr/...
orca.cf.ac.uk/131819/1/ORCA%2...
On ground-penetrating radar at Ahichhatra:
www.researchgate.net/publicat...
Professor Miano's handy guide for learning, "How to Know Stuff," is available here:
www.amazon.com/How-Know-Stuff...
Follow Professor Miano on social media:
►FACEBOOK: / drdavidmiano
►TWITTER: / drdavidmiano
►INSTAGRAM: / drmiano

Опубликовано:

 

25 янв 2021

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 902   
@jagrutitripathy3978
@jagrutitripathy3978 2 года назад
This channel is jealous of praveen mohan .
@twonumber22
@twonumber22 2 года назад
Babe wake up, new strawman just dropped.
@casualuser2317
@casualuser2317 2 года назад
More like you are blindly in love with him
@mitryours759
@mitryours759 2 года назад
Looks like you are one of those blind nationalist. Don't teach Praveen history to your children, he will be a laughing stock
@jamisojo
@jamisojo 2 года назад
What are your favorite drugs Jugruti?
@user-zu4ht7eh6c
@user-zu4ht7eh6c 2 года назад
Naaga is not snake people. It is ethnic group in india, Naagar. There is state in india called nagaland.
@WilliamSanderson-zh9dq
@WilliamSanderson-zh9dq 3 года назад
People like Mohan make me think, what if Herodotus, Polybius, and Livy were more like this guy than modern historians?
@joqqeman
@joqqeman 3 года назад
Some modern historians are like Mohan!
@WilliamSanderson-zh9dq
@WilliamSanderson-zh9dq 3 года назад
@@joqqeman but their works are subjected to modern peer review. My intended point was that the classical era historians weren’t subjected to review and that we are at times forced to take their word at face value as a result.
@georgethompson1460
@georgethompson1460 2 года назад
@@WilliamSanderson-zh9dq we definitely know Herodotus said a few tall tales.
@user-pakshibhithi10
@user-pakshibhithi10 2 года назад
@@WilliamSanderson-zh9dq Herodotus did say some weird stuff though.
@Katharina-rp7iq
@Katharina-rp7iq Год назад
Modern scientists are often people with personal ideas and stubborn determination to prove their ideas are right. They look for evidence that could prove it - the difference between real scientists and Mohan is that they work with real clues and findings, not their imagination and legends. They have to convince their peers using actual facts. That's really what all science is about - stubborn people with ideas finding facts to prove they're right (and sometimes that others are wrong).
@NoelleIsTheGeoArchon
@NoelleIsTheGeoArchon Год назад
I laugh so hard when Praveen Mohan called a clay tablet a literal modern TABLET like Ipad or Samsung Tab. Don't know if the guy just loves to troll.
@lilgnomey
@lilgnomey 3 года назад
‘He has appeared on ancient aliens...’ That... is all I needed to know.
@rosemcguinn5301
@rosemcguinn5301 2 года назад
👆
@dirtysouthclimbing
@dirtysouthclimbing 2 года назад
Great pyramid is a tomb. That’s all you need to know! 😂😂😂😂 The back patting is next level at this channel
@TheKing-xp7lq
@TheKing-xp7lq 2 года назад
@@dirtysouthclimbing It was converted into tombs
@rooktheradical1
@rooktheradical1 2 года назад
Dr. Sara Seagar (MIT)- doesn't believe in the extraterrestrial visitation theory AT ALL!!! .........has also appeared on Ancient Aliens.
@jamisojo
@jamisojo 2 года назад
@@dirtysouthclimbing I don't know about back patting... but the facts and integrity are certainly strong with this channel.
@gaurisankar6723
@gaurisankar6723 Год назад
To all the guys making fun of "NAGA" try visiting "Nagaland" one of the Seven Sisters of NE India and try to research about their history. If you guys don't know about something doesn't mean it's non-existent.
@appleeater8839
@appleeater8839 11 месяцев назад
😂😂😂nagas have their own language which means other than hindustani language family
@christophercripps7639
@christophercripps7639 3 года назад
Seems like another case of "my chosen site is the oldest & therefore inspired others." Doesn't convince me that Egyptian pyramids didn't inspire Indian ones or that as you note, anyone who has piled one block on another (or just soil) will independently discover pyramidal structures are the most stable & long lasting.
@harikareddy04
@harikareddy04 Год назад
You can check capt ajit vadakayil how Kerala kings built the Egypt pyramids and ayyappa built the pyramid of giza
@debaprasad9379
@debaprasad9379 Год назад
@@harikareddy04 bro really 😳😱
@Great_Olaf5
@Great_Olaf5 3 года назад
To be fair, the concept of a stepped pyramid is presumed to come from the idea of stacking mastaba tombs on top of one another, and mastabas were most frequently built out of mud bricks like the Indian one. So that idea isn't complete nonsense, just almost the entire rest of his theory.
@lostpony4885
@lostpony4885 2 года назад
Those have to be fired bricks.
@SWOTHDRA
@SWOTHDRA 7 месяцев назад
Its tomb....its a temple 😂🤡
@Lucasp110
@Lucasp110 6 месяцев назад
​@@lostpony4885they do be fire
@_Moraceae
@_Moraceae 2 месяца назад
​@@lostpony4885 In Bengal we used to have fire bricks from ancient times but this muslim Invaders ri write the history and later brith did and both tried to fit the history inside time frame of Jesus and Mohammad. But that's not true. Our history is older. I can give a proof if you look up for oldest king in Bengal you will see Shashanka. But we have much older structures here than of time of Shashanka. Like Chandraketu. And all the older mosque is build upon the places of worship of earlier kings so it got lost by time.
@_Moraceae
@_Moraceae 2 месяца назад
​@@lostpony4885then there is Tamluk Rajbari
@dr.zoidberg8666
@dr.zoidberg8666 2 года назад
I'll give this guy at least one bit of credit: There is no BJP-style radical propaganda on his twitter. There's plenty of new-agey ancient conspiracy theory stuff centered around "India is way older & more magical than we thought," but to his credit, there is no hateful politics... which all too often accompanies this type of content.
@MrGksarathy
@MrGksarathy 2 года назад
The new-agey Indian origin shit is impossible to separate from the BJP's Hindu nationalism. I'm personally curious if someone has caught him on camera without him knowing, and he's spouting off more hateful nonsense.
@tongstudio7140
@tongstudio7140 Год назад
Funny u said that. But his content actually highly inspired by Hindutva ideology. Because their core is Aryan Supremacy and Birthland India. But Aryan came frm outside. So they trying to establish a pseudo thesis that Aryans actually migrate frm India. Thats why they r desperately find any 'connection' between different civilizations, u can see that in this video too. when he started to compare oldest pyramid to this Temple. And how that Pyramid inspired by this temple.
@faithlesshound5621
@faithlesshound5621 Год назад
That's because Praveen Mohan is an American from Pittsburgh. He has nothing to gain from oppressing minorities in India.
@MrGksarathy
@MrGksarathy Год назад
@@faithlesshound5621 That doesn't stop a lot of them from simping for Modi or downplaying his human rights' violations. Also, his accent definitely sounds like he grew up in India.
@DiabloNemes
@DiabloNemes Год назад
Honestly I am confused that who is lying!! Maybe u guys don’t like BJP or Hindus and manipulating fact … u know … just like Some people claims Ram Setu as Adam’s bridge
@justastudent1979
@justastudent1979 2 года назад
Misleading Indians about their history is one of the easiest task, and many people take advantages of it by giving false and baseless information. Thank you for your efforts
@parmykumar8592
@parmykumar8592 Год назад
I wouldn't be surprised if the Vanaras are the same giants that roamed South America because Hanuman did go there, killed the unrighteous King & placed his son on the throne as recorded in ancient Sanskrit texts of India & evidence shows it maybe true! There is nothing strange in the fact that much of the religious mythology of the Mexicans and Peruvians was undoubtedly of Asiatic origin. Both the Inca and Mayan civilisations, even their languages had much in common with our own, inherited from the same far eastern cradle of the race” Miles Poindexter - American ambassador to Peru. ~ "Ships that could cross the Indian Ocean were able to cross the Pacific too. Moreover, these ships were really larger and probably more sea-worthy than those of Columbus and Magellan." "Ships of size that carried Fahien from India to China (through stormy China water) were certainly capable of proceeding all the way to Mexico and Peru by crossing the Pacific. One thousand years before the birth of Columbus Indian ships were far superior to any made in Europe up to the 18th century." Dr. Robert Heine Geldern anthropologist. ~ “ That primitive Aryan words and people came to America especially from Indo - Arya by the island chains of Polynesia. The very name of the boat in Mexico is “catamaran” a South Indian ( Tamil ) word. After 30 years of research i can now claim to have proved my theory of Hindu colonisation of America. The stones in every corner of America speak of Hindu influences “. Miles Poindexter - United States Ambassador. ~ "Of the cursory observations on the Hindus, which it would require volumes to expand and illustrate, this is the result, that they had an immemorial affinity with the old Persians, Ethiopians and Egyptians, the Phoenicians, Greeks, and Tuscans, the Scythians, or Goths, and Celts, the Chinese, Japanese, and Peruvians.” Indologist and Sanskritist Sir William Jones - Asiatic Researches, Volume I ~ In 1930, ambassador of U.S Miles Poindexter wrote his book, the ancient Indians crossed the Pacific Ocean and came to South America. He showed the similarities between QUICHUA language of South America and Sanskrit India. He described INCA ruler hymns and Vedic hymns as one, and he finally wrote the people of Maya and Inca civilization were undoubtedly Hindus. In the museum of Vedic hymns as one, and he finally wrote the people of Maya and Inca civilization were undoubtedly Hindus. ~ Sir Stamford raffles, the father of Singapore wrote “every poem of the Peruvians have the imprint of Ramayana and Mahabharata”. ~ Its interesting to note that the biggest festival each year observed by the Incas was called the Rama-Sitva which they have now disguised as the Inti Raymi. Sir William Jones however has preserved this historical fact in the following quote -: "Rama is represented as a descendant from the Sun, as the husband of Sita, and the son of a princess named Causelya. It is very remarkable that Peruvians, whose Incas boasted of the same descent, styled their greatest festival Rama-Sitva - hence we may take it that South America was peopled by the same race who imported into the farthest parts of Asia the rites and the fabulous history of Rama." (source: Asiatic Researches Volume I. p. 339-340
@rajangamingbaba1741
@rajangamingbaba1741 2 месяца назад
One thing teel me oldest language in the world 🌎 do you ?
@ATLevi-qw2su
@ATLevi-qw2su 3 года назад
Nationalism is one hell of a drug
@WildAlchemicalSpirit
@WildAlchemicalSpirit 3 года назад
What's interesting is that Praveen doesn't even live in India. He grew up in the U.S. He was raised as a Hindu, though, but he's apparently anti-Muslim and part of his agenda is asserting Hindu superiority over Muslim faith.
@andybeans5790
@andybeans5790 3 года назад
It's even better when mixed with a heavy dose of religiosity
@terryenglish7132
@terryenglish7132 3 года назад
@@WildAlchemicalSpirit Where did you get his background info ? I tried googling him but could only find out he was born in the US, but nothing about where he grew up, his current living place or even his nationality.
@terryenglish7132
@terryenglish7132 3 года назад
@@WildAlchemicalSpirit Thanks ! ...I did notice when some of the recent heavy shit between the Hindus and Muslims was going down he did have what I considered an anti Muslim outlook in that weeks video, but in others he ll go out of his way to say " another faith" or " another culture" so as to not inflame.
@mercedesbenz3751
@mercedesbenz3751 2 года назад
@@WildAlchemicalSpirit You simply claim anyone to be anti-muslim, but you never say why a person is anti-muslim. This makes me mad.
@Rashtrakuta
@Rashtrakuta Год назад
Could you please do a video on the history of the Kannada people (Speakers of Kannada, Tulu, Kodava, Konkani, Coorgi) and their history from genetic origin to their dynasties and incredible ancient architecture to the modern day? I have a strong feeling you will uncover some true gems of info. Thanks in advance!!
@benghazi4216
@benghazi4216 2 года назад
The easiest explanation for that cobra gods exist in both cultures, is that the snake itself exists in both places.
@Allinonetvz
@Allinonetvz 2 года назад
No but india is the reason why snakes evolved 😂😂😂
@bridiptabharali3433
@bridiptabharali3433 Год назад
@@Allinonetvz into Pakistan I know😣😣😣
@ricovictormenil7975
@ricovictormenil7975 Год назад
I agree.
@parmykumar8592
@parmykumar8592 Год назад
@@Allinonetvz I wouldn't be surprised if the Vanaras are the same giants that roamed South America because Hanuman did go there, killed the unrighteous King & placed his son on the throne as recorded in ancient Sanskrit texts of India & evidence shows it maybe true! There is nothing strange in the fact that much of the religious mythology of the Mexicans and Peruvians was undoubtedly of Asiatic origin. Both the Inca and Mayan civilisations, even their languages had much in common with our own, inherited from the same far eastern cradle of the race” Miles Poindexter - American ambassador to Peru. ~ "Ships that could cross the Indian Ocean were able to cross the Pacific too. Moreover, these ships were really larger and probably more sea-worthy than those of Columbus and Magellan." "Ships of size that carried Fahien from India to China (through stormy China water) were certainly capable of proceeding all the way to Mexico and Peru by crossing the Pacific. One thousand years before the birth of Columbus Indian ships were far superior to any made in Europe up to the 18th century." Dr. Robert Heine Geldern anthropologist. ~ “ That primitive Aryan words and people came to America especially from Indo - Arya by the island chains of Polynesia. The very name of the boat in Mexico is “catamaran” a South Indian ( Tamil ) word. After 30 years of research i can now claim to have proved my theory of Hindu colonisation of America. The stones in every corner of America speak of Hindu influences “. Miles Poindexter - United States Ambassador. ~ "Of the cursory observations on the Hindus, which it would require volumes to expand and illustrate, this is the result, that they had an immemorial affinity with the old Persians, Ethiopians and Egyptians, the Phoenicians, Greeks, and Tuscans, the Scythians, or Goths, and Celts, the Chinese, Japanese, and Peruvians.” Indologist and Sanskritist Sir William Jones - Asiatic Researches, Volume I ~ In 1930, ambassador of U.S Miles Poindexter wrote his book, the ancient Indians crossed the Pacific Ocean and came to South America. He showed the similarities between QUICHUA language of South America and Sanskrit India. He described INCA ruler hymns and Vedic hymns as one, and he finally wrote the people of Maya and Inca civilization were undoubtedly Hindus. In the museum of Vedic hymns as one, and he finally wrote the people of Maya and Inca civilization were undoubtedly Hindus. ~ Sir Stamford raffles, the father of Singapore wrote “every poem of the Peruvians have the imprint of Ramayana and Mahabharata”. ~ Its interesting to note that the biggest festival each year observed by the Incas was called the Rama-Sitva which they have now disguised as the Inti Raymi. Sir William Jones however has preserved this historical fact in the following quote -: "Rama is represented as a descendant from the Sun, as the husband of Sita, and the son of a princess named Causelya. It is very remarkable that Peruvians, whose Incas boasted of the same descent, styled their greatest festival Rama-Sitva - hence we may take it that South America was peopled by the same race who imported into the farthest parts of Asia the rites and the fabulous history of Rama." (source: Asiatic Researches Volume I. p. 339-340
@randy5894
@randy5894 10 месяцев назад
That's so weak.
@maryw1867
@maryw1867 3 года назад
I was watching a video about indigenous tribes in the Amazon and they told about an oral tradition. I wonder how much of the oral tradition is changed to fit the times, similar to Catholic Theology except they write it down. Check/Double Check.
@wodenravens
@wodenravens 3 года назад
There are methods used in such societies to ensure oral tradition is maintained. One example in the shamanic culture in which I live (a Korean island) is that traditionally the shamans would gather and retell their stories to ensure there was consistency. In preliterate societies we were far more able to maintain consistency and preserve oral stories. But this kind of group gathering (done in various ways by other oral cultures) also enforces some mechanism of control over it. I am sure Amazonian tribes use similar methods. But having said that, there are always times when the numbers of storytellers will dwindle or gifted storytellers will dominate a generation. Just like all social organisations, there is the risk of political and personal influence over others. This makes me agree that oral tales can be passed down for centuries, maybe longer, especially in the key aspects of stories, such as geographic features, basic structure, etc. But culture is very pervasive and those aspects of the stories that become misunderstood or irrelevant to the contemporary society also get left out over time. This reminds me of an interesting titbit about Newgrange (Ireland).DNA analysis showed that the interned was the product of first-degree incest 5,000 years ago. The passage tomb nearby was called 'Hill of Sin" and it was said by local tradition to have been made by a king who slept with his sister. www.nature.com/articles/d41586-020-01655-4
@MrAngryCucaracha
@MrAngryCucaracha 3 года назад
@@wodenravens that is super interesting. Do you have any idea what books could i read about oral traditions like those?
@parmykumar8592
@parmykumar8592 Год назад
@@wodenravens I wouldn't be surprised if the Vanaras are the same giants that roamed South America because Hanuman did go there, killed the unrighteous King & placed his son on the throne as recorded in ancient Sanskrit texts of India & evidence shows it maybe true! There is nothing strange in the fact that much of the religious mythology of the Mexicans and Peruvians was undoubtedly of Asiatic origin. Both the Inca and Mayan civilisations, even their languages had much in common with our own, inherited from the same far eastern cradle of the race” Miles Poindexter - American ambassador to Peru. ~ "Ships that could cross the Indian Ocean were able to cross the Pacific too. Moreover, these ships were really larger and probably more sea-worthy than those of Columbus and Magellan." "Ships of size that carried Fahien from India to China (through stormy China water) were certainly capable of proceeding all the way to Mexico and Peru by crossing the Pacific. One thousand years before the birth of Columbus Indian ships were far superior to any made in Europe up to the 18th century." Dr. Robert Heine Geldern anthropologist. ~ “ That primitive Aryan words and people came to America especially from Indo - Arya by the island chains of Polynesia. The very name of the boat in Mexico is “catamaran” a South Indian ( Tamil ) word. After 30 years of research i can now claim to have proved my theory of Hindu colonisation of America. The stones in every corner of America speak of Hindu influences “. Miles Poindexter - United States Ambassador. ~ "Of the cursory observations on the Hindus, which it would require volumes to expand and illustrate, this is the result, that they had an immemorial affinity with the old Persians, Ethiopians and Egyptians, the Phoenicians, Greeks, and Tuscans, the Scythians, or Goths, and Celts, the Chinese, Japanese, and Peruvians.” Indologist and Sanskritist Sir William Jones - Asiatic Researches, Volume I ~ In 1930, ambassador of U.S Miles Poindexter wrote his book, the ancient Indians crossed the Pacific Ocean and came to South America. He showed the similarities between QUICHUA language of South America and Sanskrit India. He described INCA ruler hymns and Vedic hymns as one, and he finally wrote the people of Maya and Inca civilization were undoubtedly Hindus. In the museum of Vedic hymns as one, and he finally wrote the people of Maya and Inca civilization were undoubtedly Hindus. ~ Sir Stamford raffles, the father of Singapore wrote “every poem of the Peruvians have the imprint of Ramayana and Mahabharata”. ~ Its interesting to note that the biggest festival each year observed by the Incas was called the Rama-Sitva which they have now disguised as the Inti Raymi. Sir William Jones however has preserved this historical fact in the following quote -: "Rama is represented as a descendant from the Sun, as the husband of Sita, and the son of a princess named Causelya. It is very remarkable that Peruvians, whose Incas boasted of the same descent, styled their greatest festival Rama-Sitva - hence we may take it that South America was peopled by the same race who imported into the farthest parts of Asia the rites and the fabulous history of Rama." (source: Asiatic Researches Volume I. p. 339-340
@russellmillar7132
@russellmillar7132 3 года назад
Dr. M., in a fair world, you would be the one with 1,000,000 views...but alas, your evidence based logic seems to fly over the heads of those who have determined that mainstream scholars are protecting orthodoxy by sticking with the official story and free thinkers, like Mohan etc. are brave, courageous and bold. WTF...over.
@WorldofAntiquity
@WorldofAntiquity 3 года назад
Aw, thanks, Russell.
@JulianoVieiraDuarte
@JulianoVieiraDuarte 3 года назад
Indeed, indeed. What I hope for and count on is the fact that serious, academically responsible content creators have a much wider horizon and potential for long-term growth. There's only so much ground for conspiracy, nationalism, excepcionalism and the respective pandering to. It does seem to operate in waves, but the demand for competent and qualified content is perennial, while its public is way less volatile. The charlatan is always digging his own grave, walking a tight rope, trying to appease the expectations of the deplorable world view of his dissimulated target audience.
@russellmillar7132
@russellmillar7132 3 года назад
@@JulianoVieiraDuarte Claro que si, estamos en la pagina misma!
@trira1171
@trira1171 3 года назад
Not at all. Praveen deserves his views. The established orthodox Phds dont deserve any views because they are simply regurgitating nonsense without any original thoughts. Even in this case, Firstly, the established date for Pyramids of Egypt is wrong. The pyramids belong to 800 BCE. (not 2000+ BCE). Secondly, the Indian history is highly distorted by fake theories like Aryan Invasion. India is where human civ began. So, it is certainly not improbable that oldest 'pyramids' might be in India. Anyway, the point is not if they are oldest or not. The point is to come up with some fresh research and original thought process.
@WorldofAntiquity
@WorldofAntiquity 3 года назад
@@trira1171 Please tell us how you know that the pyramids belong to 800 BCE. Also, now that you know Praveen gave the wrong date for this pyramid, do you think he deserves the views for this video?
@arminmir9179
@arminmir9179 3 года назад
Thanks for the video, i like the way you disprove BS with facts and scientific research. Looking forward to similar contents. maybe keeping them under 15 minutes long would help with increasing the number of viewers. Cheers
@rajangamingbaba1741
@rajangamingbaba1741 2 месяца назад
Oldest religion and language in the world 🌎Sanskrit (5000 years old) World's Oldest Language Source Unlike Tamil, which is still a widely spoken language, Sanskrit is the oldest language in the world but fell out of common usage around 600 BC It is now a liturgical language the holy languages found in thescriptures of Hinduism, Buddhism and Jainism
@OldieBugger
@OldieBugger 3 года назад
Actually, any pile of rocks can be called a pyramid, technically.
@phanikishan8432
@phanikishan8432 2 года назад
Praveen's videos are for me exploratory especially in India as very less people explore these ancient sites. I'm always skeptical about his conclusions. But they are very intriGuinG.
@shaolin1derpalm
@shaolin1derpalm 2 года назад
Yeah. Not big on the conclusions, but no I'm gonna research the site (aka read on internet). I'm not big on fantastical claims.
@StoneInMySandal
@StoneInMySandal Год назад
Agreed! I like the places he goes that I’ve never heard of. But his conclusions I do not like so much.
@parmykumar8592
@parmykumar8592 Год назад
@@StoneInMySandal I wouldn't be surprised if the Vanaras are the same giants that roamed South America because Hanuman did go there, killed the unrighteous King & placed his son on the throne as recorded in ancient Sanskrit texts of India & evidence shows it maybe true! There is nothing strange in the fact that much of the religious mythology of the Mexicans and Peruvians was undoubtedly of Asiatic origin. Both the Inca and Mayan civilisations, even their languages had much in common with our own, inherited from the same far eastern cradle of the race” Miles Poindexter - American ambassador to Peru. ~ "Ships that could cross the Indian Ocean were able to cross the Pacific too. Moreover, these ships were really larger and probably more sea-worthy than those of Columbus and Magellan." "Ships of size that carried Fahien from India to China (through stormy China water) were certainly capable of proceeding all the way to Mexico and Peru by crossing the Pacific. One thousand years before the birth of Columbus Indian ships were far superior to any made in Europe up to the 18th century." Dr. Robert Heine Geldern anthropologist. ~ “ That primitive Aryan words and people came to America especially from Indo - Arya by the island chains of Polynesia. The very name of the boat in Mexico is “catamaran” a South Indian ( Tamil ) word. After 30 years of research i can now claim to have proved my theory of Hindu colonisation of America. The stones in every corner of America speak of Hindu influences “. Miles Poindexter - United States Ambassador. ~ "Of the cursory observations on the Hindus, which it would require volumes to expand and illustrate, this is the result, that they had an immemorial affinity with the old Persians, Ethiopians and Egyptians, the Phoenicians, Greeks, and Tuscans, the Scythians, or Goths, and Celts, the Chinese, Japanese, and Peruvians.” Indologist and Sanskritist Sir William Jones - Asiatic Researches, Volume I ~ In 1930, ambassador of U.S Miles Poindexter wrote his book, the ancient Indians crossed the Pacific Ocean and came to South America. He showed the similarities between QUICHUA language of South America and Sanskrit India. He described INCA ruler hymns and Vedic hymns as one, and he finally wrote the people of Maya and Inca civilization were undoubtedly Hindus. In the museum of Vedic hymns as one, and he finally wrote the people of Maya and Inca civilization were undoubtedly Hindus. ~ Sir Stamford raffles, the father of Singapore wrote “every poem of the Peruvians have the imprint of Ramayana and Mahabharata”. ~ Its interesting to note that the biggest festival each year observed by the Incas was called the Rama-Sitva which they have now disguised as the Inti Raymi. Sir William Jones however has preserved this historical fact in the following quote -: "Rama is represented as a descendant from the Sun, as the husband of Sita, and the son of a princess named Causelya. It is very remarkable that Peruvians, whose Incas boasted of the same descent, styled their greatest festival Rama-Sitva - hence we may take it that South America was peopled by the same race who imported into the farthest parts of Asia the rites and the fabulous history of Rama." (source: Asiatic Researches Volume I. p. 339-340
@SlaveOfDevas
@SlaveOfDevas 7 месяцев назад
​@@parmykumar8592Try harder the supreme god Indra and rudra are older than Mahabharata and ramayana. No matter how you spin it
@navaneetbaruah9411
@navaneetbaruah9411 7 месяцев назад
@@SlaveOfDevas Indra and Rudra are the oldest gods according to Rig Veda, which indeed, is older than either of the two epics, Ramayana and Mahabharata. But then the later edition of Vedas also include Vishnu, Shiva, Brahma, which were likely taken from local tribal legends, in a bid for assimilation. But the worship of lingam, pashupati, mother goddess which was later assimilated into brahmanical culture were much older than the Rig Veda. Therefore it is evident that the hierarchy of the Gods kept changing
@user-hq8wm8giyujcg
@user-hq8wm8giyujcg Год назад
Here some of the best native Indian architecture from all over India. They usually have hundreds and thousands of carved statues Khajuraho temples Konark Sun Temple Hoysaleswara temple Chennakeshava Temple Brihadeeswara Temple Ajanta and Ellora caves and rock cut architecture (Kailasa Temple) Sanchi Stupas
@skeptic2561
@skeptic2561 Год назад
Ya indeed they are great architectural marvels but that wouldn't validate praveen mohan's claim about india being a space travelling and time travelling country in ancient era
@SarahGreen523
@SarahGreen523 2 года назад
Each video is a college level lecture on all the subjects that I've always wanted to get straight in my head.
@bobjuniel8683
@bobjuniel8683 2 года назад
If Praveen did not present these thought provoking programs we would not know that these places exist. He causes us to discover historic sights and to question their significance and purpose. Praveen observes many details and features that tourists would not even notice. Having studied the Pyramid of Djoser, and visiting it I agree the only thing in common is that they are stepped pyramids, similar in that respect to the Sumerian Ziggurats. David, your clarification and additional information puts these places into context and opens avenues for further study. It is for us RU-vidrs an exciting journey of discovery. While some exaggeration and imagination may be too extreme, it is a bit like Herodotus, he tells us what the people believe and that gives us a picture of the people, the place and time of the story teller. Praveen tells us what he observes and what he thinks, but he leaves it up to us to decide on the facts. "Never let the facts get in the way of a good story" 🧚‍♀️👼🧜‍♂️🧞‍♀️🎅🏻🧙‍♀️🐲🌞⛪️🕌🕍🛕🕋🏛🏰🔺 It's entertainment
@gaurisankar6723
@gaurisankar6723 Год назад
Bob you are right but people are too dumb to understand what Praveen is being doing. Hope people start using atleast a portion of their brain cells before commenting anything
@lanceedward6199
@lanceedward6199 Год назад
Well said!
@AhmetCnarOzuneUyans
@AhmetCnarOzuneUyans Год назад
👍👍👍👍
@pomponi0
@pomponi0 Год назад
Catching people's attention with misinformation may be effective, but it's also a tremendous waste of time and validates many people's paranoid delusions. My uncle told me about the Egyptians' electrical knowledge, Indian flying ships and Atlantis when I was 9. You don't want to know where he was on January 6th.
@LudwigVaanArthans
@LudwigVaanArthans Год назад
@@pomponi0 he was out there fighting the good fight against the reptilians
@rohanxdavis
@rohanxdavis Год назад
Great video, I love Praveen's curiosity and enjoy seeing where he travels next, but it's true that the assumptions are fantastical, I like to take it with a grain of salt
@TheEricthefruitbat
@TheEricthefruitbat 3 года назад
Another good video, Dr. Miano
@WorldofAntiquity
@WorldofAntiquity 3 года назад
Glad you enjoyed it!
@jsoth2675
@jsoth2675 3 года назад
Thanks again for your time, man. Always great content. A quick question/observation. How is it possible alternative history channels get so much attention, yet well researched and thought out "mainstream" channels, such as this, only have 7k subs? Why are people so interested in relative nonsense and not in the data? Thanks again for your content.
@WorldofAntiquity
@WorldofAntiquity 3 года назад
I wish I knew, but my guess is that they are more sensational and hence more clickable.
@andybeans5790
@andybeans5790 3 года назад
Also they appeal to a large market, Indian nationalism
@lilgnomey
@lilgnomey 3 года назад
People want to believe that our history isn’t as straight forward as it is. They fail to see the beauty in how far we’ve come and the immense odds and time it took to get here. Nuts like this guy love to think they’ve seen possibilities that all the ‘indoctrinated’ people have been too blind to see.
@dirtysouthclimbing
@dirtysouthclimbing 2 года назад
Back patting is loud here.
@SarahGreen523
@SarahGreen523 2 года назад
@@dirtysouthclimbing Perhaps, but if you consider how much absolute garbage is out there purporting to be ancient history, it is serendipitous to find a RU-vidr who isn't perpetuating nonsense. I know I was thrilled to find this channel and do my fair share of back patting; It's well deserved. People appreciate his knowledge and want to tell him so. Why does that bother you?
@benjaminwilliams6804
@benjaminwilliams6804 3 года назад
Mohan has a long history of making up easily disprovable “facts” for his videos and outright lying to his fans. In the last year alone he’s tried to make a movement of support over 2 separate videos claiming RU-vid was shutting down his channel. Yet, many of his fans remain fiercely loyal in the face of this. In one video on the Prasat Thom temple at Koh Ker, Cambodia, he goes on about a 30-foot tall crystal lingam from the site that had been "confirmed by archaeologists”. No such artifact has ever been referenced, discovered, or even written about by the Khmer as he is claiming, much less "confirmed by archaeologists". He made that up entirely. In another about Vatadage temple in Polonnaruwa, Sri Lanka, he uses camera tricks and differences in color between stucco and bare carvings to tell his viewers that the 4 Buddhas in the temple are holding something (although none of them are) and then goes on the speculate that it must be some ancient technology from the gods of Mount Meru. Quite a few more out there, too.
@WorldofAntiquity
@WorldofAntiquity 3 года назад
Wow. I did not know that.
@PathsUnwritten
@PathsUnwritten 3 года назад
@@WorldofAntiquity Strange, I tried making this comment under this ID but it didn't show up.
@dubdeluxe6192
@dubdeluxe6192 3 года назад
another great video David! Thank you!
@scienceexplains302
@scienceexplains302 3 года назад
The two pyramids at 10:30 are both tiered and there seems to be a sloping transition between tiers, altho on the top one, I can’t see whether that is sediment or part of the original structure. But the lower one is wider, has much more detail and looks much newer. The detail seems to indicate a different construction style. I would expect the people supposedly inspiring the Egyptian period to teach them 1) the process that keeps the pyramid looking new, and 2) the process enabling detail Since the one below looks so much more recent and detailed, I would need strong evidence* to show that it is not. * chemical dating, specific written records, etc
@bradleywiesner3774
@bradleywiesner3774 2 года назад
Thank you. I know these videos and the research that you do for the videos is real actual WORK. I love Praveen and the Late Great Chuck for showing me things I would never have seen without their hard work. Thank you for providing the evidence-based information that so many archaeologists have worked so hard to obtain as contrast to the imaginative postulations that saturate my RU-vid feed on these subjects. I would really enjoy hearing what you might know about "knobs and scoops" and "keys" found in large stone constructions all over the world. Maybe you already have a video or two about these things. I will be looking for them. Meanwhile here's a treat for you. An electrical engineer that goes by "made by one man" on RU-vid has made a video about how Coral Castle was made. Clever and mundane. No aliens or levitation involved. I hope you see this message. Thanks again.
@parmykumar8592
@parmykumar8592 Год назад
I wouldn't be surprised if the Vanaras are the same giants that roam South America because Hanuman did go there, killed the unrighteous King & placed his son on the throne as recorded in ancient Sanskrit texts of India & evidence shows it maybe true! There is nothing strange in the fact that much of the religious mythology of the Mexicans and Peruvians was undoubtedly of Asiatic origin. Both the Inca and Mayan civilisations, even their languages had much in common with our own, inherited from the same far eastern cradle of the race” Miles Poindexter - American ambassador to Peru. ~ "Ships that could cross the Indian Ocean were able to cross the Pacific too. Moreover, these ships were really larger and probably more sea-worthy than those of Columbus and Magellan." "Ships of size that carried Fahien from India to China (through stormy China water) were certainly capable of proceeding all the way to Mexico and Peru by crossing the Pacific. One thousand years before the birth of Columbus Indian ships were far superior to any made in Europe up to the 18th century." Dr. Robert Heine Geldern anthropologist. ~ “ That primitive Aryan words and people came to America especially from Indo - Arya by the island chains of Polynesia. The very name of the boat in Mexico is “catamaran” a South Indian ( Tamil ) word. After 30 years of research i can now claim to have proved my theory of Hindu colonisation of America. The stones in every corner of America speak of Hindu influences “. Miles Poindexter - United States Ambassador. ~ "Of the cursory observations on the Hindus, which it would require volumes to expand and illustrate, this is the result, that they had an immemorial affinity with the old Persians, Ethiopians and Egyptians, the Phoenicians, Greeks, and Tuscans, the Scythians, or Goths, and Celts, the Chinese, Japanese, and Peruvians.” Indologist and Sanskritist Sir William Jones - Asiatic Researches, Volume I ~ In 1930, ambassador of U.S Miles Poindexter wrote his book, the ancient Indians crossed the Pacific Ocean and came to South America. He showed the similarities between QUICHUA language of South America and Sanskrit India. He described INCA ruler hymns and Vedic hymns as one, and he finally wrote the people of Maya and Inca civilization were undoubtedly Hindus. In the museum of Vedic hymns as one, and he finally wrote the people of Maya and Inca civilization were undoubtedly Hindus. ~ Sir Stamford raffles, the father of Singapore wrote “every poem of the Peruvians have the imprint of Ramayana and Mahabharata”. ~ Its interesting to note that the biggest festival each year observed by the Incas was called the Rama-Sitva which they have now disguised as the Inti Raymi. Sir William Jones however has preserved this historical fact in the following quote -: "Rama is represented as a descendant from the Sun, as the husband of Sita, and the son of a princess named Causelya. It is very remarkable that Peruvians, whose Incas boasted of the same descent, styled their greatest festival Rama-Sitva - hence we may take it that South America was peopled by the same race who imported into the farthest parts of Asia the rites and the fabulous history of Rama." (source: Asiatic Researches Volume I. p. 339-340
@aedits581
@aedits581 Год назад
@@parmykumar8592 Hanuman ji was a brahmachari..... He had no son I didn't wanted to rebutt u coz it might look that I'm against sanatan and people might think that sanatan dharma contains all false information but I can't let u say any bullsh**...... Plz check ur facts..... Correct me if I'm wrong With all respect Jai shree ram
@parmykumar8592
@parmykumar8592 Год назад
@Dictator got the link on ya phone, yeah? RU-vid kuteh normally delete it!
@aedits581
@aedits581 Год назад
@@parmykumar8592 ??
@ivokolarik8290
@ivokolarik8290 2 года назад
Good video. Through his channel you will find some good footage of ancient sites that you would most likely wouldn't get to see
@flightographist
@flightographist Год назад
Some will never comprehend Doc., I truly admire your efforts, truly enlightening and invigorating! Reminds me of my decade in the stacks.
@garymaidman625
@garymaidman625 Год назад
This alternative history/archaeology community (some would say cult), including the followers, accuse mainstream academia of being dogmatic, when they are themselves incredibly dogmatic.
@WildAlchemicalSpirit
@WildAlchemicalSpirit 3 года назад
I wrote a paper on the use of rhetoric for pseudoarchaeological claims and confirmation bias and Praveen was my example. Even knowing what I do, I am still guilty of enjoying his videos for the entertainment value and the temples he visits. 💁
@terryenglish7132
@terryenglish7132 3 года назад
Lol, I m entertained as well. He does almost always put in some half baked theorys about what things were or what they were for, so his conclusions are usually bogus designed to reinforce wild speculation, but he does have a good eye for detail. Assuming he's giving the correct dates for various temples , he's found telescopes depicted before they were supposedly invented, and people from other lands in India before they were historically there.
@WildAlchemicalSpirit
@WildAlchemicalSpirit 3 года назад
@@terryenglish7132 I agree. I actually concluded my paper with something like, although Praveen is a case example of confirmation bias and pseudoscience, one may nonetheless still find value in his videos and enjoyment seeing the many temples he visits.
@mikedrop4421
@mikedrop4421 2 года назад
He's so damn likeable
@kklh7918
@kklh7918 2 года назад
@@WildAlchemicalSpirit I think there is no need to make claims like pseudoscience at all. He does history videos from a different perspective. some things he's talked about is pretty smoking gun stuff and others are a little weird. But he makes it clear that his claims aren't 100% undisputed fact
@DJMarcO138
@DJMarcO138 2 года назад
@@mikedrop4421 Is he though? He reminds me of every annoying tech "recruiter" I have ever dealt with.
@johntellnott12345
@johntellnott12345 2 года назад
6:49 Utterly beautiful and very impressive the size of the things they built back then. Like you I'm not sold on the lost higher cavillation theory. Without better evidence of course. But it sure is interesting thinking about the capabilities of folk back then. I do however think that accent concrete theory is very possible for Egyptian temple works and pyramids. I know it's on your list. You should also put the Chinese Pyramids on the list too as we don't know how old they are, OR DO WE?
@harshmeena4
@harshmeena4 Год назад
*Shivling don't means any organ it means 3 things* *1. When the Universe was created from nothing, shivling shape fire appeared and from it all material worlds came into existence* *2. When a person reaches its highest chakras, his aura made shape of shivling and god shiva ji is beyond it thats why it names as shivling ling means(symbol) mean shivji symbol* *3. Shivling also said to be represents universe shape which means the person who worships shivling is worshiping the universe*
@suryadevararao1795
@suryadevararao1795 2 года назад
The problem with Praveen is he never bothered to mention what historians/historical books/archeological survey of India details are and the insight of designer/building specialists ( called STHAPATIS in India) of ancient and modern temples.
@shaolin1derpalm
@shaolin1derpalm 2 года назад
@Anand Kumar who's claiming more advanced? Fact is fact. It's not older. Not even older than Harappan culture which I'm very fascinated by. I'm also impressed with this pyramid. Just not with HIS false assertions. Nothing to do with Western, cuz Egypt, mesopotamia and Harappan are all non western. I agree with taking back your history from colonizers, but fact in is fact. Older building underneath pyramid, built in C.E, his attempt to compare Egyptian monuments. He is insulting the ingenuity and creativity of the Egyptians by makling these assertions, making him no better than "people like us". If you can't accept that another culture can independently come up with the same thing as you, you're no better.
@sp_liberated
@sp_liberated 2 года назад
Why does he care about historians? He goes with nationalistic gut feel. No peer review needed not any need for credentials.
@russelledwards001
@russelledwards001 2 года назад
@Anand Kumar it’s not in the ground though, so it’s all bullshit till you find it.
@errrrrshhhhh
@errrrrshhhhh 2 года назад
@Anand Kumar Really praveen's logic is like pseudo logic which only get satisfy by hard-core nationalist.
@faithlesshound5621
@faithlesshound5621 Год назад
Praveen is neither a historian nor an archaeologist. He never discloses his academic background, but says he was brought up in a "strict Hindu family" in Pittsburgh so probably had an American education. What's most American about him is the protestant tendency to fundamentalism, that is taking everything written literally but making amazing leaps of faith when there are gaps in the evidence, and always in the same direction: India oldest, India best. Influencers of his ilk have no need of evidence or education: the less of those he displays the more dollars flow into his revenue streams, including "ancient aliens" as well as "everything came from India."
@MrShankaPerera
@MrShankaPerera 3 года назад
I have seen Praveen's demonstration on Baghdad "battery", which was hilarious. Thanks for this video :)
@shaswatshrey9712
@shaswatshrey9712 Год назад
how was it hilarious?
@PraveenJose18551
@PraveenJose18551 3 года назад
What's your view on how to interpret Hindu oral tradition in relation to historical events? Like is it historically sound to derive real world events and dating from the events described in the Hindu epics?
@WorldofAntiquity
@WorldofAntiquity 3 года назад
As with all documents, especially those removed in time from the events, there is going to be a mixture of fact and fiction. It is not always easy to separate them. Oral tradition is even more susceptible to change than written tradition.
@richiknair9036
@richiknair9036 2 года назад
@@WorldofAntiquity I agree. As long as that scrutiny is applied to all oral traditions of the world like the Jews, etc. There's always gonna be embellishments in some oral legends
@WorldofAntiquity
@WorldofAntiquity 2 года назад
@@richiknair9036 It is applied to all oral traditions.
@Thex-W.I.T.C.H.-xMaster
@Thex-W.I.T.C.H.-xMaster 2 года назад
@@WorldofAntiquity My channel had over a million subs then I watched this Indian guy who clearly lose it 🤔🙂🖕. And now I don’t have as many subs 😔. Also maybe you need to rethink your channel and or life in general 🤔😃🖕🤷.
@parmykumar8592
@parmykumar8592 Год назад
@@WorldofAntiquity I wouldn't be surprised if the Vanaras are the same giants that roamed South America because Hanuman did go there, killed the unrighteous King & placed his son on the throne as recorded in ancient Sanskrit texts of India & evidence shows it maybe true! There is nothing strange in the fact that much of the religious mythology of the Mexicans and Peruvians was undoubtedly of Asiatic origin. Both the Inca and Mayan civilisations, even their languages had much in common with our own, inherited from the same far eastern cradle of the race” Miles Poindexter - American ambassador to Peru. ~ "Ships that could cross the Indian Ocean were able to cross the Pacific too. Moreover, these ships were really larger and probably more sea-worthy than those of Columbus and Magellan." "Ships of size that carried Fahien from India to China (through stormy China water) were certainly capable of proceeding all the way to Mexico and Peru by crossing the Pacific. One thousand years before the birth of Columbus Indian ships were far superior to any made in Europe up to the 18th century." Dr. Robert Heine Geldern anthropologist. ~ “ That primitive Aryan words and people came to America especially from Indo - Arya by the island chains of Polynesia. The very name of the boat in Mexico is “catamaran” a South Indian ( Tamil ) word. After 30 years of research i can now claim to have proved my theory of Hindu colonisation of America. The stones in every corner of America speak of Hindu influences “. Miles Poindexter - United States Ambassador. ~ "Of the cursory observations on the Hindus, which it would require volumes to expand and illustrate, this is the result, that they had an immemorial affinity with the old Persians, Ethiopians and Egyptians, the Phoenicians, Greeks, and Tuscans, the Scythians, or Goths, and Celts, the Chinese, Japanese, and Peruvians.” Indologist and Sanskritist Sir William Jones - Asiatic Researches, Volume I ~ In 1930, ambassador of U.S Miles Poindexter wrote his book, the ancient Indians crossed the Pacific Ocean and came to South America. He showed the similarities between QUICHUA language of South America and Sanskrit India. He described INCA ruler hymns and Vedic hymns as one, and he finally wrote the people of Maya and Inca civilization were undoubtedly Hindus. In the museum of Vedic hymns as one, and he finally wrote the people of Maya and Inca civilization were undoubtedly Hindus. ~ Sir Stamford raffles, the father of Singapore wrote “every poem of the Peruvians have the imprint of Ramayana and Mahabharata”. ~ Its interesting to note that the biggest festival each year observed by the Incas was called the Rama-Sitva which they have now disguised as the Inti Raymi. Sir William Jones however has preserved this historical fact in the following quote -: "Rama is represented as a descendant from the Sun, as the husband of Sita, and the son of a princess named Causelya. It is very remarkable that Peruvians, whose Incas boasted of the same descent, styled their greatest festival Rama-Sitva - hence we may take it that South America was peopled by the same race who imported into the farthest parts of Asia the rites and the fabulous history of Rama." (source: Asiatic Researches Volume I. p. 339-340
@TheSoumikbasu
@TheSoumikbasu Год назад
Indians and the Sanatanas are the Originator of Humanity on Earth in this Dimensions. If you read Darwais Origin of Species and set his Example of the Langurs of Madagascars and if you correlate that with the number of races found in Indian Continent you will see a matching slope. (The the westerners blatantly put this as a result of Invasion but I beg to differ as per Haplogene spread) Now coming to worshiping gods… Our culture Worshiped Time(Shiva) Space (Vishnu) and Matter (Bhramha) and they did that with Tantra(Technology) Mantra (Code) Yantra( Machine)
@mikekenney8362
@mikekenney8362 Год назад
Bravo for the research, and I’m sure most of us expect that sophisticated prehistoric civilizations are likely to crop up in the sub continent. Before we proclaim alien visitation however, we should bear in mind that every kid in a sandbox knows that the way to create an elevation is to push the material into a structure sloped equally on four sides. It would be a surprise for builders not to leave these behind.
@JoshMull
@JoshMull 3 года назад
I love when they try to connect two cultures with animals, in this case they both have cobras. But it always seems to misunderstand the fact that all of these cultures are just people! And guess what, people think animals are neat! I propose a new law of history called the "Lions are Freakin' Awesome Rule." Whenever two cultures have the same animal represented in art, it's not because they're connected, it's probably because that animal is cool. If your people knew about lions, they probably drew pictures of them, because lions are awesome. If they knew about cobras, they probably drew pictures of cobras, because cobras are cool. 😂😂 Thanks for another awesome video!
@jamisojo
@jamisojo 2 года назад
Agreed. Next they're going to claim "They used stone" as a reason people all shared knowledge across the entire planet. 😉
@terryenglish7132
@terryenglish7132 3 года назад
Did you see his series on Angkor Wat ? Aside from his usual sci-fi extrapolation about what things were for, he does make a good case that it could not have been built in the amount of time attributed to its construction. I m just curious if he stuck to facts.
@WorldofAntiquity
@WorldofAntiquity 3 года назад
I haven't seen it yet, but I will check it out.
@ToxicallyMasculinelol
@ToxicallyMasculinelol 2 года назад
There's almost never a good argument that something "could not have been done" for logistical reasons. There are many different kinds of "impossibility," from logical impossibility (a married bachelor) to physical impossibility (a human throwing a football to the moon) to logistical impossibility (say, a bunch of millennials building a replica of the great pyramid at Giza with ancient Egyptian tools). All these alternate history arguments concern logistical impossibility, and ultimately they hinge on modern peoples' intuitions and assumptions about ancient construction. They don't rely on strong positive evidence. Instead, at best they rely on a lack of evidence, and most of the time, they rely on ignorance of evidence. They appeal to people who are just smart and educated enough to think they can make judgments about logistical possibilities, but lacking enough specialized knowledge to know what tools ancient people had at their disposal and what ancient people were willing and motivated to do. Kind of a Dunning-Kruger effect, right? We've been spoiled by modern technology, so we've forgotten many skills and, in most cases, we've never had to acquire many skills that were vital in the ancient world. Have you ever seen a true artisan, someone who's brilliantly skilled at some craft? Look up Japanese carpenters, who build structures using no nails, only wood. Apprentices are taught by masters, so they're given the cumulative knowledge of hundreds of generations. And they practice these skills for their entire lives, so they make it look effortless. Most people trying to do something similar would fumble and make a clumsy job of it. But people who have been trained for decades by their fathers, going back many generations, can move incredibly quickly on muscle memory alone. I've seen examples of this and been really surprised at just how skillfully humans can move. Real experts sometimes seem to work just as precisely as the robotic arms you see in factories, and much much faster for some tasks. Even something as mundane as spinning dough to make a pizza, it's the kind of thing the vast majority of people can't even do AT ALL because we just don't cultivate that skill. If you didn't know that people DO spin dough to make pizza, it would be easy to assume that such a thing is not even possible. And when you finally see someone spinning dough you suddenly realize that wow, it is possible after all. If you had never heard of the concept before, you'd probably assume they use some totally different technique. And if someone asked you to make a pizza from scratch, you probably wouldn't try to spin the dough. That's not your first instinct. You'd probably just flatten it out on a countertop. But if you kept making pizzas for years, and you trained your son to make pizzas, and this went on for a while, someone would eventually work out that you can make pizza a lot faster if you spin the dough. This applies to everything. Humans get progressively better at everything they do, and work out new and better techniques that wouldn't naturally occur to most people trying it for the first time. So not only does an individual person's skill develop, but the skill itself develops as it's passed from generation to generation. An apprentice stonemason gets better as he becomes a master, and by the time he passes on his knowledge, he's probably better at it (and has discovered more tricks) than HIS master. And his apprentice, in turn, will grow in skill and eventually improve on him. So the individual's skill grows, but the skill itself, the "state of the art," grows too. And it'll keep growing until the art itself is lost, usually because it's been replaced by a more efficient or cheaper method of producing the same product or service, or because demand for the product/service has dwindled (e.g., pyramids). After a few generations of the art being forgotten, its products will begin to look impossible to people. If you ask any random person today to build a pyramid, they're going to botch it and it's going to take them an obscenely long time, because they don't have the skills. They haven't cultivated those skills over generations of practice and innovation. The distance in capability between them and the most recent master bronze age stonemason will be enormous, because the art developed for a thousand years before being lost. Nowadays we have such advanced technology that innovation usually comes in the form of devices, not techniques. But not always. New surgical techniques are constantly being devised, things that require extreme precision and complex movements of human hands. You might think it's impossible to remove a brain tumor with primitive technology. But you'd be wrong. Brain surgery is actually pretty ancient. People have been trepanning since before written history, for example. The difference is that they didn't have the benefit of thousands of years of practice and discovery. So their techniques were not as sophisticated as modern brain surgeons'. But a modern brain surgeon could, in principle, perform a modern procedure using nothing but copper and bone tools. My point is that you, someone who has absolutely no relationship with the crafts taught and developed by lineages of ancient craftsmen, are in no position to judge the feasibility of the products of those crafts. You don't even know the _basics_ of ancient construction techniques, let alone all of the advanced tricks and trade secrets that only a 10th-generation master would know about. And no one alive today knows even a small fraction of what the ancients knew about their techniques, because nobody has been keeping those techniques alive. They've all been replaced by more modern techniques. Look at the same thing on a smaller scale. There are a few shops in England still making hats by hand, the old-fashioned way. It used to be standard, but all the factories have replaced it with newer techniques. The only reason there are still some shops doing it the old way is because by "old way" I just mean the way it was done in the 18th century. Give it enough time and they'll abandon the old way too, or else go out of business. At that point, the only thing left of those techniques will be their products (the hats themselves) and the documents written about the production process. Just like we have with ancient artifacts. We have the products and in some cases we have written records. But we don't have the human resources, the actual skills, that took generations to hone and evolve. So at that rate, what do you imagine has happened to the techniques that were practiced way back in the 3rd millennium BCE? Is it probable that people have kept all the ancient tricks of the trade alive? We know some of the techniques because they were written down, we know many of the tools because we've found specimens or we've seen them in art. But the best we can do is try to infer the basic techniques, practice with the tools we know they had, and then try to improve on it from there.
@ToxicallyMasculinelol
@ToxicallyMasculinelol 2 года назад
Just take the core drilling for example. Many people can't imagine how the ancient Egyptians drilled cylindrical holes in granite and diorite. It's hard to believe they did, as a millennial layperson. But the ancient Egyptians left drawings that show the tool they used. It looks much like a scaled-up version of a manual brace, which has been in use all over Eurasia for thousands of years. It's just a piece of wood with a bent handle for a crank, and a copper plate bent into a cylinder around the bottom. Then a weight is added near the handle to give it some momentum. Spin that while applying the copper cylinder at the bottom to a stone surface, and you'll eventually grind a cylinder into the stone. But it's slow as hell. Because you're not an expert. You don't know any of the tricks and you don't have the muscle memory. It takes years to become a master at anything, and surely that applies to this craft too. A person practicing this for years will eventually test out new tricks and find ways to speed it up, as they get better at the basic process. That's just what humans do. Eventually you'll find out that putting some hard abrasive gravel and sand (corundite is best) and water around the cylinder massively speeds up the process. Just as with a diamond-crusted saw blade, we can use the harder abrasive material to do the actual cutting, and just use the copper to apply the force. There are certainly tons of little tricks, many of which we probably don't know about because nobody kept the art alive. We'd need to rediscover all of them. Some might say that, even if Egyptian artisans discovered tons of tricks to speed this up and passed them down over generations, even if they had truly masterful muscle memory as any expert eventually develops, the process STILL takes too long. But what does "too long" even mean? Too long for what? For us? I might not want to do that, personally. But that's because I, as a 21st century American, have better things to do. I have a smartphone and a programming job. Nobody cares about carving cylindrical holes in rocks anymore. It's not part of our worldview. We don't have a pharaoh who we believe is an incarnate deity. But, like many other people alive today, I believe in Jesus. I'm a weak, selfish sinner, not particularly noble or fearless, but there aren't many things that would motivate me more highly than Jesus. If I thought Jesus wanted me to cut cylindrical holes in rocks, you better believe I'm gonna spend the rest of my life doing that. Many martyrs have given their very lives for Jesus. Many alternate historians mock the idea that Egyptians were willing to make megalithic sarcophagi, carved precisely and polished meticulously, just to bury bulls in them. It seems absurd to us. We unceremoniously slaughter bulls en masse today so we can turn them into beef patties and shove them down our throats. The idea that someone would spend 20 years carefully and lovingly crafting a gigantic stone coffin _just for a bull_ seems laughable to us today. But men spent more than a decade building the Sistine Chapel, and Michelangelo spent years painting it. The Florence Cathedral was started in 1296 and wasn't finished until 1436. All this to say that we should be extremely cautious when applying personal intuitions and common sense to the question of logistical possibility. We're not in a position to judge, at a glance, whether ancient people were skilled enough to do a precise and fast job of something, nor are we in any position to judge how motivated they were to spend years if necessary. We need to do very extensive research to answer questions like that. And if we do the extensive research necessary, and we still can't figure out why they did it, how they did it, or how they did it in the time that seems to be implied by evidence, we should never leap from that confusion to a positive conclusion that an ancient, lost, high-tech civilization did it before disappearing without a trace. That hypothesis shouldn't even be our very last resort, because it answers one question by posing about a thousand other questions and making dozens of assumptions that don't accord with a huge corpus of evidence. We should realize that the existence of the object is itself evidence that the people in the region at the time did it. So if we can't understand why/how they did it, we shouldn't conclude that they must not have done it; instead we should assume for the moment that we're missing some crucial facts that would explain why/how they did it. Not just the principle of parsimony but also Bayesian probability tell us that that's a more plausible assumption. In such a situation, there's clearly a hole in our knowledge. The only question is how large the hole is: the size of a motivation/means for the locals to build the structure in question? Or the size of an ancient, lost, high-tech civilization?
@jamisojo
@jamisojo 2 года назад
@@ToxicallyMasculinelol those are some long comments. You might consider just making your own video. 👍😁
@animeshmohanty2502
@animeshmohanty2502 Год назад
@@ToxicallyMasculinelol You really have posted quite and intriguing analogy of how this ancient tradition/ architecture might have got lost with time . But i think the main question which has baffled archeologist is the lack of "tools" which were found . For example, if humans were wiped out suddenly , and some alien civilization found our skyscrapers , they will also find the tools which were used to build them (e.g cranes , pulleys etc)
@AsasinoManik
@AsasinoManik 2 года назад
I recently visited this place and what I got to know was that this place Ahichatra (Today Known As Ramnagar, Bareilly) was the capital of Panchala Kingdom which is said to be established around 1100 BCE as told by some modern historians. However, king Drupadh who was one of the kings of Panchal Dynasty got her daughter married to Arjun in this same place Ahichhatra. This makes this place a part of the events of Mahabharata which happened more than 5,200 years ago as the historians claimed the texts related to it to be older than 5,200 years. But, the locals who were part of the archaeological survey told me that this was older than 9,000 years. And interestingly to my surprise I saw remains of huge walls surrounding the way going towards this pyramid and the bricks of those walls were submerged in the mud badly. It's so lucky that I noticed this wall and Praveen didn't mentioned that in his video.
@WorldofAntiquity
@WorldofAntiquity 2 года назад
*the locals who were part of the archaeological survey told me that this was older than 9,000 years* Do you mean archaeologists, or the people who helped them? *the historians claimed the texts related to it to be older than 5,200 years* Historians wouldn't say this. Writing didn't exist 5,200 years ago.
@beautiful_sky111
@beautiful_sky111 2 года назад
@@WorldofAntiquity the story of mahabharata is way older it's been passed over generations orally that's why we had gurukuls and ashrams that's how it happened before writing came along.
@jamisojo
@jamisojo 2 года назад
@@beautiful_sky111 now all you need is some kind of compelling proof. 😁👍
@parmykumar8592
@parmykumar8592 Год назад
@@jamisojo I wouldn't be surprised if the Vanaras are the same giants that roamed South America because Hanuman did go there, killed the unrighteous King & placed his son on the throne as recorded in ancient Sanskrit texts of India & evidence shows it maybe true! There is nothing strange in the fact that much of the religious mythology of the Mexicans and Peruvians was undoubtedly of Asiatic origin. Both the Inca and Mayan civilisations, even their languages had much in common with our own, inherited from the same far eastern cradle of the race” Miles Poindexter - American ambassador to Peru. ~ "Ships that could cross the Indian Ocean were able to cross the Pacific too. Moreover, these ships were really larger and probably more sea-worthy than those of Columbus and Magellan." "Ships of size that carried Fahien from India to China (through stormy China water) were certainly capable of proceeding all the way to Mexico and Peru by crossing the Pacific. One thousand years before the birth of Columbus Indian ships were far superior to any made in Europe up to the 18th century." Dr. Robert Heine Geldern anthropologist. ~ “ That primitive Aryan words and people came to America especially from Indo - Arya by the island chains of Polynesia. The very name of the boat in Mexico is “catamaran” a South Indian ( Tamil ) word. After 30 years of research i can now claim to have proved my theory of Hindu colonisation of America. The stones in every corner of America speak of Hindu influences “. Miles Poindexter - United States Ambassador. ~ "Of the cursory observations on the Hindus, which it would require volumes to expand and illustrate, this is the result, that they had an immemorial affinity with the old Persians, Ethiopians and Egyptians, the Phoenicians, Greeks, and Tuscans, the Scythians, or Goths, and Celts, the Chinese, Japanese, and Peruvians.” Indologist and Sanskritist Sir William Jones - Asiatic Researches, Volume I ~ In 1930, ambassador of U.S Miles Poindexter wrote his book, the ancient Indians crossed the Pacific Ocean and came to South America. He showed the similarities between QUICHUA language of South America and Sanskrit India. He described INCA ruler hymns and Vedic hymns as one, and he finally wrote the people of Maya and Inca civilization were undoubtedly Hindus. In the museum of Vedic hymns as one, and he finally wrote the people of Maya and Inca civilization were undoubtedly Hindus. ~ Sir Stamford raffles, the father of Singapore wrote “every poem of the Peruvians have the imprint of Ramayana and Mahabharata”. ~ Its interesting to note that the biggest festival each year observed by the Incas was called the Rama-Sitva which they have now disguised as the Inti Raymi. Sir William Jones however has preserved this historical fact in the following quote -: "Rama is represented as a descendant from the Sun, as the husband of Sita, and the son of a princess named Causelya. It is very remarkable that Peruvians, whose Incas boasted of the same descent, styled their greatest festival Rama-Sitva - hence we may take it that South America was peopled by the same race who imported into the farthest parts of Asia the rites and the fabulous history of Rama." (source: Asiatic Researches Volume I. p. 339-340
@indranidutta1945
@indranidutta1945 10 месяцев назад
I forget the name, there is a hieroglyphic inscription of chess /chaturanga being played by the pharaoh, does that ring a bell about which country chess was founded in and more or less when- it was Bharat wasn’t it? And the sanskrit name for chess is pasha/ chaturanga and we do know which part of the world called their rulers pasha too and don’t the names of Rameses1 etc ring a bell too. Don’t underestimate Praveen- he generally is spot-on but for colonised minds it’s a little difficult to digest.
@tree_relics
@tree_relics 3 года назад
Praveen is quite entertaining. Glad you are holding space to reign in the outliers. I have been watching many of such channels as entertainment for many years. Thank you for sharing the method in a virtual world ruled by aliens and mysterious global ancestors with nukes who've left no trace but our befuddled imaginations.
@PathsUnwritten
@PathsUnwritten 3 года назад
Praveen Mohan seems to have moved away from aliens lately and is instead moving into the sphere of Hindu/Indian pseudo-history. According to him, not only were the Egyptian buildiers of Djoser's pyramid Indian, but ancient Indians also created (not influenced) the civilizations of the Khmer, Indonesian archipelago, and Central/South America with their space-age technologies.
@twonumber22
@twonumber22 3 года назад
@@PathsUnwritten Sounds epic, lol
@jagrutitripathy3978
@jagrutitripathy3978 2 года назад
@@twonumber22 when facts are being manipulated by power for generations certainly it will sound epic.
@twonumber22
@twonumber22 2 года назад
@@jagrutitripathy3978 Praveen should probably stop doing that.
@parmykumar8592
@parmykumar8592 Год назад
@PathsUnwritten I wouldn't be surprised if the Vanaras are the same giants that roamed South America because Hanuman did go there, killed the unrighteous King & placed his son on the throne as recorded in ancient Sanskrit texts of India & evidence shows it maybe true! There is nothing strange in the fact that much of the religious mythology of the Mexicans and Peruvians was undoubtedly of Asiatic origin. Both the Inca and Mayan civilisations, even their languages had much in common with our own, inherited from the same far eastern cradle of the race” Miles Poindexter - American ambassador to Peru. ~ "Ships that could cross the Indian Ocean were able to cross the Pacific too. Moreover, these ships were really larger and probably more sea-worthy than those of Columbus and Magellan." "Ships of size that carried Fahien from India to China (through stormy China water) were certainly capable of proceeding all the way to Mexico and Peru by crossing the Pacific. One thousand years before the birth of Columbus Indian ships were far superior to any made in Europe up to the 18th century." Dr. Robert Heine Geldern anthropologist. ~ “ That primitive Aryan words and people came to America especially from Indo - Arya by the island chains of Polynesia. The very name of the boat in Mexico is “catamaran” a South Indian ( Tamil ) word. After 30 years of research i can now claim to have proved my theory of Hindu colonisation of America. The stones in every corner of America speak of Hindu influences “. Miles Poindexter - United States Ambassador. ~ "Of the cursory observations on the Hindus, which it would require volumes to expand and illustrate, this is the result, that they had an immemorial affinity with the old Persians, Ethiopians and Egyptians, the Phoenicians, Greeks, and Tuscans, the Scythians, or Goths, and Celts, the Chinese, Japanese, and Peruvians.” Indologist and Sanskritist Sir William Jones - Asiatic Researches, Volume I ~ In 1930, ambassador of U.S Miles Poindexter wrote his book, the ancient Indians crossed the Pacific Ocean and came to South America. He showed the similarities between QUICHUA language of South America and Sanskrit India. He described INCA ruler hymns and Vedic hymns as one, and he finally wrote the people of Maya and Inca civilization were undoubtedly Hindus. In the museum of Vedic hymns as one, and he finally wrote the people of Maya and Inca civilization were undoubtedly Hindus. ~ Sir Stamford raffles, the father of Singapore wrote “every poem of the Peruvians have the imprint of Ramayana and Mahabharata”. ~ Its interesting to note that the biggest festival each year observed by the Incas was called the Rama-Sitva which they have now disguised as the Inti Raymi. Sir William Jones however has preserved this historical fact in the following quote -: "Rama is represented as a descendant from the Sun, as the husband of Sita, and the son of a princess named Causelya. It is very remarkable that Peruvians, whose Incas boasted of the same descent, styled their greatest festival Rama-Sitva - hence we may take it that South America was peopled by the same race who imported into the farthest parts of Asia the rites and the fabulous history of Rama." (source: Asiatic Researches Volume I. p. 339-340
@chrissmithsonian4819
@chrissmithsonian4819 3 года назад
YESSS! And Thank you!! In the name of facts and science please continue to DEBUNK these charlatans and snake oil salesmen!! I really enjoy your channel and have shared it with many friends.
@WorldofAntiquity
@WorldofAntiquity 3 года назад
Thank you. I appreciate that!
@donmitchell2367
@donmitchell2367 2 года назад
Lighten up Francis!
@supernovacleaning5957
@supernovacleaning5957 2 года назад
Have you heard of Burnol? Use it to your heart's content.
@shuchko
@shuchko 3 года назад
Very nice video. Thank you
@_watawasaubilhaqq_9642
@_watawasaubilhaqq_9642 10 месяцев назад
You are inspiring students like us to look further in our research. A huge respect from an Indian. ❤
@kv4665
@kv4665 3 года назад
Although the exact date of the Battle is disputed, Historians believe the Mahabharata was composed( originally only 8000 verses subsequently expanded to 100,000 verses) between 400 BCE - 400 CE, one of the reasons being the mention of cities like Panchala and Anga which came into being only during second urbanization of India (6th century BCE). The worship of Shiva in the form of Lingam was prevalent since 2nd century BCE in Mathura region (Uttar Pradesh) but construction of Temple complexes started only during the Gupta Empire (4th century CE) who were the pioneers of Nagara style of Temple architecture. The Bhitargaon temple built during the Gupta Era is the oldest surviving brick temple of North India. The material of this so - called Pyramid is strikingly similar. As you pointed out, these were built on the fragments of earlier structure of the Kushana period. This structure might have been built by the Gupta Kings around 4th - 5th century CE. The Naga cult was an independent form of worship during 2nd and 1st century BCE which was later assimilated into the dominant traditions( worship of Vishnu and Shiva ). The claims of those people migrating to Egypt and incorporating Naga tradition into the pyramids 4000 years ago is preposterous. The kind of ludicrous claims made by Praveen would be convincing only to those who have zero idea of Indian History. Thanks Dr. Miano for debunking it.
@akshaybanawasi7471
@akshaybanawasi7471 3 года назад
Hey for your kind info all modern historians do not believe in either Mahabharata,Ramayana,Puranas,etc They have declared all these texts as literature and human imagination and none of the characters and personalities especially major ones are real because they didn't find any hard evidences or either strong proof to prove !!! And the dates as mentioned by historians are all still speculation for Indian history as each academic has its own views and completely defers another historian/academic !!! Please do not stick only what historians or either independent vloggers such as Praveen Mohan,Brein Foester,etc have declared in their views and opinions Try to discover and explore yourself the sites and you may include carbon dating and DNA experts if you really want to date sites and still you may find variations in age !
@jamesmccreery250
@jamesmccreery250 3 года назад
Interesting place, but no evidence indicating that it is older than the step pyramid at Saqqara.
@trout3685
@trout3685 Год назад
My co worker watched this indian? guy constantly on Facebook. I listened to so much and quickly assumed he just exaggerates his claims for views. I never felt like I really could dispute anything though so it's nice to hear you contradicting this guy and reaffirming my assumptions. Thanks.
@swirvinbirds1971
@swirvinbirds1971 3 года назад
I always wonder why when the building is a pyramid then they have to all be linked... Do they do the same with rectangular, square and dome structures? A pyramid with blocks is one of the most basic designs to build. Hell, we do it stacking beer cans.
@lallyoisin
@lallyoisin 3 года назад
Naga - cobra in sanskrit also means tree. In Indonesian it means dragon. you find 7 behind the buddha each representing a chakra. That said the Rig veda lists sacred trees. In Ireland we have an ancient text called the airig feda. This lists the 7 noble trees. The name Dara in Ireland means Oak root. The root chakra is mula-dhara. Mul is found in scotland which I would guess is related to maol or mael in Irish. it has a few meanings but I believe 'follower' is the consensus.. alternative being chieftain or enlightened as bald is often put forward. monks bald= enlightened. Although it is plausible that pyramids could evolve separately in different parts of the world I can't help but put forward that knowledge and language spreads around pretty quick! The snake is a universal symbol. Given it's meaning in the book of kells symbolizes renewal or rebirth 1200 years ago it's not likely that st patrick drove such a rich and positive symbol a few hundred years before. only in recent centuries did it crystallize as a symbol of satan. The druids and the older religion were most likely the snakes! This mythological narrative seems to have stuck as it was filtered through the early clerics. You pointed out only recently in a video on primary sources the value in establishing bias. Hasn't all European history filtered through Rome and the Christian education system? I find many similarities between Irish, Tamil and Sanskrit (Tamil being older) I could say the same about Serbia. Deity Danu existed in India , along the Danube and Ireland. isn't it fair to say we were a lot more multicultural than history gives testimony to? ideas move around!
@WorldofAntiquity
@WorldofAntiquity 3 года назад
Ideas certainly do move around, but we have to be careful about assuming automatically an influence of one culture on another without sufficient evidence for it.
@lallyoisin
@lallyoisin 3 года назад
@@WorldofAntiquity even the experts need a poke every now and again! 😉
@hemasreesomapalle47
@hemasreesomapalle47 2 года назад
Wow fascinating. Sir, could you please throw more light on ‘arig feda’ , Danu .. etc. Also pls suggest some sources of info on these topics. I couldn’t get more on google!
@parmykumar8592
@parmykumar8592 Год назад
I wouldn't be surprised if the Vanaras are the same giants that roamed South America because Hanuman did go there, killed the unrighteous King & placed his son on the throne as recorded in ancient Sanskrit texts of India & evidence shows it maybe true! There is nothing strange in the fact that much of the religious mythology of the Mexicans and Peruvians was undoubtedly of Asiatic origin. Both the Inca and Mayan civilisations, even their languages had much in common with our own, inherited from the same far eastern cradle of the race” Miles Poindexter - American ambassador to Peru. ~ "Ships that could cross the Indian Ocean were able to cross the Pacific too. Moreover, these ships were really larger and probably more sea-worthy than those of Columbus and Magellan." "Ships of size that carried Fahien from India to China (through stormy China water) were certainly capable of proceeding all the way to Mexico and Peru by crossing the Pacific. One thousand years before the birth of Columbus Indian ships were far superior to any made in Europe up to the 18th century." Dr. Robert Heine Geldern anthropologist. ~ “ That primitive Aryan words and people came to America especially from Indo - Arya by the island chains of Polynesia. The very name of the boat in Mexico is “catamaran” a South Indian ( Tamil ) word. After 30 years of research i can now claim to have proved my theory of Hindu colonisation of America. The stones in every corner of America speak of Hindu influences “. Miles Poindexter - United States Ambassador. ~ "Of the cursory observations on the Hindus, which it would require volumes to expand and illustrate, this is the result, that they had an immemorial affinity with the old Persians, Ethiopians and Egyptians, the Phoenicians, Greeks, and Tuscans, the Scythians, or Goths, and Celts, the Chinese, Japanese, and Peruvians.” Indologist and Sanskritist Sir William Jones - Asiatic Researches, Volume I ~ In 1930, ambassador of U.S Miles Poindexter wrote his book, the ancient Indians crossed the Pacific Ocean and came to South America. He showed the similarities between QUICHUA language of South America and Sanskrit India. He described INCA ruler hymns and Vedic hymns as one, and he finally wrote the people of Maya and Inca civilization were undoubtedly Hindus. In the museum of Vedic hymns as one, and he finally wrote the people of Maya and Inca civilization were undoubtedly Hindus. ~ Sir Stamford raffles, the father of Singapore wrote “every poem of the Peruvians have the imprint of Ramayana and Mahabharata”. ~ Its interesting to note that the biggest festival each year observed by the Incas was called the Rama-Sitva which they have now disguised as the Inti Raymi. Sir William Jones however has preserved this historical fact in the following quote -: "Rama is represented as a descendant from the Sun, as the husband of Sita, and the son of a princess named Causelya. It is very remarkable that Peruvians, whose Incas boasted of the same descent, styled their greatest festival Rama-Sitva - hence we may take it that South America was peopled by the same race who imported into the farthest parts of Asia the rites and the fabulous history of Rama." (source: Asiatic Researches Volume I. p. 339-340
@shishirprabhakarsingh4884
@shishirprabhakarsingh4884 Год назад
@@parmykumar8592 dude u r doing nothing but chutiyap, stop this see the world with unbiasedness, respect others opinions and stop doing this everywhere in the comments
@chandlerminh6230
@chandlerminh6230 2 года назад
In the beginning, Praveen Mohan was only interested in ancient astronaut theories. But lately, since a large share of Indians got internet access after the Jio revolution, he has started to claim that everything in the world comes from India. Of course, sucking up to Indian ego will bring a lot income on RU-vid
@AsasinoManik
@AsasinoManik 2 года назад
Ah he is just only interested in India related archaeological findings. He is just showing things as they are.
@AsasinoManik
@AsasinoManik 11 месяцев назад
@@kingflockthewarrior202 ego ego kaunsa ego 😫😫
@asmirann3636
@asmirann3636 10 месяцев назад
@@kingflockthewarrior202 Tum chaatne mein lage raho.
@ankursharma9019
@ankursharma9019 2 года назад
Nagas are not just semi-mythical creatures but also the name of a modern tribe as well as a tribe of people in the purported time of the Ten Kings or Kurukshtra War.
@ankursharma9019
@ankursharma9019 2 года назад
In fact Naga is a generic term in ancient Indian cources for any Mongoloid or "serpentine eyed" peoples which is most people of SEAsia of which there are many in India as well.
@parmykumar8592
@parmykumar8592 Год назад
@@ankursharma9019 I wouldn't be surprised if the Vanaras are the same giants that roamed South America because Hanuman did go there, killed the unrighteous King & placed his son on the throne as recorded in ancient Sanskrit texts of India & evidence shows it maybe true! There is nothing strange in the fact that much of the religious mythology of the Mexicans and Peruvians was undoubtedly of Asiatic origin. Both the Inca and Mayan civilisations, even their languages had much in common with our own, inherited from the same far eastern cradle of the race” Miles Poindexter - American ambassador to Peru. ~ "Ships that could cross the Indian Ocean were able to cross the Pacific too. Moreover, these ships were really larger and probably more sea-worthy than those of Columbus and Magellan." "Ships of size that carried Fahien from India to China (through stormy China water) were certainly capable of proceeding all the way to Mexico and Peru by crossing the Pacific. One thousand years before the birth of Columbus Indian ships were far superior to any made in Europe up to the 18th century." Dr. Robert Heine Geldern anthropologist. ~ “ That primitive Aryan words and people came to America especially from Indo - Arya by the island chains of Polynesia. The very name of the boat in Mexico is “catamaran” a South Indian ( Tamil ) word. After 30 years of research i can now claim to have proved my theory of Hindu colonisation of America. The stones in every corner of America speak of Hindu influences “. Miles Poindexter - United States Ambassador. ~ "Of the cursory observations on the Hindus, which it would require volumes to expand and illustrate, this is the result, that they had an immemorial affinity with the old Persians, Ethiopians and Egyptians, the Phoenicians, Greeks, and Tuscans, the Scythians, or Goths, and Celts, the Chinese, Japanese, and Peruvians.” Indologist and Sanskritist Sir William Jones - Asiatic Researches, Volume I ~ In 1930, ambassador of U.S Miles Poindexter wrote his book, the ancient Indians crossed the Pacific Ocean and came to South America. He showed the similarities between QUICHUA language of South America and Sanskrit India. He described INCA ruler hymns and Vedic hymns as one, and he finally wrote the people of Maya and Inca civilization were undoubtedly Hindus. In the museum of Vedic hymns as one, and he finally wrote the people of Maya and Inca civilization were undoubtedly Hindus. ~ Sir Stamford raffles, the father of Singapore wrote “every poem of the Peruvians have the imprint of Ramayana and Mahabharata”. ~ Its interesting to note that the biggest festival each year observed by the Incas was called the Rama-Sitva which they have now disguised as the Inti Raymi. Sir William Jones however has preserved this historical fact in the following quote -: "Rama is represented as a descendant from the Sun, as the husband of Sita, and the son of a princess named Causelya. It is very remarkable that Peruvians, whose Incas boasted of the same descent, styled their greatest festival Rama-Sitva - hence we may take it that South America was peopled by the same race who imported into the farthest parts of Asia the rites and the fabulous history of Rama." (source: Asiatic Researches Volume I. p. 339-340
@oldoneeye7516
@oldoneeye7516 2 года назад
Because I am watching your channel, the almighty algorithm is bombarding me with hundreds of vids from alternative historians. I watched a few of them and it seems that they all follow the same sturcture. First they start quite interesting with some archaeological (or sometimes astronomical) findings and pictures. Then they light up a (often tiny) detail, calling it the most interesting part. The next step is claiming that "mainstream science" is hiding this "evidence" for some reasons (despite the fact that in all the examples i looked, I easily found ample material about these details) and lastly claim alien origin. Today i watched a video about Mars. It showed the famous "face" on mars, the pictures of the shadow of the "cleaning Martian" and the supposedly ruins. So far, so entertaining. Then they compared the "ruins" which Japanese "tombs" and showed modern day pictures of them, completely overgrown by trees. Finally the part came where they lost me, claiming that the Japanese government let the trees grow on the tombs for one purpose only: to deliberatly destroy the "evidence" of Martian activity. Really? People believe in something like that? They let trees do the destruction work and do not use some powertools to cover up evidence for extraterrestial life? Why should they work as ineffectivly as that?
@WorldofAntiquity
@WorldofAntiquity 2 года назад
Oh boy. My apologies for getting you into this. 😆
@oldoneeye7516
@oldoneeye7516 2 года назад
@@WorldofAntiquity :D
@Infiniteemptiness
@Infiniteemptiness 2 года назад
Atleast Praveen mohan is bringing lot of unknown sights into Attention orelse Indian history is always ignored and showed in bad light now we know there are even pyramids in India
@heiAMB
@heiAMB Год назад
Praveen Mohans Most of The Videos Force Us to Ask Questions and That's a Good Sign to Help to Do Research.
@stevesanders1905
@stevesanders1905 2 года назад
Praveen can be very entertaining much like Georgio on ancient aliens. That sorta says it all.
@reneechavira9304
@reneechavira9304 3 года назад
Man you Rock, I love the way you call them out on their BS.
@WorldofAntiquity
@WorldofAntiquity 3 года назад
Thank you!
@oldmandan4244
@oldmandan4244 3 года назад
Ahhhh, why let some silly little facts get in the way of a good story??? I enjoy your videos. Keep them coming.
@sakshamsaxena9187
@sakshamsaxena9187 2 года назад
May your god forgive your sins 😂 In Bharat, sins create Karma and Karma brings consequences.
@dirtysouthclimbing
@dirtysouthclimbing 2 года назад
Call the so called authorities out on their epic BS. This channel is a front. Total misrepresentation of alternative theory. Scientists laugh at mainstream archaeologists. Totally irrelevant and a joke
@sakshamsaxena9187
@sakshamsaxena9187 2 года назад
Who scientists? From where?
@bernardodf9746
@bernardodf9746 2 года назад
Hi, professor! Thank you for your great content! May you make a video about the so called croatian pyramids? Greetings from Brazil!
@richardlilley6274
@richardlilley6274 3 года назад
Not been getting notifications... RU-vid suck Now I will simply check your channel Brilliant content and research Thank you
@brianmsahin
@brianmsahin 2 года назад
The area latest settlement was 2000 bce by according to your own Indian Indian Institute of Technology and the Archaeological Survey of India who dated the settlement of the area from 2000 to 1500 bce so it cannot be older than the Egyptian one. It's at least 600 years younger. However, the pottery found dates to earlier building on the site to the Kushan period which is 100 to 400 ce! Archaeologists date the present pyramid to the Gupta which dates the pyramid to be between 300 and 375 ce. It is likely less than 1700 years old.
@keshavkk479
@keshavkk479 2 года назад
Your analysis is very professional, well-done. Praveen mohan has claimed even weirder stuff about Vijaynagar empire and humpi capital temples, not many takes more importance to his vedios
@chandlerminh6230
@chandlerminh6230 2 года назад
The “pyramid” is actually a fort structure.😂 And it was built within the last 2000 years. Some part of it were constructed (or renovated) during Islamic period. The fort is well documented by Archeological Survey of India. It is not some mystery as claimed by that dikhed
@vidyapeethstudent8514
@vidyapeethstudent8514 2 года назад
Structure of forts are completely different . They are for protection of king and peoples . What type of fort it is in which everyone can enter simply 🤷
@parshuramarya4848
@parshuramarya4848 2 года назад
hahahahahahaha ............. right everything made by muslims ... they were all muslims hahahahahahahaha !
@ahklys1321
@ahklys1321 Год назад
But what about that Lingam? Please don't rain on my parade
@johnjustice8478
@johnjustice8478 Год назад
The present day Indians were present in ancient India, of course, but, as Dravidian people, they didn't rule. ("Here we go again!" I can hear you say) The Dravidian people are the same people as those native Australians, our Aborigines. The Aborigines peopled Australia, where they remained, until White settlement. They peopled India and surrounds as Dravidians, where they mixed with Europeans and to the East with some East Asian/Sino peoples. They also peopled land as far west as the Middle East. They are, thus, a good part of Shem's tribes. Thus, early Bible stories may have been set in or around India, Harappa, and Indus Valley. Whilst it's necessary to read the Hebrew, which I can't yet do, the Greek, into which the Hebrew was translated, may supply some evidence, including Indian/Sanskrit (id est, Indo-European) words. In Greek, exempli gratia, an initial vowel of a word possesses an apostrophe representing a "spiritus lenis," if it turns to the left ("smooth breathing") or a "spiritus asper," if it turns to the right (rough breathing). These breathings represent aspirated sounds, as "h," "s," "v," "w." Letters "h" and "s" possess the "spiritus asper," while "v" and "w" possess the "spiritus lenis." Let us, now, consider the Garden of Eden to possess a spiritus lenis to make the phrase "the garden of Veden." Then apply the Indo-European "a," "e," "o" to be represented by Sanskrit, "a," and you've got the Garden of Vedan. The Garden of Eden was the "garden of knowledge." "Veda" means "knowledge," from IE "vid," Skt, "vid," Greek, "oid," Latin, "vid," English, "wit."
@lostpony4885
@lostpony4885 2 года назад
If you can ignore the alien hoo ha, this guy shows lots of great stuff up close.
@andypowell4538
@andypowell4538 3 года назад
Still an interesting site just not as old as he would like it to be, great video cheers.
@Wallyworld30
@Wallyworld30 3 года назад
It's an amazing historical site. Shame this guy wants to exaggerate what it is. Sad that con artists want to promote pseudoscience to scam people using amazing sites like this. It should be told about as Accurately as possible to teach the public of what occurred their instead he's doing an injustice to what they DID accomplish.
@leonthompson2425
@leonthompson2425 3 года назад
Lets be honest here, Praveen is a total liar. He went onto Ancient Aliens, then worked out he could make money selling the gullible what they wanted to hear, and tried to make a career out of that...I'm glad he's been called out...and I feel sorry for the people who believed him....
@transparentguy9096
@transparentguy9096 2 года назад
You cannot say he is 100% lying. Being optimistic, even the slightest of the theory he gives comes out to be true is a win win. Indian archeology did more engineering than what toom for making pyramid.
@Ab-dp1eg
@Ab-dp1eg 2 года назад
Dr David miano Please give us video about sumerian and babylonian creation myth Creation of the world and humans We need authentic story
@adisura9904
@adisura9904 3 года назад
Hey hope you're doing well dude. I haven't even completely watched this but i definitely want you to checkout the sanauli finds. Would love your insight. Maybe with some focus on the chariot and the antenna sword! Hope that other research on Dr. Oak is going well as well. Hoping to see a well researched video at your leisure! As i like things well done. Someone really needs to do a LIDAR through the length and breath of india, it would end this whole argument on who came first atleast in India. Whatever comes out of it would be far better than the fights cultures keep having. I do have another suggestion. Its a loved channel by me called project Shivoham, would like to see how accurate his videos are. Essentially he talks about vedic knowledge, and its effects on the modern world. Would like to see how you see such topics and maybe a follow up video would be neat. Or just reply to me here. ideally would like a brief summary just below .Thanks again dude! Ill go back to watching
@WorldofAntiquity
@WorldofAntiquity 3 года назад
I will see if I can get to it.
@adisura9904
@adisura9904 3 года назад
@@WorldofAntiquity would be glad. Just maybe watching and a short summary as a reply would do as well. Thanks!
@essveekaye
@essveekaye Год назад
@@adisura9904 Project Shivoham binge baby here. 👋 👍
@AdvancedLiving
@AdvancedLiving 3 года назад
Great work David!
@WorldofAntiquity
@WorldofAntiquity 3 года назад
Thanks!
@sudipbiswas5185
@sudipbiswas5185 2 года назад
As an Indian, I can say your videos are good. A lot of the indian ancient document had been brunt with all the great ancient university, the last one was the Nalada University Lybrery. I'll suggest, So many recent data coming frequently, try to incorporate those in the next videos. I can sure found western lens bias in many cases but it's inherent, just lack of no indian civilization background. (Like here linga is not always about Shiva and penis....it's depend on circumstances). Nevertheless, keep it on.....
@essveekaye
@essveekaye Год назад
Agreed. N yuh, I love this channel. This guy is good! I'm Maori Irish.. modern Australian aboriginal blood mix. Love nothing better than drawing singing speaking cooking in my languages. Talk about embellishments.. !! But I was raised on ngapuhi traditional culture, my father smashed welsh/Gaelic English on his kids n demanded answers prompt. I love living in sunny Queensland Australia. Super proud of being me.. no ego, I've already been taught that in this life I'm bringing it thru for my ancestors so there's no need to be shy or shame. I will draw taa moko, te whakaairo and know each koru. Oral traditions?!?!?!!!..... shi. I guess the whole archae community has this beef culture. I love mohan.. cos he's running round ancient temples n climbing n sweating.. the places are foreign n beauty, that's it. But I do notice that even if I drop comment bout any of my ethnicity.... fk people just gunna have an eye roll like whatever..... *so your tribal love.. I get it.. ok.. sheesh* No. I'm full me. N I love it. N I like your comment too. It hit
@kalpeshmanna7233
@kalpeshmanna7233 Год назад
Very good analysis.
@RhodeIslandWildlife
@RhodeIslandWildlife 3 года назад
Thank you Dr Miano
@WorldofAntiquity
@WorldofAntiquity 3 года назад
Always welcome
@Jason-ms8bv
@Jason-ms8bv 3 года назад
Preying on wonder, confirmation bias and hyped pre expectations is clearly a profitable business, still it's appalling that this sort of shoddy disinformation can make it to our TV screens, Kids might be watching!! Keep up the good work Dr Miano, some of us really appreciate it.
@MS-yx3dr
@MS-yx3dr Год назад
Indian nationalists are very funny indeed😄😄😄
@dkakito
@dkakito 2 года назад
The Indian Pyramid looks more like a Ziggurat than it does a Pyramid to me... As even the Step Pyramids of Egypt didnt have staircases up them (that I am aware of) but is common in the Ceremonial Ziggurat, or even the Pyramids of the 'New World'
@mikebaker2436
@mikebaker2436 2 года назад
Seeing that there is modern graffiti on this site hurts my soul. 😒
@daniverson5860
@daniverson5860 3 года назад
Nice rebuttle. It touches on an area I have a strong interest in, but not a lot of information about ---the very early (neolithic) origins/forerunners of Harappan civilization (so anything pre-3000 BC or so) and what (if any) ties there are to Iran and Mesopotamia. From what I have been able to gather, there did exist earlier farming communities with a pretty significant time depth that the local Indus culture emerged out of, but I haven't seen anything that talks about whether it spread into the region from elsewhere or if it sprang up independently. Though there is lots of speculation about connections especially with the Sumerians, in particular, and very early (trade/migration/??) links between the Indus and Mesopotamia. Its very frustrating that all the popular interest stuff is wrapped up in pushing the Indo-Iranian migration back to preposterous time depths in support of Hindu-nationalist propaganda, or all the never ending space alien gobbledegook that crops up whenever discussing unfamiliar civilizations. I keep getting excited I've stumbled on something only to find myself watching crazy-making nutjob stuff... kudos to you for taking this on.
@WorldofAntiquity
@WorldofAntiquity 3 года назад
That's a worthy subject for exploration!
@shaolin1derpalm
@shaolin1derpalm 2 года назад
There was Harappan pin found in Susa matching one found in Indus valley. Plus lapis lazuli. So definite trade.
@ghostagee5232
@ghostagee5232 3 года назад
Turns out: Youngest pyramid!😅
@PathsUnwritten
@PathsUnwritten 3 года назад
That's probably Osmanagic's Bosnian Pyramids -- they're still being built.
@tehbonehead
@tehbonehead 3 года назад
@@PathsUnwritten What with lockdowns and all, I've got quite a pyramid of beer cans going in the back yard... it doesn't look like it'll be finished any time soon. 🍺🤪👍 🙃
@1TakoyakiStore
@1TakoyakiStore 10 месяцев назад
Pyramids are just geometric mounds, and it's very easy for humans to construct mounds. Civilizations also like geometicizing their structures once they hit a certain level of organization. My ancient history professor suggested that it was a comminly used method of showing how humans were improving upon nature. Don't know if I buy that fully but it would explain why pyramids are so seemingly universal amongst ancient organized civilizations.
@kaushalendramanav9209
@kaushalendramanav9209 3 года назад
You are best
@mikedrop4421
@mikedrop4421 2 года назад
Ahhh old Praveen Mohaan.. One of the most likeable cranks on RU-vid. He did that "test" where a pyramid supposedly kept fruit fresher than a box.. It was pretty hilarious. I'm convinced that the department of tourism is paying him to make India seem like the seat of all human knowledge.
@richiknair9036
@richiknair9036 2 года назад
Nah. Department of Tourism doesn't do shit. Forget paying him, it doesn't even do proper things about the thousands of brilliant tourist sites and the Archaeological Survey of India is equally pathetic and corrupt and doesn't properly preserve most of the Indian historical sites (especially the Hindu ones. cause they have this fascination for the Mughals who were one of the most brutal rulers of history and it was an era of Indian history that was highly extractive of Indian wealth. Only 655 individuals held 60% of India's gdp for themselves and their families. India's gdp was about 1/3rd of the global gdp and these families committed a massive resource capture, creating an insanely highly inequal society) . I have one rule. If someone appears on History TV on Ancient Aliens and other crazy shows, don't trust them as they're bound to make some crazy claims along with some small kernels of truth. I still watch his videos cos I like seeing the sites he shows but I scrutinise his claims every time
@ankanartworks55
@ankanartworks55 2 года назад
lol what?!!!! Tourism department and the govt of India doesn't even know that guy.. You are mistaking India with the western world where youtubers, conspiracy theorists and school dropout environmentalists are given too much attention .
@jayakrishnan26
@jayakrishnan26 2 года назад
You've no idea how people of India are being fooled using these lies and famatastical stories about indias past lol
@tucker5068
@tucker5068 3 года назад
So you don't know where he's getting his evidence. as you say it seems he's getting his evidence from. You gotta have a different opinion from mainstream in all sorts of subjects because even archeologist disagree. You seem a little petty. Why not have live debates so we can see both sides live.
@WorldofAntiquity
@WorldofAntiquity 3 года назад
I would enjoy that. The problem is finding someone that would be willing to debate me live.
@smarajitroychowdhury7086
@smarajitroychowdhury7086 2 года назад
I seriously take Mr Mohan, He has always out of box thinking, archaeologist always do work under a fixed model everything they try to fit within it , therefor archaeologist are not always correct it has been seen no of cases they proved wrong with new findings , though they always try their best to fit into it most of cases they are influenced by old prejudiced ideas , i appreciate provin Mohan at least he always try to view thing differently with logic which mainstream archaeologist don't have capability .
@terryenglish7132
@terryenglish7132 3 года назад
What's your take on why there are pyramids in general ? Genetic hard wiring like Beaver dams ?
@mekore
@mekore 2 года назад
its the easiest design to execute
@terryenglish7132
@terryenglish7132 11 месяцев назад
@@mekore Some earlier ones failed, either collapsing or being redesigned like the bent pyramid. Harder than it looks to make. The big 3 actually have 8 slightly concave sides so the sides "fall" toward their center for stability. Without trying to make one, it does seem easiest.
@mekore
@mekore 11 месяцев назад
@@terryenglish7132 easiest does not mean easy. Compare it to other designs, extreme example: inverted pyramid. Even Eiffel tower, the next to be the tallest in history, is still pyramid-esque. Tall cuboid towers did not appear till much later
@richiknair9036
@richiknair9036 2 года назад
Correction :- The oldest IVC site is Bhirana (7570-6200 BCE) . The largest is Rakhigarhi (about 6500 BCE). Your claim of earliest urbanisation in IVC is plain wrong. Please update it in the comments at least. Still, I appreciate that you debunked his claims with some proper scrutiny. The easiest claim to debunk was the Saqarra - yoni connection. That was a little too preposterous
@WorldofAntiquity
@WorldofAntiquity 2 года назад
You are confusing the time when an area is first settled with the time that it urbanizes.
@richiknair9036
@richiknair9036 2 года назад
@@WorldofAntiquity hmm but according to the archaeological report, 6 of the 7 mounds found in Rakhugarhi date back to 7500 BCE. These mounds of the IVC were used for religious rituals and public gatherings. It's a unique feature of the IVC. So, what is to be made of the dating of these mounds ?
@WorldofAntiquity
@WorldofAntiquity 2 года назад
@@richiknair9036 Public gathering and religious rituals can take place in villages. Ask the archaeologists. They will tell you the remains from that period are not urban.
@richiknair9036
@richiknair9036 2 года назад
@@WorldofAntiquity Well, I'll read more about those two and try to prove myself wrong. But 2600 BCE was nowhere near the earliest urbanisation of the IVC. Lothal City was a thriving trading port that was inhabited during 3700 BCR
@WorldofAntiquity
@WorldofAntiquity 2 года назад
@@richiknair9036 I'd be interested to see what you find.
@vaibhavramdasi
@vaibhavramdasi 2 года назад
I'm no fan of PM and his obsession with all things extraterrestrial but what you mentioned at 7.20 about lingam is Western materialistic view but I guess quick Google research can take you only this far.
@WorldofAntiquity
@WorldofAntiquity 2 года назад
If, when you say, "Western materialistic," you mean global secular, then maybe you are right. What did I say that was inaccurate?
@vaibhavramdasi
@vaibhavramdasi 2 года назад
@@WorldofAntiquity I think starting with a viewpoint of some ( no primary source suggesting it is symbol of phallus- Vedas, Upnishads, Puranas) so called secularist and topping it up with larger cosmic meaning is typical secular mischief done by seculars. It could have been avoided as it may hurt sentiments of other who consider it something entirely different. While I am appreciative of things that you are doing here, I think as far as religion is considered, as a secular ,I would avoid deciphering meanings which I am no expert of much like how I would want Religion to be out of state and policy matters.
@WorldofAntiquity
@WorldofAntiquity 2 года назад
History shows that religion is never static. It is always growing and changing. Things start simple, and they grow more complex over time. Assuming that to be true is based on experience and observation. It isn't mischievous. As I am sure you must know, historians have to apply the same standards of scholarship to all claims, favoring no religious beliefs over any other. Otherwise it would be inconsistent and biased. Unfortunately, that means some sensitive people will be offended by that. There is no way to avoid that without compromising the principles of the historical method.
@vaibhavramdasi
@vaibhavramdasi 2 года назад
@@WorldofAntiquity I agree religions are never static and that's why people did not get locked-up in just Vedas and came-up with further commentaries like brahmanas, arnyakas and upnishadas which are until this date, being discussed, debated and interpreted. But passing on a viewpoint that does not fit in overall objective of the video, I think, could have been best avoided. Also I don't understand(because of lack of knowledge) how metaphysical concepts and history are related.
@WorldofAntiquity
@WorldofAntiquity 2 года назад
@@vaibhavramdasi It is the history OF metaphysical concepts. And since I was doing a commentary on Praveen's video, and he remarked about the lingam, I provided my comment about it. Most of my audience had no idea what a lingam was.
@salinagrrrl69
@salinagrrrl69 2 года назад
Caral is out? There is there no weapons, no fort walls & no pottery. So no aliens there. An interesting word on the stepped pyramid. I heard an academic question if the designers thought of stacking traditional funerary structures via being inspired by imported depictions or witness descriptions of Mesopotamian temples.
@shakazulu301
@shakazulu301 2 года назад
Ohhhhkay but on a real note, IF YOU REALLY WANTED TO ARGUE FOR OLDEST PYRAMID, the pyramids at Caral in Peru were built around the same time 😬 yaaay, Peru 🇵🇪
@MrGOTAMA420
@MrGOTAMA420 3 года назад
i love india, but they didnt have anything on the egyptians
@Wallyworld30
@Wallyworld30 3 года назад
I don't understand why some Hindu want to rewrite history? Sure their ancestors built these amazing sites but why lie about it's origins? Reminds me of Livy in Ancient Rome dating the founding of their Democracy 1 year before the Greek. At least Livy was only off by less than 100 years but here were talking about Millenia's of time.
@amrishtripathi3831
@amrishtripathi3831 Год назад
Both praveen and this man are interesting. Their point of view are not just assumptions but based on some sources
@OldWolf1933
@OldWolf1933 3 месяца назад
It looks like a beautiful pyramid. Too bad it isn't kept clean.
@rahultamanavaru8392
@rahultamanavaru8392 2 года назад
Like your content..
@kerisnarao4844
@kerisnarao4844 9 месяцев назад
I am surprised that Indian governments have allowed these Indian Pyramid buildings wither away. These are precious.
@OnlineMD
@OnlineMD 2 года назад
One suggestion please: this regarding Harappa. It is *not pronounced as Haraappa!* It is just Harappa with short "a" vowels pronounced as in unusual, uneasy, etc. Actually in Hindi the "r" in Harappa is pronounced with a difficult-to- pronounce mix of r and d!!! And as to B.S. Praveen's video, (you know what bs means I'm sure!) I did watch it, just rolled up my eyeballs, and that was that. Thanks for digging deeper into this monument at Ahicchetra. That huge Shiva Lingam, with its top chopped off, looks precariously perched on bricks. The way it looks, raises more questions about it than anything else.
@harshmeena4
@harshmeena4 Год назад
*I will not be surprised if it is actually a pyramid because in many parts of the world, similar structures are found and pyramids in India could also be possible because:* *1.Famous cosmologist carl sagan also said that sanatan dharm is most scientific* ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-Ugyrzr5Ds8o.html *2. The person who created the nuclear bomb, J. Robert Oppenheimer , gets inspired from astra after reading bhagwad gita and quotes a line from bhagwad gita* ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-pqZqfTOxFhY.html *3. Julius robert mayer said energy neither be created or destroyed , while our god said, atma/soul neither be created or destroyed* *4. Newton's 3 law: every action has equal and opposite reaction, while in Sanatan Dharma it's called karma* *5. Einstein proves time dilation, while there are 2 events of Brahma life which talk about time dilation, first when a king and his daughter visit him after staying in bhram lok for sometime, so many years passed on earth, and when brhama kidnapped god Krishna friends, for them few minutes have passed while on earth 1 years was passed* *6. Scientists believe there could be a multiverse while when god Brahma kidnapped god Krishna friends, god Krishna summoned brahmas from different universe and tell brahma of our universe that there are far better versions of him* *7. wright brothers invented a plane in modern time, while Ravan has Pushpak Vimana (plane) and there is shastra called vimanika sashtra which talks about different types of plane models and how to make them, and even in modern times a indian named shivkar bapuji created plane before weight brothers* *8. Aerospace engineer travis taylor, proves the vimana/plane model mentioned in vimanika sashtra can fly!* ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-zpKIj4-bmt0.html *9. In some ancient hindu statues of people with guns and bombs are made which is 1000-2000 years old according to carbon dating and in some text it mentioned about fuljadi(a type of fire cracker)* ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-v5Vfy7-lnjM.html *10. Scientists also prove Ram Setu is a man-made* bridgeru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-odUtqDz4lEk.html *11. John Dalton discovered an atom in modern time while a sage named "Acharya kanad" discovered the existence of atom 2500 years before john dalton* *12. Alessandro Volta invented the first electric cell( battery) in modern time while a sage named "agastya rishi" invented the electric cell(battery), 10,000 years ago(according to hindu scriptures) but according to western historians it happened 15,000 BCE* *There are so many more inventions and ideas which the Westerners either stole or got inspired from!* *Jai Shree Ram!* 🚩🚩 🙏🏻
@jamesfaedtke2914
@jamesfaedtke2914 2 года назад
Need to lydar the ground and area. I'm new here so I don't really know you, but I have a theory it you drew a line on that map from there to the west coast of India where the ruin and building of Dawarka were found off the coast I'm guess there's a ton of hidden proof of anicent lost civilization along the way...and by the way you do work this stuff is on point.
@velu1671
@velu1671 Год назад
Very good video that explain against ancient alien propaganda.
@royseibel511
@royseibel511 Год назад
Very good critique
@patrickday4206
@patrickday4206 2 месяца назад
I'm glad you didn't just discount the legend but simply state how it can be changed or embellished over time. The pyramid doesn't look that old I'm guessing if you want to find the really old stuff from India you should be doing dives on the coastline
@nirajshrestha2309
@nirajshrestha2309 2 года назад
Even though praveen mohan exaggerate...i watch his videos cause he takes us to ancient site of India...
Далее
What Brien Foerster Gets WRONG about BAALBEK
39:41
Просмотров 171 тыс.
BABYMONSTER - ‘FOREVER’ M/V
03:54
Просмотров 28 млн
When You Get Ran Over By A Car...
00:15
Просмотров 8 млн
Incredible magic 🤯✨
00:53
Просмотров 579 тыс.
Did Civilization Begin in India?
42:02
Просмотров 274 тыс.
BAD HISTORY in ZEITGEIST: THE MOVIE
30:16
Просмотров 65 тыс.
Cocaine Mummies | Everything You Need to Know
38:28
Просмотров 54 тыс.
Is the JESUS Story PLAGIARIZED from Pagan Myths?
20:12
Просмотров 117 тыс.