99% if people aren't trying to draw a manga though If you're comparing an artist to people who aren't artists to show how good it is then it's probably not that good
That was what I was wondering. He wrote the story, he didn’t draw it. At least not anymore. He only makes storyboards and give them to his artists to draw them. Most authors who don’t even draw are called mangakas too
@@DrawperfectcirclesYeah, his art was kinda of bad. But the story carried it. Now he got someone to draw some of the best artwork. And it merely complements the story now.
@@josevictorribeirolisboa7576 I’m not concerned about his level of art, honestly. It’s just that misinformation like this spread too quickly. He’s a good storyteller, that’s for sure. But he’s an author not the artist.
One isnt even a bad manga artist honestly, mob pyshco is drawn by him yet some panels (even though not perfect) still has incredibly good attention to detail, like the cracks in the ground that are often showed during his rage for example. dont sleep on One
Majority of people whom I read says that are mostly OPM Manga only smoothie brains. Majority of us Webcomic Fans unanimously agrees that ONE's Art is actually even better than Murata.
@@RakutenZero i personally wouldnt go that far but art as a whole is subjective, just like humor for example. even though ones art may be a little rough or messy he still has an INCREDIBLE attention to detail like i said. art never has to be perfect for it to be perfect.
People forget that One had assistants which greatly helped him with Mob Psycho. He is a great manga artist, but he still greatly lacks on a technical level. But I guess that doesn't matter when you have such amazing compositions and paneling.
The thing that pisses me off is how others hate on One Punch Man for being a manga, or rather, a webcomic made for fun. Others hate on it (*ehem* DB fans *ehem*) by comparing the main character to certain anime characters with planet level destructive powers or higher, same for its fans comparing them, it's annoying
@@JADE-vw3ff every anime where there's an op character, they always gotta spotlight DB characters, cuz if Goku isn't gonna work, they bring up Zeno out of the blue, and if that isn't enough, they threaten you by saying that the Mexicans are a big fan and they'll go Rip you apart if you say that Goku isn't the strongest
They say that not realizing the guy drawing the remade version has redrawn every panel several times because it’s not god tier art work like the fans say💀
That's just wrong. The webcomic has kinda stopped and rarely releases chapters anymore. One is a great storyboard artist and his input has certainly influenced the composition of a lot of iconic panels as well as the paneling itself. The manga also has greatly expanded upon story all of which was written by One. The manga is NOT an adaptation of the webcomic, it's reimagined of the series with One still at the helm.
He IS good at figuring out where a panel should be looking. There's often only a few panels that need to be accentuated on very differently. And he is a REALLY good writer. He has quite a few projects, and all of them carry his humour in different ways, but he really is immensely good at crafting stories that double down on action and humour. His take on isekai was genuinely refreshing.
One Punch man died after One stopped working fully on the web comic. One Punch Man manga is one of the worst filler crammed piece of generic slop I’ve seen in my life. Shame to see such an amazing series be destroyed for “better art”
@@RancorSnp they hated jesus because he spoke the truth, theres been too much "god" and blast in the manga, how the hell are they supposed to do blue and the neo-hero arc if blast keeps showing up????
Yeah, I mean, it's not just the illustration that is part of the art. Story, world building, and dialogue are also elements of art apart from illustration. If you drew thousands upon thousands of panels of comic or manga, and the quality was consistent in all those other departments, then I think that's great, even if the illustration isn't top quality. In a lot of ways, it's a blessing that the art style is so simple that someone who wasn't very talented at first could endlessly create and use it to make stories that would take other manga artists years longer to create.
All art is bad when an artist begins. It's awesome to look back and see how far they've improved. And you dear commenter of this video YOU BEST GET TO DRAWING
I think it's more fair to criticize Anime season 2's art behind a full studio than the webcomic made by one guy. Especially when I feel like the webcomic lately has been better than ever.
I disagree about One’s fights being hard to follow entirely nor do I think his art is horrible. I think typically every panel he made conveyed a lot of information effectively and with personality. Yes the linework is “shitty” but it’s not shitty
People see a video on youtube and think the person making it has any sort of authority over the subject they are speaking of. Clearly, anyone can make a video on anything.
One thing I hate about people is when they say "erm ONE's art is actually SO good and incredible, 100x better than Murata!" Like fr stop lying to yourself. Yes he can draw, hell even better than my stick figure drawing self, but I'm not about to say his art is god tier. I don't need to be an artist to say "this guy's art is better than his," Same way I don't need to be a game developer in order to critique a game...
I'm so conflicted with myself. I hate hiatuses and redraws, and eager to see the upcoming chapters ASAP, and yet I wish for Murata to be healthy and well, both mentally and physically, and so these breaks are necessary, I really hope he's not overdoing it, although I know he *IS* overdoing it UPD: And his team, obviously
For someone like gege i want weekly chapters to get the story over with already For someone like murata I want him to take his time Murata could say “sorry guys not chapter this month” And i’d understand and wait a month till he gives me the most jawdropping manga panel i have ever seen
@@ChangesConstant chill man JJk ain't going anyway I understand why people don't like gege but will you wait. I get it your favourite characters or story from mangas and you don't have patience for them when hiatus drop.
@@aleysibbs2461 This aged like spoiled milk. Gege clearly rushed the ending, uraume literally thanos snapped themselves after Nobara randomly popped up to cuck sukuna. That was it. And its suggested Yuta survived apparently. What a shit way to end
One thing people don't mention enough about OPM, it's not just a good action manga series. It's also a great drama series. The realistic facial expressions of the art style really pushes that aspect far.
Opm is one of the greatest manga of all time. It is also the best superhero genre manga of all time. The art is the best in manga history nothing comes close. And the fact we are seeing such incredible art with superpowers and superheros makes the art even more amazing.
I love the fact that from time to time Murata will revert back to One's art style for comedic effect since it not only turns the commonly serious scene into a joke, but also shows how although One's art may be considered bad by most standards, it has its charm and uses, and how it actually does fit for an action comedy series showing how genius both Murata and One are.
Those who do not appreciate the original work's composition, clarity, and panel layout are blind to manga. There is no better material for a draft of a manga.
alright, I'm done every time somebody refers to a manga as an anime it takes 5 years of my lifespan you just called a web-comic an anime, that got rid of 15 years of my life I have 12 seconds left before I die, this is my final comment, goodbye
its actually pretty damn awesome to see the difference between opm webcomic and mob psycho. one still has a way to go but its so much better than before
I think you should've also mentioned how much One has improved in his drawing since he started working on OPM. Sure, his current art is still not even close to Murata's art from the first manga chapter of OPM, but it's still a MASSIVE improvement.
the emotions on the faces were translated so well from the original, that might have been the most important part and even in the OG web comic they were done super well. I almost think he is actually a really good artist.
i also love how the action flows in OPM . is super dynamic and full of life . and he does it with anything really , from hand to hand combat to sword fights to super power dbz like scenes . he does it all super well . that something people do not give enough credits for . it super hard
one punch man only got recognized when Murata drew them, ONE even quit for a little while to find a job because he's not gaining anything with one punch man webcomic. so yeah even if you have a good story and good at paneling, you really need to have good art in order for people to pay attention.
It can not be overstated that while One has minimal skill at drawing (though that has improved significantly over the years) he basically is a master of everything else. Even with his bad art, he has a way of laying it out in the perfect way, capturing just enough detail, that even if you can't understand exactly what is going on in some panels, you feel what is going on. Also he is a true master of storytelling, 99% of stories about overpowered characters eventually end up as absolute garbage, but One wrote two stories about two different characters who are both overpowered, yet makes them immensely entertaining and gripping, in two completely different ways.
The artists for DBS need to take notes. The animation alone has made that series absolutely unwatchable for me. And that isnt even mentioning the total ruin of main characters personalities or the dumb never-ending transformations everyone seems to get. sad,
very unpopular opinion: i strongly believe one's webcomic is much superior to murata's manga adaptation murata's version trades the webcomic's suberb character building, paneling, pacing, and themes to be just another overly-detailed action manga while misunderstanding the appeal of the webcomic entirely. one's art is now really well done and charming in the latest chapters anyways.
one ngl actually has good art, his art expresses anger by the drawing and stuff, it dosent really matter if it’s bad art if it can still stimulate what kind of expression it’s giving off, honestly another thing his paneling is really organized.
Fun fact: a fan translator, boon scanlation Blogspot, translated the original OPM between 2014 and 2017 before it gained traction. He is a translator who picks up indie webtoons manga that no one translates.
It's so sad that second of anime didn't match this quality at all... I hope that after all hate the studio which made 2nd season will make 3rd one at least not that horrible, can't even ask for something good.
Ah, so it's one of those anime's that shifts between artstyles- *literally every anime does this, only difference is the artstyle that's displayed 70% of the time, an artstyle which I am not fond of in the case of one punch man, but eh, nobodies dying over it" 0:18 0:39 Oh... It just had good storytelling. 2:08 Ah, so he's good at organizing his story panels too! I suck at that... 5:42 Ohhh
I think murata's redrawn of OPM makes OPM become popular yes undoubtedly ONE storytelling is really good but Without murata OPM will never came out from being a webcomic but Mob psycho is really good tho Heck i think i can say the same thing on demon slayer i am not saying demon slayer have a bad art no but demon slayer popularity is highly contributed from ufotable's godlike animation
@@ithinkguy9233 I still don't understand how demon slayer got one of the best selling mangas even though there are lots more manga that have better art and story. I'm not saying demon slayer is bad but there are many more mangas that did better. Even if ufotable is the one that made it popular, it's still crazy to get best selling manga so quick.
Im not discrediting murata, but i think we should also give some attention to his assistants. Without their help murata would probably not be as popular as he is now as an artist.
Pretty sure that one iconic panel of that alien ship or whatever wasn't even drawn by murata but one of his assistant's (cant blame anyone for not knowing tho and perhaps i could be wrong)
As someone who draws a lot, if your comic, graphic novel or manga lacks a good art style I’m not reading it. Idc how much of a difference ONE’s version of the story has from Murata.
