As a Canuck too, I though we may have gone to the same campus, but your approach and some symbols are just a little different. Different enough to know we had different profs. I guess I'm commenting on both videos here. A very nice introduction with the history (previous vid). I liked that. Ancient circuits are neat. General BiFET opamps make for perfectly good comparators for any hobbyist or, for professional use too. Op-Amps designed specific for comparator use are great and you can select the perfect one for your application. But general purpose BiFETs may meet your requirements. I have read some video comments online insisting to never use regular op-amps as comparators, esp. to drive it to the rails. However, I always use BiFETs for comparing, and never had problems except for specific applications (speed). In fact, I use BiFETs for _most_ of my circuits. I so much love opamps! Compare 741s 1V/us slew rate to 081s 13V/us. The 741 bipolar, although a classic and still used, always bothered me with that tiny little Darlington bias current. It just makes for an extra step in calculations for the biasing resistor and finding the standard values, yada yada. Whereas the TL081 or TL084 BiFETs, or similar, have given me nothing but joy! Better performance all around: Frequency response, gain, slew rate, impedances... And so simple. I have tried to encourage other opamp video makers to distinguish between bipolar and BiFETs. I don't know why it's not emphasized more often. Seems like a very important detail. Looking forward to the next one. [Ahhh! You just did. Slow it down there, Speedy. ]
Thanks for the comments. I agree, op amps are great! It does boggle my mind that the 741 is still used in new designs. TI's uA741 datasheet is dated November 1970, but was updated in 2018. My video release rate will slow down now, I just happened to save up three to release all on the same day.
Oh yeah, you're right. It's the bottom right diagram (Battery Reference) at 09:48. The inverting terminal should not be connected to VDD. That's going to short out the battery
all these explanations are the same that i find, which is great if you have a stable input voltage. what if the we're comparing the supply voltage, comparing to itself. the vdd is changing so the reference voltage is constantly changing. if ref is /2 then vdd 12v, reg is 6v, but if the vdd supply changes then the ref will change also.
