I was expecting this to be terrible because I'd read some negative comments on Consequence (I think.) This was not bad at all. The only thing that I can say is Phoebe Bridgers detracted from this cover. (Nothing against her as an artist/person, I'm unfamiliar with her. Just going by what I heard here.) I think their voices didn't mesh, but I also think the song is meant to be sung solo.
The mics sounded badly adjusted, one of the instruments was out at times in timing - quite bad at one point, and instruments were swamping the tone, and Phoebe's mic was far too low. I would liked to have heard her voice more prominently. Some of the instruments sounded a touch dead. Could have been badly captured though. The bass was far far far to loud, and the middle was scooped really badly