Тёмный

Pratt & Whitney JT8D Vs. Rolls Royce BR-715 Engine Sound Battle! 

SOUTHEND AVIATION
Подписаться 8 тыс.
Просмотров 44 тыс.
50% 1

YOU DECIDE! JT8D or BR715 which do you like better. If unsure the JT8Ds belong to the MD-80 and the BR 715s on the B717.

Развлечения

Опубликовано:

 

1 ноя 2016

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 163   
@MD88Pilot
@MD88Pilot 6 лет назад
JT8D wins it every time.
@thecaynuck4694
@thecaynuck4694 3 года назад
JT8D does have great noise but you gotta admit some other engines do sound great as well. I miss the MD-80 already.
@davidperry4013
@davidperry4013 3 года назад
@@thecaynuck4694 for example the F135 engine on a fighter jet and PW J58 have very nice sounds too pretty much all pure jets and low bypass turbofans sound like music to my ears. There are high bypass turbofans that have a sweet sound too such as the Trent 800, CFM56, CFM Leap 1A, GE passport, GE CF34, CF6, GE90, Trent XWB, BR725, GENX, and GE9X.
@apa182
@apa182 3 года назад
is this even a question
@navajocapi
@navajocapi 3 года назад
JT8D has no competition. Period.
@monterok006
@monterok006 2 года назад
The greatest is in the 707, the JT3D
@cometghost5799
@cometghost5799 7 лет назад
Nothing beats the bone rattling rumble from a JT8D especially the older revisions. Always enjoyed watching 727's take off. This JT8D looks and sounds like it was neutered with a shush kit :/
@chrisnizer1885
@chrisnizer1885 7 лет назад
JT8D all day! Love that sound. Especially on a 727 with 3 of them grouped together going full blast.
@SOUTHENDAVIATION
@SOUTHENDAVIATION 7 лет назад
still have yet to ctach a 727, hopefully one day this year though!
@cometghost5799
@cometghost5799 7 лет назад
It's becoming more rare to since they're largely decommissioned, might be able to catch some of those birds soaring in Africa or South America though.
@Vanadeo
@Vanadeo 6 лет назад
I do know that the 727/737 originals had JT8D 15/17 something like that and the MD 80 has the JT8D-200 series engines which had a higher bypass ratio than the 72/73 engines.. I prefer the crackle of the older gen JT8Ds its like comparing sausage to bacon.. Sausage is good but I'll take bacon any day O.o...
@Duderocks5539
@Duderocks5539 6 лет назад
+Comet Ghost The MD-80s use the JT8D-200 engines which are Stage III noise compliment ,The Hush kit is a Stage IV Hush kit. Some MD-80s have them already. But all won’t need Stage IV Hush kits probably not until the 2030s.
@Fraxion_
@Fraxion_ 5 лет назад
Them: Cover your ears Me: **grabs headphones**
@edwardsedgley1714
@edwardsedgley1714 7 лет назад
I love the buzzing noise from the JT8Ds always loved the sound
@SOUTHENDAVIATION
@SOUTHENDAVIATION 7 лет назад
they truly are fantastic!
@MD88Pilot
@MD88Pilot 6 лет назад
StarAviation - HD arguable.
@AADFWspotters2
@AADFWspotters2 7 лет назад
That RR stands no chance against the mighty 8D! Long live the 80's
@SOUTHENDAVIATION
@SOUTHENDAVIATION 7 лет назад
both sound fantastic
@arthursurrey9511
@arthursurrey9511 7 лет назад
AADFWspotters2 and long libe GE TF39S
@michaelo1929
@michaelo1929 5 лет назад
Lit Evipereye Hell yes! C5A/C5B
@michaelo1929
@michaelo1929 5 лет назад
F.B.I Those are stator vanes. The low pressure compressor (fan) sits behind the “non moving blades”
@davidperry4013
@davidperry4013 3 года назад
As for high bypass turbofans the Rolls Royce Trent 800 on the triple seven wins.
@markpotvin7119
@markpotvin7119 7 лет назад
I love the sound and rumble of the JT8D, and the efficiency of the IAE V2500. My vote goes to Pratt & Whitney.
@SOUTHENDAVIATION
@SOUTHENDAVIATION 7 лет назад
nice mate, thanks for watching
@thecaynuck4694
@thecaynuck4694 3 года назад
I thought the V2500 is on the MD-90, not the 717
@MayorMcCheese47
@MayorMcCheese47 3 года назад
@@thecaynuck4694 Correct. The md90 has the v2500s and the 717 has the RR BR715
@davidperry4013
@davidperry4013 3 года назад
@@MayorMcCheese47 also Airbus A320s have V2500s
@drifteradol86z
@drifteradol86z 7 лет назад
my vote is for the JT8D, it´s just amazing turbine roar!!!!! And you should add the sounds on board in taxiway and takeoff, excellent video
@SOUTHENDAVIATION
@SOUTHENDAVIATION 7 лет назад
never had the chance to fly on the 80s, and 717 was filmed on a potato. but this year im flying on 2 717s and 3 MD-80s!
@nankervisj
@nankervisj 6 лет назад
I must say I do love the sound of the BR710. The spool up sound from them is phenomenal
@SOUTHENDAVIATION
@SOUTHENDAVIATION 6 лет назад
Sure is a truly wonderful noise!
@emmettcunninghamjr.5207
@emmettcunninghamjr.5207 5 лет назад
OH!...EASY. THE UNIQUE BUZZ OF THE JT8D's...HANDS DOWN! :)
@SOUTHENDAVIATION
@SOUTHENDAVIATION 5 лет назад
A true classic engine!
@djvycious
@djvycious 4 года назад
There's a competition? Obviously the JT8D.
@jamesinman1198
@jamesinman1198 Месяц назад
I like the JT8D sound because it sounds more real and when it takes off as it flies up towards the sky, it creates more thunderous sounds. That sort of sound is phenomenal!
@remylopez2408
@remylopez2408 6 лет назад
I worked at McDonnell Douglas on those aircraft when they were new on the flightline and by far my favorite engines or the Pratt & Whitney JT8D-219s The BMW Rolls-Royce BR 715 engines you could almost have a conversation standing right next to them they were that quiet he couldn’t do that with the JT8s
@SOUTHENDAVIATION
@SOUTHENDAVIATION 6 лет назад
As far as today's engines are concerned I'd say the BR715 is still a relatively loud engine for a narrow bodied jet. Have only heard the JT8D-200s but they were so loud it was ridiculous!
@markcorry878
@markcorry878 5 лет назад
Air New Zealand had 737-200s and even with the hushkit on they were still great. I miss the old clamshell reversers. JT8D gets my vote.
@davidca96
@davidca96 5 лет назад
Pratt & Whitney ftw
@craigdoran6811
@craigdoran6811 5 лет назад
JT8DS all the way, esspecially on 737 200s. I like the RR spool up though, allmost sounds like a mini ge90!
@breathtakingblue
@breathtakingblue 2 года назад
Imagine 8, yes 8 of those 717 BR715 engines roaring on the reengined B52 bomber. Can't wait for the first flight of that!
@SOUTHENDAVIATION
@SOUTHENDAVIATION 2 года назад
Sadly its the 725 on the refitted B52 which don't sound nearly as good as the 715 or even 710 sadly.
@SuperSpotterATL
@SuperSpotterATL 7 лет назад
THE MIGHTY JT8D! The BR is still amazing no doubt but those P&W are too 💯💯💯💯💯. Thanks for the cool video!
@SOUTHENDAVIATION
@SOUTHENDAVIATION 7 лет назад
thanks mate, glad you liked this, subbed ya!
@SuperSpotterATL
@SuperSpotterATL 7 лет назад
SOUTHEND AVIATION I appreciate that mate! Thank you so much!
@Major_Tom98
@Major_Tom98 4 года назад
The JT8D is a classic while the RR sounds more modern.
@Leon-Hardt
@Leon-Hardt 5 лет назад
The old sound jet like old Soviet plane today.
@MiamiAviationPlanespotting
@MiamiAviationPlanespotting 7 лет назад
Wow! Awesome video! I prefer the BMW RR BR715. Awesome channel! You earned a subscriber!
@SOUTHENDAVIATION
@SOUTHENDAVIATION 7 лет назад
Yes me too, thanks man
@michaelo1929
@michaelo1929 5 лет назад
JT8D all the way! There is no comparison.
@billyw5260
@billyw5260 4 года назад
JT8D for sure!!!!!
@olliebrown4068
@olliebrown4068 5 лет назад
Absolutely love the JT8D it screams 👍
@philipplazarou981
@philipplazarou981 6 лет назад
JT8D similar with Tu-154 engines sound. Nostalgia- it is great!
@SOUTHENDAVIATION
@SOUTHENDAVIATION 6 лет назад
There is indeed a similarity
@aviatorman8
@aviatorman8 7 лет назад
JT8D
@georgemallory797
@georgemallory797 Год назад
The JT8D in this video is not the same one found on the 727 or DC-9. Those earlier engines were far louder than the updated version found on the MD-80.
@angelumanzor3083
@angelumanzor3083 5 лет назад
I love both.
@febryan3767
@febryan3767 7 лет назад
JT8D :D
@airplaneguy3389
@airplaneguy3389 5 лет назад
is it possible that you bass boosted those takeoffs to make them sound louder than they actually are? Just curious. Because the loud, earrape like sound happened very suddenly
@SOUTHENDAVIATION
@SOUTHENDAVIATION 5 лет назад
Old camera had a pretty poor mic tbh, if I ever get the chance to record the sound differences on the 717 and MD80 you bet your ass I'll do another video with better sound quality!
@anuaviation3510
@anuaviation3510 7 лет назад
md83 Boeing 717 taxi =5 taxi=5 spool up =5 spool up10 takeoff = 10 takeoff=10 total md83=20/b717=25 717 wins:) awesome video
@SOUTHENDAVIATION
@SOUTHENDAVIATION 7 лет назад
I agree, 717 for me.
@fossilknifeful
@fossilknifeful 5 лет назад
A true mechanical symphony 😍😍
@eastcoastnick4501
@eastcoastnick4501 7 лет назад
Nice!! Both are music to my ears! Once again I'm first like!
@SOUTHENDAVIATION
@SOUTHENDAVIATION 7 лет назад
and me too!
@davidhildebrand8894
@davidhildebrand8894 2 года назад
JT8D! Love the sound so much! If they could make a fuel efficient variant with the same sound…..that would be PERFECT!!
@corkaviation8885
@corkaviation8885 7 лет назад
Both really good but Pratt and Whitney for taxi and Rolls Royce for take off
@SOUTHENDAVIATION
@SOUTHENDAVIATION 7 лет назад
ooo, interesting.
@ruskikazik
@ruskikazik Год назад
Jt8d vs Soloviev D-30?
@fredy2971
@fredy2971 6 лет назад
Jt8
@dontrufit7889
@dontrufit7889 2 года назад
My vote JT8D all day for me, it has that warm feeling
@browardintegrativemedical6324
@browardintegrativemedical6324 3 года назад
Rolls Royce wins for me. This reminds me of the old mash up between the PWs and the RRs on the 757s.
@Mark_Ocain
@Mark_Ocain 5 лет назад
Even with the hushkit baffles, my vote is the twin spool low bypass turbofan JT8D. The only thing that sounds better is a JT3C or JT4
@bhobo09
@bhobo09 3 года назад
Nothing beats the growl of the Rolls Royce RB211
@shhmule
@shhmule 5 лет назад
Love the footage! But the music and intro is something a teenager listens to.
@SOUTHENDAVIATION
@SOUTHENDAVIATION 5 лет назад
Thanks mate, tbh I agree with you. I was 15 when I made this, I like to think I'm more professional nowadays. Feedback like yours is always welcome.
@psa722
@psa722 2 года назад
JT8D wins hands down. I have always loved flying on 727's and DC-9's, especially in the rear of the aircraft when the captain would perform a power back. Music to my ears.
@VoraciousAvgeek
@VoraciousAvgeek 7 лет назад
Both are loud but the MD80 is louder and more rocket sounding which is good! But I like the BR715's spool up better
@SOUTHENDAVIATION
@SOUTHENDAVIATION 4 года назад
Mitchell C Sigh*
@caribbaviator7058
@caribbaviator7058 5 лет назад
MD sounds great I'd take the 717 if I had to fly somewhere.
@sepehrpirabi8888
@sepehrpirabi8888 6 лет назад
MY EARS ITS EXPLODED
@joequillun7790
@joequillun7790 7 лет назад
The RR has a more distinctive whine. (Sorta-like a TF-39) But personally I'll take the roar of a J-58 in full AB anyday :)
@SOUTHENDAVIATION
@SOUTHENDAVIATION 7 лет назад
well, as cool as it may be, I don't think you'll find a J-58 on an MD 80 :)
@joequillun7790
@joequillun7790 7 лет назад
And I guess that's a sad fact. :( (Watch out SST!):)
@ronparrish6666
@ronparrish6666 7 месяцев назад
If we're talking early Rolls Royce on the Air Canada DC8 and BOAC 707 nothing beats those Conway's for smoke and sound
@rainbowrailroadcrossing7798
@rainbowrailroadcrossing7798 3 года назад
JT8D!!! Sounds very 🗿
@JMG717
@JMG717 6 лет назад
I love the sound and roar of a JT8D, but this particular 8 was ruined by those hushkits... In this video, the BR715 wins, as the sound of spooling up is unbeatable, and it may be quiet, but it is naturally quiet. The JT8D is supposed to set off car alarms, but this one, like mentioned before, has been neutered. Give me a JT8D-5/7/9/11/15/17 without hush kits any day of the week, but like I said, my vote goes for the RR BR715
@SOUTHENDAVIATION
@SOUTHENDAVIATION 6 лет назад
Had a good feeling you'd go with the Rolls Royce's, I remember your video on the DC-9 fan club on Facebook of a 717 departure. Love the sounds of the BR-715s on 717s from the start up all the way to shutting down!
@UrLocalFriend_2024
@UrLocalFriend_2024 2 месяца назад
People will disagree, but the BR-715 engines will be one of the most powerful engines ever made for the 717-200. Very modern DC-9
@danhurst5221
@danhurst5221 2 года назад
jt8D all day. it's such a fine buzz at full chatter.
@TaxiwayKilo
@TaxiwayKilo 7 лет назад
Love then both but probably MD83
@SOUTHENDAVIATION
@SOUTHENDAVIATION 7 лет назад
me too but 717 for me
@harrisoncarey4031
@harrisoncarey4031 7 лет назад
I think the MD-83 is too loud. But don't get me wrong I love loud planes
@cometghost5799
@cometghost5799 7 лет назад
Lol no one beats loud like the Avro Vulcan, or the Bone.
@alejandrorocha9377
@alejandrorocha9377 4 года назад
JT8D!!
@paulchambers6657
@paulchambers6657 3 года назад
We need a BAC 1-11 with early RR Spey engines for a fair comparison, my ears are bleeding already
@coydog7902
@coydog7902 4 года назад
The JT8D is the champion
@andrewcolsen
@andrewcolsen 3 года назад
It’s known as spooling up not revving up
@ALLpurpose85
@ALLpurpose85 Год назад
Pratt and Whitney md83 and the Pratt and Whitney 757 too
@skipcampbell4226
@skipcampbell4226 11 месяцев назад
I like the PW's the best! But it's all about efficiency and noise now. Even though cities and morals are crumbling. But we do have quiet jets now!
@sepehrpirabi8888
@sepehrpirabi8888 6 лет назад
My ears are exploded
@SOUTHENDAVIATION
@SOUTHENDAVIATION 6 лет назад
You may wanna fix that ;)
@mintyaviation2376
@mintyaviation2376 7 лет назад
Personally, I would have to choose good old Rolls Royce :)
@SOUTHENDAVIATION
@SOUTHENDAVIATION 7 лет назад
yh me too
@markpotvin7119
@markpotvin7119 7 лет назад
I thought the IAE V2500 was a Pratt & Whitney and Rolls Royce partneship
@SOUTHENDAVIATION
@SOUTHENDAVIATION 7 лет назад
I beleive it was just IAE
@83zillafan
@83zillafan 5 лет назад
@@markpotvin7119 Pretty much. Pratt & Whitney and MTU Aero Engines whilst compressors were provided by Rolls Royce
@diego90XD
@diego90XD 3 года назад
2:19 that RR seems too loud🤯
@funniyoutuber
@funniyoutuber Год назад
Thats what a real engine sounds like
@chrisnizer1885
@chrisnizer1885 7 лет назад
Hard to beat the rumble of a JT8D on a Mad Dog at full grunt.
@SOUTHENDAVIATION
@SOUTHENDAVIATION 7 лет назад
it is a great sound don't get me wrong! My vote goes the RRs though
@timdodd3897
@timdodd3897 4 года назад
JT3 for me!
@JuanIparraguirre
@JuanIparraguirre 4 года назад
JT8D all the way!
@eltoro6688
@eltoro6688 5 лет назад
JT8D! BY FAR AND AWAY!
@SOUTHENDAVIATION
@SOUTHENDAVIATION 5 лет назад
Nice classic BUZZZZ!
@davidcole333
@davidcole333 3 года назад
The JT8D has no equal.
@katherineberger6329
@katherineberger6329 3 года назад
JT8D wins! BEST. SOUND. EVAR.
@carl41767
@carl41767 2 года назад
JT8D wins all the time (JT8D is my favorite engine)
@2010kb1
@2010kb1 2 года назад
Honestly you could of done a better JT8D sound.It’s unequalled winding up.The RR has a nice whine to it.
@Static1701
@Static1701 Год назад
P&W any day
@lol-ug2ry
@lol-ug2ry 5 лет назад
717!!! Awesome spool up!!! Awesome Video!!!
@SOUTHENDAVIATION
@SOUTHENDAVIATION 5 лет назад
Nice choice! Thanks for watching!
@navajocapi
@navajocapi 3 года назад
You voted 717 just to bring fire to the comment section right? :D
@SOUTHENDAVIATION
@SOUTHENDAVIATION 3 года назад
Honestly no, I do prefer the 717. It’s probably because it’s the aircraft that introduced me to Maddog family, first Maddog I flew on etc.
@sherwinsalvatori6997
@sherwinsalvatori6997 3 года назад
Am patriotic to JT-8D
@gustavohenriqueF1
@gustavohenriqueF1 5 лет назад
Rolls-Royce.
@serg2963
@serg2963 2 года назад
No comparison... JT8D will always win!
@gingerelvira6587
@gingerelvira6587 2 года назад
U need to Ditch that No Focusing camera
@SOUTHENDAVIATION
@SOUTHENDAVIATION 2 года назад
Did that years ago my friend
@spicypeppers2019
@spicypeppers2019 6 лет назад
Both sound like hairdryers.
@SOUTHENDAVIATION
@SOUTHENDAVIATION 6 лет назад
On Steroids...
@spicypeppers2019
@spicypeppers2019 6 лет назад
SOUTHEND AVIATION yes!
@badass6.0powerstroke10
@badass6.0powerstroke10 Год назад
It's hard to Beat a JT8D !!!
@pieroysumalaconducta2272
@pieroysumalaconducta2272 3 года назад
JT8D the best sond ever
@gabrielhalston6726
@gabrielhalston6726 3 года назад
P&W wins hands down!
@jovanholland36
@jovanholland36 3 года назад
JT8D is the best
@hikakin_mania440
@hikakin_mania440 Год назад
2:07爆音
@andywilliams949
@andywilliams949 2 года назад
The Pratt is an antique compared to the rolls so not really a contest
@ysaviationtrains2313
@ysaviationtrains2313 7 лет назад
I would say B717 because its sounds better and more modern like
@SOUTHENDAVIATION
@SOUTHENDAVIATION 7 лет назад
I prefer the B717 too man
@michaelo1929
@michaelo1929 5 лет назад
Screw modern. Modern engines are quiet and princess-like. Listen to a JT8D in real life and you will not only hear the loud thunderous roar, but you will also feel it. Just like a loud clap of thunder. You can feel the rumble. Engines nowadays don’t even set off car alarms. Modern engines are boring and not impressive whatsoever.
@jerrystanfield6894
@jerrystanfield6894 6 лет назад
PW jt8d
@the747videoer
@the747videoer 2 года назад
BR all the way, sue me
@brocanova
@brocanova 6 лет назад
Definitely the GE90
@jadendavis5186
@jadendavis5186 4 года назад
8d wins
@RealSaulGoodman78
@RealSaulGoodman78 Год назад
Boeing ruined this plane That’s why it didn’t sell a lot
@harrisoncarey4031
@harrisoncarey4031 7 лет назад
BR 715s defo
@SOUTHENDAVIATION
@SOUTHENDAVIATION 7 лет назад
yep, same for me.
@harrisoncarey4031
@harrisoncarey4031 7 лет назад
It's a hard to decide
@Zangg217
@Zangg217 4 года назад
I hate old engine
@cdllc1956
@cdllc1956 4 года назад
JT8D
Далее
When A Gang Leader Confronted Muhammad Ali
11:43
Просмотров 4,1 млн
Лепим из пластилина🐍
00:59
Просмотров 549 тыс.
Каха заблудился в горах
00:57
Просмотров 4,8 млн
Mapping the Trump Shooting
6:12
Просмотров 14 млн
Dry motoring a JT8D turbine engine
10:45
Просмотров 11 тыс.
How a JT8 Engine Works
1:15
Просмотров 36 тыс.
the engines of a 737-200 speaking!!!!!
8:27
Просмотров 54 тыс.
Разговор на Патриках
1:01
Просмотров 4,2 млн
Разговор на Патриках
1:01
Просмотров 4,2 млн
İnside out Balloon game
0:18
Просмотров 16 млн