Side by side... they appear to be identical. My advice is to get on the email list for the next run of pathfinder skillets. Outstanding quality and value from wilderness outfitters! Thank you! www.selfrelian...
In case anyone is still wondering - I actually bought both and sawed both of them open. They are the exact same inside with an aluminum disk at the bottom. End of argument.
I actually have the Pathfinder skillet (WITH lid) and it has to be the best buy I've made. One thing tho, you NEED to watch Dave Canterbury's video on "treating" the skillet and how to properly use it BEFORE first use. follow his video's advice and it will serve you very well. I did and "haven't looked back" so to speak., since!
I thought for sure that you were going to say the Pathfinder skillet was more expensive than the Primus, it's good to see that the "common man" as Mr. Canterbury like to say is actually the affordable one,,,and with a lid! Thanks for sharing.
I have a Pathfinder from Self Reliance Outfitters and it is exactly the same as the Primus 21cm skillet. Although the Primus skillet does not come with a lid, it does have a sexy "Primus" etching on the skillet and tag (rare Peruvian Satin guinea pig leather?) attached to the handle for about $15 more.
Wrong. They are not the same. The Primus is better to cook on. The Primus pan is built like standard and higher end kitchen cookware with an aluminum layer on the exterior for better heat distribution. Go to Macy's, William Sonoma, or visit the All Clad website. You will learn from the sale staff why aluminum bonded to the underside of the stainless steel pan is a better solution. This difference is readily available when cooking. You can see it when simmering, you can see it when the wind is blowing the flame uneven on your camp stove, you can see it when a stove flame is hotter than required or has poor heat controls. There are many outer instances where you can view the superiority of the Primus pan, but you actually have to cook with it and not just take a video of it when it is nice and shiny.
Okay. I wanted to buy the 25 cm. pan but pathfinder was a hard find. With the extra delivery charge on Amazon the 21cm. Pathfider pan was pricier, however with a lid. I opted for the primas 21 and 25cm. skillets and with universal lids from the Stanley even cook pro set I am looking forward to some enjoyable cooking. It is obvious that the Primas fit and finish makes it appear to be a better pan but the proof is in the cooking.
I believe the Primus has a bonded aluminum disc on the bottom of pan for even heat distribution (according to their website). I don't think the pathfinder does.
Eat Carbs Outdoors that's right! At first it was just the pan for $15, but then sro came out with the lid both as a separate item for people who already bought one and they changed the new buyer option to $20 with the lid. I'm a big fan of sro setting a more common man profit margin. It makes you think about what you get for the markup on some of these items.
Pathfinder ... In Stock ??? I never could find one in stock with them. Even left a to be notified with them , heard nothing. After 6 months ( I even checked back several times ) I gave up and got the Primus. To make it even sweeter , I'm a Cabelas member so I used some of my saved up Cabelas points to get it. ( no money exchanged hands )
Chuck Littleton they sell out fast. The last time I bought one for a friend I was alerted by the email. The good news is they are more likely to have the separate sale lids.
Agreed. They are all made in the same Chinese factory, they just print your own brand on it :) Many products are made like that nowadays, we only believe we are buying different brands, while we actually buy the same Chinese products...
it is really ugly that company's can just start buying stuff and brand them with there own logo and say it is a new product. you see it everywhere and it really annoys me.
Good comparison. I have the Pathfinder skillet with lid and have cooked in it dozens of times. It is a great skillet and heats very evenly across the bottom. Low heat works good. I've been curious about the Primus skillet for some time now. It does look the same but it is advertised with an aluminum disk bonded to the bottom. The Pathfinder skillet has a steel disk and is very magnetic, much more than the cooking part of the pan. If you have a magnet can you check both the Pathfinder to see what I mean and then the Primus to see if there is indeed a difference (if the priumus bottom is aluminum like they say, which would make it non magnetic). Also have you seen any difference between them performance wise when cooking? Thanks
I have the 25 cm Primus and it is a great pan but I seen the pathfinder and it looks exactly the same to my eyes. Pathfinder says all steel but Primus says alum base......can you weigh each one? let us know? Cheers
The primus skillet seems to be nonexistent in Canada now. Do you have any experience with the 10" glacier Stainless troop skillet as a comparable replacement to the 25cm?
Jay Kae stay tuned. I recently picked up the GSI troop skillet which looks to be pretty fantastic... I have it in my possession but I haven’t gotten a chance to use it yet. The skillet is available separately as well as with the very large troop pot set.
@@Thereal111t I'm very curious to see how it pairs with the alpine 4 pot set and the trangia 25 set. I like the systems you've put together. I eagerly await the verdict.
@@Thereal111t could you confirm whether it nests together with either the alpine 4 pot set or trangia 25? It's on sale at my local outdoor store but due to corona I can't confirm if it will fit or not before ordering.
Gary voigt yes I’m sure you’re right. It’s amazing that the pathfinder school is able to sell it for $20 with a lid. It’s simultaneously amazing that Primus is selling it for $40-$50.
The primus is built with an aluminum base plate. They are not the same pans. The Pathfinder is a cheap stainless steel only pan that will burn food easily.
