Prince Imrahil of Dol Amroth - Epic Character History

Подписаться 384 тыс.

Просмотров 85 тыс.

50% 1

Prince Imrahil of Dol Amroth was a renowned leader of Gondor during the War of the Ring, and his story and time in Middle-earth deserves remembrance! Thank you all so much for watching, let me know your thoughts about Prince Imrahil in the comments below! As always, a great thanks to the online artists whose visual works made this video possible! If you are one of the artists, please let me know and I will post your name and a link to your work in this description!
#LordoftheRings
#Lore
Consider donating to our Patreon for the Westernesse Podcast and Discord Server:
/ menofthewest
Check out our Merch:
www.spreadshirt.com/user/Yoys...
Check out our music channel:
/ @musicmotw
Join us on Facebook at:
/ yoystan
Join us on Twitter at:
/ yoystan
Related articles:
tolkiengateway.net/wiki/Imrahil
lotr.fandom.com/wiki/Imrahil
tolkiengateway.net/wiki/Dol_Am...
Settlements of Gondor:
• Settlements of Gondor
Faramir, Captain of Gondor - Epic Character History:
• Prince Faramir, Captai...
Éowyn, Shieldmaiden of Rohan - Epic Character History:
• Éowyn, Shieldmaiden of...
The Tragic Love Story of Amroth and Nimrodel:
• The Tragic Love Story ...
The Love Story of Faramir and Éowyn:
• The Love Story of Fara...
Thank you for your patronage!
Adrian De la Torre
Peter Sheppard
Chris Ortner
Kyle Wetzel
Lane Grimes
Samuel McBee
Jonathan Putnam
Mark Kralick
Diego Perez
Berni McCoy
Daniel Orlandi
John Crowley
Rasmus Hansen
Susan Henry
Atlas
Jennifer Wood
Maz Gibs
Ryan Warren
Renato Filipe
Imiel Elenen
Chiara Siasat
Tyler Lund
Hydro Knight
Joshua W
Ádám Kis
The new Men of the West logo was created by Raffe - Twitter: RaffetheRandom
The final image “Bag End” was created by Wayne Glassbrook at designly.net
The first song was developed and produced by my associate Galafee.
The last song used in this video is from:
library.techsmith.com/
Many related and/or used art come from these artists and sources:
Ted Nasmith:
www.tednasmith.com/
Jenny Dolfen:
goldseven.wordpress.com/
Alan Lee:
www.iamag.co/the-art-of-alan-...
John Howe:
www.john-howe.com/portfolio/g...
Hildebrant brothers:
www.brothershildebrandt.com/Br...
DonatoArts:
www.deviantart.com/donatoarts
Magali Villeneuve
www.magali-villeneuve.com/
Wolfanita:
www.deviantart.com/wolfanita
Gerwell:
/ gerwell
Mirach Ravaia:
www.deviantart.com/mirachrava...
Kaprriss:
www.deviantart.com/kaprriss/g...
EKukanova:
www.deviantart.com/ekukanova/...
steamy:
www.deviantart.com/steamey
Laurelinartistry:
/ laurelinartistry
SaMo-art:
www.deviantart.com/samo-art/g...
kimberly80:
www.deviantart.com/kimberly80...
Anke Eissmann:
anke.edoras-art.de/anke_illust...
Fabio Leone:
www.artstation.com/artwork/48...
Luke Martins:
www.artstation.com/artwork/Qz...
Joshua Cairos:
www.artstation.com/artwork/l6BVo
Even Amundsen:
www.artstation.com/artwork/0X...
Álvaro Calvo Escudero:
www.artstation.com/artwork/8l...
AbePapakhian:
www.deviantart.com/abepapakhi...
www.deviantart.com/abepapakhi...
meneldil-elda:
www.deviantart.com/meneldil-e...

Опубликовано:

5 сен 2020

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 275

@rhysoverbeck5251 3 года назад

Him being in the movie instead of the dead mountain men is prolly the one thing I would change. That or the Gondorian soldiers not being idiots at fighting

@TANKTheImmortal 3 года назад

I don't think they were idiots. Take osgiliath for example, they held out through the entire night against a force that far outnumbered them, fighting for hours and hours till daylight and only being forced to retreat when the nazgul showed up. And at minas tirith they fought and fought against a force that was massive and far exceeded their own forces. A testament to their training and dedication. No real life force could've ever held out against those odds, would've been crushed in a couple hours at osgiliath. only time I feel they were idiots was shooting arrows at the drive towers and not the trolls.

@rhysoverbeck5251 3 года назад

Tank_the_Immortal I mean like actual screen presence, when you look at Gondor battle footage, like 8/10 chance it’s a gondorian getting killed by an orc. But they were good for holding as long as they did

@kathleenhensley5951 3 года назад

The dead mountain scenes were way too bloated. and that downpour of skulls was just silly.

@josephgomez2249 3 года назад

Right! Compare the Gondor soldier fighting and dying to Boromirs death scene. Both are soldiers fighting against overwhelming odds and dying after putting up a fight. Except the Gondor soldiers death’s only look miserable. You aren’t left with the impression that they were capable men, though they were.

@mattlien5844 3 года назад

I would change two things:The relationship between Aragorn, Arwen and Elrond. One of the most important in the book, the movie ruins it. And most importantly, Orlando Bloom on a skateboard. That alone almost ruins the movies for me.

@NOIDEAIWILLJUSTUSEHAILEYIGUESS 3 года назад

Prince Imrahil was such an under-rated character, Loved how important he was in the battles of the Pelennor, and how bravely he stood at the black gates, putting himself on the frontlines, all while not losing too many knights, showing off the skill and valour the knights still had.

@MenoftheWest 3 года назад

Absolutely, he was a hero of Gondor, and I hope more people learn about him!

@genghisgalahad8465 3 года назад

@@MenoftheWest I should like to paste my comment from HotA: I have decided in Ent-fashion that Prince Imrahil is now my favorite newly discovered obscure character in Middle Earth, from all Ages, at this time. Being a relatively hidden character for some until now. His unassuming heroism is to be commended! To the lately recognized heroes of Middle Earth! Since I had finished this video and not having my wits about me, began the HotA video (yet unfinished) and commented this!

@lughiee Год назад

Hi Hailey

@NOIDEAIWILLJUSTUSEHAILEYIGUESS Год назад

@@lughiee Hey Lugh, funny seeing you here. :D

@OpenMeyendid Год назад

Do you provide transcripts for your videos? Great quotes and speaking. Thanks

@TheTabletopAlliance 3 года назад

One of my favourite characters! Always wish he was included in the movies!

@deathraven7314 3 года назад

Technically he was

@Ipitydafool2005 2 года назад

He was actually. But not mentioned directly. Watch The Return of the King and watch out for a long blond haired guard who appears often in the Minas Tirith scenes. He's the one.

@kaguya6900 3 года назад

Nearly every Tolkien good-guy character had flaws, but I was always amazed at how Imrahil had no flaws. He always made the correct tactical, political and strategic decisions. As you mentioned, he knew that Eowyn was alive. He was one of the three leaders who came out of Pelennor Fields unscathed because of their prowess in battle. He recognized Aragorn's claim, and made no comment against it. He deferred to Gandalf even when Denethor was skeptical. He was the perfect human.

@muz9663 2 года назад

He was meant to be a character that shows what Gondor would've looked like in the glory days. Legolas says "That is a fair lord and a great captain of men. If Gondor has such men still in these days of fading, great must have been its glory in the days of its rising" It kinda shows that Imrahil was meant to be of purest Gondorian blood

@championsgaming1 2 года назад

Dol amroth as a whole is supposed to be the glory of what gondor should be. They had enough elvish blood and i believe the purest numenorian blood left, incredible horse riders, with terrifying infantry. True decendants of numenor in the south.

@zippyparakeet1074 10 месяцев назад

Yep. Dol Amroth is the last place in Middle Earth where you can still find the purest Dunedain with its nobility even having Eldar blood. Imrahil was said to have an elvish glow in his face which is why even Legolas bowed to him in greeting. They were all tall, incredibly long lived, strong people with great arts, music riches and technology. Dol Amroth really was Gondor's greatest asset in the Third Age.

@suflanker45 3 года назад

I know Jackson wanted to streamline the story for the movies and he did a very good job. (The Army of the Dead at Minas Tirith made more sense in the movie) But keeping Imrahil and the Swan Knights in the Return of the King wouldn't have been a major hassle IMHO.

@Norralin Год назад

It greatly annoyed me how they skipped the summoning of the "banners" of Gondor. It would have showed that there was more to Gondor than the inhabitants of Minas Tirith..

@orrointhewise87 3 года назад

"Ride! Ride for ruin and the worlds ending!!!" I get why they were left out of the film, but maaaaaaaaan would they have been awesome to see riding in from the south to help in the battle for Minas Tirith. I always get pleasantly surprised when I read the books and realize OH RIGHT! These guys!!! 😂

@Revenix 3 года назад

Yeah I would have loved to see the great Swan Knights ride out of the gate!

@NOIDEAIWILLJUSTUSEHAILEYIGUESS 3 года назад

I agree, the Swan-Knights riding out of the gates to save the day is one of my favorite moments, you know its serious then the most elite knights of Gondor ride out of those gates.

@muz9663 2 года назад

@@NOIDEAIWILLJUSTUSEHAILEYIGUESS I love PJ for actually having the battle take place within Minas Tirith unlike the books where none enter except the witch king. It would've been cool seeing the swan knights behind the gate instead of the average soldier, which would've been great for introducing or developing Prince Imrahil as a character.

@nutyyyy Год назад

@muz9663 Yes, that would be a good way to include them. Maybe a simple cameo.

@GamingTremor 3 года назад

The most unfortunate exclusion in the movies, even more than Tom Bombadiil in my opinion!

@kathleenhensley5951 3 года назад

Maybe it is for the best that Jackson didn't try to portray Tom Bombadil? Tom can seem absurd until you read further and realize how very strange he is... He is a very, very special character .. The ONE ring didn't have any power over him? He was first. He fell in love with the river's daughter? what i mean ... look how Radagast was treated.. Jackson made him a buffoon. All we know is he loves animals, was a herbalist, doesn't much involve himself with mankind and is an Angel incarnate like Gandalf... (a Maia)

@timonsolus 3 года назад

Kathleen Hensley : I think Peter Jackson brought many aspects of Tom Bombadil’s character into Radagast - since the personality of Radagast was extremely vague and virtually unknown in the books. We have only Saruman’s description of Radagast, and that is very biased against him, and therefore unreliable.

@chefitaly7339 3 года назад

And erkenbrand

@just_cade 3 года назад

The saddest exclusion is Glorfindel in my opinion.

@muz9663 2 года назад

@@kathleenhensley5951 I think PJ would've still made Tom Bombadil a really strange and interesting character. I don't think he had enough time to include him and make the story even more complex. PJ would've definitely showed Tom holding the ring and having no effect, that would've caused a great deal of confusion among the audience, plus he would've likely been discarded in the later movies anyways.

@kevincanales7655 3 года назад

Too bad they discard him from the movies, such charismatic character, and as always your videos are awesome

@Revenix 3 года назад

Yeah, that would’ve been awesome to see him!

@austinbaccus 3 года назад

He’s in ROTK for one or two very short scenes

@Dude_1864 3 года назад

I'm glad honestly, that Peter Jackson discarded him as a usable character. Fairly certain he would have gotten the Faramir treatment otherwise.

@kevincanales7655 3 года назад

@@Dude_1864 I agreed but characters like him, Glorfindel,Tom Bombadil and even Elrond's twins would have given a unique flavor to the movie, but nothing is perfect

@scottcameron174 3 года назад

Complete agree I always loved Prince Imrahil. I think the issue as always was it would have confused the casual fans of the movies.

@johnpatricktan5545 3 года назад

I feel sad that they left him out of the movies

@zakfett92 3 года назад

I thought he was that blonde guy that brought Faramir to Denethor...

@Mr.im1 3 года назад

zakfett92 I think that that was a cheap version of Beregrond tho he doesn’t act even a litte bit like him.

@AndrewMRoots 3 года назад

@@zakfett92 That guy's name is Irolas

@zakfett92 3 года назад

@@AndrewMRoots Who the hell is that?

@AndrewMRoots 3 года назад

@@zakfett92 The blonde guy you mentioned, his name is Irolas, maybe I should've been more clear

@kiratsingh3065 3 года назад

Great Character Who Unfortunately Was Left Out Of The Movies. Thanks for the vid!

@shadowofchaos8932 3 года назад

I wonder how powerful the navy at Dol Amroth added in the realm of Gondor. The Swan ships of Dol Amroth are said to be Grand in craftsmanship. Great video.

@NOIDEAIWILLJUSTUSEHAILEYIGUESS 3 года назад

Its likely that they were quite powerful, the corsairs, even with umbar and pelargir, were about equal in strength with the forces left to defend western gondor. after the war, with pelargir going back into gondor's posession, its likely the Prince Imrahil commanded one of the most fearsome naval powers.

@SantomPh 3 года назад

Gondor's navy was headquarted at Pelargir with the command given to the Lord of Ships. However during the Kin-strife led by Castamir most of the navy sided with the rebel prince,who was its commander. His sons fled to Umbar, weakening the navy. Gondor never became a naval power again, at least to rival Umbar -they could still support Arnor later- and Aragorn's brave foray into Umbar as Thorongil later was one of the few times Gondor sailed to war after the Kin Strife. The swan ships are not war galleys like the ships of the Corsairs.

@ChiaraSiasat 3 года назад

Prince Imrahil was definitely an underrated character in the lore. I wish they had shown a little more of him in the movies as well. Definitely one of my favorite minor characters in the books. Great video once again Yoystan!!

@MenoftheWest 3 года назад

Thanks Angel, you’re the best!

@paulwagner688 3 года назад

The arrival of the out companies is one of the best scenes in the books. Of course, if you include the out companies, you would have to include the journey of Aragorn from Morthond to Erech, to Pelargir.

@ChiaraSiasat 3 года назад

Paul Wagner agreed it was definitely one of my favorite parts in the book! Something like that could have been written in well somehow in the movies. Imrahil was a great presence during the war of the ring and I wish that PJ had maybe shown even just a small bit of it.

@hostilenative920 3 года назад

Did they show him in the films ?

@ChiaraSiasat 3 года назад

NATiVE MOB no they did not I wish they had though.

@MrDuck797 3 года назад

So sad Imrahil wasn’t in the films. I really liked him in the book

@AmiraMekki 3 года назад

Ight this world needs more people like him. Such an honourable character and I never knew about his deeds.

@mahmudurzakaria9217 3 года назад

If it wasn't for Imrahil, the Knights of the Mark probably would've buried Eowyn alive.

@matkosotosek Год назад

Prince Imrahil is one of my favorite characters in the LOTR trilogy. He represents not only the full might of Gondor cavalry but the wisdom of the West. He is the character that made the difference, not just in defending Minas Thirith, but defending Faramir, crying: "Dol Amroth for Gondor! Dol Amroth for Faramir". Just imagine 700 full-armored knights charging against the Nazgul. EPIC!!! Not the mention, he is a healer and general and, unlike Denethor, immediately accepts Aragorn as King Elessar. As for the LOTR movie trilogy, since there was no Tom Bombadil, Elladan& Elrohir, there was just no point in putting him in the movie. Big shame, but still, Tolkien fans will always know the immense value of Dol Amroth ;)

@DanielDtravis11 3 года назад

Top 10 favorite character of mine. As a teen I was bummed that he didn't make it into the movies.

@r.blakehole932 3 года назад

I as well missed Imrahil in the movies. But, in the defense of Peter Jackson, in the movies creating a memorable and worthy character is much more difficult and time consuming than it is in books. So, they have to cut down from what is in the books in order to have the time the time necessary for the most central characters.

@AnnaMarianne 3 года назад

Frankly, they also wasted time here anf there. They could have left out or at least shortened certain action scenes to squeeze in more time for side character development. Now Gondor as a country and a people was left criminally underdeveloped.

@valentinom.4292 3 года назад

@@AnnaMarianne You see, they also had a massive budget to pay. I don't really think a movie with barely any action scenes would sell like the trilogy did. I would love it tho.

@genghisgalahad8465 3 года назад

Perhaps a stream series surrounding Gondor would flesh out the Heroes/Lords of Gondor!

@Will.Flavell 2 года назад

If Prince Imrahil was in the movie I would think Gary Oldman would have been be a good choice to play him.

@hydroknight8612 3 года назад

He's done it again folks! 👏👏👏 Seriously Thank you for keeping the lore fresh and new with every video. Good job my man 👍👍

@Revenix 3 года назад

Yeah! He is awesome!

@dodgykingdom7502 3 года назад

Great captain of men.

@KaustubhVarshneyPnpl 3 года назад

He was absolutely one of the most important captains in the war, as much as Faramir and Eomer in my opinion, but he felt even greater and braver and more steadfast to me.

@TacticsTom54 3 года назад

Literally my favorite character from the LOTR besides Aragorn . Great video .

@thehighguarduk4820 3 года назад

What a fantastic character. I did not know Prince Imrahil had saved both Faramir and Eowyn, two of my favourite characters. Which raise Prince Imrahil even higher in my good opinion of him. Awesome video really well told and explained. Nicely done!

@jesuscoyt-munoz2753 3 года назад

Great video and summarization of this great man yoystan! I’d also like to add that imrahil also teaches us that uncle’s can be great people to their nieces or nephews as from what I saw he loved faramir and possibly boromir as his own children and I’d like to think he was like an iroh to boromir and faramir! I’d also like to add that he teaches us that loyalty to family and friends is greatly important and you must always show that even in impossible odds such as iimrahil did in the siege of minas tirith and the battle of pelenor fields!

@mahmudurzakaria9217 3 года назад

Yes. Finally. Been waiting for this for so long. Thanks Yusten.

@bobbob-yr4bh 3 года назад

I have always thought that the low number of knights of the silver swan where the best cavalry in the world. even surpassing the horse lords

@NOIDEAIWILLJUSTUSEHAILEYIGUESS 3 года назад

Same here, they lost so few during the war, despite being mostly on the frontlines. having elvish and numenorean blood is also very op. I like to think of them as the last "true" numenoreans in middle-earth, and its likely they rose to great power since pelargir was retaken.

@SantomPh 3 года назад

No one surpasses the Rohirrim in horse riding and combat, even the Knights of Dol Amroth. However they are Gondor's best cavalry and one of the last vestiges of the days of Elendil, with a special air about them.

@terry7907 3 года назад

I always pictured them as being heavy cavalry (knights/armoured men at arms) while the Rohirrim were more medium cavalry since they lived their lives on horeseback.

@uniboss5519 3 года назад

It does talk about horse riding only, so I’d like to think the knights excel in different areas due to that high blood

@segundajuganda 3 года назад

@@terry7907 exactly. KoDA - heavy hitting unit for certain tasks. Rohirims - all rounded commando forces to deal with anything anywhere.

@matthewmckendree305 3 года назад

It’s been awhile without Gondor, good to see you back my friend.

@pbell4660 3 года назад

It's disappointing how so many characters and scenes were discarded to make space for videogame battles and made-up drama. Not only the usual Tom Bombadil, or the magic battle against fell wolves, or my boy Ghân-buri-Ghân, but also that scene were Pippin watches the bannermen from all over Gondor come to Minas Tirith before the battle even if they're not nearly enough to make a difference, until Imrahil comes with his elvish-like army playing a flute as nothing bad was about to happen, and people rejoice. (more or less, can't recall all details) You own me those goosebumps, Philippa Whatshername.

@Arcflo 3 года назад

Your videos are the best thank you!

@MenoftheWest 3 года назад

Thank you, that means a lot! And thanks for watching!

@DaPenguin 3 года назад

Imrahil has been my favorite character in the books for as long as I can remember. Thank you for doing a video on him!

@jonystyles9473 3 года назад

FINALLY MAN, great video new lore!

@jvercouillie 3 года назад

Great description of this character, and the pictures you included made me rethink Imrahil the Fair.

@jonasaho6722 3 года назад

Imragil is very important character in his own right. In the Prince of Dol Amroth we see shadow of the might that Denethor had during his prime and presence he could still have had during the war if the mind of the steward had been sound. Imrahil like his brother in law had keen eyes to assess different situationss both on battlefield and consul table. For exsample he was correct about the gamble they took at he Black Gate even if not many others saw it as morbidly hilarious as Imrahil himself. The elven bloodline of Imrahil, that he got most likely from Mithrellas and her children Galador and Gilmith does play a role, but It is not only thing that makes this man so great Imrahil the prince of Dol Amroth is indeed worth to remember.

@noahnieto45 3 года назад

A very interesting character indeed. Great video mellon!

@katokhaelan4881 3 года назад

My dude... Thank you so much for this. So well done.

@rodneysmith4745 3 года назад

Yours is one of my favorite RU-vid channels, whenever I have stress or am feeling a little overwhelmed I stop by and learn/enjoy something new about my favorite story.

@himerosTheGod Год назад

I can hear my mother screaming at our tv now as we watched LOTR “This was the days of real men”!!

@markaruski 2 года назад

This was great, thanks for making this, one of my favorite characters in LOTR! I agree with so many of the great comments on this video, good stuff.

@GreenHavoc Год назад

Great topic! Never knew about this character before and was cool to learn

@morgandavid6908 3 года назад

Thank you for this story. I was not aware or remembered the lineage of this character. I have probably read Lord of the Rings a dozen times. But i always seem to learn something new listening to your stories. As always, thank you for your time and efforts.

@TheStwee 3 года назад

Never been so early before. Thank you for creating this video ! Shame he didn't appear in the movies.

@arisan4480 3 года назад

Definitely one of the best character in all of Middle Earth’s Third Age. Great video, as always. Now I’ll spend the rest of my day thinking about the Amrothian knights’s shining helmets and mighty steeds !

@trent6134 3 года назад

Amazing Video man! Thank you for doing a character history for Prince Imrahil. He is my favourite minor character.

@vincentdamienarneo369 3 года назад

Thanks for a vid on imrahil he also one of my favorite book characters

@unlimitedperseverance1706 3 года назад

Great videos

@MemoryTroll 3 года назад

Great vid! Love it, man! 👍

@stardust949 3 года назад

Thank you so much for the back ground of Prince Imrahil!! I have long wished to know more about his Elven blood and how it came to be a part of his lineage. Wonderful video!

@naphasorn3993 3 года назад

Great Character, love this vid:)

@IronDragon-2143 3 года назад

Hey I remember watching a video on the Friendship between Legolas and Gimli so can you do one between Frodo and Sam? Or maybe Gandalf and Bilbo?

@rook1513 3 года назад

Something I've noticed in many modern movies is that characters appear out of nowhere without a lot of set up; one nice and tight package. This is something encouraged in modern writing and by professional writers. Prince Imrahil demonstrates the huge and realistic world Professor Tolkien created. Before his marching to Minas Tirith, the reader has no idea who this is. (The southern territories are vaguely hinted at; and Legolas tells the family legend of the history of Dol Amroth.) Prince Imrahil and his knights lent a realism; that there were more people and places. The Knights of Dol Amroth allowed the Professor to include the pure-hearted, shiny Galahad type. This role could not have been filled by any of the people whom we had met (except elves) Gondor was too sullied by war and Arnor lived in the forest. It was through the Knights of Dol Amroth, LOTR possessed the paragon of European chivalry., This is one man's opinion.

@MrSRA13 3 года назад

Best middle earth channel on RU-vid along with Geekzone! You guys are awesome

@gregdingel 3 года назад

Great character history, thanks!

@t.c.thompson2359 Год назад

Whenever they adapt the series again, which they will inevitably do, it should be in a miniseries format so they can include a lot more book material and characters, like Imrahil.

@Revenix 3 года назад

Do you think maybe you could do a video covering some of the family trees? Also love your videos! ❤️

@Mr.im1 3 года назад

YES FINALLY Imrahil is my favo characters from Tolkien his legendarium. Thank you 🙏

@mohamadmusavi3097 3 года назад

i love your work well done

@jankaiglarova7917 3 года назад

Epic video! 😍✨👑 Love it so much. Hannon le for making it.

@beaumagoffin7397 3 года назад

I really love your content, and i have an idea for your who would win series, the Dwarves of Khazad dum versus the Dwarves of Erebor

@TheBLRBear 3 года назад

Great video as expected! Thanks for taking the time to give us the back story to a great character, it was greatly enjoyed by me, and many others alike :) I do believe he is featured in the movie though. When Faramir is brought before Denethor on a stretcher, the man without the helmet that says that he is still alive is supposed to be Imrahil, although somebody should and surely will correct me if i am mistaken, as that could be one of the captains of the Steward as well :)

@celestejohnston6613 3 года назад

Yoystan! Wonderful video! The exclusion of Prince Imrahil and the Swan Knights is possibly the biggest error in PJ's ROTK. With the exception of Eomer finding Eowyn on the battlefield which always manages to rip my heart out every time. Prince Imrahil's actions would have made a great movie that much greater!! It is a great shame they were not there!

@JohnOdd 3 года назад

Thanks for posting I never knew of this character :)

@chefitaly7339 3 года назад

He is such a noble and oft overlooked hero

@unclejoe7466 3 года назад

Great spotlight on Imrahil. I like that he had a small role in the story. Maybe because any more focus on him would have required flaws to give him complexity, and I like that he is basically flawless (except, perhaps, for his pride).

@charlesrichards8132 2 года назад

That was a good one !

@lsporter88 3 года назад

That was really good. 😎

@thedreadtyger 3 года назад

This is wondrous indeed! He is a truly magnificent character, little known but well loved by those who do.

@joshuapaulson9116 3 года назад

I really wish this character had been represented in The Return of the King.

@yourseatatthetable 3 года назад

Even though Prince Imrahil's role was limited it played a very important part in that he was the first high ranking Gondorian to openly acknowledge Aragorn's claim and bloodline. As kin of the Steward, and with both of Denthor's son's killed or incapacitated Imrahil could have easily laid claim as the next Steward. From a political position, Imrahil noting Aragorn was a king, fulfilling the ancient proficiency, greatly legitimizes Aragorn. I believe the character also serves another role, one that shows that the blood of Numenor was not spent in Gondor, even in this late age. Imrahil and many of his men give us a window into what Gondor must have looked like in it's prime, and what it might again look like in the Fourth age.

@DanTheYoutubeAddict 3 года назад

He is a minor but important and noble character. Thank you for covering him.

@davidpatrick4871 3 года назад

Great content. I got lost though. I’ll watch it again tomorrow.

@DiracComb.7585 3 года назад

Ah yes, my second weekly dose of Tolkien, my first being the Tolkien club I’m a part of. A great video once again. Keep it up 👍

@Steel-101 3 года назад

All right a new Men of the West video!!!! Thanks for the entertainment man God bless and stay safe. Hey I may have an idea 💡 for a video. Why didn’t Frodo ever get married and have children? That question could apply to both Frodo and Bilbo. I’ve always wondered why.

@SantomPh 3 года назад

The Baggins are both famous bachelors who lived alone in Bag End, seemingly caring little for making families . Frodo is 50 in the book at the start, meaning that like Bilbo he kept single in anticipation of Gandalf returning. In Frodo's case he was wounded 3 times with traumatic events that sapped his enjoyment of life. The Morgul blade, Shelob's sting and Gollum's biting off his finger made him almost hollow. Even in Lothlorien all Frodo got was warnings of the future and peril instead of comfort. In short Frodo was miserable and could never enjoy anything, unlike Sam who got married, planted a mallorn tree and started a blonde family and became the Mayor.

@idkwhattomakemyname101 3 года назад

Can you imagine how lit it would be if they started an animated TV show about the Tolkien books fashioned the same way as the Star Wars clone wars TV show

@mountainboinaps6471 3 года назад

this is such a good one, i wish he was in the stories more

@sethmiller2534 3 года назад

I cannot say he is much a looker, but as you speak deeply on this man, there is clearly no better nor no more beautiful a man than you

@loremaster234 3 года назад

So far, 1.1k likes vs 7 dislikes. Just shows you how well received this channel is, and rightfully so. Keep going brother and God bless!

@Ella-hq9ih 3 года назад

I’ve never been this early, haha For a theory video, you should consider doing , What if Fili had survived the battle of the five armies, & took the throne since he was Thorin’s heir!

@animalmuther4000 3 года назад

This is great because it's someone that people don't know much about. I would find when you do the polls people always vote for the ones that were in the movies. Keep up the great lore.

@heinrichkornelius 3 года назад

My favourite character in The Return of the King. The example of a good lord, especially when contrasted with Denethor.

@lynnpoint6395 2 года назад

Peter Jackson could inanely make up elves at Helm's Deep, but ignore the Imrahil and the Knights of Dol Amroth at Mina Tirith.

@JonathonSwinney2814 3 года назад

I love Prince Imrahil! He's one of my favorite of the race of man

@thinkfirstt 3 года назад

Princess Lotheriel marries Eomer. Yes. How nice. Imrahil's daughter. So both marriages (Faramir &Eowyn)support the continued friendship between Gondor and Rohan.

@ErelasInglor 3 года назад

One of the characters that I feel Tolkien may have expanded upon with a lineage and story of that realm of Gondor, perhaps even a short side-story of Imrahil's deeds as a youth.

@azipoor3468 3 года назад

Hi Yoystan it was awesome...by the way Tolkien had an essay called on fairy-stories which now is in a small book I'm not sure...could you make a video about it please?

@isaiahsullivan7199 3 года назад

I love you guys. I really hope Amazon comes out with that show because I really want to see the second age on the big screen

@blakej5444 3 года назад

Hi. Big fan, I noticed you don't have an Epic Character History on Saruman. I would very much like to see such a video.

@Mr.im1 3 года назад

I always thought you became less active for a reason. But the men of the west is back !!!

@rebeccaburgess8901 3 года назад

Am I the only one who kind of imagines him of father like figure to Boromir and Faramir after Denethor became distant to them?

@michealcormier2555 3 года назад

My only big disappointment of the movies was that Prince Imrahil was not in it. I could understand why the Scouring of the Shire didn't make it, but to this day, I don't understand why he got left out.

@michaelheatherwall2495 Год назад

One of my favourite characters and as is said one that is underrated but of great importance as is seen by Legolas’s greeting to him.

@igorpl12 3 года назад

Would be great to see him on screen, always think that the Swan Knights are some of the most awesome and beautifully described armors from Tolkien

@designtechdk 3 года назад

There probably isn't a lot about it, but I would love to hear more about Éomer and Lothíriel! :) I also love the part where Eomer discovers Eowyn in the books. He basically rides off to die, filled with the grief of the supposed death of his sister.

@srimadhumithra2330 3 года назад

Prince Imrahil of the Dol Amroth. He should have been in the movies. His character was one of the most important ones! Like always, Great Video, Mellon!

@history1099 2 года назад

My favorite character!

@HyperGlameow 3 года назад

Such a cool character

@gm2407 3 года назад

When they said he had elven blood I thought he was a scion of Elindills line. I didnt know another elf human marriage occured outside of the Elrond Elros lines.