Pro-Torah Scholarship and First-Century Meal Customs (Interview w/ Caleb Hegg) 

Thank you for sharing this interview My family and community have benefited greatly from both of your ministries and resources. Shalom shalom!

Interesting conversation. It was enlightening to learn about greco-roman tradition in meal eating. My husband and I used to attend Beit Hallel, Tim Hegg's congregation. Nice to see you online, Caleb! I pray you and your family are doing well.

I'm so happy to see this discussion. David, you were a big part of the Lord awakening me to the Torah. Then I found Torah Resource. There, I've been devouring information in their library and learning Hebrew. You both have been such a blessing!

David - through a debate you won - you had me reconsider my theology which led me to get your book "remeber the sabbath" --- which led me to Tim Hegg and buying all his books - which led me to Torah Resource learning center... My family has been growing into Torah observance ever since !! 🎉 Thank you !!

Just fascinating. Thanks for this interview. Inspired to dig even deeper.

Great interview, I'm really looking forward hearing more on this topic. Kinda with Caleb would do that info dump he was talking about. So I can look over the info.

This was great! Thanks for posting :)

I’m so excited to learn more about meals as worship. Great conversation! Thank you

Also to add to the conversation, in the Acts of the Nazarines (clementine literature) Peter will not eat with those unbaptized.

So, in consideration of the "Passover Meal" issues, I am interested in your take on the "Eliyahu". It seems to be in every Passover Siddur, but I object. It seems to be a prayer to Elijah. I have seen two translations. One was clearly a prayer to Elijah, and one rephrased it as being only about Elijah. Who is right, and why is it in there, anyway? Thank-you so much for bringing in this particular guest. I have so much been seeking an alternative to FFOZ for years. Actually, this channel, and 119 Ministries, have been my alternative. But I still need more comprehensive study and research resources to be more actively engaged in. Thank-you so much for all your hard work!

Good discussion. Thanks David and Caleb.

He discusses "scholarship," and I agree it's a vital resource. However, in the Torah movement, people reject all forms of scholarship (Sean Griffin comes to mind) and submit their fringe and radical doctrine to no one for critical critique. I support his statement that you don't have to have a degree, but scholarship can be helpful to us when we are not as well-studied on a topic as someone else.

You should interview Dojacin Zivadinovic. 😊

Could it be that Yeshua is having meals with the Father in heaven right now? And we will also take part and “worship” and have meals in the millennial reign? Meaning animals are in heaven?

Just started watching this video with both of you. I am of Caleb's father's generation and remember getting into the early days (at least for me) 2000 of the Torah understanding. In all my early studying and visiting groups from the traditional Jewish Messianic to Sacred Name and later Hebrew roots. There are commonalities and differences and sadly some bad teaching/teachers. That all said the anti Torah crowd some of which you mentioned their concept of a thing called the Church and how it relates to national Israel has been rooted back into Roman Catholic doctrine. No one bothers to ask Did Jesus/Yeshua even start the universal church system or did that system grow out of the false teaching Paul warned the Ephesians about.

Actual conversation starts at 21:14.

The passage in 1 Corinthians 10 is saying if you are buying meat at the market and it is undisclosed, go ahead and eat, but if it is disclosed that this meat was pagan religiously killed (such as muslim Halal meat) then you should avoid it.

Yes! I love this because I saw the Lord’s Supper as the same thing, “as often as you do this, do it in remembrance of Me”, as often as we gather, we commune with Him, where 2 or 3 are gathered together in My Name I am there in the midst… How often are we communing together to honor our Messiah? Then how often are we actually participating in “communion”? Sounds like should be pretty often lol… forsake not the assembling together of yourselves even more as you see the day approaching! 🙌🏼🙏🏼

Interesting. I haven’t heard yet about how we should commune with the gentiles…. Which is part of the grafted in believers? You think this is also possible alongside what he’s stating, think this is very interesting and I can like how yall speak so I’ll be tapping in during my cover to cover which I’m hoping to start this weekend. I’m new 2years in still a baby learner so very intrigued and looking into the studies . I will say my online pastor each time they always have meals with worship…btw after start of my comment he answered my gentiles statement

Shalom I have to differ a little bit with the brother that an uncircumcised person can eat the Passover meal if there is no animal sacrifice. Exodus 12 and Leviticus 23 mandate to cook the animal by fire therefore there has to be a sacrifice to share the blood. The Torah gives us a physical aspect and a spiritual side of ceremonial customs but we cannot separate one from the other The rules for the Pesach meal are set and they are not to be changed,obviously Shaul or no one else is going to contradict the Torah much less Yahshuah to be circumcised means you are part of the people of IsraEL Ephesians 2:11-13 and part of being the people of a israEL-and to be circumcised is to be both heart and flesh(EzekiEL 44:5-9)otherwise you are not part of the Covenant with Abraham and you will be cut off (Gen 17:14) Shaul emphasis was on the fact that the heart should come first but never take away the physical aspect of the covenant Shalom Alechem

Here is a hint: The "day" starts at evening. Genesis 1:5 [5]And God called the light Day, and the darkness he called Night. And the evening and the morning were the first day.

Great conversation, guys! 36-mafia ;)

That was fantastic. What a cool conversation

Haven’t hebrews been doing this bread and wine blessing ritual since the time of Abraham? Isn’t this what Yeshua was talking about? Wasn’t he simply saying that the ritual always pointed to him, and so it should also be remembered in light of what he has done (pay the penalty of death for the broken blood covenant in the place of the guilty party).

You will often see pro-torah people shouting "the lord's supper was passover!!!" but it's like... what exactly did the early church do then when they met? Clearly there was a thanksgiving (eucharist) meal happening when they got together. How did that work? Like a jewish kiddush today? Isn't that like "communion" in the church today? What should church look like today? It's not enough to just say "the lord's supper was passover".

So we are justified by faith alone. True faith will cause a change in action/life. The Holy Spirit quickens us to protect Torah as a way of life. But only atonement saves.

Interesting perspective, but not really into the "new" interpretation of Paul's letter to the Corinthians. He dismisses the broader context and also I understand that the Last Supper is directly related to Passover, which he has to make a few arguments against in order to... further confuse the letters? Seems like chasing "new" just for the sake of having a "new" perspective.

I think brothers that we have to remember clearly that you can’t add or delete from the Torah so the Pesach has to be incorporated and established as the celebration to Yahshuah if we apply the Torah you will find that whoever did not have the blood of the lamb in their posts was going to perish and that can’t be changed, again, the physical and the spiritual meaning have to go together

Why did you leave 119

Don't eat the pork at the potluck.

The LORD's death = The LORD's sacrifice.

The animal lamb has been replaced by Jesus the Lamb. Still need to be circumcised.

Pursuant to 1 Corinthians 5:7-8, It is a passover meal! You cannot celebrate the feast and it not be the passover meal. Christ is our passover. CHRIST IS THE LAMB!!!

@Caleb Abib 14 passover (Yeshua dies) Abib 15 sabbath/ulb (Yeshua dead and rest) Abib 16 foff/1st day of week(Yeshua ressurects)