Prof. Bernard Lewis - Radical Islam, Israel and the West

Подписаться 52 тыс.

Просмотров 54 тыс.

50% 1

A Dialogue between
Prof. Bernard Lewis (Prof. Emeritus, Princeton University)
and Prof. Robert Wistrich
Tuesday, February 16, 2010
Research Seminar
The Vidal Sassoon International Center for the Study of Antisemitism - SICSA
The Hebrew University of Jerusalem

Опубликовано:

28 сен 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 114

@BenWeeks 7 лет назад

56:25 "As a historian I find it difficult enough to predict the past."

@4flbj407 5 лет назад

بسم الله الرحمان الرحيم سبحان الله والحمد لله ولا اله الا الله اللهم صلي على محمد وال محمد استغفر الله رب العالمين

@mohammedzakariaali1169 3 года назад

Sorry to say this: but he knows nothing about Islam & this is so misleading.

@stephenconnolly1830 Год назад

So true...pro-Zionists blathering on the whole lot of them. Deeply immoral people, the opposite of humanity in action.

@cantilever 14 лет назад

When I think of what the term "scholar" epitomizes, I think of Bernard Lewis. Ninety-four years old and still sharp as a tack... (And no offense to the first speaker, but Prof. Lewis begins at 21:00)

@stephenconnolly1830 Год назад

Thank God He has deprived us of Lewis's company. A more unethical and immoral human one could ever have the misfortune of knowing.

@trollhunter2971 10 месяцев назад

@@stephenconnolly1830why?

@TheZestyCar 14 лет назад

Hey, your video stopped playing for me at 41:33. You might want to take care of that some how because this is very interesting to me.

@Kurtlane 13 лет назад

I don't get why Bernard Lewis seems to whitewash increasing dimmization of Europe. OK, what he says about "you give us the rights we gave you" about separate communities is true of the middle of Islamic pressure groups. (This policy is called segregation or apartheid.) (cont)

@consoledev9380 6 лет назад

Bernard 'fucked up the world' Lewis - The Warmonger. Do not rest in peace Mr!

@stephenconnolly1830 Год назад

Hurrah, a sane person commenting at last!

@currymakersuperfly 12 лет назад

A 20 minute introduction isnt something id call "brief".

@stephenconnolly1830 Год назад

No, it's neither brief nor enlightening.

@PersonWConscience 11 лет назад

Thanks.

@AfarinPournasr-tm6vz 5 месяцев назад

The greatest historian.

@lulu0320 14 лет назад

They are easy to find.....amazon, public library, .......

@12ut5 14 лет назад

21:00-32:00 Lewis' preliminary remarks.

@Kurtlane 13 лет назад

@peymaania, I have the highest regard for Robert Wistrich. I have seen him many times on youtube, and he always impressed me. He is one of the few people brave enough to tell the truth in our dark times. It's Bernard Lewis who disappoints me here.

@stephenconnolly1830 Год назад

The way Wistrich essentialises and anthropomorphises Islam and Muslims is problematic; as well as his supreme blindness to imperialism, particularly colonial Zionism perpetuating suffering on the Palestinians. And he can't even pronounce the word "Muslim" properly!

@ppetal1 7 месяцев назад

Houthi confounds Vanity. Who would have thought?

@ppetal1 7 месяцев назад

@stephenconnolly1830 a total absence of the role of 'the West' in promoting 'islamic fundamentalists' over more fundamentally democratic and secular movements in the majority moslem countries, not least in Afghanistan. We have seen that Islam, nevertheless, is able to accommodate democratic ideals better than mass Christian fundamentalist movements in the USA. Jews still have less to fear from Islam than Christianity. It was ever thus.

@Kurtlane 13 лет назад

But there is also an avante-guard, composed of people like Anjem Choudhary: people who stand in front of Westminster Cathedral and harass anyone trying to get in, who very aggressively demand mass conversions to Islam and openly proclaim the fall of Europe. With massive support of Muslim leaders from Qaddafi to Erdogan. This is far beyond "separate rights for separate peoples." (cont.)

@stephenconnolly1830 Год назад

It's easy to point to one outlier, an extremist, and then to speciously draw general conclusions from that. What a cheap and ridiculous shot.

@BenWeeks 7 лет назад

59:15 On the Muslim Brotherhood. Long answer. Continues to about 1:08:00

@ahmadradwan5914 2 года назад

Comments with no offence being erased 😡😡😡

@natalierosen 14 лет назад

LOVE him. Brilliant. I originally saw Professor Lewis on a documentary called "The Longest Hatred" am a liberal BUT I am unabashedly supportive of the Jewish state. I think that to BE a liberal, to BE concerned with the Separation clause of the US constitution, to be in favor of free speech, press, etc., to be in favor of ALL the civil liberties accorded by our Founders in their brilliant document, I can EASILY be in support of Israel by the evidence of MY OWN EYES. My eyes do NOT lie.

@77unclefedor 12 лет назад

@GnosticHumanist Thanks for sharing such a nice quote from the honorable Chomsky (& adding your valuable comment), but the same can be said about Chomsky & you - you're just an opposite side of the same coin, with "one set of rules" for people who think like you & a complete denial of other's right to have an opinion. Prof. Lewis is a wise man, even if you don't agree with his opinion regarding Islam, Iran, etc. Calling somebody "racist" for not thinking like you is shameless...

@SRMscott 14 лет назад

@natalierosen Please give me one, just one, example where peace was achieved through any other means than war. The only reason invading Iran is impossible is because America has completely lost its heart and courage especially under the current regime of Imam Obama. We need another Ronald Reagan to lead us against the pure evil of the Muslim faith.

@papapepepenultimo 13 лет назад

@drzakir123 You forgot the Freemasons and the Easter Bunny... Or are you working for THEM?

@natalierosen 14 лет назад

@srmaczkaz: t I just do NOT know. I just don't. One side says one thing and the other says another.I am a FAIR person.I see both sides. I was NOT a Ronald Reagan supporter but he was not always so quick and the ramifications are HUGE now so I'm not so sure he would confront it. The Soviet Union was finished in and of itself so I argue with those that said Reagan was the Pied Piper. No I don't think so. Things are not simple and LIVES are at stake. It is serious to send young men to war!

@ClareBoyd-f8c 16 дней назад

Anderson Sharon Thomas Karen Walker Laura

@SuperStrik9 8 лет назад

I stand with Israel.

@robharris5467 8 лет назад

+SuperStrik9 Professor Bernard Lewis will turn 100 on 31 May. As a long-time admirer of Prof Lewis I intend to send him a congratulatory message in the week leading up to the 31st. The Middle Eastern Studies Dept at Princeton has agreed to pass messages on to Prof Lewis. Accordingly, if any fellow well-wishers would like to do the same, these should be sent to the Department Secretary Ms Karen Chirik. Karen’s email address is kchirik@princeton.edu It would help if the subject line is ‘Professor Bernard Lewis’

@Tsnore 8 лет назад

The people or the Likud Govt.?

@robharris5467 8 лет назад

Remind me of the date of the next election in Gaza and/or the West Bank.

@alo0oshful 8 лет назад

Wow! So you stand with the real terrorism that has been happening on earth? So you stand with killing thousands of thousands of civilians? So you stand with killing children? So you stand with migrating million of Palestinians? No wondering why the worled is corrupt because it got people who can see the truth but they *choose* to lie and believe their lie. Good for you!

@robharris5467 8 лет назад

Let's remember the 700 000 Jews expelled from Muslim countries in 48. No UNRWA for them, just the UNHCR. They accepted reality and got on with life. More Palestinians have been killed in the Syrian civil war (5 years) than in all the Israel v Arab wars. Bit like BLM. If a black kills a black it doesn't register. If a white kills a black it's a national disgrace

@englishsteve88 10 лет назад

38.00 islamiasation of europe.

@mendy05 3 года назад

the "brief" intro was over 20 minutes long I wanted to hear Lewis not him!!!!

@Mehranrokh 13 лет назад

@MattyJames25 typical argument by someone who actually does not have an argument about the case and therefore makes a personal attack. I live wherever I want, what the heck has this to do with Israel being a nuclear occuping murderer regime?????

@natalierosen 14 лет назад

What way would he like the US to show a different policy to Iran? what invade Iran? Impossible. I would like to hear him express how we can change the course of the direction of Iran?

@meriadocbrandebouc 11 лет назад

(cont.) What you say is complete nonsense and your last sentence is simply illogical, and frankly, I have no idea where did it come from. Please, stop spreading such idiotic, nonsensical and ridiculous claims about Islam.

@mohamedelzein73 3 месяца назад

MR Louis may be Professor in history, but he is totally ignorant in Islamic faith and related history🤔

@michelecampanelli5419 2 года назад

This video is interesting about radicalization in Europe but forget Italy in which there is no significant radicalization. Probably the reason for the lack of radicalization in Italy depends on the fact that Italy is a peripheral country and that attacks in Italy would not have global impact

@stephenconnolly1830 Год назад

It helps that Italy, despite its despicable colonial past and legacy, hasn't invaded any Muslim lands throughout its recent history. Did you twig that? Eh? Interesting correlation don't you think?!

@michelecampanelli5419 Год назад

@@stephenconnolly1830 Several Italian soldiers have died in the last twenty years fighting in Islamic countries alongside the allies (not only Christian allies but also Muslims).

@HassaneRamix 4 месяца назад

Is there any one speaks english watched this video

@legalmonkey 13 лет назад

it starts at 20:58

@Kurtlane 13 лет назад

As for the Iranian nukes, we have already passed the point of eminent danger. We are now at the point of hopelessness. Overall, disappointing. People talking and talking, buried in the past on the eve of WWIII.

@natalierosen 14 лет назад

I HOPE you are wrong. I disagree about Reagan, however. We will have to agree to disagree. I hope you are wrong about Iran. This country does not have the capital, the troops nor the inclination which is oh so tired of perpetual war, to go to war with Iran. If you thought Iraq and Afghanistan are tough add Iran to the mix. It cannot be done without a draft. Time will tell, I just HOPE you are not correct. You may be but I do not know.

@Nasiruddin84 14 лет назад

I must strongly object to Said al-Asm. Europe will not be Islamicized. The general weakness of Arab political thought : They always underestimate their counterparts.

@natalierosen 14 лет назад

ChiefOren: My guess what you suggest is not exactly a light bulb thought to the US. I am sure although I am NOT an expert nor have I ever worked in the international relations field so from a fairly decently informed layman I would say we are PROBABLY doing those things AND exchanging information. I was addressing my comments I think although I haven't reviewed what Prof Lewis said but an actual troop invasion boot on the ground policy is just plain NUTS! We already BOTCHED two wars!

@SRMscott 14 лет назад

@natalierosen You want to talk serious, I would encourage you greatly to look up "the 12th imam/Iran" and learn about it. If Iran secures the ability to build a nuclear weapon, there will not be an "if" they use it, there will be a "when" and when that happens, u will see many more lives at stake than there will be if we go to war. You are incorrect about Reagan as he ended the cold war through SDI - Russians used nuclear power to negotiate whereas Iran will use it to bring forth the 12th Imam

@gusibrahim6961 8 лет назад

In depth study to what happened in Iraq since 1914 to date is desperately needed in order to understand the current situation and hopefully a remedies can become available.

@Kurtlane 13 лет назад

And then, there is blatant Jew-hatred. This is one point where modern Wahhabi Islam has come under major influence of Nazism and is now more like Nazism than like traditional Islam. European Jews are now emigrating to America, Israel, Australia, and it increasingly looks like a flight for their lives. So while it might be apartheid for European Christians, it's something far worse for European Jews. I don't understand why Bernard Lewis is ignoring all this. (cont.)

@stephenconnolly1830 Год назад

Another asinine comment; what's the relationship between Wahhabism and Jews leaving Europe for America? Aren't you over egging your omelette a bit? Surely the significant rise of the right wing and neo-Nazi movements in Europe has had a far greater impact on anti-Jew hatred than the modest number of Wahhabis residing throughout the continent. Furthermore, you have chosen to focus your ire on the wrong faction within the Muslim community - the Wahhabi movement is distinguished by its apolitical stance which is a product of the autocratic regimes' control over their scholars thereby inducing a quietist approach in them which emphasises ritual practices.

@brianfinnegan664 5 лет назад

Obviously if u criticise a book u are racist...

@Kurtlane 13 лет назад

Bernard Lewis is right on about Iran. Unlike Arabs, who to this day don't have a notion of nation, Persians are a true nation. And the current regime is trying to turn them unto generic Muslims, people with no national identity. The people resent it very much. How many believe in modernization and westernization in Egypt? 2%? 3%? No, they are not numerous. (cont.)

@ElectricQualia 6 лет назад

Not a fan of israel or zionism but an admirer of ashkenazi intellect. Huge fan of dr Bernard Lewis.

@SaelPalani 11 лет назад

A real historian.

@Kurtlane 13 лет назад

May God save us all from Arab democracy. Robert Wistrich says at the very end, that all the problems of modern Arab societies are not being dealt with. But they are not just not being dealt with, they are impossible to deal with. No "good ruler" or "good movement" can change a thing about this onslaught of evil, or they will share the fate of Sadat. And the evil comes from the "Arab street," i.e. from the overwhelming majority of Arab people themselves. (cont.)

@stephenconnolly1830 Год назад

This is a manifestly stupid as well as ignorant comment - it's akin to saying Moses shouldn't have bothered standing up to Pharaoh because nothing could change the fate of the Israelites due to their resignation to remain downtrodden under the absolute, entrenched tyranny of the Egyptian system under his rule. Worse still, this type of essentialism applied to a whole people - the Arabs - amounts to a form of racism.