I admire your knowledge and your accolades Dr.Ingriis and I agree with everything you said but at the same time you can’t hide the other part of the history where the same people who wanted freedom from Regime to destroy Somali infrastructure to the ground and successfully keeping us as. Failed state 30 years later
Prv waxa ay ayaan darada ugu wayni tahay ,in ay maanta 30 sano kadib ay wali Ragaa aad sheegtay sida guul wade ,mahamed cali yuusuf ,ay la taliyayaal ka yihiin muqdisho.oo ku doodayaan in dawladii wanaagsanayd la dumiyay, saxna ay ahay in somaliland lagu duqeeyo diyaarado, waxaad ku mahadsantahy taariikhdaa saxa ahayd eed ka sheekaynayso.
Waxaa halkaan iiga cad in dhinaca diinta aad ka liidato. Culumadda dulumka waxa ay ku sheegaan sida geed yar oo la abuuraayo. Wuu sii koraa geedka- oo, ma yaraado. Dulumka waa sidaas ina adeer.
Xaqiqdi wa Decumentary aad u wngsan wax bdna iga cawiyay caqligeyga iyo Garadkayga markan firiyo Siyaad barre iyo kuwi bixiyayba hal isma dhamin oo Stretegy ah Siyaad hadan bixino maxa no xal kama aysin fikirin Si walbe ahato Somali alle ha isku qalpi nadifiyo Hana is jecleysiyo Waxana kula talin lahay “Labatan jir ina ader wuxu ku dhamo lawa”
Roberto be oglyi - 1983 -1984 James bishop - 1990-1991 Always analyze the history carefully before being criticized scholars like Dr. Mohamed Haji Ingiris.
Qofka darjadiisa been ka sheega wax kalena Maxaad ka sugi. Waayo ninkani Professor ayuu sheegtaa mana aha Professor waxa ka horeeya Lecturer waxa ku xiga Associate Professor waxa ku sii xiga Assistant Professor ka dibna Professor. Markaa waa sidaa beenta jooji ina ingiriis
Inta aanad comment bixin soo baro ama daris heerar kala duwan ee la maro Marka professorship career laga hadlayo . Mida labaad in aqoonyahanka umada taarikhdooda u iftiminayana la aflagadeeyo waa ceeb ethically.
@@abdiqanihussein8670 Adigu dib u eeg Ranking of Professor. Assistant then associate and then Professor. Qabyaalad ayaa ku qaaday ayaan filayaa ee iga baro hada Ranking
@@abdiqanihussein8670 markaad tahat Academic spacially historian waa inaad ka saartaa researchkaaga bias. Markaa taas ayaan ku dhaliiley ina ingiriis. Anigu isma amaanayo mana xaasidayo ninkaa. I am PhD candidate long time ago i am not holder. Thank you
@@ayanahmed1487hhhh , adigu hada analytic argument aad ka hadlaysa muxu yahay ama aad ku dhaliilaysa historical footnotes uu Dr . Mohamed Ingiriis ku sheegayo videogan ? Mida kale Bias waxa lagu tilmami kara marka evidence comparative analysis la sameyo . Hada Dr. Ingiris waxa uu ka hadlayay kaliya Memoir uu qoray Safiirka wakhtigas somaliya u fadhiyay Maraykanka . Dhanka kale classified documents sirdoonka ka qoray xaaladas wakhtigaas somaliya ku jirtay ayaa raacsan . Hadii aad ledahay waxan waxba kama jiraan inkastoo adiga dhalishada hore ahayd title bal nala wadag xogta aad adigu hayso taarikh ahaan ?
Beenaale. RU-vid kay ku jirtaa general caydiid oo afkiisa ka leh siyaad bare ilaa uu wadanka ka baxo wada hadal mayaalo. Wlhi waan daawaday RU-vid ay kujirtaa.
