Тёмный

(pt. 2) Converting from Traditionalist Catholic to Orthodox: 5 MORE Frustrations 

The Roman Orthodox
Подписаться 222
Просмотров 1,6 тыс.
50% 1

What have you struggled with in your conversion? Let me know in the comments!

Опубликовано:

 

18 июн 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 81   
@theowilmot1841
@theowilmot1841 3 дня назад
I was made an Orthodox catechumen on the 15th June - on the eve of the Sunday of the Fathers of the First Ecumenical Council, appropriately enough! 🙂
@Patriarch.Chadimus
@Patriarch.Chadimus 3 дня назад
I will say, I don't know of your familiarity with it, but as a Western-rite Orthodox Christian who converted from being a Traditional Catholic, I actually have found a greater appreciation for these traditions I thought I wouldn't be able to experience in Orthodoxy.
@JohnAlbinus
@JohnAlbinus 7 дней назад
Wife and I are currently TLM Catholics who are contemplating moving to Orthodoxy. Please pray for us! Great video.
@TheRomanOrthodox
@TheRomanOrthodox 7 дней назад
You are certainly in my prayers!
@bengensiejewski5002
@bengensiejewski5002 2 дня назад
I'll pray you don't. Traditional Catholics don't deny the Catholic Church.
@Tollski
@Tollski 2 дня назад
The grass is not greener in Orthodoxy. The Papacy is true. I'll pray for you.
@handmaidleah
@handmaidleah 6 дней назад
if one prefers Gregorian Chant, then one may enjoy Valaam Chant as an alternative, it is sublime.
@FaithfulComforter
@FaithfulComforter 8 дней назад
I grew up Roman Catholic, welcome home brother 🙏☦️❤️
@rumpelstiltskin9768
@rumpelstiltskin9768 8 дней назад
Loving it. Here, in Japan, the Orthodox liturgical readins are based on a Bible that was translated back in the Meiji period (late 1800's) . The chinese characters are very old and non-standard today. It was a point of high cuiriousity when I showed Japanese acquianitnces around me. The missus said if they want more converts they are going to have to update their Bible. FWIW>
@gillianc6514
@gillianc6514 8 дней назад
I am a coward, I haven't told most of my Catholic friends. I am 2000 miles away, but they will have to know soon. My biggest problems is that I am godmother to some of their children. Children I have not ceased praying for. This is a very difficult situation. St John Cassian proved my bridge to Orthodoxy, but I was having such difficulty finding an Orthodox priest to take me seriously that I ended up praying to St Rita (my Catholic patron) for it to happen, if it were God's will. The rest is history and her statue is still on my dresser.
@TheRomanOrthodox
@TheRomanOrthodox 8 дней назад
That's a tough one! I have never known what to do with Catholic godchildren after conversion. I think I would want to talk it over with their parents to see what they want to do.
@bengensiejewski5002
@bengensiejewski5002 2 дня назад
Sounds like a demon talking rather than the intercession of a faithful Catholic.
@gillianc6514
@gillianc6514 2 дня назад
@@bengensiejewski5002 No talking statues pls, I have never gone in for that sort of stuff, I have always been governed by the Eastern concept of 'prelest'.
@bengensiejewski5002
@bengensiejewski5002 2 дня назад
@@gillianc6514 A saint wouldn't guide you toward schism.
@gillianc6514
@gillianc6514 2 дня назад
@@bengensiejewski5002 Exactly!!
@gillianc6514
@gillianc6514 8 дней назад
I am an English speaking Trad Cath who converted to Orthodoxy in Romania. I would like to add that here too, women are more involved in the Liturgy and the first time I saw female monastics acting as thurifers in a procession, my mind threw a hissy fit! On the other side, the designation of men on the right and women on the left of the narthex is very well adhered to and the order for receiving Communion; infants, children, men then women would have even some Trad Caths turning into feminists! Incidentally I have heard three different Romanian versions of the Our Father whilst I have been here, the translation thing is not confined to being an English issue.
@TheRomanOrthodox
@TheRomanOrthodox 8 дней назад
That is really interesting! I didn't know other languages had such translation "diversity."
@danocinneide1885
@danocinneide1885 3 дня назад
Matt 10:2...The names of the twelve apostles are these..First Simon who is called Peter...
@javierduenasjimenez7930
@javierduenasjimenez7930 2 дня назад
In every gospel the order is different, but the only thing they all have in common is that Peter is the first and Judas the last one
@CosmicMystery7
@CosmicMystery7 8 дней назад
Folks coming from Trad RC backgrounds will probably find Russian chant less abrasive at first.
@Damascene749
@Damascene749 8 дней назад
Brother. Welcome home.
@JUJUisKARMA
@JUJUisKARMA 8 дней назад
I’m a super fan
@dianelevy419
@dianelevy419 2 дня назад
Coming from Novis Ordo to Byzantine Catholic and this past year, fully Orthodox. It’s been a very lonely road but I would never go back. Just found your channel and it is a comfort as most converts I meet are former Protestants. Thank you.
@TheRomanOrthodox
@TheRomanOrthodox 2 дня назад
Thank you for dropping by! I am sure as a Byzantine Catholic turned Orthodox, there are even MORE challenges (like having the divine liturgy explained to you despite having attended it for years).
@dianelevy419
@dianelevy419 2 дня назад
@@TheRomanOrthodox It was only for a year that I attended a local Byzantine mission and the services there were quite limited. I couldn’t take the local RCC parish liturgies anymore even though I still believe they consecrate the true body and blood of Christ. I not only lost most of my contacts in the parish ( my dear beloved husband still remains there as a deacon), but I also lost friends from the local charismatic Catholic gatherings which I avoid now like the plague, even though they are good ,truth seeking people. I found a wonderful monastery 40 minutes from home and I love their English Byzantine chanting, but most people who attend there live at least an hour away in all directions so it is difficult to form close friendships. All the losses though are worth it to me as I finally feel that I can put my trust in truth of Orthodoxy and of course with the Lord, I am never really alone in this world. God bless you.
@OrthodoxChristianBeliever
@OrthodoxChristianBeliever 3 дня назад
There Are Some Orthodox Churches In Spain too, Could they Do The Divine Liturgy In English, Spanish, And Whichever language they Do them In?
@nathankirwan2565
@nathankirwan2565 8 часов назад
Any language, language of the people has always been encouraged
@gunshotlagoon922
@gunshotlagoon922 12 часов назад
I'm happy you have found your home amongst the other thousands of churches you could have chosen. But as someone who once attended a Russian Orthodox Church, I still have a hard time believing the Orthodox Church is the one true church. Eastern Orthodoxy is purely and exclusively Byzantine (and further divided amongst nationalistic lines) that it's difficult for me to accept that in order to be in Christ's one true church everyone must surrender to this single isolated liturgical rite.
@nathankirwan2565
@nathankirwan2565 8 часов назад
It isnt just Byzantine
@hestolemybrainatyouthcamp7750
@hestolemybrainatyouthcamp7750 3 дня назад
Have experienced Western Rite Orthodoxy?
@bengensiejewski5002
@bengensiejewski5002 2 дня назад
Which is widely mocked and rejected by many Orthodox.
@hestolemybrainatyouthcamp7750
@hestolemybrainatyouthcamp7750 2 дня назад
@@bengensiejewski5002 That's unfortunate- guess they need to take that up with a few Patriarchs and Bishops. Bless Them!
@TheRomanOrthodox
@TheRomanOrthodox 2 дня назад
Yes
@bengensiejewski5002
@bengensiejewski5002 2 дня назад
@@hestolemybrainatyouthcamp7750 It's because it doesn't have a place among the Orthodox. The Catholic Church is the universal Church.
@Gigi-ho2qk
@Gigi-ho2qk 7 дней назад
There's no such thing as "roman orthodox".
@TheRomanOrthodox
@TheRomanOrthodox 7 дней назад
Well, two points. First, I am Antiochian, and the term for my Church is the "Rûm Orthodox" Church of Antioch, meaning "Roman" or "Greek." Second, Constantinople was the capital of the Eastern Roman empire, which spoke Greek. I am also a Latin-speaker. So, the name just seems to fit. "Eastern" Orthodoxy has as much right to be called "Roman" as the Latin church does. Hence the name. Thanks for dropping by!
@stephanterblanche4597
@stephanterblanche4597 7 дней назад
Do you know what the Eastern Orthodox are called in Constantinople in this day and age? No? They are called Romans.
@Gigi-ho2qk
@Gigi-ho2qk 6 дней назад
"Latin church"?.... There's no " Latin church" and no " roman orthodox". The Church is One (1) - the Orthodox Church.
@TheRomanOrthodox
@TheRomanOrthodox 6 дней назад
@@Gigi-ho2qk I really think you need to be less abrasive and stop overreacting here.
@TheRomanOrthodox
@TheRomanOrthodox 6 дней назад
@@Gigi-ho2qk I really think you need to be less abrasive and stop overreacting here.
@102483989
@102483989 8 дней назад
Why change from catholic to orthodox? especially if you are not Eastern European or from the more eastern countries of the world? I dont understand why want for someone else to do this?
@dashcamacademy6457
@dashcamacademy6457 7 дней назад
worshiping God is spirit and truth.....
@TheRomanOrthodox
@TheRomanOrthodox 7 дней назад
Thanks for dropping by! The simple fact is that I believe Eastern Orthodox to be the true Church founded by Jesus Christ for all people in all nations. I do not believe that the Roman Catholic Church is that Church. And, I believe that the Orthodox Church has the way of eternal life, and the Roman Catholic Church doesn't.
@MariaDeJesus06
@MariaDeJesus06 5 дней назад
@@TheRomanOrthodox Well, we as catholics belive the same, guess that we will have to wait to the end to see who were right...
@mariorizkallah5383
@mariorizkallah5383 2 дня назад
@@MariaDeJesus06wait and see? We arent muslims, we can read the Church Fathers
@hiltonchapman4844
@hiltonchapman4844 2 дня назад
​@@TheRomanOrthodoxI have no issues with your conversion away from Roman Catholicism. But your reasoning is puerile beyond belief. If you really want to be Orthodox then your only reason should be: (1 and only 1) the Holy Ghost does NOT proceed from the Father AND the Son. Everything else pales into insignificance (including the issue of "Supreme Pontiff". No generalities. And I sincerely wish you well in your new home! HC-JAIPUR (26/06/2024) .
@gerardducharme2146
@gerardducharme2146 7 дней назад
Sorry, to see you become Orthodox, well the Catholic Church is the True Church. I attended the SSPX parish in Canada. I will pray for you and all who have left the church.
@Madokaexe
@Madokaexe 7 дней назад
The sspx is heretical and the pope is against it.
@MariaDeJesus06
@MariaDeJesus06 5 дней назад
I am from the sspx in south america! I will also be praying for them
@xravenx24fe
@xravenx24fe 2 дня назад
If you are SSPX you aren't a real Catholic. I wouldn't be surprised if the Pope disbands the order in due time.
@Porphyrios02
@Porphyrios02 День назад
he came to the true chruch
@AS-np3yq
@AS-np3yq 8 дней назад
Just be greek-catholic...
@TheRomanOrthodox
@TheRomanOrthodox 8 дней назад
Um...no? Why would I do that? I like St. Porphyrios of Kafsokalyvia too much.
@bengensiejewski5002
@bengensiejewski5002 2 дня назад
@@TheRomanOrthodox I would hope you would like the Truth more. Question: Is contraception wrong?
@TheRomanOrthodox
@TheRomanOrthodox 2 дня назад
@@bengensiejewski5002 By default, the use of contraceptives is wrong, but there are some exceptions that one should navigate with the help of a spiritual father.
@javierduenasjimenez7930
@javierduenasjimenez7930 2 дня назад
​@@TheRomanOrthodox Either something is a sin or not. There is no such thing as "unsinful sins"
@bengensiejewski5002
@bengensiejewski5002 2 дня назад
@@TheRomanOrthodox Where has the Orthodox Church spoken about this? "Exceptions" is another way of saying the Orthodox lacks a clear understanding and teaching regarding this issue.
@JWMTR
@JWMTR 7 дней назад
I pray for your return home to the Catholic Faith.
@TheRomanOrthodox
@TheRomanOrthodox 7 дней назад
I follow the true Catholic and Orthodox faith. But thank you for your concern!
@javierduenasjimenez7930
@javierduenasjimenez7930 2 дня назад
​@@TheRomanOrthodox Have you tried the genuine true orthodoxy!
@TheRomanOrthodox
@TheRomanOrthodox День назад
@@javierduenasjimenez7930 Such a misnomer for a tiny clique.
@javierduenasjimenez7930
@javierduenasjimenez7930 День назад
​@@TheRomanOrthodox What do you think about them? ROCOR and similars
@TheRomanOrthodox
@TheRomanOrthodox День назад
@@javierduenasjimenez7930 ROCOR is under the Moscow Patriarchate and not really part of that movement. It is a strict jurisdiction, for sure, but a wonderful, blessed one. As for the schismatic groups, I am not a huge fan.
Далее
Игровой Комп с Авито за 4500р
01:00
Barry Policeman And His Son Vs Prisoners
00:26
Просмотров 691 тыс.
We need a new Orthodox Study Bible...badly
28:01
Просмотров 5 тыс.
The Mystery of the Eastern Orthodox Church
26:57
Просмотров 786 тыс.
How the Church Fathers Made Me Catholic
38:07
Просмотров 107 тыс.
From Eastern Catholicism to Orthodoxy
34:10
Просмотров 11 тыс.
Fr Josiah Trenham: Eastern Orthodoxy & the Great Reset
40:10