Тёмный

Race day Stihl MS391 vs Speedsaw E5 

Project of the day
Подписаться 35 тыс.
Просмотров 167 тыс.
50% 1

The big Racy Day...
Competition between Logosol Speed saw E5 and Stihl MS391 on my portable sawmill Logosol Farmers M8. Which saw the fastest?

Опубликовано:

 

18 июл 2015

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 70   
@HerrSlurfi
@HerrSlurfi 9 лет назад
Thanks for the film, always fun to see films about sawing
@tdidriver1234
@tdidriver1234 9 лет назад
Thank you. I really enjoy your videos.
@cheapwoodworking_plan-to-build
Nice video. What are the power requirements for the speed saw? And is the kerf the same between the two saws? Just curious, I like that setup.
@Projectoftheday
@Projectoftheday 9 лет назад
Brad Clark In Europe it is 3 phase 400V 16A. and in the US is 3-Phase, 220V, 40 amps. The cut gets better with the electric saw, guess it's because the chain has a higher speed.
@ressansangkay6602
@ressansangkay6602 6 лет назад
Good job
@thefirewooddoctor
@thefirewooddoctor 9 лет назад
Would love to see a speed comparison between that electric saw and the Stihl MS660 or Husqvarna 390xp.
@Projectoftheday
@Projectoftheday 9 лет назад
Jeffrey Beyer agrees that it would be fun to try. Im try and see if any friends have a big saw I can borrow. Both to get to do a race against my electric saw. But would be fun to see the difference in the sawmill between my MS391 also
@thefirewooddoctor
@thefirewooddoctor 8 лет назад
Would donate my Husky 390xp for a quick run, but live in the north central USA.
@Projectoftheday
@Projectoftheday 8 лет назад
+Jeffrey Beyer Gets a little expensive to send by DHL , I think. Must see if I can borrow a larger saw and test with.
@Dc_tech386
@Dc_tech386 5 лет назад
How much horses is the induction motor
@Flowing23
@Flowing23 6 лет назад
great vid :)
@Projectoftheday
@Projectoftheday 6 лет назад
Thanks
@mlkyllo
@mlkyllo 8 лет назад
It would be interesting to see a comparison between the electric and the Stihl with more of a logging/competition fat belly chain bar. This would give more of an apples-to-apples bar shape and closer race. The electric is impressive with the speed it cuts and the amount of chips it's throwing out...no doubt about it. Nice video I enjoyed it.
@Projectoftheday
@Projectoftheday 8 лет назад
+mlkyllo Unfortunately I do not have such a long extension cord
@danielrunyon4830
@danielrunyon4830 Год назад
This electric motor is much, much more powerful than the chainsaws engine.
@davewelch1932
@davewelch1932 3 года назад
What speed does the chain turn on the speed saw compared to the chainsaw.?
@vermontjeff2535
@vermontjeff2535 2 года назад
It doesn’t matter, it’s over 2 to 1 boards with no effort
@siriosstar4789
@siriosstar4789 5 лет назад
That was no race. It was a Lamborghini against a VW Beetle. 😜
@Projectoftheday
@Projectoftheday 5 лет назад
+Sirios Star hihi
@davidthorne6796
@davidthorne6796 8 лет назад
Hey there ... Great vid! What's that electric motor rated at in horse power? You need three 1/4 inch holes in that 391 muffler and a retune on its carb... Like 20% more power....
@Projectoftheday
@Projectoftheday 8 лет назад
+David Thorne Is not quite sure but it is between 12-15 hp, in Sweden we notice the engines with effect in kw only
@davidthorne6796
@davidthorne6796 8 лет назад
How many KW? I've been thinking on building a mill and with my location at this house our backyards face each other and the other neighbors have complained to me about my buddy four houses done that cuts lots of fire wood making chainsaw noise... So the electric would work here where a gas engine wouldn't ... I'm glad for your video as not only do I now know there are electrics being made but I can now try to see specs and look at yours for the design...
@davidthorne6796
@davidthorne6796 8 лет назад
Hey....Also, I see the twin (??? Bar Lube Jugs???) do they recommend a light oil? Regular bar lube? Or water? On mine I don't think I'd want to use bar lube because I want my boards for my house furnishings and shelves and whatnot????
@mattseymour8637
@mattseymour8637 5 лет назад
Do these motors rev higher or lower than chainsaws ?
@Projectoftheday
@Projectoftheday 5 лет назад
+Matt Seymour I think it’s about the same.
@Projectoftheday
@Projectoftheday 5 лет назад
+Matt Seymour i think it’s an the same
@peter_kelly
@peter_kelly 9 лет назад
That speedsaw is amazing. I wonder what advantages it'd have over a bandsaw mill.
@Projectoftheday
@Projectoftheday 6 лет назад
Yes more wasted but much nicer cut. so you have to plan more when it is sawed with band saw.
@ucanliv4ever
@ucanliv4ever 4 года назад
Plane
@jesegeraldodearaujoaraujo1536
@jesegeraldodearaujoaraujo1536 3 года назад
😍😍😍
@madreamer
@madreamer 5 лет назад
watching the whole thing thinking man that cutting probably smells great
@dio19831
@dio19831 4 года назад
Qual o preço de uma serra dessa
@owenjohnson5030
@owenjohnson5030 8 лет назад
I would think something like the Stihl MS 661 or MS 880 would be better comparisons. The MS 391 does not have enough horsepower to effectively use it in a sawmill. I bought the MS 661 for this purpose and am buying a MS 391 for crosscuts and limbing.
@Projectoftheday
@Projectoftheday 8 лет назад
+Owen Johnson Yes it would be more fair. But at the same time, my electric saw (E5) is the smallest model of Speedsaw as Logosol sells, and MS391 is the smallest saw as Logosol recommend that you use
@KnuckleSandwichMint
@KnuckleSandwichMint 5 лет назад
I've used my 461 on Grantsburg saw mill and it worked great. I also own a 391 and would never use it for something like this
@Dc_tech386
@Dc_tech386 5 лет назад
I have a 9 horsepower solo chainsaw and 10000 rpm and it cause slow still because it font really have 9 hp in it no chainsaw have the right foot pound on it but a induction motor do so the motor win alway r u can get a 18 hp gasoline engine dat work at the same
@mattseymour8637
@mattseymour8637 5 лет назад
My saw is a 362 and cuts pretty much anything you put Infront of it and very quick with a 15 bar on so think it would have enough hp
@charlesmason1278
@charlesmason1278 2 года назад
@@mattseymour8637 great saw, and the predecessor models were good as well, but for ripping, you really need 80CC or better. I had pretty good luck with an 056 super in red oak, but my MS441 struggled in green hickory of a smaller diameter.
@sedataydogdu8224
@sedataydogdu8224 8 лет назад
How much
@kojomensah7474
@kojomensah7474 7 лет назад
What would happen if u don't have a genorator
@arpadvidovenyecz2615
@arpadvidovenyecz2615 7 лет назад
motor 4,6KW 2850rpm.
@jaisahu8403
@jaisahu8403 2 года назад
Kitne ka hai Mujhe kharidana hai batao
@Ticdaniel
@Ticdaniel 3 года назад
Knpeigt jag hejjar alltid på motorsågen.. men satan va mkt snabbare elen är. Hade vart kul om man kunde få nått bensindrivet som gick lika fort
@69sungam
@69sungam 7 лет назад
Stihl är bara massa plast. /Småland
@jesegeraldodearaujoaraujo1536
@jesegeraldodearaujoaraujo1536 3 года назад
Oi boa noite como faz para compra uma dessa
@briankleinschmidt3664
@briankleinschmidt3664 9 месяцев назад
Milling is really hard on a chainsaw. But, the chainsaw is much faster if you are no where near a 3 phase 240 outlet.
@Projectoftheday
@Projectoftheday 9 месяцев назад
In Europe every home have 3 phase 400v as standard. So normally not a big problem
@Laukermarcus
@Laukermarcus 5 лет назад
Elsågen är på 4.6kw och motorsågen är på 3.3kw. Dock har motorsågen endast 3.3kw vid toppvarv (peak) och sågen pressas hårt i filmen, vilket leder till lägre varv och lägre effekt än 3.3kw. Elsågen är grym, men filmen visar egentligen inget annat är felaktig sågning med en för liter motorsåg.
@neverlessdesign
@neverlessdesign Год назад
På vilket sätt felaktig sågning med motorsågen? Nyfiken för jag har den uppsättningen
@Projectoftheday
@Projectoftheday Год назад
Han tycker att jag matade för hårt under filmen så motorvarvet på motorsågen sjönk för mycket.
@neverlessdesign
@neverlessdesign Год назад
@@Projectoftheday okej ganska tyken kommentar. Jämförelsen av sågarna gjorde du fenomenalt👍 Har sågat många stockar med 391an eller vad den nu heter så jag vet hur långsamt det går😅 man får känna av varvtal men matar man inte på rejält så kommer man ingenvart. Musiken i videon kunde du skippat🙃
@Projectoftheday
@Projectoftheday Год назад
@@neverlessdesign är 7 år sedan jag gjorde denna film, då använde jag bara gratis musik på nätet och den var inte direkt jättebra. Nu betalar jag för den så får betydligt bättre musik nu.
@user-ux8hl8it3q
@user-ux8hl8it3q 5 месяцев назад
How mutch
@HimansuKumbhar-lo8zu
@HimansuKumbhar-lo8zu Год назад
Price please in India
@Projectoftheday
@Projectoftheday Год назад
I don’t sale Logosol, but check there homepage www.logosol.com for local price
@sonjahentrich8109
@sonjahentrich8109 3 года назад
Very nice video. Electric is faster and not as noisy than the petrol version. I would prefer the electric. In my life i changed many things into electric. Lawn mower , chainsaw, family car. I like things doing their work with less noise an polution. MFG Dirk from Switzerland
@69yenko65
@69yenko65 3 года назад
Why is electric more environmentally friendly?
@sonjahentrich8109
@sonjahentrich8109 3 года назад
@@69yenko65 because you need x times more energy to produce gas and oil until you have it into your chainsaw, insted you will use the electicity imediatly for the saw . I know, producing electricity is not clean every time. Producing batteries too. But i think Gas is gone and batteries can be charged many many times until you can recycle it. In europe to 96 % Sun is shinning every day and put much of ernergy on our planet. We only have to collect and use it. Im no green punk, i love my motorbike, but what i am able to do easily for our earth, i try. I work on my one lawn care service. I can tell you, if the wind does not blow, you will be in cloud of gas and you breath it. This is not healthy over a work day. MfG Dirk
@ulhasbhagit6231
@ulhasbhagit6231 Год назад
Hii
@Projectoftheday
@Projectoftheday Год назад
Hi
@dan82667
@dan82667 7 лет назад
this is a stupid comparison.your comparing two diff worlds here.
@Projectoftheday
@Projectoftheday 7 лет назад
Certainly there is a difference, many ask how much difference is there between my two saws. And here is the answer. And I use them both to cut boards, yes electric saw much stronger and more expensive
@jamesturner7728
@jamesturner7728 2 года назад
a dull saw blade proves nothing
@Projectoftheday
@Projectoftheday 2 года назад
Its all about power and not dull chain. Gas saw is about 4,5hp and the electric you can push out around 12hp
@jamesturner7728
@jamesturner7728 2 года назад
@@Projectoftheday that saw would not cut butter the blade was to dull nothing to do with horse power
@Projectoftheday
@Projectoftheday 2 года назад
You don’t know what your talking about
@MyGFIsMaria
@MyGFIsMaria 4 месяца назад
@@jamesturner7728did you even watch the video? He changed both chains to brand new ones before the test.
@jamesturner7728
@jamesturner7728 4 месяца назад
Q2yes i did but was it a rip chain it did not look like to me@@MyGFIsMaria
Далее
ELA NÃO ESPERAVA POR ISSO 🥶 ATTITUDE #shorts
00:20
Fake Stihl Chainsaw Better? Let’s Settle This!
11:37
Stihl MS391 - hanging idle diagnosis & muffler mod
29:23
Sågning med logosol m5, high speed
7:03
Просмотров 40 тыс.
Amazing way to speed up your sawmill setup!
10:54
Просмотров 20 тыс.
Saw 30 foot long logs
6:57
Просмотров 100 тыс.
Husqvarna 592 XP vs 395 XP Chainsaw!
8:11
Просмотров 332 тыс.
When milling - Stop doing this!
7:09
Просмотров 7 тыс.