Ranking Every RDR2 Character By Strength/Combat Ability 

And Deadeye is just a representation of how quick their reflexes are, which is insane. Micah seems to "kind of" have a Deadeye, just not as good as Marston or Arthur. In the scene Sean gets shot, Micah quickly headshots 3 guys before Sean hits the ground, so he's no slouch for gunslinging.

Pearson is like a cornered tiger. A tier

Bro really said Sister Calderon is a lover not a fighter even tho she dropped a zombie that was attacking John Marston in undead nightmare 💀💀

Sean being higher then Lenny and Eagle Flies is a crime. I don't have a memory of him doing something crazy with a gun. But with the other two: Eagle Flies saves Arthur by shooting 3 soldiers in one sequence and Lenny literally carriers the trolley mission. Also I don't think Bill is better at combat ability than Sadie or Dutch

Don't underestimate Mary-Beth.. She's a good thief I'm glad you gave Micah the proper credit

Colonel flavours was smoking Confederates in his youth

Dead Eye is just a representation of how quick there reflexes are, Micah has deadeye since he outweighed Johns dead eye, if we were to play as Micah wed have dead eye

For what it’s worth, Charles is probably the only one that can hold his own in a fist fight with Arthur. Maybe even beat him.

Reins fall is deffinetly a guy that could fight if he would

A Tier, Mrs. Braithwaite: she killed at cribbage.

I love how for Arthur he just put the "Arthur." video in there

Only thing I would change is moving Dutch up on the list. Between Micah and Arthur/John. Mainly because he mentored Arthur/John, he survived past RDR 2 and was still giving the Pinkertons a hard time. Also thinking of the clip from rdr 1 where he hit Marston's binoculars from long distance with a pistol. He's definitely a warrior. Only drawback is you don't get to see his combat prowess much in the games, mainly his gift of the gab.

Rank all the characters by how good their relationship is with Arthur

8:22 Jamie woke up and chose violence

The gang Frontline is Arthur, John, Micah, Javier, Bill, Charles and Dutch (i put Sadie too because she became Just as ruthless as the rest of these guys) so I think these guys would be the best of the gang 1 - Healthy Arthur (rivals Charles in melee combat, best shooter of the Gang) 2 - John (nearly as good as Arthur but was not in Guarma) 3 - Micah (literally negs John deadeye in American venom, shoots entire Towns) 4 - Dutch (shoots John from far in Rdr1, IS in the Saint Denis shootout with tremendous Head pain) 5 - Bill (Army man, Gang leader in Rdr1, solid fighter in Rdr2) 6 - Javier (Survived Mexico being even more wild than America, One of the best shooters in the gang, Personal killer of the Army in Rdr1) 7- Charles (Would beat everyone on this list in a One-on-one fight maybe Arthur too but would Lose to everyone on the list above in a draw duel, best bow user of the gang solid gun shooter nonetheless) 8 - Sadie (might be better than Charles in Guns, can clear the rest of the O'Driscolls by herself, became a ruthless bounty Hunter)

Nice that you made so many videos for us.

Sean started to show some character growth in chapter 3 and got better with a gun like when he headshots those two grays while sprinting on horseback away from the fire he and Arthur caused

Rains fall is underrated af

Whatever pays the bills ahh content

Great video :)

I guess you've never played undead nightmare (sister calderon)

Bravo, great video. Guessing I'm way older than you, so I'd say: Sister Calderon could kick Brother Dorkins' a**.

Favorite Arthur moment is when Micah pulls the gun on him at the end of chapter 6, when the gang has the standoff. Although Micah reaches for his weapon first, Arthur still draws it before Micah, despite his failing health. Arthur Morgan, the fastest gun in the west

U should rank each characters outfit or each gang members outfit

Rains Fall should be higher. He has fought earlier in his life. And the last tier doesn't really make sense. Someone who's a pacifist doesn't need to be shit at combat ability.

About Sister Calderon, Rain Falls, brother Dorkins and Thomas Downes, I wouldn't ranked them like that. Sistar Calderon says she did bad things in her youth, so maybe she can have combat abilities. Thomas Downes try to fight back Arthur when he comes for the money, even if it was pathetic. Rain Falls fought in the past so he has some capabilities. I think Brother Dorkins should be the last one.

Sister Calderon got grabbed by a zombie and iced him afterword's in Undead Nightmare iirc, so she's got a a bit more fight in her than you give her credit.

The best physical fighters in the gang: Arthur Morgan Charles Smith John marston Mac and Davey Callander Bill williamson somewhat

By the end of rd1 John was easily the most proficient and skilled fighter in the gang

In undead nightmare sister calderon actually kills zombies and helps john

Abigail and karen are definitely high up for the strength needed to fight the urge

I agree arthur is the best fighter in rdr2 but Marston in rdr1 surpasses him in deadeye speed and other areas like accuracy for example being able to shoot a rifle with perfect accuracy in deadeye with just 1 arm in a moving wagon

your ranking alot of them by their skill with guns and not with any other weapons

"The fact thats shes a woman" bruh

Jack after RDR1 is probably 3rd😌

Sadie is no better than Dutch and in terms of short weapons we see that Micha is quicker on the trigger and better at aiming than Jhon Marston, although in terms of physical strength and skills with different weapons Jhon is actually ahead, but Micha is definitely a "terminator", he and Arthur slaughtered Strawberry and Rhodes, as Arthur said: "Why every time I go rob with you, it end up in a pile of dead bodies"

Rains Falls, chief of a native american tribe, weaker than Thomas Downes, skinny farmer dying of TB. Just because he's personally a pacifist doesn't mean he's incable. Likely, he was still able with a bow and such. Could definitely beat everyone, up to Swanson, maybe higher.

did you hear the breath he took after bronte😂

You forgot tho pearson was in the navy so he prob knows some stuff even if its not that much

1 john marston 1911 2 arthur no tb 3 micah 4 dutch 5 and 6 are bill and charles but i dont know how to put them. 7 javier 8 and 9 are lenny and sadie 10 hosea

Nah Dutch shot a pair of binoculars out of John’s hand in RD1 real far away, well after his prime. #3 or #4 for sure

How is katherine over brother dorkins? 😂

Pacifist and combat abilities are two different things 😂 Arthur could decide to be a pacifist, does that mean he drops to F tier?

Thomas downes has a final smash toxic spit

you cannot put the cornered tiger in D tier thats blasphemous 😱

Nah Javier should be over Bill since One Time in Camp where Bill called Javier a Greaser Javier made quick word of Bill

00:18 😦

Dutch should be higher

John always had deadeye he lost it in rdr1 because it's been 4 years

Arthur is 1. Dutch 2. Micah 3. John 4. Micah and John could switch though either way

Sister calderone would destroy Jack tbh

I disagree with Lenny's ranking. Arthur talks highly of his fighting ability during the game.

You never played RDR 1 John is wayyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy superior than Arthur

How is Sadie better than Dutch?

No. 1 is new austin sniper

Sadie higher than dutch😭

My list 1. Charles 2. Arthur 3. John

RDR1 Jack (main story) could probably beat some of the F Tier characters

Who's joe?

Dutch solos sadie

did'nt John survive way longer than Arthur

Sean is probably the worst fighter in the gang, he's not physically strong, he's easily knocked down, he doesn't have the skills of a gunslinger, he doesn't know the weight of his loaded weapon, he can't make a quick draw, he doesn't have aim, he doesn't have intelligence. emotional, Uncle is better than him, Leny is better than him, Javier is much better, there is no comparison, Joel is better and I think even Cleet is better

id say red dead 1 marston is ahead of arthur

Micah is not strong physically compared to Arthur, Charles or Bill, he shouldn't really be that high

Do people not realise that any character that's hypothetically controlled by the player is going to be really good. John and Arthur aren't necessarily better than Micah. John certainly isn't. We just don't get to play as Micah but if we did he'd be just as good. John and Arthur have identical skill for each player. That's not canon. Micah is canonically better than John. Even John knew he was outclassed. Sadie knew this too which is why she wanted John and Charles to help even the odds. They didn't know how big his gang was. They assumed they were just going up against him until Cleet told them he had a new gang.

42nd

1. Charles 2.Arthur 3.Micah 4.Dutch 5.John 6.Sadie >>>>Javier Bill Sean Lenny

you put sadie on top of dutch are you crazy dutch was probably a fantastic gunslinger in his day he taught arthur and john and still probably great with a gun hede kill sadie in 3 seconds if he wanted to hese the LEADER of the whole gang to top it off he has a bad temper and is extremely smart utterly stupid putting sadie over dutch even in his older age