Ranking EVERY Super Mario Game - PBG 

Head to keeps.com/pbg to get 50% off your first order of hair loss treatment. What do you guys think? Agree with my tier list? Disagree? Thanks for watching! =)

This is everyone's reminder that Doki Doki Panic started out as a Mario 2 tech demo so it's a legit Mario game.

Can’t wait for ten years when Peeps redoes this list and laughs at how bad it was

As soon as you mentioned your hair, I had an instant flashback to 2012 "Dear PBG, you need a haircut" "Dear PBG, you DON'T need a haircut" "Dear PBG, has anyone ever told you you look like Shaggy from Scooby-Doo" I don't know how I remembered it, but I did. Glad you're still around from all the way back then.

Are we not gonna acknowledge that we now have a sound clip of PBG saying “shut up twink”

MMMM WHAT YOU SAY

I can’t believe he put Mario: Twilight Princess in D tier, smh

Title says every mario game. Within the first 30 seconds: "I'm not doing every mario game."

"Mario's my best friend!" *Arthur will remember that*

I don't think Peebs is ever gonna have to worry about hair loss.

Peebs: immediately puts New Super Mario Bros DS in the don't care section Me: excessive crying

"When i think of mario bros 2 i think of the fact you can play as luigi, yoshi, and toad to" -PBG 2020

3D world is the most slept on Mario game ever

Thank you for trusting me enough to edit this video for the main channel, Peebs.

If Mario Teaches Typing isn’t number one I’m suing.

Haven’t watched PBG in like 4-5 yrs and he’s still as amazing as i remember

after tuning in to a pbg video for the first time in years, i'm glad to see the topic at hand is still that he needs to cut his hair

"i just don't like how jumpy Mario is in this game" Mario : Jumpman is LITERALLY MY MIDDLE NAME

Peebs: it's not just nostalgia Also Peebs: it is nostalgia

"Imagine Super Mario Odyssey but in space" -PBG

Super Mario Bros 3 was my first Mario...and it still holds up today, in my opinion. Especially with the Gameboy versions updated graphics, it's timeless.

17:04 So in other words, in Mario Sunshine, Mario is not capable of 'Doing the Mario'.

"I am not really a completionist", Jirard is gonna have to talk to him.

Dude you didn’t include hotel mario

6:34 "When i think if super mario bros 2 one of the first things i think of is how you could actually play as not just Mario, but also Luigi *YOSHI* and Toad." Princess Peach: *"Am i a joke to you?"*

Can we appreciate that PBG talked about Mario sunshine for 6 minutes and 40 seconds

Peebs having an existential crisis over Mario Sunshine

Thank you for always cheering me up when I'm in a bad spot with my depression. I wasn't expecting that from a tier list of all things but you just always manage to make me smile.

"I'm going to make the list by comparing each Mario game with the others." Ends the video by putting Mario 64 as his top tier for nostalgia reasons alone.

We all know what’s number one. Mario is missing

I totally agree with you about sunshine’s controls. I played it for the first time when 3D all stars came out and I was constantly scared I would end up launching myself off a platform if I moved the controller too much

Peebington is just Tsundere for Sunshine.

>calls Sunshine's control janky >Puts Mario 64 in first position "Sure, Jan."

Peeps: Mario is my friend Also Peeps: Yells, abuses, and kills Mario

Peebs is in an abusive relationship with Mario sunshine.

you're long schpiel about Sunshine just reminded me how i really did miss that game and im glad i got to play it again after so long. it is oddly designed, but ive heard its the most unfinished Mario game and SO many things stick out that make me believe that.

It was hard to watch PBG wish for a Space concept that has literally been done as described multiple times 💀💀💀

I love how chaotically HEARTBREAKING this ranking is.

24:15 Wait, did i just see Peter freakin' Hollens in a PBG vid??? Best collab EVER

The thing for Mario sunshine is it's like a nostalgia feeling since it has been my favorite Mario for soooooo long, but when I started on the switch version of it I realized how much harder some of the controls are compared to other games.

pbg: WHY DID I PUT TWILIGHT PRINCESS UNDER ZELDA 2??? 1 year later pbg: im putting Mario 3d land under Mario 2

Ok. The Mario crotch level? Those are CLEARLY the contents of his fertilized egg sac. Mario be ready to spawn! This is the only canon explaination.

YES I loved your top tens more than anything, this brings me back

Man where mario shot you that brought me right back to the early days of youtube haha. Love your videos man been watching you for years theyre always great

"Mario is my best friend!!!!" Arthur wants to know your location

“He’s my best friend!” 10 seconds later “I killed him!”

HOLY CRAP I friggin lost it at MMMMWATCHASAAAYYYYYYY. Classic.

"oh cool you found the coin that's better" lol

25:50 "Shut up, Twink!" This has great meme potential

17:55 I agree. Mario feels very slippery when controlling him in Sunshine. It's a fun game, but sometimes you feel like the game is against you.

I think this is one of the best videos he’s ever made. Thoroughly enjoyed it.

The poor 3DS Mario's never get any love. ;_;

8:47 y’know, a hack called “newer super Mario bro’s DS” made the exact same level with updated music and everything! It’s really cool!

14:23 every time I hear that "no" I burst out laughing. It's the most dismissive and disrespectful sounding thing I have ever heard.

Mario oddysey moons are like star coins with more of a completionist award because you don’t have to pause and go into a hardly used menu to see them, you see them whenever you go to the oddysey, and you can flex on your friends

'It's midnight! There's nowhere I can go!' How about to bed? Is that a place you can go? LOL

Why did a hair loss company sponsor this when he complains about having too much hair at the beginning?

Mistake at 0:33 . You were talking about "tier lists" but you mistakenly showed a picture of a "rear list". Common blunder.

SM64 still has my favorite movement in 3D platformers to date

I was literally just thinking about how good the editting was in this video, and of cours its Sirtoasty! I love that guys videos.

2:42 PBG single handily bringing back normal boots madness

I don't see Waluigi gets his Walu-weenie stuck in a vending machine. This is extreme clickbait.

I love that even when peebs does a tier list video is is still highly edited you know how many of these I have watched with no editing? dudes are literally staring into a camera for anywhere from half an hour to an hour anyway great list there is no wrong list only your list

I had such good memories with new super mario bros for the wii. My sister, my best friend and I would play it at like 3:00 am when he slept over and it would be a blast.

Bruh NSMB wii was literally my childhood mario game, you broke my heart peebs :(

I really look forward to the Mario and Zelda Months, because it means lots of great PBG content

YoU fOrGoT tHe LoSt LeVeLs!

Last I checked; you don't need to get every Shine Sprite in Mario Sunshine and you can choose whichever levels you want to visit, as long as you unlock them.

I thought the controls were fine in sunshine. BOOOOOOO, (great video btw)

I'm so happy that this showed up, I literally just said I don't have anything to watch

I miss watching your old videos! So much fun to go back to!

He ignores the spinoffs in the tier list but ironically immediately uses the battle theme from Superstar Saga

"I've tried to convince myself to cut *it* (my hair) but he just doesn't listen" BIG MOOD

there’s a lot of audio potential for pbg yelling “SHUT UP, TWINK”

anyone start laughing at when Peach went flying into the abyss in the 3D Super Mario World section XD

Your videos are still as fun if not more funny then when i started watchin you. You are fantastic!

For those who say anime hair is unrealistic, just look at this man.

You really clickbaited me with Sunshine.

Peebs: I don’t like the levels without fludd very much. Also peebs in an earlier video: I actually enjoyed the levels without fludd more than the rest of the game

All your videos are awesome. Will you do a top 10 Luigi games in the future?

17:19 that analogy was comedy gold 😂🎮

6:34 ah yes, yoshi in mario bros 2

PBG is my first ever subscription, my absolute childhood is in this page!

the dear sister spoof thing you did legit cracked me up.

I literally dropped everything when I got this notification. Peeb time Peeb time .

PBG you always put me in a good mood your videos are amazing and I am happy that you celebrated Mario Month this year. Thank you for doing this. Also Toasty did a spot on job with editing this video. Thank you guys for making Mario Month outstandingly entertaining! Yahoo!!!!!!

Gotta love how Peebs has the thumbnail for Caddy’s Crash Bandicoot Rear List video in the A tier

This video made me really want to go play some more Mario! Thanks PBG

Not to defend sunshine, but I'm sure it would've won more awards if as many awards existed back in 2003

So we can bring back telling pbg to get a haircut? Thats a callback.

The editing on this video is really on point

I remember watching your old Majora’s Mask mask walkthroughs. Still love your content!

YES! At most B for sunshine was what I hoped. Sunshine is an A for me, but that is probably some nostalgia

Peebs: *complains about sunshine * also peebs: *wearing sunshine shirt*

it's because the controls in Mario Sunshine take a long time to get good at, but are really good when you are good with them.

when PBG said “shut up twink!” I had to do a double take before realizing it was just the actual name of a character... ohhhh boy. I was very scared for a second but that’s so funny

Here’s how I would have done this list: Add a tier list called never played Put all of them in there

if I don't see hotel mario at number one I'm going to cry

Completely forgot about Super Mario Land 2 untill watching your video, music in that game was on point.

Okay, ranking my favorites. #1 - Super Mario Odyssey. Such a cool story, the levels were really neat, it was fun scavenger-hunting for all those moons, and I finally got to play as a Hammer Bro. #2 - Super Mario 3D World. It's classic-style Mario for a modern era. Multiple playable characters, explorable world maps, and a boatload of power-ups. #3 - Super Mario Bros. 3. Also a boatload of power-ups, and plenty of activities on the world maps. #4 - Super Mario Galaxy. Epic game with it's opening and space theme, and Rosalina's introduction. Also that orchestrated music. #5 - Super Mario Land 2. This game is really weird and creative. Going to space, being shrunken to the size of a mouse, exploring a giant mechanical Mario. Also takes some inspiration from Mario World, with secret exits and the spin jump. Now if only it had Yoshi. #6 - Super mario Galaxy 2. It's like a bigger and better Galaxy 1.... but then it's not. Glad it has Yoshi. But completely lost that epic feel, and that big star guy is a poor replacement for Rosalina. #7 - Super Mario World. This has Yoshi, and emphasis on exploring and unlocking levels. Also my favorite castle theme. #8 - Super Mario Bros. 2. I don't care that it's not a "real" Mario. This game is pretty dang neat, with it's throwing mechanic, and the level designs are pretty good, and of course the multiple playable characters. #9 - Super Mario 64. Game can be fun, but neither Mario nor the camera control all that well. And some of the objectives are just dreadfully obnoxious. Though at least you can skip them. Shoutout to the DS version. It could've been the definitive version of Mario 64, if it only had proper analog control. #10 - Super Mario Land. It's like a more creative Super Mario Bros. 1. Explodey enemies and weird locations, and even a couple shoot-em-up levels. #11 - Super Mario Sunshine. First off, I do like the water mechanic. I like the overall tropical theme. But again, so many annoying objectives, and this time, many of them are not optional. And the finale is disappointing, making the playthrough overall not worth it. #12 - New Super Mario Bros. U. The only NSMB game I really played, and I enjoyed it enough. Plenty of level gimmicks. Power-ups were only okay, though. Having two Toad characters was petty lame. And the fact this was basically the Madden of Mario sours my perception on it a bit. As an aside, I haven't played much of New Super Luigi U, so I can't speak for that, though the speedrunny levels seem interesting. #13 - Super Mario Bros.: The Lost Levels. Also a frustrating game, but I will give it props for having more interesting levels than Super Mario Bros. 1. #14 - Super Mario Bros. 1. It's okay. Set the groundwork for future Mario games. But that's all it is, is the groundwork for future Mario games.