Stroud is Top 5 at least. He put up phenomenal numbers last year with ZERO elite receivers or even much of a run game. Prior to Stroud - Nico was putting up less than 500 yards a season, Tank was a 3rd round rookie, and Schultz wasn't a Top 10 TE. Pierce was barely a Top 20 RB, and Singletary wasn't even Top 25.
@@kaninesenses He is great but I need him to be more consistent before I can move him up to the top tiers but I do think that he is going to do great so I wouldn't be suprised if this season he is a top 10 qb
i dont see why stafford should be lower on this list for being old and injury prone when aaron rodgers is a tier higher and was exactly that getting his achilles destroyed on the first snap of the season
I can see where your coming from but I believe that throughout Rodgers career he has been a top 5 qb and throughout Staffords career he has been a top 10 qb so that is whey I put Rodgers at 9th best qb and I put Stafford at the 13th best qb
quick tip, don’t make your thumbnail the actual list. didn’t even have to watch a second of your video because of that. read the whole list on the thumbnail 😭
Top 4: correct top 4. Allen is the 2nd best QB. He doesn't have the elite talent the Bengals and Ravens have and still leads his team to a top 5 Offense every year. His defense gets exposed by elite QBS every year in the playoffs but it's the right top 4. I think you have to move Herbert and Hurts out of 5 and 6. Herbert has had some weapons and still hasn't won a playoff game. Hurts looks great one year and then falls off. You can't have him that high because you don't know if he's good without his 2nd best situation (only Purdy is in a better position to succeed as QB). I'd move Love and let Rodgers or Purdy sneak in. Stafford over Tua. Trevor Lawrence just isn't good. Kirk Cousins, Kyler and hell maybe even Baker MAyfield are better than him. He is probably on the same level as Watson.
Allen is not above Jackson or Burrow because of the way he plays he tries to take way to many risks that don't end well, Herbert has had a horrible coach throughout his career, Hurts has made it to a superbowl, Rodgers and Stafford are way out of their prime, Tua and Purdy are just system qb's, and Lawrence is not in a great situation on the Jags, Kirk has had a top 5 wr most of his career, Kyler is good but not great, Baker is very inconsistent. and Watson has fallen off.
@@RWPYT He really doesn't take risks. His TD to interception ratio is one of the all time lowest. He has only ever had one good WR that he turned from a pro-bowler who barely got over 1k yards to an All-Pro. Herbert has had elite weapons his entire career. Hurts made it to the SB in the NFC; it's the easier conference. So you punish Cousins for having a top 5 WR but not Burrow? Lawrence had Ridley, Kirk and Engram with a good pass catching RB in Etienne and plays in a weak division..... yeah he was in a great situation and just isn't good
@@ryanshedler4861 Allen threw 18 int's 2nd behind Sam Howell with 21 int's, Herbert has had good weapons but they could almost never stay healthy and his coaches were trash, Just because the NFC is easier doesn't mean that Hurts making it to the superbowl isn't any more important than a qb from the AFC, Cousins vs Burrow is a crazy comparison because Burrow is way better than Cousins, Lawrence had mid wr's a good rb and a good te but his division is not weak the texans are good the colts were only bad because Richarson was injured and the Titans are bad I will give you that one.
@@RWPYT Go and watch the Allen interception reel. See how many were off his WR's hands. How many his WR ran wrong route or how many are 3rd and prayer deep shots that got picked off. It's like 10-12 of those. This is the problem with people who watch stats and not games. Also Keenan Allen was mostly healthy. Sure Mike Williams was hurt a lot but Ekeler wasn't. He;s always had a good (not great TE). Henry, Cook. Everett. Also; Allen also has had terrible coaches. You've seen McDermott's defenses in the playoffs. Pretty much his defense is Allen go score and we can play soft zone when the QB has to throw it. I guess what I'm trying to say is that in baseball they use WAR (wins above replacement) and imo Allen has the highest WAR in the NFL.... he is simply put the only elite player on the Bills (unless you want to count Milano coming off injury) and leads them to a top 5 Offense year in and year out.
@@ryanshedler4861 Looking at the Allen Interception reel you can make the argument the some of the int's were his were not his fault but looking at some of the other int's you can tell the he is more careless with the decisions he makes.
He is a great qb and in is prime he would have been up there easily but now he is older and more injury prone that is the same reason I don't have Aaron Rodgers top 4
@RWPYT he was one of the best QBs in the league down the stretch of last season. Going into this year he deserves a top 7-8 spot but if we were starting a franchise today he would be a lot lower
