Red Dead Redemption 2 in 2024 is Disappointing? 

*What are your honest thoughts on RDR2?* 👀

The greatest game of all time, I can’t believe rockstar hasn’t chose to expand this game in any way.

RDR2 > GTA 5

As someone who played the game 2yrs after release, avoiding all spoilers, reviews, etc like it didn't exist, I am So annoyed with myself that I never streamed and uploaded my playthrough. This game RUINED open world gaming for me cos it's So Damn Friggin Good and Immersive. I've completed the game 6x already but my 2nd playthrough, after knowing the outcome, I stayed in Valentine damn near indefinitely and leaving Micah locked up, exploring with Arthur. I still throw the game on every now and again to do a spot of hunting, fishing, exploring, drinking in the taverns and return to camp just because it feels like I'm Really there doing it myself. The fact Rockstar Never released any updates or dlcs to this masterpiece is criminal. Best Game Ever Made!

Yes it is a strong statement to say RDR2 is the best game ever. But those who have spent real time with it, know for a fact, it's the best game ever made.

things they could fix 1: add some RDO clothing and wepons to the story 2: add John Marston's animations insted of being stuck with Arthur's 3: fix 'the cowboy' outfit so it looks more like it's RDR counterpart 4: fix john's face 5: add mexico 6: undead nightmare 2

All it needs is a 60fps update but they won't do it

RDR2 Undead nightmare would be game of the year. Or at least close to it 😮

Honestly couldn't agree more. I couldn't give 2 shits about online mode. For GTA or Red dead. But that's what they've chosen to focus on for both games because...money. It sucks to have such a perfect game get no extra love or expansion. We can probably expect the same for GTA 6.

If rockstar does these things for RDO specifically it will be perfect •train robbery’s bank robbery’s and store robbery’s in free roam •private lobbies •make it easier to start out I’m starting out after completing the story and getting gold is impossible I think these will make the game so much better

Imagine how fuckin awesome the expansions for RDR2 could be. Map expansion into Mexico, or maybe further North into a Wyoming/Montana inspired area.

the real DLC have been mods/ and RP servers. they add so many things to do... for me it gave me reasons to keep playing the game longer. but I wish Rockstar would've gave us PROPER updates and content.

we need DLC in the form of a remake of RDR1, so we can play Arthur and Marston's story mode in its entirety! After completing 100% of the story, challenges, etc., Marston's cutscene at Arthur's grave will be directly connected to the cutscene a few years later in RDR1! I think it will be magnificent! RDR will truly be the real GOAT!

Story mode is fun butt online is just another troll hole sandbox like gta5 online

bro I just wanna know what mod is the the crazy graphics

What happened to the console warehouse

GTA five red dead redemption, two red dead redemption one and GTA four will never get old

sadly i do not have access to mods (im on pc) because i do not know how to download them like the tutorials are hard to understand and theres alot of stuff i have to do for mods

Why doesn’t Rockstar put the love into RDR2 that they do to boring old GTAV that is like a million years old but always have tons of content added? RDR2 is beautiful, I wish there was more to do in the sense of what Rockstar could be doing to it like they do to played out GTAV

The fact GTA 5 got a next gen upgrade for PS5 and Series X (which was decent, but it's still a 360/ps3 game at it's core) and RDR2 (Rockstar's greatest game to date) has not speaks volumes about where Rockstar as a company has gone. There is no reason RDR2 should have not been updated for consoles by now. 60 frames with some updated textures/ lighting would of been everything.

currently on my 10th run in rdr2 I NEED THAT 100% COMPLETION

Yo why is seeing my acount in one of you vids feel so awsome😂 anyways great vid really touched on important overlooked stuff

I don't even care about GTA 6 I care about the game in my hands right now and that's RED DEAD ONLINE

All I want is a 60 fps next gen update. Is that too much to ask?

Didn't even add the navy revolver to story mode :(

It sucks for me also, RDR2 is my alltime fav game and they still haven't done a 60fps rerelease for the current gen.

what are your pc stats and rdr2 graphic settings

I spent money on gold bars in red dead 2 a few times. Never even had the thought to do that for gta 5. Red dead is way better. I love the combat using older weapons. Especially the carcano. Sniping is fun and takes a little more skill than using lock on aim weapons

Been gaming since a wee lad with me ol man, playin n64 and what not being a 92 baby. Tons of fond memories, but rdr2 was the game i roped my ol man back into with and the amount of memories and reactions experienced is unfathomable. Even to this day, we discuss the game at least once every other time we visit one another. Showing a boomer the legendary bear scene is something only a few can embrace.

GTA 6 2026 Why do I find that hilarious 😂

Im just glad that rockstar took their new release hiatus after rdr2 instead of gta 5 online but still am pretty pissed

I ligit thought that they added a 60fps patch on that update. 😢😢😢

Would absolutely love a map expansion. Mexico would be dope

Anyone know if they patched over being able to get Micah's gun early by killing him in jail?

I mean after gta 5 getting no story dlc its no surprise to me rdr2 got no story dlc

I can not start a mission, i hold l2 too talk to the guys and then it says too press interaction option? I play on ps 4 please help

The problem with both gta and rdr2 is,these games had so much content that dlc would have been awesome,but it is truly disappointing that we never got any for the story. I personally do not.car for playing online with rdr2 because too many people kill you for no reason,until they add private sessions like we have on gta5 online,I personally have no plans to return to rdr2.

I totally love rdr online even in 2024 I haven’t played the online version until recently I’m a level 60 and absolutely love killing the griffins

I beat it for the second time just the other day 2024 and I had an amazing experience even better than the first time I beat it so I don’t think it’s disappointing at all

were do we go to demand undead nigtjmare dlc

It's definitely not disappointing. To give you perspective, I'm very disappointed with most of ps4 and ps5 catalouge- this is the last game I bought.

i wish there were ship robberies where you can board a big ship and rob it

Im hopeful the latest patch is followed very quickly with a next gen patch for series s/x

I heard they fixed a lot of the GTA glitches too

Bro if u only played the story mode then u have to try ONLINE it's basically like playing story mode but with more missions

It’s on sale rn so I don’t know what to do

I know this is kind of a cliche phrase but Red Dead Redemption 2 is not a video game. It's an experience. And that can be justified. Red Dead Redemption II was the first Rockstar video game to be like that. It stopped looking like a video game and became more of a massive interactive movie. And the catch is that it was not just Rockstar's debut to developing this kind of games. It arguably is the first (and last the momment this comment is written unfortunately) game that did this. The combination of an insanely immersive open world and a story that can make a grown man feel genuine emotions along with the stunning graphics and the realism in all aspects of the game is something you just CAN'T find anywhere else. That combination and dozens of other virtues as well is what makes this game an experience. I don't think that the first walkthrough of one in Red Dead Redemption 2 can be relived with many games on the market. It's something truly special that someone who hasn't played the game cannot understand through words in a comment section. Rockstar Games are not criminals because they didn't release any DLC's or because of ruining the online mode (The second one is something I don't give a flying fuck about but anyways). They WILL BE criminals if they don't release a sequel to this masterpiece. Even if it takes 10 years. I believe they will release a sequel because even if they don't plan to do so already, after GTA 6 gets released next year and some time passes where most of the gamers will have played the game guess what will be the main talk in the whole single player community...You guessed right...RED DEAD REDEMPTION III. However I believe that they themselves plan of doing so and it might even be in development right fucking now. Red Dead Redemption II is the best game of all time just because it isn't your typical video game. Because Rockstar cracked the code and created something that punctured the wall of the video game room and unveiled a ceiling of something...entirely different from what the video game world was used to for more than 20 years. And that ladies and gentlemen is Red Dead fucking Redemption 2

The CEO of Rockstar said that he wants games to be priced by the hours of entertainment you get. So when we look at the release pricetag of RE Village and StarWars Outlaws, AC Red and that Ubisoft pirate game. We can all be assured that GTA6 will have a 80 dollar pricetag. (at minimum)

Rockstar gave their greed time to shine with RDRO! The game was in "beta" and they were trying to sell us microtransactions!

Honestly im so annoyed that Rockstar hasn't provided a next-gen update that im not even going to bother with the next grand theft auto. As a company they care nothing about their customers. The witcher 3 and cyberpunk got free next-gen updates because the company actually appreciates it's customers. Rockstar is the complete opposite which is sad because they make far more money than the other game companies. Im not going to support companies like that. Just my opinion.

you don't even own those games except you pirate them... pro tip: NEVER EVER Pay for something which they can take away at any moment.

Things we needed: New animal DLC for story mode. Including porcupine, otter, wolverine, bobcat, gopher etc. RDR1 created in the new word Leverage the Mexico landscape and new Austin

Rockstar will become a shell of itself since dan houser left

Wait. It hasnt even been out for 10 years what?

Yeah i am so disappointed I thought for sure there would be a undead nightmare it was one of the greatest selling games/dlc ever and they just abandoned it I never would have guessed that

About the game gap between 2018 to 2025. They did release another game in August 2023. A re-release of RDR1, the same game made in 2010, no remaster, just the same thing.

Not disappointed at all bruh even the online is fire and always active, may not have a bunch of stuff to do but it’s still fun to play.

We need a PS5 Release of Red Dead Redemption 2 with all the cut content or maybe John DLC

Imagine if this game was remastered for ps5

I agree with we need expansions as of now the only way to play undead nightmare is to get mods which is not easy on console I think idk console players please give me information on the current modding state

Are you ever gonna make a follow up to the xbox emulator vid

I just started playing rdr2 again a few weeks ago. Online is an absolute nightmare so many hackers. Moonshine shack and stables not working. Just started with those issues about a week ago. I'm to a point to give up on the game.

3 months late but how did you get your game to look like this? To me it looks quite good 0:11

I also never understood why RDR 2 never got a Story Expansion.

30 fps on ps5 IS FUCKING SHIT just kill me

I reinstalled after all these years, and made it to the Epilogue. I love it. I still think this is top three games of all time. I also think the environments and ecosystem is still the absolute best. The detail, storytelling, and liveliness of everything is just top notch.

Man I can't wait for rdr3, as a gamer I only finished this game & the last of us 100%. Best games ever made period

Trying to kill time until Stellar Blade… think I’ll get into this tonight!

Bro had a point on mute

if they jump on this title hard this could be the best game ever made

a good thing about gta online is they've been slowly fixing things and listening to people with each new dlc they maybe small but there not that bad

Honestly, the customization for story mode is good and all, but looking at all the customization in Online, theres so much that can be done. How hard is it to add the online clothing options to Story Mode? One black banada and a few weird masks to wear are good and all, but theres so many more bandanas with a wide range of colors and patterns in online. And last thing, the goddamn offhand holster. It sticks out like a sore thumb and just looks bad. I know they wanted to add dual wielding, and thats good too, but why not add the option to take it off? The game worked perfectly well in the beginning with one holster, and just looked so much cleaner without having your second revolver just sticking out to the front like that. Plus, no other npcs (that I know of) have it, so it kinda takes away from the imersion for me personally, but not by much. Thats just my personal opinion tho.

If think I know the reason why Rockstar don't give RDR2 more time. Game like GTA and RDR needs lots of time and money for development, so they rather invest all time to create gigantic and almost perfect game, than making some dlc. I really appreciate them for that. Because is much better than most recent rushed games.

if this game is the pinnacle of all video games... I guess my gaming experience will only go downhill from here.

FSR allows this to run on a 4-year-old potato with iGPU at 1080p.

Hopefully the work environment at rockstar isn't too toxic, because if so, that means the employees who really do care about the game and the fans, aren't going to be brave enough to put forward suggestions for groundbreaking ideas that will help the company. It's in the companies, and the investors best interest that they listen to the fans. And most certainly mine, since I've got money riding on take two..

Rip Sean, lenny, Hosea and Keiran

Truthfully.. if there was a next gen upgrade to RDR2 I couldn't care less about GTA6.

The fact that Rockstar hasn’t even done the bare minimum by giving RDR2 a next gen update boils my blood. Also no story DLC is disappointing. They could’ve done so much. Whether it was Undead nightmare 2, the Blackwater massacre, Sadie and/or Charles after the epilogue or between 1899 and 1907 or playing from their perspective in chapter 5 as they were keeping the gang together. I mean they had SO much to work with. It sucks.

At or around two minutes or something. I keep coming back to it every year, I try to play only once a year as to not get bored for sure, because I love horses. This is the only good horse-game out there, the only cowboy game focused on horses and horseriding right now. I love it. ...but yes, some dlc would be nice. I wish some parts of Online would've been brought to offline, like more bounties and the five Specialist Roles in general and more horses and more stable space etc. Doing these things or variations of them with Morgan and/or John would have been cool.

So the game is good but 80% of the vid feels like a rant about it not having an expansion? Hmm, I'll give it a try for the story mode. :)

to me the massive drawback to a game like rdr2 is that you only get one experience. it’s a very staged game so once you’ve played it, you already know what’s gonna happen next time you come around to play it again. each random event, each treasure map, each mission, you name it. however it does serve for an amazing first time experience. so whoever hasn’t played it yet, should really appreciate the first time they play. cuz after that, the game will slowly appear more as a program rather than a game.

This is why i downloaded many mods for this game.

I just bought the game 5minutes ago and already a Millionaire in the game with Money glitch lol.

a next gen port would go hard

If it had 60 fps on my series x, it would be perfect.

building own house ,pay public for doing the home .i would like that in RD2

man all i want is 60 fps for rdr2

Uhhh yeah I haven’t played this game for 3 years because I’m still waiting for a next gen upgrade. I deleted it.

Litteraly playing my second and a half play through. Legit have a chapter 2 Arthur and an epilogue John. I just explored all of new austin and was very disappointed. Was dead and was a clear example of wasted potential

I love rd2 so much but definitely want rd3. I beat rd2 12times already im done

I hope thay there isn't an online mode for gta 6

just bought it and is installing right now. I have been grinding witcher 3 for a long time and I have alwaysthought it would be hard to beat it. I have however seen a lot of post about rdr2 and now I finally decided to give it a go. I send you the bill if I hate it

I just deleted cod mw3 to play this again love the immersion

It needs a ng+

They cant lay the older game to rest? Its like rockstar playing favorites instead of just giving what all rockstar players want.

New subscriber mate you are hilarious 🤣

At this rate i imagine them making gta6 and then abandon it so they can go back to milking gta5 because that's what they know best

theyve neglected rdr2 so hard they didnt bother making a 9th gen console version of it...

Sad to say but that's not true abt story they can make a dlc for it right now and wont make nearly as much money as online even though its far better. RDR came out in 2018 and has been carried and still talked abt it today bc of the online mode