@@Ace-dv5ce The sky is the most realistic with volumetric textures on ultra, on consoles the game is downgraded for performance. Rdr2 is photorealistic trust me
@@alekksu4293 Haven’t played it on pc but I’ve done some graphic settings on tv and it’s pretty great, although the sky is great it’s not going for realistic style that wouldn’t fit wit all the other stuff the game does realistically, the sky box is great and looks like a painting for real
This is true I was playing it a few days ago. Until my mum realized I was controlling it, she thought it was a movie going on xD (safe to say my best game i ever played in 25 years of my life)
Exactly how I see it, GOT looks like its trying for more of a artistic look which is evident in the vibrant colour and the painting like look of the grass and trees while RDR2 is going for more of a realistic look with different shades in grass, depth in snow and way more than can be listed. I got these mostly from the video as I haven't played GOT.
Got wasn't trying to be realistic. Like Witcher. Witcher also has a very good environment to its year. It is an amazing game but not realistic looking. Rdr2 aimed for the most realistic world and done it soooooo perfect!
@@fransthefox9682 I think it's time to have a conversation nobody wants to have: consoles are consumer friendly PCs with less processing power than one you can reasonably build yourself. As someone who played Cyberpunk on PC, my experience was fantastic. One or two minor bugs but nothing game breaking. Great story, fun gameplay and great voice acting. At a certain point we have to realize that consoles are no longer providing consumers with a strong enough platform to support their MASSIVELY ambitious games like Cyberpunk. That's on the platform, not the developer.
@@jakelee5096 Consoles still support lots of other ambitious games that are coming out these years. On consoles Cyberpunk looks like a PS2 game and the PC users think that this is the absolute best graphics that any console can produce.
@@peacefulman9369 still hating the game after all this time? You can’t deny the fact of how well design the game is, especially with attention to detail. I can’t wait to see what Naughty Dog does with their next game, and eventually Last of Us 3 to end this generation of PS5
Rdr 2 made with passion and perfectionist in every small details, even the npc, conversation, physics, interaction, animal etc, the colour grading are so on point
I never really experience problems with my console on any game, apart from like AC Unity, or Cyberpunk. But those were released way too early. My Xbox one s handled RDR2 with no problems, if the game is polished, it should run fine on console, thats what your paying for isn’t it? With PC you can get better hardware but it costs more and have too make yourself, and console is ol’ reliable, can run any game that they sell for it, type thing.
Can you imagine a interaction between Arthur and Jin Jin: So even though you’re an outlaw, you still have a code of honor you follow. I respect that. Arthur: You’re damn right Boah
Well depends what point in Arthur's story this is, it's called Red Dead Redemption for a reason He wasn't always a high honourable great guy and isn't even always in some playthroughs
Two very different approaches in art style imo, and they both do their job incredibly well. As someone else in the comments said: RDR2 looks like a photograph, while GoT looks like a painting. These are both easily among my favourite games from this gen.
When I first saw the gameplay footage of ghost of Tsushima I knew right then and there I needed it in my life. Couple months later got a ps5 and ghost of tsushima and it has become my favorite game ever did not disappoint me in the slightest.
@@StalkerOfPripyat you can't compare because they are completely different games. Rdr2 was made with realism in mind while ghost of tsushima is more assassin's creed style
For a game which is already 3 years old ... RDR2 is still the standard against which all games of this genre are measured. And it looks like it will remain this way till the next RockStar title ...
@@TzsNatureWithJameelFar I highly doubt farcry 6 will surpass RDR 2 as we all know Ubisoft loves downgrading graphics and details in their retail game.
@@RodrickShay of course it takes time, most of games takes at least 5 years nowadays. And talking about details, no, GOW and TLOU2 aren't even close to RDR2
I'm trying to get into tw3, but it's combat sucks to hell I can't stand it, and the NPCs are kinda dumb, Ai is dumb, they only say 1 sentence when u speak to them... The horse mechanics are ass... Rdr2 also had clucky controls and stiff shooting.. But it was far far better and more fun than the Witcher combat.. Attack, dodge dodge, attack, spell dodge roll... It bored me to hell
@@anonymous_dot_com2326 Not just that also the way geralt moves and controls is so clunky and nervewrecking it completely makes you lose interest in playing the game
@@anonymous_dot_com2326 The game is from 2015. It was a big deal at that time, i clearly remember. Someone who has played games from the recent years won’t be able to appreciate the gameplay, its quite natural. Even I would probably prefer killing Roach if I replayed the game today😂
I’ve played both, and both are amazing games. Although RDR2 has better horse physics in my opinion, both have amazing stories that had lots of hard work put into.
Well I’d say that’s more of a fact that the RDR2 horses are better, because the game is a western, and horses and Cowboys were a pretty big deal. GoT horses are just cool looking.
Having extensive experience with both, I'd say both are unmatched by any other games, but both are uncomparable. Rdr is beautiful in realistic ways, everything is detaile as in real life GoT is beautiful, end of story. So much more pleasing to look in the eyes.
One thing that sort of annoyed me about RDR2 is that when I’m tryna just explore with my horse and look around places a bear comes outta no where and my horse just fucks off. Kinda ruins the vibe lol
@@shriram._8426 which breed is that. I just bought an Arabian and I was riding near a cliff. Bear came out of nowhere and the damn horse off the cliff and killed me and itself and I had to waste $1000 for another horse
@@greengoblin5488 make sure you get the arabian to lvl 4 binding But if you want a fearless bulldozer of death you should buy a turkoman from Saint Denis
RDR2 is a masterpiece that is way ahead of its time. I'm pretty sure it can still beat games releasing for the next 5 years. But GoT is a beautiful game too it's just RDR2 is a masterpiece.
@@shalindelta7 I haven't played it myself either but I played TLoU 1. And based on what I saw on trailer of TLoU 2 before and my experience on TLoU 1, I can say too that it is exceptional. It's just RDR2 is such a masterpiece, beautiful graphics, full of little details and amazing NPC that makes the world so amazingly alive.
@matheus 3511 oh okay, well if that's the case it's a good thing we don't do reddit. It's a sad community if you can't express your opinion and be bashed if you are a fanboy. What's wrong of being a fanboy if such a beautiful game. Btw, thanks for explaining bro.
They're very close, which makes RDR2 that much more impressive considering it's a few years older. I'd say only the water is a very obvious difference in favor of RDR2. I love the vibrance of Tsushima, even though it's not necessarily realistic, and I think I enjoyed GoT just a little bit more overall. One day I'll finish all the side stuff in RDR2 (legendary prey, dinosaur bones, dream catchers,...). That's actually what I enjoyed the most, but I got side-tracked by other games... Edit: just started a second playthrough of RDR2 and it's still glorious and in no way worse that GoT. It's my perfect slow-paced games.
Sadly Rdr 2 won’t be topped by other open worlds for a while(except gta 6 and other R* games). But games like Tlou 2 have more realistic graphics, but they are linear.
@@shalindelta7 it's a lot easier to render more better graphics for a small space than a biggg open world like rdr2.If tlou 2 was open world then the ps5 would sound like an airplane when running it.Its the small scale of the game that makes it easy to run.
I am still stunned that this was the first time sucker punch even made a game like this and still managed to compete with one of the most realistic games ever
This is the Sophie’s choice of video games! They’re both incredible games! But, the tiny little details that Rockstar put in their games makes Red Dead a winner in my opinion, but seriously, both are spectacular games! Especially the Directors cut of GoT on PS5!
@matheus 3511 Actually Red Dead Redemption 2 feels more real and alive, while Got is more colorful and feels more like a fictional world of fantasy, both look so awesome
Tsushima makes me feel like a mythical ghost, RDR2 makes me feel like a tuberculosis riddled outlaw who just wants to make things right. I love them both ❤️
Visually speaking. GoT's gameplay is 100% superior. They focus on different characteristics that are important for the experience. Still both masterpieces
@@SirFuffy I don’t think GoT is a masterpiece, in my opinion its just a generic open world that copied Batman combat. Although the game definitely looks beautiful tho, also p5 is goated
Aint no thang back in them days. Wake up, go for a stroll in the fields, watch a man get mauled. Go back home and write in your diary or whatever. Eat some dinner, go to sleep. Repeat
Even if no game so far has surpassed RDR2 I'm happy that its slower pace and details has influenced other games. I hope that influence becomes more and more obvious as time goes on
Both great game and love them both. However RDR2 had $500M+ budget while GOT only had $60M. It's really tough to compare an Indie Company against giants like rockstar games in terms of resources to create a game but GOT is considered as a masterpiece even on a low budget.
Not to be "that guy" but RDR2's art style is very strongly inspired by American Romanticism, especially with its cinematic travel mode that shows off the landscapes: www.polygon.com/red-dead-redemption/2018/10/26/18024982/red-dead-redemption-2-art-inspiration-landscape-paintings Ghosts of Tsushima's art style is inspired by the Kamakura and Haien periods in Japanese art which use bold, vibrant colors. gamerant.com/ghost-tsushima-concept-art-inspiration/ magazine.artstation.com/2020/08/sucker-punch-productions-ghost-of-tsushima-art-blast/ Both games have gorgeous styles!
@@Erilis000 Yeah I was gonna write that lol, it literally took place in the historical era of romanticism m which encompassed areas such as philosophy and art
I'm going to say it like this, RDR2 are very cool, and GOT are artistically beautiful. In terms of how realistic, i'll go with RDR. Both games are masterpiece.
I played both games, Combat is amazing in story mode and so is gameplay until you defeat every enemy camp for GoT. But I give rdr2 extra points for remaining some fun after story mode.
@@noheadzone2103 I mean man,god of war is a masterpiece,the sad fact is that it's a linear game... Which makes me want to prefer rdr2,an open world game,I wish gow was a open world. But hey,there's a reason why rdr2 won so many awards in 2018 including the best story award
@@noheadzone2103 and rdr2 makes you you have regret killing someone since you know that they have a family and routines but some don't though,there are homeless people in game too :( That's how unusually immersive it is. Both games had stories that amazed me
Idk if that is true but all I know is that Rockstar Games was founded in NYC U.S and Rockstar north in England and together they made a red dead series so therefore I think your wrong. (Correct me if im wrong)
Haven't played GoT but I started RDR2 a couple weeks ago and I was astonished firstly by the snow tracks that we leave behind in Colter chapter. The attention to detail is topnotch
they are both good but there are other games that does a pretty good job as well, i have played witcher 3 and ac valhalla and the horse physics in those games are not bad at all
Never owned a horse. But I have eaten one (not a whole one), so the only thing I can confirm is that Horse meat is edible. And yet neither game has an option to eat your horse. This broke my immersion.
@@KebabsRock1997 yeah the first Last of Us was such a powerful game for me as a kid. I own a PS4 but haven’t bought TLOU2 yet, seen all the spoilers etc but I’m still keen to experience it for myself. Hope you get the opportunity to play it too my friend
I just started playing GoT, and think it’s amazing in so many ways. One thing I find a little off about it after playing so much RDR2, is the open world doesn’t feel as alive. In RDR2 you can greet, antagonize, rob and kill all the stranger NPC’s, which is fine, because you play as an outlaw and that’s what they were going for, but in GoT, you just kill the enemies and bow to the locals. Recourse gathering like wood, bamboo and flowers, you click on them and they break apart and appear in you inventory. In RDR2 you get to SEE the process of picking plants, fishing and dressing game animals. Both have beautiful open worlds to gush over, but in terms of detail and realism, RDR2 has the best. All in all, I’m just happy to finally be playing these games. They both so phenomenal and I’m loving the samurai combat in GoT.
@@pubgplayer1948 that would be great but is something that 90% most likely wont happen. i would probably just buy a ps4 after i get the series x so im not too broke😂