Ridgid vs. Ryobi HP! [SUBCOMPACT SHOWDOWN Episode 01]

Подписаться 15 тыс.

Просмотров 9 тыс.

50% 1

Will the prosumer Ridgid R8723 outperform the high-end DIY Ryobi HP PSBID01? Which Home Depot subcompact should you buy? We put these two impact drivers through several rounds of fastening and drilling challenges to find out!
** NEW MERCH STORE! **
philly-fixed-merch.creator-sp...
Ryobi Subcompact Impact: homedepot.sjv.io/OR1A3Z
Ridgid Subcompact Impact: homedepot.sjv.io/b37d9g
Please LIKE, SUBSCRIBE, and RING THE BELL!
****
Please support the channel by using the following affiliate links!
Ohio Power Tool: shrsl.com/1oa9w-1h1y-k3nc
CPO Outlets Deal Zone! bit.ly/CPO-Deal-Zone
Acme Tools Deals: imp.i284638.net/Ea0Ek2
Home Depot Deal of the Day: homedepot.sjv.io/c/2799330/10...
****
FACEBOOK GROUP: groups/phillyfixed
INSTAGRAM: @PhillyFixed
TIKTOK: @PhillyFixed
*Equipment Used in this Video*
Video Camera: amzn.to/39ESa9N
Field Lapel Mic Recorder: amzn.to/3wJ373V
Tripod: amzn.to/2PPIP87
Video Lighting Kit: amzn.to/3oTQ8ZF
Voiceover Microphone: amzn.to/3cJZIde
Microphone USB Computer Interface: amzn.to/2PMShJg
Legal Stuff:
Please assume all product links are affiliate links. I may receive a small commission. If you'd like to support this channel, please use links in the video description to add items to your cart if you plan to purchase them. It won't cost you anything extra and I'll get a fraction of a penny or something!
Philly Fixed is produced by JIM DAVIS PRODUCTIONS LLC. Jim is not a professional contractor. This content shall not be construed as an instructional video and is for entertainment purposes only. Do not operate power tools without proper training, personal protective equipment, and all of the equipment manufacturer's safety measures in place. By watching this video, you agree to fully indemnify and hold harmless Jim Davis Productions from any and all claims, lawsuits, demands, causes of action, liability, loss, damage and/or injury of any kind whatsoever arising out of, in any way whatsoever, any acts, omissions, negligence, or willful misconduct on the part of Jim Davis Productions LLC, its employees, contractors or associates.

Опубликовано:

26 июн 2021

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 80

@TorqueTestChannel 3 года назад

Introducing our NEW HP line, brushless, high power, works best with our HP batteries that really communicate with HP tools and deliver the best performance. Looks up kit: does not come with any HP batteries. Every time. If you don't get dinged for that, where do you get dinged for stupid brand decisions? Milwaukee doesn't do it. They have HO but dont say basically you need it for the advertised performance, and the tools that do need it come with one (1" impacts). Bosch says you need their profactor batteries, but has enough respect for you to not sell you a worse battery with it as a kit. It's like advertising 0-60 times with wide slicks then selling the car ONLY with 195 commuter tires. Good testing Jim!

@PhillyFixed 3 года назад

A theme with TTI. And SBD is even worse for putting those pathetic 1.3's in kits with XR tools. They know it's embarassing so they don't even print the amp hour rating on the sticker. Kobalt at least sells an Ultimate Output battery in their XTR kits.

@georgedavall9449 3 года назад

Thanks for commenting and support of Jim! 👍✌🏻😁🇺🇸

@6atlantis 3 года назад

They don’t give hp batteries with the hp tools and ironically they sent me a 5ah hp battery in their dual action polisher kit, but it isn’t an hp tool. Azz backwards.

@daymianhayes2493 Год назад

They do come with HP batteries now.

@bread-gz3rl Год назад

The compact series is complete garbage but the full size HP tools come with the right batteries

@MasteringMayhem 3 года назад

It looks like you’re really enjoying making these videos…🙂✌️❤️. Great comparison. Appreciate all your work.

@ToolswithSoAlz 3 года назад

I enjoyed that video. The winner was by design from TTI. They go DIY, Apprentice and Pro with Ryobi being the DIY and Ridgid being the apprentice level. Neither would stand a chance against Milwaukee. I will say, having used Ryobi before, they don't get much better with a bigger battery. It has to be their 3.0ah high output in order to really see a difference.

@PhillyFixed 3 года назад

You mean the one they discontinued? 😅 Dumb move on their part

@ToolswithSoAlz 3 года назад

@@PhillyFixed What else would you expect? Too good and people might not buy Milwaukee.

@amerintex 3 года назад

Great video and loved the intro as always.

@PhillyFixed 3 года назад

Thanks, Phillip!

@gamingjoss4180 3 года назад

great video. full information abt tht tools ‼️ keep doing tht bro ‼️❤❤

@PhillyFixed 3 года назад

Thanks for watching and commenting!!

@tjo8673 3 года назад

Great video!

@vincentlawrence677 Год назад

Being a Ridgid guy, I have to come to Ryobi's defense. 1.5 aH v 2 aH. That's 9 more watts of power for the Ridgid. A step further... if you're going to be fair, use the HP battery on the HP tool. They are designed to work together to deliver the highest performance. Then to make it completely fair, put a Max output on the Ridgid brushless.

@PhillyFixed Год назад

I'll refer you to 2:07. Also, the subcompact tools lack the extra 2 terminal connections on the rear of the stem that provide additional communication between the tool and High Performance batteries, so the benefit of an HP battery would rely entirely on the increased current output of the cells used, which would be negligible on tools this small. Thanks for watching.

@luisriver11 3 года назад

This is a series of videos I really want to see. Hope you put the Ryobi numbers with the HP battery there too... 👍

@georgeferlazzo7936 3 года назад

Hello Jim and Philly Fix Thank you for another Great Video. I am looking forward to seeing how the rest of the drills and impact drivers rank. This is something I am going to have to replace my current Hitachi tools. All options are open. Again thank you

@PhillyFixed 3 года назад

Thanks for warchig, George!

@ToolswithSoAlz 3 года назад

I wouldn't go from Hitachi/Metabo HPT to Ryobi. That would likely be a huge downgrade.

@PhillyFixed 3 года назад

I agree with @Tools with SoAlz here. I hadn't used any Metabo HPT (Hitachi) tools prior to starting this channel. But now that I have some, they're competing with Makita for my favorite tool line. I wish the Metabo HPT line was a bit more extensive though, they don't venture out into specialty tools much. But their saws, drills, impacts and nailers are best-in-class. I think Metabo HPT for core/heavy-use tools and Ryobi for one-off/random or occasional-use tools would be a good strategy for building a collection. Hart would also be a good fit in that Ryobi slot, they seem to be aggressively expanding their line.

@p24t 3 года назад

The Ryobi looks good framed along side big words reading "THE WRONG BATTERY". Who wants to buy a tool/battery combo with the wrong batteries?

@PhillyFixed 3 года назад

TTI missed the mark on both of these kits! And shame on Ryobi for discontinuing the P195 with 21700s. I found a straggler (I assume it was an online order return) P195 at my local store and picked it up. Plan to do some tests with it.

@kentuckybeardsman 3 года назад

Yes please do the hp 2ah on the Ryobi. Would love to see what the difference would be

@Ty_7 3 года назад

that ridgid and makita, the only subcompacts i have a eyes for. I'm glad someone is finally doing subcompact versus as they are competent tools without the typical size and weight. My complaint with the ridgid is the stem that holds the battery size (its mostly plastic and could have been much smaller), m12 competition? I have octanes with much smaller stems and the new brushless also have smaller stems than the subcompacts. Thats just not right. Makita is the black rubber dream!

@dannyhamby6334 2 года назад

I just bought the Ryobi. Got it at the direct tools outlet tool only so I can get a better battery like the 2 amp or the go battery. Got a great deal on it $69 factory blem. I’ve had great luck with the factory blems and reconditioned units from direct tools. Infact I’ve got the 12 volt drill I’ve had for 5 years now and still works great same battery aswell.

@PhillyFixed 2 года назад

Yup, DTO is great. Factory Blemished really just means "we wanted to get around selling at Home Depot" 😉

@bwselectronic 3 года назад

You used the wrong battery‼️🤣🤣 It would be nice to see the difference with the HP+ battery

@varga13zsolt 3 года назад

Great test, I was checking the Ridgid at Home Depot the other day and it's really compact, but feels weird with the "huge " battery. I think would be perfect as a 12 volt in Milwaukee style.

@PhillyFixed 3 года назад

Agree, there's not much benefit when the base is wider than the body of the tool!

@geoffstrickler 3 года назад

Yes. This is Ridgid’s weak spot on the subcompact line. Yes, they’ve done as much as they can to shrink their new batteries, but there just isn’t much you can do when you have to fit in 5 cells and a bulky connector designed for your full sized, and previously bulky, 18V tools. Makita, Skil, and DeWalt all opted for 12V slide-pack batteries as their primary subcompact models, although Makita and DeWalt do offer 18V subcompact models with similar battery size issues.

@toolhead147 3 года назад

Great comparison.👍👌 what was ryobi thinking not including the hp. Probably wanted to make the kit cheaper.

@PhillyFixed 3 года назад

Exactly...

@LilasTools 3 года назад

Meatbo? Is that a new brand??! 😝😂😂😂😝 11:40 - Great Testing As Always! ❤️

@PhillyFixed 3 года назад

Hahaha ... yup, high-protein tools for all-day energy! Nice catch.

@geoffstrickler 3 года назад

Well, they clearly kitted these with the wrong battery. Pretty solid win for the Ridgid, won literally every test, including size and weight.

@pflaffik 3 года назад

If it makes people go back to the store to buy HP batteries its very profitable for Ryobi and profitable for retailers too, its clearly kitted with the right battery. Whats wrong is that its a Ryobi, it wasnt cheap to switch to Makita but it was abundantly worth it. That being said, i kept the Ryobi tools, most are good enough for most tasks (except the utterly crappy impact wrench) but i really dislike the thick handles; Ryobi is committed to not changing their batteries but i wish they did.

@RayW808 3 года назад

Yeah but does Ridgid make a $20 fan? Didn't think so... Really looking forward to the Meatbo👍

@ProxyFinal 3 года назад

Philly fixed, can you do a little short video showcasing the wobble of each subcompact driver? Try spinning a screw no load on an extended bit like 6 in.

@PhillyFixed 3 года назад

Sure! I'll get it in the queue.

@ProxyFinal 3 года назад

@@PhillyFixed I know Makita likes to advertise that their impact driver has less wobble when compared to the other competitors. Dewalt was notorious for having the worst wobble, but I think....the new impact driver from Ryobi HP line takes the cake. Something about that collet....that ejects the bit out might play a role in the wobble of the bits.

@PhillyFixed 3 года назад

@@ProxyFinal The DeWalt DCF887 has awful wobble, for sure. I'll see what the Ryobi does...

@iloveknives75 3 года назад

Lol, Meatbo is one of my favorites!!!

@PhillyFixed 3 года назад

Mmmm... meatbo

@tammyshellikoff3482 3 года назад

Can you please test the craftsman cmcf820

@PhillyFixed 3 года назад

It's not available online with Lowe's but I'll see if I can find one in store!

@tammyshellikoff3482 3 года назад

@@PhillyFixed ok the Price is 169 dollars

@Biaanca5036 3 года назад

Ohhhh impressive! 18v but only 2 pounds! It's usually only the 12v tools that end up weighing near the 2.0ths of 2 pounds And as far as dirtiness of the rubber texture goes, I cheat: I actually put protectant//dashboard-shine on my drills when I clean them up at the end of the week

@PhillyFixed 3 года назад

That's a great idea!

@elvis7094 3 года назад

Cough, cough....you used the wrong battery. Go Birds! P.s. I purchased the Metabo HPT UVP saw. That thing’s a beast. I’m not used to so much powah in my hands. Burned up two Diablo metal cutting blades while trying it out. I think I need to simmer it down. Keep up the videos.

@PhillyFixed 3 года назад

I absolutely love that green recip. And their 36V circ saw.

@pflaffik 3 года назад

I dont care much about the power, using a subcompact with a 6Ah battery would be a paradox in my book. I got the Makita brushless subcompact, using it with a light 2Ah battery, its a delight in every way.

@PhillyFixed 3 года назад

I think for those that own the XDT16 and a 2.0aH battery, there's no reason to purchase the Makita subcompact. But if you don't have an impact and need a light-duty version, the Makita is a decent choice although not one of my favorites from the brand.

@mmbodnar 3 года назад

It would be good to know which tools actually benefit from the HP Batteries I do know that not all HP tools actually need the HP battery,.. I suspect that this drill may not unless the user guide recommends it. Would have to run the test to see i guess. For some reason i find the styling of AEG tools (Rigid branded) to be too bulky and boxy (mostly the battery) for my liking and could not get into it.

@PhillyFixed 3 года назад

Agree, the Ridgid/AEG stuff is boxy.

@andrewavellino6427 3 года назад

I'm willing to bet if you slap a high performance battery on the Ryobi it would do a whole lot better. You know "You used the wrong battery!!" Lmao 🤣😂 😆

@levipankey 3 года назад

To much talking at the beginning but love your vids man keep it up!

@PhillyFixed 3 года назад

I had gotten some comments that people wanted more insight on tool features, functions, size comparison, etc. Changing it up a bit!

@levipankey 3 года назад

@@PhillyFixed I'm just giving you a hard time brother, I will watch your videos regardless. I like your style and I hope your channel continues to grow as quickly as it has been!

@SouthFLTools 3 года назад

The Ridgid kit with 1 battery is $50 more expensive than the Ryobi kit with 2 batteries, so it should outperform the Ryobi, IMO...

@matthewsquillante1590 3 года назад

Isn’t the m12 the milwakee compact option not the m18?

@PhillyFixed 3 года назад

They call the 2850 "compact brushless" ... even though it's essentially the same size as the 2854 and the M18 surge.

@matthewsquillante1590 3 года назад

@@PhillyFixed thanks for the clarification

@user-jh1mq2ih2u 3 года назад

M12 impact wrench is smaller and stronger

@plaid11 3 года назад

Great, now I have to watch Austin Powers lol

@PhillyFixed 3 года назад

You're welcome 😉

@djjd3027 3 года назад

It seems all of the Ryobi HP line comes with the wrong battery.

@PhillyFixed 3 года назад

The full size hammer drill and impact combo kit does come with HP batteries - a 4 and a 2, at least.

@DanielGomez-cf6vk 2 года назад

I went with ridgid for the LSA that ryobi was not impressed with

@PhillyFixed 2 года назад

Good choice!

@VikingOlberg-NymoenOfNorway Год назад

Hey man, you used the wrong battery

@InNerdimensional 3 года назад

That little Ridgid impact driver will beat a Makita XDT14 in removing lugnuts... But won't in driving fasteners...

@mike_t_007 2 года назад

I plan to Frankenstein this unit soon and will demo it with lug nuts and other automotive fasteners. If it's anything like the M18 Frankenstein, it'll be an amazing sub compact impact wrench too... Probably better than the Ridgid Subcompact since it has higher IPM ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-2nWztRe0yNs.html

@InNerdimensional 2 года назад

@@mike_t_007 the Ridgid might still beat the gen 3 at harder fasteners like lugs

@mike_t_007 2 года назад

@@InNerdimensional Nice!! I have the M18 Frankenstein now and will test them both side by side when the Ridgid and anvil arrive in the mail soon. Still trying to decide if I should make it a 3/8" or 1/2" like the M18

@georgedavall9449 3 года назад

👍👍👍👍👍👍👏🏻😁✌🏻🙏🇺🇸

@KosmicHRTRacingTeam Год назад

Great video to test the AS IS tool kit, but really limited and disappointed that you didn’t take the extra time to throw the other battery on it to truly test it against the ridgid. In other words, it’s kind of a crappy video if one wants to know the true capacity of the actual tool, which seems to be the point of the video (according to the title). Maybe it should say “cheaper Ryobi kit vs Ridgid kit”. Just kinda wasted my time expecting to see the capabilities of the actual tool. Just saying.

@betods1013 3 года назад

Its the correct battery. I'm tired of these videos (not yours) trying to get all the tools to have the exact same battery config - voltage, size, cell count, color, build factory, same 12-year-old to put it together, yada yada yada. Those two batteries are roughly the same. .5 AH will not make a difference. And if you were to use an HP battery, you would have to use the MaxOutput for the Ridgid. Or........the tools should be tested in their bestest, badest, beastliest configuration. Have each tool manufacturer use their best battery available. Basically, I'm tired of all the battery talk. Is the tool good: yes/no. That's all that matters. :) Rant over.