Тёмный

Russia and Ukraine: What Does Putin Want? 

Columbia SIPA
Подписаться 29 тыс.
Просмотров 11 тыс.
50% 1

Опубликовано:

 

27 авг 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 38   
@adrienpartier7207
@adrienpartier7207 2 года назад
1:10:08 "There really isn't anything like [Russia's actions against Ukraine] in post-WWII history", then goes on to cite Soviet invasions of Hungary, Czechoslovakia and Afghanistan as other examples of the "evil empire's" wars of aggression against neighboring countries. On the other hand, US covert operations, economic strangulation or military interventions in its own sphere of influence, against such countries as Guatemala, Cuba, the Dominican Republic, Haiti, Chile, Nicaragua, El Salvador, Grenada, Panama, Venezuela or Honduras, as late as 2009, really don't come to mind. There still is a level of wishful ignorance, or actual deceitfulness, in US foreign policy circles to which this fellow belong regarding US imperialism and the role of the US in the Cold War that is astonishing.
@brendanbeirne2
@brendanbeirne2 2 года назад
Remarkably little on 'what Putin wants' here. The realist perspective is completely missing; instead we get a lot of speculation about Putin's psychology. Hopefully this crisis can be resolved with a neutral Ukraine sans NATO and the West's misguided belief in liberal hegemony can be put on the shelf for a while.
@wc4154
@wc4154 2 года назад
A hypothesis is rarely proposed with the expectation of achieving answers but rather invites speculation to encourage discussion. I think the devil is in the details with any lecture/discussion on this topic but that question was eventually addressed directly at 1:44:18.
@simoncolombo6640
@simoncolombo6640 2 года назад
You surely are not a liberal, denying the Ukrainians the right to choose their own future.
@brendanbeirne2
@brendanbeirne2 2 года назад
@@simoncolombo6640 no that’s reality doing the denying. Their choice is costing them lives and territory. Blaming Putin doesn’t change the outcome. Neutrality would have been far preferable to this.
@simoncolombo6640
@simoncolombo6640 2 года назад
@@brendanbeirne2 As a Finn I can tell you that we got neutrality because we fought the Russians/USSR. And still Putin talks about reversing the mistake Lenin did (like with Ukraine) in granting Finland its independence. That is, what you are avoiding is the other reality of Russian imperialism. Putin has always been imperialist and so is the narrative that Russians tell themselves about their country. Neutrality did not help Ukrainians (=they are not in NATO), because Putin explicitly said that they could not tolerate a pro-European leader in Ukraine. That is, NATO refused Ukraine's entry into NATO but that was not enough for Putin. That is why, even if I supported Finnish neutrality before this crisis, I am for NATO membership now, because Putin deleted the concept of a neutral buffer state by invading Ukraine. When you live next to Russia freedom does not come for free.
@brendanbeirne2
@brendanbeirne2 2 года назад
“Putin has always been imperialist” - Putin’s near abroad adventures in Georgia, Crimea and Ukraine have been direct responses to NATO expansionism. US imperialism = unprovoked invasions / occupations / attacks on Iraq, Yemen, Libya, Syria, Vietnam, Somalia, Afghanistan to name just a few… “Neutrality did not help Ukrainians (=they are not in NATO)” Ukraine was never neutral. It was a defacto NATO state since at least 2014. Russia’s demand to formalize the commitment that Baker / Bush made to Shevardnaze / Gorbachev was simply an effort to clarify the existing consensus, i.e. that Ukraine membership would constitute a threat to Russia’s legitimate security concerns. “NATO refused Ukraine's entry into NATO but that was not enough for Putin.” This is false. The West has held out the prospect of NATO membership to Ukraine - see Zelensky’s recent comments to that effect.
@patrickmcdonough412
@patrickmcdonough412 Год назад
If the world just let's this go we would have to apologize for all those who sought justice in the Nerenberg trials.
@woodwage7988
@woodwage7988 2 года назад
I watched another show where someone said "The West play's by the rules while Putain play's with the rules ".. what l see is , the West play's with the rules against it's own people but not aginst strong foreign powers..Look at Canada..but all over "Democracy's "..people are really tired of being run around in circles while just a few are becoming filthy rich..of course we must defend Ukraine but..afterwards let's be alittle more fair with our own people.."Democracy " will go over alot more believable..anyway..bisous a tous..
@davidhughes4728
@davidhughes4728 2 года назад
I hate War I hate to see countries go to war no one wins under American and I love all people
@jacquelinejackson4067
@jacquelinejackson4067 2 года назад
Thank you for providing this information.
@Klopp2543
@Klopp2543 2 года назад
How comes putin/Russia have no problem rather they helped facilitate Baltic states in joining NATO. Why is their red line only Georgia and Ukraine?
@thbr1175
@thbr1175 2 года назад
so boring and main stream, same old stupid arguments
@jakelamb4096
@jakelamb4096 2 года назад
I asked RU-vid,”Putin Ukraine lecture”. I’m a historian so I hope this is based on research rather than opinion. Really looking forward to hearing and really hoping…Thanks either way!
@patrickmcdonough412
@patrickmcdonough412 Год назад
Well this mystery is somehow tied to China and Taiwan.
@joeshmo8626
@joeshmo8626 2 года назад
Former Ambassador 🔊 not Khruchev nor Gorbachev
@jakelamb4096
@jakelamb4096 2 года назад
👍
@joeshmo8626
@joeshmo8626 2 года назад
🦆for ✌Crimea ✌ 45 45 45 45 45
@10thejgm78
@10thejgm78 2 года назад
Send in the USS Milk....
@n2cat
@n2cat 2 года назад
PROFESSOR OF WHAT? 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
@joeshmo8626
@joeshmo8626 2 года назад
93yrs💥 Lenin 💥Lenin 💥Lenin poo🐜STRONG Milita🥀 Coup 💕91Gorbachev ⚘🇷🇺new new new new 🇰🇭new
@janis4847
@janis4847 2 года назад
Well this aged like milk.
@davidhughes4728
@davidhughes4728 2 года назад
🐻🇱🇷♥️
@joeshmo8626
@joeshmo8626 2 года назад
Elections elect vote 🦆 (+none of et, 💕)= 45 45 45 45 = it's it's = uuuu
@joeshmo8626
@joeshmo8626 2 года назад
🦆✌👖+✌👡+✌💰+✌🗝🔑+✌building +✌☕+✌Son Tay Son 17yrs 💥47yrs kissingirl 30yrs💥💥 43yrs
@joeshmo8626
@joeshmo8626 2 года назад
uuu 🔊😈 UUUU
@patmccaffery1543
@patmccaffery1543 2 года назад
ZZZZZZZzzzzzzzzz..!!
Далее
А ВЫ УМЕЕТЕ ПЛАВАТЬ?? #shorts
00:21
Просмотров 1,5 млн
Putin's War on Ukraine: The Costs Of Invasion
1:27:22
Просмотров 27 тыс.
A History of Eastern Europe: Ukraine-Russia Crisis
31:54