Scene Analysis: The Day Captain Janeway Defeated Fear

Подписаться 122 тыс.

Просмотров 23 тыс.

50% 1

This is a scene Analysis, I hope you enjoy!!!
================================================
Want More Lore?!
Star Trek Lore: goo.gl/McF2i5
Star Wars Lore: goo.gl/Hzyrk2
Battle Star Galactica Lore: goo.gl/jpPPUY
Star Trek Dominion War: goo.gl/fmwtPf
================================================
Twitter: / lorereloaded
Facebook: / lorereloaded
Twitch: / lorereloaded
Patreon: / lorereloaded
================================================
Come Hang out while I play..
Mixer: goo.gl/YhgNiE
Twitch: goo.gl/kiVw8w
===============================================
Citations! These are my most often used resources:
Memory Alpha: memory-alpha.wi...
Trekyards: / knightstalker666
Spacedock: / @spacedock
Ex Astria Scientia - www.ex-astris-s...
================================================
The music in this video is licensed Royalty Free.
Songs:
Music by:
© 2017 Epidemic Sound

Опубликовано:

29 сен 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 186

@FortoFight 4 года назад

I love that holographic Janeway chose to keep trolling him after they'd already won.

@sh4d0wfl4re 4 года назад

It is very much what Janeway would have done if it were herself there in person. The hologram truly was a fine representation of who Janeway is

@King_George_VI 4 года назад

‘Starfleet captains don’t easily succumb to fear’. That’s the mic drop moment

@mrspidey80 4 года назад

Good old Kobayashi Maru training

@chrism3845 4 года назад

Absolutely !!

@starblade8450 4 года назад

One thing I loved about this episode was how Fear responded to new people, or people outside of his power. He's a bit kooky, and to those he feels will be in his power he's confident, almost Q levels of cockiness. But to the Doctor, and Holo-Janeway upon learning her real nature, his demeanor instantly changes. To the Doctor he's annoyed, partially cause the Doctor is more or less (at the time) his opposite. Reasonable, not willing to kill, and is focused on saving others. He finds him a party pooper naturally. But with Holo-Janeway, who more or less tricked him, he's afraid. He knows the end has come and will show him as much mercy as he'd shown those he killed. His own fears have become reality. And embodied by Holo-Janeway.

@whyaddnamehere 4 года назад

I love this episode. It made me like Janeway even more.

@drakejohnson5386 4 года назад

What episode is it?

@AngelaRyanXX 4 года назад

@@drakejohnson5386 The Thaw, Season 2

@michaelcarney6280 4 года назад

Janeway is kind of a love hate relationship for me one minute she's the epitome of a Starfleet captain the next time she's a megalomaniac despot

@igl0031 3 года назад

Finally got to this episode and I have to say, it is easily one of my favorite eps in all of Trek. The acting, the concept of the clown and of course this scene are all some of the best in classic Trek

@catchthewind8563 2 года назад

The random pause after the crescendoing digression was hilarious 🤣

@Mate397 4 года назад

I liked this episode, just the way they had to deal with a manifestation of fear was great.

@Maya-bu2rf 2 года назад

This episode scared the crap out of me. I am sensitive, and the chaotic parts upset me. I am ok with the scenes on the ship with them discussing fear and why people do things that create fear. I definitely love this final scene. That deadly whisper! Even fear starts to get it when he says what will happen to us, and changes it to me. Some decent psychology going on.

@Starbat88 4 года назад

Voyager may have had a limited budget, but the people who made this episode really knew how to make the best of their craft. :D

@uhthin 4 года назад

I very much would like more of these screen break downs

@jamoecw 4 года назад

'note the shadow across half the face, with the other half illuminated.' said as her face was fully illuminated from the front.

@DoomFan2010 4 года назад

I only watched this episode once and I didn't really have an appreciation for it back then, but I certainly do now.

@thomasdownes9863 4 года назад

I kind of passed on this episode before now, the start of the episode kinda put me off because it looked goofy but I might have to rewatch it

@khartog01 4 года назад

"I shall know no fear for I am fear incarnate!" Caption Janeway

@slothboy1501 4 года назад

Is that Michael McKean?

@nickimontie 4 года назад

Yes, inspired casting!

@TheRyujinLP 4 года назад

See progressives? See?! This! This! Is how you make a female lead look powerful! It's not that we don't like female leads, we just don't like shitty characters regardless of their gender. I also love the fact that character with power is female and the bad guy is a male but at no point is that relevant. It's almost like fear was caste as a male just because a male actor auditioned for the part and gave the best performance, almost unbelievable right? Can you imagine if this was Discovery or Picard?

@Qardo 4 года назад

One hand. I did not like this episode. Though at the same time. Have to agree. The message was clear. Fear only has power over a person. When the person fears Fear.

@Medicranger 4 года назад

Not holographic. It’s a simulation running in a computer.

@brokeneyes6615 4 года назад

“I’m afraid” “I know...” “...Drat”

@kevinskoien6165 3 года назад

I always thought he said "Dread."

@Logarithm906 3 года назад

It's the way she whispers it too. She knows she's the most dangerous thing there and that Fear is hanging on her every word, so she displays that power by whispering and forcing him to listen very carefully, only for her words to offer no respite, no peace, only inevitability. It's a very good power move.

@xanderguldie 4 года назад

I thought this was a great episode. The kind of thing I'd like to see in star trek. It's not always about looking cool and blowing things up.

@mbntr2363 4 года назад

Xander Guldie yup, the episode was really good

@AngelaRyanXX 4 года назад

@@mbntr2363 One of the best.

@sergeantassassin3425 4 года назад

Honestly, the fact that she kept constant, unending authority through the entire damn scene is brilliant acting by Mulgrew. Never once giving Fear a single damn thing, and taking everything instead. Then throwing that brilliant one-liner at the end: "...I'm afraid." "...I know~"

@zacharythompson7911 4 года назад

We have to give credit to McKean too, actors don't work in vacuums. for a guy known for being a great comedy actor, he pulled off psychotic scary very well.

@phillippi2 4 года назад

There are quite a few links between humor and fear. It is often said that horror is comedy minus the humor

@teshtishtoshtesh3218 4 месяца назад

I've read it argued that he's the greatest pick for the role of Batman's Joker that never actually played the part... and this is a fine substitute role.

@hifiandrew 3 месяца назад

Michael McKean was absolutely extraordinary as Charles MacGill in Better Call Saul. Brilliant actor.

@ChrisParlett 4 года назад

I never understood the dislike of Janeway.

@cajundude62a 4 года назад

Same here! She is a straight up bad ass!

@scaper8 4 года назад

More than anything, it's the inconsistencies in her (and, indeed, all of _Voyager's,_ but even more so her) writing. Mulgrew herself has said how much it bothered her, and her own headcanon is that Janeway had some sort of bipolar disorder or something similar. When _Voyager_ was good, it was great. It just had so much just okay or down right bad in between, and so much uninspired and/or inconsistent writing, that it's just not as well remembered on the whole.

@timothydoyle9635 4 года назад

@@scaper8 This. Janeway can go from stricter than Picard, to looser than Sisko with the rules. Voyager as a whole suffers from this. The writing is inconsistent, and characters never fully develop. It shows in the actors performances as well. Basically everyone on the cast outside Tim Russ, Jeri Ryan, and Robert Picardo have devolved into phoning in their lines for the last couple seasons. As for dislike of Janeway(Not Mulgrew, she can act as seen in this episode and others, but you gotta work with the script you're given), and Voyager as a while its more of the missed potential angers people more than the quality it self. The show has some very good episodes, but they are the exception rather than the rule. During my yearly rewatch of the Trek shows, Voyager has more skipped episodes than the other series.

@MonCappy 4 года назад

It's because she is the worst written captain in Star Trek. Not because her character is bad, but because she was written so inconsistently throughout the series. Out of all iterations of Star Trek, Voyager had the most inconsistent writing in terms of quality. This badly affected Janeway's character arc as a result. Frankly, I think Kate Mulgrew should be celebrated for making the most of what she was given to work with. She was absolutely brilliant at her portrayal. A lesser actress would've failed where she succeeded. Overall, I liked Janeway as a character, but looking back on Voyager, I feel like the series was ultimately a failure. It could've been great with better writing and if the writers didn't play it safe.

@Maya-bu2rf 2 года назад

@@timothydoyle9635 Voyager is the only ST series I watch. Kirk was a whore, Picard a bit emotionless ( I do like Patrick Stewart). No opinion on the others because I could never get into the series. The new Picard is too dark for me

@Betterthenme 4 года назад

You can say allot about Janeway but she was one of the most badass captains in star trek

@usernamunavailiable 4 года назад

Honestly I think she is the best. I also like how they never made her into a Mary Sue. They made her into a honestly developed character.

@kilowolf5488 4 года назад

She is and likely will remain my favorite Star Trek captain of all time.

@kevinasman1036 4 года назад

When Janeway gets angry she is genuinely terrifying

@Darlf_Sevil 5 месяцев назад

@@kevinasman1036if at the same day she lose all coffe and fight aginst borg... They dont even know how clous from not exsisting they be

@krzosu 4 года назад

The one of the last lines delivered by Janeway "I know" - That was great line delivery in that episode :) So ominious :D Sheer power behind those two simple words was amazing :)

@TexasAnlaShok 4 года назад

And it all comes down to that last whispered line from Janeway: "I know." That is chilling.

@mbntr2363 4 года назад

r/unpopularopinion janeway is one of my favourite captains, with Sisko, Picard and Kirk

@AndDiracisHisProphet 4 года назад

lol :D

@p.j.w7564 4 года назад

Janeway getting all up in Fear's face, 👍🏻

@999benhonda 4 года назад

I liked voyager, sure it had some not-so-great episodes and there were things that could have made the series better, but it had some damn good episodes as well. This episode is one of the very best, very TOS in theme, with the captain saving the day and being a bad ass in the end!

@kurtengel4652 4 года назад

This was a cool episode, it felt like it could've been a plot in The Original Series, but also with a Voyager twist to it

@vovacat1797 4 года назад

The moment Janeway took it in her own hands, I knew that this fear guy was sooo screwed up. Badass.

@WolfHeroEX 4 года назад

So after the room backdrop went black, I noticed that it wasn't just the camera that was aligned with Janeway, but it's as if Fear had shrunken slightly, they appeared to be on the same level physically, their heads parallel. ... Yeah, maybe she was on the step and that's why that happened. Maybe she stood on her toes, or maybe Fear actually shrank because his power over the situation had dwindled. The only reason I even noticed was that you pointed out before that he was taller than her before. I gotta pay more attention to this stuff.

@ZontarDow 4 года назад

There is nothing to fear, except fear itself... wait...

@kilowolf5488 4 года назад

To be fair, I don't think anyone ever accused Mulgrew of being a bad actress. She was always very good. I think most people had/have and issue with her because she is not a cookie cutter "holier than thou" captain that everyone seems to want.

@shaftoe195 4 года назад

There is a mistake in the video title. Janeway defeats fear on a regular basis - it's her job. But on that day, _she intimidated and utterly destroyed fear._

@TrensGemini 4 года назад

You may not love Voyager as a show, but you must admit that a scene like this is marvelous. And when the rant began at the end before "Technical difficulties" one meme pop up in my mind "I see no god up here, other than me."

@BreadApologist Год назад

Iirc it ends with janeway going super saiyan 2 and destroying fear with tuvoks signature attack, galick gun

@lancer525 3 года назад

Who needs Chuck Norris when you have Kathryn Janeway? When the Boogieman goes to bed, he checks under it for Captain Janeway...

@tassadro 4 года назад

this is one of the best moments in star trek. the point where janeway did a "gotcha!" moment

@BioGoji-zm5ph 4 года назад

08:40 Actually, note that because no part of the actors are visible in that shot except for the mirror, it is most likely a redressed part of the set to make it look like a mirror, or a result of digital editing techniques in post-production. Feel free to correct me if I'm wrong, though.

@BioGoji-zm5ph 4 года назад

In regards to your points about camera angles, Lore, I think it would be really interesting to see an episode of a Trek series, any series, that is viewed entirely through the angles of security cameras on a ship, as if the entire episode were a collection of recordings from different parts of the ship, similar to experimental episodes of other TV shows that have one stationary camera in a single environment for the entire episode, only sort of opposite, yet achieving the similar result of having a different perspective than what is normally shown.

@sebiloard 3 года назад

Also the moment she enters the stage the music changes from happy carnival music to danger music and its not janeway who is in danger xD

@TheStapleGunKid 4 года назад

This was one of my favorite ST episodes out of all the franchises. Fear is like the Star Trek version of the Joker. Such a shame he could only get one episode.

@alexb6234 4 года назад

Yes please make as many of these as possible! I think this (and many other scenes with Janeway) show that while some might not like the writing of the show, you can't question Kate Mulgrew's ability as an actoress.

@techstepman 4 года назад

9:58 that is not feminism. Thats just a person with a strong character = starfleet captain.

@woogha 4 года назад

I literally just finished watching this episode.

@uhthin 4 года назад

Well done sir!

@uhthin 4 года назад

I normally skip this one on rewatches. I've clearly been doing it wrong

@Dustballguy 4 года назад

Dude, great video. Thank you

@captainrgd1565 4 года назад

God, I love Janeway's voice!

@Radintoriov 4 года назад

I am genuinely loving these scene analysis videos. And the obligatory jabs at Berman. :v

@hiddentrailvideo6992 4 года назад

And she didn’t even have to call Saul.

@jasonclark2590 4 года назад

Hidden Trail Video lmao

@KingOfLesbia 4 года назад

So this is how chuck became tinfoiling wearing electricity fearing little troll lol

@firebird6522 4 года назад

I thought this was Voyager's best episode, IMO.

@KatrinaLeFaye 4 года назад

Thank you for this work and please continue breakdowns. Always hit as soon as I see notified on these.

@Marchand848 4 года назад

Favourite scene. Made the series for me. I would have followed Janeway in a heart beat.

@nowlwane9623 4 года назад

Janeway: I know

@ericb6309 3 года назад

Thank you so much for this analysis. On just the surface level, usually I would assume going in that I would have hated this episode. A clown? Ruminating about human emotions for a whole hour? SOUNDS AWFUL! Normally the kind of episode I would have hated. But this was beautifully written, performed, and filmed. And Ms. Janeway could be a complete badass when the occasion called for it. I would have submitted a job application to her!!! And the camera guys probably had to battle drinking problems. Trust me, I know things. But hey, at least we don’t have it as bad as the audio guys, right??!!

@aperioculus1988 4 года назад

I like this one, but I prefer the story of Coda.

@Safer7Sephiroth 4 года назад

They say the next episode (Tuvix) is where the Voyager crew is proven evil, but this episode is just as bad, if not worse. "Fear" in this episode is clearly a new life form. It doesn't want to die. Any other Trek Series would have explored that. Not on Voyager. NOPE! They taunt a dying being.

@Nesseight 4 года назад

Janeway is a true "strong female" character. If Alex Kurtzman, Rian Johnson or Dan Weiss and Dave Benioff directed this, Fear would have died 5 seconds after he was introduced by falling off of a platform with a Wilhelm scream, then for the duration of the episode Janeway would lecture Ensign Kim (who is now non-binary) about how she is in charge of all the men because she is better than them.

@Dabhach1 11 месяцев назад

The great weakness of this episode, I've always thought, is that holo-Janeway is such a perfect representation of the real one. We've always been told that creating a convincing holo-character took weeks, or even months, not hours. Other than that, great episode.

@999benhonda 4 года назад

Starfleet Captians don't easily succumb....to fear.

@christenorio9555 4 года назад

I got a new thoary Voyager is a prison ship lying to her Crew by recreation the speech of chakotyi of (Shattered (episode) aka cheated &after endgames Janeway is Lost after with the Klingon time device uses time stones of discovery!

@EricMadWolf 4 года назад

The amount of chill that ending brings could freeze hell over.

@exposingproxystalkingorgan4164 4 года назад

This is an excellent analogy of the psychology of fear.

@lordofsparks 4 года назад

Excellent analysis! Although for all the good stuff it is a little undercut by Fear's character design being a lazy reuse of DS9's off brand klingons...

@kenjett2434 4 года назад

I had too see this a second time to understand and appreciate what was really being portrayed in this episode. The first time I really didn't get the whole picture and ended up smh and wondering wth. I am glad I watched it a second time it really is a powerful and human story just what we as fans love most about Star Trek. This episode was some of the best writing of the series as it made you think.

@whoshotdk 4 года назад

So *thats* what Captain Disillusion did before going onto RU-vid!

@RandomGuy33369 4 года назад

This is the first of your videos I've watched... You gained a subscriber

@ryavix 4 года назад

Honestly until this evaluation I all ways hated this episode, feeling that it was overly mellow dramatic.

@garyrichards6079 4 года назад

My all time favourite ST VOY episode ... thx

@ViroVV 4 года назад

OK, Ill toss a few coins at the lore master for a bit to see how these kinds of videos do. Personally always hated the episode but the analysis here does show how good the episode really was. Just for different reasons

@GoblinModeKnives 2 года назад

This was the episode that sold me on finishing voyager, for better or for worse lol.

@salc8016 4 года назад

Is this ending the prelude to the end game... January sacrifice herself In a fake out

@BlueSideUp77 3 года назад

And this is why you graduated Full Sail. :) Nice analysis!

@candyman19891 4 года назад

Can someone link me an article to the whole cameraman situation. Can't really find anything about it.

@thejohanvalli 3 года назад

One of the greatest analysis on this channel, which is full of them, good analysis!

@davidjones3165 3 года назад

Voyager gets a lot if crap most of it deserved but they do some episodes really well, this is one of those.

@cambriaofthevastoceans6721 4 года назад

Did Fallout steal the idea for serenity lane from star trek, or did they both borrow it from somewhere else?

@kaleotter 2 года назад

"You might not have noticed... but your brain did"

@wangbot47 4 года назад

Easily top 10 episode of Voyager. Maybe top 5

@usprulse 3 года назад

janeway is still waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaay better then micheal burnham...

@christenorio9555 4 года назад

It suck there is no 4k remastered for the startrek series franchise on CBS all-access!

@spacepiratecaptainrush1237 4 года назад

I'm impressed and frustrated by this, because I wanted more of this Janeway.

@gregthwuen 4 года назад

The lighting in this set reminded me of TOS! Really miss that look.

@stevenschiro1838 9 месяцев назад

The score is so good too. Great breakdown of the scene

@Maya-bu2rf Год назад

Left out the best ending in a Star Trek episode.

@tzisorey 4 года назад

Loved that episode. Never expected I'd feel sorry for fear.

@TheAnanaki 2 года назад

This episode gets so much hate and idk why.

@PublicLeeSpeaking 4 года назад

Voyager's writing is a dumpster fire and Janeway is a despicable hypocrite that's an insult to the uniform, but the cinematography of Voyager is almost always great.

@Numba003 4 года назад

This is an excellent analysis. This is one of my favorite episodes of Voyager, particularly because it’s so psychological in its themes like much of the best Trek often is. Stay well out there everybody, and Jesus Christ be with you friends.😊

@AndDiracisHisProphet 4 года назад

Is this what we call it now? Nostalgia Trek?

@philiphockenbury6563 4 года назад

Did she just intimidate the personification of fear itself to death? Badass!

@MICKEYrenraw 4 года назад

yes, yes please :)

@savagebear4374 4 года назад

Fear: I'm afraid Janeway: I know Fear: Drat

@dashfatbastard 4 года назад

If you appreciate dramatic lighting, check out Matt Decker vs the Planet Killer in The Doomsday Machine. When you consider how quick, cheap, and dirty they had to work. I don't think I've given this a second look since it's original broadcast. Michael McKean is an ill improv god at whose church I regularly worship, but it occurs to me this scene might play well if he were replaced with Gilbert Gottfried ;) Very well done, sir!

@Blasted2Oblivion 2 года назад

"Fear is the most honest of all emotions." I find that statement to be objectively wrong. I can't count the number of times fear has lead to a misunderstanding or mistake just in my own life.

@joshscott5213 2 года назад

Fear never lies, only distorts and blurs one's vision like trying to look in pitch darkness. Fear is honest because fear makes you look inward. only seeing yourself or what you fear to lose from your side. Did the darkness in a room lie to you when you didn't see the object you ran into or did the loud sound lie to you when you misheard someone because of it? No they didn't, fear is a very primal prospective, if only one prospective guide one's actions they will be blind to everything else around them. Humans have the ability to look through several different lenses at the same time that's one things that makes humanity special. That's just my opinion of fear sorry for it being so long.