Siblings with more talent than the star… 

Thank you for choosing Finneas. He deserves more recognition that he has. Plus, as you said, he's so involved in her music that it feels right to choose him!

Noah Cyrus has a pretty discography. It’s not for everyone but still it’s very impressive. It’s kinda sad how she isn’t recognised as an artist. Her songs are mostly sad songs and I feel like she always sings them with lots of emotion, I really feel it when I listen to her songs

Britney's "Everytime" is beautiful. It was the song that got me to give more of her music a chance. It's so simple and considering all that's she's gone through the lyrics are just heartbreaking.

Britney always wins, hands down. The only advantage Jamie Lyyn has is she was allowed to sing in her actual voice

I believe the reason Miley went full on "leaning into sexiness" has a very calculated logic- she saw what Disney did to Brittany Spears. Disney also wanted her to stay the sweet innocent little girl- even with all Spears' sexy songs, they still made her hold a "little girl" persona. Miley went as far as she could to make sure Disney would disown her forever. I really can't blame her.

I love Noah Cyrus's song July. The only one I know lol, but it's great, and very vulnerable lyrics. I'm usually not that into chill songs or care much about lyrics necessarily, but this one catches my attention. Her voice is very similar to Miley, can definitely tell they're related. She seems to have a different vibe though.

Finneas also helped may Billie successful with his songs and production so I agree that he is underappreciated.

Miley runs on the treadmill to prep for her moves and voice too. It really is a great thing to do for high performance levels

The thing about the Andy Gibb song is that it features the Bee Gees on (very loud) background vocals, so it's hard to judge. In any case, my favourite Bee Gee voice is Robin's. The pain when he sings songs like "I Started a Joke" or "I've Gotta Get a Message to You" is gloriously heartbreaking.

Andy Gibb, what a voice. He was a teenager heartthrob in 70s (alongside David Cassidy and Leif Garrett and many others. Teen music was very good back then). So sad he passed away so young 😢 btw his songs were written and produced by Barry so, it's a win win situation there 😅

Okay in Traces defense, he started Metro Station with Mason Musso. If that name sounds vaguely familiar it's because that's Mitchel Musso's brother and he met Trace on the set of Hannah Montana. Also put out stuff under Ashland High when Metro Station was on hiatus, had a really The Ready Set type vibe to it that you can kind of hear in parts of the one that's played for him. I'm not saying he's a great artist or anything but the story behind Metro Station is just a kinda cool story imo.

Thank you for remembering the Brothers Gibb....Barry, the oldest is the last one left. He is an amazing singer, huge song writer and producer.

I've never heard of Noah Cyrus, and can I just say I'm in love with that song! Reminds me of a dark Kate Bush, the song itself is so melodic and emotional, gonna be replayed for many many times. Thanks for this! 🧡

Did he really just call Julian Lennon, John Lennon's brother??? 😂

Fun fact: Some kpop idols do train on a treadmill as well and sing their heart out while doing it. Having stamina while dancing and singing is important I guess it does really help in figuring out how to control the voice and breathing while moving like crazy.

Janet Jackson is amazingly talented, but the competition just isn't fair

I love Joel talking about MJ's control over his body cause Joel clearly has no control of his body

Monday left me broken.

Fun fact: Noah Cyrus is also the english voice actress for Ponyo

No way to choose between MJ and Janet!! They both amazing, even Michael admits this on interviews. They are equally amazing, reason JANET still rocks her concerts and maintains her fan base.

Noah Cyrus's collab with Demi was EPIC! Her voice come through so much better than in this song

i love joel because he's so real. i dont know how to explain it. like, he does not comment on solely music - he notices normal stuff, like miley's teeth, and it makes him so real? it just makes him a person?😭

I'd like to hear a full cover of Joel singing Champagne Supernova. That'd be thing ever.

Interesting that even with different mothers, Julien and Sean definitely have some similarity in singing voice with their father.

Level 1: Jackson Level 2: Cyrus Level 3: Bad guys Level 4: Knowles Level 5: Jonas Level 6: Bee Gees Level 7: Spears Level 8: Lennon Level 9: Simpson Level 10: Gallagher

Finneas is so underrated, I'm grateful he was given more appreciation in this video. But I love both of them, Finneas & Billie❤

Am I the only one who's in love with Solange's music? Hers is one of the few albums that I've been listening to for years and I never get tired of it. I'm surprised she gets so little credit here, she's an amazing musician!

Noah Cyrus's most recent album I actually really enjoyed, more so than Miley's. The folk/country direction suited Noah's voice very well, the production was full, and there are some really great highlights.

Thank you for giving recognition to Bruno Mars! He is probably one of the most underrated singers who is actually really great. And yes, Finneas does help Billie so much, he is most of the reason she is what she is today, this man is so so underapprecated

Joel always admires great performers/dancers like MJ- I’d love to see Joel attempt that level of awesome moves if he ever goes on tour, although I think I can imagine how that would go after the iconic dances vid 😂

I couldn't stop smiling every time Joel randomly threw in some singing here and there in his videos 😊

I honestly love the Joel commentary. Filling in with his music theory knowledge and honest thoughts is so refreshing 👍🏻

For a Michael and Janet dance comparison, you should watch Scream. They're both amazing in it and there's a dance break where they're exactly synchronized but still with their own style.

Joel : "Welcome back to another Friday video!" Me : BRO ITS SATURDAYYY

Not obviously through yet, 6:45, but Finneas's voice is actually super cool, never heard him😁

Me: oooh my favorite Britney Spears song! Joel: “might be one of her least bangin’ songs…”

"I get it, I don't love this vibe" 😂😂😂 "Soloange, so long and goodbye" 😂😂😂

Andy Gibb died due to a heart condition that was attributed to years of drug use throughout the late 70s and early 80s. He was 30 when he died in 1988. Also should note Barry Gibb wrote most of Andy Gibbs songs including Shadow Dancing

Everytime has powerful lyrics, it has more substance than circus for example.

Great video 😊 your reaction to Ashlee and Jessica being sisters was the best, the sheer surprise and laughter was hilarious! 🤣 I feel like Trace Cyrus got done dirty though, your researcher should’ve gone with Metro Station Shake It instead cause it’s such a BOP! 💃🏻

Since I was a teen in the 80s, I can still remember the time before Thriller and the video, when Michael Jackson really was the King of Pop. Even when I didn't listen to his music, really.

I went through both a Michael Jackson and Janet Jackson Phase. So much great music from both. I have to agree, that Bruno Mars is one of those artist who will be considered legendary in the future. I also think The Weeknd will reach that status as well.

Jermaine Jackson also should've been in the video. I think he's actually a really talented musician.

If you do another video with this premise in the future I recommend including the sibling pair of Taka, the front man of One Ok Rock and Hiro, the front man of My First Story. They have the same vocal training and their accents when singing in English are also p much the same but the genres they perform are slightly different so how they employ their technical skill differs a lot and I think it’d be really interesting to see someone’s POV on it who isn’t already familiar with one of their works.

Anyone else find it fantastic whenever Joel says "what". I love his style of saying that word. I've started quoting it

Loving the Andy Gibb appreciation!!!!

ive never listened to Finneas and i really love billies music but I completely understand and agree with your decision to choose him over her. Being talented has so many factors and i think he has so much talent that get overshadowed .

Heath Ledger and Andy Gibb looked a lot alike. Both of their careers were exploding when drug abuse ultimately led to their deaths at such a young age. Andy had just celebrated his 30th birthday five days before he passed away and Heath died three months before he turned 29. So sad.

Lots of random Joel singing thrown into this one ❤. That makes my heart happy.

Billie’s brother writes all of her songs. They are a power duo!!

I didn't realize there were so many Cyruses. Cyrusi?

The Swedish Producers whose confusion for "sex on the beach" made a genius bop of a song. ❤ 🍰🌊

If there's a part two of this, a comparison of David and Shaun Cassidy could be interesting.

So glad Joel is back with these videos.

I didn't know about some of those siblings, really enjoyed this video 😊 What a treat, Joel singing parts of those songs! 🙂 I hope Bruno Mars won't quit touring before I get to see him live somewhere 😅

I’m one of them who’s team Noah Cyrus all day.. she is absolutely breathtaking when she sings, and her songs are beautiful 🖤 It annoys me how many people don’t know she exist

I'd never heard Billie' brother. That song was lovely

I’m honestly so sick of listening to Miley’s song flowers

Happy to see you being yourself. Putting on a persona can be tiring, that's why actors fall into depression as was the case with Jim Carrey. Just be you :)

Why all the $ex appeal in modern music? Its becoming quite annoying, and is a testimony to the fact, that some music is becoming so generic that records can't get people to listen for the musics sake, but need to spice it up in artificial way. Music videos used to be support to the music and now it's almost reverse, more to distraction and just to fill some pockets. Sad😢

Liam had a very distinctive, oddly pleasant and resonant tone, but if you hear them live Noel's singing is better almost everytime.

The Jamie Lynn Spears video is 99% professional Nashville writers and musicians. Those guys/gals are pros when it comes to songwriting and recording.

Dude, u might like Andy Gibbs’ song, but his brother Barry’s voice & singing capabilities were technically superior. All Gibbs bros could sing, it’s the way they harmonized effortlessly that made them great.

What a great way to start the day with a new video from RoomieOfficial ☺️

Friday video is Saturday this week but I'm here for it!

Not siblings, but the real test is choosing between Tim and Jeff Buckley. Talk about a father and a son that were both incredible singers and exceptional songwriters. Both gone far too soon, as well.

Billie and her brother are both equally deeply singers but also sprinkle in some preppy songs here and there. Equal talent to me! Also, Joel is looking more and more like Dylan and Cole Sprouse😂

Mileys Flowers has a 70's feel to it with the muted drums and synth

See, I was going to question Joel's dance talent vs his siblings...🕺💃😅

I really love these videos. I find many artists and songs I had no idea of before and they're such bangers

Wait- I've never heard the BeeGees sing normally without the *NYAAH. NYAAH. NYAAH. NYAAH. STAYIN ALIVE.*

Joel - please go research ALL of the songs the Bee Gees (especially Barry) wrote not just for themselves, but for Andy and others. Incredible volume of hits. Also, Andy died from a drug overdose way to young - partly due to getting into a bad group in the industry and also heartbreak from his lost relationship with Victoria Principal.

Awesome video!! I wonder about how the siblings treat each other -- are they supportive of each other or do they feel envious of their siblings success? Thanks for making my Saturday so much better😊👍🎵

Love that roomie is trying new ideas on videos to make❤❤

With Trace Cyrus he was part of the band Metro station who produced the bop Shake it in 2007.

The Cyrus’ should all have a band together lol

I miss august and jonas, i miss the trio, y’all need to bless us with a video soon

Hey, Joel! I’ve just started watching your videos after seeing you featured in other RU-vid content. I saw the song you made with Felix and Dave, and your singing was simply perfect, lol. Recently I checked you out on Spotify and I’ve had your song “It Kills Me” stuck in my head haha. Super catchy and of really good quality. Thanks for doing what you do, it’s inspiring and entertaining :D

I got chills listening to Joel singing Chapagne supernova

“Welcome to another friday video!” On a Saturday!!!

Michael Jackson was 21 when that song came out. Bruno Mars has made a pretty good career too, but it's taken him a whole lot longer.

I’m just wondering how those siblings feel having a more successful famous “star” at home 🤔 Are they happy and supportive? Or jealous and intimidated? Especially when a “star” and them doing the same thing (singing/music/business etc.)

Trace cyrus was in metro station as well (they sang that shake it song)

Love YOUR voice. You were right on point today with all your choices. I actually still have the Andy Gibb album that was released with Shadow Dancing. I totally crushed on him as a “tween”.

Loved you choosing Finneas! He is so amazing and definitely deserves more recognition. I love his songs

I love shadow dancing, it’s so funky! Thank you for choosing Andy!

“They look very similar” um, I wonder if that has anything to do w/ genetics 🤔😂

"Flowers" sounds like someone re-recorded the vocal track of a Fleetwood Mac song or a title rejected from a later ABBA album, but used the original backings. It's groovy with almost no interesting texture.

Really enjoy saving the time to watch on my day off. It feels so relaxing to enjoy all the wonderful commentary. Off and on singing, was doing the singing as well. If I know the words, it just comes out. Thank you for such a wonderful video. When Joel gives musical knowledge, just love it. Thank you, and Joel that match for you is in the world. The question is, are you ready? Finding isn't about searching, it's more about being balanced and open to that possibility without being desperate. I've had to learn this, made my mistakes. If anyone reads this, hope you understand. Truly desire peace, love, and joy for you 😘😘❤️❤️

I love Miley as a whole but I listen to Noah almost everyday now. So much good material

I love how joe does his intro half way through the video when it’s called INTRO 😂 should be call midtro since it’s the middle of the video

It is so sad about Andy Gibb, taking the path of using drugs and dying so young. He could have had a long career, so lovely voice.

The problem with Noah Cyrus is that could hear one of her songs and recognize her voice and be like "Oh is this a new Miley song?", because she just sounds like her sister.

the goosebumps i got for finneas is surreal..

Shadow Dancing is a good song, but the best part about it is Barry's hamony in the chorus... All hail Barry Gibb!! 🤩🤩🤩

Ive watched a lot of your videos, but I didn’t know you were such a great vocalist as well as producer. Super cute and talented.

Ashlee Simpson also had an MTV reality show to launch her career. I really liked her at the time. She wasn't as dumb as Jessica. It's a pity how the lip sync issue really killed her career. She just couldn't recover.

I just found your channel yesterday and have bingeing your videos crazily since then......I love everything I've seen so far..thank you ❤

24 minute video, and I still felt like it ended too soon. Great job!

Joel: I’m gonna go with Noel. Joel’s editor: Shows picture of Liam.