Singers Reaction/Review to "Pentatonix - The Sound of Silence" 

It seemed like all 5 of them sang in a lower register than normal. I liked it.

Kevin is amazing here. Stomps, claps, beat, a body of work.

We all have to agree that Matt is not Avi, so they just had to adapt to him. Though he is the supposed bass of the group, we all have to agree that his voice is different from a normal bass and I'm really happy that they opted to give him more ways to shine and adapt the songs at his range. If you see them live and them singing songs like halleluja you'll notice the difference and how they all adapt their old songs to fit him. Is kinda sweet and they are all great. It's like he is not there to replace Avi, but to be another fifth member of the group.

****IMPRESSIVE DOESN'T EVEN COME CLOSE TO DESCRIBING HOW INCREDBLE THIS A CAPELLA GROUP IS & I CANT EVEN COME CLOSE TO A WORD, GOOD ENOUGH TO EXPRESS, JUST HOW INSANELY TALENTED THEY ARE!!!****

99 percent sure Matt is a natural baritone with a very rich lower register

You're only the second one to point out that Matt had Mitch cover the highest part of his solo, well spotted. I agree with Marco that Scott's lower register is warmer than Matt's. You might hear more in superfruit songs, or Scott's "I'm gonna tell ya momma on you". They found a beautiful way of changing the key for Kirsten's solo, and then the wavy run by the trio was epic. I agree with others, your extensive comments are warranted because of the incredible arrangement of this epic song. Thank you.

This video is the finally clinching proof for me that Matt is a far superior mid-range soloist than bass. Now that isn’t to say that he is a bad bass, but when he gets to belt like that? There’s nothing better.

When they do this live it's EXACTLY like this❗😭❗😭❗😭 they are insanely talented it's crazyyyy😍

Mitch: Everyone thinks I’m the best ptx singer. Scott: Hold my margarita!!! (And I’m a massive Mitch fan!). This is an absolute Masterclass from Scott. Loved you reaction guys ❤️

Scott's bass was grittier than Matt's smoother, lower notes. Both were sweet!

“Please go down!” When Matt was singing I was also hoping he’d go down at the end of that phrase haha. Such an awesome reaction 👏🏼

Its ok, we all know that Matt doesnt have a super resonant base. They picked him for other reasons. You focused on one reason I see too. Mitch and Kirstie are so tight and, now, so are Matt and Scott. Its like having a quartet vs a trio. You saw it here and with the Wicked 15th anniversary "What is this feeling?" Matt and Scott work so well together. Its the new feature of their music.

I think what i heard in this song is that Scott and Matt are on par with each other like Kirstie and Mitch. And then when you put all four together it is a whole new sound. However, when it comes to Kevin, you did miss quite a bit. He helped out not only on the harmonies, but the bell sounds. And in my opinion the percussion, brought the whole thing together.

Kevin held it all together! 💖

The live version of Hallelujah when Avi sings the vers and Scott the bass, already showed the qualities of Scott's voice.

My favorite version of any remake of this song...Scott, Mitch, Matt&Kirstie killed it!!! Simon and Garfunkel would be proud!!! (Kevin was awesome in his beatboxing!!)❤️❤️

Scott has really increased his range! Fantastic! It was perfection.

I told you - this is the MOST EPIC I have ever heard from Pentatonix - EVER! I have listened to this rendition at least 50 times. When I got the notice that you covered it I turned everything off and listened to this. I knew you would be blown away! By the way, you both look hot as shit today 😍😍😎😎!!!!!

I couldn't wait to hear your reaction on this one. Honestly, this was a PTX personal best. The key change was brilliant, The Chord exchange when Matt needed to go high, the team took it for him and yet his voice wasn't lost in the mix at all so the focus stayed on him. And then, OMG that base note. Talk about smooth register change. But who cant talk about Scott here... Proves what a versatile vocalist he is. Kudos to Kirstie, Mitch and Kevin. Just stunning.

Have you EVER seen or heard So Much talent in one group before? Amazing.

Finally!! I wait for your reaction. Ptx just blow my mind with this. More pentatonix reactions!!!

Its a common recurring theme with PTX where you don’t know what to expect but after watching they’ve just far exceeded your expectations. This has become my favourite version of this track as well, and Scott- no words. Just utmost adoration and admiration.

Their chord changes are like that, so subtle yet powerful that you know things just got taken up to a next level but it's just blended so well that it flows like water!

I always enjoy watching both of you react and review. I read some comments somewhere where it was said that when Avi was singing lead Scott would sing the bass in the background. Many couldn't believe that this was true. Now, with Scott singing in the foreground like this it can be seen that he definitely can sing bass. I'm not sure which member said this, but one of them commented that they all had very wide ranges and it could be tricky (tricky might not be the correct word, but you get the idea) to decide who would sing what.

This was a great reaction all of them in their lower registers Matt’s solo killed it and Kirstie belting for her life

I think we were all pleasantly shook by this video. Scott’s tone letting that Texas slip out, and Kirstin and Mitch being angelic as usual. Then Matt showed up and showed out proving yet again what an amazing replacement he is. Oh and Kevin is still the most talented human being on earth imo. That is all. Thanks again for another in depth and genuine reaction, guys!

The length of it was fine because you were not just repeating the same things and you had a whole lot to say about every member. PTX just continues to blow my mind with every performance and I love watching everyone’s reactions!!!

Lol I love watching Petnatonix reaction videos to watch the joy I feel on other people’s faces.

Pentatonix keeps you on your toes because you never know what's coming.

I have been WAITING for your reaction! Did you notice Scott was doing the bass when Matt was singing? Watch Scott and you will see him! It was awesome!

Guys you probably forgot that Scott BACKED UP the bass on Hallelujah and I Need Your Love, that's when Avi's part came out, and maybe some other songs that I didn't notice. That range guys, just don't you try to forget it. What a great song and a great reaction from you guys. Much love from your Indonesian fan💜

Okay, first I want to say "thank you"! I searched RU-vid looking for your reaction to this song and here you are! You guys are awesome! This song blew me away and it first showed on Twitter under Matt's post and I was like "no way". But I was blown away by Matt and Scott. Honestly, I forgot that Scott was bass because we always hear him sing and his range is crazy. Matt was crazy phenomenal! They all blew me away, but Matt and Scott took it all!

Listen again when Matt is singing, Scott is doing the bass line!

This is one you have to watch multiple times to get everything out of it. Just so much going on. Lots and lots of surprises and I also think that this is one of their very best.

If they are going to high light Matt, which thank God they did, someone has to pick up the low end. Scott has a lot of talent as do they all. No one can deny that Avi has been replaced. Totally. I will always miss him. Pentatonix no longer needs him...

Scott sings this low in the PTX cover of “the greatest show”. You should consider reacting to that one. It’s audio only (I haven’t seen a video ). Ali may like this since Scott uses his “rock” . As usual it’s very very good.

Scott has always done a great job covering the bass lines when Avi / Matt are doing a solo - here and in 'Hallelujah' for example.

Let's dispel the argument that Matt and Avi sing bass vs. mid-range solo differently. They actually don't. Both use an affected bass. Both sing in the mid-hi baritone when they sing solo. Avi goes to bass a little more naturally than Matt, but that's more a difference in technique than end-effect - and that would likely be because Avi trained in opera. As for Scott, he is a full baritone. He can go low into the upper-bass register, or go high into the low/mid-tenor in his chest voice. Because he had Avi, and now Matt (bass), and Kevin (also a baritone), he's never needed to sing low solo. But you HAVE heard him sing this low before. Every time Avi or Matt sings solo, it's Scott filling in on bass to allow Kevin to stay on percussion. But it IS rare to hear him go low solo, so it's something to appreciate just how complete a singer he is.

💥I WAS WAITING FOR THIS REACTION!!! I TOTALLY SPAZZED WHEN I HEARD SCOTT THE FIRST 100 TIMES!! I LOVE THIS VERSION !!💯💯 It's a WORLD TOUR .....GO SEE THEM!!!💥Don't miss the chance to meet Scott!!😘... Kirstie, Kevin, Mitch and Matt💥

I love your reactions! They're so honest, and poignant. And, even when you do interrupt at times, it's because of the song content and not your way of over reacting. You two are good critics! "Harmonies!" :)

I love watching you break down the technical parts of Pentatonix style. More please, not less. You guys are fantastic!

You are not talking too much. This is why we watch your reactions. To get your opinions and see you responses to key parts. Keep up the true feelings of the music that you love

Matt is a natural baritone with a rich low register. I've only heard Scott hit notes this low when, in Hallelujah, he sang bass while Avi was singing his solo. His first note in this song blew me away! Also, Kevin's rhythm in this song sent it to another realm of "epicness". It was just awesome. They will be in Germany in the Fall; the Europe and Asia schedule hasn't been published yet. They will be here in Nashville in June. I've never seen them live but I will be at this one!

re-watch hallellujah again and pay attention to Avi's solo... Scott sings bass during, and Avis register is a lot higher than we anticipated... i didnt realize how similar these two songs were and how they were arranged until i heard Sound of Silence a few times..

Your commentary wasn’t too long. It’s never ever too long! I personally want to hear your comments. I respect your views and opinions. I too would love for Pentatonix to focus an arrangement on Matt’s solo Bass.

Scott killed it!!!!

Don't ever be sorry! I like hearing people who know more about music then I do explain things that were going-on! I was really shocked when Scott sang a solo in his lower register. As far as we can remember as fans that's never happened. In the past he carried the bass line when Avi was singing a solo. And that's it! Also, I didn't hear one single riff or run come from Scott. I was blown away by that! It would have been to soulful for the sound of this song. And he was using his vocal fry beautifully! I also love that they didn't have Mitch do any vocal acrobatics in the stratosphere. I love when Mitch accentuates his solo with an exclamation point of a high note! But it wouldn't have been right for this song. And Matt saying with such fullness and richness for his solo adding the vibrato at the right point and never once falling off at the end of those held out notes. And he emoted beautifully! I keep in mind that he had just graduated from Berkeley when Pentatonix scooped him up. He didn't have a lot of experience as a professional musician yet. He was only 23 and look at how much the remaining members of the original group have grown in 7 years. Matt's going to get better and better and he seems to be a fast learner, and according to other members of the group he's a very hard worker. I know that he still taking vocal coaching and I'm confident that the lower end of his range will be fleshed out quite soon! When he's singing in his bass register from the very beginning of a song, like in Making Christmas from A Nightmare Before Christmas. He sounds absolutely great way down there in those bass notes even when they perform it live! Just really really glad that you guys watched this and enjoyed it!

Yes! I loved your reaction as always. Matt's voice is beautiful and he is such an amazing bass. They are finally coming near me on tour so I can finally see them live!

“Which way are they going to choose, the bass way, or not the bass way?” The answer was Yes! The bass with Scott at the beginning, the not bass of Matt in the beginning of his solo, and that amazingly smooth drop during the end of his solo. They took every expectation we could have had and turned them sideways. I love PTX for that.

idk why you would think people wouldn't like this???? you guys are always delivering

So you said Scott beat him now it's a competition. Its probably hard enough being the new guy. Now he has to compete with other members of the group too. Poor Matt 😔.

They are wonderful. This is one of the best songs that was ever written. Once upon a time there were actually songs that had meaning. Thank you Simon & Garfinkel

I really liked when you went back and replayed the parts you liked and told why you liked those parts. I would like to see more of this type of analysis.

It was Tim Foust who sang this song with Peter Hollens. And I'll say what you didn't want to, if I'm thinking right. Scott's balls dropped, making it easier for him to hit those low notes, he hit his second puberty. Lol. Love you two guys so much, I couldn't wait for your reaction to this, and you definitely didn't disappoint. I love every reaction the two of you do, keep up the good work. I sit all day and listen to music, I'm unable to much else, this is what helps me get through my day, and you help make me smile. 💜

I LOVE your PTX reactions!!!!!♥️ Your commentary is stellar and so honest and true that well, what’s not to love! You guys are just the MOST and I look forward to your PTX reactions every time! THANK YOU!!! 🙏🏽 I also have a reaction request for SUPERFRUIT “The Promise”! They released the video a day before this Pentatonix video. I know you’ll do a great reaction video for us on this one too 🥰

You may never get this message and that's ok. I just want to say that I have come back to ALL your PTX reactions over and over again. I just love watching the two of you enjoy them sooooo much! Thank you so much for sharing your personalities with us.

i totally agree with you guys. This arrangement is pure genius! Thank you for the great reaction!

Not to worry about the time. I watched it all the way to the end.

Take as long as you want in your react. This is gold. I LOVE that you went back and played and replayed parts of the video! Good stuff. By the way, I’m going to see them in concert in Oklahoma in May

Finally! I’ve been waiting for your reaction, guys! 😊 Thanks for your highlights, I had same thoughts about Scott’s base toning... the unbelievable harmonies... c’moooon, they are just insanely beautiful! 😊 Thank you for sharing your emotions and thoughts! 😊

Loved this so much! I agree with everything you said. I kept waiting for you to watch it twice haha I cannot get enough of it, it has been on my playlist all week :) Scott`s range is insane, this has given me a whole new appreciation of his talents!

“This is such a perfect song for a bass singer.” Really? I had to chuckle at that, since neither Paul Simon nor Art Garfunkel, who originated this song, is a bass singer! I liked the Disturbed cover of this, but Pentatonix brought a whole new dimension to the song, IMO. Greetings from Florida!

Scott is a lyric baritone. His voice extends well into both the bass and tenor ranges. When Matt (or previously Avi) sings a solo and the underlying harmonies require bass notes, Scott regularly supplies them. *Everyone* in Pentatonix has a range that exceeds their nominative ranges. Kirstie is officially a mezzo soprano. That's the lowest soprano voice, just above alto. But Kirstie can sing as high as Mitch. Mitch's range is just over 6 *octaves!* Kevin is another lyric baritone, but his voice doesn't go down into the bass range like Scott's. Instead it goes way high into the tenor range, and that's just before he engages his beautiful falsetto range. Add in the fact that he's also a cellist and a saxophonist and you have a top-notch musician. Add to that the fact that he apparently eats drum kits for breakfast and you have one of the best percussion sections of any band out there, including bands with several drummers with real drums. But Kevin can also *sing.*

FINALLY!!!!!!

Been waiting for your reaction!

Been waiting for your reaction!! Loved it

Oooh been waiting for this! 😁

"Finally!! I wait for your reaction. Ptx just blow my mind with this. More pentatonix reactions!!! " me too bro ,you are amaizing

Love this! So glad to be able to catch up! You guys are awesome!

Never be afraid to say what you think please. Everyone is entitled to their feelings and thoughts. I think Pentatonix version is eargasmic. All the harmonies and transitions. A work of art. The atmosphere of the song is completely different from the original (calm and sad) or the Distrurbed version (scary and accusing). Pentonix seems more anthemic to me, almost hopeful and joyous. Fills my heart with energy and love. Beautifull. I think Matt is more all round. And has a beautiful tone in the mid-range. But his bass misses color, what scott and avi do have. So I think they did him right, they gave him the part and tone where his voice completely shines. And it's nice that they all shine in more ways then one. They can do so much more with multi talented members. Keeps it exciting, so much possibilities.

I’ve been waiting for your reaction to this! ❤️

YES! I was waiting for this! Oh my gosh!

I’ve never hit the like button so fast! I KNEW this reaction was going to be GREAT. I wasn’t wrong. Looong is GOOD! Yes, Yes & Yes!🙌👏😍

Perfect reaction! I've been waiting for this for soooo looong!

I actually really like that you took time in the beginning to give thoughts and assumptions before watching. ALSO do you two like 80s music? Do you like figure skating? How about fantastic harmonies?? If you do you'll LOVE the new Superfruit video, The Promise!!

YES!! Ive been waiting for this reaction! Love you guys!

matt is definitely more of a soloist and I 100% hope they choose to highlight him in his baritone range more.

I love how much insight you brought to the video and the style.

loved the reaction! was waitimg for you to react :)

Love when you guys react to Pentatonix.

I legitimately appreciate the time you spent on Scott's lower register because I was absolutely floored. He has one of my most favorite voices and while I have heard him flirt with the lower notes I have never heard it like this. I have been waiting for someone to be as blown away as I was.

Ohh yes!!! I've been waiting for you guys to react to this...😊😊😊

I was so excited when I first saw this and tweeted it to you so fast, I was so looking forward to what you thought before the start, and right through:) and you reacted sooooo well:) thanks chaps, its nice to see you both together(im following supernatural, but not lost) happy happy day

Matt, Kirstin and Scott killed it!!!

Thank God you finally reacted to this. This was beyond awesome! Great reaction 😍😍😍😍😍😍

I love watching y'all talk after the video! You pointed out a lot of stuff I didn't notice!

I love watching your reactions - you totally say what we are feeling and thinking. - Thank you!

oh, and you should listn to 'the Promise: superfruit....gorgeous

YESS! FINALLY WE'VE BEEN WAITING!! YAAY

...and the title of this video should be "Marco gets his mind blown". Loved your reaction guys

I was also waiting for your reaction to this. This just blew me away and I know you would be amazed!

Love you guys! Hello from South Carolina, USA. Thank you! You are wonderful and I anxiously await each and every reaction from you!

Great reaction as always. I really appreciated all the commentary both before and after, especially when you went back and replayed portions of the song to highlight the point you were making. Loved it!

Yes! I love you. I love them. I love this. Watching it again for the first time through your eyes made my day!!

Love the long comments! Great job! Your insights are so great.

Scott was just giving good bass in the beginning and when matt sing

Incredible. I remember when it was originally sung by Simon and Garfunkel. To be honest, this is the best version I have ever heard. They killed it!

Yey i tweeted you to see this and you reacted just as I thought brilliant

I knew you guys would love this one! At first I thought, oh geeze, this song is being over done, but Scott blew it out of the water immediately!! I love their versatility! Glad you enjoyed it too, & I hope they go to Germany. I have my ticket for Denver!! Also Superfruit has a new one too, it's an 80s cover, I hope you check it out eventually.

Again straight out dropped everything out of excitement!!!