Тёмный
No video :(

Sire "Larry Carlton" S7 vs Fender Player Series Stratocaster - What's the best affordable Strat? 

Johnny Cox Guitar & Bass School
Подписаться 753
Просмотров 43 тыс.
50% 1

Find the specs for the Sire "Larry Carlton" S7 here.
sire-usa.com/p...
Find the specs for the Fender "Player" Strat here.
www.fender.com...
If you've followed my other videos you'll know that I've played quite a lot of Sire instruments by now. I like all the instruments I've played to varying degrees and you can find some of my other reviews in the following links.
This is my review of the Sire "Larry Carlton" H7.
• Sire Larry Carlton H7 ...
And I've done a few videos for the SIre "Marcus Miller" Basses, you can find them in this playlist.
• Sire Marcus Miller Bas...
Sire seem to have found the knack of giving guitar and bass players what they want for less than you'd expect to pay. They design and build all their own pickups, preamps, hardware etc. which helps to keep costs down, and they've secured the endorsements of legendary American musicians Larry Carlton and Marcus Miller, which was a marketing master stroke.
A lot of the Sire instruments are clearly targeted at musicians wanting a Fender, without paying Fender money. The S7 and T7 guitars are obviously Strat and Tele style guitars, while the V7 basses are like active Fender Jazz Basses (in the style of Marcus Miller's modified 70's Jazz Bass).
So, it seems like an obvious comparison to compare a Sire "Larry Carlton" S7 with the cheapest Fender Strat that you can buy, which is the Mexican made "Player" series. Which one should you buy if you want an S-style guitar on a budget?
You can see that Sire have really thought about that question. The "Player" series has an obvious advantage over the S7 in marketing terms because it has the name "Fender Stratocaster" on the head stock. So, in order to compete, Sire needed to produce an instrument that sounds really good which means it needs authentic sounding pickups, plays really well which means having a great neck, and offers a bunch of extra features over the "Player" series. It's also cheaper than the Strat.
To my taste, both guitars sound authentically Strat like. I like the neck on both guitars. Of the extra features you get with the S7, I would say that the locking tuners and the nut are relatively cheap upgrades you could make to a "Player" Strat if you wanted to. The baked maple neck doesn't matter much to me (although some people love it).
The place where I think the S7 feels noticeably better than the Strat is in the tremolo arm. But i don't use the trem a lot so it doesn't bother me that much. And the Strat trem is more authentic, but then I guess everything on the Strat is more authentic as it's a genuine Fender product.
The thing that I prefer about the Strat is that it's lighter (although there's no guarantee that every guitar weighs the same) and it feels (to me) more like a real Strat, but I am willing to believe that it might just be the name on the head stock that makes me feel like that.
It feels like a bit of a cop out to say this, but I honestly can't say which guitar I prefer. I can say that I'm surprised by how much I like the Fender "Player" Strat. I was expecting to like the S7 more, and I do like the S7, but I like the Fender as well. I honestly don't think you can go wrong with either of these guitars.

Опубликовано:

 

25 авг 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 82   
@sh4rkbyt3
@sh4rkbyt3 Год назад
I bought the Sire s7 over a Fender Professional II. No regrets whatsoever! Great sound, great feel and plays like buttery smooth! Pickups are really good too. The neck feels custom made for my hand too. Saved $1k so bought a new Roland JC40 to go along with. Incredible combination for sound!
@grimora-dg3vq
@grimora-dg3vq 3 месяца назад
I bought the Sire S7 FM Blue V2 with coil splitting in the bridge and it's not a just for the money comparison, it actually plays better than the Fender. Frets are better finished, no sprouting and I get better tonal variety from the Sire pickups compared to the Fender's which are very narrow sounding. The locking tuners are also stepped so I don't have to bother with a crappy string tree resulting in much better tuning stability! I know fanboys will standby their selected favorite name brands but I KNOW I got a much better guitar for even less money! The big 3 have rested on their "Made in America" BS for way to long putting out mediocre quality guitars and just like the arrogance that ruined the auto industry, they're now losing ground daily!
@marcohermans3207
@marcohermans3207 2 года назад
I've purchached the S7 natural flame maple top also. I love it! I've several Strats, Mexican player, USA, Custom Shop. I've bought it because it's a HSS and therefore is more versatile in a Coverband where you need a lot of different clean and high gain sounds and not want to switch guitars too often. It was a suprise for me that the neck, neck-middle, middle pick positions sound exactly the the same as my custom shop Fender Strat. The S7 has the better tremolo bridge and when you use it heavy the locking tuners are a welcome addition. The neck is suberb. The only thing I want to change is the tone control pot and some Dunlop straplocks. There is also a treble bleed circuit on the volume pot. If you cut off the resistor/capacitor the guitar loses some of it's high end harshness.. That's personal preference. Nice video!
@robz1980
@robz1980 2 года назад
Where is that resistor specifically located? I would like to do the same to my blue S7 fm
@TheGuitarGuy.
@TheGuitarGuy. Год назад
@@robz1980its in your volume pot a small orange circle things attached with two wires
@stevendegoodmojosmet4034
@stevendegoodmojosmet4034 2 года назад
For me the Fender has a more strat jingle twinkle, the Sire is more round, warmer midd... It almost sounds like a real strat.. I like the two. OK let's get a Gretch :)
@tutif
@tutif Год назад
my man really said: 🗿 on 1:35 Fantastic playing. I got a S7 and its just wonderful. Good vid
@bobaldo2339
@bobaldo2339 Год назад
I liked the Fender better in every position except one: the humbucker in the S7 bridge position sounds better than the single coil in the Player bridge position.
@cookiemonster2949
@cookiemonster2949 6 месяцев назад
Wow sire easily beat fender. I need to go and buy a sire. Great guitar 😂
@snan1384
@snan1384 9 месяцев назад
loved your cover of dire straits : )
@juhaniranki5323
@juhaniranki5323 8 месяцев назад
They're both fine. I probably buy the Player, but I'd be happy happy happy with the S7 also.
@powerhouse1949
@powerhouse1949 2 года назад
The S7 vintage would have been a better comparison here. I’m my opinion it knocks the Fender out of the park !!
@SylvanTuck
@SylvanTuck Год назад
I just got a S7 vintage a week ago. I love it. Pickups are great and tone variations are too. Craftsmanship A plus. I agree that it is better than the Fender. Fenders in the 1200.00 and signature models are better, but you pay for it a small difference. You can't compare a maple fingerboard next to rosewood. Completely different tonal qualities. Should have compared the S7 vintage to the player with a maple fingerboard. Also every guitar has to have a set up done for your playing style, especially a Strat type guitar.
@davidevans3359
@davidevans3359 2 месяца назад
I certainly think the Sire has a better spec. My only reservation is that with the Fender, you can change the electronics, pick guard colour, and the neck if you're into periodically changing the look and sound of the guitar. If Sire sell replacement necks and pick guards (and I don't know if they do or not), then for me, the Sire would be a hands down winner.
@carllocarlos1
@carllocarlos1 2 года назад
I agree with @dannyplaysguitar: Sire is insane for the money!
@spryrecords5418
@spryrecords5418 2 года назад
Thanks for the interesting video Johnny. It made my buying decision much easier. All the best for 2022!
@GuiitarBilly
@GuiitarBilly 2 года назад
I agree. The Player sounds more Straty in this demo. The pickups are sweeter, with a bit more mids. The Sire’s middle and neck pickups are brighter and ,with less mids…thinner. In a playing or recording situation you could likely eq the guitar, amp or modeler to dial in (or out) what you want to hear from the Sire’s single coils. As with all shootouts, in a real world situation you wouldn’t be a/b-ing against another guitar, so it’s just ‘does it work for you.’ I currently have the pure Strat thing covered nicely and am looking for an affordable HSS. The Sire is looking and sounding very good. Thanks for this demo, it really shows all the tones the Sire can produce against a good reference point- the Fender Player Stratocaster.
@joeholland4936
@joeholland4936 Год назад
I think the Fender sounds the best and l am happy since l am lefty and Sire doesn’t make strat style in left. They say they do but extensive search in USA yields no luck.
@racesla
@racesla Год назад
I give the Fender the advantage on the neck pickup, other than that the Sire shines. If you wanted to replace the Sire pickups. You could install a pair of say fender custom shop Texas specials and still be into the Sire for a bit less money and have a ridicules guitar for under $900.
@AdelinCroitoruM
@AdelinCroitoruM 11 месяцев назад
Thank you for the review! To my ears the Sire sounds like it has a more buttery smoother tone that blends nicer in the mix, while the fender has a more sparkly one with a bit of attitude that gets a bit more in front. I prefer the sire's sound in the mix from what you've shown us. I feel like they complete 2 different roles. If you're a live guitarist that wants his guitar to cut through when he's soloing i'd say fender is the way to go, for me, i'm getting a sire for the studio sound. But then again, if you're a live guitarist the locking tuners are not a bad idea either so....... dunno, you can upgrade later if you feel the need for them i suppose.
@mg5672
@mg5672 Год назад
Sire is thinner in sound but an upgrade with the pickups would make it something amazing. So buying a sire and buying USA pickups instead of a MX strat and putting in USA pickups. However a lot of RU-vid guys on site and that neck needs rounding and frets . This is where MX strat would win due to the workers ergonomically making these guitars and small hands makes the final touches a lot better.
@sh4rkbyt3
@sh4rkbyt3 Год назад
Thinner sounding? Not on my Sire at all. Much better mid-range than anything Fender offers. Amp settings in these videos has a lot do with it.
@BryanClark-gk6ie
@BryanClark-gk6ie 2 месяца назад
If you think so then use your guitars tone control' that's what it's made for and learn to EQ the amp.
@robwilkguitar4458
@robwilkguitar4458 8 месяцев назад
Well I really like your playing I think I should get a few lessons in, nice playing. Regards the two guitars I thought the S7 sounded a bit muddy as you rolled off the tone and was quite harsh compared to the Fender but that could be me. Anyway, most helpful as I was considering a Larry Carlton. Thanks.
@jameswilliford5478
@jameswilliford5478 Год назад
Close enough that I would definitely take the Sire over Fender. Price, imput jack placement and fretwork. Still not sure if I like the gloss fretboard but maybe there will now be no fretboard maintenance besides a quick dust off.
@russtyruss_i-Invest
@russtyruss_i-Invest 2 года назад
Would have been cool to hear you compare a Strat HSS with that Sire. Obviously, price wise there's a big difference and would love to be able to compare the two. I own a American Strat HSS and would consider selling it to swap for a Sire if the tone is right...but need to hear them in comparison. That Sire sure sounds good for that price.
@Evil.Turkey
@Evil.Turkey Год назад
I bought the Sire S7FM over a Fender Player Plus series. The Sire is just overall a killer guitar! Hard to beat!!
@Anjohl
@Anjohl 2 года назад
The Sire is better in every way. Even if you upgrade the pickups, you're coming in cheaper than Fender.
@ChrisDeJuanMusic
@ChrisDeJuanMusic 2 года назад
Hi! Would you recommend any specific single coil pickups to upgrade the Sire? I'm thinking of upgrading the pickups on my S7
@sh4rkbyt3
@sh4rkbyt3 Год назад
​@@QuantumGamingUploads So far the Sire's I've checked on Reverb are holding their value very well.
@sh4rkbyt3
@sh4rkbyt3 Год назад
@@QuantumGamingUploads Possibly, but I think with the quality they're poised to give Fender a run for their money. Either way these impressive mid priced guitars are forcing the established builders to step up their game giving is better choices.
@yeehawtwistyarms
@yeehawtwistyarms 2 года назад
Good to see you back - great video, both strats sound nice.
@johnnycoxguitarbassschool3957
@johnnycoxguitarbassschool3957 2 года назад
Thank you! 👍🎶
@davelewis4215
@davelewis4215 2 года назад
Nice video but IMO the Larry Carlton HSS & SSS Strats are vastly superior to the Fender players and more expensive fenders. Tuners are not just locking they are stepped the nut neck rolled off frets and body cut is superior . I have the white Tele version and that’s also a fender giant killer.👍
@Smokey_bearz
@Smokey_bearz 2 года назад
i’m about to buy a new guitar and want a strat like guitar. I was really thinking about buying a player but now this has changed my mind a little. How do the specs compare?
@ybissonnette
@ybissonnette 2 года назад
@@Smokey_bearz i am selling my strat player for The fire s7 tiger blue. They dont compare not even close
@Smokey_bearz
@Smokey_bearz 2 года назад
@@ybissonnette thanks for the input. Definitely going to buy an S7 in 3 tone sunburst this week 👌
@BigBSinclair
@BigBSinclair Год назад
​@@Smokey_bearz How do you like your s7? Thinking of buying one!
@iliastsitas1552
@iliastsitas1552 2 года назад
Perfect! Thank you!
@baulder3055
@baulder3055 2 года назад
You deserve a much bigger audience Johnny
@johnnycoxguitarbassschool3957
@johnnycoxguitarbassschool3957 2 года назад
Thanks very much! 👍🎶
@lbsubstylee
@lbsubstylee 2 года назад
Great video!
@alextaylor6216
@alextaylor6216 2 года назад
Everybody seems to compare the Sire to a Fender with Pau Ferro fretboard, maybe because of the dark color of the S7's roasted maple. Tonewise, the better choice would be the One Piece Maple Version of the Strat, which to my ears has much more of that bell-like tone many are looking for. BTW, you sometimes find issues like frets sticking out of the neck sides on both Sire and Fender guitars - I wouldn't buy either one unplayed.
@dohoeijmans2432
@dohoeijmans2432 2 года назад
What great playing!
@Worship4LifeGuitar
@Worship4LifeGuitar 2 года назад
Who plays with the tone all rolled off super dark?
@Yogi231faza
@Yogi231faza Год назад
Dzień dobry mam pytanie Który Gryf jest grubszy który jest bardziej wygodny bo ja wolę raczej grubsze gryfy? Pozdrawiam serdecznie z Polski 🇵🇱😊🧐☕😎
@ChrisDeJuanMusic
@ChrisDeJuanMusic 2 года назад
Hi Johnny, thanks for this video, great comparison! I've just received my Sire S7 and am absolutely loving it! The only thing I think I'd upgrade on it would be the pick ups, maybe just the middle and next position picks... would you recommend any good single coil pickups ? Many thanks again! :)
@keithb5612
@keithb5612 2 года назад
Hi. I swapped out the Sire S7 HSS Pickups for House of Tone boutique hand wound pickups (Alnico 2/2/5 magnets) and also had a Freeway switch selector (from Amazon) mod fitted which gives a total of x10 series/parallel tone positions. I'm much happier with the tones now.
@ChrisDeJuanMusic
@ChrisDeJuanMusic 2 года назад
@@keithb5612 Thanks! Nice one... i'd never heard of that brand, will check them out. I was thinking of some Suhr pickups and also the Fender Texas Special ones... but in the end someone recommended to me some hand wound pickups made in Argentina, it's a brand called Diliberto Pickups, I live in Spain and they have shop in Madrid... so I ordered a HSS set of these for 200€... can't wait to get them up and running! Interesting too the Freeway Selector thing! Cheers :)
@ChrisDeJuanMusic
@ChrisDeJuanMusic 2 года назад
@@keithb5612 So does the Freeway switch substitute the 5 way toggle switch or do you have to make another whole for it?
@ironandzinc
@ironandzinc Год назад
I'm thinking that the roasted maple neck on the sire guitar gives it the better tone.
@jenniferthompson9441
@jenniferthompson9441 2 года назад
One has locking nuts bone nut shaved conture better Wang bar better neck strats ask way to much money. But good video
@Savvathan
@Savvathan 2 года назад
hello! Thanks for the video! Can you do a T7 vs Player Tele?
@kevinwightman1
@kevinwightman1 2 года назад
I've had both, the Sire was much better. The Player Tele frets were horrible. Having said that, my player strat was great!
@johnnycoxguitarbassschool3957
@johnnycoxguitarbassschool3957 2 года назад
Hi, I haven't played a T7 yet. If I can get my hands on one, I'll do a video. 👍🎶
@Savvathan
@Savvathan 2 года назад
@@johnnycoxguitarbassschool3957 thanks in advance!
@bratskiy.ostrog
@bratskiy.ostrog 3 месяца назад
Я купил s 7 в белом цвете на синглах! Я буду менять звукосниматели на сет Dimarzio! Гитара превосходного качества! У меня был Фендер Де люкс мексика и он намного хуже по качеству!
@jackdheb7071
@jackdheb7071 Год назад
I don't know .... what is the definition of 'Strat tone' ???? Most people would refer it to 'Fender stratocaster' 's tone , right ??? Then a Fender should sound like a Fender .... isn't that normal ??? So, saying Fender sounds more like a Fender is weird in this kind of comparison. We might compare peach and plum to see which one taste like mango more but compare peach to a kind of mango to see which one is more like a mango ... is it weird ??? Strat shape guitar should sound Straty ???? ... really ??? where did the idea come from ??? If so, what a point that we should have hundreds of Strat-shaped guitar brand ??? I don't think Larry Carlton had tried to copy Fender tone ... he just make it sound like what he prefer. So the comparison should be the quality, price, playability, tone difference ... but not ... which one is more Straty. At the end of the day, if you want Fender sound, then go buy Fender. If you prefer Gibson sound, go buy Gibson. It doesn't make any sense to buy a guitar and want it to sound like another. (Your wife wouldn't like that idea too hahaha) And that 's why I have a few of Sire and a few of Fender myself. I play Sire more cuz it's more comfortable for me and my hands. But sometimes I do need Fender's tone or sometimes I miss playing Fender. Each of them is like a total different girls to me and that's why it makes perfect sense to have them both. ^ ^
@musicalgear1024
@musicalgear1024 Год назад
Should have compared it to the American Deluxe Strat. At least that would have been fair for fender.
@412willis
@412willis 2 года назад
Fender pickups sound way better.
@TONY-gj3jl
@TONY-gj3jl 4 месяца назад
Sire è una bella chitarra ma il suono fender è unico !
@emre259
@emre259 Год назад
I liked all the features of Sire S7 and and was planning to get one.Also very goo for my budget.However, comparing to fender, even player series, Sire sounded too simple and artificial against it.
@devinsinderwitcz9134
@devinsinderwitcz9134 Год назад
Sire by a mile! The Fender isn't even comparable, costs more, less features, less quality hardware and the so called revered pickups pale in comparison overall. Sire also has straight pull going to the headstock so no need for those terrible string trees that f up your tuning! Sire STAYS in tune, Fender? Retune after 1-2 songs every time! And forget the whammy bar on a Fender, use, re-tune, use, re-tune, use, re-tune. Wash, rinse, repeat!
@maybethshirah3711
@maybethshirah3711 2 года назад
The Sire sounds "glittery" here.
@bertonedes
@bertonedes 2 года назад
Unfair comparison, you should test it with a maple neck Fender, it has differend and much glassier tone than pau fero. Sire has also one peace neck here?
@multipipi1234
@multipipi1234 Год назад
. Are you asking a question on one 'piece ' neck... or I already know the answer to the question I'm asking ?
@Bembol01
@Bembol01 Месяц назад
It’s just a brand but Sire is the best
@Brendanbassman
@Brendanbassman Год назад
S7 is way better
@Johnny1.0
@Johnny1.0 2 года назад
Swap the tuners and nut and you have a gig monster
@fr3ak1shh
@fr3ak1shh Год назад
Why? The locking tuners and bone nut.
@BryanClark-gk6ie
@BryanClark-gk6ie 2 месяца назад
The Old tuners and nut comment lives on LoL
@johanjahwicki235
@johanjahwicki235 5 месяцев назад
Fender player is much better on this test...
@JoseQuijada-lr7gr
@JoseQuijada-lr7gr 6 месяцев назад
Fender es fender
@x2d2x
@x2d2x 2 года назад
Fender sounds better!
@ChrisJones-ht9zn
@ChrisJones-ht9zn 2 года назад
Yeah, I agree. Sounds more like a Strat, as I want to hear a Strat sounding anyway.
@tonyro1805
@tonyro1805 2 года назад
That may be, however the build quality on the Sire guitars are much,much better. If Fender would pay more attention to detail on their necks/ fret construction on the Player series they'd have a winner.
@moises8477
@moises8477 2 года назад
😌 P R O M O S M!!!
@mach1853
@mach1853 2 года назад
The Fender is just a significantly better sounding guitar…
@jenniferthompson9441
@jenniferthompson9441 2 года назад
Actualy the S7 is lighter
@markbye7128
@markbye7128 2 года назад
Between Muscians Friends & Sire guitar, The customer service totally stinks. I would love to be enjoying my new guitar but, i have no idea where it is!! And yet they hold my money for it in the form a debit card hold and the bonus is every 10 days they hold twice the amount because a new hold goes on before the old one expires. Horrible!! Neither Sire or Musicians Friends keeps me informed as to what is happening. Both are Terrible, Terrible customer service companies.
@sh4rkbyt3
@sh4rkbyt3 Год назад
Sweetwater had mine setup, inspected and shipped to me within one week.
@devinsinderwitcz9134
@devinsinderwitcz9134 Год назад
I've seen this fake review on over 15 different videos now. Sounds to me like you aren't much of an actual player?
Далее
Fender vs SIRE - Which Guitar Has the BEST Tone!
8:16
Просмотров 120 тыс.
SAME GUITAR, 4 BUDGETS! (Can you hear the difference?)
17:59
拉了好大一坨#斗罗大陆#唐三小舞#小丑
00:11
Sire Larry Carlton S7... What's It Like One Year On?
18:39
when strat players can't do fender
10:09
Просмотров 45 тыс.
Before You Buy a Sire, Watch this for Pros and Cons!
17:47
When A Gang Leader Confronted Muhammad Ali
11:43
Просмотров 7 млн
This Sire S7 sounds great but we have a problem
12:01
I Played (almost) Every Telecaster To Find The Best One
18:12
Every Level Of Stratocaster
40:54
Просмотров 46 тыс.
拉了好大一坨#斗罗大陆#唐三小舞#小丑
00:11