I agree. Billy and Jimmy have bought in to the idea of performing true to the records, but this song (which is my favorite SP song) shines at their “Live” tempo from 1996 - 2000. I’m hoping it comes together better when they perform in Dallas in a few months.
The 90s live versions were great examples of young musicians rushing. Older musicians don't need to favor adrenaline over intent. The MC tour ending was also exemplary of the song's meaning: A moment in time that isn't repeatable.