SOLVED: Connecting Windows 10 to Netgear ReadyNAS (SMB Protocol)

Подписаться 6 тыс.

Просмотров 36 тыс.

50% 1

My new PC running Windows 10 would not connect to a Netgear ReadyNAS Duo that I've had for a long time. Turns out the issue is an SMB1 protocol issue. I take a look at the packets and figure out how to solve it
*WARNING: SMB1 is disabled for very good reason on Windows. It is not secure and you could be exposing yourself to risk. I would not recommend leaving SMB1 enabled long term*
Problem description: 00:00
Capturing packets: 00:50
Googling error code: 01:31
Analyzing NAS packets: 01:57
Googling for an answer: 05:43
Connecting to a Mac with SMB2/3: 08:21
Enabling SMB1: 10:26
Connecting to ReadyNAS packets: 11:21
Wrap up: 12:26
Sign up for Wireshark minicourse: packetbomb.com/
Join the PacketBomb Discord: / discord

Наука

Опубликовано:

23 июл 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 55

@xkitejunkie Год назад

Thanks for the excellent video. It was exactly what I needed to talk to an old ReadyNAS and I learned something too about wireshark and SMB protocols!

@PicRic 3 года назад

Thanks for that tutorial. I don't fully understand all the technical stuff behind it but your solution works with my ReadyNAS NV+. I subscribed too.

@raphaelalemany891 3 года назад

Thanks a lot! I had the same symptom with my ReadyNas duo ! Great job !

@adenircamargo713 7 месяцев назад

Really good troubleshooting mate. Well done.

@stephenmarmoy2424 3 года назад

Thank You, Thank You, Thank You I'd given up on my old Netgear ReadyNas Duo v2 until I stumbled upon your Video. I used the Control Panel - Windows Features route and ticked the SMB 1.0/...... box, rebooted and hey presto it's now working perfectly. Thank you again here from the UK.

@timurs8335 3 года назад

That was great! Powershell did not work for me, so I put the tick through the Control panel. Now it works. Thanks a lot!

@diegodevops4151 Год назад

Yeah, I did the same. Add / Remove Features. Also installed Firefox version 56 to access the NAS via web and it works.

@RobertSheehan2w2 Год назад

I'm so excited to try this tonight, thanks for the video!

@PacketBomb 4 года назад

Use the timestamps in the description if you want to skip to the solution. My videos are more about the process of solving problems than the end result. Troubleshooting is fun!

@sekritskworl-sekrit_studios 3 года назад

The link that you copied and pasted would be nice...

@delwilkins2086 Год назад

The image of the Control Panel config you showed worked a treat thanks :-)

@nickyandmurraydillon8728 2 месяца назад

Thankyou for the info… it brought my Readynas back to life 👍

@Littletart010 3 года назад

I had the same problem as you so were you looking at windows features box at 6:11 min I checked that box and it worked thanks, I did not how to get around this problem. I was going down the youtube rabbit hole and I found your video and it fixed the problem thanks again

@einark.2019 3 года назад

Any idea to which value i have to change my subnet in order to connect with the ReadyNAS Duo RND2110? and, yeah: There is a "v2" partly covered by that RND Sticker on the main label..

@anjbish 4 года назад

Vooohooo. Another amazing video here

@Lucian-M.M. 3 года назад

I have enabled the SMB1 and I gained access to the NAS, but only for reading. If I want to "paste" something onto the drive, the `paste` function is simply faded. Does anyone have an idea about how to solve this? Thanks!

@kurtkaeferboeck5323 3 года назад

many thak's, great video. you saved me a lot of time

@oleinfidel 3 года назад

Thx that worked great! However, I now do not have the option of 'deleting' files on the NAS?

@marekpolanski1414 2 года назад

Hello, thank you for nice tutorial. I have followed and managed to enable SMBv1 protocol in windows, however the problem with my NAS 102 remains the same. At another computer it works, with TV it works, with new PC - no. I see it in network but when I click i get the same message. Any further thoughts? Thank you in advance. Marek

@Grunchy005 2 года назад

I think there's a way to enable SMB2 on the Readynas? At least that's what I had done, and I could access it, but it wouldn't show up in my Network / Computers listing unless I enabled SMB1 client. And now it's problematic because I renamed the hostname of the Readynas but that's for another day.

@pollomacco 2 года назад

Hi! I have a recent Synology DS218 and I think I have almost the same problem… is it possible that the nas still uses the smb 1? I will try to enable it and I will let you know! Thanks man!

@oleinfidel 3 года назад

Curious, when I enabled [clicked on] all SMB protocols thru the Windows 10 Features interface and restarted...Nothing/nadda/zip! So I installed Powershell7 and it said something about the script not being 'run in elevated mode'; so I searched for 'powershell elevated script' and found a script that would do that.....pasted in your referenced line of powershell script, rebooted and Vwalla! , all my ReadyNAS files came up. *** For some reason, while I can now access the files on the NAS, I cannot Delete?? Thank you very much!

@mikeguschke 5 месяцев назад

Is there a possible way to update the ReadyNAS system to use the later SMB protocols?

@stephenmacfarlane17 3 года назад

I've got the ReadyNAS duo v02 it was all working but now it's not coming up in the network unless I connect through RAIDar. I went through these steps but sadly what ever I did hasn't fixed it I even tried the WireShark but the numbers etc I got back were all differnt to yours. Seems an expensive change to get a new NAS just because mircosoft decide SMB is not safe.

@BrandonJaffe14 4 года назад

intro and outro are sick

@redmatrix 2 года назад

The powershell trick worked for me, thanks.

@padhraigodonoghue6453 Год назад

Thanks! Was getting the same error and this worked. I'm on Windows 10 Pro version 21H2 and under Control Panel > Programs > Turn Windows features on or off, SMB 1.0/CIFS File Sharing Support SMB 1.0/CIFS Automatic Removal was enabled while SMB 1.0/CIFS Client and SMB 1.0/CIFS Server were disabled by default. Enabling them and rebooting allowed me to connect to my ReadyNas 102.

@erminc1891 2 года назад

does it still work with the 21H1 Upgrade of Windows 10?

@theelvisphoto 3 года назад

Thanks a lot for a thourough and fun tutorial. Only thing is, that PowerShell command does not react in the same way for me. It ends up saying "Path : [blank], Online : True, RestartNeeded : False". And it doesn't get me my ReadyNas back either. Any clues?

@theelvisphoto 3 года назад

My SMB seems to be on and still Windows can't attach the drive. Unit is visible in the Computer/Network. Also in Netgears admin tool. Any idea? Stopped working after that damn 20H2 update..

@kingvizrael7524 Год назад

hi, please can anyone help, i have the same version, for whatsoever reason my readynas is not detected on router page or pc, doesnt matter its windows os or mac pc, changed pc, router, cables, but for whatsoever reason it always blinks all the lights with full fan speed whenever i switch on with or without the hard disks, i have installed even the smb package in windows 10, turned off firewall but no use, pls help, how to solve this?

@FrancescoMorazzini 3 года назад

Thanks, it works!!

@TheOpacue 6 месяцев назад

But so, what am I supposed to do? I wanna use the NAS, but everytime I'ma access it I'll have to enable SMB1, and then disable it again when I'm done?

@mikeperrett1539 3 года назад

For some reason, although this looked exactly like the issue I was having, but the solution in the video did not solve the problem

@AdultDevelopmentInstitute 2 года назад

In 2022, there is a tick box under the Windows Feature list at 8:00 that says "Disable all SMB1 thingies". If you untick that and reboot, it works. Much simpler.

@1697djh Год назад

Thank you for your video, I found that using Apple's Safari browser will support the web UI from the DUO, which relies on the obsolete TLS standards

@yt_legend_papa 4 года назад

Hi, can someone provide me the pcap file for that case?

@PacketBomb 4 года назад

It came from here: old.reddit.com/r/networking/comments/37c8py/slow_network_throughput_for_the_first_65_seconds/

@tjfSIM 3 года назад

Aint nobody got time for this, seriously. I regret buying this thing - tried setting it up when I bought it years ago and got nowhere. Similar experience now. Could it be any less intuitive?

@user-oi2xo8ve8q 2 года назад

Thank you!!!

@leventefazekas2661 4 года назад

Yeah, I believe SMB1 got disabled by default after wannacry and petya

@buba8472 2 года назад

Thanks a lot!!!! You saved my Files from this Netgear Crap. But why did you made such a long vid? I almost clickes away :(

@themistoclesnelson2163 2 года назад

Thanks!

@yt_legend_papa 4 года назад

I got it thanx

@mp44christos 2 года назад

This worked! a router change disabled smb1 for some reason.

@dominiquefaure7349 3 года назад

The Netgear brand has not been able to develop the management software of its NAS product. Flash players have disappeared and we lose our equipment. Thanks Netgear

@shituru4737 5 месяцев назад

Подключайтесь в EDGE в режиме IE, нет нужды усложнять

@fleshwound8875 3 года назад

Gota be honest that was a lot of wireshark garbage just to get to..... enable smb 1.0 /facepalm guess we needed content

@Markfromthe80s 2 года назад

So.. nobody seems to care that SMB 1 is totally unsafe to use these days? "Oh, great, we just enable it an bam! Everything's solved!" ... Or do you have some other methods of providing safety to this old protocol?

@PacketBomb 2 года назад

It's a good point. I used to have a pinned comment on this video highlighting the risks and I'm not sure why it's not there anymore. I will add a note to the video description