Star Trek Bridge Commander USS Defiant vs USS Lakota Rematch 

I think the battle is potentially accurate but it would depend on tactics , the Lakota in the Dominion war era was the most advanced excelsior with late 24th century tech, phasers and quantum Torpedoes. The defiant has agility but the Lakota has mass and firepower.

You torpedo guidance system is way off. That is what caused you to be blown out of the preverbal water.

These always look really cool but the time to kill is so high that the combat becomes dull.