Superman vs Superman! WHO WOULD WIN IN A FIGHT? 

Fun fact:Superman is stronger than Superman.

I think Superman won. I really didn't like Superman but Superman was really good!

As soon as i clicked on this video, i knew that Reeve's Superman would win in the Abilities category via wall building vison. 🤣🤣😂😂

reeve went faster than you said because he wasn't at the earths surface

Well obviously Kal-el would destroy the Son of Krypton😏

Cavill was dragging a ship through rock solid ice with zero effort on his face

For durability, Reeve/Routh was stabbed with kryptonite and survived. Cavill had some gas in his face and collapsed. Not to mention the island was made of kryptonite. And for intelligence, in Superman 2, he got Zod and them away from the city and took them to the Fortress of Solitude. Also, I'm pretty sure that when he turned back time, we saw the earthquake undo itself. At least some parts, so it wasn't just Lois. And, Routh was able to get his spaceship back up and going to go search the ruins of Krypton and return back to earth. I think that's pretty damn smart

Ya didn’t take into count how the DCEU Superman stopped an earthquake by moving the plates

I knew Superman would win!

"MCU Thor Vs DCEU Shazam, but that won't happen anytime soon." *DCEU announces Shazam movie* Gubz: Huh.

Christopher Reeves is easily the most powerful. He has all of Cavill's powers like X-ray vision, heat vision, freeze breath, strength, speed, and durability+time travel, memory wiping, the ability to rebuild a wall, and a shield, he's basically like Superman on steroids. There's no doubt that he wins in this battle.

Christopher moved the moon

Tv flash vs movie flash

I love how light-hearted and trivial your approach is to these match-ups. It's a breath of fresh air compared to how seriously most people online debate which fictional characters are more capable than other fictional characters.

Strength: Reeves Rouths Speed: Reeves Rouths Durability: Cavill Intellect: Cavill Abilities: Reeves Rouths

ReedRouths would have won endurance since he lifted an island the size of Manhattan made from kryptonite. Which is supposed to kill superman.

Can you a PUNISHER BATTLE ROYAL between the 80s Punisher 2004 Punisher Warzone Punisher and MCU Punisher?

Didn't Cavil's superman took a nuke in the face?

The new one was more realistic . That's why the old one won. Just think about it.

It was actually shown that the modern day superman travels around 90 quadrillion times faster than light (90,000,000,000,000,000)

Deadpool(deadpool movie) vs deadpool(wolverine) Flash(dcu)vs flash (cw) Elektra (Netflix)vs Elektra(Elektra movie) QuickSilver (aou)vs Quixksilver(x men) Punisher(Netflix )vs Punisher(from which ever punisher movie u like) Kingpin(Netflix) vs kingpin(daredevil movie) Ghost rider (movie) vs ghost rider(agents of shield) Hulk(mcu) vs hulk(lou ferigno) Joker(batman trilogy)vs joker(dcu) Captain boomerang (dcu) vs captain boomerang (cw)

X man: the last stand juggernaut vs deadpool 2 juggernaut

I was hoping you would factor in Kryptonite tolerance for the endurance part. One died from a Kryptonite spear while the other was able to lift an island of Kryptonite after being stabbed by it. In terms of that, Reeves/Routh gets the point. 4-1

This should be a draw mostly. The only reason Cavill's Superman hasn't been shown to be as strong is because the script just hadn't called for it yet. Also Routh's/Reeves Superman took a bullet straight to the eye. Also you rip on Reeves in the Intelligence, yet how he lured General Zod delibrately into a trap in Superman 2 and took him AWAY from the POPULATION and innocent civilians of Metropolis showed a very high level of intelligence, instead of Cavill's stubborn "stay and fight" mentality. Reeves Superman knew when he was beat and needed an alternative solution to the problem. He took Zod up to his home turf at the fortress of Solitude.

SUPERMAN 2 3 KRYPTONIAN VILLIANS SUPERMAN 3 BEAT A SUPER COMPUTER SUPERMAN 4 BEAT NUCLEAR MAN SUPERMAN RETURNS LIFTED AN CITY SIZED ISLAND

HULK (2003) vs HULK (2008) vs HULK (2012)

Why doesn't it say "Justice league"

I’m bingewatching these videos by you, thanks for making this it must of taken a lot of research

In man of steel he tried to put citizens first, shows clip of superman killing 500 skyscrapers

There's a segment in Batman v Superman where a tiny newspaper has a headline that claims that Superman "shifted a tectonic plate." I left out the argument because: 1) We are never shown Superman actually "shifting it." 2) News headlines are dubious and no context is given. 3) I didn't think it would be relevant, seeing that it was in the corner of the screen for 3 seconds -- obscured in the background. I also forgot to mention that Christopher Reeve's Superman moved the Moon with ease, so even if Cavill's version did "shift it," I don't think it would really change anything.

Please gubz come back! Your videos are legendary.

Thank you Gubz you are a youtube gem 💎❤️

It’s getting real interesting with this comparison after the JL movie. In the comics, it was mentioned that Supes had placed unknown mental barriers/blocks, due to the fragility of the world he grew up in, on his abilities until after his death at the hands of Doomsday. After his resurrection, he learned of those mental barriers and learned how to remove them when needed. After Supe’s rebirth in JL he did things that he could not do previously. His concept of time and his speed were no longer limited allowing him to see and react intelligently to things moving at unbelievable speeds....even keeping up with the Flash’s base speed and putting Barry on his heels. That was the most noticeable difference whereas before he couldn’t react that fast when he fought Zod or how he reacted when the A-10C opened fire on him at Smallville. If those things happened post JL movie he would see and react to the A-10’s bullets at a level similar to the Flash. Almost like he could enter a different plane of existence where things are moving in super slow motion when needed. He also had no problem lifting and carrying a entire apartment building filled with ppl and flying it to a safe location. He also realized he had the capability to exhale his breath at such velocities that he can freeze things whereas previously that ability was unknown to him. In many ways Supes is now unshackled after his death....much like in the comics.

henry cavil's superman survived nuclear bomb,kryptonic staff and batman!!

rewatching this in 2022, still holds, MISS TA GUBZ!!

The plane scene from routes' superman is literally my dad's favourite scene

do the 2003 Hulk vs the 2008 Hulk please thanks gubz for another video I can't wait for another video

Ghost Rider (2008) Vs Agents of Shield (2016-) Ghost Rider Joker (Heath Ledger 2008) Vs Joker (Jared Leto 2016) Plz shout out if you use any of these ideas apart from first one because you kind of already made that one a possibility

This is one of the only channels I (Actually like) watching until the full end. I love Gubz!

Superman won against Superman. I wanted Superman to win but Superman won

Superman Vs. Superman Winner: Superman

Superman wasn't actually exerting force to cause the earth to rotate backwards...he was flying so fast that he breaks the speed of light that causes him to turn back time (comics physics..) The Earth changed direction because we were watching time run backward as he traveled. It didn't actually have anything to do with the direction he was flying.

In my opinion Strenght: Reeve/Routh Wins Speed: Reeve/Routh Wins Durability: Cavill Wins Intellect: Reeve/Routh Wins Abilities: Reeve/Routh Wins

Well, Reeves did stop the earthquake. The earthquakes was only caused by the Nuke, he rewinded time to where the nuke never hit the area and then he went to go stop the nukes. So the earthquake never happened.

Prediction: Christopher Reeve's superman would win because he has cellophane and cellophane beats everything

But remember, this modern day Superman barely had a chance to show any of his powers, abilities, endurance, etc.

I’m gonna have to go with Superman, but I don’t power scale and I haven’t watched a couple of the movies

It's nice to see the difference in how people use to talk in the comments compared to now

Congratz on 100K Gubz!

He wasn't making earth spin to reverse time He was travelling in time and earth was a way to show that

I really appreciated your explanation of Reeve’s Superman as being indestructible due to the era he was birthed, vs the new Superman being the relatable revamp. Good job *thumbs up.

I thought the 1978 Superman went back in time, and we saw it from his perspective.

Whoa you're comparing how Cavill dealt with Zod with how Reeve dealt with an earthquake. Cavills way of dealing with Zod caused thousands of deaths but when Reeeve had to deal with Zod he lured him away from the population to his fortress of solitude then tricked Zod into forfeiting his powers saving millions of lives. That's Reeve winning intellect for me.

Basically Golden age Superman vs Modern age Superman, haha. Not a fair fight.

For the speed you forgot when in man of steel he flew to the 3 leg machine on the other side of the world.

Reeves was my hero as a child I can still remember crying my eyes out when I first saw superman 3 with the fight in the junkyard and I will always have that nostalgia for the superman I grew up on but man of steel is the best superman film ever made

so for strength we just gonna ignore that cavills superman broke the neck of a kryptonain under the effects of a yellow sun...

In Superman 2 the Richard Donner cut the way Superman 2 was originally intended , at the end he goes back in time and fixes everything right back until Zod and his allies get sealed in the space/black hole prison. It can be assumed he went back and prevented the earthquake also.

But Reeves' Superman outwitted Lex Luthor and General Zod in Superman 2 :)

Personally I think Cavill Superman messed up more because reeve’s Superman was traveling back in time and he could save millions of people but he wasn’t the one who killed them and Cavill technically killed soldiers by punching his enemies into the city.

He didn't spin the world backwards. He traveled faster than light and went back in time. The view point is how Superman would see time while he was flying around the planet.

I'd say Nuclear Man, despite his silliness, deserves more credit for power. After all, Reeve/Routh didn't even flinch from getting shot in the eye, and was also punched through buildings the same way Cavill was. Also, Reeve/Routh got nuked and simply didn't care.

Who knew superman would beat superman

Henry Cavill probably would win though because he was able to inhale large amounts of gaseous Kryptonite and still fight a steel-encased god-like Batman. Reeves nearly drowned with only a small Kryptonite necklace.

Christopher Reeve would win, because he's the one that can smile at the camera... Seriously, though, EVERY version of Superman is measured against Reeve's Superman. To answer the question though, Reeve was based on the 70's Superman while Cavill is based on the modern, less powerful Superman. So, no contest.

Too bad this is before justice league

Great video, but I think on the Intellect side you should also consider Reeve/Routh's performance protecting the people of Metropolis near the end of Superman Returns. If your "Intellect" category is about situational awareness, you see Routh's Superman doing things like looking over his shoulder to vaporize falling debris with wide-angle heat vision while flying off to prevent some other disaster, probably using his super-hearing at the same time to gauge how long he has to get into the sewers and stop the water mains from flooding. ... that's probably not the exact scene, I haven't seen it in a while, but you get the idea. He's keeping track of all those things at once, so maybe he's learned something since turning back time.

The infinite cellophane part was hilarious!

John Constantine (Keanu Reeves) VS John Constantine (Matt Ryan) Joker (Jack Nickolson) VS Joker (Heath Ledger) Hulk (Edward Norton) VS Hulk (Mark Ruffalo) Batman (Animated Series) VS Batman (Arkhamverse) Jim Gordon (Gary Oldman) VS Jim Gordon (Ben McKenzie)

make joker vs joker please

Reeve's Superman told the world his one and only weakness in an interview. That's pretty low intellect in my opinion.

The thing is Henry's version is still new to being Superman and learning his true powers

I didn't even start watching this video and clicked the Like button because I fought that this video will be coll And I was right Good job Gubz

Vs ideas: Hulk (the hulk )vs hulk (MCU) Punisher (the punisher) vs punisher (MCU daredevil) Deadpool (X men: origins) vs deadpool (deadpool) Ghost rider (ghost rider) vs ghost rider (MCU agents of sheild) The flash (CW -the flash-) vs the flash (DCEU justice league) Individual fantastic 4 members (fantastic 4 2004) vs individual fantastic 4 members (fantastic 4 2015) The joker (the dark knight) vs the joker (suicide squad) Colossus (x men days of future past) vs colossus (deadpool) Thanx I love you!!!!!

I really love this videos

Great video

8:21 Lol "believe me" remind of trumspter 😂😂

Henry Cavill's Superman stopped a Earthquake by moving a tictionc plate(watch Comic Books vs The World)

Come back gubz... I miss your videos 🥲.

Actually this question was answered decades ago in Superman III. If you consider the fight more of an 'inner battle' where Clarke Kent struggled against a corruption within him caused by a synthetic kryptonite, that it manifested into two Supermans. Even though the fight was seemingly physically real, it was more a symbolic battle of "defeating our inner demon"

You could have also mentioned that Reeves' Superman lifted a continent to prevent an earthquake in the first Superman movie... that was probably heavier than the island.

Brandon routh superman had the ability to differentiate earths voices to extrapolate the location of the intergang heist (the minigun scene) i would expect some level of intellect would be required for that. He also had the knowledge to decelerate the Air plane rather than stopping it abruptly - thereby saving all the passengers. In addition he expanded his heat vision to destroy falling glass debris which would require higher level calculations to compensate for the width and speed of the debris.

Intellect: Reeve loses for wearing pants before briefs.

If only Man of Steel superman could rebuild the city just by looking at it

Please do shield ghost rider vs move ghost rider

I was thinking exactly what you said in the end. You can't lose in these competitions. If your favorite superhero/incarnation has more powers, that's cool. If he has less powers, you can say that he's more relatable, and that will likely also be true. In the end, we mostly sympathize with characters based on their personality, not their powers.

3:23 Me: Oh yes my Idol is gonna win 3:43 Me: Oh wait.. I know this part, Please dont! 3:54 Me: NOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!

These videos are the only good things to come out of reboots

Cavills superman is such rookie,reeves superman more mature and educated in fortress so at the end 1978 superman will win

5:16 did I mention that Routh's Superman lifted an ENTIRE ISLAND MADE OF KRYPTONITE??!

I'm veeeeeeeeery late, but eh, wth? 4:48 Alright. I'm gonna be gentle with you on this one: That's not very good evidence on Reeve's durability feat. "A slap and a tickle to the back of the head?" I'm pretty sure that "slap" and "tickle" is infused with magic, and most iterations of Superman have a specific weakness to magic. It's possible his durability is equal to how much he can dish out in this universe. Now this doesn't change the match's result; I'm fine with Reeves being the victor here. I'm just saying...

When Reeves turned back time, if you watch the film everything did go back before the earthglquake

I putting my money on superman

“Part of what makes superman “super” is his strenght” I thought it was his underwear over his pants

Yo Gubz, you should do the 2005 Batman, and Ben Afleck Batman

slapped in the face and tickled in the back of the neck and DIED BRUHH DIS HAD ME DYING

Flash 1990 vs Flash 2014

redo this because of justice league

The reeves superman is so OP

The fact that Roth lifted an island made of the element that’s supposed to kill him should have gone under the durability section