Тёмный

The Age of Revolution: Corrections, Questions, and Omissions 

Sam Aronow
Подписаться 65 тыс.
Просмотров 12 тыс.
50% 1

Опубликовано:

 

6 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 62   
@Gallalad1
@Gallalad1 2 года назад
One tiny nit pick. The conservatives never ceased to be Tories. To this day the British (and Canadian) conservative parties call themselves Tories
@SamAronow
@SamAronow 2 года назад
Only as a nickname though. The name was changed in the 1830s.
@Gallalad1
@Gallalad1 2 года назад
@@SamAronow was there even formal party names in the 1830s? Brb gonna go spend an incorrect amount of time looking for 19th century ballots
@tzvi7989
@tzvi7989 2 года назад
@@SamAronow yeah the original Tory name comes from the Gaelic for outlaw but took on a very different meaning after Benjamin Disraeli befriended Queen Victoria. (However it is still a dirty word in mainstream British political discourse today)
@memer3548
@memer3548 Год назад
@@tzvi7989 why
@rin_etoware_2989
@rin_etoware_2989 11 месяцев назад
to be even more nitpicky- it can be said that the Tories underwent a transformation during Robert Peel's time as leader. in 1835 Peel issued the Tamworth manifesto devoting the Tories to moderate reform, and in 1846 Peel's government passed the Corn Laws, breaking up the Tories into two: the Peelites (who'll later team up with the Whigs to become the Liberals,) and the faction under Disraeli and Lord Stanley (later Earl of Derby,) the Conservatives. that transformation wasn't just in terms of policy too: while the Tories seemed like a club for only the landed and wealthy, the Conservatives involved support from every level of society-a mass movement, if you will.
@benjamindarnell6296
@benjamindarnell6296 2 года назад
I was very surprised when I discovered that in Hebrew school in the USA we learn the Sephardic pronunciation, despite the country being overwhelmingly (>90%) Ashkenazi. My parents and I even pronounce the prayers differently (which has led to a ton of confusion).
@SamAronow
@SamAronow 2 года назад
It is simply the standard, same as Spanish classes in Los Angeles don't teach the local dialect of Spanish (Caló).
@patrickrowan6001
@patrickrowan6001 2 года назад
Another fun fact: Thiers was president of France much later, during the Paris Commune. He besieged the city to crush the revolution - which was defended by the walls built in his name
@TheLoughDuck55
@TheLoughDuck55 2 года назад
The workload and effort that goes into these videos is astounding. Criminally underrated.
@ghdzsi
@ghdzsi 2 года назад
"..join the Conservatives, in order to advance Liberal policies." What a lad...
@coe3408
@coe3408 2 года назад
In relation to surnames; Sephardic Jews had surnames since the Middle Ages. The Iberian Peninsula has one of the oldest surname traditions in Europe.
@matthewbrotman2907
@matthewbrotman2907 2 года назад
As a child in the ‘70s, I was taught Hebrew with the Sephardic phonology. But I heard a lot of Ashkenazic accents from older people.
@SamAronow
@SamAronow 2 года назад
My parents and grandparents were secular Mapainiks, so the first time I ever heard Ashkenazi Hebrew "in the wild" was in 7th grade, when a classmate who went to a different synagogue asked if I'd gotten my "tallis" yet. I was in my fourth year of learning Hebrew and genuinely didn't understand what she was saying.
@Pooply21
@Pooply21 2 года назад
Everyone keeps calling the Israeli Hebrew accent Sephardic. It has a larger sound inventory than the Ashkenazi one. There is no Heth, Teth, Qoph, or 'Ayin is israeli Hebrew. The Resh today sounds like a Gimmal Rephuya... And the beghedh kepheth is another story... Same with the niqqudh - Talleth vs. Tallis as you noted. Or even meaning of words like Shibboleth Shuʿal. Or even pronouncing the Shewa Na' Shelomo vs. Shlomo. There is more to say on this but I'm not going to on one foot in the comments.
@SamAronow
@SamAronow 2 года назад
Resh as a uvular trill does originate in _a_ Sephardic dialect, but it's that of Iraq, and it only became standard in Hebrew in the mid-20th century.
@Pooply21
@Pooply21 2 года назад
@@SamAronow not all Iraqis either. But yea that doesn't address the other issues 😂 Israeli Hebrew was never in parallel with any dialect with Sepharadi Hebrew. It is it's own beast.
@denisearonow4921
@denisearonow4921 2 года назад
@@SamAronow I thought "tallis" was Yiddish.
@samwill7259
@samwill7259 2 года назад
History will always resist resist simplicity, especially SO MUCH history from all over.
@lempereurcremeux3493
@lempereurcremeux3493 Год назад
8:06 Adolphe Cremieux also sounds a lot like Adolphe the Creamy in French.
@denizalgazi
@denizalgazi 2 года назад
An enjoyable corrections vid LOL! Safe travels and Shabbat Shalom!
@butternutsquash6984
@butternutsquash6984 2 года назад
Enjoy your travels. Will miss you!
@smorcrux426
@smorcrux426 2 года назад
I just finished watching every single video in row! Even though I watched some of them separately whenever I had some specific question, this series was absolutely insane. Everything ties in so well to the rest of history, and it's honestly a little shameful I know so little about Jewish history as an Israeli, even (or maybe especially) modern Judaism and the way it works. You do such a good job contextualizing Jewish history and specifically talking about the things that were most politically important (especially to non-Jews whenever they were ones who held the majority of political power), rather than what was most important to the Jewish community specifically, which is less relevant to the rest of the world, and that focus helps tie this story in to the rest of history (though I'm afraid that might mean people who have less knowledge of all this background history will enjoy this series less, since a large part of why I personally liked it so much is how it tied in to all my previous historical knowledge, especially with those extremely wonderful maps). I think one of the things that shocked me the most was the actual relevance of Jews to the rest of history, and since they rarely appeared when I was learning about other countries' history I assumed they were relatively politically irrelevant, and seeing how major political problems both affected the Jewish community and were affected by them was super cool. I am really looking forward to see you talk about the end of the 19th and especially the 20th century, and I really hoped that by the time I finished watching all these videos a new one would be released (it took me around 2 weeks to watch all the videos). I might look in to become your patron in the future, and I recommended you to a bunch of my friends.
@almogz9486
@almogz9486 2 года назад
15:55 you said my name but you wrote someone else's lol Also thanks for answering the question it was very interesting I never learned of 19th century British politics
@jeffreyschweitzer8289
@jeffreyschweitzer8289 2 года назад
Thank you!!
@sagetmaster4
@sagetmaster4 2 года назад
HYPE! Also enjoy your travels friend
@matthewsteele99
@matthewsteele99 2 года назад
16:30 sounds like the basis of disdain between Galitzianers and Litvaks
@SamAronow
@SamAronow 2 года назад
That's more of an America-specific thing, feeding into the hierarchy of "who arrived first" with the Western Sephardim at the top and the FSUs at the bottom.
@gabdewulf
@gabdewulf 2 года назад
Lovely as always..enjoy your break.
@moontreeboutique7995
@moontreeboutique7995 Год назад
I love this damn channel so much!
@cgt3704
@cgt3704 2 года назад
Can you make more history of the jews in Romania ?
@SidheKnight
@SidheKnight 2 года назад
Safe travels!
@JM-fv1jf
@JM-fv1jf 2 года назад
When is your video about late Tsarist Jewish life coming out? Interested in it as a descendant of two post Soviet Jews.
@shmulik8471
@shmulik8471 2 года назад
Great video!!!
@sportzajent
@sportzajent 2 года назад
Where can I learn more about the proposed Reform rabbinate in the US? I’ve never heard of that idea before and I went to school in Charleston, SC.
@SamAronow
@SamAronow 2 года назад
This very channel will get to it soon. But if you are impatient, check out _American Judaism_ by Jonathan Sarna.
@RobertGrif
@RobertGrif 2 года назад
Are you going to make a video about the results of your viewer poll?
@gedgar
@gedgar 2 года назад
Ive known someone with the surname haddad
@navetal
@navetal 2 года назад
17:49 Hey, I'm not Almogz 9! (No offense to Almog, I'm sure they're a great person)
@SamAronow
@SamAronow 2 года назад
Ugh, I lapsed for that moment in the graphics. My bad.
@almogz9486
@almogz9486 2 года назад
It's he and yeah I spotted that error too lol no biggie at least he said my name out loud
@joelabraham9456
@joelabraham9456 2 года назад
Hmm. Is the incident you mentioned at the end the moratara affair by any chance?
@duddyrosenberg5701
@duddyrosenberg5701 Год назад
How come you didn’t mention anything about the Hungarian teilung in the haskula videos?
@forthrightgambitia1032
@forthrightgambitia1032 Год назад
I'm surprised you didn't mention George Eliot's book Daniel Deronda. Gwendolen Harleth was very much in the stereotype of the la belle juive. Though the author was highly sympathetic to Jewish issues.
@orenstep7997
@orenstep7997 2 года назад
what will you do once you reach the modern day?
@trevor1667
@trevor1667 2 года назад
More
@CivilWarWeekByWeek
@CivilWarWeekByWeek 2 года назад
Wait Nintendo?
@SamAronow
@SamAronow 2 года назад
It's a reference to a video game that came out before you were born.
@doronbenhadar7583
@doronbenhadar7583 2 года назад
I still don't get the Damascus affair episode at all. You hint that the affair was a conspiracy by the Egyptian and French governments, but to what end? Was it to distract the local Syrian Arabs from their grudge against their new Egyptian rulers?
@SamAronow
@SamAronow 2 года назад
It was a conspiracy by Ratti-Menton specifically to increase French influence in Egypt, using its recently self-appointed status as the military/diplomatic protector of the Catholic Church, in the expectation that Egypt would indeed overthrow the Ottoman Empire and become the new Middle Eastern power.
@user-gr9fq9gt9w
@user-gr9fq9gt9w 2 года назад
Nave Tal = Almog9
@almogz9486
@almogz9486 2 года назад
Yes. I am (not really though lol)
@OliveOilFan
@OliveOilFan 2 года назад
Top 10 Jews to exist?
@user-gr9fq9gt9w
@user-gr9fq9gt9w 2 года назад
1) Rosa Luxembourg 2) Ayn Rand
@user-gr9fq9gt9w
@user-gr9fq9gt9w 2 года назад
@@hfyaer I literally wrote that because they have completely opposite ideologies, genius...
@junefranklin458
@junefranklin458 Год назад
⁠@@user-gr9fq9gt9w3) karl marx 4) milton friedman
@donaldbenjamin6358
@donaldbenjamin6358 2 года назад
The Ashkenazi accent sounded ridiculous to you because it IS ridiculous
@tzvi7989
@tzvi7989 2 года назад
*the yeshivish askhenazi accent. The general one not as inspired by Yiddish isn't that ridiculous and just sounds like Yemenite vowels with fewer consonants
@benjolicious
@benjolicious 2 года назад
first.
Далее
The Jewish Risorgimento (1815-1870)
28:15
Просмотров 48 тыс.
Kishinev (1903)
35:52
Просмотров 35 тыс.
ПРОСТИ МЕНЯ, АСХАБ ТАМАЕВ
32:44
Просмотров 2,2 млн
The Revival of Hebrew? (1879-1908)
22:42
Просмотров 104 тыс.
Who Would Be King of Finland?
10:33
Просмотров 193 тыс.
Zionism Before Herzl (1882-1896)
32:05
Просмотров 69 тыс.
Jews in the Thirteen Colonies (1654-1789)
22:00
Просмотров 235 тыс.
Mesopotamian Gods Family Tree
24:24
Просмотров 1,4 млн
Why Does Joseph Stalin Matter?
46:20
Просмотров 1,3 млн