No video :(

The avoidable electrocution of Harvey Tyrell

Подписаться 34 тыс.

Просмотров 86 тыс.

50% 1

The tragic death of a seven-year-old child and the acquittal of the electrician who installed the circuit that killed him.
The aim of this video isn’t to say whether the jury was right or wrong in finding the electrician not- guilty of manslaughter by gross negligence, after all I wasn’t in court to hear the evidence presented. What I do know is that the electrician made mistakes by failing to undertake basic tests or make recommendations to the landlord who was the duty holder.
He made assumptions on safety and plead ignorance about the site that didn’t hold up in court; quite right too as he’d spent ten weeks working there. This sparky took a going rate for providing his professional services, yet he cut corners that directly led to a dangerous situation in a public area and he failed to cover himself by undertaking basic tests and recording the results.
I want to open up what happened here because examples of poor workmanship by amateur installers and lazy electricians are rife. We come across these types of dangerous installations all the time, and its simply dumb luck as to whether someone gets hurt or not. At this site, improper modifications and poor maintenance had been the norm for years and it was only a matter of time before someone got hurt.
Music:
Kindly edited and supplied for this video by This is Royalty Free from her Out of Time piece:
• Royalty Free Tense Act...
The images used in this presentation are copyright of their respective owners.
This content is also available in written form on my website which will see updates posted as new information comes to light:
www.dses.co.uk/index.php/pers...
Source links:
www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news...
www.romseyadvertiser.co.uk/ne...
metro.co.uk/2021/02/17/electr...
www.echo-news.co.uk/news/1907...
www.romfordrecorder.co.uk/new...
www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england...
www.dailymail.co.uk/news/arti...
www.dailymail.co.uk/news/arti...
www.msn.com/en-gb/news/uknews...
Much of the content credited to sources such as The Romsey Advertiser come from the Press Association and can be found verbatim across multiple other sites such as ITV News. And yes, I did get Romsey and Romford confused, so while I thought I was promoting a local rag by lifting snapshots off their site, it turns out they're 200 kilometres away!

Опубликовано:

4 мар 2021

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 492

@oliverriall 3 года назад

As a dad this sort of thing gives me nightmares, it also drives me to do a good job at work and make sure everything I do is safe.

@electrician247 3 года назад

Rest peacefully little man.

@Danny-do2ov 3 года назад

This really is so sad. Being an Electrician myself and having two young children, this breaks my heart. Sending so much love to Harvey's family. ❤

@robertchapman4726 3 года назад

Exactly this, i had to watch this because ive two young children & needed to understand how the man who undertook the work in the premises wasnt liable. Theres a reason why these regulations and guidelines exist. Absolutely heart breaking. Unfathomable loss for the parents & totally preventable.

@slopsallover 3 года назад

As a career sparky having served my apprenticeship in the 1970s I can say that guys of Naylor's age often became electricians in an afternoon having been a butcher or a printer or postman on the morning. There was was little scrutiny back then. Many so called Sparky's of that era have never kept up-to-date date with the regs etc and have never joined an accreditation organisation. Sadly I have come across dozens of them. Condolences to the family of the young lad. Great video report. Keep up the good work.

@LOTPOR0402 3 года назад

What was perfectly acceptable back then , is not today .In some ways a good thing in others over the top health and safety rules and regs , which keep on changing .Making it more complicated .For every install where someone gets killed 99.99% of the time no one does. If the accreditation is anything like motor trade ATA accreditation it means nothing .A monkey can get past that .Jobs for the boys in colleges

@mathman0101 3 года назад

That’s why I have huge respect for you David because you are always informing sparkys about the importance of standards, regulations and RCDs and moving onwards to AFDDs - adding safety. If properly explained to the customer most customers will pay extra. One thing I have always liked is your warnings about lighting devices which are bought off the internet and have not been fully tested and certified by an independent safety lab, or even CE mark at worst. The importance of testing cannot be underestimated. Keep up the educational encouragement. Question is if you went to a public place and saw shoddy work and you wanted nothing to do with it would you be required to report to HSE or council or would you report it because of your conscience. My deepest condolences to the family it should never have happened.

@jimmyb1451 3 года назад

"or even CE mark at worst"? You do understand that CE literally stands for "China Export" and means absolutely nothing with regard to compliance or standards, right?

@mathman0101 3 года назад

@@jimmyb1451 yes agree not a quality mark it’s a conformity mark for goods sold in EEA for health, safety and environmental standards, similar to US where we have conformity to FCC. it’s better than nothing. In the USA we have private testing laboratories such as UL listed products which are fully tested for electrical safety. What about the move to UKCA marking now post brexit? assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/950107/Guide-to-electrical-equipment-regulations-2016-tp.pdf I have seen David and talking about this issue in the past when installing products brought from the internet. At least PAT testing would give some assurance not sure how many electricians do that at second fix? When the focus is often only only electrical safety testing of the installation.

@anonnona8099 3 года назад

@@jimmyb1451 That's wrong, I'm afraid. A common misconception, but wrong.

@semperidem2577 3 года назад

Erm, Sparkys as you put it, shouldn't be out working if they need to come and watch videos like this in order to realise what they should and shouldn't be doing. I was an electrician until fairly recently when I gave up my job to care for a relative but the very first thing I used to do on any job, or even going to appraise a job, was to inspect and test the Earthing and bonding. Whenever problems were found, it was a difficult job persuading customers you hadn't just made up a fault to add extra work and cost. Telling a customer you couldn't do the job because you needed to run bonding first can be a quick way to losing the work. In the end I used to combat this by providing the customer with a printed Electrical Safety Council leaflet on the subject. Even with that some still were suspicious. If that was the case I then decided they were likely to be further trouble and dropped the job anyway. The last thing you need are customers that penny pinch and question every decision.

@mathman0101 3 года назад

@Flat Sign true and it can happen with pristine or corroded contacts but latest AFDD can pick these surges earlier before that stage. Moreover in the UK with the existence of ring circuits current draw is lowered reducing the likelihood of joule heating and arcing.

@edward_grabczewski 3 года назад

Well said and it reminds us all that cheap-skating on electrical work is a serious, and often tragic, business. I have a BSc in Electrical and Electronic Engineering but there's no way I could convince myself that I'm an electrician - for the reasons you've given. I haven't devoted enough time to training and studying the regulations and, frankly, I wouldn't want to take on that responsibility.

@aaronmdjones 2 года назад

Well said.

@ady1397 3 года назад

Such a waste of a young life. It's sad when anyone dies, but when it's entirely preventable it's heartbreaking. Thanks David for making it.

@StricklandBanksTV 3 года назад

Every half arsed spark , DIY Dave and joe public who’s thinking of having work done needs to see this. Maybe then people will think twice about doing a shit job or customers will stop accepting the cheaper quote from diy Dave thinking they’re getting the same bang for their buck. Great content as always Mr Savery ! Most informative and entertaining spark on RU-vid hands down.

@GeoB24 3 года назад

Anyone who calls their own work “first class” shows it is anything but

@westinthewest 3 года назад

@@sarahjrandomnumbers There's something intriguing about the way standards like BS7671 only requires that work is 'Satisfactory'. It keeps one's ego under control if you decide that satisfying all aspects of the standards is enough of a challenge, and that wishing to be 'the dog's bollocks' or 'first class' is a distraction from that goal.

@LOTPOR0402 3 года назад

To do a skilled job you need 3 things Some knowledge the tools and time .The later being the one most people are short of always being rushed , and that's where mistakes happen

@nuttytechy 3 года назад

My condolences to the family of Harvey. Thank you David for this up. Sadly this is more common than many think. As a part time job, I am a DJ and I have been to a few pubs where the landlord has done the work themselves in regards to their electrical work. I've had to refuse work as I normally visit a venue before hand to get an idea and I will purposely look at their sockets etc. I normally ask the landlord a couple of questions to get an idea. As they don't realise that I am also a spark then when I ask them the dumb questions and acting dumb myself then I could get an idea if they did the work or they got a competent electrician in. Even though I am insured and my gear is all checked yearly etc. If something happened while I was DJ'ing then the landlord would try and pass the blame onto me for his dodgy electrics. On 2 occasions I've had to cancel work as one venue had just a 13amp socket and the land lord said that if you put more than x amount through it then the breaker would trip. Another occasions in a venue where the landlord decided to put as many sockets in as possible, feeding to a plug. On both occasions I did report the pubs to the relevant authorities.

@croikeyaustralianbetamales3432 Год назад

i went to repair a cut cable that a joiner went through, cable repaired, flip back on breaker, doesnt hold, double and triple check my junction box joiner grabs the landlord, "oh yeah that one trips all the time, we need to unplug a few things first", about 5 electric heaters plugged in and about 15 tvs, plus other items most businesses are winging it from day to day i find.

@johnburns4017 3 года назад

This is a salient reminder that RCD's and RCBO's are *essential,* on all circuits.

@trevorkemp1292 Год назад

I have just become aware of your work David through the Monday night electricians podcast which is ace. I really enjoy watching you and Nigel for the entertainment but also the great technical content. I never comment on things but I have to on this video. This video should be a mandatory what at the beginning of any electrical training program. It is put together and explained so well that is understandable to everyone and direct to the point. This is how education should be delivered. It is such a shame it has had to come from something so tragic. My heart goes out to the family. Keep up the good work and all the best.

@AndyFletcherX31 3 года назад

Thanks for doing this video. Really sad topic but deserved to be analysed and discussed. Hope you keep your enthusiasm for doing youtube.

@davidelmer2502 3 года назад

A fantastic piece of work David. It really hits home how important our responsibilities are to the safety of others while we do our job which apparently anyone can do.

@garry2115 3 года назад

Hi David, Excellent analysis of this tragic event. As always, huge respect for your electrical standards and regulations. Looking forward to your next upload !

@g6electrical847 3 года назад

I have been following this tragic and avoidable incident and your summation is spot on. Well done Sir

@simon96211 3 года назад

Sad story but very interesting and informative..glad you are back on the old RU-vid hope all is well with you and hope for more soon .keep the faith we love your channel

@pnxelectrical 3 года назад

As others have said; tragic and unavoidable. There's 1 part I'm curious of; A pub is a licensed premises under Licensing Act 2003, surely (as Paragraph 11 of the HSE Publication 'Electrical in places of entertainment' points out) the state of the electrical installation should form part of the decision to grant a license to trade, with that potentially being the case, why isn't the local council in the dock? They even state that n frequent visits the faults concerns etc weren't addressed; so why didn't they revoke the license and close until rectified?

@pnxelectrical 3 года назад

Should also add BBPA (British Beer and Pub Association) also have a Code of Practice on Electrical Safety - beerandpub.com/wp-content/uploads/woocommerce_uploads/2018/02/Section-1.-Code-of-Practice-for-Electrical-Safety-in-Beer-Dispense-in-Licensed-Premises-2011-without-Appendices-4th-Ed-2.pdf - Granted it's to an older edition of BS7671, as a publican he'd know of the code of practice.

@ForTheBirbs 3 года назад

I'm watching from Australia so not up with UK regs (other than Dave and other sparks channels). Sounds like the EICR requirement should be applied to pubs etc and a condition of licencing.

@johnburns4017 3 года назад

@@pnxelectrical Codes of Practice have no teeth. Periodic inspection of premises open to the public, inc' shops, should be mandatory. I am not advocating this Gassafe nonsense. The readily available form should have the test results. To insert the results you need to know how the test equipment works. One follows the other.

@pnxelectrical 3 года назад

@@johnburns4017 I'm with you, why the premises wasn't given a improvement & suspension order/noticr, forcing it's closure until it can be deemed as safe and compliant I don't know, hell I've seen EHOs close down premises for a single cockroach, why it wasn't shut down for shitty electrics I have no idea. If licensed premises aren't held to higher standards as terms of their license then something is broken.

@normanboyes4983 3 года назад

PNX - you make an excellent point.

@MrKarlPrince 3 года назад

Thank you for this video David, hopefully this will get a decent number of views and help the spread the word about the danger of drive by EICR's, and the criminal danger the "inspectors" are putting themselves in saving the dodgy landlord from blame.

@xxDADDYDAYCARExx 3 года назад

WOW...... regrettably one of my favourite videos of yours 😭 Thanks for the report and for dropping the funnies. My heart goes out the the family and the individual's in question should see the inside of a prison cell ........ disgraceful standard of work from so called professionals? ?? Brings the reputation of all sparks down and crushes trust from the public. Take care David ✌✌✌✌✌

@charlotterobinson9452 3 года назад

Thank you for making this video, David, there's a lot of food for thought. I consider myself to be a diligent and competent electrician, but I do have a weakness for paperwork. I carry out my work to a high standard and then test and record the results; but I must admit to being a little lax at actually getting the paperwork to clients. I definitely need to get better with all of that, thank you for making this video, it's been a bit of a wake up call!

@jasontownley3130 3 года назад

Condolences to the family. Thanks for reporting on this Dave. I've shared with all of the Electricians that I work alongside.

@peterc3228 3 года назад

Thank you David for taking the time and effort to make this very respectful and imforative video. Especially good how you explained the importance of Earthing on the installation. I can't believe the number of times I have gone to what should be a simple job of changing or upgrading a light fitting only to be confronted with no earth continuity at the point, earth's (cpc's) not terminated or even worse just cut back out of the way! This seems to be more common on newly refurbished kitchens and bathrooms, where the guys will "do the electrics as well" Keep up the good work, stay safe, Pete 👍

@andythehedge 3 года назад

This is a fantastic video, heartfelt and sincere. It highlights the importance of doing a proper job. Thanks David.

@fairplaytoyou2041 3 года назад

this is why we should not treat any job as a favour for a friend or let friendship or family relationship requests to the the best we can to save them money . the wee man has paid the ultimate price for there disregard for safety the 2 guys are old and have lived their lives to the full and took harveys life and his full families enjoyment of watching him grow and enjoying his life , we all should think of harvey on every job we look at to quell any attempt of a friend or relative trying to persuade us , well presented dave thankyou

@gerardoconnell4201 3 года назад

Excellent presentation David, sincerely hope judge and family legal team get to see your presentation before any sentence is passed. Sincere condolences to the boys family.

@adrianraith3831 3 года назад

This sounds like a pretty typical "it's only 3 wires, how hard can it be" type "electrician", without understanding the implications until tragedy struck...

@westinthewest 3 года назад

@@hycron1234 Funerals aren't cheap these days either.

@westinthewest 3 года назад

@@hycron1234 I don't even think the point of this video is particularly test meters. I'd say it's just as much about having proper tools, a diligent and consciencious approach, and an constant need to improve your game. You can work under the supervision of someone who has the test equipment, and then branch out as soon as you've done the 2391 and acquired the proper equipment to measure insulation resistance, loop impedance, low resistance and RCD timings. I agree Flukes and Meggers seem overpriced, so I paid £450 for a Seaward 1557 which is perfectly adequate. You can't start up as a dentist with just a chair and some pliers either.

@tombackhouse9121 3 года назад

@@hycron1234 Dude if you think you're ok fiddling with the electrics in your own home at your own risk, more power to you. Sounds like if you're not up to the standard of a professional electrician, you are at least better than your landlord. If you were putting other people's lives on the line, that would be a different story.

@mitchpender8113 3 года назад

@@hycron1234 omg... a voltage probe and a multimeter plus the internet and common sense is 100% not enough .. there is a reason electricians need at least 4 years of training and 3-4 years of tertiary study to obtain a licence, nothing shown youtube or the internet is training enough.. this very video highlights that. Im sure you got your lights working just great .. but its the things unseen , something that makes sense electrically for an average person , is very different to how somebody trained, looks at the same thing... Spend the effort instead pestering whoever is responsible to organise a tradesman .. Also note that insurance companies will not pay a claim if they find evidence of unlicenced electrical work , in some cases even when said work did not directly cause the issue , the case being made that evidence of unlicenced electrical work means the only electrical work that is to be covered is documented licenced work ... just saying ..

@acelectricalsecurity 3 года назад

The most important wire in an installation, yet because it sits there seemingly doing nothing, it's perceived it can be discarded or it's not really required, but the lack of that one wire has changed so many lives and cost a young boy his life.

@Mister_G 3 года назад

Well done on relaying the reported facts of this, and congratulations on having the balls to post it. My condolences to the family for a death that really, really should not have happened. Something is wrong when people expend endless energy on relative trivia (like whether a CU needs a metal or plastic box for example), yet installations like this can persist in a public place. More power to your elbow.

@dsesuk 3 года назад

Originally, this was tacked on to the last video about Part-P with exactly that sentiment - how social media gets good conscientious sparkies who follow the rules tied up in knots with each other arguing over how someone has spaced a saddle incorrectly or interpreted some grey regulation in a different way. The squabbling among those who genuinely try to do the job right and by the book sometimes seems ridiculous when you see people like this who operate as if they simply couldn't care less.

@Mister_G 3 года назад

@@dsesuk With any luck, it will hopefully give some people food for thought. Thanks for taking the time to make the video.

@matthewbeddow3278 2 года назад

Naylor was eventually sentenced to 12 months & Beerman 9 years. Neither is enough for a child's life lost. RIP young Harvy, my deepest condolences to the family.

@jamesmcintyre5583 3 года назад

Such a tragic, completely avoidable death. So easy for people to call themselves electricians and carry out totally incompetent, and dangerous standards of work. Excellent video David - appreciate the detailed explanation, and depth of knowledge.

@andrewcockburn412 3 года назад

Thank you for your sober and Frank analysis and the due deference you have shown.

@kieranmchugh5299 3 года назад

Excellent presentation on a very serious and devastatingly sad subject. 💔

@petertallowin6406 3 года назад

A horrible thing to happen that was completely avoidable. :( Very well constructed and thought provoking video David which highlights the importance of inspection and testing before and after any and ALL work. Thoughts to the family.

@chriskilgour422 3 года назад

Tragedy Dave absolutely horrible. Love your videos this was different but very well done .28 years myself In the industry and just set my own business up your videos are on point keep them coming 👍🏻👍🏻

@mart1711 3 года назад

An honest well presented video David great job 👍 For me the fault path is the foundation of any installation. Check your CPC. Check your RCD. Your circuit protection. Your supply cable. If all is good then go from there. For even the jobbing electrician these are basics and fundamentals and the fact they are regularly overlooked is ludicrous and in this case fatal. I’ve been at this a long time. I don’t even know the answers to a lot of the industries problems. There is also a lot of elitism and stubbornness that doesn’t help. This has left such a chill up my spine that something we all do on autopilot has been missed and caused this tragedy. As wrong as it would be in the regulations, even if I’d seen just one big RCD isolator up circuit would at least (for me) have given the impression that someone seemingly in the industry for so long knew the potential disaster that could happen with unearthed metal equipment in a public place. Sad all round ☹️

@davidfleck6551 3 года назад

Ty David ... 🙏 thoughts and prayers with Harvey’s family

@metrotechguru5863 3 года назад

David, thank you for your well thought out commentary. We can only hope this will raise awareness so that some daft landlord or "want to be" sparky don't create this situation again in the future.

@drummerbod 3 года назад

Great video. Tragic for such a simple and even a probably low cost upgrade. Thanks for this video.

@LeighWinspear 3 года назад

Very brave dave for making this. applauded for sticking to the facts. Im glad to be entering the electrical world with fact proving video channels such as yours around. seems like too many supposed electrician boys, being allowed to do tradesmans work.

@StuartTaylorEsquire 3 года назад

Liked and leaving a comment so the YT algorithm can do it's thing. Good man David for making the video 👍

@jeff777lufc3 3 года назад

Excellent video. I would like to see all cases such as this properly discussed and reported in the electrical press, so we can all learn and be reminded of exactly what can and does go badly wrong.

@RaithUK 3 года назад

Good worthwhile video David. Very respectfully done. 👍

@markgilder9990 3 года назад

Tragic and avoidable.

@LOTPOR0402 3 года назад

Yes but only in hindsight like most accidents

@davey6024 3 года назад

Your explanations and examples are second to none Dave.

@JacobKelly02 3 года назад

Great video as always Dave. More people need to see this, just shows the importance of RCD protection and proper testing and certification. There needs to be more laws so anyone can't be cocking around with electrics especially in a public place.

@Darkonon 3 года назад

Well done with this video, its basic enough that if the public stumble across it that they may start to learn the importance of having things done properly, just a shame its at such a high cost

@alantorrance6153 3 года назад

David, thank you for your excellent inspection and dissection of this totally preventable tragedy - preventable had the two prime culprits undertaken and completed their work properly, with all the requisite inspections and tests having been carried out fully and completely. It is to be hoped that the Safety Authority will "throw the book" at the both of them for their multitudinous failings.

@leonblittle226 3 года назад

The pub's owner David Bearman, 73, was sentenced to nine years by Snaresbrook Crown Court on Thursday after previously pleading guilty to gross negligence manslaughter.

@leonblittle226 3 года назад

Bearman's 74-year-old brother-in-law Colin Naylor, was jailed for a year after he was found guilty of failing to discharge a duty under the Health and Safety at Work Act following a trial. Naylor was acquitted of gross negligence manslaughter.

@davepallas1626 3 года назад

David this is a great piece of work well done YOU!! I feel for the Family.

@lakispattalis2506 3 года назад

Great reporting. Good honest professional are always worth their fees. Thanks for highlighting the issue.

@jamescleary5198 3 года назад

Condolences to the Harvey family 💕 and thanks David for bringing light to matters like these

@wirdy1 3 года назад

I am so glad you've done this video; I looked for the actual HSE report online but drew a complete blank, so you've filled a few blanks for me. I'd like to see the hse report, if it ever gets published, & I agree on your thoughts regarding the culpability of the 'electrician'. We can all read between the lines here.... Yep, just do the install (for your mate), but not doing the final connections & turning a blind eye to the bypassing of the meter, etc. We can imagine the conversation, eh?

@Defender23AD 3 года назад

Thanks David for taking a sensitive approach to this video

@DoctorElectricYouTube 3 года назад

good video David and a good lesson that we are all trying to impart to landlords etc.

@lordwombat8169 3 года назад

Excellent video Dave, that poor family, I can't stop thinking about it as the day goes on. One would think that with 50 yrs experience a sparky would have Z's in his blood and not the pillow type either. Claiming to be a spark carries a lot of prestige within the community. Easier when just claimed than being the real Mcoy. Your video is a wake up call for everyone to be on the ball. Thanks again Dave.

@latersow8425 3 года назад

Excellent video - thank you for posting.

@jimreece7615 2 года назад

Good coverage of this case

@tonywharton5220 3 года назад

Good to see you David. Just such sad and totally avoidable circumstances.

@sosurko 3 года назад

So sad that this kind of thing largely goes unpunished in the right way. Excellent production of facts and opinions in a sensitive manner.

@OCD_Sparkies 3 года назад

Brilliant video, I think you’re doing an excellent job of bringing this to the attention of exactly the right people who need to hear this news. This topic should definitely be a regular feature, hopefully the more electricians who hear about stories such as these, the less of these stories will take place. Who knows, maybe the industry might even become properly regulated, we can all fucking dream I suppose.

@mb63 3 года назад

Very brave and commendable video. This is precisely why, I do my CCTV job, but if any electrical work needs doing, I.e. a fused spur in a loft to power my cctv installation, I will not install until the power has been installed. Others...... might just run off the lighting, or shower feed, etc and do their cctv. I WILL NOT. I fit cctv, I am NOT an electrician. It is like asking someone who washes cars, to service your engine! Horses for courses. Brilliant video.

@wilfvoss 3 года назад

What a sad story, thank you for highlighting the importance of professional tradespeople to complete work. Common sense, one would think. Condolences to the child's family...

@conlon861 3 года назад

Thanks David for the detailed video, my heart goes out to the parents, im a spark aswell and it baffles me as to why people think they know what they are doing when it comes to electrical work, 4 years I trained, and I'm still learning and training today, this guy on here looks like he couldn't Wire a plug. The industry needs more action as I'm sick of diyers and shit working sparks. Rant over Thanks again

@jamesfollon 3 года назад

Unfortunately many more accidents waiting to happen.

@LOTPOR0402 3 года назад

And not just with electricity

@theavchap 3 года назад

Good video again Dave. What really saddens me, is that this poor boy has died and his family will continue to grieve and suffer, and nothing will be done about the policing of electrical installation work. This isn’t the first youngster to be electrocuted due to negligence, but Govt. still find it easier to swerve any responsibility for policing electrical work. Far easier to let their friends set up “training” establishments and for CPS’ to continue taking the money without lifting a finger when clear breaches are pointed out. I suspect this is because they know that the moment they open that floodgate, they’ll be bankrupted by those costs. I don’t have the answer, but we all know the electrical industry isn’t policed. It is always a case of prosecution after death, similar to prevention being better than cure, in every way except you can’t cure electrocution and nobody is preventing anything. My sincere and heartfelt condolences to that family.

@robkelly5722 3 года назад

Absolutely tragic case and it would be a travesty if neither of them were held to account for shambolic and dangerous work. God knows what else they have done or ignored in the past.

@J0nny61 3 года назад

Excellent analysis David, what a tragedy.

@casecurityandelec 3 года назад

Saw this in the paper a while ago and wondered what could have happened to cause the, glad you've made a vid on this!

@garethhodson3896 3 года назад

A sad but excellent video - a tragic waste of life and it should be a lesson to us all of the real danger we work with everyday and the lives we are responsible for.

@raychambers3646 3 года назад

The times I've heard "works don't it?" .

@jakefreeman6024 3 года назад

Rest in peace Harvey, I'm no electrician but it's so sad that events like this are still happening, after looking online myself it seems that their is alot of stories like this one, keep up the hard work bud

@seandempsey9396 3 года назад

Absolute tragedy, there are so many old pub's that have old and dangerous wireing and some landlords are happy to just let a costomer try and fix it or install some fancy lighting in the beer garden, why oh why don't get me wrong there not all like that but there are a lot. Fantastic video David and yes our hearts go out to that young lads perants and may he rest in peace. Thank you for your heart felt opinion

@kippers32 3 года назад

Thanks David , it’s good to remind us electricians the first rule is safety first before any work starts

@finba100 3 года назад

Well presented and explained. Hopefully it will make some people think twice. Seen far too many potential death traps already!

@craigemmott4976 3 года назад

RIP Little man 😥 I've no idea how these people sleep at night. I worry constantly at the smallest of things. I may not be the neatest or the best, far from it, but I will always make damn sure it's safe!

@guffermeister 3 года назад

I remember seeing this in the news a few months ago. Something as you say that should have never happened. The audit trail is only as good as you can provide. I suspect the lack of paperwork was due to it being a relative, and something "I'll get around to" but even so, you would have as you say given the basic's a quick once over such as earthing etc. Installations can be old, but still "safe", although improvements can usually be made. The re-use of the luminaires could also suggest a lack of funds. Without being able to see the prosecuting evidence its difficult to say exactly where the issues were. RCD's don't cover every fault or shock scenario but they at least give you a chance.

@davidpatterson1574 3 года назад

Excellent presentation David. Many thanks.

@jamessparks7962 3 года назад

I think what’s bollocks is that you’d go to an “eye brow raising” DB, and not perform a Ze or a Zs at DB. I’d want to know exactly what earthing system was in place before I touched it. Poor Harvey, it serves as a reminder to all us spark’s to be diligent, never assume and cover your own backside. I don’t think 230v should ever be exported outside commercially for lighting, it’s just asking for trouble.

@stewartross1654 3 года назад

An excellent summary on how culpability appears to have been avoided in this particular case, though the separate prosecution by HSE may in due course lead to an outcome reflecting the gravity of the negligence involved. What I find particularly troubling is, as David pointed out in his commentary, that a SELV system with LED lighting could have been used instead, removing the danger of misconnection altogether. Instead, mains power was run to second-hand external lighting units with no RCD protection and reliance on the integrity of the CPC (if it was ever fitted) - an act of deliberate choice which is so incompetent that it beggars belief. That a seven-year-old died as a result of the negligence of those involved is shameful. My heart goes out to the parents who had to watch as their child died in front of them from the incompetence of these supposedly experienced people.

@SqwarkParrotSpittingFeathers 3 года назад

Excellent analysis and, well done for keeping to opinion, a defence in any defamation action. It looks like a competent lawyer must have been lurking in the background. Always look forward to your remarkably informative vids, this being no exception. Thanks for posting and, for your well written, presented and researched work. 😷👀

@matthewstevens7486 3 года назад

A great video covering a sad avoidable death.

@ArthurDentZaphodBeeb 3 года назад

The guilty go free due to incompetent prosecution yet again. Inconceivable that a 'qualified' electrician could work 380 hours in such a small building claim yet ignorance of faulty wiring or that the meter had been bypassed. Such a tragic waste.

@iancockett7591 3 года назад

Great video Dave. I think this story highlights the demise of competent oversight by the local authority licensing teams. My father spent the last years of his career as an electrical engineer inspecting premises, together with building control and fire inspectors. As a team, they would regularly close down licensed premises if there was evidence of shoddy practices and/or dodgy or non-existent certificates. If landlords know they are likely to closed down following a failed inspection, I think they are less likely to bodge it themselves. Sadly, since councils outsourced many of those functions, there are neither the skilled, experienced electricians, or the budgets to do meaningful, regular inspections of licensed premises. If local authorities had properly staffed inspection teams and had the clout to close down places, it might avoid this kind of tragedy and perhaps avoid other disasters such as the Grenfell fire.

@ManxAndy 3 года назад

Vey sad, but ultimately , a timely tale of circumstances coming together to cause a tragic death......that should never have happened, Thankyou for sharing you’re view on the case.

@MRFANCYFACE30 11 месяцев назад

I have no words to describe how furious I am.... Rest in peace little man.

@James_Bowie 3 года назад

Whether or not Bearman is (or has been) an electrician ought to be a matter of record. How come it is still an open question?

@wisteela 3 года назад

Absolutely disgusting. The pub should never have been open. Subscribed.

@simonbmr 3 года назад

Hello Dave, a tragic story, many thanks for sharing and giving your insight. One slight issue is Romsey is a market town in Hampshire and it is nowhere near Romford, so I think your crediting the Romsey Advertiser with some of the quotes might be incorrect.

@dsesuk 3 года назад

Yeah, that was a balls-up of sorts. The credit is correct, but they got their information from the Press Association which means the same story is written word-for-word across numerous national and localised news sites. I got Romsey and Romford befuddled within my hangover, so I thought I was promoting a local rag and didn't spot the error until it was too late!

@simonbmr 3 года назад

@@dsesuk okay mate, just wanted to be sure you were not open to abuse/prosecution for not giving correct credit. Thanks again for the excellent and informative video.

@malcomcrawley9819 3 года назад

Well said Dave!

@TeamSimpsonRacing 3 года назад

Fantastic video on a very sad topic

@paulmorrey733 3 года назад

Tragic - thanks Dave

@robertchapman4726 3 года назад

The most important termination & part of any circuit is that of the CPC or earthing connections. My heart goes out to the family of the young lad.

@christopheryoung5480 3 года назад

Bloody good video . well done

@SquirreliciousMe 3 года назад

Good video, and does sum up why cutting corners and omitting due process can lead to tragic consequences. Perhaps happily, but ultimately luck over judgement, the general setup of electrics here tend to afford so many "get out of jail" scenarios that this type of incident is rare, and when it does go this wrong does - as is ultimately suggested - come about because of systemic and repeated failures to do the right thing, with the result that a family has been destroyed. Perhaps the odd cowboy will come across this video and think twice before cutting corners, perhaps ultimately saving a life.

@davidmason5163 4 месяца назад

I do point some young electricians to this video, as a warning for not "half arsing" work. It's a good explanation and examination.

@stephencunningham405 3 года назад

This video should be a warning to everyone doing this type of work. The people involved should all be jailed and as for the local authorities they should also be made to pay for the unnecessary death of this young boy. The full industry needs to be tighten up we all need in this country some sort of government licence to do electrical work stop diy full stop and make the scheme providers have more powers. Electrical trade is a shambles letting all do short courses and then letting them lose it tells you everything and as for the people involved need to keep up with work standards. They to blame they did the work and never tested the circuit shamfull on you all hope you all have nightmares for the rest of your lives. My heart goes out to the little lads family god bless and Rip. They will have to live with What they have done. And the industry needs tightened up full stop competent person is not good enough someone's technical ability is key to all standards keep the videos going dave you do a wonderful job. TOP BOSS

@iankerr4380 3 года назад

Hi David, good informative video, Hope this stops chancers from touching electrics! Sorry to ask miner puzzling question, Are we permitted to leave existing lighting wiring as is without taking account of premiture collapse if all tests prove wire sound (IR, cpc, continuity etc)

@dsesuk 3 года назад

Changes to the wiring regulations are not retrospective, so there's no need to go back through your jobs to bring them up to today's requirements unless you recognise there's a particular risk somewhere that needs to be mitigated. Work that was signed off to older standards is just that - signed off to older standards; that doesn't mean it's now not safe or needs remedial action. You have to take older installations on their merits and make your recommendations based on risk. A lot of wiring in plastic trunking in a communal fire escape area may be better upgraded. Wiring secured by plastic clips at a low level in a non-escape route is less likely to require attention.

@iankerr4380 3 года назад

@@dsesuk that's the way I treat things, it's just good to get as many professional opinions as possible, it was just that the new spec states that it ain't just escape routes that have to be taken into consideration, thanks for your input.

@normanboyes4983 3 года назад

Thanks for this David - very well done by you in honing in on the fundamental issues. Maybe the Prosecuting counsel should have called you as an ‘expert witness’ which may have swayed the jury to a more confident assessment of the facts, beyond all reasonable doubt. My view as a non electrician is that the Landlord’s character gives the best assessment of what was happening - Irresponsible attitude to electrical faults, making deliberate alterations with the sole purpose of bypassing the meter, employing a non accredited electrician ( my assumption he was not registered) and failing from the outset to comply with improvement notices. Essentially he was and is a chancer who was directly responsible for the death of a child AND it could have been worse as others could also have been killed in rendering aid to the young lad.