No. This is just pathologically specific, like every individual band is its own genre. To quote Douglas Coupland, "The Violet Roadkills are a great example of White Urban Folk crossed with Ska."
@@mournblade1066 I'm not the biggest fan of genre classification either, I just think the sheer amount of music and variety is amazing. But I agree sites like RYM are too much of a circlejerk and should be used more as entertainment than real discussion
@@leonardoramos764I think it is a band that is well valued, but I think it was very forgotten since the 2000's had passed and the post-punk revival was already out of fashion and commercially successful.
@@dariiofernando the album in the video is Relationship of Command for Post Hardcore. Look, I love that album but I don’t think it’s better than Repeater by Fugazi or The Shape of Punk to Come by Refused. I know, opinions right? But this one is valid I swear bro
Interesting list but what I would have different Post-Hardcore- Repeater by Fugazi (surprised Fugazi was nowhere here) Cowpunk- Straight to Hell by Hank Williams 3 (come on what’s better than the grandson of one of the greatest country singers showing that old school country can be Punk AF) Would have also added Funk Punk and have it be Remain in Light by Talking Heads
I know people will bitch about definitions and X band not being x genre or whatever, but there's a lot of new stuff I've never heard of that I'm excited to explore
Loved seeing Wire's Pink Flag there. Such a masterpiece of an album, with both a pure punk rock sound at times as well as some of the seeds of post punk clearly present already.
You should do this with the top album in every Rock genre, including Metal and it‘s subgenres (i know you‘ve done them separately but still), or maybe all the Pop genres.
I'm very happy with the inclusion of Siekiera, it's one of the best post-punk or new wave bands out there. I guess you could call it Coldwave, whatever that is
Having the Crackrocksteady EP instead of No Gods/No Managers from Choking Victim is a crime. I know it's based on rym, but that album is a masterpiece and easily my number 1 for hardcore ska-punk.
I'd probably replace pop-punk with something from Green Day, probably Dookie, and I think that some of the classic bands like Ramones, The Damned and The Clash probably deserve a shout somewhere, as well as some staples of hardcore like Black Flag and Minor Threat. First Two Seven Inches is probably the definitive straight edge album. Also I'm a fan of some classic hardcore like Minor Threat and Gorilla Biscuits, but this video makes them sound like Green Day by comparison lol
Personally I'd put dookie or enema of the state for poppunk (even tho A hangover you dont deserve is my favourite) and Your gonna miss it all for midwest emo
@Morphstock I wasn't familiar with Wire when I made that comment, but, yeah, I can see that. That being said, "punk rock" is something that I do think can be interpreted quite broadly. RYM has MCR in their top 10 punk rock albums (London Calling is actually the top one on that website). idk what metric this video uses (I will check the description, probably won't edit this comment after doing so, though) update: this video is according to RYM.
Seeing The Devil and God are Raging Inside of Me for emo made me so happy, tbh Brand New’s entire discography is near perfect and is widely ignored nowadays
How is industrial punk not on here? Artists like Pigface, Pailhead, etc. For being a more known sub genre in the punk scene, I’m surprised it’s not listed here :0
Genres I like (bold means I love): *Emo* *Emo-Pop* *Midwest Emo* Screamo Hardcore Punk Grindcore Crossover Thrash Melodic Hardcore *Metalcore* *Deathcore* *Mathcore* Melodic Metalcore Nintendocore Post-Hardcore *Post-Punk* Dance-Punk *Post-Punk Revival* *Punk Rock* *Garage Punk* *Pop Punk* Riot Grrrl Ska Punk Skate Punk Surf Punk I do not like RYM's opinion on Deathcore music
Orchid is based for emoviolence, HOWEVER!!! Worry by Jeff Rosenstock is by FAR the best pop punk album. Defo not Black Parade. Even if I had to pick a different album it would probably be Dookie lol. But yeah, Jeff Rosenstock is the goat
That’s what I’m saying. Some people don’t even consider MCR/The Black Parade to be “pop punk.” I think that slot should’ve gone to Dookie or something.
Its okay to be wrong Violent femmes are nothing like most current folk punk, and there are definitely artists that capture amefican folk culture better in the genre, dead Kennedys are barely even comparable to the likes of negative approach or minor threat, and pig destroyer is good and all but im tired of mfs choosing like the biggest most detatched band possible to represent grind when there are so many good underground artists who not only are more true to the genre but who are more creative and need/deserve the attention
i agree with your take but this isnt personal opinion, this is the best album of each genre from the opinions of many, so ot makes sense why people would choose the "biggest and most detatched" band
@@DentalFlan sales dont equal quality. Most people have entirely skewed ideas of what most of these genres are. The grind band with the most album sales is arguably the worst grind band and im sure most committed fans would agree with me
@@DentalFlan like yeah sure a lot of people like it but not bc its a good fit for its genre, and for some of these if you heard the song used as an example, and then you heard anyone else who goes by that genre, you wouldnt even see any similarities. Violent femmes might be technically considered folk punk but they sound nothing like the 5000+ other folk punk bands who literally define the genre. Put violent femmes in the same room as ANNOYING or blackbird raum and theres literally nothing to compare. And grind is a die hard underground genre, equating sales or popularity to quality in that genre is laughable because most of us would say any band who stopped doing basement shows are sellouts and usually thats true. You cant be sales oriented in a DIY scene, at that point you might as well sign with a record label and start pumping out pop tracks as fast as possible
@Dentalflan Okay but Violent Femmes may be a popular record in general punk circles, but very few folk punk listeners would put it as their top folk punk record. To many the idea would probably not even come up as most of the folk punk subculture is based around the music from the late 90s and onwards.
the dead milkmen not being on here is a CRIME, and i probably would have picked one of bikini kill’s albums for riot grrrl, but otherwise, great list! you really know yr stuff :)
I’m not gonna lie. That section when the artist was on the first line instead of the second line broke my immersion for a hot second. But I love the albums I knew and am curious about the ones I didn’t so thanks for showing me new music.
Hey boy(z), you did a good work, I know there is many subgenres of punk rock music worldwide, and I'm here to talk about forró-core. It is a punk subgenre that was developed in Brasília (Brazil's capital) and the first (and main band that time) were Raimundos. (Only in first album (which is self-titled) and some songs in the second (named Lavô tá Novo) and [today] last album, Cantigas de Roda (such as Opa, Peraí Caceta, Esporrei na Manivela, BOP, O Gato da Rosinha, etc). Name explanation is very simple: "Forró" are some parties that were originated in brazilian northeast from XIX century. Do not confuse "forró" with "baião", the music that is played in that kind of parties. (And, of course, "core" is from hardcore punk). But in my opinion, the best album of this subgenre is the self-titled album of Jumentaparida, a defunct band of Cariri, a country town in the state of Ceará, who were part in the "Movimento Cabaçal", a cultural moviment that ocurred in 2000s, inspired by Manguebit moviment. Here is some bands that can fit in forrócore label (or just incorpored baião with rock music): Raimundos, Catapulta, Jumentaparida, Dr. Raiz, SoulZé, Selestinos and Farofa de Porco. Some of these bands has their records on RU-vid. Thank you for everyone that read this. Hope my low-level English was understandable. Bye
P.S.: I forgot to talk about lyrics. Sorry. Raimundos (and Selestinos as well) was influenced by an specific subgenre of baião named "forró de duplo sentido" (literally means "double entendre forró") [whose main artist in the 70s was Zenilton]. Because of that, their lyrics was full of dirty words and some stories that spoke about sex and drugs. The bands from "Movimento Cabaçal", such as Jumentaparida, SoulZé and Dr. Raiz, didn't incorpored these lyrics. In opposite to this, these bands incorpored lyrics that spoke the culture of their place, and some social issues of northeast as well
I always thought street punk was a funny thing to call it cuz I have never once seen one out wandering the street and it seems as though most of them live in the burbs
@@jay5467 people in the streets ain’t listening to anything like that bullshit it’s all rich kids masquerading as though they’re rebelling in some way when they’re literally not at all. Almost 100% white subculture
@@bigcheese2128 I like street punk dont get me wrong but when I see punks living on the streets, its almost entirely by choice and not for economical reasons
DIGITAL HARDCORE , DESCIPLES OF BELIAL SONGS OF PRAISE ..HARDCORE PUNK, CAHOS UK SHORT SHARP SHOCKED.............DEATH CHURCH GREAT ALBUM ..............23
As much as I love ASOB (Jeff Rosenstock is probably my favorite artist of all time) and Operation Ivy, the best ska punk album has to be Everything Goes Numb by Streetlight Manifesto. The quality of songwriting is leaps and bounds ahead of anything else of that era. Operation Ivy might be the progenitors of the genre, but Streetlight Manifesto perfected it.
This video is just amazing but im sad because im overwhelmed with all this. Its sad to know you will only know small fraction of good music in the world. But video good. Also, Polish ones! There are more polish that i like
You can always become a Rateyourmusic power user! Only a fraction of these were a surprise to me because that's where I frequently go to find my share of "hmm today I will listen to insert punk subgenre here"
