No one will ever fully agree on a list of even the top 1000 albums but I do think the fact that this list is the result of tens of thousands of music fans voting on albums they love gives it some level of weight and credibility that a list from say, Rolling Stone or Pitchfork will never have.
while true, most people voting here are very clearly influenced by, for example, Rolling Stone or Pitchfork. the top 40 is still terribly reeking of Rolling Stone core album picks. thankfully, as time goes by, the site seems to be getting more and more younger users, which are making genres like hip hop and electronic music get their deserved recognition on the charts
@@xbenci Hip hop is pretty well represented on this list imo, it’s very loved over there. It’s really music by women they tend struggle with. I do agree there could be a bit more love for electronic music though.
@NIAAGGR567 ye look man I’m not here to criticize them or anything and at the end of the day we all know music is subjective, but yeah some of these rankings are “incorrect” music - standers wise and yeah whatever, I know it’s not the owner of this channel making these rankings and Rym is good but it has some obvious flaws
@NIAAGGR567 technically music is subjective since ppl react to it in different ways according to the emotions and experiences they’ve had and how that music resonates to them but yeah I agree there are some aspects that are objective, although id say that philosophically speaking the more objective you try to define music the less creative it gets but that’s just some food for thought
@@WhiteAssassion677 and yet some ppl enjoy lil pump more than Pink Floyd, how would you explain that? Is there something wrong in that? No cuz there is no right or wrong in music. Maybe you can define that guy as having cheap music taste or whatever but you can showcase an artistic merit over anything pretty much and I’ll say it again that there is some objectivity to music but just like how you can listen to who dat boy by Tyler and love the aggression and punchiness of it other ppl won’t like those qualities and say it’s just noisy and yelling and whatever. Stuff like familiarity also play a big factor
@@musicminute2004 close to the edge is considered by a lot of critics to be the pinnacle of prog (but yeah this types of lists doesn't make any sense and it's not even worth to discuss over)
Same bro it actually hits on another level it’s insane I started with Kid A and I knew it was supposed to be good, had no idea what to think after the first 2 other than that it was weird af, then I heard National Anthem and I fucking died Amazing how every album and independent project is incredible from them (except Pablo Honey but you know), having 3 albums in the top 10 of all times crazy
@@stevemalek2970 Didn't say anything about not being allowed to have opinions on this list. All I'm just saying is that this list was compiled by the opinions of thousands of music fans, not one singular person
Albums I feel like should’ve made this list Carole King - Tapestry Joni Mitchell - Blue Sade - Love Deluxe Prince and the Revolution - Purple Rain Lauryn Hill - The Miseducation of Lauryn Hill Michael Jackson - Thriller Aretha Franklin - I Never Loved a Man the Way I Love You Public Enemy - It Takes a Nation of Millions to Hold Us Back Fleetwood Mac - Rumours Kanye West - Graduation
Unfortunately purple rain is deweighted because its a soundtrack and just doesnt have that many ratings. Its rating is 4.12 so it actually would get into the top 100. Also i would like to add that ranked #3 in soundtracks so thats already a great achievement.
@@kuunoooo7293 There were far more than 2 rap albums, and this is an all time list, rap as a genre is only a few decades old, so it’s to be expected that some other genres appear more frequently, especially rock which is extremely broad.
If you're sorting by new, scroll back up and sort by top. It's all boomers whining about there not being enough rock when the list was pretty much all rock
@@savannahmapping2340it's a pretty well-known phenomenon that people view the music they listened to in their teenage and early adult years on a pedestal. As a teenager who listens to a lot of older music i fear that i will seem more and more pretentious as i get older lol.
They’re absolutely overrepresented in the ranking. Maybe if it were the best 100 albums of the 90’s and early 2000s, they could have 3 albums in the first half. But this thing is an all-time ranking.
@bltelysian True. One in the 90’s and two in the 2000s, is it? Then many voters were teenagers at the time or something. To be clear, I’m from that period too. Anyway, I like their good stuff, but that doesn’t change the fact that they’re overrepresented in an all-time ranking.
Heaven or Las Vegas definitely deserves its spot as the best album of 1990 and the 57th best album of all time, and I will not hear any arguments to the contrary!
0:21 my favourite album of all time, considering how Massive Attack (and generally Down Tempo for that matter) are only really big in the UK, seeing them crack the Top 100 is enough for me. I love this album, to me, it’s just perfect.
YO i started to listen to Massive Attack because of this comment and came to find that one of the songs they made is the intro song to my all time favourite TV show House MD. THANK YOU RANDOM PERSON
random question: do you also listen to royksopp? i used to a lot and i got always told they are similar to massive attack but never got round to listening to them.
@@anthraxboiYeah, it's though to choose between those 2. I'm also a guy that thinks Islands is underrated. It actually is hard to say they have a subpar album. Amazingly consistent for sure, unlike Floyd f.i.
The amount of people that don’t understand that all these ratings come from a website where people “rate your music” is baffling to me. I don’t care if you think “x is overrated” it’s not this guy’s opinion it’s based on thousands of other’s opinions it’s what the rating number is based off. This doesn’t mean your favorite album is “invalidated” it means that it’s probably either unheard of “low ratings” or people on the internet don’t like it. Y’all don’t have to be babies just because your favorite artist isn’t in the top 1 or because recurring artist have multiple albums in the top spots it’s literally just a number. TL;dr it’s literally just stats bro it’s not going to kill you 😂
For anyone curious: Albums which have left the top 100 since this vid was made: -Rubber soul -Agætis birjun -Tago Mago -Daydream nation -Black sabbath(self titled) Albums that entered the top 100 since this vid was made: -Clube da esquina -Velocity : Design : Confort - Grace -Ants from up there -98.12.28 男達の別れ
respect for this list. I don't know every album on here but respect for Death - Symbolic, pretty much every hip-hop album, ...Endtroducing and each Radiohead album
No list is perfect because music is constantly changing, evolving and moving. One minute your favourite might be Ziggy then ok computer then speaking in tongues then tpab or Dsotm. There's so much and it's so varied that I personally could never place a definite favourite, I just love music
Artists that make 1 appearance (Great): Massive Attack Death Nine Inch Nails Daft Punk Sigur Rós Sonic Youth Pharoah Sanders GZA OutKast Have A Nice Life J Dilla Leonard Cohen Aphex Twin Tyler, The Creator Talk Talk Swans The Doors Marvin Gaye Elliott Smith Cocteau Twins DJ Shadow Led Zeppelin Yes Television Danny Brown Frank Ocean Pixies Slowdive The Microphones Kate Bush Portishead The Smiths Fishmans Nick Drake Neutral Milk Hotel Slint The Cure The Beach Boys Wu-Tang Clan Nas John Coltrane Nico Charles Mingus Talking Heads my bloody valentine Artists that make 2 appearences (Ok I see you): Nirvana Metallica Can Stevie Wonder Sufjan Stevens The Velvet Underground A Tribe Called Quest Jimi Hendrix Joy Division MF DOOM Björk Godspeed You! Black Emperor King Crimson Kendrick Lamar Artists that make 3 appearances (Holy cow): Kanye West Black Sabbath Bob Dylan Miles Davis Pink Floyd Radiohead Artist that makes 4 appearences (Is this cheating?): David Bowie Artist that makes 5 appearences (You guys really seem to know which band you consider to be the best) The Beatles
List of albums in the video available on Bandcamp for those curious. Sigur Rós - Ágaetis byrjun (1999) Can - Tago Mago (1971) Sonic Youth - Daydream Nation (1988) Stufjan Stevens - Carrie & Lowell (2015) Can - Future Days (1973) Have a Nice Life - Deathconsciousness (2008) J Dilla - Donuts (2006) Aphex Twin - Selected Ambient Works 85-92 (1992) Tyler, the Creator - Igor (2019) Sufjan Stevens - Illinois (2005) MF Doom - MM…Food (2004) Swans - Soundtracks for the Blind (1996)* Elliott Smith - Either/Or (1997) Björk - Homogenic (1997) Danny Brown - Atrocity Exhibition (2016) Godspeed You Black Emperor! - F♯ A♯ ∞ (1997) The Microphones - The Glow Pt. 2 (2001) Björk - Vespertine (2001) Neutral Milk Hotel - In the Aeroplane Over the Sea (1998) Slint - Spiderland (1991) Godspeed You Black Emperor! - Lift Yr. Skinny Fists Like Antennas to Heaven! (2000) Radiohead - In Rainbows (2007)* Radiohead - Kid A (2000)* Madvillain - Madvillainy (2004) Radiohead - OK Computer (1997)* *Indicates that not all the tracks can be streamed prior to purchase
I wish to shake the hand of the person who compiled this list, SWANS & Slint, you are a legend and somehow entered my record collection as I have half of these..
Just a recommendation I'm throwing in the air like that but I personally would like to see more videos based on specific years/decades. I like genre-based videos but year or decade-based videos would be an even better showcase of how music is such a chameleon-like, versatile form of art, imo!
Yes, this probably ought to be renamed the top albums of the Anglosphere, because you are not going to convince me that out the millions of artists in the world 99% percent of the best music comes exclusively from the UK and US
Solid list! Here's my personal top 50 albums of all time imo 1. Nirvana - unplugged in New York 2. Townes Van Zandt - live at the old quarter 3. Nirvana - in utero 4. Joy Division - unknown pleasures 5. Alice in chains - dirt 6. Velvet underground and Nico 7. The stooges - fun house 8. Nick Drake - pink moon 9. Bob Dylan- bringing it back home 10. The Melvins- stoner witch 11. Black Sabbath - self titled 12. Nirvana - nevermind 13. Elliot Smith - self titled 14. Morphine - the night 15. The stooges - self titled 16. The doors - self titled 17. Bob Dylan- self titled 18. Mark Lanegan - whiskey for the holy ghost 19. Queens of the Stone age - lullabies to paralyze 20. Winter - into the darkness 21. Alice in chains - unplugged in New York 22. Darkthrone- under a funeral moon 23. 2pac - all eyes on me 24. Pantera - the great southern trend kill 25. Buzzoven - sore 26. Perfume genius - too bright 27. The stooges - raw power 28. Stone Temple pilots- tiny music 29. The Jesus lizard - liar 30. Tool- Aenima 31. Smashing pumpkins - infinite sadness 32. Soundgarden - badmotorfinger 33. Bob Dylan- Free wheelin' Bob Dylan 34. Dax Riggs- say goodnight to the world 35. Queens of the Stone age - rated R 36. Nine inch nails - the fragile 37. Dr. Dre- the chronic 38. Snoop Dogg - doggy style 39. The dicks- these people 40. Tool- undertow 41. Cypress Hill - black Sunday 42. Joy Division - closer 43. The Jesus lizard - goat 44. Alice in chains - self titled 45. The Melvins - Houdini 46. The germs - GI 47. Scratch acid - the greatest gift 48. Mayhem- de mysteriis dom sathanas 49. X- Los Angeles 50. Mark Lanegan- blues funeral
I love how there’s so many boomers or “le wrong generation” kids complaining about rap and electronic music on here. Even though Tpab is a masterpiece, it being at number one also has the added benefit of making these kinds of people seethe, and it’s pretty godamn funny.
@@ash_11117 I don't know, maybe I'm not looking at it objectively because I listen to dire straits too much, but for me communiuque is in god's realm. I haven't seen many fans except me. The self-titled album is listened to a lot by people. Brother in arms is also very good but one of them could be here.
Why not? Their albums have been hailed as some of the greatest of all time, and for good reason. They are one of the most influential bands of the past few decades.
@@thepillowcomfortable1880 i'm a massive radiohead fan but no matter how big of a fan i am of any artist, i would never put three of their albums in my top 10 of all time
Sure, I might not agree with all the picks here, but instead of complaining or arguing about it, I simply accept that my music taste doesn't align with popular opinion and I move on with my day
Best albums here (imo): Late Registration In Utero Master of Puppets Nevermind Symbolic Rubber Soul The Downward Spiral Discovery Daydream Nation Black Sabbath Midnight Marauders Ride the Lightning Station to Station Blood on the Tracks The Doors What's Going On Electric Jimi Hendrix Master of Reality The College Dropout The Low End Theory Blonde Hounds of Love White Album Songs in the Key of Life Sgt. Peppers' Lonely Club Band Animals My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy Pet Sounds Enter the Wu-Tang Clan Kind of Blue Paranoid Illmatic Revolver The Velvet Underground & Nico Remain in Light The Rise and Fall of Ziggy Stardust and the Spiders from Mars Abbey Road The Dark Side of the Moon In Rainbows Loveless Kid A Wish You Were Here OK Computer To Pimp a Butterfly
@@ash_11117thats not the album he means. And dark side of the moon is overrated. Pink floyd are awful. Money is a good song but nah, pink floyd are so bad
People really act as if an album is bad if it isn't in this list. This is a list of the top 100 albums OF ALL TIME. So your favorite album can be great and still not make the list.
Missing: 40oz to freedom - Sublime Ten - Pearl Jam Astral Weeks - Van Morrison Exile on Main Street - Rolling Stones Superunknow - Soundgarden Rust in peace - Megadeth Parsley, sage, rosemary and thyme - Simon & Garfunkel Cavalcade - The Flatliners the boy with the arab strab - Belle & Sebastian Ill Communications - Beastie Boys Rage against the machine - RATM Siamese Dream - Smashing Pumpkins Moving Pictures - Rush
Isn’t it funny that just a month before this video came around, there was the top 100 Worst music releases. What a Contrast between the two videos. Also, it’s funny how both of these lists feature an album by The Beach Boys.
La lista la dominarían Yes, Genesis y Crimson en los primeros puestos. Obvio se colarían bandas como Tull, ELP, Floyd, Rush o GG también con sus mejores producciones. Y Kansas posiblemente no estaría tan alto como realmente merecen...
for me , you forget : london calling (clash ), scum ( napalm death ), shadows of the sun ( ulver ) , never mind the bollocks ( sex pistols ) , treasure ( cocteau twins ), aqualung ( jethro tull ), selling england by the pound ( genesis ) , the unforgettable fire ( u2 ), thick as brick ( jethro tull ), elephant ( white stripes ), fresh fruits for rotting vegetables (dead kennedys ) ... these are some that coming in my mind...
@@Darth_Bulldog yeah man, it was astounding. i’m Always listening to music throughout the day so i knocked this down in around 40 days. i’ve listened/listen to many artists here so i’m glad i was able to delve deeper into each of their discographies. what do you think so far ?
BEFORE WATCHING THIS VIDEO OR COMMENTING; KNOW THIS this is ONLY a top 100 list and putting whatever album you think should be in on the list ALSO means pushing out other insanely good albums, not everything can fit in a top 100, the common albums people are wondering why they arent in this list are mostly hovering near the top 100, which is impressive considering that there are likely over 35,000 albums that have enough ratings to be in the contending spots for the top 100
Wasn’t expecting these but albums I think should’ve made it Alice In Chains - Dirt Soundgarden - Superunknown Pearl Jam - Ten Linkin Park - Hybrid Theory
I think Demon Days by Gorillaz is a great album that I wish could’ve made it to the list. Also 13 by Blur, practically anything by PJ Harvey (she’s amazing), London Calling by The Clash, Last Splash by The Breeders and many more.
3:51 I urge ALL music lovers to check that one out. If you liked Floyd, Radiohead, Crimson or even some of the most "out there" Beatles and Queen stuff, you might enjoy this album with a bit of patience.
I can see Rym charts are big fans of Radiohead lol...how about Michael Jackson, Abba, the Doors, the Queen, Simon and Gurfunkel, Oasis, Cranberries, U2, Depeche Mode, Elton John, Madonna, Tina Turner, Deep Purple, George Michael and many others? Where are they?
Honestly only a few of them deserve to be high on this list. Deep Purple? For sure, Machine Head is top 20 at least, I mean if Paranoid got that spot, why didn't Purple also got there?
Ill be honest i cant help but feel like this list would be entirely different if fantano never existed. Albums like lift your skinny fists probably wouldnt be up here if it werent for him. I think he has plenty of bad takes but hes put me onto some of the best music ive ever heard and i can appreciate him for that
Bjork deserves two entries: one for Homogenic, and another for Vespertine. Ride The Lightning for best 1984 album is a tough call when you also had Prince's Purple Rain (it should've made it to the list rather than Sign O' The Times!). Radiohead does NOT deserve three entries among the very best (but Ok Computer surely does!). But, overall, it was still a solid list nonetheless.
Comparing this to the recent Apple Music "definitive" list lol There's never going to be a good "definitive" list, but these are fun to discover more music.
Artists who appear more than once The Beatles (5) David Bowie (4) Kayne West (3) Miles Davis (3) Pink Floyd (3) Radiohead (3) Black Sabbath (3) Bob Dylan (3) Nirvana (2) Metallica (2) Stevie Wonder (2) Jimi Hendrix (2) Joy Division (2) Bjork (2) Can (2) A Tribe Called Quest (2) Godspeed You Black Emperor (2) King Crimson (2) The Velvet Underground (2) Kendrick Lamar (2) Sufjan Stevens (2) MF Doom (2) If I made a mistake let me know
A very good list. My ranking would be different, and some of those albums would probably be more in the 100-200 area for me, but who cares? This is here is still better than most music websites lists. There are only 14 albums on this video that I don't already know and own, and I'm pretty sure a lot of them are great.
