The Evolution of Carter | Yellowstone 

that scared the hell out of her

I hate how they did this scene…we all know she not his momma…but she acts like it

And she instinctively says "Hey Baby...😬

Beth is fighting it. Rip is fighting it. But he is their kid.

One of the most heartbreaking scenes in the entire series imo

I don’t understand why the hell she did that. He’s a mini Rip.

@@mckaelyntennison Dude exactly he now looks like a teenage Rip. Whenever they show Rip flashbacks I have to double check that it’s not Carter.

😭😭😭

true - his mama was real and her baby was equal to it....she may come around yet

We still knew exactly how she felt about that boy after that scene was over, too. She fooled him but no one else.

Poor baby. I think she meant it about not feeling like she could be a mom, but she definitely loved him.

She loves that boy like her own, you can see it. I hope in season 5 her and rip adopt him as their own

Hahah so good!! Love her character, well written show ❤

I don’t think they will ever have a mother son relationship. They’re two lost souls from two different times who fortunately crossed paths. Cause only we know how much they need each other.

Beth and Rip are not good people

@@codranine6054 I think they are exactly what they need to help them both heal old wounds.

@Mr Zimm I agree they may not be great people but let's face facts we deal with horrible people in real life everyday. That has nothing to do with having kids unfortunately.

@@Mr_Zimm The good people rarely do good things. When you have seen the world a lot one thing you realize it is those who have seen the worst are many times who has the insight to do the right thing. The average "Good" people does not have the frame of reference for the need of doing Good or what is the good thing to do if it hits them on their face.

🤣😂🤣😂🤣

The emotions, a split second of joy followed by surprise, sadness and even fear show what a great actor Kelly is.

Which scene are you talking about

@@ashleytrout7452 the last one, with Beth and Carter, when he said "Morning, mama"

@@dmitrytannill7436 that was soo sweet, it’s even worse when she said “hey baby” so smoothly back to him

Having both their traits, good and bad would be a lethal combo.

He's like the bunk house grandpa. So sweet

@@Heck111yur One question remains. Is he truly in his late 50? Or does he refuse to acknowledge his true age? 🤣

@@tjjordan4207 it's obvious he just denies his true age you can tell when Rip was a teenager he was in his 40s then

@@johneverette699 Still, he looks good for someone that old, especially if he's in his 70s.

🤨 💭 Hmmm, that wasn’t a serious growth spurt during 9 months period. Remember the Indian girl announced she was pregnant at the end of season 4; then got into a car accident in season 5E1. Therefore, it is within 9months…

She's so gangster it hurts lol

Wait till you see him in season 5!

When, Carter said, "Good Morning, Momma" when, Beth walked past him through the horse stalls, my heart just fell and cried for, Carter.....

Rip calls him son a lot of times. I don’t think he means it in the general older man/young man dynamic either. Both him and Beth need to get over their trauma and just accept him as the kid fate has given them.

@@nexpro6118 held his heart out to her.

Love the honesty of the characters in this show.

Yes better than Tate.

For real

Truly, cause is addiction n amounts to putting ur habit before those ur "supposed "to care for n kids become alienated n resentful, hateful It's tough when ur a kid n u don't always have words for understanding what ur feeling, emotions," you react . Carter's pretty cool all things considered 👍♥️

That's why I hate addict, alcoholic and smokers

​@@crisostomoalmeida670 As do I. Nope kids should ever, EVER have to say the things he said to his deadbeat excuse of a father. I can't begin to imagine how i would have coped, or not coped, were I in that kid's position.

I'm criying 😔😔😔

Jerry Lee "Funny that Beth doesn't want the title of mother, but she has been a mother to the whole family from Episode 1. Respect" Edit: "Chase" corrected to read "Kayce" Jerry Lee, "respect" for sure👍🏼, but maybe for a different reason. She's more of a leader, 2nd to her dad, of the family. She would have been the tough no non sense son, if she had been a boy. She just seemed to have stepped up to assuming a leadership roll. Kayce, for a long time after getting out the military, wanted little and nothing to do with involving himself and his family with the ranch, much less to being eventual heir and leader. Jamie was essentially brought on board as a youngster and "adopted" into the family by John as a "son". Taylor Sheridan, writes ALL the dialogue for all his shows including Yellowstone and the actors deliver the lines as written...with no deviations or improvisations. I mention that, because like many viewers, there may be a character the just gets on your nerves or we think that they need to be "gone". All that is in Taylor's hands. I have a theory about Beth. I see Beth as the Dutton family "Fixer". She is almost a superwoman, but like Superwoman or Superman, she can't be everywhere and "fix" everything, every time. Her "Kryptonite" may be that she doesn't believe she cannot "fix" everything. She seems to thrive on attacking problems and people. If she had been a guy,. she would have probably made a good special forces operator. People say that Beth is being seen too much lately in recent episodes. I'm wondering if it is a set us up to find her finally overwhelmed from trying to "fix" too many things. Beth is devoted her dad and all things Yellowstone. Between John and Rip, Rip is the one who has a way of reaching and talking sense to Beth. It may be Rip who may have to be there to "catch" Beth, if and when she hits her saturation point. She isn't going to be an example of a mother, in Carter's life, but he is observing that there is more to her than most see, based on her interaction and relationship with Rip. My apologies for blathering on so much.

She *does* want the life of a mother. She just doesn't want others to think/know that she does, lest she be be seen as weak.

Not the responsibility just to do an stop when wants to

Never heard of an adoption?

@@gandres_07 Yes I have. Although that is not how the character Beth operates. Absolutely she can adopt Carter and he can call her mom. However at the end of the day, Beth knows she is not his real mother. Beth is a realist. And being one of the bloodlines to Yellowstone Dutton Ranch, Beth cannot give another line to the ranch like Kasey and Jaime can. Adopting Carter would be amazing and Beth can ensure Carter has a place at the ranch but when it comes to what Beth, Jaime and Kasey does for the ranch, Carter cannot do that. Although Carter can be the next Rip Wheeler of the business. A good hard working hand that is loyal beyond a shadow of a doubt.

She can be very black and white. A biological mom does not make you a mom roght away... just like family it is not always by blood... She too hung up on not able to have a baby and her own mother died. It stands in the way of something beautifull and fullfilling.. so sad....

Totally draws u in to the story,scene! So does everyone else too, great cast! 👏

Yessss, she is amazing!!!

Yes! 👏🏻

Man I want to move there. People not taking crap from others.

@@batman66ism But with respect due.

@@sonofizzy Oh of course. That's the key word.

This needs to be said to every Karen who tries to poke her nose in shit

I really like Carter can't wait for season 5

When, Carter said, "Good Morning, Momma" when, Beth walked past him through the horse stalls, my heart just fell and cried for, Carter.....

there's a novel and movie with both names (mentioned above) combined...

I love it. Not only does it show how she feels about herself but how carter gotten so comfy with her 😢❤

Whats that episode?

I wanna see them fight to the death😂

@@Link.dg1 I wanna see Rip destroy Jamie painfully and slow!

@@richardcasados 😂 honestly same

@@Link.dg1 it's interesting to see what's gonna happen next when it resumes in the Summer. The season was just starting to get good. I thought it was gonna shoe the reunion with Jimmy before it ended. But oh well.

@@Link.dg1 wrestle maybe but when push comes to shove cousins always have each others backs

Apparently, John wants this kid to shut up and ride. Besides, talking is not concentrating.

If hypocritical.

@@monteagudoabeezekieljardie7884. John didn’t mind talking, he did kind how much Carter was cursing

Dam ! Well said! U have the gift of gab, heartfelt 👏♥️

Beautifully put 👍

She is his mama, but, since she can never have children, it is too painful for her to adopt the title. But, regardless of what she says, she is his mama - mama by choice - now and until the end of time. And Lord help anyone who tries to do him wrong while she still walks the earth.

Wait... Why does he have to get a haircut?!

I bet he becomes a Michael Corleone type of character.

Not unfortunately. He was tough already but had zero self worth, having to earn something set him up for life.

Idk if Kenzie meant making him work. which was definitely good for him. Beth was too hard on him in the store, but she has her own anger issues and he upset her by responding to the woman accusing her of abuse. I'm glad they worked it out, and he now has numerous different adults to look after him and teach him different things.

Yeah it's like he just doesn't respect boundaries or know his place , like with the shirt And Beth don't play n going to pull that shirt off of him n let him know, it's my way or the high way! Tough love, well striped! I truly love this show 👏♥️

@@whitespirit26 I humbly disagree hon, I was one like Carter n couldn't, wouldn't take no for n answer n u needa be straightened out or it leads to stealing n disobedience in many forms ☮️And scripted in, it shows itself. Really great writing

You don't sound like Carter, he started listening to them before the shirt incident.

But ur still here to speak bro, Survivor! ♥️👏

Sorry but you made it

Sending you so many hugs ❤️ my older brother died 12 years ago (yesterday) back when I was 19 in a motorcycle crash, and my mom died this past November from non smoker’s lung cancer. I thought nothing in the world could compare to the pain of losing my brother so suddenly, but losing my mom, who was such a beautiful soul to such a dreadful disease so gradually cut me deep in ways I never imagined. My dad and I are still coming to terms with the sudden loss of her, four months after she was diagnosed. I hope things ever only go up from here for you filled with joy and light❤️.

❤❤❤

Really, that kid they can't make 👏 Can't wait for more 👍

I wasn't angry at her bc I understood her reasons, but I wanted to hug the poor kid so badly.

@@whitespirit26 That's cuz you're a feminine gal.. Beth would only dare to be feminine and vulnerable around Rip and that's cuz he's monster.. the only one that can match (and surpass) her ruthlessness

@@TopNotch770 Rip is a stand-up man, a Western Knight, not a monster. And no one will hurt his lady while he is around. I particularly enjoy the scene where paid thugs try and he comes charging in and takes them out, running right into pistol fire. Favorite quote later that night when he looks at what they did to her face: "I wish that I could bring 'em back to life so that I could kill 'em all over again." My kind of hero.

@@TopNotch770 I don’t understand. Can you please explain it?

@@TopNotch770 beth comforted the kid when the first met. cried when he hurt her. she is vulnerable around him. shit even the 2nd dinner they have shes smiling ear to ear because she has a chance to be a mom. something she thought shed never beable to. thats why she snaped back the way she did. she resigned herself to never being called mom. do you even watch the show lmfao

For robbing a store?? So awful.

@@whitespirit26 absolutely terrible thing to say.. but this is why this show is so good! Goes over the line sometimes.

@@brayallen7290 Plus I think the point was that Beth saw what attitude he was up against and wasn't going to let him be given up on.

@@whitespirit26 right she completely seen rip in him. But that line.. Jesus lol

Yeah, poor sweet kid. Thank goodness he got a good place.

Hope Carter turns into Rip for Tates Kaycee

@@Mark-ki7ic a scenario that intrigues me is if Tate’s mom’s side influences him into taking control of the ranch and letting them settle on it and Carter (the outsider) steps up for the Duttons to lead the fight to regain it

I just hope they dont put Tate against Carter as i think it would be a bad thing in my opinion. If it happens i think it may partially ruin the story line between those 2 characters. I dont see how it would actually add anything positive and really just kind of be a bad bump in the road. I think it would almost be a obligatory story line that really wouldnt do any good or add more to the show.. just my open ended opinion.

Yes! I'm real excited and interested to see how theor dynamic goes

Now I'm imagining Carter meeting Tate. The two enjoying each other's company as time passes. Carter being an older brother figure for Tate; and maybe showing him how to play a little poker.

Big hypocrisy about the swearing.

My favorite Carter quote is ‘I know what I wanna be when I grow up.’ Jake: ‘What’s that kid?’ Carter: Him, I wanna be him’ Jake looks toward Rip and Carter says ‘No, him’ and points to John.❤️

What did I miss

That was bill the butcher from the boys

You got it. There was so much in just that quick look on her face (says a lot about her acting skills). A lot of nuances dating back to HER life as a kid specifically how her mother died and her inability to have kids. It's all in there. At first she liked hearing (maybe been longing to hear) then you can see the impact of her mother wash over her face. Great acting on both parts. He and Tate are the future of yellowstone

He is not same as Rip. Rip has honest heart.