The fact that Whitebeard kept fighting long after half his head got blown off was one of the most badass things to happen in One Piece, and I hate how the anime toned that down.
Actually it's so stupid. Yeah, I know this is One Piece and everything is possible here blah-blah-blah, but even in this universe, you totally completely absolutely no way can survive with chunk of your destroyed. The part of freaking brain is destroyed, it's 100% certain death even for these demigods of anime. So anime made some sense here although it obviously lost some dramatism.
I like knew but not by that much thought it was like his mustache maybe his ear and like part of his shoulder. But not that much of his brain cooked. The pirate warriors games also censored it in a funny way by just removing the mustache or in pirate warriors 4 they just had the model dodge like always but no damage. Pirate warriors 4 really was lazy in parts.
@@Cathart1c I think Whitebeard would have eventually died from the injuries he got fighting Akainu. The way I see it he was just running on adrenaline and will power.
i read the Manga much later after watching the Anime so i also didn't know at first, but then i kept seeing people in comments go like "WB lost half his head to akainu", like really they kept saying "half his head", eventually i went to check in the Manga and what do you know- he lost like 20% or less of his head. still way more significant than simply losing the mustache, but that "lost half his face" exaggeration really annoyed me at the time.
@@haissaig7137 theres a difference between straight up filler and anime cannon… anime cannon is for example extending a very short battle (assuming the outcome and major moments remain equal) another thing is something that directly contradicts the cannon source (aka akainu vs WB, sanji vs page one or drake and all the movies and filler arcs basically )
I prefer the manga version of Zeff losing his leg because it really goes towards the whole point the themes of Sanji’s backstory, that being the importance of food.
I couldn't look at the scene though. It really is such a visceral scene. So, partly, i am fine with how the anime changed it. You still see the importance of food from Zeff giving sanji all of the food. You still get the kind of man Zeff is without such an intense scene being animated.
@@goldmemberpb , I’ve bled more blood all of the floor after trying to shave my head bald, and the blood loss I suffered from that had way more blood loss shown in Sanji’s flashback in the manga, so it didn’t really bother me that much.
@@RoronoaZoro-ur6hr It is less blood loss and just how gruesomely Oda depicts Zeff's leg getting crushed. It bends almost 45 degree upwards. I still wince just thinking about it.
@@Mantosasto You're right, but the way Oda portrayed it was for comedy. Not for Sanji nobly coming up with a plan to save another slave. Hence why the anime changed it...
I know this scene wasn’t censored, but the part where luffy is carrying Nami to drum castle always makes me cringe when he starts to slide back down the mountain and his skin just starts to tear off because of the cold.
6:20 I think if we go through the context of the whole scene then Sanji's, " Nami, could we buy her too." isn't problematic. as I recall, their plan was to buy out Camie from the auction then free her. so Sanji asking Nami to buy that girl can also mean that she will be freed after they purchase her.
What else could it mean? Sanji isn’t the type to enslave a woman. He may hire girls to be in bunny suits but he would never do anything that is bad. Just by seeing it out of context I have no problem it is only if people don’t know Sanji.
I only recently learned about zeff’s leg. I was anime only until skypia, because i wanted the story to go by a little faster. I got my brother into one piece, and he’s been manga only from the beginning. He saw the sanji backstory with Zeff when I fist watched it and told me the difference after he read It.
@@dogboy8679 Somehow, I lasted allllllllllllll the way to Whole Cake Island before I lost the tolerance I had build up of Toei's bs and switched it to the manga. I've been happily binge-reading it again hence
@@KsaksaG It's actually more than one person with the same channel name and profile. It's not hard to do. In fact the profile picture on a few of the other ones still uses the old model.
I don’t think the buying thing is that deep, we knew Sanji would treat her like a Queen regardless, he wouldn’t treat a lady like a slave at that point in the manga/anime it’s already quite clear, I understand it though. It’s not like he knew they were going to save the slaves due to Luffy’s recklessness at that point, if anything it was a way of saying to save her.
@@Broducts , Law is just a more edgier angsty version of Luffy which I guess if the fans of Law in the anime/manga likes his character then I won’t try to change their minds on hating Law as a character, but he isn’t my all time favorite character like Zoro is.
I remember when Buggy actually killed an underling in his debut. You know, the guy who said "robber knows", and Buggy took it as "rubber nose", so he rather brutally killed the guy with a cannon.
In defense of the manga about Sanji wanting to "buy" the girl: If I recall correctly, they were commenting about when they would show Cammie and then Sanji asked if they could buy the girl too, Chopper and Nami got that as a misunderstanding of his interpretation. We know Sanji as the ultimate simp and gentleman, his intentions would be to free both Cammie and the poor girl, but the anime made a good job too showing how disgusted he is, it would be perfect to mix both his reaction of shock in the manga and his wish of saving the lady in the anime.
As a scientist, I am less concerned about the fact that you drank dark matter and more concerned that you just have a cup of dark matter lying around in your room.
The Zeff thing is great to me because he shows he's the kinda of pirate who wouldn't even think of letting a kid starve. And that's exactly the crew that the Straw Hats are. Not to mention how often we meet starving kids in the show
In the anime during the scene where Zeff saved Sanji it was shown that he brought his severed leg with him when he saved Sanji, and when Sanji discovers Zeff’s bag is full of treasure, you can see a left bone next to the bag.
8:17 The knife actually goes all the way through his chest in the anime as well, it's just a colouring mistake: if you look closely you can spot the tip of the knife, which by mistake got colored black. I guess one of the animators assumed it was a part of Sanji's jacket
🤣🤣🤣 Have a great day! God Bless! Stay strong, stay safe and take care of yourselves! Wishing everyone the best! Jesus loves you! May the Holy Spirit guide you! 😇 💗🕊 Cheers to a better year buddy! 💞🥂🍻
I still find it fascinating that Toei removed the scene where kid Luffy stabbed himself in the face resulting in his iconic scar. That was supposed to be your first impression of Luffy, the 2nd page of the manga, and really throw you into a wild ride, and instead we got it cut and our first scene of the show was a couple of no-name sailors wanting ocean-beer I think this and the Zeff leg point to a trend of Toei having issues with self-harm in the story
@Tundra Mantra Yes, but they still cut out the moment of impact. In the manga, the act is shown in its full glory, with blood squirting out of Luffy's face with the cut and everything. In the anime, they cut away to Luffy's cry of pain and Shank's reaction to it.
While the anime does show people getting stabbed, and a lot of blood, it's quite different depicting a child nearly gouging their eye out. To air something on TV it has to go through a lot of checks to make sure it's "suitable" for a generalized audience, its stupid, but these types of complaints are even more dumb because this isn't a new thing.
Zeff losing his is one of the very few major changes they kept consistent even to present day. Whenever they reanimate some of the older scenes, they actually uncensor them. So, we actually see kid luffy get his scar, Bellmere getting shot in the head etc.
I really appreciate this video (well, all of your videos, but this one in particular) because I didn't realize how many changes there were in the anime. I'm a manga reader, occasional anime watcher (for OP). The examples of Whitebeard and Zeff hit me much harder because of how brutal they were and led me to appreciate the characters even more. Seeing these small but significant changes is really cool.
remember, whitebeard still fought despite half of his head blown out in the manga shows you that a man who has a lot to lose refuses to die no matter how hard you try to kill him.
@@bastardbastard4998 , it was exactly half his being blown clean off because even Shanks mentions that fact in the manga which was changed in the anime for some reason.
@@waynicliz the best thing anime has done,it was dumb for it to be still alive in manga and these mangatards never cease to amaze me by how instead if looking how well done a scene is they try to find fault..she stupidity knows no boundd huh
I would give Toei some credit with the Whitebeard scene, because yes they change him losing half of his face to only losing part of his mustache, however I think you may have forgotten but Akainu made an extra hole in his chest with his magma fist in the anime. So overral I'm fine how they did that scene in the anime
Nah … toei made it INSANELY unfair towards akainu… in the manga akainu showed as being as a lowball relative to marinford WB I would actually say he was definitely superior though but the anime just ruined it and thats why the admirals are still the most underrated characters ever
Thanks to the anime so many people downplay akainu and the admirals when the truth was whitebeard barely survived that encounter. Akainu is a beast who is one of the final villains of the series and now people think he's gonna get mid diffed
WB slapping Akainu around and Sakazuki being scared of WB in filler is what I have issue with. In the manga, WB cheapshots Akainu gets his head melted off. Then his final quake sends Akainu(who is still conscious) into the ground. Anime filler had Sakazuki paralyzed sliding slowly into the earth cursing WB. In the manga, Akainu is sent crashing into the ground but it is implied he begins chasing Jinbei again underground. WB basically did nothing to stop Akainu. Akainu already had told WB Pirates that he didn't care about them(even WB) just Ace and Luffy(because of their terrifying potential) Akainu a few minutes later popped up in front of Jinbei like nothing happened
I remember the moment with Pascia when I was reading the manga after I had caught up to the anime, it kind of stunned me. I knew Sanji was a creep but I never thought it would go to that level.
I dont think Sanji's comment is really bad at that time They are BUYING Kamie, wich is their friend, they are doing that to save her So sanji is saying to buy the girl to save her too, theres not humor into it either he is just asking to save that girl Yes, its cause he likes to save women, but thats all, ita not like they buy Kamie as a slave, for this girl would be the same
I keep forgetting that Sanji is the same age as Zoro in the Strawhat Pirate Crew, and for some reason I thought that Sanji was closer to Nami or Robin’s ages than Zoro’s age.
Zeff choosing to eat his own leg instead of risking taking even a little of the food he gave Sanji is such a noble character moment. He wasn’t above cannibalism but he doesn’t even consider hurting sanji to survive.
I got introduced to one piece through my best friend when I met him 2 years ago and decided I'd watch all of one piece to be able to talk to him about it, although achieving that I have also found myself entangled in this story almost as much as my own life because there is just SO much going on and I have come to love One Piece as my #1 show In the world and it awakened my love for pirates before I found I have pirate in my blood
8:40 - I don't know what Oda was thinking with this design. Breasts don't need to have swirls to hypnotize men. And some women. Edit: I'm an anime watcher, but I preferred the manga's version of what happened to Zeff's leg. It is a much stronger demonstration of what kind of man Zeff is and why Sanji admires him and feels he owes him so much.
I feel like it's more of an accidental effect. Oda likes to characterize characters a lot and give them weird designs, So he put swirls all around her clothing and realized his mistake too late. I as well didn't even realize there was anything wrong with it until GLR pointed it out in this video. I thought it was a stylistic change so I didn't really care much about it.
@@adarshsridhar6051 Yeah, I've got no complaints about it myself, and probably wouldn't have noticed it if it weren't pointed out. My "criticism" was just a joke about anime tiddies.
The biggest manga to anime change I will always remember is during Syrup Village. When Jango throws his circular blade at Luffy. In the anime Luffy caught it with his teeth and that was how I always knew it but when I finally read the manga and it hit Luffy in the back of the head and he just ripped it out and was ready to fight I was in oure shock and awe it was amazing
I'm surprised in the Finger Of Doom conversation it wasn't also brought up that Law's finger tattoos are upside-down for some reason in the anime too. Which is a change that I can not find a single reason for other than someone did it wrong the first time and no one ever corrected it. Fun fact, if you go to a (decent) tattoo artist and try to get knuckle tats going that way up, they WILL try to convince and explain to you why the other way is correct.
I mean in the defense of Sanji they where gonna buy Camie to save her so thats prolly what he also meant but i aint gonna deny the fact that he was prolly thinking more about how shed thank her saviors than actually saving her.
I’ve heard that the scene in Episode 83 when Luffy slides down the cliff he was climbing up was anime only, and that’s the one scene that traumatized me with physical violence alone
As a kid I somehow oversaw the part with the anchor chain and in my head canon Jeff always ate his own leg to survive because it made sense and they reveal the missing leg right after Sanji asks what he's been eating the whole time. Cool to see, that this was true in the manga all the time.
Fun fact! Because Shonen Jump and Manga/anime in general were harder to get a hold of in the west when I was young, I experienced the Zeff foot thing in what I consider the most dramatic way possible. I knew about him saving Sanji, but I never saw the panel where Zeff bashed his leg, nor the moment he removed it in the anime. The first time I saw Zeff without his leg on that rock was the same time Sanji saw it. And talk about a bone chilling reveal.
You know as an anime only watcher I always thought the fact that they draw attention to his leg after Sanji sneaks up on him to get more food implied that he ate it, to know that the manga confirms this makes me happy.
@@SaifKhan-ub9vf you know what considering all the things we've seen people survive from,Akainu one doesn't seen controversial,well unless you were an ace fan😂
Started reading the manga at the wano arc, and now I wish I had been reading the manga the whole time, I find there are al lot of upsides to reading through it rather than watching it (especially the pacing) though I still like watching the anime for the moving action stuff
The change to Sanji and Absalom's fight was actually due to a particularly nasty and highly-publicized stabbing incident shortly before that episode aired leading Toei to alter the scene in question to avoid being perceived as drawing parallels with current events. It's rather similar to the circumstances that led to the final episode of School Days not being broadcast on television in its day later on.
You know, I actually thought that Zeff lost his leg, and somehow saved it and then ate it... I guess my brain merged the two events to save space on memory or something.
There's something funny in the brazilian version regarding Sanji. We had our own company bringing the animes (One Piece, Yu-Gi-Oh, etc) to the brazilian media and they did A LOT of censorship. With Sanji they changed the cigarette to a lollipop and it's just so funny
Hey Liam! I'm currently doing a project on finding dark matter using laser plasma experiments, could you send me that dark matter? If you do I promise to mention you in Nobel prize speech.
@@GrandLineReview While we on this topic you said 3 month ago that “ Ranking all of Luffy getting captured moments being a good video idea” or something along that lines. I’m still waiting for that video
One thing I've noticed that in the end credits of the second movie, Vivi does have her hypnosis top. It's slightly cut off but you can clearly see the pattern
For me it was still just as impacting when whitebeard lost part of his beard cause in my eyes it was his pride that Ive never seen damaged prior so I knew it was over for him
The german dub of oncepiece and the jeff incidence heavily implied that he ate his own leg with a statement akin to "you can't eat gold" while sanji notices the missing leg. Also funny enough in that version the leg ripping underwater was censored.
My canon for Zeff's leg is that in the anime the "cut off leg to not drown" was a story to not permanently scar kid Sanji. And the only thing different from the manga was not standing up to give the food.
I think I might be biased, since at that point of the story, in the slave auction at Sabaody, I was still an anime only fan, but I kinda think that the anime version is more Sanji than the manga, though yes, I know the manga is the true canon, but what Sanji does in the anime seems more like something he’d actually do in that situation
Not really, he wanted to buy her to free her. The plan already was to buy cammie and free her, so buying another lady to save her doesnt seem unreasonable.
Liam posting videos fresh off that Yami Yami no Coffee. Dangerous. Also they definitely should’ve had Whitebeards face at least burned or an eye shut for the rest of the scene perhaps
Anime changed that too. They cut a hilarious scene of him getting lost in Wano. In Manga he just disappears and Luffy realizes what happened and laughs a ton. In anime Zoro randomly leaves to fight a random tiger and just doesn't come back
@@AsheSkye yeah him getting lost riding a dog is hilarious Have a great day! God Bless! Stay strong, stay safe and take care of yourselves! Wishing everyone the best! Jesus loves you! May the Holy Spirit guide you! 😇 💗🕊 Cheers to a better year buddy! 💞🥂🍻
If you check on the scene correctly, I believe Sanji IS stabbed all the way through, they just changed the color of the point of the knife maybe at the last minute because you can actually see the point of the knife in his chest at 8:14 is just painted the same way of his suit therefore seems like part of it. Or maybe is just me...
@4:05 For folks who don't remember or weren't privy infomercials of thee great hair removing product from Australia 🦘"Nads" our very Captain or Emperor's home idk this is the Grand Fleet which could qualify you for the title or Commodore perhaps🤷🏼♂️ anywho "Nads" is that fine hair removal product. It's been a minute since I've heard or seen a commercial or product in stores here in the states. Thanks for the throwback 🤣🤣 oh the jokes that came from our dirty minds 🤣😂
With the Sanji being stabbed by Absalom moment this was down to a stabbing that happened at the time. The incident was the akihabara massacre. I can't confirm if this is true but the dates line up the incident happened on the 8th june 08 the episode aired 22nd june 08. The explanation was that the episode was censored for sensitivity around the incident being fresh in peoples minds at the time.
I love how people argue about blood loss logic in a world with devil fruits, haki, and people repeatedly losing more blood than they should logically have.
I actually thought it was dumb how half his head got blown off and was still able to fight (you need your brain to do things you know) but it was a bit lame in the anime he just lost part of his moustache. I would of liked to have seen a middle ground in the anime between the manga and what we got, like half his face was badly burned or something.
There actually is a scene in the anime we're somebody flips someone off in the fish man island ark. In like a flashback it shows the captain of the flying dutchman (sorry forgot his name) flipping of the sky. I took a picture of it.
Sanji's reaction in the anime to the female slave is more in-character for him because he's the kind of guy that will not tolerate a lady being mistreated and since the lady is a World Noble slave, she is most likely being mistreated. I dunno why Oda will pull that comedy gag in such an inappropriate moment. Sanji will NEVER say that.
You forget that in Ennie's Lobby, the anime cut a entire character wich was a Marine, who fight against Franky if I recall. I think it was because his devil fruit. Good video 👍🏼
@@yeet807 His name is Sharinguru, he is a marine captain. I think that he was there in Ennie's Lobby, but the power of his devil fruit, the Shari Shari no mi, the anime don't show it for some reason
My favorite anime change is when they dropped the panel of Usopp giving Nami a completed ClimaTact before entering Rain Base in Chapter 168. I like this because it doesn't make Nami look like a moron for not practicing with it or asking Usopp about it during the 12 HOUR trip to Alubarna on Pincers (the Ero-Crab). Instead, the anime allows us to infer that Usopp worked on the ClimaTact up to the last minute & Nami only had his concept notes to work with.
And in Enies Lobby, where they replayed the backstory of EVERY strawhat TWICE. And even went so far as to replay episodes from the water seven arc. It was really frustrating
There was also all the part with Ace in Alabasta. In the anime he follows luffy and his crew for a little while, but in the manga he just help him with smoker and sink the fleet of barock works then he’s off
About sanji I always thought that he wanted to save the girl by buying her just like camie. As he used 'too' here so he was most likely thinking about saving camie by buying her.