0:37 Mixed up the written title in the intro, sorry about that. When you put this much work into a video sometimes some small things fall through the cracks. Hope you enjoy the video regardless of that tiny mistake!
Agreed! I always felt it was also a very illuminating scene as well. It clearly shows how people always feel sorry for Harry because he is an orphan whereas nobody ever feels sorry for Neville. Even though his parents, in a way, made the same sacrifices as Lily and James. The only difference between the two is that Lily and James died, whereas Neville's parents survived it (physically), yet both Harry and Neville ended up growing up as orphans. While Neville did have a grandmother who loved him in her own way, the few scraps we get from his childhood (such as his family assuming he is a squib) seem to suggest he was not much better off than Harry was at the Dursleys (aside from being well fed and decently clothed), since he too was mentally abused by his grandmother and uncle always arguing his incompetence. I agree with Sirius Black, the Longbottoms suffered a fate worse than death and for Neville to have to be reminded of that every time they go to visit seems to me even worse than growing up knowing your parents are dead (I have to speculate on this since I was lucky enough to not experience either). The main difference in their fates is probably also that both Harry and Neville continuously walked in their parents' shadows, being reminded about their achievements when they were still alive. Whereas Harry was able to meet these expectations and perhaps even exceed them, Neville was not able to live up to it until much later in the series. This means that whereas Harry always felt a surge of pride at the mention of his parents, Neville also felt a tinge of shame. Not of what happened to them but of what he felt unable to do, make them proud.
Technically she is in the first film, but she never got a character development or any inportant scenes. She was actually quite an interesting character in the book, so it’s sad that she wasn’t really in the movies.
“Give her hell from us, Peeves." And Peeves, whom Harry had never seen take an order from a student before, swept his belled hat from his head and sprang to a salute as Fred and George wheeled about to tumultuous applause from the students below and sped out of the open front doors into the glorious sunset.”
The character that I think got the shortest end of the stick is Regulus Black. He was a hero. The true hero of Slytherin. (He never bullied innocent children). He gave his life to stop Voldemort and didn’t take credit to protect his family. And the movie mentioned him once.
Exactly! Regulus helped A LOT, for example, if it weren´t for him, Harry probably would have never broken the ice with Kreacher and the house-elves wouldn´t have joined the Battle of Hogwarts.
Its so funny how you throw snape under the bus here even though regulus' actions barely helped anything and even made the situation with the locket far worse than it already was... Like yeah dog dont try to reach Dumbledore just go alone knowing youre the only one who posesses the secret to defeating V, dont tell anyone at all. Like the motivation is heroic, but lel man its his fault he died like a dumbass, legit nobody elses
KOT EBANA ROT Snape only helped Dumbledoor because he found out Lily’s child was gonna get murdered. He didn’t care about any other child (aka Neville) that would have taken harry’s place.
Something that really bothered me about the books is the fact that EVERYONE ON SLYTHERIN IS EVIL. I mean, I get why most dark wizards would come from that house, but to portray every single one of them as mean and evil doesn't seem too believable. The only kinda good Slytherins were Regulus and Slughorn. Snape was ultimately fighting for the good guys but he was still a world class douche, not to mention horrible teacher.
The scene when Neville meets his parents in S.Mungus is one of the best of the entire saga. It made me cry when I read it. So delicate, and so painful.
@@jule5988 Plus it gave us that wonderful "bitch slap" moment when Dumbledore informed an angsty Harry that his own life was a coin toss. That it could have been him with the parents in St Mungo's.
It is so upsetting that i didn’t even remember this scene until i saw this comment!! The movies may be great but it is truly heartbreaking that there is so much they cut, causing so many people to forget about some amazing parts of the stories.
I feel like Regulus and his backstory all ties in with the whole Kreacher redemption sort of arc that was really interesting in the Deathly Hallows Book yet was completely cut. Would have been cool to see that as well as Regulus’s backstory
I was really disappointed the St Mungos scene was left out of the films. I had been looking forward to it and when they skipped it I was like, wait, what?!
Tormented Soul i never said it was a good thing, and i by no means endorse that behaviour to be healthy. lots of individuals use humour as a way to cope with things we may have sadly experienced. i am incredibly sorry my comment raised your concern or even offended you. it was not intended to be in bad taste but i completely appreciate how it may have upset you, for that i am very sorry. wishing you a lovely day ☺️
I wish we saw more of Tonks and lupins relationship in the movies and books because it is a really interesting plot going on while Voldemort is gaining power. Could you do a video about their relationship? I would love it!
@@InTheNameOfMusic77 Actually apparently they were together during The Attack On The Burrow (Christmas time) which makes no sense because TONKS’S HAIR IS BROWN!!!! IF THEY ARE TOGETHER, THEN HER HAIR SHOULDN’T BW BROWN!!! You can tell and I am *very* passionate about this particular subject.
Neville's grandma is badass in the last book She had sent some death eaters to the hospital Also The Olivander, Gregorovitch and Grindelwald that little detail about these characters in the books is interesting, we come to know about Wands and stuff Also Victor Krum's role in the last book is interesting
@@namehere7309 no i think most of the houses ghosts were, like the grey lady and nearly headless nick but peeves wasnt (he may have been in the background tho but we never see him being acknowledged) wish he was tho!!
I didn't like how they animated the centaurs in the movies. They were supposed to be so gorgeous that all the girl students had crushes on Firenze when he started teaching...
Fragulas it’s a joke because Tonks (Nymphadora) doesn’t like being called by her first name and when Mad Eye Moody called her by that she immediately told him "Don’t call me Nymphadora!"
I have no idea why Andromeda wasn't in the film, she actually could've been played by Helena Bonham Carter in a brown wig🤣️...according to The Deathly Hallows, Andromeda and Bellatrix resembled so much that it terrified Harry to draw his wand as he woke from unconsciousness to find her kind face staring at him!
I was never the reading type of kid, but after watching the Harry Potter movies about 20 times each I’ve recently started reading the books. I wish I had read them earlier, they are so enjoyable and easy to read. So much more details and you see the real personalities of the characters, really getting to like them even more
I think it would be hard to find an actor for regulus tho cuz he had to look similar but not exactly the same as sirius. if you think about it, that a lot of requirements :(
Percy being in the films like the pompous ass he was in the books would have been nice. They never explained his being with Cornelias Fudge. Audiences who never read the books were probably wondering what the hell was going on.
@@lunayen read the books :D I think it comes up in the sixth one but im not entirely sure (maybe the fifth one). Edit: it hast to do with fudge, thats to say ;) i now know in which one it comes up, but i wont tell you! Read all the books, its worth it :D
Hes not wrong tho. In my mind I think that at some point Harry,Hermione,Ron,Ginny,Neville and Luna return to Hogwarts as teachers and have a lot more adventurous experiences with unraveling mysteries of the castle. ( Maybe the Cursed Vaults? )
Charlie and Bill simultaneously appearing for the first time in person in the books before the QWC had Harry identify Charlie through evidence of his work on his hand
I am still shocked and mad that peeves wasn't even mentioned once in the films! He was a straight up asshole, but one of my favourite characters. Same with Tonks Parents. They were important in the 7th book and they completely left them out.
It was Rik Mayall who apparently stole every seen he was in. 🤣👏 After having the perfect peeves they could re-cast cos he was too perfect. Search- drop dead fred👌
-Mango Juice- I read it now and I understood and I absolutely hate the book. JKR should rewrite the whole thing majiga and NOT make Cedric a death eater
ok so the only thing i want is for them to make a 10 hour movie of that doesn’t cut out any main details and is accurate to the actually Harry Potter book series. that’s all i want in life and i will PAY to watch it
Haha I agree. I am only on the 6th book but I love the books more. Although I would totally do nothing all day just to watch the whole 10 hour movie without breaks🤣
Nirawit Karnjanasomwong making a movie is Harder than a book in a book u can Add what u want when u make a movie u need to Find some people Who looks like the character and use almost 1 hour each scenes really think about IT before u hate
That's not true at all The movies will never do the books credit but they did a really good job considering its such a detailed complicated story I feel like this is as good as its gets otherwise it would have been too much for general audiences who didn't really read the books and don't care about every tiny detail like we might do
ProGHost'Z GameCreed Actually, the Bloody Baron shows up in the first movie, after they were sorted. He is flying over the Slytherin table and someone says: “It’s the bloody Baron!”
I think they should've had Regulus Black in the movies like when Kreacher was taking about the locket there should of maybe been a flashblack or something
I just realised that Zacharias Smith might have been related to Hepzibah Smith, which makes him a descendant of Helga Hufflepuff too. And he also is in Hufflepuff.
C. C. It could be true but Zackarias smith was the only Hufflepuff to run at the battle of Hogwarts which makes him un loyal and Hufflepuff was know for being loyal
@@ccormore in the book it says that Zacharias Smith was pushing through everyone to get to the front of the evacuating students. he was the only Hufflepuff that didn't stay.
as much i loved the later movies, they felt more like a compilation of the action scenes of the books. missing most of the classes, library scenes, holidays and the scenes from the hallways and gryffindor room it basically missed all the scenes that lead to the action scenes that were in the movies. in my opinion it would have been the best if every book would have had 2 movies for each. because the thing that made so deep emotional connection to the HP world for me was of how much we actually got of it in the books. can't imagine how shallow my HP experience would have been if i had just watched the movies and never read the books.
Edgar Retana I couldn't agree more. It's my favorite book & the movie was butchered to fit in with the teen romance trend that was in at the time like Twilight so stupid
Am I the who is so mad that they cut the Remus Lupin scene from deathly allows when he arrives at Grimmauld place to meet Harry He was so underrated all the time!!! Remus Lupin
Yes although the scene would have been slightly weird. Since they didn't explain the whole pregnant thing before it would have been slightly weird for Remus to suddenly ask Harry to be godfather. Also Remus and Harry didn't have as close a bond in the films as they did in the books. This is a recurring problem in the films, however, they have characters show up 1ce or 2ce briefly and then later on in year 6 or 7 when there's a dramatic moment with these characters Harry is suddenly heartbroken about someone he hasn't seen for several years and only made brief appearances in his life at the time. The same thing happened with Dobby. His death was in my opinion one of the most tragic ones in the books, whereas in the film it was reduced to a seemingly over dramatic response from Harry over an Elf who annoyed him in his 2nd year (which was around 5 years ago) and he hasn't been in contact with since then, who only suddenly reappears as some Deus Ex Machina during films 7 and 8.
I mean this seriously, I love peeves with my whole heart. Also, the Longbottoms deserved some screen time, their story is so tragic, and one that has so much influence on the story, being one of the first things Harry sees that really shows him the effects of the previous war.
I'm Hufflepuff proud, and am I the only one who noticed that Smith was the ONLY Hufflepuff not to stick around for the Battle of Hogwarts? Rowling said that, other than him, every Hufflepuff stayed, but for different reasons than all the Gryffindors. They stayed because of bravery, the Hufflepuffs stayed because of loyalty.
Honestly the intricacies of the Black family is one of the coolest things in the books, and the movies just glossed over most of it (although understandable as all the connections can be kind of confusing).
8:32 "One day, when Tom was visiting her, she showed him her two most priced possessions..." FBI? Yeah, there's this- "...Hufflepuff's cup and Salazar Slytherin's locket." Ok, false alarm.
More ‘I want to rip out at least three organs, specifically one lung, a liver, and then the stomach. This will mean they will die very slowly to either suffocation or starvation’
My friend saying she’s a Potterhead. Me: what’s your favorite character? Her: oh Hermione Her again: who is yours? Me: Peeves Her: who’s Peeves? Me to myself: bruh...
@@sketchbookmenace ikr. I'm not a potterhead but I watched all the movies and sometime rewatch them just because. They're shown in the tv and my friends are potterhead. So it's kinda funny if someone who doesn't read the novel and only watch the movie said they're a fan when everyone have seen the movie.
Ikr! In the films the most powerful part of their relationship was when they were lying dead together. It was so much better in the books, I loved the part when Lupin burst into shell cottage to tell them about Teddy.
Rik would have been spot on as Peeves, since that's the type of character he could easily play! In fact, he played that type of character in Drop Dead Fred.
@@cindchan Rik was cast as Peeves, but the cast kept corpsing every time he opened his mouth, so in the end they had to just give up cos Rik was too good at being straight up hilarious.
@@bessieburnet9816 yes but she wasn't nearly as badass and there was absolutely no development with her character. It just went from shy little first year to in fifth year hexing everyone left and right. And she didn't even get her famous bat bogey hex!
@@dreamedones7775 so there was development, she went from shy to badass. Perhaps it wasn't well worked out but there was definitely character development. Also I don't believe the bat bogey hex wasn't her own spell, she was just very good at casting them.
When I read the Order Of The Phoenix, I was so excited to see Lockhart again and to finally meet Neville’s parents. But when they cut the scene, I was disappointed.
When I read Deathly Hallows, I cried, when I the death of the Creevey brothers was revealed. Human parents loosing their young sons over something they couldn't understand.
@@eliaelirko9849 I am going to have to go back to the books. I could have sworn that when Harry was looking at the dead, it says that he saw the Creevey brother lying together. However, I am getting old and senile.
NOOOO!!!!!!!I LOVE THE CURSED CHILD!!!!!!I think it's amazing that we get to see more of the Malfoy family. Scorpius❤️ when I heard him say that I wanted to SCREEEEEEEEEEAMMMMMMMM!
Even though they took a giant wet shit on the ending to the series, I still think it would have been so adorable to see all those house-elves running out of the kitchen with knives to join the fight!
@@bakeryfiskree5927 they left it out of the movie. In the book, there is a part where all the house elves that work in the kitchen come running out with knives bigger than them, as it described and it just sounded cute, even though it was a time of war and they were going out to attack Death Eaters. I just think it would have been a cute addition to the movie.
didn't Peeves also have an important role in Harry discovering the Room of Requirement for the first time? or am i mixing smthg up? *EDIT*: my bad, i was actually referring to the portal that connected the Room of Requirement to Borgin & Burkes. iirc Peeves did smthg that caused it to break in CoS, and Malfoy spent most of HBP trying to fix it. he eventually succeeded, which is how Death Eaters entered Hogwarts on the night of Dumbledore's death.
@@Whitneypyant mentioning a brother who lives in Romania is a good enough reason to have him not show up in the films. If you mention a poltergeist who supposedly lives in the castle where the majority of the films takes place does make it slightly weird if said poltergeist then never shows up in the films. If he was not intended to make the films the better choice would have been to just leave him out. And since all the ghosts have been reduced to more or less passing appearances (pun intended), this choice isn't so surprising. That being said, I would have loved to have seen him in the films for comic relief purposes which perhaps would have left more room for Ron to be a serious character as well, rather than just the moron friend.
I was always annoyed that Bertha Jorkins was never even mentioned in the films. Her story along with Barty Crouch Jr's backstory is one of my favourite parts of the series.
Kinda stupid that she did that to her niece and cousin, because if you want a world of only pureblood wizards, stop killing them off. Not saying Dobby's death wasn't sad! Just saying that it was a REALLY bad choice to murder other wizards/witches if you only want purebloods in the world.
And that is why many people who only saw the movies are confused and complain about plot holes. Don't be lazy and actually read Rowling's work instead of JUST the movies. It makes more sense in the book.
It's also a problem with films. Imagine watching an avengers film and having massive plot holes where they just expect you to have read the comic book series
I will never forgive that Charlie Weasley wasn't in the movies. It's an insult to the Weasley family. He wasn't even in the final battle or supporting his family over Fred's death.
I was very sad about Charlie not being in the movies. I also thought that the inclusion of Bill in the 7th movie was a little hamfisted. I had the feeling that they would have cut him if they could get away with leaving out the wedding.
A little hamfisted? That shit was ridiculous..."Hi I'm Bill, got these scars from a werewolf". Gaahhhh!! Yeah, in a battle AT Hogwarts! It makes no sense in the movies why he is marrying Fleur.
When I kept rabbits, I named them Harry Potter names. When I named one Ludo, it really showed me who had read the books and who had just watched the films... the number of people who asked why I didn't go with a Harry Potter name was unreal 🙈
