Тёмный

The Most Unrealistic Things About Portrayals of Work Onscreen 

The Take
Подписаться 1,5 млн
Просмотров 105 тыс.
50% 1

Hollywood loves to portray various professions in the same - sometimes inaccurate way - over and over. Whether it’s the computer programmer living a double life as a hacker, the baker who communicates through pastries and magically maintains a successful small business, or the way seemingly every romcom protagonist just so happens to be an architect, careers onscreen are more often a shorthand for personality traits than an accurate reflection of working life. Here are the most commonly misrepresented professions in TV and movies - and why they’re so off-base.
If you like this video, subscribe to our channel and support us by becoming a Taker or joining our Patreon for amazing perks like early access and custom polls!
Become a Taker: bit.ly/jointhetake
Join our Patreon: / thetake
Watch our TikTok: / thisisthetake
Bonus Content and Articles: www.the-take.com
Follow our Socials: linktr.ee/thisisthetake
CHAPTERS
00:00 Jobs are so often misrepresented onscreen
00:47 Cops
03:38 Politicians
05:38 Chefs
07:27 Lawyers
10:50 Scientists
CREDITS
Executive Producers: Debra Minoff & Susannah McCullough
Chief Creative Director: Susannah McCullough
Associate Producer: Tyler Allen
Writer: Eric Thrum
Narrator: Charly Bivona
Video Editor: Dan Wolff

Развлечения

Опубликовано:

 

26 июн 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 519   
@thetake
@thetake Год назад
WATCH MORE - So film/tv get a lot about jobs wrong. But they also have ton of laughable cliché's in other areas. Here are the most overplayed and hilarious ones: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-xv_dHTxi_yc.html
@alissiamiller7291
@alissiamiller7291 Год назад
Stay at home parents and influences. And nannies and doctors
@CrimsonGlow
@CrimsonGlow Год назад
Dentists. They're almost always in comedy and horror as being the absolute most terrifying things possible.
@christinebeyke5528
@christinebeyke5528 11 месяцев назад
Yes, it's ridiculous. Doctors spend most of their day in front of a computer, looking up data, documenting, etc. I believe it is pretty well documented that less than 30% of their time is actually spent with patients. Outside of complicated procedures (like surgeries, central lines, etc), nurses are doing all gritty stuff like placing IVs, giving medications, turning patients, etc. Everyone is overworked & understaffed. No one has time to socialize. They had to actually put a legal maximum work hours on residents (doctors in training) to 80 hours per week (it was not uncommon to work 130 hour/week before then), but the same doesn't apply to fully licensed doctors. Burnout is a huge issue everywhere in the health field
@greghuffman3061
@greghuffman3061 9 месяцев назад
heard a podcast about movie pairings. how about: Pig (2021) the menu (2022)
@sydneylynskey7587
@sydneylynskey7587 Год назад
I had someone tell me once that a lot of the things you see Doctors do in television shows are actually in real life, the nurse's jobs.
@PCharat17
@PCharat17 Год назад
Yes, like the show "House" where apparently three doctors would be by the patient's bedside for hours at a time, doing all the jobs that a nurse would do.
@annamaryu3645
@annamaryu3645 Год назад
Yup, watching Grey's anatomy as a nurse is hilarious.
@PCharat17
@PCharat17 Год назад
Not to mention the health care workers have all the time in the world to be intimate in the janitor's closet. It's like... Please, we barely have time to even go to the bathroom.
@heatherann9548
@heatherann9548 Год назад
@@PCharat17 The nurses have extra time because the doctors are doing all their work!
@2BENURSE
@2BENURSE Год назад
Yeah.. Doctors don’t give meds or ambulate patients. Most of them don’t do compressions either
@SlayerNinaFriki
@SlayerNinaFriki Год назад
The three unrealistic things: 1. People enjoy their jobs 2. People have time outside their jobs 3. People can pay rent with their jobs
@egyptianqueen4007
@egyptianqueen4007 Год назад
I agree with your first point but there are a lot of different careers that pay well and have free time outside of work.
@ygnit5793
@ygnit5793 Год назад
The most bitter thing is that you often have to choose between your first and two later points. Even if you find a job you genuinely enjoy, you may be forced to quit it and move on to something better - paying out of necessity, at the cost of your personal satisfaction.
@laskotyk
@laskotyk Год назад
I enjoy my job, I have time outside, I can pay my rent and even more ... so it's not like that in every case
@ygnit5793
@ygnit5793 Год назад
@@laskotyk Great for you then, I didn't say it's impossible. Just that it's a case with many people. I for once also enjoy my current job, but I wouldn't be able to pay rent and live on it on my own, not to mention anything else
@SlayerNinaFriki
@SlayerNinaFriki Год назад
@@laskotyk great. Blocked for your inability to read the room
@karrihart1
@karrihart1 Год назад
The rude server or customer service person to the main character drives me crazy. You’d get fired in a flash, and most of the time it’s the customer who is the one being horrible.
@jamesgomez9151
@jamesgomez9151 Год назад
QFT
@briannagravely9349
@briannagravely9349 Год назад
you know that character is written by the rude customer.
@LeahWalentosky
@LeahWalentosky Год назад
Agree I am a CSR and love my job!
@tyriaxepheles7996
@tyriaxepheles7996 Год назад
You never encountered a ride customer service worker? For real?
@mariaskabardonis8353
@mariaskabardonis8353 11 месяцев назад
I have encountered rude service people it’s rare but it’s possible
@PokhrajRoy.
@PokhrajRoy. Год назад
An underrated good representation of lawyers was ‘Clueless’. Josh and Cher along with the other employees had to sift through documents.
@trinaq
@trinaq Год назад
Agreed, at least they actually showed the amount of paperwork that lawyers have to contend with, though it seems unlikely that Mel would have his teenage daughter and ex stepson work on his documents, especially when he's shown to have a large legal team who'd be employed to do all of that already.
@pixiebells
@pixiebells Год назад
I thought of those scenes too! I'm surprise they didn't include them.
@pixiebells
@pixiebells Год назад
​@@trinaq maybe, but on the other hand, they weren't going through annotations for legal briefs, they were literally highlighting each phone call that occurred on a specific date so IDK
@loissandereyes2253
@loissandereyes2253 Год назад
Where are the September files???
@sharondaatlagniappe
@sharondaatlagniappe Год назад
@@trinaq I thought this was Mel's way to include Cher in his work, almost as an intern.
@trinaq
@trinaq Год назад
I've always wondered why characters who have high powered, demanding careers, such as lawyers, chefs or professors, somehow have ounces of free time, when in reality, their days would be consumed with work. However, that wouldn't make for interesting TV.
@karrihart1
@karrihart1 Год назад
Yeah Monica would never be seeing her friends. How is she a chef and yet always has her nights free? Edit: Not to mention her and Chandler moving to the suburbs would be horribly inconvenient for her. She wouldn’t get home until 2-3am.
@FuzzyKittenBoots
@FuzzyKittenBoots Год назад
I guess lawyers and professors aren't as caged in time and place wise as a chef at a restaurant (as an example) is so there's maybe a bit more room for shenanigans but still...
@meganh7526
@meganh7526 Год назад
@@FuzzyKittenBootsI think the lawyers are unrealistic as well. Obviously it depends on your practice but many lawyers work 80 hour weeks.
@FuzzyKittenBoots
@FuzzyKittenBoots Год назад
@@meganh7526 It depends really. Lawyers generally do t works 80 hour weeks because then they would be dead. They do however work 80 hours week when they are close to a case going up in court for example. But lawyers are also no tied to being in a certain space and their days don’t look the exact same every day either
@EASJR1991
@EASJR1991 Год назад
This is a valid observation. In the Cosby Show, Cliff and Claire are a doctor and a lawyer respectively, yet they seem to have a lot of free time. Perhaps the only plausible explanation is that Cliff's medical practice is located in the basement of their brownstone. However, it's unclear how Claire manages to have so much spare time. Similarly, in Sex and the City, Miranda is a lawyer who works at a high-powered firm in New York City. Realistically, her job would require her to work well over 40 hours a week. Yet, she still has plenty of time to go to brunch with her friends Carrie, Charlotte, and Samantha. Additionally, we rarely see Miranda in court or interacting with judges or clients. The only episode where she appears to be working with clients is when she is set up with a woman because they believe she is a lesbian.
@BlankGreenCanvas
@BlankGreenCanvas Год назад
I would love an exploration on how journalists are portrayed onscreen - and how it often ignores how the profession is severely underpaid and overworked.
@0723niki
@0723niki 11 месяцев назад
I agree. There are quite a few excellent movies on real journalistic achievements, but on television, for the most part, journalists are portrayed as villainous paparazzi or liars. Unfortunately, a great many people believe this is true in real life as well because they have very little understanding of how news and reporting works.
@irishtom30
@irishtom30 11 месяцев назад
@@0723niki Once again, The Wire seems likely to be the most accurate. The show's creator was a reporter at the Baltimore Sun for years, and season five features reporters.
@joeypethan5083
@joeypethan5083 11 месяцев назад
I would STRONGLY recommend Spotlight
@tracyfitch4873
@tracyfitch4873 Год назад
You forgot Teachers. As a Special Educator (I’m a Teacher of the Visually Impaired) it annoys me to no end when I see a somewhat modern day movie with a child with special needs receiving zero support. No one mentions IEPs or accommodations or the fact that there is usually a whole team of people supporting the child (Teachers of the Visually Impaired, Deaf Hard of Hearing Teachers, Occupational Therapists, Physical Therapists, Speech Language Pathologists, SpEd classroom and co-teachers, etc.)
@hanidham5326
@hanidham5326 Год назад
How they portray educators in a classroom full of quiet and focused students and knowing exactly what to say to shut the students up. and the emotional speeches and quotes from poems etc...hahahah
@gabrielleduplessis7388
@gabrielleduplessis7388 Год назад
I am in the middle. I have two disabilities and my IEPs were not always followed. I had to put in the work to follow my own IEP. My mom always advocated for me. At one point, they tested me again and because of budget cuts, the test was not thorough. They thought I was cured. I was not. While teachers are changing now, there was a time where people did not care or just did not know how to help people with disabilities. I heard stories from other people with disabilities where they were bullied by their teachers and teaching assistants. For some, there was zero support. For others, they had some, but not a lot. It varies. But I feel that people with disabilities have to adapt, manage, and advocate for themselves in order to get any support or help.
@gabrielleduplessis7388
@gabrielleduplessis7388 Год назад
I do agree that the professions you listed are never portrayed in movies and that is a shame. I had occupational and speech therapists and they are patient, helpful, and supportive. My first comment is based off what I and other kids experienced in the school systems. I really want more representation of people with disabilities because they are always on the back burner and I am sick of it.
@belafaulds6405
@belafaulds6405 Год назад
The people writing movies are often 40+. A lot of the time teenagers dont like teen movies from their time because thats not accurate to their experience but to the experience of the much older writera
@joy9585
@joy9585 Год назад
Amen! The whole team in education is severely underserved in the media - fiction or otherwise- there are psychologists, social workers, guidance counselors, teachers, PT, OT, and speech pathologists to name a few who help students with IEPs succeed.
@lindz758
@lindz758 Год назад
I think therapists and psychologists are often portrayed as the stereotypical cold, stoic sit in a chair while the other person lays on a couch type or the kooky, hippie, overly nurturing with horrible boundaries type
@patthornton1556
@patthornton1556 Год назад
Or they sleep with many of their patients! I find this infuriating as a psychologist myself!!
@cv8499
@cv8499 Год назад
I work in book publishing, and movies and shows always get it hilariously wrong. Like in The Best of Everything, one of the characters is hired as a typist. She makes one insightful comment on a manuscript she's typing and is immediately promoted to senior editor in a huge corner office, getting paid tons of money. Meanwhile, editors usually suffer through years of working their way up the ranks and doing unglamorous tasks like making copies and going through slush piles in a tiny cubicle, getting paid just enough to make their share of the rent. They also make it look like a person writes a book and it gets published the next day. The process usually takes about 8 months.
@ManuelaOliveiraMusic
@ManuelaOliveiraMusic Год назад
Musicians. Always portrayed as someone who was lucky to be born with talent and that can play anything without practice, years of study, rehearsals, self actualization, tedious hours of everyday practice (a professional musician has to practice almost everyday, like an athleete, otherwise your speed, stamina and other skills start to fall behind). Also, it’s never portrayed the sheer amount of people that a show/concert employs and the time it takes to put on a show or an album. It’s always portrayed as something that just happened by inspiration, epiphany or some sort of magic.
@xition25
@xition25 Год назад
And even if they do practice they normally show it as playing some beautiful piece in its entirety, when in reality practice is full of repetition and exercises that are not that fun to listen to.
@arlaur
@arlaur Год назад
This, a million times over! Movies portray music as some sort of ephemeral magic, and that a person needs to let go of his or her inhibitions and “feel” the inspiration, when in reality, it takes concrete discipline to master technique. Whiplash is the only film I’ve seen that portrays our field correctly!
@jcspoon573
@jcspoon573 11 месяцев назад
I knew one musician who was so talented he just aced his audition. Then there was the rest of what one would call "an orchestra", or nearly 130 people.
@petitecamusette3913
@petitecamusette3913 11 месяцев назад
And then the auditions in movies! They actually never take place in a big concert hall, most of the time you're just put in a crappy little chamber and after playing half a minute the jury interrupts you, sends you home and tells you: "We'll send you the result per mail." Not very glorious...
@mariaskabardonis8353
@mariaskabardonis8353 11 месяцев назад
@@petitecamusette3913 I had a friend who had a band in high school and he was saying how his band never had auditions because unlike the movies where everybody would suck and then you would have that magical great person there was no magical great person so auditions are probably a myth as well Nashville did show the album process a bit and they did show a lot of the characters go through a process to write even though some of the things did come through inspiration. It was a soap and not everything super realistic but there was a little bit of process in it
@lebocharp
@lebocharp Год назад
Cybersecurity engineers or “hackers” in movies: wearing sunglasses in a dark room filled with screens of code and are frantically typing away to churn out lines of code and when something goes wrong, the entire room turns red and massive “error” messages appear on all screens and sirens start blaring
@CrimsonNineTail
@CrimsonNineTail Год назад
I also hear, in the movies, it takes mere minutes for them to take your whole bank account too.
@QueenOfTheDamned
@QueenOfTheDamned Год назад
😂 So true
@jeank8061
@jeank8061 Год назад
How often do these characters go clickity clickity click on the keyboard then look wide-eyed at their screen and exclaim "We're In!"
@felisd
@felisd 11 месяцев назад
Apparently, in movies, the more proficient a person is with computers, the less they use a mouse?
@trinaq
@trinaq Год назад
On "Boy Meets World", Feeny not only seemed to teach every single class that Cory and his friends had, but he even followed them from middle school, to high school, and then college. In the spinoff, Cory was the same way, he was the centre of every class scene that Riley and her friends had, yet he was supposedly only the history teacher.
@karrihart1
@karrihart1 Год назад
At least the show did make jokes about Fenny teaching every single class in every single grade.
@christophergarrett7082
@christophergarrett7082 Год назад
Cory was a horrible teacher
@latonyajefferson9699
@latonyajefferson9699 Год назад
Up until I was in 6th grade, I did have only 1 teacher for my core subjects. I had a different teacher for P.E. There was also a teacher at my school that followed his class from 5th grade to 8th grade, then start over with a new 5th grade class. So, it does happen.
@mariaskabardonis8353
@mariaskabardonis8353 Год назад
In the high school there were other teachers like Turner and it was joked. Plus the show as much as I loved the show there was some retcons. The early years and the late years felt like different shows In Girl Meets World there were other teachers. It is possible to have the same teacher for multiple grades. I went to a Montessori school so I had the same teacher for 1st and second grade and would have had her for 3 if we didn’t move. I had the same math teacher and English for two years. It’s possible
@LeonardsParka
@LeonardsParka Год назад
@@christophergarrett7082I lived girl meets world when it ran and I agree with this honestly. Still found it funny though
@pixiebells
@pixiebells Год назад
Do teachers, specifically daycare & preschool teachers next, please!! 🙏🏻 There are lots of misconception about us and what we actually do & some are pretty infuriating. I've been a daycare teacher for nearly 5 years. Once, I had an Uber dropping me off at work and I told him I worked at the daycare center & he goes "Oh, you babysit?" I said "I'm a teacher." and felt really insulted that he thought I just babysat. I'm a professional. I have a bachelor's degree. I make my own lesson plans. And even though my kids are only 2, I have quite a lot to teach them every single day. From things that are less academic, like emotional self-regulation or potty training versus more academic skills like learning how to use a paintbrush, knowing your colors and shapes, reciting the alphabet, things like that. Reading books helps their vocabulary, art projects encourage creativity. They learn both fine and gross motor skills by activities like cutting with scissors or playing in the gym. They learn social skills the entire time. These are all essential for their development. Daycare teachers have a lot of work to do to make sure your kids are ready for kindergarten. We take care of your kids and educate them while you are working. You couldn't do your job if we didn't do ours. All teachers should be paid so well because society would collapse without an education system. On that note, PLEASE praise Abbott Elementary! I know you already have a great video about them but they definitely deserve an honorable mention when you're talking about accurate portrayals of teaching!! ❤
@quiestinliteris
@quiestinliteris Год назад
Ugh, the fingerpaints and sing-alongs stereotype. It's so obnoxious. No one ever depicts the intensity of pedagogy. Yeah, anyone can tell a kid what a preposition is, but not anyone can explain the information six different ways and provide enough interesting and unambiguous examples to get the information to stick.
@luluscaglione
@luluscaglione Год назад
That unfortunately is a world wide misconception, I guess. When I was in university here in south América I used to hear my colleagues poke fun at pedagogy students saying they had a 4 year course just to learn how to do origami and change diapers. The funny thing is we were studying history and most of us become.... teachers
@pixiebells
@pixiebells Год назад
@@quiestinliteris Exactly! it's like they don't even realize that there are at least 12 if not 16 different learning styles, and there's more even counting kids with an IEP. My momwas a Special Ed teacher for over 20 years in K-2nd grade and is a TREMENDOUS amount of work! And I don't do finger painting bc it's too messy & they need to learn about more ways to craft art
@sierra8077
@sierra8077 Год назад
Even Abbott Elementary makes the things teachers have to deal with seem less hard than in real life
@cooperminion825
@cooperminion825 Год назад
I remember that one of my preschool teachers had us do fun dances once a week. We would do The Hokey Pokey, The Chicken Dance, and a few others I can't remember. As a kid, I thought it was just fun dances. Now, I realize it was a fun way for us to develop our muscles, learn to follow directions, and learn coordination
@karrihart1
@karrihart1 Год назад
It’s also ironic that the film/TV industry itself is almost never portrayed accurately. Sorry La La Land, Mia is not getting cast as a lead in a film after doing a crappy one-woman show for only one night in a 99 seat theatre. Most actors are pounding the pavement for 10-20 years before something finally breaks through for them, if they’re lucky that is.
@lorettaknoelk3475
@lorettaknoelk3475 Год назад
I hate massage therapists always being portrayed as weird, sexual or funny. It takes a year of school and an extremely hard exam that most people fail at least 2x where I am to be one. But it's portrayed as a low barrier to entry "fake job".
@Nicciolai
@Nicciolai Год назад
Or you are treated like a prostitute
@Nikitomate
@Nikitomate Год назад
My mom started out as massage therapist and is a physiotherapist for a while now. This Job demands so much knowledge and strength in the arms and hands, it's amazing. I once got a nerve stuck in my neck and couldn't move my head to the left side and she just felt for a moment and then loosened the nerve in 10mins tops. (Also I wouldn't anger a massage therapist, because they can unknot your muscles the nice way or the painful way😅)
@osabhopeful
@osabhopeful Год назад
Please cover doctors next. There are soooo many medical shows like Grey's anatomy that glamorize the profession. They rarely show how a good chunk of the day is sitting in front of a screen charting or doing other paperwork.
@christophergarrett7082
@christophergarrett7082 Год назад
The main thing is the sense of family at jobs. Not everyone you work with will be your friend or you'll become super close with. Maybe a few people but not everyone
@cindeecalton9588
@cindeecalton9588 Год назад
Archeologists: In movies they find things in good condition that aren’t broken. In real life they mostly find small parts of things like shards. Or just nothing.
@tyrant-den884
@tyrant-den884 Год назад
Pot shards that three generations can make entire careers on testing new theories, technologies, and methods of curation and cataloging.
@jmchez
@jmchez Год назад
Ins=diana Jones was a grave robber and destroyer. Once a site is found it is mapped. The news goes out to the research world. Grants are obtained to do further research. A team is hired and very slow and detailed studies are done with preservation as the main goal. Papers are then published. Stealing an artifact to show off at a gallery without any provenance is absurd. Then again, Indiana Jones battled supernatural beings and could never be killed so a suspension of disbelief is in order. That still doesn't make it any less disturbing that he destroyed so many ancient sites.
@michiganscythian2445
@michiganscythian2445 11 месяцев назад
That and they usually just pick something up and take it whereas in reality, WHERE something is found is often just as important as what it is. Archaeologists don’t just pick stuff up at a site to show off to undergraduates
@jessicaliew4735
@jessicaliew4735 Год назад
I’d love to see one on teachers. So often they’re basically extras in the background while the student drama is going on. When they have a bigger role they’re often inappropriately over involved with their students (I’m looking at you Mr. Schu) or it’s the creepy story line where a teacher dates a student. The genuine care and support that teachers put into their students, their passion for their subject area, etc. are rarely shown-unless they’re the impossible to live up to hero teachers, like Dead Poets Society and Dangerous Minds. There is a reason so many public school teachers love Abbott Elementary; it’s one of the few shows that represents the reality of the job.
@valerietema9807
@valerietema9807 Год назад
They should cover the Nice White Lady trope, which a lot of times is a teacher/social worker. There's a hilarious old MadTV skit about it!
@michiganscythian2445
@michiganscythian2445 11 месяцев назад
Either that or teachers get fired over ridiculous things (Gods Not Dead 2) or get away with way more than they would in real life (Twilight where they stab Bella’s finger with a needle).
@DCMarvelMultiverse
@DCMarvelMultiverse 6 месяцев назад
I liked how Genera+ion had school officials as idiots, jerks, and standing in the student's way. That was realistic. Seriously.
@DCMarvelMultiverse
@DCMarvelMultiverse 6 месяцев назад
​@@valerietema9807Yhara Zayd did.
@makesbymic
@makesbymic Год назад
As an architect, I'm begging and pleading for a part II that includes architecture as a profession. BEGGING
@felisd
@felisd 11 месяцев назад
Right?!?! I feel like a lot of screenwriters don't know what an architect actually does beyond drafting pretty pictures of buildings and carrying around maquettes. The episode of HIMYM that made me want to throw things at the screen was when Ted decided to take his class on a "surprise tour" of a construction site and was flabberghasted when the foreman turned him and the students away because he hadn't cleared it with him first. No architect would EVER be dumb enough to do that. Not even a professor who only ever taught architecture at a university.
@Zarolea
@Zarolea Год назад
I'm a lawyer. Never grew up watching lawyer shows, thank god. My expectations would have been disappointing. I went to law school to escape from an existential crisis, and forgot that meant I'd be a lawyer and take a bar exam. It worked out though, I like my job. You definitely don't want to go to trial. I always explain to my clients that going to trial is gambling. You might as well roll some dice or flip a coin to determine your outcome. Judges and juries are unpredictable. Ultimately, a trial means spending several month to several years of litigation and court procedures, thousands of dollars, for someone else (a judge or jury) to make a decision for you on something that is so important you spent several years of your time and thousands of dollars on your money, that you get no say in the decision. You do all that to have someone else make a decision for you. Might work out. Might not. Just settle the case and move on with your lives. You might not get everything you want, but at least you get a say. At least you get to partake in the decision making process. All lawyers know winning at trial is luck based. I've seen some of the best lawyers money can buy lose cases unopposed.
@vanessac8193
@vanessac8193 Год назад
So you're putting 50/50 odds on the outcome of Trump's trial?
@Zarolea
@Zarolea Год назад
@@vanessac8193 I'm not even paying attention to that, but yeah. It's more political, and a celebrity trial, not the same for regular people. But if it's anything like trials for regular people, then yes. Unless you have a lawyer that is both clairvoyant and telepathic.
@josefk7437
@josefk7437 Год назад
I took the California bar exam three times but I never passed. I was 20 points below the minimum passing score the last time. I am not interested in taking it a fourth time. I lost a lot of my motivation while studying the last time. It was really exhausting. My favorite lawyer portrayal was the "Don't Go To Law School" song from Crazy Ex-Girlfriend.
@susannpatton2893
@susannpatton2893 11 месяцев назад
So you basically talk them out of going to court and just settling 🤔
@Zarolea
@Zarolea 11 месяцев назад
@@susannpatton2893 Yeah, that's like 90% of a lawyer's job. Sometimes if the other side is being disagreeable or unreasonable, I'll write a motion. It's more likely that ends up persuading the other side to settle on my terms rather than heat the actual motion in court though. Me: Can we give my client 60 days, dismiss with prejudice and seal the file? Opposing counsel: No. Me: Writes 15 page motion. Me: Can we give my client 60 days, dismiss with prejudice and seal the file? OC: yes
@kj7067
@kj7067 Год назад
Scientists in movies don't worry about funding nearly enough. Also, academics in movies are almost always scientists - Arrival really gave us all some much-needed representation for the humanities.
@cooperminion825
@cooperminion825 Год назад
Don't forget about how whenever the scientists make a breakthrough, they get all the fame and accolades that come with it. In reality, it's usually the rich asshole who funds them that gets the credit bc of a bit of fine print in the contract that says all discoveries are his property. Plus, the scientists usually can't fight back bc they signed an NDA and breaking it would mean that they can be sued for way more money than they could ever make
@michiganscythian2445
@michiganscythian2445 11 месяцев назад
I remember when people were panicking about how the covid vaccine came out so fast, “well, yeah, the scientists had all kinds of money thrown at them. Amazing how fast things can be developed when there’s funding.”
@allis_o2628
@allis_o2628 Год назад
Any kind of baking/pastry chef type of job. Common job for love interests in romantic comedies, we get to see a woman in a cute apron in her cake shop (that she runs on her own), putting a ton of details and all her love into one special cake for a happy customer. With her hair uncovered, jewellery still on, and regular clothes beneath the apron. In reality, you're seldom just making one cake or one lovely loaf of bread, you're making 10-20 at the same time, for orders and the store. And owning your own bakery is an incredibly tiring job, both physically and mentally with early hours, a lot of heavy lifting and a toll on your back, neck and arms. You most definitely can't run one alone.
@waniyamasood3337
@waniyamasood3337 Год назад
You should do one on teachers too. They are usually shown as morally correct and caring and even contended with just changing lives. I am a teacher and I find this profession not just underpaid but stressful and unsatisfying
@Martina-jr8ji
@Martina-jr8ji Год назад
Doctors, not only for the amount of free time doctors in screen seem to have, but also for being ready and focused after 24 hours shift and for treating the diagnosis like a detective-case: in most cases it's old people with multiple diseases we have to treat, with confusing exams (like one parameter could be wrong for thousands of reasons), but in tv shows it's always "oh my god, we didn't think about that, that's the solution!"
@ObaREX
@ObaREX Год назад
One thing that I found pretty funny in the Netflix show "Beef" is that both the main characters aren't actually good at their jobs and the skills you'd think would be gained from their professions never end up helping them. Danny tries so hard as a contractor. But he can't actually fix anything. And when he finally gets to build a house, it explodes. Amy runs a plant shop. But it turns out she doesn't know shit about plants. And when she has to survive in the wild, she ends up eating poisonous berries.
@habeashumor9814
@habeashumor9814 Год назад
My Cousin Vinny isn’t taught in law school because the trial is realistic. There are small excerpts that are used as good examples, usually in evidence class, of things like hearsay rules and expert witness qualification. It also is a frighteningly familiar tale of a lawyer adrift in uncharted territory, really unsure of how to find their way through in a high stakes situation. Non-lawyers might be surprised to know how common this is in the profession.
@georockstar09
@georockstar09 Год назад
lol I thought that movie was going to be depicted on the unrealistic side of things. Interesting!
@habeashumor9814
@habeashumor9814 Год назад
@@georockstar09 The filmmakers were diligent in making just about all of the court case stuff consistent with reality as far as rules of procedure and such. But I wouldn’t call the story itself or the trial in the story “realistic.”
@Lilianamarie999
@Lilianamarie999 Год назад
Marissa Tomei was exceptional 😂
@habeashumor9814
@habeashumor9814 Год назад
It’s like, most of the court stuff in the film COULD happen, but probably wouldn’t.
@360shadowmoon
@360shadowmoon Год назад
I work a generic corporate job, but I think this applies to other professions: TV shows wayy overrepresent how close coworkers are with one another. I know that romances/hookups are the bread and butter of TV and movie drama, but if people at my workplace hooked up to that extent at work, they would be written up by HR and then fired. Also, dating subordinates is normalized in TV when in reality, there are major moral implications to this IRL. You could get in major trouble for dating a subordinate. Same with the extent to with coworkers are portrayed as being friends. More often than not, coworkers only see each other at work and maybe the occasional after work happy hour, but hang out with their own friends outside of work. (Obviously, people date/befriend their coworkers IRL, too, but not to the extent that it is portrayed on TV on aggregate.)
@josefk7437
@josefk7437 Год назад
I am glad someone mentioned the romance architect thing at the beginning. 500 Days of Summer didn't go much into Tom's desire to be an architect being part of what is wrong with him. Tom's desire to be an architect could have been shown to be just as misguided as his infatuation with Summer.
@tylerwatkins2923
@tylerwatkins2923 Год назад
My mom is a nurse and my father a teacher, so I want to see how accurately the jobs are portrayed
@PokhrajRoy.
@PokhrajRoy. Год назад
I’m on a rewatch session of ‘Bones’ every other day and I’m so bummed out by this inter-office dating that’s…quite something.
@tyrant-den884
@tyrant-den884 Год назад
Man that show dropped in quality when Temperance stopped beating people up.
@graigjanssen9966
@graigjanssen9966 Год назад
This is fantastic, really like the format of looking at unrealistic portrayals of professions followed by a more realistic example. Some ideas for future installments, which I hope will be in the works: businesspeople/executives, soldiers/military, spies, actors/filmmakers, doctors, farmers, teachers, bank robbers, gamblers/poker players, athletes
@izzyob186
@izzyob186 Год назад
The film Honeyboy is a prett6 gripping and gritty portrayal of the truths of child acting, I recommend (even though I no longer support Shia after the allegations against him following the film)
@katherinealvarez9216
@katherinealvarez9216 Год назад
Every time I watch anything with a school, I keep wondering where the office staff is, or the support staff or why there's like one or two teachers in the whole building and the kids are allowed to be anywhere without adult supervision. Not to mention there are unions, child services, occupational therapy and physical therapy, guidance counselors and disciplinarians. Basically, none of the onscreen schools have any of this. Not even the ones that are made to look well funded.
@trinaq
@trinaq Год назад
Agreed, usually two teachers are shown in every school environment, and if we ever see the teenagers characters in class, expect one of the main teachers to take their class.
@katherinealvarez9216
@katherinealvarez9216 Год назад
​@@trinaqexactly! When I watch Recess, the cartoon, I keep going "There's one recess monitor and she outsources to a 9 year old?" And then there's all the teen shows where there's zero adults.
@HealthyObbsession
@HealthyObbsession Год назад
What school basic has physical therapy? The other stuff you mentioned I agree with but none of my schools could have afforded a physical therapist
@katherinealvarez9216
@katherinealvarez9216 Год назад
@@HealthyObbsession we had one that came in every two months. We also didn't have a nurse, one did come in but not all the time.
@pixiebells
@pixiebells Год назад
​@@HealthyObbsession if the district has a child who requires PT or OT or Speech, they're permitted to visit the child on-site to work on their issues. We do it in preschools too. I even had services like that when I was a kid back in the early 90s I required a vision teacher because I am visually impaired and he came to help me at school.
@PrettyPrincess9609
@PrettyPrincess9609 Год назад
I work in Claims and most of my day is spent working and after I get off work the only hobby I do is work out and that’s it. I shower, eat, watch a show or movie, and go to bed. A lot of shows and movies push this idea that people have all the time in the world and go to the bar everyday or a nice coffee shop with their friends everyday after work. Most people just watch tv, go on their phones, and go to bed. 🤷🏿‍♀️
@mkulla8267
@mkulla8267 Год назад
The scene in The Bear where he gets home and makes himself the easiest throw-together meal possible - peanut butter jelly sandwich and eats it like it's the first thing he's eaten in weeks is so scarily accurate to someone in the service/cooking industry
@silver6735
@silver6735 Год назад
Can we talk about how high school theater is portrayed on screen??? Or just theater in general. No one ever gets that right. And I wish movies/ tv talked about the process of making a show! How long it takes to write a good musical/ play, how many people influence the design of a show. How it changes for practical, personal, and or current political reasons.
@karrihart1
@karrihart1 Год назад
tick,tick….BOOM is the best portrayal of the theatre world, and in the artist life in general, I have every seen on screen. The money struggles, the gatekeepers, the wonderful highs, the crushing lows, etc.
@silver6735
@silver6735 Год назад
@@karrihart1 yes! You are so right! We need more of that! Because of that movie my family tell calls this period of my theater career my “Johnathan Larson days”. Meaning I’m poor. 😂
@karrihart1
@karrihart1 Год назад
@@silver6735 And those were the struggles of a straight, white, cis, male artists. You almost never see stories about marginalized artists trying to make it and the struggles they have to face. Hollywood Shuffle is the only one I can think of that does that.
@silver6735
@silver6735 Год назад
@@karrihart1 I’ve never heard of Hollywood Shuffle! I’ll look it up!
@cv8499
@cv8499 Год назад
GLEE used to drive me crazy with their seemingly unlimited set budget, the fact that they never actually rehearsed anything, never started off by singing scales, decided what they would sing in major competitions pretty much the night before or day of... Just ugh, no.
@Michaelalovespandas
@Michaelalovespandas Год назад
Crazy Ex Girlfriend seems like a more realistic portrayal of being a lawyer. She only goes to court like a couple times, and she usually is shown doing research or meeting with clients.
@yvette4948
@yvette4948 Год назад
And don’t forget the classic song: Don’t Be A Lawyer
@treyricks7348
@treyricks7348 Год назад
No money no money no money
@medealkemy
@medealkemy 11 месяцев назад
And when she does that big rousing trial of the people against big corporations in season 1, she loses!
@annejohnson5875
@annejohnson5875 Год назад
Thank you for mentioning the Wire. It does depict police work as tedious, with lots of paperwork, and in the courts lots of plea deals and cases that make one good bust, but so much is still left uninvestigated due to orders from command or to save some local politician's hide.
@marjolijnzuidema1475
@marjolijnzuidema1475 Год назад
I once had a collegue whose husband was a chef. We were all quite impressed, because we thought she would have amazing dinner every night. But she said: 'No, I'm the one that cooks. When my husband has been cooking all day at work, he doesn't have energy left to do it at home.' Eye opener :p
@jamesgomez9151
@jamesgomez9151 Год назад
I had a friend who was a chef, and also single. He dinner was often the Jack in the Box late night muchie meal🤢🤮
@michiganscythian2445
@michiganscythian2445 11 месяцев назад
My fiancé is a chef and he lives on fast food and gas station sandwiches when I don’t cook, lol. It’s difficult to go to a sit down restaurant because he’s analyzing the food (and can usually guess what supplier they use). It is nice when we do find a place that passes his muster, lol.
@thechefette3701
@thechefette3701 11 месяцев назад
after being on your feet for 10-12 hours in a blazing hot kitchen you really thought we'd get off and get back on our feet and into another kitchen!? FOR FREE!?
@SariSarkku
@SariSarkku Год назад
Fashion designers! Please do a take on how we are portrayed as lone geniuses when in actuality there is a large team working on a fashion collection
@aleenax2490
@aleenax2490 Год назад
Also everyone seems to have intense feelings about their coworkers, most love them and they are friends as well while others hate them, no one is ever just neutral about their coworkers
@kate8438
@kate8438 Год назад
As a physicist I feel like we get a parallel set of misrepresentations to the ones discussed in this video for the biological/life sciences, but we sure get a lot of them. One of the most bizarre to me though is the "multiple PhDs" trope. Like, why on earth would Bruce Banner have seven PhDs? What went wrong with the first six? In real life that would make him seem less serious, not more. Interestingly, one movie that really resonated with the career experience of my friends and I was Whiplash. Even though it's about a completely unrelated career (music), it really captures the fine line between dedication to one's craft and unhealthy obsession - or even exploitation - that comes with trying to operate at the top of your field.
@CrimsonNineTail
@CrimsonNineTail Год назад
Really, having more PhDs would make you look less accomplished?
@sierra8077
@sierra8077 Год назад
@@CrimsonNineTail Yes because you only need one to do research, so why would you not stop after the first and start publishing papers without an advisor
@trashyink2132
@trashyink2132 Год назад
That's the issue I had with black panther. You're telling me Tchalla chose to go back to college repeatedly to get more and more degrees? Why would anyone want to do that willingly?
@kj7067
@kj7067 Год назад
Frankly, doing more than one PhD would probably turn you into the actual Hulk. What's wrong with competing for an insanely limited pool of postdoc positions like the rest of us, Bruce?!
@jmchez
@jmchez Год назад
@@CrimsonNineTail The eternal student is not seen as a serious person.
@gabrielleduplessis7388
@gabrielleduplessis7388 Год назад
I love Legal Eagle’s film reviews because of how he points out the good and bad of these films. He understands what is used for characterization and entertainment, but recognizes the research some of these writers do.
@sadiayusuf3067
@sadiayusuf3067 Год назад
Writers! Can youtalk about writers in movies and tv? Especially movies and tv based on books where the protagonist is a writer. The process is more grueling and involves more procrastination and writers block than how it's romanticized.
@poetcindylynn
@poetcindylynn Год назад
Yes! And they always just publish one book and then are immediately able to live off that and get invited on book tours etc. when in reality very few professional writers can live without other jobs on the side, and many experience the anticlimax of very few reviews of a book it has taken years to write and get published, and even the most popular books have a short life-span in the public.
@Forceprincess
@Forceprincess Год назад
I really like the moments on parks and recreation that demonstrate how, emotional and uninformed the general public can be. Like, the less we know, the louder we get😂 and watching these people who want to help the public, navigate tricky conflicts of public opinions.
@kovilil
@kovilil Год назад
Most of the jobs and professions are not movie friendly as it would be kind of boring. However, there are ways to show them as interesting and more realistic, by avoiding the big dramatic aspects movies add
@josepharmstrong1788
@josepharmstrong1788 Год назад
I think that custodians, and fast food workers are strong candidates as they’re almost always portrayed as dead end jobs that are grunt work. That it’s impossible to find fulfillment in these kinds of jobs. This might explain why SpongeBob SquarePants is beloved by adults as his passion for his job goes against this ideology, plus the show even highlights how ego, greed, and rude customers are the real antagonists of these positions. Often, they aren’t even subtle about it.
@egyptianqueen4007
@egyptianqueen4007 Год назад
I don't think anyone truly enjoys working in fast food or as a custodian. It's hectic work with low pay.
@idealstrontium
@idealstrontium Год назад
Doctors for sure! Literally zero doctors sit at the bedside of their patients for hours on end (looking at you Greys) and it's not constant 'groundbreaking' never-been-done-before cases. Also nurses. They don't just 'take orders' from doctors. They are highly independent, highly knowledgeable, highly skilled and trained critical thinkers, time managers and compassionate workers.
@PokhrajRoy.
@PokhrajRoy. Год назад
My favourite misrepresentation is Social Media Influencers (apparently we’re all watching various versions of one person) and Female Actors in a Murder Mystery about the Movie who are rendered passive and inconsequential.
@josefk7437
@josefk7437 Год назад
Legal Eagle has a lawyer react to movies about lawyers. That is a good series. The song "Don't go to law school" from Crazy Ex Girlfriend was really good.
@joy9585
@joy9585 Год назад
I see teachers once again are overlooked or misunderstood by everyone to not even get a spot on this list. The media hugely underrepresents the fundamental basics of being a teacher: you can’t just walk off the street and get a teaching job because you’re “passionate” about a subject. It takes years of schooling, a Masters degree, and multiple certification tests to even qualify to become a teacher. Never mind once you actually work as one. Sure, summers are usually off (if you don’t have a second job to continue paying bills), but during the school year you’re typically working well past the kids get on the bus, weekends, and “vacation” time. Never mind the endless meetings (and emails), state-mandated professional development, and collaboration with colleagues. It’s not all “I’ll just throw on a movie!” or flighty wannabe writers who “couldn’t hack it.” One show that I love, but gets it wrong is New Girl (oh, and when did she get her administration certification? Because that’s more school and more tests and interning). There’s definitely more, but I’m drawing a blank right now. HOWEVER, I will say that Abbot Elementary is the closest to getting it right. How the principal got her job is still a little off, but the day-to-day grind and the hoops teachers need to jump through just to get some glue or a carpet that isn’t falling apart is realistically portrayed.
@jamiemeicheng6589
@jamiemeicheng6589 Год назад
0:47 Cops 3:39 Politicians 5:39 Chefs 7:28 Lawyers 10:50 Scientists
@lucasgagliardi433
@lucasgagliardi433 Год назад
What about teachers? We are either treated as inspiring mentor-like social assistant figures or as repressive gears of the system most of the times. Abbot Elementary and Bad Teacher at least make fun of many of those tropes.
@watsonmelon6575
@watsonmelon6575 Год назад
I'd love to see you guys talk about how historians are represented because, to put it lightly, National Treasure isn't exactly the most realistic....
@gretachristina6148
@gretachristina6148 Год назад
Therapists! Please do therapists! Screen representations of mental health care typically depict it as being about Big Breakthroughs - getting a patient to have One Big Moment of clarity or understanding, which will then fix them forever.
@mattmew28
@mattmew28 Год назад
Yes agreed… and therapists either being cold and detached or really unethical is infuriating
@chalyndajackson9384
@chalyndajackson9384 Год назад
Please do a part two. As you were naming more professions at the end you could really do one, probably a part three as well.
@bookbum19
@bookbum19 Год назад
Teachers!!! I've never seen a realistic depiction of the teaching profession onscreen. Either the teacher has a ton of free time, an immaculately decorated classroom, and a relationship with a single dad of one of her students OR the story only focuses on what a teacher did for a few years but ended up having to sacrifice their personal lives in order to achieve those results. Society at large holds unrealistic expectations for teachers, yet none of the decisions made in education center the well -being of the teachers.
@patriciaa4451
@patriciaa4451 Год назад
Please do retail workers next. I'd like to know how my favorite show, Superstore holds up to real life.
@dragongrrl3
@dragongrrl3 Год назад
That’s what I’d have said. Most people would assume we get paid right or assume we love where we work or that a company cares, but half the time that’s completely lies. They also don’t show things like how we can’t get benefits or afford things or like what is a common theme here, having spare time.
@cazia9
@cazia9 Год назад
You could do an entire video on Teacher Tropes alone - the fish out of water who comes to learn about the (usually other’d) community where they’re teaching, the wild card who upsets the stuffy institution with their radical thinking, the inspirational speaker who convinces their students to become like them, the bored burnout who sees teaching as a ticket to an easy life, the disconnected / disillusioned who have given up trying to be good at their career , the widely mocked new teacher who is wide eyed and eager to make a difference, the hot predator who sees the school social circle as their dating pool … the list goes on
@user-iv1lm6ib7o
@user-iv1lm6ib7o Год назад
As an educator, I can tell you that media gets teachers wrong. They're usually depicted as wholesome, wise types, but they're honestly just like everyone else. I love my job, but it's simply my 9 to 5. I have a whole life outside of it.
@Rodprz73
@Rodprz73 Год назад
I love how scientists are portrayed, they are always tasked to solve and conveniently invent a cure for a zombie virus. But she specializes in colon cancer.
@PokhrajRoy.
@PokhrajRoy. Год назад
0:20 Lee Pace in ‘Pushing Daisies’ deserved more love. Also, what an impeccable man.
@idealstrontium
@idealstrontium Год назад
The way I cried when that show was cancelled 😭
@aussiejubes
@aussiejubes Год назад
My contribution to this conversation is how little people in TV and movies work lol. Or how much life they're fitting in outside of work. They're always off in the middle of a work day meeting friends and colleagues, and having dinner out or friends over 7 nights a week. People popping over before work...do they have 43 hour days or what? 😂😂 Its that or theyre workaholics yet never get tired despite never getting sleep.
@farihamohamedhilmy4700
@farihamohamedhilmy4700 11 месяцев назад
Please do a Part 2 for this too! Like doctors, journalists, HR people, firefighters, and other typical office jobs (clerical jobs)
@timbuktu8069
@timbuktu8069 Год назад
"Drama is real life with all the dull parts removed." -Alfred Hitchcock
@PokhrajRoy.
@PokhrajRoy. Год назад
My favourite commentary had to be the ‘Scandal’ Parody on SNL and how ridiculous procedurals can get.
@XenoRaptor-98765
@XenoRaptor-98765 Год назад
Can you do a video that explains what movies got wrong with school and college?
@PokhrajRoy.
@PokhrajRoy. Год назад
6:15 Jennifer Coolidge talked about how chefs operated in restaurant kitchens. There’s also a spoken word piece by Dan Souza (a culinary expert) on a day in the professional kitchen.
@lkeke35
@lkeke35 Год назад
I worked in both public (fast food) and private dining situations (schools) and both jobs were grueling but still fun. I liked the people I worked with who really seemed to love the work too. And the customers you make basic food for are generally nice and appreciative.
@HeatherRising
@HeatherRising Год назад
I would love this to become a series! I'm a therapist and it is rare for a therapist to be portrayed accurately onscreen. I just watched the movie Bad Therapist and cringed all the way through. You could do this for actors, teachers, finance-related work (ahem Wolf of Wall Street), and so many more!
@sarabakkali4655
@sarabakkali4655 Год назад
I think you should do architects, artists (and how the glamorisation of these careers makes it seem that these people are living the dream while they aren’t) and doctors (how most of them have no time to even shower or sleep but we see them on tv having multiple affairs)
@Nikitomate
@Nikitomate Год назад
Oh yeah, Illustrator here. 60% of my work is meetings, invoices, maintaining my own social media and portfolio, selling my art on fairs and conventions and teaching art. Also doing art is just sitting in bad posture over the tablet screen or paper and listening to podcasts for hours. And also looking at other peoples art to figure out how they did where you struggle 😅
@lkeke35
@lkeke35 Год назад
Librarians are never depicted correctly onscreen. The only ones ever depicted are usually public ones who are old white ladies with glasses who are constantly shhhshing people, a trope that was old as soon as it became a trope! Most librarians are simply boring public servants just like all the others. We don't read books all day or tell people to be quiet (nobody cares if you talk in the library) and we actually love kids! The most realistic depiction of what being a public library worker is like is the 2018 The Public, starring Emilio Estevez.
@bjrlib
@bjrlib Год назад
I agree, there are as many different kinds of librarians as there are patrons qq and we're not all emotionally repressed folk who hide from the world in sterile, empty, silent libraries all day. Nor are we savants who can pull up whatever bit of esoteric document is needed at a moment's notice. And we don't sit around and read all day. It takes work, physical and mental, to keep a library running. On The Public, I think the early scenes are really good, funny and accurate, but once the plot kicks in, I feel like no library worker would respond the way Estevez and his director do.
@bjrlib
@bjrlib Год назад
For another option, what about Party Girl with Parker Posey?
@annejohnson5875
@annejohnson5875 Год назад
Not only that, but movies and shows often show people in lower paying jobs having their own apartments. In New York City.
@farrahaliceblack7453
@farrahaliceblack7453 Год назад
I'm a writer and comedian, and I'm so tired of the idea that creatives have to suffer for their craft, until they get their Big Break™ and then overnight they go from not being able to afford rent to world famous millionaires. I feel its why many don't sympathise with the WGA strike because they wrongly assume that if they're working at all, they must've had their Big Break™ so they can't complain. The world is full of working professional writers you've never, and probably will never know about. They work in teams, they work in gaming, they work in advertising, they work in museums- they can make comfortable livings, and they likely also have multiple jobs/income streams- sometimes related to their writing (like coaching/ workshop leading) sometimes not, like yes... Waitressing. But the solution isnt to expect writers to struggle and starve until they DESERVE to be a millionaire.
@thekage100
@thekage100 Год назад
Looove this video!! Could become a series! Helped me! Especially as an aspirating writer!
@allegory6393
@allegory6393 Год назад
A film noir of the early fifties (a great one) called 'On Dangerous Ground' gives a much more accurate representation of the lives of different policemen, It is rare in that it depicts the long boring hours of police work, sitting around in a car waiting for someone to come out of their flat or return to their flat. It also depicts their different family lives, from fathers of multiple children to loners, but all rather poorly paid (as their homes testify). Also, they depict policemen working on various cases throughout the day, not just one. When 'action' begins, about 30 mins. into the film, the police detective's role is more focused on stopping vigilante action rather than be himself the one who acts to catch the assassin (a 16-year-old with a neurological condition not actually accountable for the murder of a young girl -the whole film is melancholy like that). The great Robert Ryan plays the detective, and criminally underrated wonder Ida Lupino the blind sister of the young man. Highly recommended.
@akmaral6485
@akmaral6485 Год назад
this is such a great video!!
@Nekochou
@Nekochou Год назад
Psychologists. As someone training to become one, I now wince at so many on-screen psychologists. A lot of the times they are weird and/or manipulative or the villain in some way. And a lot of "sessions" portrayed are so unprofessional. They are sometimes too involved in the patient's life or otherwise clearly judging them which is a big no-no.
@PotatoChicken-gg1ju
@PotatoChicken-gg1ju Год назад
Any customer service job like fast food or retail. Honestly, the most accurate depiction I've seen was Squidward from SpongeBob, and you could argue that was still much more family-friendly than the reality.
@ChildOfDarkDefiance
@ChildOfDarkDefiance Год назад
I really liked The Good Wife, but as it went on I started to get exasperated with how many billable hours they were passing on to spend time scheming for power in the firm. One of my favorite parts of the serries is when Carry has been double crossed again, and rather than plotting his next move, he remembers this is SO not why he became a lawyer, and just walks away.
@kingshoob6105
@kingshoob6105 Год назад
Teachers. Being a teacher is less about inspiring the next generation and more about soul crushing paper work.
@goblinb
@goblinb Год назад
Thank you, thank you for mentioning chefs(actually cooks) in this, and getting it right.
@larissatom6910
@larissatom6910 Год назад
Nurses. I’m too busy to have an affair with a physician in the supply closet. Plus many of the tasks you see doctors do on tv are the nurses’ responsibilities.
@adrianghandtchi1562
@adrianghandtchi1562 Год назад
I work in hospitality, and I recently watched a film that did a similar duty at my place of work. When they film there a couple years ago, it’s very surreal, watching my occupation on screen and also our own policies that conflict with what is going on on the screen so it made me think. Wow this is what it’s like to see somebody do your job on camera and get it so wrong.
@clarasouza8157
@clarasouza8157 11 месяцев назад
I'd love an archaologist analysis, becaus people keep asking me where they can find dinosaurs close by, if I can read hieroglyphs and if I ever heard of ancient curses.
@post-electric
@post-electric Год назад
I'm an IT network infrastructure engineer. Apparently the role of me, my team, and the entirely separate cyber security team can be played by the guy that fixes the printers who is also a genius security professional (i.e. hacker).
@realshehrkhan
@realshehrkhan Год назад
The Wire, VEEP, The Bear and Saul/Vinny are excellent picks... good job @The Take
@ghinwamoujaes9059
@ghinwamoujaes9059 Год назад
Friends portrayal of Ross's academic career was bad too
@jovil666
@jovil666 Год назад
We need a part 2 heck even a part 3
@justingriffiths6931
@justingriffiths6931 Год назад
With all of the medical dramas, I would like one to one day even show a competent health care chaplain. Or show that doctors do not do everything.
@ChildOfDarkDefiance
@ChildOfDarkDefiance Год назад
For good pollitical shows Yes, Minister and it's sequel series Yes, Prime Minister are great examples, though quite a bit older.
@hardcandy9880
@hardcandy9880 10 месяцев назад
The media always portrays HR as boring or straightlaced or always against employees. But working closely with them, it's actually colorful and exciting because there are so many branches of HR (if you are a creative or into tech or into teaching etc, theres always something). Plus, they actually do what they can to help employees, it's just that they have to balance it with the business interests as well, and unfortunately they become the scapegoat when the two sides dont like the outcome. When in fact, most of the time, they are the only reason why it isnt worse.
@bloodmooncomics2249
@bloodmooncomics2249 Год назад
Stay-at-home parents. It is always a mother, unless it is a comedy about how 'dad can't cut it'. There are a lot of great stay-at-home-dads, but according to Hollywood only if it is force on the family and the dad has no idea what he is doing (pushing the idea of mom has to do all at home stuff even when she works just as much as the dad). It also loves to show how the stay-at-home parent has everything together, again unless it is a comedy laughing about the parent having a hard time. Not every stay-at-home parent makes their kids perfect lunches for school or has everything perfect for when the kids bring a bunch of friends over, yet still has time to make a perfect five course meal by the time dad gets home. Another one is teachers. Teachers are always shown to be nearly stalking their students. They are always in the main character's (sometimes a side character's) business. They are always there way before school and stay way after school. If the kid/teen has any personal issue the teacher is right there to listen and help with the perfect advice. In reality a lot of teachers are overworked. They want to help, but do not know how or spread too thin to really notice small details showing a kid needs help. Of course you also have horrible teachers as well who seem to hate teaching and hate children yet are there. Those teachers are never shown.
@Dm34421
@Dm34421 Год назад
I’m always shocked that tv character liked their jobs
@enzmondo
@enzmondo Год назад
I’d love to see a continuation of this topic with more examples of misrepresented professions. Some from the art world, some in the office world, and some in the healthcare world (bout not doctors, more of nurses and caregivers)
@chloependleton
@chloependleton Год назад
Nurses. According to TV/movies, we don’t exist in the medical setting until doctors need someone to sleep with in the call room. Almost everything they show doctors do in shows (direct pt care) is a nurse’s job.
@SystemaAlpha
@SystemaAlpha Год назад
Programmer, like 90% of the time I was sitting there looking at a problem to understand it and then researching possible solutions.
@michellem9444
@michellem9444 Год назад
Okay, this isn't a career that's unrealistic, but can we talk about the size of some houses and apartments on TV shows? Especially when there's a super-expensive area like New York or San Francisco, and people with low level jobs have all the space in the world! And the houses are always multi-million-dollar mansions. Does no one live in a basic 3BD/2BA ranch anymore? LOL
@DoloresLehmann
@DoloresLehmann Год назад
In Germany, there's a really funny police show centered around a police station in a small town in deepest Bavaria, and the main trait of almost all the protagonists is being hopelessly incompetent. I've talked to an actual policeman and he said that's one of the more realistic depictions of actual policework he's ever seen.
@Nikitomate
@Nikitomate Год назад
Mord mit Aussicht? 😂
@DoloresLehmann
@DoloresLehmann Год назад
@@Nikitomate Nein, Hubert und/ohne Staller.
@Nikitomate
@Nikitomate Год назад
@@DoloresLehmann dann muss ich die mir mal ansehen. Danke für den Tipp 👍❤️
@DoloresLehmann
@DoloresLehmann Год назад
@@Nikitomate Is was für Leute, die auf echt albernen Humor stehen. Mit Christian Tramitz in einer der Hauptrollen, also wenn du den kennst, weißt du schon ungefähr, wohin der Hase läuft.
@Nikitomate
@Nikitomate Год назад
@@DoloresLehmann ich schreib es auf meine To Watch Liste! Das klingt nach einem absoluten Muss 🤩
@chrissiem3958
@chrissiem3958 Год назад
I think the Revolutionary/Manic Pixie Dream Teacher trope and the Misanthropic/Antagonistic Teacher trope. I know a lot of teachers in my life who, though that job can be (and often is) f**king exhausting, they still really do love it. But 'loving their job' doesnt mean that they are encouraging their students to stand on desks, or teaching Shakespeare through rap to under priviledged kids. It means getting on with your job, the good and the bad, and finding what solutions you can along the way. Its one of the reasons why I love Abbott Elementary so much. It shows the younger, more optimistic (and therefore perhaps more naïve) teachers, as well as the older (and therefore wiser to the complexities) teachers, but each group teaches something to the other, and usually ends in how to have realistic expectations, but to still have hope and strive for better, even if you lose or fall short. And all of it in a under funded public school in Philidelphia. I mean, even the SCHOOL BUILDING is portrayed as solid, but needing lots of work! But in the end, with the teachers in the show, much like in real life, they all love their jobs and do what they can to educate and take care of their students to the best of their abilities.
Далее
The Housewife Onscreen - Why She's Devalued
22:55
Просмотров 198 тыс.
Movies That Wrecked Directors' Careers
23:30
Просмотров 283 тыс.
АСЛАН, АВИ, АНЯ
00:12
Просмотров 167 тыс.
Policing Women’s Clothing Needs To Stop | FEMINISM
13:05
Inside The Hollywood Method Acting Backlash
13:19
Просмотров 82 тыс.
How Virtue Signaling Killed Hollywood
16:20
Просмотров 185 тыс.
Why 90s Movies Look and Feel Different
10:07
Просмотров 433 тыс.
The Fab 4: Why 4-Person Shows Work So Well
13:33
Просмотров 71 тыс.
The Other Woman Trope - Demystifying The Villain
24:41
Просмотров 320 тыс.
тот самый ред флаг…
0:40
Просмотров 2,1 млн
Он разрубил планету😱
0:59
Просмотров 5 млн