There was an incident happend in North A police wale asked me u dont even know hindi being an Indian (I a from Tamilnadu) Being a police officer he doesnt even know the basic english and then I started asking questions in Sanskrit he starts blinking I asked him back dont call urself Bharatiya unless u understand sanskrit. Hindi is imposed language if Government promotes sanskrit we are ready to learn. FROM TAMILNADU
@@influencer3 In what terms? is Samskrit derived from Tamizh in any way? now don't tell me Tamizh is older than Sanskrit ... that's a too absurd way to compare languages. Samskrit is literary more rich than Tamizh and forever will be
@@ADas-ux6el officialy the oldest ever scription for language is found to be 5000 years old which is Thamizh and Sanskrit's was 3500 years !.. not me or you to decide it is history.. you can't change that !.. Tamil is official language of 8 countries unlike no other indian languages.. and coming sanskrit you said richer than tamil ? 🤣 A dead language which not even spoken in india and you compare that with forever living language tamil !. You never know about tamil history ! Ask to your PM modi he will say what is "Thirukural" and himself told that Tamil is oldest language of World that every indian should be proud off .. and if not you are anit-indian !.. I'm a malyali " I'm proud of our indian language the greatest ever language tamil " your sanskrit is not even equal to shoe dust of tamil" ( if it had a shoe ). 🗿
@@pokemonitishere202 just seen your previous comment Telugu Golti 🤣 you literally said " Telugu is mother of Sanskrit " 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 🤣 a multi dimensional joker 🃏
This is why coming 2026 elections in Tamilnadu is so important not just for TN but for hole of India, the sooner we free Tamilnadu from the clutches of the DMK thugs, the better.
Thats you imagination you ST... F...., Sanskrit and Tamil lived and evolved together for over 3000 years at least, you D.... F... if anything destroying Tamil it's the stupid english. And by the way I am a Tamilian.
@@tsMuthuraman-hm6wg Tamil and Sanskrit lived and evolved together for over 3000-year, the Pallavas, Cholas, Cheras and Pandiyas who developed Tamil also developed Sanskrit, in 200 years it introduced the English is the one that destroyed Tamil the most, WHY THE F ME A TAMILIAN REQUIRED TO SPEAK FLUENT ENGLIHS TO WORK IN TAMILNADU????
I am Tamil, presently staying in Odisha only, odisha is a very culturally rich place. Please start use old odia words instead of modern mixing words. Keep working to secure your history and language.
as a north indian ,i think it is time everyone learns 3 language. english + mother tongue+ pick any from 22 lang . 3rd one for speaking only , no need to burden kids with grammar or writing. english is taking over, most of my rich friends kids can barely speak mother tongue. my nephew speaks hindi like he is nri kid from america. when i was in bengluru, people only wanted to speak english, so never got the chance to learn kannada. but when i was in a arab country i had to learn basic arabic, bcz no one wanted to converse in english.
As a South Indian, I can tell in next 100 years, English will vanish from South India. Currently world is connected by English, it was Persian before and so on. English time is coming to end
@@venkatakishore8941 English wont go anywhere to be honest. Even if the west stops speaking English, Us south Indians will keep it alive, Its Integral to us, Its our second langauge and we will chose english over Hindi anyday. you learn it or you perish
@@prajualdennis8760 😂perish?? Are u a MoFo rice bag?? There are billions of ppl who don't know English nd are still leading a good life Us South Indians?? 😂😂 English is not our language it is just need of the hour if the west nd other parts of the world move on to another language English will RIP nd we'll learn the new language Don't live in delusion
Made to hate Sanskrit? Don't make me laugh with your idiotic clickbait question. Only state with more Sanskrit classes and teachers than Tamil Nadu are Karnataka and Maharasthra both of which still have Sanskrit speaking villages. Without Tamils preserving Sanskrit palmleaf manuscripts cowbelters would still be reading Persian, Turkish and Arabic scripts. Without Tamils devotion to Hinduism and spreading of Bhakti movement the weak North Indians who were conquered by foreign Muslims for 800+ years would all be worshipping Allah instead of our indigenous Hinduism. We should be asking why North Media and culture hates South Indians specifically Tamils for daring not to kowtow to their stupidity and accept Hindi as dominant language of India despite Hindi being an bastard language with many Arabic, Turkish and Persian loanwords. Even movie industry wise we see what accepting Hindi has done to Bengali industry essentially dismantling and destroying the industry that in the 70s was still the largest film industry in South Asia... and don't dare bring up acceptance when Gujarat, Punjab, Maharashtra, Assam and Haryana have all had Anti-Hindi riots where Bihari and UP migrants were attacked while Tamil Nadu has never had a riot against Hindi people.
Finally India is a union of States and Unity among diversity. So i respect all the spoken and written languages. Don't keep on fiddling with languages and create disharmony among the people of India which is sensitive. Narendra Damodaradas Modi's regime is the darkest side of Indian politics which made discrimination among people of India on communal and language basis which can't be accepted my dear Indian people. I love you all❤❤❤
It's self preservation what did Congress do to help Hindus cause. No mention appeasement of mus.. modi speaks as it is. Brushing everything under the carpet and then pushing moderate narrative is bound to break down some day and modi just did it. I have seen countless debate and leftist can't even put up a fight the right debaters just tramples them
Certain section of society who make videos by leeching of content like this might come after you and your channel in the future, breaking apart everything, labelling as pseudoscience,false narration. Don't falter,don't fall for their provocations. Keep spreading the information and uniting us as one. We are with you ❤ 🙏🏻
When I was a kid, I used to think why a perticular thing is called as the way it is. Example, I could call a 'chair' as 'chur' or 'chaour' or 'charur' etc. any word can be used, why rigidity in language. But actually people are really dynamic, as you go from one to another geographical boundaries, languages and scripts are changing. Actually people are using any word the way which they like and that passes through generations. Yeah, Languages are really very rich in nature but that's not the only way.
Most north indians have given up their local dialects or languages and adopted hindi for easier, broad based commincation at an inter regional level. Why should the south be an exception to the nation building process? The need for a common language was emphasized by all the leading freedom fighters, from netaji bose to ambedkar.
From maharashtra, local maharashtraians are facing economic and social invasions from all sides..we don't hate north or south but want life freedom in our state.. Constant rush is created by outsiders.
So what’re you suggesting? That we stop speaking tamizh? I don’t get why tamizh is so targeted. Hindi speakers will come to your place and tell you to speak Hindi. That’s what the colonizers did. There’s a reason Tamizh Nadu is doing better than most states.
For everyone saying that gujarat , maharashtra having their own language, Have basic knowledge that u r from same indo-aryan language which makes u easy to understand Like how other Dravidian can understand basic of other language of south
The mental gymnastics this video is goung through is amazing - this guy is ignoring the wild elephant in the room standing right in front of him and trying to find the dog barking on the horizon. The modern fault line is no longer in this Aryan Dravidian nonsense that you're spouting but in the attitudes of both the Union government and the loud voices echoing across from the Hindi heartland. That's the real problem. It's about Union government policies that promote and invest significantly more on infrastructure, signage and education in Hindi than in any other Indian language. It's in the deliberate attempt, as specifically mentioned in the annual reports of several government departments and PUCs, to promote Hindi. A national department or organisation is mandated to develop Hindi at the cost of regional languages. It's the Hindi heartland politicians that come to power in the centre and demand Hindi be forcefully made the national language and lingua franca, threaten to impose the language. And there's track record of how Hindi has eroded dozens of more popular languages in Bihar - Maithili, Awadhi, Angika and many more have loat ground ever since the British elevated Hindi over other languages in an attempt to break the locals' link to their roots and power bases. Yes folks, modern Hindi is a colonizer's language. Add to that the attitude of so many loud North Indian voices who look down upon South Indian languages and demand that we all pick up Hindi. Demand that locals talk in the language of Hindi immigrants in their own hometowns. And the venom that are nowadays being spewed against Tamilians and Keralites, linking their linguistic identities to all sorts of vile beliefs. Address all of this instead of crying over spilt milk no one remembers or cares about. It's this sort of smokes and mirrors that seems to divert focus away from real issues fuelling the divide that gets a channel like this called out as a Sanghi channel. It has nothing do with religious beliefs or cultural pride or any of that sort - just the willingness to shift any accountability away from the core Sanghi voter base that's perpetuating this cycle of hatred. It's the language or its speakers that annoy us and get us to push back. It's this high handed tactics using Hindi as a blunt force weapon that is the problem. This is why even generally accommodating Kannadigas in Bangalore are losing patience.
Yes, I'd be more than happy to be called out hindi hater than be imposed to learn and accept Hindi. If I must accept Hindi, let the rest of non-Dravidians learn at least one Dravidian language. All politicians must learn one Dravidian language fluently and converse in others with limited fluency.
The author states that the 2 british fellows had motives or were driven by ideology to spread their north south divide stories. Same applies to the author. He seems very driven to show a joint Sanskrit based origin and force of India. Even in this modern Era where ample genetics based proof have been presented on the diverse origins of not just peoples of India but also languages, he seem to be immersed in this unification zeal. Unification is good, but not through subjugation of the other sides. I don't see any will from northies to assimilate any other culture 😅. In fact the author doesn't know or conveniently ignores that most northies who are brought up in strict caste based families hate anything outside their caste..too bad for them though 😅😅😅. And I have a counter theory to his. I have a strong feeling that Indus valley civilization had no present day north Indians and the languages that they spoke gave rise to Tamil, Sanskrit and other Indian languages and influenced European languages.😊
When i went to study at Banglore in the year 2000 in a well-known renowned institution some seniors and locals taught us or rather gave us geographical and historical gyan " that from odissa and Maharashtra they count it South India. Whereas im coming from Kolkata that means im North Indian 😂", whereas im an east Indian..and some people addresses some as " ae hindi idhar aa, bangali idhar aa"....still cant understand what they want to prove by that we are 1nation 1 people. Brother my motto is:- Born Sanatani Die Sanatani. Jai Shri Ram 🙏🏻🚩❤️ If somebody ask that did they pressurized me to learn Kannada? No they don't..i tried to learn it as i have to raoam around for my study,my daily necessities,my pleasure time....and because of "Sanskrit" there are many words in Kannada which is symmetrical to my mother tongue "Bengali" . Meaning is same but the pronounciation is different. Like " Salpa" = "Alpo" ( give some space etc..)
I am a Malayali who spent my first 25 yrs in Calcutta.My father was in ISI where there were a lot of people belonging to ( previous) Andhra Pradesh. Bengali/ Assamese have a small change of using "o"kaar for hrasva letters, 'ba' for 'va',etc Similarly ,for 'sha',Assamese use 'ha'( hence Ahom), same for people from Sylette,Karnataka who use 'ha' for 'pa'. Since I onow English, Malayalam ( southernmost state of India),Hindi and Bengali & can understand Tamil,I feel confident that I can travel to all parts of India and communicate my needs.Bengali,Marathi, all have loads of Sanskrit,and hence similar words as in Malayalam.Malayalam pronunciation is best,I felt,yet,in Marathi they say"punah,punah" for which in Malayalam we say "pinneyum pinneyum", such similarities are seen across the length and breadth of India.Only ,while in some languages,the term is used as a literary one,the other as a colloquial one I being a doctor,and knowing Bengali,one such example is:- Bengali patients come and say we have "vedana"( "Bedona" is used as 'sadhu bhasha in Bengali, while they use the term " byetha" --- "vyatha" used as literary word in Malayalam. We all are definitely one. There are many such words -- Bihu in Assam is Vishu for us,same day too. Malayalees wear a two-piece cloth very akin to Mekhla of Assam. Sabuj or Sabaz of Punjabi is Shobooj in Bengali -- meaning green. Lovely video.I hope you have the patience to go through this whole thing.
पूरे भारत को भाषा द्वारा एक करने का एक ही मार्ग है और वह तभी संभव है जब हम हिंदी शुद्ध बोलें। परोक्ष रूप से मैं कह रहा हूं कि हिंदी में जितना हो सके संस्कृत शब्दों का प्रयोग करें क्योंकि हमारे मराठी, बांग्ला, ओड़िया, गुजराती, मलायालम, कन्नड़ा, तेलुगु और यहां तक कि तमिल में भी संस्कृत शब्द हैं। मैं आपको एक उदाहरण दूंगा. अनुमति शब्द, हिंदी- अनुमति तमिल- अनुमति कनंड़ा, मलायालम, तेलुगु- अनुमति बांग्ला, उड़िया, गुजराती- अनुमति यदि हम शुद्ध हिन्दी का प्रयोग करें तो लोग बहुत अधिक हिन्दी समझ सकेंगे। अब यह मत कहिए कि अंग्रेजी का उपयोग करें क्योंकि भारत में एक-दूसरे के साथ संचार के लिए विदेशी भाषा का उपयोग क्यों किया जाना चाहिए।
1 genuine question, why do we let hindi be polluted by Persian words but can't have words from our own Indian languages, it will help in nation building also it will minimize the difference! languages are not made in a day or decade but centuries or millennia, if India is to be the nation we want we have to work on homogenizing our society! creating uniform market of 1.4 Billion Indians and creating much more wealth to sustain this nation!!
u idealising homogeneity in a nation, BHARAT is always known for diversity that's y we say unity in diversity , in one's home also two people don't have similar choices how can u except that in a country , if u have studied little bit of economics u should know there is nothing like uniform market though u can peruse to end monopoly nd oligopoly , cultural are like soup bowl different things get mixed nd gives its unique taste nd language is part of culture nd nt only language, food, architect; use of white marble, which was favored in Persian architecture, became prominent in Mughal buildings nd now in every Indian home , BIRYANI most ordered food in India is Persian dish , nd Persian words nd Hindi grammar made Urdu nd Hindi nd Urdu are both Indian language thus words gets interplayed as Persian words are part of Urdu there is NO national language of our country , the Indian constitution recognizes 22 major languages of India in 8th schedule , Purpose is to communicate u can do that with love, hope u r nt poluting Hindi by calling 'गोलगट्टम लकड़ पट्टम दे दनादन प्रतियोगिता' as Cricket
@@6666Rudra I can give you different arguments for everything you wrote but sooner or later we need to understand this "unity in diversity" rant actually weakens us, i have been in policy making side of govt and believe me It's not easy to govern a country like india with diversity+ our diversity i actually used against us by china and pakistan! china has contained it's diversity, pakistan has almost killed it's diversity! what do you think they'll do after they complete homogenising their society? BTW do you know china has no real connect with outer world through any type of social media! we can't do this in India! As much as anybody in india likes to hate, China will be a super power in this region and only country that can challenge that is India with it's size and population what do you think they'll do to India when USA hegemony is over? earlier we were colonized by mughals then by britishers and coming century we will be colonized by chinese if we don't mend our ways! there is time to be romantic and there is time to be practical, now is the time to be practical!!
As a tamilian here no ones hates hindi or any other language,we just want to save our language,we are against hindi imposion not hindi,lot of north indian languages itself gone extinct or in the edge extinctiion because of hindi,a language is the thing which carries our history and culture ,if we lose our language,it equal to erasing our history from earth,in simple term your language is great in its own way,likewise ours too,so don't impose your language on your.
I have bot been to tamil nadu but i can kind of agree, but i can't agree their only being one sided victim. The so called Dravidianists don't just hate hindi but also hate on the immigrants from northern states and that too is truth. The major propoganda arises from making a racial divide between both people, while all of our cultures are interconnected. I guess we do need a language that culturally unites all of us, it can either be sanskrit which has absorbed and influenced everyone in the subcontinent through history, or it can be a new simplistic artificial language that is created by taking inspiration from every Bharti language. Also in some cases lingual hate is very much true, as one can see in Bengaluru where literally all shops with non kannada boards wete threatened or tried to vandalize them. A kind of hypocrisy is also that muslims in these states speaking urdu is tolerated but hindi speaking people are hated on.
I hope Tamil hindu survives the next 15 years in Tamilnadu. I believe only Tamil speaking people will be there, but no hindu culture will be left as Tamil will be spoken by muslim. And Christian, like in pakistani punjab, all speak punjabi, but all are muslim.
Sir, But those who come from other states to Andhra Pradesh are now the two Telugu states Telangana and Andhra speak to us in their own language and we the residents of Telugu states will have to learn their language and speak to them like sorry to say slaves, this is what I observed from those who come from other states even in hotels, oriya and bihari people only speak in Hindi and insist on us to speak in Hindi in Hyderabad and even in Visakhapatnam. Telugus also now a days not liking their mother tongue. Now a days, even some letters are not pronounced and they forgotten telugu letters like ళ,శ,ణ and so on.
😂😂this is a rational observation. Just go to the godavari districts of Andhra Pradesh and see how one is treated if he doesn't know Telugu. Scorned. Anyways be happy atleast this video is getting u guys recognition. Alot of fuss about Telugu. Btw, I'm not a North Indian.
Well in kannada if we see there is prevalence and should be used letters as u mentioned ಣ , ಳ , ಶ in kannada if we interchange the latter the meaning will only change off like ಅನ್ನ it means rice ಅಣ್ಣ means brother ಳ is heavily used in kannada without it there's is no words which can be made it's still important in kannada
Telangana Telugu people pronounce శ(श) correctly. But we pronounce the Retroflex sounds ణ, ళ, ష (ण, ळ, ष) as న, ల, శ (न, ल, श) respectively, because we don't have a habit of pronouncing ణ, ళ, ష in our dialect. As per my observation, Andhra Telugu people, Tamil, Odia and Assamese people pronounce శ(श) as 's' instead of using 'sh'. Like, instead of writing Shiva(शिव/శివ) they write it as Siva. Especially I observed Andhra people writing వంశీ / वंशी as Vamsi, while in Telangana we write it as Vamshi.
Only one part of the story. Other part- North Indians are brainwashed into : 1. Believing that Urdu vocabulary is Hindi 2. That language is national language and everybody must speak in it. Otherwise they are separatists. 3. There are not taught about 'Proto Dravidian language'. It really exists. Talk in Sanskritized (Shudh) Hindi in South. Be more gentle while interacting.
Let me tell you I'm from north and i can give you clear picture here nobody cares about langauge if you go to gurgaon you will find no board in hindi all in English we just want one common language to communicate to you properly one bhartiya language simple
@@soumyadipmukherjee6627agree Sanskrit is much better language, was official language in almost Indian Kingdoms even Chola. While Hindi was a regional language .pS I am from UP, Hindi is not my Grandparents language it was Braj Bhasha.
I'm not sure Hindi is hated in certain parts of India. It is the politicians who make it an issue. If you look at the graduates of Hindi Prachar Sabha, there are more candidates from Tamil Nadu. That shows, it is the politicians who engineer the hate, for votes.
The land for hindi prachar sabha is also given by the state government. And no one hates hindi Or hindi speaking people here. We just hate the insensitivity people from hindi belt have towards tamil speaking people. Tamils don't get offended if we go to North and no one speaks to us in tamil. We accept all the differences that are there. And North indian workers here feel more safer than they were in their villages. Most of them say the same. Only few people from North working in white collar jobs get offended for even telling you don't have a surname!. They keep B!tching about the differences they see here. That's my observation.
That too is true, main thing is the politicians themselves are motivated by these british division policies and are supported by evangelists and NGOs funded by breaking india forces.
I truly hate.. for activities... They should immediately stop this... North Promote only Hindi/Urdu/Persianised... South wants Sanskrit Delaying of teaching, promoting Sanskrit will leads to more Rift and misguided...
The good thing is all this wrong can be corrected. All our Gurus hail from Southern part of India. The invaders destroyed temples in North India but could not reach the Southern part of India. If anything, this is our time to display to the world not only is India one but we also enjoy the diversity embedded in our culture. Bounded by an invisible thread of the same reality.
90% gurus came from north not South and invaders didn't came I'm South cuz North Indians were fighting invaders abd there were 10 times more foreign attack om North than South
@@Worldcitizen7777 out of 5 jagadgurus 4 are sri adi shankaracharya , sri ramanujacharya , sri madhavacharya , sri nimbarkacharya born in southern part of india
"The invaders destroyed temples in North India" - this particular ignorance should stop. To dictate invasion wasn't happening in south or the extreme idiocy of the same which dictate south wasn't faced with war is complete ignorance of history. Muslim invasion started in south much earlier than in north from Africa and our SE Asian friends weren't staying idol either, there are multiple reports of conquest and war made onshore and offshore with them. Heck did none of you wonder why many SE countries as South Indian, especially Tamizh flavors in their society and for some even their language is influenced by Tamizh. Not to mentions for thousands of years south was divided among four major kingdoms and they were at their necks at the chance and then there is forest/mountain tribe. Destruction of temples in North is not just subjected to invasions alone rather due to your own frivolous practices and lack of intolerance in every empire that ruled these region. And this shows even today. In simple words you people way too focused on religion...to the point you look like cult members.
being an Marathi (Maharashtrian), i love all indian languages, & respect them. i like शुद्ध हिन्दी but I hate new north indian/ Bollywood "hurdu" ( हुउर्दू mixer of hindi & persian) language.
North Indian languages are different because common people of North India stopped using Samskrutham words in local dailacts and started using Urdu and Persian words..the very word "Persian" is a Samskrutham word Parushini. A culture developed in banks of river Parushini
Origin Middle English: from Old French persien, from Latin Persia, via Greek from Old Persian pārsa ‘Persia’ (modern Persian pārs, Arabic fārs ) Parushini is Ravi river where porus fought alexander😂
I'm from Tamil Nadu. No one hate Hindi or North Indian. Its just a myth. We Only against imposing. Then how North Indian Rajinikanth became a number one hero in Tamil Nadu. Even if he is Marathi we never saw him as a Marathi. Same goes to Periyar who is kannadiga.
If that was case, loving too much of mother tongue language, why do Tamil govt impose strong English language in all subjects, Even in our Andhra also they impose strong English language in all subjects, why are not look English as communication language
Wait for voice enables LLM translators in built in watches and phones etc. No one will require to learn nay language. It may sound as idiotic as back 20 years ink pen was thought be irreplaceable a. Language is just medium and we should not fight. CuLture is one. Once revival happens in TN, it will be greatest. TN IS the cultural capital state of India and t TN politicians knew the fact if they keep open they will become irrelevant and thats why linguistic divide was taken as catalyst to carry on politics because after anti hindu anti brahmin eradication there was no issue accept language as a barrier for them to survive. It is a just a matter of time TN will have its glory and DMK goons cannot stop it no matter what they do. NB:Dont bother to reply if you are a DMK goon. i wont entertain
There is a valid reason for Hindi hate - The problem with most Hindi people is their expectation from others to learn Hindi, rather than them showing respect to local languages. They tend to establish that Hindi is superior.
That's just your perspective to see things. Just because someone speaks Hindi in a nonHindi demography doesn't mean they are asserting their superiority. It merely means that the individual isn't aware of the local language. If people know what the individual is speaking they would reply, if they don't they'll pass. That's how it is ought to be. Inspite of being a South Indian, I cannot understand Kannada and Telugu, so does it mean I feel that my language is superior, exactly no.
@@peacepact8875this is not about he/she speaking in Hindi. It is about him / her forcing others to speak in Hindi in unwilling non Hindi speaking states through individual actions and through central govt.
@@Aratiii06 I will again repeat. If someone speaks in Hindi and you understand it, then reply. If you don't understand, you can freely say I don't understand and pass. I have only heard Classical languages being promoted by Central government and Hindi is not a classical language on first place.
Just realized: You speak Hindi because that's the only language you know. We speak to you in Hindi because that's the only language you know. It's a Hindi circle of life!
For the propaganda driving people adding dividing comments won't work in project shivoham audience. .. for us desha and dharma are important..... not dominating on one another...jai shree ram...
Not only Hindi. Sultanates, Khiljis, Timurs, Mugals, British etc everyone and everything got foothold on north india because of incapable people without any selfrespect and value for their mother tongue or culture.
A place surrounded by water on three sided is called as dravida. A language spoken in this region is called as dramil -> tamil. Mix of dramil & Sanskrit in trilinga(region surrounded by 3 linga) region is telugu. Same for karunadu & chera nadu.
@@HelloShri-hi7ui No, it's somewhat true. In ancient times, we don't have name for language. so the place name became language name. Dravid -> Dramil -> Tamil. (First Dramil represent the language spoken in Dravid region. Then later it became as present Tamil). Trilingual -> Telungu -> Telugu. Karu(black) + naadu(country) -> Karnataka(black soil land). Malai(mountain) + aal(man) -> Malayalam (mountain region).
@@Aamaaraan7 for that i accepted coz our young generation in Indonesia they already become real Indonesian but they’re still understand tamil language but for replied little beat difficult, but now in medan (specially) we starting for teach them tamil language…we need also some support tamilian from india (maybe in future)…for teach us about language n origin culture from south India🙏🏻, thanks for the attention bro👍🏼
@@VijAl-s6b yep, these fools can't even accept india was united by british east india company. why the hell they have to create a divide using Tamil vs North ?
I am from Uttarakhand, and I respect the people of southern part of India. External actors tried to divide us by telling false stories and they also succeeded. This is the time to take India forward. There is no doubt that South India is more developed than North India and there are still many problems in the North. We all should work for the country like Indians. And as far as language is concerned, you can speak in whatever language you like, there is no doubt that South India has rich Indian languages and we all respect them. One of the main reasons for the bad conditions in North India is the invasion of external forces from the North, which our ancestors faced bravely, we should respect it and do the collective development of the whole of India. And please stay away from those leaders who talk about dividing India. They are ready to do anything just for there votes. Jai Hind ❤🇮🇳❤️ (Ps-: I'm trying to learn some South languages 😅 its tough 😭🥲 but I'll 🤧)
@@Aratiii06 thanks for the suggestion. But I'm really not a RU-vidr. Just an audience who has a right to an opinion. And i wouldn't take the trouble to boost one single language majorly. Only an inferior person will go the extent of blowing his own trumpet, whether with proof or not. Every language is unique. It's not about which language we speak, it's all about how well we connect humbly to a human or an animal. Once we die, we leave it all to the 5 elements.
People living south of Godavari are called Madrasis and people living north of Godavari are called Biharis. So in India two categories live one Madrasis and other Biharis.
Thx for explaining. I keep seeing "bihar bhai" in some Hindi twitter accounts and didn't know what they refer to. FYI: I'm a foreigner who learned Hindi surrounded by good people from Kerala and Telangana. REALLY wanna learn Telugu. 💕
@@akhripasta2670dear language learning takes time, link language is required. Like Indonesia has Bahasa Indonesia(Indonesian language). Indonesia like India, is pretty diverse too.
21:46 we tamils always wanted to speak and write in pure tamil without the mixing of other languages, thats what all the tamil poets also insisted (of course now while speaking we use english and other language words also in between, but while writing we won't mix most of the time ) . this is not because of hate to other languages or sanskirit, it is because love to our Tamil and tamil culture and to protect it from other language mixing to protect its originality/ uniqness , that's the whole idea . And this idea is not started after british it was here way before from the sangam age , that's why Tamil is being the oldest language spoken by large number of people in the world. so the whole point is we don't hate any language we love our language and culture more than anything and we want to preserve it.
It is more accurate to say that tamil is actually the LEAST sanskrit mixed language instead of It is pure.. cuz since 1bce or 1ad tamik started to get sanskrit vocab now there are considerable number of sanskrit words which can easily or hardly pick up in tamil..
@@ChannaJayawardhana-h1o Yes, of course there are some sanskrit words mixed in Tamil, but those words don't have to be in Tamil and Tamil don't need that also, because Tamil can be spoken and written without the help of any other language's vocabularies, (which is not the case of some other languages that need Sanskrit or Tamil's vocabs to speak and write). So Tamil being like this why we have to mix sanskrit in Tamil to ruin is purity. And i am saying this again we don't hate any language , we hate any language imposition and we want to protect our languages purity like how our ancestors did , at least we will try. And i won't believe that point u said about Tamil started getting sanskrit vocab from 1bce or 1ad, it should be started hardly 600 or 700 years(maximum) before from now . Because in 1bce and upto 1000-1200AD Cheras, Cholas and Pandyas where around there at that time so they will never let it happen.
But I am very happy to hear that Telugu is from Sanskrit. As I read in some text long ago that Sanskrit was born from the mouth of Bhavan Vishnu and Telugu from his mind( heart hridayam హృదయం)
I'm from Bengal. Today politicans, historians especially the leftists communist propagate this Arya - Dravida propaganda. In Bengal they are trying to portray mahisasur as the native dravidan of Bengal and ma Durga as Aryan. I think as Hindu and Indian we need to support intercaste and inter State marriages make the bond stronger. And we need to learn our mother language+ Sanskrit.
Next is the “exclusion of Ravana” in Periya Puranam. One can write a thesis on this subject but let me make it simple. Any Tamil scholar who has some association with the Siva Tradition (not Saivite tradition) knows that the whole of the Periya Puranam is based on the “one poem” found and made available sometime in the 12th century (Suntarar - Tiruttondar Tiruvandhadhi - Thirumurai 7). The compiler of all these poems (Nambiyandar Nambi) created a verse using this single poem. Any one not found in this verse (including Manikavasagar of Siva Puranam) is not listed in the 63 Nayanmar, let alone Ravana. It is as simple as that. Now to provide more explanation, previous to this, these is no mention of the “history of any of them listed”, as they were made “lost” until the Chola Empire came to power in Tamil Nadu. Were the Chola Kings “truly responsible for bring these books out”- I am not sure, but what is the truth is that the 11 + 1 (= 12 Thirumurai books) and the (3 + 11 (= 14 Siva Sastra Books), were compiled / written during this period. Until this time the term “Saivite” was not recorded in any of the 11 + 3 original books of the Siva tradition. Next “Nambiyandar Nambi” arranged the poems in accordance with the “100 + 3 (=103) Panns (musical treatise of the Tamil tradition)”. Once again it was the “Aryan Sanskrit Brahmins” who had destroyed the “literature, music and the theatre tradition” of the Tamil people. So, the revival of Tamil treatise had to be stopped. So started the dual strategy of the Brahmins. As for the Sastra books they wrote the “explanation of the 3 books” and codified it as the “only true translation” of the so called “Saivite Madams”; while for the Thirumirai they created the “Periya Puranas” which were codified by the Brahmins and retained as the “history of the saints”. After the fall of the Chola Empire the Tamil tradition took another round of beating by the Aryan based Pallava Dynasty. The whole of the Tamil tradition would have been lost if not for the conquering of India by the British. That was an indirect benefit of the Tamils. Now after independence, this Tamil movement had to be stopped. So came this “traitors of DMK and Periyar”. DMK and Periyar are NOT people of the Tamil tradition. Their strategy (which I personally think) worked in cohort with the Brahmin or Aryan people. On one side this “DMK and Periyar followers” are preaching not to touch the “Tamil religious books and the temple”; while on the other hand the Aryans Brahmins are in full control of the “temples and the interpretation of the Tamil books.” This joined strategy of the “DMK and Periyar and the Aryan Brahmins” have perfectly prevented the Tamils to go deep into reviving the Tamil tradition and culture. This Periya Purana (including the Ramayana and Mahabaratha) are nothing but “made up mythology stories”. There many be some elements of “truth behind these stories, but which of them precisely is the truth” - no one knows. The Indians are only only people who still believe “monkeys can fly and tied people on stones can float”. Thanks to the “brainwashing” of the Sanskrit puranic tradition.
What are people afraid of? You can learn a second language without losing your culture and identity. People who are bilingual also benefit from higher iq leading to a better quality of life and better career opportunities.
Yeah. True. So why do Hindi speakers not learn local language of other states they migrate to so that life is easier for both Hindi speakers and natives?
Fair enough. English is sufficient for a second language. But Hindus north & south, must vote for Bjp otherwise the anti-Hindu powers will rule India again.
✅ Dude, Though Telugu and Kannada have some Sanskrit words but they are not a part of IndoAryan Languages.❌ Some words are because of travelling ans settling of people for many years.
I am a Hindi speaker but I have keen interest to learn Southern languages especially Telugu and Tamil as well as East Indian languages like Bengali ❤ my mother is Angika a dialect of Maithili
@@GoudSabhab north fought for their territory which is done by all kingdoms, their intention isn't to save South from invasion, for your kind reference South also witnessed Islamic invasion.
India should have a three language education policy. Students should learn Sandkrit, their mother tounge & any other Indian language of their choice (from those enlisted in our Constitition). Sanskrit should be our official language, & English optional foreign language. People will learn it if they find it useful. An appeal to the government, please do not limit education to wage earning skills only. It is of no value if it doesn't create responsible refined citizens for a country.
@@tsMuthuraman-hm6wg No give up ALL Bharatiya languages, adopt English only and become BROWN successful rich Englishmen like the US, Canada, Australia, NZ etc. FOR THE EMPIRE!
Excellent ideas, but people will learn the languages of currency and choice. As BHARAT recovers from centuries of invasions, foreign rule and the extraction of $45 TRILLION by the British Empire, we have to make a conscience choice of we are. My first comment in this debate? I am still BHARATIYA because of the heroic resistance offered by my ancestors, so much so, that my soul is still BHARATIYA, even more so after living in the land of Sunak for 50+ years. JAI BHARAT JAI BIHAR!
@@tsMuthuraman-hm6wg Why not? Either respect and learn your own mother tongue properly (not KHICHRI) or learn the IMPERIAL language properly. All the Arab states gave up their languages to speak ARABIC from Arabia, as they converted to Islam. Enough of this language nonsense! Learn the IMPERIAL language, convert fully and stop wasting valuable time!
Biryani its not tamil name neither any South Indian name but u will find biryani every corner of South India.....most of south indian even don't follow sanatan dharm most are Christian with Hindu name other muslim.....
Sanathana is very complicated with enormous literature , mostly lie stories like ramayana , mahabharatha which have no under ground archeological evidences !
@@tsMuthuraman-hm6wg I am not surprised by ur comments because u r tamil that's y ...u PPL Only have Hindu name other wise u have more faith in Islam and Christianity.....
@@SaurabhGupta-sn4yv Questioning the historicity of the ithihasas is not islam or christianity , but it is geuine attempt to clear the real tamil history from being masked by these lie stories ! The IVC was tamil , not sanskrit .
@@tsMuthuraman-hm6wg I don't care...just don't write Hindu or sanatan in religion column on paper... don't make fool others state....tell to whole bharat that we Tamil are not Hindu but Periyar muslim and Christianity with ravan lover....
@@SaurabhGupta-sn4yv We are truth and tamil lovers , not lie story lovers. Hindu is a fake religious name . It is actually tamil culture. Rig veda has no idol worship. What you call hinduism is itself tamil culture right from IVC times. You are trying to mask that history by lie stories like ramayana, maha bharatha etc.which have no real evidences .
🙏ఆధారాలు చూపిస్తూ చాలా లోతైన విశ్లేషణ చేశారు. నాకు తెలిసీ ఇంత వివరణాత్మకమైన వీడియో YT లో ఇంకొకటి లేదనుకుంటున్నాను. అభినందనలు ఆచార్య గారూ 🙏 జయ గురు దత్త శ్రీ గురు దత్త 🙏
Hindi.. no Thanks. We are happy with Malayalam, Tamil, Kannada, Telengu. We co-existed without any Problem. In South india we used to understand eachother and still we do. After the kindi..i mean Hindi.. we got confused. So Kindi...no Thanks and keep away from South india
Anti-Hindu, anti-Bharat missionary strategy to oppose Hindi to divide Hindus by North-South and Tamil-Sanskrit-Hindi to facilitate religious conversion.
Lets say that the Dravidian languages are indeed a separate language family, that have over the millenia been influenced by Sankrit. All languages tend to evolve with time so then what difference does it make! As a Kannadiga, I concede that regardless of how the language started out, in its current spoken form it is atleast 40% Sanskrit. And honestly i find nothing wrong with that. If anything i am happy that Sanskrit is being preserved in the South when all the northern languages have become so heavily Persianized.
Ironically, Sanskrit is closer to Persian than any Dravidian language. The thing is that, both these languages are more Arabized, which is the main impurity here. Pure Persian words sound and appear similar to Indo-Aryan words. It will rather be great to get rid of this impurity 'Arabic' from both these beautiful languages. Plus, best thing would be actually speaking Modern Standard Sanskritised Hindi than just teaching in schools. Needs to be promoted through media. Stay away from Urduwood.
Brilliant work my brother. Amazing insights with proofs. Just my two cents on Hindi. You see I am a Bangali. I was raised in Gujarat and I now live in Mumbai. I can fluently converse in all the three (Bangla, Gujarati, Marathi, and also Hindi) But imagine a truck driver or a tourist or a business consultant who has gone to a southern state for traveling or for work. You can't expect the person to suddenly know your language. It's the same thing for a Tamil or a Kannadiga in Gujarat or Bengal or Punjab. In that case we need a common language to smoothen the communication. Which language will cause the least time and effort? Bangla is the world's 7th most spoken language. But it will be extremely difficult for the entire nation to adopt Bangla. English is the world's most common language. But if we are to adopt the decolonization then we must let go of English as it causes a lot of class differences in Indians. Even most people from Southern India don't speak English. Hindi on the other hand is the 2nd most spoken language in the world and most popular language in India. It will take less time and effort for adopting Hindi than any other language. Now, a common argument given is that: Hindi will corrupt the mother tongue. Absolutely NO! I still speak Bangla and Gujarati with my parents, my spouse, my bong and gujju friends. In fact, due to inferiority complex I read Bengali literature of Sarat Chandra and Bankim Chandra. So, Hindi is easier to have a common language and no, it will only strengthen the influence of mother tongue.
Made to hate Sanskrit? Don't make me laugh with your idiotic clickbait question. Only state with more Sanskrit classes and teachers than Tamil Nadu are Karnataka and Maharasthra both of which still have Sanskrit speaking villages. Without Tamils preserving Sanskrit palmleaf manuscripts cowbelters would still be reading Persian, Turkish and Arabic scripts. Without Tamils devotion to Hinduism and spreading of Bhakti movement the weak North Indians who were conquered by foreign Muslims for 800+ years would all be worshipping Allah instead of our indigenous Hinduism. We should be asking why North Media and culture hates South Indians specifically Tamils for daring not to kowtow to their stupidity and accept Hindi as dominant language of India despite Hindi being an bastard language with many Arabic, Turkish and Persian loanwords. Even movie industry wise we see what accepting Hindi has done to Bengali industry essentially dismantling and destroying the industry that in the 70s was still the largest film industry in South Asia... and don't dare bring up acceptance when Gujarat, Punjab, Maharashtra, Assam and Haryana have all had Anti-Hindi riots where Bihari and UP migrants were attacked while Tamil Nadu has never had a riot against Hindi people.
I am Marathi form Maharashtra. I love all people of entire India. We are so diverse but at the core have the same values. There is no harm in our diversity, it is and needs to made into an asset. Don't believe in any politician who tries to divide us on the lines of our own culture and heritage..
Meanwhile everyone in the comment section forgetting North Eastern India exists XD. Seriously tho our main attempt should be oriented towards making cultures from North East India mainstream .
What is Sanskrit ??? Let's learn about it first.. A language is called advanced only if it has its own script form ( written form) Sanskrit is not a single language its two different things.. 1. Vedic sanskrit 2. Classical sanskrit.... Vedic sanskrit ( 1500bce to 500ce)..... Vedic sanskrit is not a spoken language, not a written language... It's a language used in vedic literature.. Which is not used for spoken.... And it didnot have any written form... Thats why Vedic Sanskrit is written in all forms of script present in local indian geography like brahmic ( damma) script, pallava script, proto Tamil script..... Vedic sanskrit can't be understood without commentaries.. Because it's not used as a spoken form... If you don't believe this... Try to read or see all the literature forms between 1500bce to 1000ce... Sanskrit Is always written in brahmi script of many prakrit languages... If you towards south Sanskrit is written in pallava or Tamil script.... But it doesn't have its own script.... Classical sanskrit ( 500ce to 18th cen) is a hybrid language formed by the fusion of many prakrit languages and local dialects under the influence of Vedic Sanskrit... Thats why classical sanskrit is a literary language which is also not a spoken language.... Which is used only in literature and it can't be understood without giving bhavam ( explanation) separately.... Also classical sanskrit also don't have a script of its own... It derived its script from nagari script which was an evolved form of brahmi script ( u can find the similarities in word forms if u check them)..... That's why it calls it's script as devanagari script.. Which originated from Nagari script used for local languages spoken in Indian ( northern regions).... If you analysis any vedic text words of vedic Sanskrit it's root words and origin keeps spreading towards upper regions of Europe rather than coming down towards central and southern of indian sub continent.....it traces It's impact mostly on European.. Scandinavian Baltic areas....... Classical sanskrit on the other hand... indegenously developed in Indian subcontinent.... With infusion of prakrit languages... Astadyayi grammar and nagari script.... That's why classical sanskrit has many words from all languages... That doesn't make it origin language..... Also classical sanskrit is highly patronized during vijayanagara years... That's why it got more influence on Telugu and southern regions are the most important factors for classical Sanskrit to survive in literature form.... Because later 1000bce... Northern region had Persian influx and languages got evolved into many hindustani language forms with many script form with strong native dialects.... So how can a literary language be recognized as origin of language...??? This is just 1%.... If you keep analyzing linguistically the language is analyzed deeply..... To it's origin... But people don't know about all these and they don't even speak classical sanskrit.. They don't even know it... Still keep telling unaccounted statements... Because it's been connected with religion.. So that's the blind spot for Sanskrit as a language being not questioned...... I don't want you to blindly believe it... Read this and analyze yourself so U can get clarity.....
I'm a Tamilan. Its linguistically proved that Dravidian langs have separate origin & over time mixed with spoken Prakrit & Sanskrit langs. Today Tamil is the only Drav lang that can function independently without words of Indo-Aryan langs although such words circulate in TN ppls' vocabulary. Periyar was a leftist who hated not only Sanskrit but also Tamil! It was the efforts of Maraimalai Adigalar, an ardent Tamil Shivite priest who established pure Tamil movement, as a result of which practice of combining Tamil & Indo-Aryan langs words r abolished in press, newspapers, govt records, etc. Over time this resulted in increased pure Tamil words in ppls' vocabulary too (however English words r increasing due to globalisation). Tamilars don't hate any lang. Tamilars learn & adopt to regional langs wherever they work. We only oppose the imposition of langs in TN which is absolutely our rights. After independence Indian gov announced Hindi as National lang, told it must be used by all state govt & ppl must learn it. Then protests bursted in TN after which Congress reverted it. However Cen. Govts continue to impose Hindi in one way or other like through education policies which face criticisms. At last, Ravana celebration is due to recently increasing Tamil Nationalism ideology against Dravidianism. Ravana is speculated as ancient Tamil king (before Nayanmars' Bhakthi movement) as Sri Lanka was historically inhabited by Tamilars. This stands based on speculation that demons who opposed Vedic Yajnas are non-Aryan local leaders. Hope u r open minded & won't delete this comment.
The Tholkappiyam mentions the influence of Sanskrit on Tamil literature. It borrows literary theory from Sanskrit texts. This shows Sanskrit has a much older origin.
@@tmahavishnu Brahmins were living in Tamilakam during Sangam times, so Vedic culture was present. They too contributed to Tamil poems. Since Sanskrit didn't had its own writing script, Tamil was used to write Sanskrit (as told in this video too). Tholkappiyam created rules on how to use Sanskrit words in Tamil like Lakshman, Hanuman, etc. Tholkappiyar mentioned that he learnt phonology from previous Tamil literature called Ayndhiram (now lost). No evidence in ur saying that he borrowed literary theory from Sanskrit texts. Vedic hymns were orally transmitted for many generations, such practice was not with Tamil. But this is not way to conclude that Sanskrit was older to Tamil. Both the langs were independently evolved Vedic lang/Vedic Sanskrit -> Classical Sanskrit Ancient-Tamil/Proto-Dravidian -> Sangam Tamil -> Modern Tamil If u want to conclude the oldest lang based on ones influence on another, then Ancient-Tamil/Proto-Dravidian sounds r even present in Rig Vedic hymns which shows Tamil is older
Tamil alphabet begining change in Tamil nadu Because of the pronouns Tamil is difficult to pronounce the some alphabet like: ஸ்ரீ, ஸ,ஷ, க்ஷ,ஃ. North india change the south Indian sign bord in tamil.
You are misguided and shallow..... answer following questions 1.hard scientific evidence of sanskrit older than Tamil 2.Who fabricated anti Urdu mindset in Tamilnadu from 1600 to 1800 ad 3. Anti sanskrit mindset from 500 to 1600 ad 4.anti persian mindset from 500 bc to 500 ad 5. Anti prakrit mindset from 1200 bc to 500 bc You can say we are anti everything....or we (Tamils)are the ones that maintained our indigenous language culture and identity........
Why don’t you provide hard evidence that Tamil is older than Sanskrit. Both sides claim they are older but general global opinions/scholars favour the Sanskrit side. And Tamil Nadu was able to preserve its language and identity because it was free from external rule and hostile invaders hell bent on destroying culture for 700 years more than the north. That opportunity was deprived from North India for a millenia.
@@badKrma epigraphy , archaeological artefacts, i can back a lot...but u will only say u lost everything in invasion...and start talking religiously motivated empty declaration...few years later u will jump to mandarin or russian and start declaration about its history.....
@@தங்கமயில்ராசன் Ok first off I am from the South too so u lose the northerner patronizing condescension. Secondly, it is well documented that Takshashila, Vikramashila, Sharda Peeth and Nalanda were destroyed and countless manuscripts and historic records were lost. Lastly, for the last few years it hasn’t been about taking pride in Tamil heritage anymore. Anti-north separatist ideas are actively sprouting, which if not contained, will end up having disastrous consequences for the South as well as rest of the nation.
@@badKrma This country only have Tamil separatist,no sanskrit separatist or hindi separatist,few sanskrit speakers saying national language is sanskrit is not separatist dialogue....we have to make all people Learn hindi is not separatism....what iam asking u is not religious or political question....show proof that sanskrit is older than prakrit.... according to our belief Ram prayed in prakrit when Ravan prayed in Tamil...u are claiming prakrit and pali script as sanskrit....
@@Hindustani_jaago Learning Hindi is unnecessary for us. Culturally, we have our classical Tamil language, and for national and international communication, we have English. So, why impose Hindi unnecessarily? If someone wants to work in a Hindi-speaking state, they can learn it for survival, but imposing it on the entire population is unacceptable.
As a shivbakht and tamilian shivan portrayed in thiruvasakam more than 2000 years back where this land had only sanskrit and tamil. In thiruvasakam we can see only pure tamil words. If people stop this comparison all these arguments will fade away
Over 30% of English words are from French but English is not a Romance language its a Germanic language. Just because Dravidian languages and Sanskrit have some same vocabulary it doesnt make them same
Nobody said Dravidian languages are same as Sanskrit. However, since all Dravidian states are Hindu-majority, the religious, cultural and linguistic unity in them is attained thanks to Hinduism only. Even the word 'Dravidian', the unifying term for all the South Indian languages, is a Sanskrit-origin term. Nothing wrong in admitting this either.
These dividing comments won't work in project shivoham audience. .. for us desha and dharma are important..... not dominating on one another...jai shree ram...
As a tamilian, I have no hate for Hindi and it's the same with most of Tamils. (I'm sorry If you'd met some nutcases, especially politicians. But tbh, no sane one would say that they hate Hindi) And I've always loved Sanskrit, and I would love to learn Sanskrit, I wish we'd mandatory Sanskrit classes in school. We'd Hindi subject for the span of 3 years in school and I now know how to read, write and understand Hindi pretty well. I hope our education system and government focuses on saving the dying out language the same way it implements the widely spoken language. And to the creator of this video, I've watched a couple of video of yours, and the dedication you've towards your work and the effort you've put into every one of your video is admirable ❤👏🏼
Sanskrit is not mandatory in Tamil schools? I'm from UP and we had Sanskrit mandatory from 4th standard to graduation. ( I'm genuinely asking no hate at all )
@@TheDevBellowStairs Unfortunately, no. It's not mandatory in Tamil schools. But some schools have it as an optional subject in 12th grade. And it also depends on whether you are studying in a cbse or state syllabus based school as well...
Dont call your self a Hindi speaker when half the words you use are Urdu or Persian...if a Mahrashtrian learns Hindi so that he can work in tge north...it is a responsibility of a Northener to learn Marathi
@@kala-ujala They should be...if you want to speak Persian, speak Persian, if you want to speak Urdu, speak Urdu and if you want to speak Hindi, speak Hindi
To call an idiot Periyar is the greatest injustice ever administered - he is சிரியார்; இவரைச் சூழ்ந்தவர்கள் சிரியோர்கள் அல்லது சின்னப்பயல்கள். All EVR statues have to be pulled down or adorned with garlands of slippers
Well said. EVR was a fake atheist. A true atheist would criticise all religions. EVR criticised only Hindus but did not dare criticise chsulim and missionary. EVR was an anti-Hindu element.
At last you have asked 2 questions but actually those are one and same. Because periya Putnam it self story of 63 nayanmars. I think you want to learn the book completely. Answer to question: Shaivaite Sundarar listed 60 saints in his work "thuiruthondar thogai" and later namibiyandar nambi of Rajaraja chola time composed as another book expanding 60 to 63 by adding Sundarar and his parents. Periya Puranam expands it into a big book. Sundarar from chola region mostly included shaivaites from chola region followed by pallava pandya region and only 2 from chera that to his friends. None from Sri Lanka. That to most of them lived during Sundarar's time and other's story are just 200 -300 years earlier than him which he heard and noted. The story of 63 is to tell the people one can attain Shiva foot by just being devote and falling love of him. And not practicing high rituals and sacrifice like Buddhist jainism monks. Sundarar lived in 7th century before that tamil land was full of Buddhism and jainism. Now to point: Ravana was puranic character that to decipted as powerful person with 10 heads and 20 hands and with more powers. He is not equal to common man to include in list of 60. People accept him as devote of Shiva with great power. At last there are 12 tirumurai of books contains hymns towards lord Siva in Tamil. Most of them contain Ravana as great devotee of Shiva for e,.g malai mattrru pathigam (palindrome) songs of sambander mentioned Ravana.
@@Sundarin8duமுழுசா படிச்சு புரிஞ்சு பேசுபவன் கூட தர்கம் பண்ணலாம் இப்படி அரைகுறையா பேசுறவங்க கூட என்னத்த பேச, சரியான பதில் தர மட்டும் தான் கூற முடியும், ஆனா அவர்களுக்கு புரியாது. இவர்களுக்கு இந்தியா என்பது எல்லைவரையரை நாடு (Territorial Nationalism ) என்பதை ஏற்க முடியாது மொழிவழி (Ethinical Nationalism) மதம் வழி (Regious Nationalism) நாடு என காட்ட (கட்டமைக்க) முற்படுகின்றனர்.
I'm from Tamil Nadu, we don't actually hate Sanskrit, even Tamil kings have helped more Sanskrit literatures here.... But we hate it when it's imposed on us or when our language was treated as a secondary in our own land.... Dravidian party opposed imposition of Hindi as a third language in TN, but how many North Indian started learning Tamil or any other southern language as a third language in your carriculum....no, then why we should accept it.... We only opposed implementation of Hindi and Sanskrit in schools but the institution for those languages were still running and you can learn if you want.... Abd onemore, if a South Indian travel any Northern states, we actually try to adopt to the local language.... But when a North Indian came to South, they expect us to speak Hindi and that's completely a rude mentality....
Because its official language not north and south like English So its better when learn three or more language Not fluent but for communication English, Hindi, regional language this is what many people do and gov promote Because india have so many languages specially in north can't promote every but you can preserve it And think if currently gov which is more gujrati started promoting then and this is why regional language is promoted by state gov but not gov of india because it has so many languages and Sanskrit as mother language should be respected this is what north think
@@santoshthakur1679 I respect Sanskrit, but it's not the mother language of India, if it's a mother language then why it's been spoken only by a particular set of people.... South Indian languages, especially Tamil literature and grammar was completely different from Sanskrit... Even if you remove Sanskrit dialects and words from Telugu, kannada and Malayalam you can end up with a pure version of those languages, which has no connection with sanskriti, we respect the language but it's not our mother language....
@@NaveenKumar-nq8mhsouth Indian languages are a derivative of Sanskrit , only Tamil is a separate language but that too has a large Sanskrit vocabulary. Telugu , kannada and Malayalam are more sanskritized than Tamil. There are no south Indian languages without Sanskrit , they are just regional languages that evolved independently , like some North Indian languages as well (Bengali and Gujarati for example).
@@alpha-vs1fx South Indian languages didn't originate from Sanskrit, it may have some impact with sanskriti but not originated from it.... Have you ever heard manipiravalam literature, it's still used in Kerala and it's the foundation of Malayalam language, it's about how the Tamil and Sanskrit mixed up together and formed new literature.... Likewise, all South Indian languages have the mixture of both Tamil and Sanskrit in it ....... But in what ratio We commonly use English words on our daily basis, that doesn't mean our language originated from English, likewise if we Remove sanskriti words from Tamil, it'll be a pure version of it... We have our grammatical system for 1000s of years, even before the sanskriti entered South... Do you want to know, when Sanskrit popularized in South India, it's during Vijayanagaram Kingdom, only at this time Sanskrit became much popular here.... So understand one thing my friend, Tamil originated separately, not from Sanskrit..... And one more thing, do you know which language stone inscription was found most in India, go search for it .... And even in Andhra and Karnataka, the oldest and mostly found stone inscription was,... I'm not gonna tell it, go search for it my friend... What you are saying is like, we have many European and Islamic architecture all over India, which means they were one who taught us architecture and Indians learnt from them.... It's not like that
Hello Sir If Sanskrit was the Top language, why its not existing? As you said, the upper caste people how they dominated all ancient people, their language Sanskrit also started dominating. So some Tamil people used to use Sanskrit words into Tamil Language in those days. Otherwise we Tamilians have NO Sanskrit origins. You can see only Tamil language is without Sanskrit. But in between some years it was considered a prestige if Sanskrit was used (how now adays we are using English words when we talk Telugu) And NAYANMAARS are not related with Ravanaa! Ravanaa is a King besides a Siva Bhakta! 63 Naayanmaars are not to be compared with Ravanaa. EVR was a human who fought for Untouchables. So this old man was a General Enemy for the Upper caste people. You should see the difference on the other side of the people also, gentleman🙏
Bro Sanskritam has no script of it's own we can write Sanskritam in any script but they adopted Devanagiri & Marathi language is really the link language but foolishly we adopted Farsi version of so called Hindi which has made Hindi alien most of our Bharatiya language have 80% to 95% sanskritam words ,Max muller only complied all the scriptures he never translated but he doctored & in the end of his life admitted that he added too many fakes, Tug EVR a fair skinned guy as per his theory of Aryan Dravidian he should be classified as Aryan
@@primanftw THERE IS NO SUCH THING OF PURE HINDI ( SUDHA HINDI) 😂😂😂😂😂😂 IT IS A MISCONCEPTION. 😂😂😂😂 THAT'S WHY IT IS ALMOST IMPOSSIBLE TO CREATE OR WRITE A SONG IN PURE HINDI LANGUAGE 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@primanftw DO YOU KNOW HINDI WAS DEVELOPED (CREATED) IN THE FORT WILLIAM COLLEGE IN CALCUTTA BY THE BENGALI SCHOLARS OF SANSKRIT (IN BENGAL)😂😂😂 THEY REMOVED MOST OF THE ORIGINAL URDU WORDS FROM HINDUSTANI LANGUAGE TO CREATE MODERN HINDI, THAT IS YOUR SO CALLED PURE HINDI 😂😂😂😂😂😂 AND ALSO TOOK DEVNAGARI SCRIPT FOR WRITING. THEY INTENTIONALLY ADDED LOTS OF SANSKRIT WORDS TO THE HINDUSTANI LANGUAGE TO CREATE MODERN HINDI 😂😂😂 AS THESE SANSKRIT WORDS USED IN HINDI DID NOT COME NATURALLY TO THE HINDI LANGUAGE SO THESE WORDS ARE NOT HINDI WORDS. 😂😂😂 THESE ARE ACTUALLY SANSKRIT WORDS 😂😂 HINDI = HINDUSTANI LANGUAGE + INTENTIONALLY ADDED SOME SANSKRIT WORDS. URDU = HINDUSTANI LANGUAGE + INTENTIONALLY ADDED SOME ARABIC WORDS. HINGLISH = HINDUSTANI LANGUAGE + INTENTIONALLY ADDED SOME ENGLISH WORDS. BUT HINDI, URDU, HINGLISH ARE SAME LANGUAGE (HINDUSTANI LANGUAGE) 😂😂😂 THERE IS NO SONG AVAILABLE IN PURE HINDI LANGUAGE. ❤️❤️ BENGALI IS OLDER THAN HINDI ❤️❤️
I'm so sorry, but as a South Indian the thing that irritates me most is that when our most important person the honarable prime minister makes a speech no where is there an automatic translation live to the other Indian languages, as a *requirement*. In fact none of these speeches are even translated to English. It needs to start from the top. Non Hindi speakers do not feel respected as citizens, it's that simple.
Why English? Well, English is neutral and gives no one the feeling that they are less favoured. Most of India doesn't speak Hindi and doesn't understand why everyone should be made to. English ironically allows us some equality.
Modiji is not a native Hindi speaker though. He's a pakka gujarati. We gujaratis arent hindi speakers btw. Less than 50% soeak Hindi in our state. Only in urban speakers you'll find hindi speakers. In rural areas, hindi speakers are at most 15% and even their Hindi is very basic
@AtheistNationalist aren't you ashamed to say close to 50% speak hindi. Don't you want your people to speak their mother tongue. If speak hindi what brings people closer in North means you failed horribly
Just realized: You speak Hindi because that's the only language you know. We speak to you in Hindi because that's the only language you know. It's a Hindi circle of life!
Do tamils like other South Indian languages? Tamils love tamil only - there is no north south - may be tamil india divide? Telugus, kannadigas, malayalis would not unite with tamils to separate from India.
Dude stop making your own story! Kannada, Telugu, Tamil, Malayalam, Tulu these are the main Dravidian languages and this languages are not diverted from Sanskrit.
The word Gentoo is in no way connected to the word Hindoo, according to me. In the Bible you find the word Gentile to mean all non Jewish people. Hence Gentoo law is a law to govern all non Jewish and also non Christian subjects.
This divide is purely political. In ancient India, the south of India was below the vindhya mountains, which includes today’s, maharashtra, KA, MP, TN, Orrisa, KL, AP and TL. Even tamizh has many sanskrit words in it. High time, we people let our egos off and stop acting like one is superior to the other. Nobody is higher or lower, no language is superior or inferior to the other. It doesn’t matter which language is oldest or youngest. Lets respect all languages and people and not be manipulated by the political ideologies that are dividing us.
You said right , but not tamizh have lot of Sanskrit word first understand , one language's word was in another language that's not one language is derived from another language , learn about etimology of tamil language ok then you talk about it , sanskrit also have lot of tamil words so we did to say sanskrit is derived from tamil
@@Sundarin8du Tamizh does have a lot of Sanskrit words. Even days of Tamizh are in Sanskrit. It doesn’t matter where a language originated from or who came first. Today Tamizhans have become very egoistic. That’s not our culture. Our Culture was to welcome everyone and ideas. We follow nothing of it and like to call ourselves as tamizh etc without following any of our cultures.
@@rohitramanathanchanakya then why indian government always praise sanskrit and disgracing tamizh history bcoz tamizh have deep and long history then sanskrit , its historical provened , you are correct all are equal... But why govt always belongs sanskrit, its who's mother tongue, your mother tongue is sanskrit ? Unborn language... Pali and prakritam these two languages mixed is samskritam it is also meaning itself... Tamizh have unique grammer, culture etc... Its totally different from today fake Hinduism and We tamizhs always welcome everyone not like north indians , in tamizhnadu all other staters are living good life then tamil bcoz of we allowing them
@@Sundarin8du I partly agree with your points that pai and prakrit could have influenced sanskrit. Sanskrit is definitely a high level language, as it has vocabulary that can come can have. All of our vedas , shastras and smritis are in sanskrit- thats why its very important for hindus. It is important to realise this fact . Second - this divide is purely for political reasons. Thirdly, recently we have a lot of respect given to tamizh with the sengol and tamizh- kasi sangam . First time in history which nobody gave. Let us at least respect that they are putting an effort this time. Unlike previous times we were ignored. Just because other people dont have respect and values doesnt mean we lose our value and lose our culture by becoming so violebt and unwelcoming to outsiders. In India, people from all castes and states , across the length and breadth of this country are same. Which shows that our ancestors mingled with people from north, south, east and west. So, in a way many of our outsiders to the current state we are from. We need to stop this I am a pure fellow and outsiders to get out. Lets start from ourselves.
@@Sundarin8du If we tamizhs are welcoming why we kicked the kannadikas and recently even told north Indian labourers to go out? Happened very recently. This fake hinduism is another nonsense narrative created now. When hindus are fighting for their rights, people will call it fake hinduism. All temples and temple money is controlled by state govts and are eating the money without using it for temple activities. They are using it for their personal benefit also.
Why English? Hindi, anyways is not an Indian language. We never had Hindi in India except in a small part of Delhi.....why can't we make Hindi as common language & throw away English. Make mother tongue first language and Hindi as common language....it's business that make life called Yajna in Sanskrit.....so it rules, we like or not, we live as per Need....that's called Dharma.....dhara is what we wear on & in body....
While I accept the fact that it was the European Christian missionaries' agenda to create North South divide and creating hatred towards Sanskrit language in Tamilnadu, But i don't believe one thing in this video. That is, you r trying to say that Telugu is nothing without Sanskrit. The fact is, we love Sanskrit and started using too much Sanskrit vocabulary to a point that we replaced or forgot the Telugu equivalent words. And the other reason is we didn't focus on preserving pure Telugu, that's why we started adopting the language that is famous during those times. For example, we didn't create any special word for Tractor in Telugu. We all use the English word Tractor to refer 🚜(tractor). Similarly, we were not much focused on creating new words or using pure Telugu vocabulary because we got used to adopting the language that's considered Professional and sophisticated, be it Sanskrit then, or English now.
Tamil celebrates its rich heritage without imposing on others, showcasing the beauty of linguistic diversity. In contrast, the push for Hindi often feels forceful, diminishing this diversity. We need to embrace all languages with equality & respect! 🇮🇳
Ask the non telugus in Andhra too... Especially Godavari districts. If it not about language, it's about region, caste, religion, status, etc. Telugus go everywhere to make a better living or get an education and them find fault. Let others also talk about u guys. Listen, accept, learn and mingle. Vasudaiva kutumbakam🙏🏼
@@sanaksanandan u have a right to ur opinion. Truth shines like the sun. Cannot be hidden. I have no interest in sticking to the point when i see something from another dimension. Spare me my right.
@@sanaksanandan I am a Tuluva from tamil nadu. We stated speaking tamil by ourself not because of imposition. And Periyar, Stalin, karunanidhi all are telugu's.
@arjavgarg5801 can't help it if ur an idiot. Over 500000 DNA samples were tested in india for ancestral genetics and it'd ended up proving all indians have the same genetic ancestry. Open ur fat eyes check the research out for urself. It was done in 2012.
Brother tamizh is as old as sanskrit and very much connected to this land of bharat more than sanskrit. We tamizhs are not non hindus or against sanskrit. We need recognition for tamizh and in tn tamil will be given importance more than anything. Jai hind ❤🙏 let students learn sanskrit as third language and taught about proper sanatan dharma
