Тёмный

The Permian-Triassic Boundary - The Rocks of Utah 

Benjamin Burger
Подписаться 19 тыс.
Просмотров 35 тыс.
50% 1

The Great Dying! In this episode we head out to the Permian-Triassic Boundary and try to discover what caused Earth's Largest Mass Extinction event, 252 million years ago.
After 4-months of research, I'm excited to finally release this exciting video!
A pre-print of the scientific paper is available at: eartharxiv.org/khd9y
I've submitted this research to the journal "Global and Planetary Change" for peer review.
If you like to contribute to my Patreon Page: patreon.com/user?u=9235837
To learn more about me visit my home page at: www.benjamin-burger.org
A gratefully thanks to M. S. Gustin and M. V. Estrada at the University of Nevada-Reno for running the Hg analysis, S. Lyman for productive discussion of Hg detection and E. Swanner for productive discussion of pyrite formation. A. Lonero and D. Newell for help running samples through the ICP-MS and Mass-Spec. at Utah State University in Logan, and L. Jolley, Z. Jolley-Burger, and F. Jolley-Burger for help collecting samples in the field.
Personal funds were used to conducted the research.

Опубликовано:

 

22 май 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 86   
@BenjaminBurgerScience
@BenjaminBurgerScience 5 лет назад
You can read the peer-reviewed paper in the journal of Global and Planetary Change here: authors.elsevier.com/a/1YoVL3HcE1VIQA
@rd264
@rd264 5 лет назад
thanks for your excellent introductions to the geology and chemistry.
@citizenschallengeYT
@citizenschallengeYT 4 года назад
What a shame "This link has expired and can no longer be used to grant free access to the article." Please share a link if it appears open access anywhere. Nice video, thanks.
@jameseldridge4185
@jameseldridge4185 9 месяцев назад
Link has expired
@jframe5512
@jframe5512 6 лет назад
Hello my name is Daniel McGinnis I have watched all your videos and I feel compelled to reach out and say thank you for all your amazing lectures and field studies you have brought to us I have learned so much from you !!
@BenjaminBurgerScience
@BenjaminBurgerScience 6 лет назад
Thank you!
@FrontierLegacy
@FrontierLegacy 6 лет назад
And it is great to see the rest if the science beyond the field work.
@agmartin2127
@agmartin2127 Год назад
The best explanation for non-geologist to date.
@jamesdobrovnik
@jamesdobrovnik Год назад
Wow dr. That was the most incredible treat I’ve had in a long time. The chemistry really muscled my brain. The extinction scene with the cans was epic. I’m still laughing as it’s so Utah I’m so missing daily. Looks like I’ll be getting modern and figuring out this patreon thing. Congratulations! You’ve made yourself a multifaceted Rock Star. Pun intended. Our national treasure and unsung heroes like yourself. This format changes everything and will be impossible to not notice. See you on patreon when I figure it out. Amazing! Like wow dr. Lol!
@gatlingburst
@gatlingburst 6 месяцев назад
We really missed you Dr
@Laserblade
@Laserblade Год назад
Excellent example of the scientific method. I leave with a better understanding of my home, thank you for that.
@jackprier7727
@jackprier7727 5 лет назад
Love the chemical-formulae showing the process of the many steps.
@jujuman333
@jujuman333 6 лет назад
Great episod!! Fascinating to get a first hand look into the process of a geologist. There must be an eerie vibe when looking at all that evidence for what appears to have been a truly hellish time on Earth. 😰
@martinfernandez882
@martinfernandez882 6 лет назад
This video is truly amazing!
@7inrain
@7inrain 8 месяцев назад
Another great video that shows how the scientific process works. Thx!
@cr3513
@cr3513 2 месяца назад
This is a wonderful video although it did give me a headache from time to time. Loved it, loved the methodical approach, loved the learning!
@coastwalker101
@coastwalker101 6 лет назад
Found your video off a link on Digg. Thanks for sharing the story of this paper so effectively in this video. This is the most interesting and exciting description of geological science I have seen for ages. Subscribed and looking forward to learning more by watching the back catalogue. The preprint is well worth a read too having been primed by the video.
@cactuswren9771
@cactuswren9771 5 лет назад
EXCELLENT!! Beyond just the regular chemical reactions of the sulfur in gas, you should learn more about the BIOCHEMISTRY of metabolic pathways for sulfur within the cells of the bacteria themselves. Framboidal pyrite structure, rather than cubic pyrite structure, indicates that the pyrite was GENERATED by biologic metabolic pathways rather than just chemical processes. Framboidal pyrite indicates the formation of the crystal structure was biologically mediated! You have regular chemistry and biochemistry going on at the same time with the sulfur cycles. Thanks for including us in the process of serious research and not just goofy rockhounding. :)) lmao at your teaching method for the mass extinction. I'm packin'!! :))
@johnlawrence9957
@johnlawrence9957 5 лет назад
Outstanding video Dr.! Thank you!
@brentonboutin9584
@brentonboutin9584 4 месяца назад
Looks like somebody had a nice reaction on the table of that is true. It.. notice the suit stains. just started watching your videos. You're doing a great job thank you
@brianholtzmusicsound
@brianholtzmusicsound 5 лет назад
Absolutely fascinating stuff . Great forensic detail and scientific process and critical thinking. Cheers!
@markgorman1951
@markgorman1951 6 лет назад
Compelling work! Thanks.
@SixthMassExtinction
@SixthMassExtinction 6 лет назад
Great work. Thank you for the video.
@TeachMeLordGod
@TeachMeLordGod 9 месяцев назад
History truly repeats itself
@richriddle9690
@richriddle9690 6 лет назад
Awesome! Keep up the good work.
@nisoar
@nisoar 6 лет назад
Great video
@michaelhawkins6501
@michaelhawkins6501 Год назад
Awesome info, and a sobering warning. Can you update the link to the paper? Also, have I been saying the name of the Dinwoody fm wrong?
@kenlawrence3007
@kenlawrence3007 Месяц назад
Very informative and interesting, with special relevance to our present day climate issues! But what was the cause of the Siberian Traps lava field in tectonic terms?
@stevewhalen6973
@stevewhalen6973 Год назад
I think about those furious forces beneath our feet that are contained by a few miies of unbreached crust , and what all they did in the great permian extinction . Its always possible for another mantle plume eruption to happen again at sometime .
@SpedisOwl
@SpedisOwl 6 лет назад
An impressive investigation, laid out in some detail. Thank you. I'm not competent to judge much of the evidence and the conclusions derived from that evidence. But my curiosity (and sense of caution) was activated at a couple of points during the video. Examples: 1) I think volcanic eruptions can discharge quantities of mercury. For instance, the Mt. St. Helen's explosion of 1980: people.earth.yale.edu/sites/default/files/files/Thomas/Thomasetal1982Zn.pdf 2) I wondered what we know about the buffering capacity of the seas during that era. I'd guess that it was less then than it is now. If so, that might actually bolster your hypothesis. 3) You note the absence of volcanic ash in the boundary samples. Given the magnitude of the physical and biological changes posited, should there have been more evidence of burnt and unburnt coal (ash)? Evidence of coal burning in modern sediments (see fortress.wa.gov/ecy/publications/summarypages/0103001.html) includes elevated concentrations of polyaromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs). 4) Your musings near the end of the video seemed perhaps unduly speculative. Under the scenario hypothesized I'd expect the seas to be (on average) cooler than the land masses. The land (and atmosphere?) would be expected to, at least, have wider temperature swings than the oceans. And fresh waters would likely have wider pH swings. If proteins are being denatured, it seems that wouldn't occur just in the oceans. Salmon evolved, I believe, long after (>150 million years), well after the early Jurassic. Linking their anadromous life cycle to events 252 million years ago seems to, perhaps, strain credulity. Despite my sense of caution, the work seems to merit considerable continuing investigation. Thanks for putting it forward. Bill Yake. Olympia WA
@BenjaminBurgerScience
@BenjaminBurgerScience 6 лет назад
Bill, I don't think I've ever gotten such a well written comment on my RU-vid channel. I'll reference a few papers, which I did not have time to go into but can help answer your questions: Yes, there is some coal fly-ash reported from the boundary in other sections, so there are other lines of evidence.... need to find more. Grasby, S.E., Sanei, H., Beauchamp, B., 2011, Catastrophic dispersion of coal fly-ash into oceans during the latest Permian extinction. Nature Geoscience4104-107. doi.org/10.1038/ngeo1069 Mercury at the boundary is also reported here and attributed to coal emissions. Sanei, H., Grasby,S.E.,Beauchamp, B. 2012. Latest Permian mercury anomalies. Geology 40 63-66. doi.org/10.1130/g32596.1 The high Zinc lead researchers to suggest volcanic activity or bolide impact, but lack of Ni in Utah is perplexing.. This paper found high Zn in China Kaiho, K., Kajiwara, Y., Nakano, T., Miura, Y., Kawahata, H., Tazaki, K., Ueshima,M., Chen, Z., Shi, G.R., 2001. End-Permian catastrophe by a bolide impact: evidence of a gigantic release of sulfur from the mantle. Geology 29 815-818. doi.org/10.1130/0091-7613(2001)0292.0.co;2 I was really surprised to find low Ni, especially since I read this paper: Rampino, M.R.,Rodriguez, S.,Baransky, E., Cai,Y. 2017.Global nickel anomaly links Siberian Traps eruptions and the latest Permian mass extinction. Scientific Reports 7, 12416.doi.org/10.1038/s41598-017-12759-9 However, after looking at it closely, I realized that these Ni anomalies are not right at the boundary interval, but stratigraphically above or below the boundary. The temperature proxy comes from this paper: (They used conodont teeth) Sun,Y., Joachimski, M.M., Wignall,P.B., Yan,C., Chen, Y., Jiang, H., Wang, L., Lai, X.,2012. Lethally hot temperatures during the early Triassic greenhouse. Science338366-370. doi.org/10.1126/science.1224126 Check out the pre-print here: eartharxiv.org/khd9y
@SpedisOwl
@SpedisOwl 6 лет назад
Helpful! Thanks.
@citizenschallengeYT
@citizenschallengeYT 4 года назад
35:15 Hydrogen Sulfide and Pyrite Nightmares, right here in Utah. 38:00
@jimvanderhoek2861
@jimvanderhoek2861 6 лет назад
How do we know that the mercury in the boundary area came from burning coal, and not from the increased dying bio matter? We don't have enough resolution to say that mercury (byproduct of the proposed causal event) came first, and then was followed by the mass extinction (effect), or if the spike in mercury is a result of the mass extinction, do we?
@reverendlukewarm666
@reverendlukewarm666 6 лет назад
I've made it to the black powder section!!! ahahaah
@FrontierLegacy
@FrontierLegacy 6 лет назад
Hey, Benjamin, could you do a video on field notes? My son is wanting to get into fossil collecting and I want to get him more into the science side of it. I think it would do him and a lot of us if we can see what a pro does for field notes.
@BenjaminBurgerScience
@BenjaminBurgerScience 6 лет назад
That is a great idea! I have a new series that I'm in the planning stage for called 40 Key Concepts in Geology, which will include all the basic information someone needs a geologist, including a video on geological mapping including how to take great notes. Also how to using a Brunton Compass, measuring Dip Strike, and making Cross Sections. I'll start filming this summer when the snow finally melts!
@FrontierLegacy
@FrontierLegacy 6 лет назад
I was hoping for something sooner but oh well.
@BenjaminBurgerScience
@BenjaminBurgerScience 6 лет назад
I still have a foot of snow to melt before I can get out to the rocks right now. Itching to head back as soon as this all melts.:)
@FrontierLegacy
@FrontierLegacy 6 лет назад
Benjamin Burger I hear ya. It's getting real nice here. I hope to get my son out this weekend.
@7thrx
@7thrx 7 месяцев назад
33:57 This dude thinks he's the only thirst quencher in town. What did sprite do to you?
@MrBebopbob
@MrBebopbob 5 месяцев назад
A wonderful who dunnit. Agatha Christie could not improve on this story. Thanks.
@brentonboutin9584
@brentonboutin9584 4 месяца назад
My mind takes me back to the giant crater in the gulf of mexico. Wouldn't that have affected your samples?
@ScttDynamite220
@ScttDynamite220 2 месяца назад
The rock layers he’s testing here were laid over a hundred million years before that impact and would not have seen exposed until the uplift of the Rocky Mountains well after it.
@kennethgall
@kennethgall 6 лет назад
OMG background music waaay too loud about a minute in.
@janoosterbaan263
@janoosterbaan263 5 лет назад
Ongeloofwaardig!! De kaart in het filmpje op 2:10 is NEDERLAND en niet Utah. Zeeland staat er perfect op zoals het nu is.
@janoosterbaan263
@janoosterbaan263 5 лет назад
Bullshit, it is a fake map at 2:10. It is The Netherlands right as it is now in the delta part (south). Nothern part is The Netherlands 400 yr ago.
@eszterszep9163
@eszterszep9163 5 лет назад
Thank you for this AMAZING, complex and insightful episode (not the first one). Shooting cans was one of the most engaging and original pedagogic solution I have seen in a while. I am not a geologist myself, but I have watched a great number of your videos, and will go to Utah later this year. I like it that you explain things in a clear way but absolutely not condescendingly and not in the action film-like tone that dominates some documentaries. I hope the peer reviewers at Global and Planetary Change have liked / will like your paper!
@robertberman5701
@robertberman5701 5 лет назад
Thanks, most interesting to see how a real field geologist works. This is not just sitting at a lab bench! BB
@semidemiurge
@semidemiurge 6 лет назад
Thank you for taking the time and effort to make this, well done.
@gilesmahoney45
@gilesmahoney45 6 лет назад
This is great, really ties together and gives stark evidence for what I had read about these events. It also got me thinking about some pyrite I found in one small location on the Dorset coast about a mile or two west of Lyme Regis. I looked up the geological map of the UK and was excited to confirm that the permian triassic boundary is there too. I remember now how the mudstone of the triassic passed into the sandstone and limestone of the permian. Large pyrite inclusions within softer grey boulders then passing into great chunks of limestone. I will certainly go back to that point armed with this new insight. The great dying has always fascinated me, thank you.
@jwc449
@jwc449 5 лет назад
This was a surprisingly engaging and interesting video - especially when it takes off at the 32-minute mark. I've been studying the Permian-Triassic Extinction in depth for a couple years, and I have some questions about some of the conclusions in this video.
@BenjaminBurgerScience
@BenjaminBurgerScience 5 лет назад
Justin Clark Feel free to email me any questions at benjamin.burger at usu.edu a peered review based on this research should be coming out soon. But you can check out the preprint linked in the description.
@jwc449
@jwc449 5 лет назад
@@BenjaminBurgerScience Awesome - thanks sir! I might hit you up one of these days - thanks so much for your reply, and keep up the great work and excellent videos!
@Alberad08
@Alberad08 6 лет назад
Thanks for sharing a lot of interesting info here! BTW in earlier times, my dad and I enjoyed black powder target shooting too, but we shied away from erasing whole species ;)
@reverendlukewarm666
@reverendlukewarm666 6 лет назад
Thanks for the very thorough video. Really valuable for beginner geologists. .
@radicalshifttowardsknowled987
@radicalshifttowardsknowled987 6 лет назад
Fantastic video! Getting interested in the scientific methods in studying ancient events. Your channel is really a perfect way to move forward on my path to more knowledge. :)
@dwightehowell8179
@dwightehowell8179 5 лет назад
Thinking more about the science. Even a huge basalt eruption doesn't seem to produce much of an ash cloud. The big island of Hawaii doesn't when it erupts. If Yellowstone or Tambora go up ash will cover the planet but even a mega eruption of basalt, not so much.
@citizenschallengeYT
@citizenschallengeYT 4 года назад
Yeah but when the volcano goes through a huge coal seam? Also remember it's not just ash, there's a lot of gases being released.
@dwightehowell8179
@dwightehowell8179 Год назад
@@citizenschallengeYT I did overlook that it is believed that a staggering amount of coal was burned.
@tennisguyky
@tennisguyky 5 лет назад
Found this fascinating thanks for such an in-depth analysis I’ve been studying the Permian-Triassic extinction for some years and what is the current thinking for how long the extinction took? Also I’ve always been struck at the difference in colors of latest Permian rocks and Triassic rocks. Late Permian rocks are blue/green and then the huge difference in Triassic rocks is striking, becoming bright red and you get a sense for how immensely hot and parched the earth became the planet was clearly being roasted.
@paulcooper8818
@paulcooper8818 6 лет назад
www.SkepticalScience.com brought me here. Clearly and well presented plus showing the various processes involved in your work. You inspire me to do better at my job.
@bhappy641
@bhappy641 6 лет назад
thank you for another great video...
@shelledreptile5626
@shelledreptile5626 6 лет назад
Your videos are awesome man ! Keep goin
@yvonneraptis3908
@yvonneraptis3908 6 лет назад
Thank you, really interesting video and you made the science clear and easy to follow
@shelledreptile5626
@shelledreptile5626 6 лет назад
Your videos are awesome man ! Keep goin
@bjnslc
@bjnslc 6 лет назад
Cool stuff. How does the Dinwoody there compare to the type location in Montana? By that, I'm wondering if it may deserve its own name if it's from a unique environment, and that the Dinwoody is typically set as only early Triassic.
@milonguerobill
@milonguerobill 5 лет назад
Well done presentation and great science, if humanity kills itself and everything else on earth no one can say that they weren't warned, don't poke the bear that is methane hydrate.
@coreofnothing
@coreofnothing 5 лет назад
2:12 hey, I live in the netherlands and that looks just like it, you sure it was once part of utah?
@evilswahili2991
@evilswahili2991 4 года назад
That is The Netherlands allright! I live there too
@amacuro
@amacuro 5 лет назад
Great video Prof Burger! I have a couple of questions please: At 49:00 ish you talk about the ruling out of an asteroid because of the lack of increase in the concentration of elements that have affinity to Fe. This makes sense if we expect a metallic asteroid. But aren't there rocky asteroids, ie. silicate rich, poor on metals? What if one of these hit the Earth? Second question: those rock/sediment samples you took from the field have been near the surface for millions of years. Wouldn't rain water cause elluviation and illuviation processes that transport and deposit soluble compounds such as carbonates across the different layers, making the elemental analysis a bit tricky or deceiving? Thank you. I learned a lot with your video. I think it's an amazing idea to make a video blog of theory combined with field work and lab analyses. Amazing stuff!
@BenjaminBurgerScience
@BenjaminBurgerScience 5 лет назад
Gondwana both iron and stony meteorites have an excess of Pt-group elements compared to the Earths crust. Geology’s call these elements siderphile, since they occur deeper with Earth, Fe (iron) is a commonly known siderphile element. The way to identify these layers is to look for an abundance of these elements in a section of rock near earth’s surface. Which are normally very rare. I think your second question refers to erosion, or more likely diagensis, the term for alternations of rock due to burial. Yes, there can be some alteration. In carbonate rock the most common is the translation of argonite crystals into calcite crystals. Some minerals are more soluble, like Mn and Fe, but others less so and remain in the rock. These rocks are mostly mudstone and shale so lack much porsosity and permeability, so they did not change much since burial. There has been little metamorphism due to heat and pressure in these rocks which is very unique, most rocks of this age have undergone some metamorphism. Carbonate rocks that have undergone this type of alternation are called dolomite, and eventually marble.
@amacuro
@amacuro 5 лет назад
@@BenjaminBurgerScience ah excellent, thank you for answering both questions! They both make a lot of sense. Please keep up the good work!
@rapauli
@rapauli 6 лет назад
Great presentation - thanks so much ... resonates with the book: Under a Green Sky: Global Warming, the Mass Extinctions of the Past, and What They Can Tell Us About Our Future - Paleontologist Peter D. Ward, ... "has come to a stunning conclusion. In his investigations of the fates of several groups of mollusks during those extinctions and others, he discovered that the near-total devastation at the end of the Permian was caused by rising levels of carbon dioxide leading to climate change. But it's not the heat (nor the humidity) that's directly responsible for the extinctions" .... it was sulfur so concentrated that the sky might have been green - (yellow plus blue)
@dwightehowell8179
@dwightehowell8179 6 лет назад
Music at the start was to loud. Hurt ears. This shows up in other people's videos as well. That rock rang like an anvil. How hard is that stuff?
@Drakowiecki
@Drakowiecki 6 лет назад
Loved it very informative now we have to worry about the coal resurgence
@marcg1001
@marcg1001 6 лет назад
Wah!?!?....I can't believe you killed all those expensive craft beers 😨
@BenjaminBurgerScience
@BenjaminBurgerScience 6 лет назад
No beer was harmed in the filming of this video. Only luke warm soda.
@marcg1001
@marcg1001 6 лет назад
😆😆😆
@jimvanderhoek2861
@jimvanderhoek2861 6 лет назад
similar to the acidic oceans during the event ;)
@semidemiurge
@semidemiurge 6 лет назад
You have hit the big time. Well deserved BTW. www.theguardian.com/environment/climate-consensus-97-per-cent/2018/mar/12/burning-coal-may-have-caused-earths-worst-mass-extinction?CMP=share_btn_fb
@Jan-mu6vs
@Jan-mu6vs 4 года назад
That's a Sat imagine of the Netherlands 😂
@kyoatbites7865
@kyoatbites7865 5 лет назад
enjoyed your vid ...but not your choice of music
@Mncat30
@Mncat30 6 лет назад
How about a planet covered with water less than 12,000 years ago....all because those people weren't very smart either.
@angharadllewellyn2192
@angharadllewellyn2192 5 лет назад
Please revord WITHOUT crappy music! I want to hear the geology.
Далее
Permian-Triassic Extinction Event - The Great Dying
19:08
Appalachian Geology: Surprising Implications
36:55
Просмотров 317 тыс.
CAN YOU HELP ME? (ROAD TO 100 MLN!) #shorts
00:26
Просмотров 6 млн
The Last Time the Globe Warmed
10:54
Просмотров 9 млн
Eocene Green River Formation - The Rocks of Utah
27:23
How Bad Was The Great Oxidation Event?
26:49
Просмотров 4,6 млн
Triassic Chinle Formation - The Rocks of Utah
26:31
Просмотров 31 тыс.
Great Earthquakes of the Pacific Northwest
1:04:01
Просмотров 1,5 млн
How Decoherence Splits The Quantum Multiverse
15:25
Просмотров 671 тыс.
The Triple Junction of Southwest Utah
38:57
Просмотров 412 тыс.