@@andrewbecker9062 yeah starring in one of Netflix top shows for a whole season is a sure sign of him tanking. Really just sounds like you dont like him in other roles no big deal
@@andrewbecker9062 it didn’t tank. He does the movies he wants to do. He’s not a money chaser or just wants to do blockbusters. He’s made some great independent movies.
@@izack5596 Also how many jews and soviets had to suffer under German occupation under the areas that he helped to conquer? Unwilling or not he actively contributed to the Nazis war effort for the better part of 5 years.
@@FirstNameLastName-wd8gn True, although I slightly disagree. He may not have been in the war by choice but was conscripted into the army. I don't know but what I do know is that he CHOSE to save lives where he could have easily ratted them out to gain profit in the war machine. I heard some time ago that there is a diary of his (the Officer) but I have to get around to search for it and read it.
@@FirstNameLastName-wd8gn Well i see it like that. The german officer(his name was hosenfeld)probably joined the army before or at the time, the nazis gained power. The first things, the nazi party did in germany were getting jobs for anyone and ending the poverty so most of the people supported them. Their Jew ideology didnt play a big role back then and very few people cared. He probably too. But after he realised at a certain point, where jewish people were not just pushed out of society but killed and massacred that he changed and did the things he did. Yes he was in an army that did terrible things but thats just not a reason to call him a bad person. Should I call american soldiers bad because their military bombed two big cities full of civilians in ww2? Probably not
@@ohio This was not the only jew he helped. I dont know the exact number but you can look it up. He helped multiple jews in the yeara before too. Why are you all just not able to imagine that some german soldiers were just good persons with conscience too?
Unfortunately, you`re right.I`m not going to make excuses for what he did...sex with an underaged girl is an outrage.All I can say is that Mr. Polanski left indelible images of the Nazi holocaust in the great movie "The Pianist."
I was crying while watching the movie and awhile after it, & this video also brought me to tears.. I just cannot watch documentary or photos of the WW2 where people are murdered or tortured or looking through the fence of concentration camps, I always turn away or close my eyes. I just can't, I feel like guilty examining the images of all this insane grief and suffering while sitting comfortably on my couch..
Stories like this, movies like this must continue to be told/made in order to educate today and tomorrow's youth. Doing so keeps the memory alive, and holocaust deniers irrelivent.
Holocaust denial isn’t so much of a problem compared to overall desensitization of today’s youth. At least until something bad happens again. People hear and watch stories of atrocities, and think little of it. Like “man that sucks but it probably won’t happen again” instead of trying to prevent it. I don’t think Ive talked to a single person who’s outright denied the Holocaust. Most people who do that like to create little groups so they can circle-jerk their denials and try to invade Internet forums with their beliefs.
Totally agree. But they make me hate on that country and its people so much. I have worked with some of them, its surprising how inherently racist they still are and so much pride. I dont wanna hate, but it comes.
The story of Wladyslaw Szpilman is the story of millions like him. Polanski got this film correct! It tears the heart out watching it. Moving is the rendition of Chopin's works at the Nazis attacked, but even more moving was Szpilman playing Chopin upon his return to Polish Radio.Long live his memory!
The scene where the Nazis threw the Jewish handicapped man on the wheelchair from the balcony and knowing it really happend, I almost threw up and got chils all over my body , how can a human being kill without any remorse, they just broke inside the Jewish families houses and killed them, took away the parents, the wifes, husbands, children, what a horrifying part of the human history . I'm german myself and I hope such horrifying things never happen again nowhere. R.I.P to all the victims.
Yes that was one of many horrific scenes. I nearly had to leave the cinema. It shocked me then and still does now. I m not German , but I visited Germany in 2018 and was very impressed with the country . We stayed in Munich and visited Dachau town and Cc. The buses are painted in a memorial scene and theres NO covering up by the German people today of what happened. On the entrance to the camp, theres an inscription in english and German, warning of the inhumanity to other humans, and the last line says " This will never be erased from German history". That been the case, however, theres should be certainly NO guilt directed at German people today as they werent even alive. Just for the record I really enjoyed Germany in 2018, and wish we implemented many of Germanys ideas here, such as recycling, shops closed sundays and solar power.
@@christownley2497 Yep, Germans really didn't make any cover up unlike German. I saw one video where an elder got arrested for trying to revert a history about Nazi genocides towards Jews
@@christownley2497Have you seen the police kicking homeless people in Munich? The Germans have not changed, they are still in power, the descendants of the criminals are still in power, and no one is held accountable
you don't have to be a Jew tto feel their suffering. I you cant', you are not a human being. Great work from a man who llived a lif aof horros. Greay finest work ny Polanski!
One of the most amazing scenes from the movie was an old man robbed an old woman's food, and accidentally the food dropped, then The old man was eating the food on the floor. What a incredible acting.
God's Kingdom will change all this wiping away the wicked and Satan the Devil of course and the meek will inherit the earth. There will be a great crowd who will survive a great tribulation. Go to JW.org. There you will find answers to all our questions about God and his purposes. Remember this God loves and cares about his servants. He will rescue them and save them so they can live in the promised Paradise forever with pure worship of our Father Jehovah God restored.
Thank you for uploading this. This is truly one of the greatest non-fictional movies ever made. Seeing the BTS footage explaining the heart behind the story is amazing.
Every time i find myself alone in the house. When husband is traveling and my son is alseep i pour myself a glass of wine and watch this movie. My polish family survied the war. My great grandad was in Anders army and his family from Dabrowka szczepanowska near Tarnow helped a lot of Jewish people. They would provide food to jewish family hiding in the woods in hole in the grand for 2 years. During one night germans were selecting young woman from the village, my grandmother and her sister run away in their night dresses to the woods in snow ( it was January). My grandmother while running stuked her foot in the animal trap and injured it badly. Both were found in the woods by their parents next day. Somehow they survived this horrible night in the freezing.
There have been particularly three movies that I did not stop crying for a moment while watching. The pianist, Schindler's list, and Ane Frank. Especially on Ane Frank I could not sleep good for almost a month. All the scenes were in my mind and I was crying every time a scene flashed before my eyes. So painful
11:30 "...and what you have around here in Warsaw was rebuilt and is a different type of architecture, with the exception of one area on the other side of the river, where Soviet Army sat on their asses and waited until the Polish uprising would be put down, because it was not a communist uprising, and it wouldn't help them." Hilarious but enraging at the same time!
It was nominated for best picture and lost to Chicago. Unbelievable. Polanski won best director and Brody won best actor and it won for best screenplay.
Me encantaría poder entender las diferentes narraciones del reportaje. No hablo inglés, sólo esperaba que tuviera subtítulos en español, es una pena no poder conocer los entresijos del rodaje de la película!
This is so hearthbreaking movie, i can'tstop crying Oh my God my heart is really cry😢😢😢😢eto yung movie na sobra kong iniyakan grabe talaga yung awa ko napakasakit sa puso😢ang masakit pa don ngyari din ito sa panahon ni Hitler
Dam 2 decades already. Bc of this movie I picked up piano. Found a out of tune upright on side of road. Went to RU-vid university to fix it play it. Now I have 30 up rights tune fix traded 10 of them for a white grand Yamaha
@@pythagorasnine But it's not really a surprise, because they are clearly not the same thing. Only a tiny teenie perporsion of Germans are Neo-Nazis and Neo-Nazis are now evenly spread out like butter in every country by the amazing vector of auto mobiles and flying mobiles. I mean, South America has a little more since their precersers were hanging with Adolf until his death by constipation. But overall, the riech is really sitting pretty selling lucurative authentic German sausages to survive in the harsh light of Multiculturalitarianism. The blood is still pure as distilled water. You can practically taste it if you were a cool creature of night and avoided the cross as the ppm for any other races is well below Fiji. My throat hurts above a certain pollutive level so I totally would appreciate the cleansinest of their fluids. I just figured other people would appreciate that consideration as well which is actually very hard to achieve over generations considering all of the tail available. Do you know what I am saying?
@@andrewbecker9062 you know exactly what I mean. And I don't need to wonder anymore. In the meantime I had few opportunities to meet few Germans from my brother's workplace. I know how they feel about it. Some of them knew ex-Wehrmaht soldiers. Can you say the same about Americans? Do they know any ex-slave owners? Some people from WW2 are still alive, you know. That's a bit of a difference if you see what you father or grandfather was responsible for. Don't you think?
Hi! I'm German. As a 16-year-old teenager I, of course, can't talk about these monstrous events from the perspective of the "time witnesses" but there is luckily a big difference between most Germans and the Nazis. We feel disgusted by what Hitler and his party did and know that this can never ever happen again! I personally don't feel proud saying I'm German concerning this topic, however one must realise that we as the new generations are not the ones following those disgusting acts. I have read a lot about the Holocaust along learning it in school, and for me, it is one of the most important topics that should be discussed in every school in Europe. In Germany, this is already done, most school also visit concentration camps, just to show ever student: Never again! I often ask myself, why were it the fucking Nazis and why were the fucking Nazis German?! Just a horribly unlucky coincidence of a failed art student from Austria coming to the country to spread is horrific ideas of race ideology and anti-semitism who somehow found a lot of followers. What would have happened if he had been accepted to that university? Would someone else have done it? No one knows. Some members of my family were kids during the time of the nazis and the stories they tell about seeing the poor voctims but fearing to say anything because of risking their own death (many opponents of Hitler got murdered) sounds like a horror film!
I never bought the “if you really want it, you can survive” bs. No. All of those people wanted it. They wanted to survive. Some got lucky and were able to
"put their asses., the Russians" hmm...sorry , what we supposed to do ?surely it was a command not being involve yet, we have lost millions and millions of people to fighting Nazis for 4 years. Inhave lost grand grandfather in war and he never returned , leaving his wife with 4 children, Polanski just needs to be calm down here and surely he went threw a lot , but being that rude. shame! why only they angry with Communist?how about English, Usa or otehr countries. POlanski u r great producer but pig sometimes.
I am really sorry about them and this movie is one of my best.But history full of same sad and horrible story like that.But they are making film only about jews.They shoul tell about other sad storys some time
