The PROBLEM with Purple Kiss (why i'm worried ...) 

In general I think they should do 2 MVs per comeback. A lot of groups are doing multiple MVs these days. It's a good chance to get more recognition. The second MV would probably be more low budget but that's ok.

Do you have an exemplar of what versatile concept they should go for. I was think about how Purple could be their dark or halloween concept and then Kiss could be the other side. Not sure what though?

@@cloudchungxiaowell I mean they did a more summer concept but what would’ve been better is if they took the red velvet route and made it a upbeat tempo song with a creepy message/undertones.

zombie came out 2 years ago and wasn’t THAT popular either

Yea, they're doing okay in a general sense but they're kinda starting to regress a little. Swan is relatively popular and Yuki is starting to get popular. Zombie did do pretty decently but yea that was two years ago and so even if it helped elevate them within the next comeback, we would kinda start to see a lot of that momentum lost to the point where people wouldn't think about zombie as the reason they still continue to listen or support them unless they were fans

I swear zombie should have gone crazy viral because of how colourful and catchy it was..it should have been their 1st win..and sweet juice was perfection to a T..at least that should have been a first win for them 😢

How are they doing ok? :(( they barely sell 40.000 album copies :(( I'm a fan and I hope RBW will promote them better and choose better songs for them in terms of title tracks

I mean album sales is not the only metrics as a comparative to success. But yea, their concept might be just not as easily digestible for a general audience so it might really take some time

Ohh for sure. Plus Dreamcatcher has always had a niche but strong fanbase and so I could easily see Purple Kiss follow suit and just continue to thrive with their niche fanbase until it kinda clicks for a bit more of the general public for them to be noticeable beyond their fans. It really is hard for girls groups to go for that darker concept though

Yea, Queendom puzzle was such a good activity for them to both capture that hype but also generate more attention from Sweet Juice's kinda popularity compared with what they did in their previous year. It was just a real 180 switch up which I hope was just a one-off

This is so true! they should have sticked to their inicial image instead of experimenting with 7heaven, it wasn't a bad comeback but it was just a bad moment to release it

Yea, I was wondering whether them doing something like 7heaven early on may have helped not feel like this. Kinda like how IVE tried something with baddie. But yea, they really committed to such a starking contrast of a concept that 7heaven was a big woah.

Wait I could kinda see that. The second half of the year releases of Zombie, Nerdy and 7Heaven all kinda have a more "refreshing side" that doesn't feel too dark like Ponzona, Memem and Sweet Juice. 7heaven was an interestingly timed comeback though.

@@cloudchungxiao my theory is that they weren't expecting Yuki to make it, hence the weird timing for 7heaven, as well as the lack of personality it has.

Honestly could see that. I mean even Rocket Punch and H1-Key too. They promoted like immediately right after to the point where I wonder whether they expected someone debuting in Ellzup

i cant agree more tbh

Yea, even if the comeback had dark elements with 7 heaven sound like Zombie. That would have done way better I feel. But yea, this comeback felt lowkey rushed both in the lead up but just during the era too.

memeM was unfortunate timing because it had just become trendy to hate on girl crush, which is stupid in of itself since girl crush includes everything not cute or a ballad depending on who you ask. And kpop fans are always quick to jump on the latest trend because they want to seem like they are insiders when in fact they are afraid to think for themselves. Also not agreeing there was a sudden switch from being quirky witches since zombie was then the only TT where they are not in fact witches.

(1) would be hard because that would target such a niche part of the public. Like it would drive attention for sure but does not translate to fans which depending on their musical route, might be extra unnecessary cost when their concept photos and teasers don't look the worst atm. (2) would be nice. They are defs getting some things to do to promote but yea it would be nice if we got a bit more.

i agree about memem. as someone who fell in love with their sound from their first 2 EPs, memem was a jarring change and disappointed me. the sound is just not something i enjoy. it's not simply because it's girl crush and i hate anything girl crush, it's just the fact that they stood out to me because they had a *different sound* than the over-saturated edm/noisy girl crush gg market. it's why newjeans are also very popular and stood out from other groups (but nj had more visibility because of hybe so they sky-rocketed while purple kiss are struggling more with audience). purple kiss had a niche sound going for them, but then suddenly went to what everybody does (to a sound a lot of their audience was escaping from) and stunted their momentum. however, i really liked nerdy, and this album with sweet juice is great, autopilot is a really good b-side too. it's just a shame they don't have a bigger fanbase to support them through it.

Omg kinda like their Ven Para by Weeekly situation. But yea, idk if it's because I have spent a lot of time listening to them while researching them but all the comebacks besides memem and 7heaven have grown on me. Hopefully, this really was one off and they go back to their concept

memeM disappointed me bc i had just begun stanning purki, but what really REALLY killed them was nerdy. this is just my opinion but… nerdy was like the worst song released that year. cringe lyrics, forgettable, no promotable or stand out bsides. after geekyland i unstanned. i loved sweet juice but 7heaven was kind of generic and boring. so far they haven’t really done anything to regain all the fans they lost.

Yea, I would vibe a dark fantasy. In the realm of Ponzona and Sweet Juice. Plus throw in some Zombie, or maybe going back to their pre-debut pre-release type of route like Skip Skip or My heart skipped a beat.

Thanks. And yea, defs seems to be atleast getting the bare minimum and is not completely being neglected so we can only hope general public starts to kinda get it soon. As for the concept, yea, let's hope this was a one-off thing

Yea, seeming like the general consensus in the comments about 7heaven is that most people are disappointed or confused by it. Hopefully, we get to see them go back to a Ponzona/Sweet Juice type of vibe which I feel like is the good balance of not feeling to dark halloween-ish and being relatively palatable for a dark concept type of vibe.

Bruh they are just experimenting and showing their versetality. No wonder 4th gen is so boring when groups that changes concepts gets hated on.

i couldnt agree more. i LOVED hide&seek and memeM was amazing. sweet juice and cabin fever wasnt in my top3 fav, but it was great too. but 7heaven is literal definition of disappointment tbh. worst album of theirs

Yep. 7Heaven was nice but it was a total different concept. The song is nice but it wasn’t something I would go out and listen to. Memem at least stayed with the concept a little. I hope they would do more songs like Sweet Juice

@@vixxexo6855 I definitively wasn't hating on them 🤔 As I wrote already, this is simply not my kind of music, and if they keep on doing similar stuff, I will simply stop listening to their new music, as it is not to my taste. I think the girls showed their versatility already on multiple occasions on B-Sides. However, I think it is important for a group (and not only in K-pop) to stick to their genre of music, or to stay close. If you were a big fan of a group doing ballads, and they suddenly started producing hard metal, you would be disappointed right? And on a more "marketing" point of view, this isn't a really wise decision to switch concept without a really strong fanbase behind following no matter what, which sadly Purple Kiss doesn't have yet, as said in the video. If a huge group, like Blackpink, started releasing songs that have nothing to do with what they usually do (let's take the example of hard metal again), they would still have a huge fanbase following them in their projects, but PK doesn't. And finally, it is a thing to do some songs who are different to show your versatility, it is another to make it your main track. If we look at Dreamcatcher for example, they have a very wide and varied discography, but their main songs/MVs stay in the genre of rock/rock-pop/electro. Also I would just like to add that there is this expectation in K-pop-world that I really don't like that if you like a group, you should also stan them, and you should love all of their musics and follow them in everything they do. Again, I'm a big Dreamcatcher fan. That doesn't change that they are some songs by them that I simply don't like and don't listen to. Just because I don't like one comeback of Purple Kiss has nothing to do with being a hater. I simply have an opinion on one of their music. In the end, my opinion doesn't matter. If the girls like the song, and are happy with singing it, great for them! I wish them the best, really. It doesn't mean that because of that I have to force myself to listen to this song I don't like, and say positive things about it I don't believe in. Anyway, sorry for the long text I got a bit lost in my thoughts again ! What were your thoughts about 7Heaven? Have a nice day/evening 😁

Yea, definitely all great points. I do wonder whether they were expecting a Zombie 2.0 though or whether they would have been okay with something similar to Pozona. Like I could see the whole experimental nature creating mixed reception but would people be okay with a darker concept without the experimental sound?

Yea, while doing this video, I didn't realise how good some of the songs were. Still been stuck in their debut era and so hearing the more experimental songs and sweet juice, they really don't sound too controversial like Next level

For sure. They don't follow the trends which will make their journey not as smooth breezing. But yea, thoughts on 7heaven?

Omg nice, was this your first kpop group concert?

Yea, the potential is pretty big for them. RBW certaintly has the resources to do things and kinda make them a bit more bigger than they are at the moment. Just really about how they're going to go about it and whether it is the right thing with consideration of how the kpop market is too.

Yea, Ponzona and Skip Skip for me. But yea, That sphere you described sounds really good tbh. Might even throw in something like Zombie too because that was a good comeback too. But yea, the appreciation for darker concepts have not been seen as much and so they'll almost have to create their own lane.

Mamamoo also had quite a lot of success from being versatile, but they weren't fully like red velvet either. At least they should release 2 songs in a row with the same concept.

Yea, from the comments, I've kinda noticed the contrast between the comebacks they have in a year is almost like one darker like ponzona, memem and sweet juice and then one experimental but a bit more "lighter" song like zombie, nerdy and 7heaven

Yea, their concept isn't as palletable for a general audience but they have talent to outweigh this which I feel like one strong release to the general public and it'll be vibes.

That dual MV with a dark take could be interesting. Almost like how G-Idle did a nightmare version to one of their old songs. But yea, would it sound off it they had some summer sound in their mini albums with their main title always being a more darker concept? That was what I was thinking they should have done instead of having 7heaven

Yea I think some are confused by musical sound and group concept being different but even with different musical sound, that can kinda impact how people see the groups too. 7heaven seems to be the comeback that has made people start to feel iffy about Purple Kiss. Not in a "imma unstan them" but more in a but why though? I'll just hope the next comeback is back to the previous concepts. But yea, not having a fixed concept or sounds has its benefits and downsides which can explain a bit of how general audiences might feel about certain groups

I didn't really think about the timing of their music release but yea that would help them if they released them at a better time to align with intention. Like Zombie being released close to Halloween-ish or atleast leading up to it.

Yea for sure. That whole coming back every late october would kinda make the concept more fitting and palletable. Kinda like how summer concepts come during June - August. Suprisingly, the closest to this was Zombie which came out in early september and lowkey one of the more recognisable and successful comebacks for Plorys and maybe even the general public.

Vibes. I've been seeing videos of them doing english versions of their songs. Do you vibe with that more or the original?

@@cloudchungxiao I personally prefer the original versions. I think everything flows better in its native language.

Ohh nice, are they performing both though?

@@cloudchungxiao lol. That was delayed. In the US they did the English versions of like 4 songs and everything else was original. There are a few people who posted the whole show, so you can check it out. I myself will be posting the New York show to my other channel in VR format within the next week (or as soon as I get the time to finish editing it).

After loving "Cabin Fever" so much, I was just disappointed by "7Heaven"

I very much agree

Unfortunately yeah I love their whole discography but 7heaven just wasn't it

I literally waited up till 5am (that’s the time it premiered where I live ) and was like wtf is this?!? Give me more like pretty psycho, and zombies and meme lol I thought it was my lack of sleep why I disliked it on the first listen and tried to play it while at work later that day. Literally all my co workers were like wtf is this change it so I did

Yea, and interesting switch up. I wonder if it was them not trying to niche themselves too much even though it kinda feels a bit too late. But yea, since it's a single album, maybe it was just a one off era and hoepfully they kinda go back to before

Thanks, they will be my next video.

Yea, Goeun had that initial popularity from Produce 48 but I feel like they kinda didn't end up doing much with her. New marketing team for sure though, they've got so much potential and so marketing them right and getting them out would defs help them so much.

Definitely, let's continue to support them. They are in no way on the verge of disbandment, but hopefully they get the attention they deserve.

Yea, it's kinda unfortunate but maybe it might get them a bit more attention??

Yuki did perform in some of the 7heaven promotions but not alot of them. I heard she's gonna be inbetween Ellzup and Purple Kiss promotion during the US tour

Thanks, defs will my next vid

Yea, she really was underutilized. But honestly a lot of them don't get that much opportunity

​@@cloudchungxiaoyes but unfortunately she was the least popular among fans..goeun swan were always popular for singing most lines dosie ireh were best dancers of the group Yuki is the rapper so she was always popular and cheain being the all rounder ..for jieun people only thought of her as just a visual not seeing her singing potential or that she is a great dancer.. too bad she was always overshadowed..i miss jieun she was such an underrated gem..i hope she decides to come back to the industry maybe as an actress or soloist though I highly doubt it

10000% she was a hidden gem within the group that never got her chance to show her full potential. She was already so good but they never gave her any lines and barely any center time so it was easy for fans to overlook her. I definitely lost some interest after she left as she was my bias. Her voice was so good and her visuals were so unique and she was an amazing dancer and performer. She always looked so happy and like she was having so much fun when performing. It was so fun watching her on stage. I'm still bummed about it. 💔

I mean kpop consensus within domestic fandoms place a great emphasis on visuals and so I feel like she would have been relatively appreciated. To the extent that she deserves? Probably not, but hope she enjoyed her time in Purple Kiss and hope she's doing well

I'm a bit suprised because I though Classy would be more controversial but seems like people are more receptive. But yea, hopefully 7Heaven was a summer special because they definitely thrived with their darker concept despite how mixed the reception was when they experimented a bit more

Yea, there is something in going to those flyover cities tbh. They tend to get overlooked and so when groups to come those cities, there's even more of a "bond" that they have for the group. As for 7heaven, both the concept and sound was just not what Purple Kiss has done at all. Atleast one aspect between the two was present in terms of this kinda dark aesthetic. Then as for RBW, yea idk. They really be lacking with addressing stuff for the most part. I think cultivating talent is what they're great at but actually putting in the management skills to better the groups; it's always been a weak point for them

Yea, kpop does have some fandom culture things where they'll support the groups a bit more regardless of perception of the music. I feel like solidifying that plus having relatively general public friendly music could cement Purple Kiss. The whole general public friendly could be interpreted in many ways so there isn't a defining way to achieve that part

So would you say they should have stuck with the Ponzona sound? Defs get what you mean about consistency. I think that's what they did with their concept but not necessary their sound which can be a bit divisive. From the comments the two notable standout songs for Purple Kiss were Zombie and Sweet Juice which kinda have both different sounds. Was there a certain title track that you think they should have stuck close to but also have you listened to BBB? and thoughts?

@@cloudchungxiaoI'd like to pipe in on this question. Zombie was my first exposure to PK and that kept me coming back. Whomever did the videography deserves a medal and the singing, dancing, and playfulness and the singing and music was a winner for me. Then next I heard/saw My heart skip a beat and that too was very fun and creative and great video directing. Next Ponzona. For me that is the pinnacle. The vibe, the dancing, the creativity, the singing, the concept, all gelled, For me everything that came aftward, I realize there were a few popular tracks after that, but they seemed to fall more in the typical K-Pop wheelhouse and although I liked subsequent titles they seemed to lack what I perceived as PK's vibe. The vibe that sold me. When I heard the 7th Heaven track, my mind said, Oh no, they're going cookie-cutter cutsie same-old, same-old K-pop cutsie, dull, musically monotone crap that most other K-pop bands thrive on. Sure it was a fine song, but is fine good enough? Would say not by a very long shot. This latest track, BBB, I just don't get it. If that was the first thing I heard from PK, it likely would be the last time that I listened to them. Maybe that's just me though. Personally I think that they need to ditch RBW and find a company that will just let them run wild with their own vibe and then promote them in an effective way.

Right. I think maybe the first year seemed to encapsulate a good balance of kpop trends with a hint of Purple Kiss's identity. Like it wasn't too jarring to completely alienate the general public. However, it wasn't generic enough where they could be any other group. The releases after that still delved into their identity still but experimented heavily on their sound which saw the major discourse on Purple Kiss. 7th heaven was a left field choice to promote which I don't know why that was done. However, I actually really like BBB. Didn't really watch the MV enough to remember if it ties into their identity but the song defs suits them vocally, despite maybe not necessarily sounding like it relates to their concept.

@@cloudchungxiao BBB is kind of growing on me and I think that now I have a better handle on the message but even with that said, for my own taste or musical esthetic, it was fine, but again, is fine, enough? It lacks the, who in the heck are these guys and were can I get more? All of the earlier tracks hit me that way For me, the song is more of a oh, well that was ok, nothing special but not terrible. And oddly enough I just found a version of Yuki and Chain doing a rap of Vegas by Doja Cat. It is fricken awsome but even though it was released a Year ago and I actively follow their posts, it took a Year to fall into my lap. Why? Sure it's a cover but it is so good. A couple of things I have noticed that RBW is likely pushing fro exposure is there are a lot of new clips with them singing/dancing with other popular K-Pop idols. I think that's a great decision. IN any case, it would be a great tragedy if they would be pushed aside an left to wallow in the pond. They are way too good to be poorly represented imo.Oh, one last thing I noticed with BBB, and I know that they all are good actors, but I really noticed that Swan is starting to exude more.... I don't know if the right word is Confidance but earlier tracks, video wise, she didn't seem quite comfortable in the dancing mode. YOu don't get that at all in BBB, she is definately growing into a multi-threat contender.. Check out Vegas if you haven't already heard it.. Thanks once again for the very insightful and beautifully articulated observations. "Purple Kiss Vegas"

Ohh for sure. BBB is relatively basic as in comparison to their catalogue, but still a good basic to me. But yea, this era has seen a bit more exposure in which we are seeing more interactions through the challenges. It seems like they're in okay spot where I just can't seen them completely toss purple kiss to the side. However, whether they make an impact like that is a different story. I did actually hear the Vegas cover previously and I really enjoyed it too.

Honestly could be. A mixture of being Mamamoo's sister group and expecting residual fame from Mamamoo to boost them on debut and then to replicate the a similar culture of fandom for them to continue boosting up Purple Kiss but it's not that simple which I think they are kinda but also not really getting.

Yea, it wasn't really my vibe so would be less interested in them. But omg I saw a comment recently about Cherry Bullet's name. Thoughts on the idea of Purple Kiss having a Purple side being dark concept and Kiss side being kinda like 7heaven and more "brighter"

Weki Meki haven't really been doing much so I feel like I wouldn't be adding too much to the existing video already out there

Yea, it was such a departure that I hope it's kinda like IVE with baddie. Like it was just a departure to allow them room to explore other concepts and not confine themselves. But also, it lowkey was what them Purple Kiss too so idk

Ohh for sure. I'm excited to see what this new comeback brings though. Plus sweet juice is kinda get a slightly minor renaissance of a good comeback that was paid dust.

Yea, they kinda need that balance to still be palatable to a general public unfortunately. Darker concepts haven't seen the best track records so something dark adjacent like Zombie might do more.

What do you mean by comeback content? Like the behind the scenes type of thing?

​@@cloudchungxiaothey usually only doing music shows and radio for comeback promotions, barely attend to like variety or interviews kind of things.They did a lot in ponzona and zombie but during memem and nerdy there so much lack of content. Feels like rbw just started to make them busy again this year lol

@@cloudchungxiao variety, 1thek,muply,weekly idol etc

Right right. I mean Covid restricted a lot of this so I see what you mean. I'm not sure whether comeback content is extremely important during the rookie eras or just any comeback content, but hopefully we see more from them. I know they're doing their tour atm so can't really accomodate for too much comeback content for 7Heaven

They'll kinda continue as is with decent success and defs no sight of early disbandment. But whether they can grow into like Mamamoo territories for RBW, we'll kinda have to see. How do you feel?

@@cloudchungxiao mamamoo is very talented than why they can't famous like other world wide kpop group????

@@cloudchungxiao and now rbw does focus on international fan

Not sure what your first comment is trying to say. Is it that Mamamoo isn't famous worldwide?

@@cloudchungxiao yeah i want to say that mamamoo is very talented they deserve popularity like blackpink but they didn't get it WHY?

I can kinda excuse the different sounds if the music was good and concept was still consistent. Haven't vibed with 7heaven. Vibed with Ponzona, Zombie, Sweet Juice. Then Nerdy and Memem, I'm real 50/50 on. But yea, I can see how the change in sound can throw people off.

@@cloudchungxiao the inconsistent with sound only works if a group is popular. purple kiss still had a small fanbase so it didn’t make sense for rbw to experiment rather than focusing on what gained them attention. its a shame since they’re so talented and the music is good

Ahh right. Do you think the sweet juice sound would have been a better focus or zombie? Probs the two most well received comebacks for Purple Kiss

Thanks for the clarification. Must have changed after my research. It's been updated in my description

Yea, that's pretty unfortunate. Makes me wonder whether they actually believed Yuki would make it into the line up.

Thanks. What's crazy is the fact they are approaching around half the term of a standard contract so it could make sense why their fire isn't completely there. But I do wonder whether RBW or Purple Kiss will be able to do much unfortunately. I mean with the strong prescense of rookie 4/5th gen big 4 groups as well as existing big 4 groups; there is such a small period of promotional time that can allow them to get a big more recognised with their music. Unless they make some song that really transcends kinda like Cupid by fifty fifty type of noise, then I think they'll just kinda continue to stay in their own lane doing their own thing. Could even pull a Dreamcatcher where they get more attention in the late game so they are not completely done for.

@@cloudchungxiao I may be completely off-track here but I'm from Canada and the typical formula for Canadian musical artists is that they have to gain some notoriety somewhere else, the US mostly, before they will get real recognition in Canada. It's a sad model but all too often it is true. The tour to the US was a good idea but it seems to me that the venues were poorly chosen and really onlypromoted to fans of PK on the internet. Purkies. The venues were small and intimate, and that's just fine if you're just doing a concert for you fans but if your aim is to attract a broader audience then I think that was a fail. I think that , and I am not knowledgable enough about the minutiae of promoting. but I felt like those performances should have been more broadly advertised and exposed, more than just pre-existing fans, to the Purple Kiss vibe. Again, the intracasies to achieve that are beyond my scope of knowledge.

Ohh for sure. I think for the formula for success; it's always been establish a decent fanbase domestically before venturing overseas for kpop groups. There's been very few groups who establish more of a international fanbase before they get relatively successful. As for the US tour, I lowkey don't think of Purple Kiss as ones to promote in the west like that, so it was a nice surprise. In terms of the size of the venues; I think maybe they underestimated the sizes just to ensure they can maximise the utilised cost. It would be more unfortunate if they were to hire big and still have a decent amount of empty seats which this was their first venture to the west; so they could have played it safe. But yea, the reception surely should influence abit more investment into bigger venues for the future if they do plan to go over to the US again.

The reputation of RBW is slowly slipping tbh.

If you're referring to what I said in the "Group Visibility" section, I said it's dwindled down to the point where it doesn't FEEL like they have anything besides music shows. I know they've done stuff as a group but to me it feels like it's more targeted to their domestic audience or Plory's because it's not felt as much. As for RBW, I do defend them a bit during my "RBW Ent" and "Final Thoughts" section. They're obviously not the worst company and still have so much potential to uplift a lot of their groups which will take kidna time for them but promotion is defs one area that they have not perfectly executed for most of their groups.

I did wanna kinda bring this up which is why I made that Yuki comment in comparison to all the other solo activities that Swan has done. Idk, her voice is definitely unique but that's kinda it in terms of her appeal to me. Idk if that can carry her that far to be the next any Mamamoo member tbh. Ireh though, she a lowkey dark horse and i could see her pop off if given the right opportunity and with the bare minimum treatment in showing her.

Idk about that. They're still getting consistent comebacks, going on another tour overseas which shows there's a market but in saying that, we aren't necessarily seeing the exponential growth that we may want for them to be "comfortable" as a group.

@cloudchungxiao Look at the amount of the company’s spending on the group at the beginning of the group’s inception and the comebacks that followed. And look at the recent comeback, you will notice that the group’s budget has been reduced very significantly. consistent comebacks do not mean anything because with each comeback you notice that the group's fans has decreased significantly and they have lost interest in the group. As for the tour, it is only a last attempt to save what can be saved, although I am sure that the return from the tour will not even cover the expenses. The company does not receive a tangible return from the group. The company has two options: the first is to disband the group, and the second is to neglect the group and donate a little money from time to time for some of the group’s activities.

Ohh yea, not too sure about the returns from Purple Kiss's activities to feel confident that they are comfortably doing well. However, it's the fact they RBW is still relatively trying. There is that balance that ultimately needs to be done where sadly you can't guarantee success for all groups even if companies go all out constantly. They at some point have to balance the fact of promoting without going all out if they know the returns aren't gonna completely match the same amount they invested. However, in saying that, at what point should this happen is highly subjective and so that' where it could kinda be debated whether RBW is "giving up" way too quick or is their actions towards Purple Kiss relatively justifiable.

Laughing in a what way?

Same tho lmao

Don't worry. It doesn't help that her release was in the same week as NewJeans's 1st pre-release & TXT's collab with The Jonas Brothers.

@@monib111 I really enjoy the txt Jonas brothers Collab. OHH MY GOD, don’t know how you do it like that! BLOW MY MIND then somehow bring it right back! Lol

Yea, Swan was getting pushed a lot with all her appearance within Korea shows but then it didn't really translate when they would eventually announce her solo

Hahaha that was at the beginning. Surprised you didn't leave when I said I only heard their debut era and then after that kinda barely anything. But yea, feel free to give me constructive feedback if you felt like my research was wrong but I feel like it was pretty accurate with slight add-ins of my analysis of Purple Kiss