The Rise and Fall of Mindless Self Indulgence and Jimmy Urine - What happened? 

THE CHAOTIC CONTROVERSIES OF PANIC! AT THE DISCO: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-L99PlUvZ7GQ.htmlfeature=shared ALSO: I love hearing all of your opinions in the comments! This video was my first video to blow up and it’s cool to see so many people interested in this case & my vid! EDIT: For anyone looking for updates, there is a pinned thread on the subreddit r/MSI. Jimmy has been served by an investigator, after pretending to not be home 4 times. EDIT 2: The case is now dismissed. Also I edited the description :)

its so weird and eerie that after this whole case the members just, vanished from the public eye so you dont even know what theyre up to these days or ANYTHING. i would love to know what happened to them but i guess they just want to be left as a memory.

I’m mad that he didn’t really defend himself and didn’t even reply or give any of his fans like a reason to still be interested in defending him. Maybe he jus accepted that he can’t have a comeback? I don’t know.. Edit: stop replying to this comment yall , I was hyperfixated on msi at the time. 😭 - 10/19/23

After 2017, it's especially important to take allegations like these with a grain of salt.

Played a show with MSI and I got more the vibe from the crowd that they wanted to bang him more then he wanted to bang them. It always seems more like he was amazed with the reaction, of course seeing MSI play with coal chamber is what even inspired me into making more ridiculous music and going live. So mixed feelings. Keep writing music Jimmy. Thanks for making a fair video @ToMeItzN0thing.

I'm not sure. Innocent until proven guilty is important because mob hunts literally do nothing good, but he's also done some weird shit in the past. I know he likes being shocking and edgy, which was absolutely a common thing up until the mid 2010s or so. But it's been decades, and there's only one case of this against him from what I know, which has to use music lyrics in the lawsuit? I've been a MSI fan since 2006, so it's pretty weird to see all this. I don't personally think this is true, BUT none of us are lawyers/judges. If it ends up true, I'll be wrong but a creep will be outed/put away. (Which is a good thing, IF it is true.)

this is pretty old now, but ive been trying to stay neutral on it until we get a final answer on if he was guilty of it or not!! i still enjoy the music the band made though

I completely missed out on all this shit. For me, as a punk rocker growing up in fucking Kentucky in late 90's early 2000's, I might as well have grown up in the 50's in Candyland. MSI gave me a certain amount of power over the hateful things people said about me and the things my community hated. Calling me gay when I wasn't, accusing me of drug abuse when I was straight edge and just thought and talked differently. All of the hyper judgmental christians that I grew up with couldn't hang when I blasted MSI's songs about cocaine, sex and just about every single topic that the grown adults around me pretended didn't exist. For that, I will always listen to their music and understand its importance to my own personal perspective. Imo, lyrics, poems, books, are all safe from censorship. We can agree on which artists we show support for, but we don't get to silence the artists we don't like. As far as allegations go, I do take it with a grain of salt and understanding that if someone was hurt, that should be validated and respected. They're very serious allegations, but also from a long time ago. If he made some mistakes in his life, that's his life and his lessons to learn from. I don't think it's my place to judge him for the rest of our natural lives. Fuck knows Ive made mistakes; a decade of alcoholism leaves me glad that I didn't live under the miscroscopic scrutiny of the fucking ravenous masses the whole time. I'd probably still drink all the time tbh, but luckily, I'm sober for over a year and finally have my life back from the madness. Anyways, i hate writing fucking essays online but this shit hit me some kind of way and I just wanted to voice it.

Mainly Jimmy is the one I'm most concerned of, but the lawsuit states that the rest of the band knew about Jane but just didn't do anything, so I'm iffy on the rest of them too.

it's a weird situation, lol. the case does seem suspicious after all with the evidence being song lyrics and nothing concrete, but jimmy's reaction to that was also kind of weird? hopefully we'll find out more.

I heard the girl that sued him needed money for a surgery and this is the way she was trying to get it, and that crap happens to famous people a lot

Frankenstein Girls is such a good fucking album. It definitely makes my top 5 ughhhh

I had a WHOLE phase of MSI since 2021, in 2022 when I discovered that Jimmy was a bad person I was traumatized and sad, because there are A LOT of their songs that are so catchy...sometimes I still listen to them because I liked their songs (Only the songs that are from my favorite albums) Now I discorvered new bands that helped me to forget about msj, stuff like kmfdm, system of a down, korn, TV Girl... it's hard to try ignoring something that you loved and then discovering that it's a bad thing. (Sorry for my bad eng

Two videos that I feel do really well with explaining what happened with Jimmy are Edwin's Generations video and Heavy Metal Slumber Party's video.. they both explained it pretty well

MSI and Jimmy Urine are the personification of "I remember when I had MY first beer".

Found this while trying to see if there's any updates after watching another video mentioning what happened a year ago. The lawsuit seems kind of suspicious. From what I heard the only real evidence is a birthday card that says Happy fifteenth. I'm not saying this person is lying but am I not one birthday card away from having the same evidence to use against him too?

"with all consequence I will do it again" He must have got very big-headed off of his impunity. All those years alongside R Kelly, with NO consequence for what he did must have tricked him into a false sense of security. When the backlash came, he didn't have anything to defend himself with, so he blanked it. His victim was voiceless until then, but once the lawsuit was out and he didn't have anywhere to run, everything stupid he'd done for the last 25 years was going to come to light and be seen in that light. He's trying to salvage the family man her decided he wanted to be all along. He can only do that by playing dead. Personally, I think he has a lot to answer for with the kind of stuff he was filling his fan's heads with. Laughing at jokes that weren't really jokes, stewing in that filth, wasn't a good look for us.

Maybe it is true, maybe it is not, maybe band members knew, maybe they did not. It is all speculative & that is them as people. Them as musicians are songs like 2 Hookers & an 8-ball, so how much you choose to speculate on girls from seven-eleven & how much of the night they stay up & who gets discounts is all just on you. If you wish to hear Molly & think of 15y.o. being fed booze then that is what you are going to do & that is not anything I can control just like you can’t control that I feel Molly is a song about someone whom feels safer living in a closet under the weight of their life of lies & it is sad, but a peppy beat makes it a great reminder that it is always a choice to either live your truth or live their lies & that message is ageless & applicable to a lot more than just one’s sexuality. That being said, Jimmy Urine marketed himself as a singing erection so expect & accept that those are the songs he believed an erection would sing.

I know this was a year ago! I just wanna share my personal opinion!! Since Jane Doe & Jimmy agreed to settle the court case, I really hope we atleast get some sort of answer whether he's innocent or not, it'd be nice to get a small update!! I don't think he's innocent, however i cant exactly label him guilty since there was a lot of evidence used against Jane Doe leading to them being false allegations 😭

They just released an album a few days ago chat

Jimmy cracked corn and I don't care mindless self indulgence 4life

5:54 I FOUND IT STRANGE TOO?? why the HELL would you use PUBLIC INFORMATION as evidence? it's just plain odd.

This is an amazing video but I think most people prefer it if it wasn't an automated voice

“Oh so he didn’t do anything bad, it was just rumours.” “Until”

SAD that he's not coming back to States. He just needed a great attorney. . Apparently he and family are happy in NZ.But how can he be happy forever not playing out?

i just wanna say, i like the left rights but god i cannot look at their first album cover, its so disgusting

i dont believe it cuz elektra one the first half of the case then it got dismissed for awhile, thats just me tho.

0:45 how? if their's a video of them live in 1997

WHAT ALBUM ARTWORK?

Cool video, hope you keep making more content.

4:07 Jimmy turned Saul Goodman

Yo... have any of these people listen to insane clown posse??🤣🤣🤣

I needed this

he got married. that's what happened. legit saw him go from drinking his own piss on stage while wearing fairy wings to...whatever they are now.

omg, your video is awesome! keep it up, buddy!

This is one of my favorite bands one two I live by n punk and push the envelope so to speak this is one band like Sucidal tendencies and other bands oingo bongio to name few there Lori s and sound is awsome but if you are a person of options then you won’t get this language sorry but not offend but this song is music that speaks from a different place

They just made a new album oh no

Did you skip over Frankenstein girls?

thank you!!!

this is why separating the art from the artist is important

James just flew too close to that depraved sun and well... he got burned. Time to take him out back of the chemical shed. Can we do Jimmy Page too?

I’ve known some girls that I never would’ve guessed were only 15. And I’ve known some guys in their 20s who were like teenagers. If they just dated I don’t see it is that horrendous. But I guess I need to look at the lawsuit.

The album art for tight is just gross. The art plus the title is pretty disqusting.

Left tights is superior

You owe it to everyone, to post how this case was dismissed, with prejudice. Which means more than you may think.

if album was the end of their good music and the beginning of the what the fuck is going on era imo lol

I was into them for a liittle bit in Early 2000

Anyone getting lostprophets Ian Watkins vibes?

This was way back in the day too. Before he was known for all of the shock rock shenanigans, or as well known. No excuse saying he fell into a persona or got comfortable with the lifestyle. I didn't catch his age but she was 15, no excuse.

No 😢

he left the country in 2018. . . . and i guess we know why now

good video:)

WAS I FRIENDS WITH YOU AT ONE POINT IM SUBSCRIBED TO YOU

I'm part of the crowd that pirates his shit now when I can lol. I gotta get my music files back tho, got a new phone.

Nahhh fake, and even if its real, the music is magical, it makes you ascend to another dimension

I mean….this should have been obvious from day one. Guy has plenty of photo and video evidence doing gross things