Тёмный

The Russia-China-India Strategic Triangle: A New Alliance - TLDR News 

TLDR News Global
Подписаться 751 тыс.
Просмотров 143 тыс.
50% 1

Sign up to Brilliant (the first 200 sign ups get 20% off an annual premium subscription): brilliant.org/...
Despite the near universal condemnation of Putin's invasion of Ukraine, China and India have stayed remarkably quiet on the issue. In this video, we explore this strategic triangle, and how Russia has balanced allies with historically tense relations.
💬 Twitter: / tldrnewsglobal
📸 Instagram: / tldrnewsglobal
🎞 TikTok: / tldrnews
🗣 Discord: tldrnews.co.uk...
💡 Got a Topic Suggestion? - forms.gle/mahE...
Support TLDR on Patreon: / tldrnews
Donate by PayPal: tldrnews.co.uk...
TLDR Store: www.tldrnews.c...
TLDR TeeSpring Store: teespring.com/...
Learn About Our Funding: tldrnews.co.uk...
TLDR is all about getting you up to date with the news of today, without bias and without filter. We aim to give you the information you need, quickly and simply so that you can make your own decision.
TLDR is a completely independent & privately owned media company that's not afraid to tackle the issues we think are most important. The channel is run by just a small group of young people, with us hoping to pass on our enthusiasm for politics to other young people. We are primarily fan sourced with most of our funding coming from donations and ad revenue. No shady corporations, no one telling us what to say. We can't wait to grow further and help more people get informed. Help support us by subscribing, following, and backing us on Patreon. Thanks!

Опубликовано:

 

8 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 1,5 тыс.   
@HarpreetSingh-mn3kp
@HarpreetSingh-mn3kp 2 года назад
India isn't in strategic triangle with China. Infact the main reason India isn't taking sharp position in this conflict is because India wants Russia to remain neutral in future China India conflict. Weakened and isolated Russia will be a client State of china. This dragon bear alliance would seal the fate of Asia no matter what India and Japan do. Therefore India is staying neutral in this conflict.
@Chetanarora2308
@Chetanarora2308 2 года назад
Hnji bro
@Saiputera
@Saiputera 2 года назад
India and china and Russia have 2+bilion population total! That more then liberal Europe and USA lmao
@Quantum-1157
@Quantum-1157 2 года назад
Agreed 100% . West isn’t realizing that if India upsets Russia, then it is opening the flood gates for Pakistan in the west and China in the north to - both nuclear armed neighbours India loves!
@Tom_Bee_
@Tom_Bee_ 2 года назад
Thank you for your perspective. It seems very realistic based on what I've already learnt.
@prplt
@prplt 2 года назад
it's already a client state of China lol 😂
@ricardokowalski1579
@ricardokowalski1579 2 года назад
The analisys is incomplete until you add that 1China buys a lot of Saudi oil, 2 that oil is shipped thru the Malacca strait 3 India has placed considerable military in the Nicobar and Andaman Islands that guard the entrance to the Malacca strait 4 Indonesia has allowed India to operate from a base in Sabang, closing the net 5 China is not happy that a major oil supply lane is under India's surveillance, and possible control The "skirmishes" for territory that no one cares in the mountains are a sideshow. The Indians are buying the russian oil to stop China from taking it.
@manipulate9374
@manipulate9374 2 года назад
Albeit less efficient, the same oil can be sent to Pakistan and then sent over through Pakistan to China, which, I doubt Pakistan would oppose.
@carlwilson8859
@carlwilson8859 2 года назад
Russia, China & India will be tied together through their dependence on fossil fuels: Russia needs the other two as customers who will be outside of US dollar domination. China cannot depend on Saudi oil due to the vulnerability of shipping oil through ocean routes. They think it's enough that they now have Russian oil & gas almost in their hands as Europe works on getting out from under Russia's domination through oil & gas. Russia, China & India will be blind-sided through their ignorance of the implications of climate change. The West intends to address climate change problems starting 10 years from now; Russia, China & India in 20 years from now. Even our deluded and lying scientific establishment doesn't believe we have 10 years.
@Crysizz
@Crysizz 2 года назад
@@carlwilson8859 Yep u r right ,Climate change is happening because of this developing nation while developed nations don't even releasing a bit of green house gases till now
@durgeshsss
@durgeshsss 2 года назад
@@manipulate9374 the route china using to transport oil through pakistan goes from POK pakistan occupied Kashmir ... eventually india will take back its land ...which will cut pakistan and china from each other
@samarthadanvadi878
@samarthadanvadi878 2 года назад
thats the reason they are doing the belt and road project, at least a major reason. To make china self sufficient in energy, by building gas and oil pipelines to china they don't have to import that through malacca strait, More gas pipelines from sebaria to china will be built in the near future, why do you think russia will not give oil to china?
@StevenSmith-mk5fg
@StevenSmith-mk5fg 2 года назад
This dynamic is the pinnacle of the term 'frenemies'. In politics/geopolitics, there is no such thing as friends, just interests.
@solidoperative
@solidoperative 2 года назад
From a geo-political sense all 3 of them have massive chips on their shoulders.
@sinoroman
@sinoroman 2 года назад
same goes for the US alliance system
@solidoperative
@solidoperative 2 года назад
@@sinoroman Really who in particular?
@StevenSmith-mk5fg
@StevenSmith-mk5fg 2 года назад
@@sinoroman Yep. They do have more in common with each other in that they are all Western style democracies though. They all mostly speak English and don't have real border disputes with each other too
@sinoroman
@sinoroman 2 года назад
most allies of the US are junior allies. they go out of their way to help benefit the America without gaining much themselves. there are many US bases in junior countries
@ssjgogeta1979
@ssjgogeta1979 2 года назад
1:48 India doesn't claim Kashmir. They don't need to do that. Kashmir was Indian from 1947 itself. Pakistan and China have illegally taken up their land.
@SafavidAfsharid3197
@SafavidAfsharid3197 2 года назад
Shhhh..... Don't tell them about treaties or things like instruments of accession.
@user-op8fg3ny3j
@user-op8fg3ny3j 2 года назад
Why was their autonomy revoked though?
@abps9947
@abps9947 2 года назад
@@user-op8fg3ny3j because of stop promoting terrorism
@theanglo-lithuanian1768
@theanglo-lithuanian1768 2 года назад
Did you just say "We don't claim it... We claim it"?
@theanglo-lithuanian1768
@theanglo-lithuanian1768 2 года назад
@peristera mpazo So... Claiming? It doesn't matter whether or not they are right, it's still a claim. All nations have their territory which they "claim".
@ravenlord4
@ravenlord4 2 года назад
Hats off to India. They are in the Quadrilateral Security Dialogue which is an anti-Chinese block, and this new "Triangle" which is essentially an anti-US block. I'm not sure how many other countries could pull that off.
@balajeepratham8200
@balajeepratham8200 2 года назад
We are great at balan
@Dodsodalo
@Dodsodalo 2 года назад
I wouldn't really call China occupying 4000 sq km of Indian land being.... An ally in many, or any ways really,
@casualsuede
@casualsuede 2 года назад
India hasn't pulled it off. The wolves will be knocking on India's door and they will eventually have to choose. The worst thing for India is if chairman Xi is boosted out of office and china's next chairman is pro-west (like Jiang zimin) and leverages their friendliness to push India off to the side. You see, the west needs a partner and the problem with India and China is they think they are the next big thing and will overtake the west, and the rest of asia. India and china has clout but no real friends, but they need the west more than the other way round.
@Hhhh22222-w
@Hhhh22222-w 2 года назад
@@Dodsodalo the border dispute is due to the British, who decided their borders, so ofc
@badluck5647
@badluck5647 2 года назад
Seems like a failure as a policy. They don't have the Chinese support to stop Chinese encroachment and they don't have the US support as a counterbalance.
@LplusRatioLol
@LplusRatioLol 2 года назад
Correction: the 1971 Deal between India & Russia was mostly due to US being a Pakistan ally. In the Indo-Pak of ‘71, US, UK brought their navies to the Indian Ocean to choke Indian navy and support Pakistan. So India signed a deal with the Soviets for mutual understanding & USSR navy protecting India in case any 3rd party interferes. This was the major reason. NOT BECAUSE OF CHINA really. The west has a problem in acknowledging the fact that it supported a terrorist, Human tight violator state of Pakistan who conducted atrocities on Bangladesh.
@bear.2d
@bear.2d 2 года назад
what's the indo-pak '71? is that the bangladeshi independence war
@LplusRatioLol
@LplusRatioLol 2 года назад
@@bear.2d yes
@bear.2d
@bear.2d 2 года назад
@@LplusRatioLol ah ok
@ayushmeena780
@ayushmeena780 2 года назад
@@bear.2d Nah it was war where India Russia came close, that's the reason why India still supports Russia
@bear.2d
@bear.2d 2 года назад
@@ayushmeena780 no one asked or cares
@pennyfarthing7332
@pennyfarthing7332 2 года назад
This Triangle is even Sussier than Bermuda
@gamehacker2801
@gamehacker2801 2 года назад
There's no traingle.
@PerryKobalt
@PerryKobalt 2 года назад
@@gamehacker2801 there just only *Among Us*
@スガル
@スガル 2 года назад
One is full of conspiracy and can make people, plane, and boat mysteriously disappear The other is in Atlantic Ocean roughly bounded by Miami, Bermuda and Puerto Rico
@raakbas1
@raakbas1 2 года назад
It's a complete mess!🙄
@Siience...s
@Siience...s 2 года назад
@@PerryKobalt 😂👌
@saurabhdang7307
@saurabhdang7307 2 года назад
Pretty good analysis as an Indian this war has shown us that you just can not depend on other countries hardware for defence , That's why many defence deal have been given to India company so that indian defence industries could thrive
@user-op8fg3ny3j
@user-op8fg3ny3j 2 года назад
Not just military industry but other like computer chips manufacturing
@georgebouloukos8264
@georgebouloukos8264 2 года назад
Yeah... No the truth is that India tried making its own shit but ... White people know how to make weapons ,brown people not so much!
@yj9032
@yj9032 2 года назад
Now all Indians are experts on geopolitics?
@samatha1994
@samatha1994 2 года назад
and Indian investment in non fossil fuels. We're expected to be one of the worst affected by climate change. The recent and ongoing temperature changes in India are just a sign:(
@WannabeShady90
@WannabeShady90 2 года назад
@Red Bull Say, what technology does India have that we might be interested in? 😂
@VikramSingh-jj1bk
@VikramSingh-jj1bk 2 года назад
For your kind information, majority of NATO countries are buying more energy imports from Russia then india since Ukraine Invasion, 👉 Europe is Still buying Rússian energy imports and and even paying in Rubles
@nishantshah9298
@nishantshah9298 2 года назад
Yes, but don't let the facts come in the way of a flashy video, ill researched if I may add.
@alexanderlipowsky6055
@alexanderlipowsky6055 2 года назад
yes we still are buying oil and gas from russia, but we cut ties on oil (they can turn of our oil, we wont crumble) and SEVERELY reduced our reliance on the gas (still gonna hurt, less than the russian eco would if they did cut it) and dont forget its 10 countries that buy it with rubles, partially only, of 50+
@zammiatesparker152
@zammiatesparker152 Год назад
All indians report to youtube thus guy is using wrong Indin map, We are atleast a quarter of youtube If they want to operate in India they should follow Indian rules.
@DomCombatVids
@DomCombatVids 2 года назад
This ignores the geopolitics of the Asian continent and views a matter that is entirely Asian in nature through the lenses of Ukraine. India will never enter into any "alliance" with China, even saying that they're "frenemies" is stretching it. India and China have remained quiet over the issue in Ukraine, yes because they have some stake in Russia, but mostly because they have no horse in the race. It's a European war and Asia does not care about it. Europe has not cared about any Asian war since the days of Vietnam, with the genocide in Bangladesh still not being tried in the Hague and the perpetrators of multiple genocides in South East Asia living out their lives in peace. Why should Asia care? China and India do not care to curry favour from the West and are capable economies. The West relies on food imports from India, China and South East Asia and it would take at least 2-3 years (based on crop cycles alone) to replace that dependence. China and India, best described as mortal enemies, simply don't care
@Kids11111
@Kids11111 2 года назад
@bruce parka If India had access to US technology, then they wouldn't have had been in a position to not oppose Russia. It is precisely the US "not caring" for India that has led to this situation where it finds no takers for it's own meddling in Asia. To put it plainly, the US is seeing the consequences of it's stupidity.
@harshjain3122
@harshjain3122 2 года назад
@bruce parka it's not like the west can wage a war against Russia either, can they? It's not about morality man, it's just...Asia has a lot of shit to work on and catch up to u guys. For example, getting involved against Russia can lead to India losing Russian military equipment directly putting it's national security at danger against china, a superpower literally next door. How many nations are in that situation? How many US soldiers will fight in the Himalayas against the Chinese for india? Exactly. We are on our own. So it's about maintaining a delicate balance, and more so...not risking higher inflation on oil and crude prices(might seem like we are selfish, cuz our nation will practically break down cuz unlike west, we can't sustain too much high levels of inflation whilst FDIs are also leaving)...there a lot of reasons, but you can't and shouldn't try keeping us against a wall and expecting co-operation.
@AG-vb6vv
@AG-vb6vv 2 года назад
I don’t know what food India exports to the West but what gives them (us) leverage to do as we please is that we know the West needs us as a counterbalance to China in the Asia Pacific region. I mean SK, Japan, Australia are great but India is the only nation that can fit that role. Plus Russia is our friend and has been a good and loyal one at that.. we cannot betray them. We dislike a war between brother peoples, especially ones we rather like (ex USSR), but will still stand besides Russia as long as it doesn’t compromise our relations with the West. Our relations with Russia are one of friendship and genuine goodwill, I’m afraid our relations with the West are as of now based on pragmatism and fraught with mistrust. That’s why the government is trying to walk the fine like between Russia and the West.
@_-_-_-TRESPASSER
@_-_-_-TRESPASSER Год назад
Can v blindly trust usa? Didn't usa earlier ditched Taiwan for CCP China Didn't usa supplied modern weapons, f16's billions in aid to Pakistan even after knowing thy endup used against India (democracy) Never once usa sanctioned Pakistan, even after they become like silicon valley for all radicals extremists psych and terrorist organisations Even after thy attached indian parliament Not even single time usa sanction Pakistan, y? Yesterday Japan, today china , u not tomorrow india? Dollar bomb Usa holding others hands dragging them to walk on shit Usa sabotage Nord stream gas pipeline, now supplying it's gas at more price to Europe Usa profits by selling weapons to all nations Europe , Ukraine,Taiwan by creating unnecessary tension, which could b averted. Usa dragging nation against nations to fight against each other, just to maintain its cash cow petro dollar unchallenged Y any Ukrainian Russian Japanese chines r any Indian people have to die for USA , to maintain its cash cow petro dollar (dollar as global reserve currency ) from being challenged So thy could SPEND RECKLESSLY JUS BY PRINTING more and more DOLLAR AFTET KILLING EVERYONE fight for humanrights, democracy
@_-_-_-TRESPASSER
@_-_-_-TRESPASSER Год назад
​@@AG-vb6vv Can v blindly trust usa? Didn't usa earlier ditched Taiwan for CCP China Didn't usa supplied modern weapons, f16's billions in aid to Pakistan even after knowing thy endup used against India (democracy) Never once usa sanctioned Pakistan, even after they become like silicon valley for all radicals extremists psych and terrorist organisations Even after thy attached indian parliament Not even single time usa sanction Pakistan, y? Yesterday Japan, today china , u not tomorrow india? Dollar bomb Usa holding others hands dragging them to walk on shit Usa sabotage Nord stream gas pipeline, now supplying it's gas at more price to Europe Usa profits by selling weapons to all nations Europe , Ukraine,Taiwan by creating unnecessary tension, which could b averted. Usa dragging nation against nations to fight against each other, just to maintain its cash cow petro dollar unchallenged Y any Ukrainian Russian Japanese chines r any Indian people have to die for USA , to maintain its cash cow petro dollar (dollar as global reserve currency ) from being challenged So thy could SPEND RECKLESSLY JUS BY PRINTING more and more DOLLAR AFTET KILLING EVERYONE fight for humanrights, democracy
@ThiagoSilveira1
@ThiagoSilveira1 2 года назад
A very loose alliance. India and China don't really get along with each other and they still have constant skirmishes in their disputed border. China and Russia also aren't that keen on each other. China has indirectly before that they would like to take back Vladvostok which they call Hǎishēnwăi and China is pretty pissed on Russia's influence in the Central Asia, a place where China wants to develop its One Belt One Road project, specially Kazakhstan. Only India and Russia seems more trust on one another.
@filipeareias3265
@filipeareias3265 2 года назад
you are completely wrong, china and russia have already solved the problems at the border and for several years they are partners in practically everything
@filipeareias3265
@filipeareias3265 2 года назад
China has had no sympathy for Nato since at least the time they bombed its embassy in 1999
@mint8648
@mint8648 2 года назад
China is currently running russian propaganda in their own country what are you talking about
@filipeareias3265
@filipeareias3265 2 года назад
@@mint8648 stop being stupid that I didn't need to see anything past in china to know that Ukraine has neo-Nazis and that america is involved is not because of ukrainians but because of hegemony and petrodollar
@righthandstep5
@righthandstep5 2 года назад
THIS OP^^^
@nChauhan91
@nChauhan91 2 года назад
India has been criticizing the war since start, we just haven't taken a hostile position against russia like the west because of our dependency & relations with russia
@wangyi8031
@wangyi8031 2 года назад
NO because your an unethical and untrustworthy country is the reason... Australia does more trade with china as a percentage yet will still critisize them and support Taiwan... if india gets attacked the best move for the west is stay out of it and let anyone have India as India doest care about anything else but India
@jamesn0va
@jamesn0va 2 года назад
I've always thought of India as losely aligned with the west due to democracy so it saddens me to see that is not. I think the west should back India in all its territorial claims and prove that democracy is the most important of its ideals. We can't critique India about its position when we are effectively doing the same to you.
@nChauhan91
@nChauhan91 2 года назад
@@jamesn0va we are aligned in that sense but we are also dependent for weapons with our 2 main rivals being Pak & China ( both nuclear powers). You can't leave the security of 1.4 billion people to chance & without weapons by going against your main supplier to get good headlines.
@jamesn0va
@jamesn0va 2 года назад
@@nChauhan91 absolutely, I could not agree more. I hope our country's can forge a joint future of Co operation. We benefited from colonising your people for so long. Its time to give back. It seems absolutely ridiculous to me that we don't support India as a permanent member of the Un security Council. India The largest democracy on earth and a future economic superpower, with such good demographics that it will most likely out perform China within the next few decades, it seems like a god send to the western mindset yet western nations treat you as a second class state, it boggles my mind how short sited we seem to be.
@yuritardid7761
@yuritardid7761 2 года назад
@@jamesn0va Germany and many other central and eastern European countries have also been hesitant to criticize Russia because they depend on russian gas, same way India is surrounded by chinese and russian allies... so if India takes an openly hostile position against Russia (they will lose a ton of weapons and trade) and then China (and their allies neighboring india) takes a hostile position against India it will end very badly for india... from what I've seen most Indians are sympathetic to Ukraine and support them just not in action to protect their own security, they are surrounded by enemies compared to the US which is oceans away, they have no choice
@kurousagi8155
@kurousagi8155 2 года назад
Highly unlikely. India working with China is just not going to happen. India and Russia do not border, and Russia has a history of being incapable of directing assisting its overseas allies that do not directly border it.
@prateekdhingra292
@prateekdhingra292 2 года назад
Russia sent submarines and warships in Indian Ocean to help india during 1971 Bangladesh liberation war in which us and uk had sent their navies to intimidate India.
@MPdude237
@MPdude237 2 года назад
@@prateekdhingra292 That was when the USSR was still up. The Russian Navy is in shambles and is incapable of conducting any combat operations outside the Black Sea or Baltic Sea. It certainly cannot contest waters outside of Europe.
@kurousagi8155
@kurousagi8155 2 года назад
@@prateekdhingra292 actually, the Russians sent those ships and submarines late. The Americans were in the Bay of Bengal for several days and the Russians didn’t get there until after the Americans left. The only contact between the American and Soviet ships was famously a holiday greeting between a Russian cruiser and the American carrier near the Straits of Malacca.
@gp-1542
@gp-1542 2 года назад
Imagine if they did tho That would be a “interesting relationship”
@Saiputera
@Saiputera 2 года назад
India and china and Russia have 2+bilion population total! That more then liberal Europe and USA lmao
@napoleonibonaparte7198
@napoleonibonaparte7198 2 года назад
The US and West should shift their relationship priority from the PRC to India.
@fromfareast3070
@fromfareast3070 2 года назад
They've tried before. But their invetment in India got busted. So that's why they'd rather invest in Vietnam instead of India LOL.
@banditonehundred
@banditonehundred 2 года назад
That is already happening, but India is afraid of becoming a Western colony, so they continue to put hinderances when things seem to get better
@leihtory7423
@leihtory7423 2 года назад
India rarely buys American Goods. Ford and GM closed factories in India, due to low sales. China buys USA goods. Ford and GM have been doing well in China. USA fast food is popular in China. As well as American apparel brands. India is a democracy workers have rights & they protest. Compare that to Chinas work force. Because China buys a lot of products and services from USA companies, this more than compensates for any physical material trade deficit.
@mint8648
@mint8648 2 года назад
How is china a relationship priority
@uzochiokeke4328
@uzochiokeke4328 2 года назад
@@leihtory7423 America is currently India's largest trading partner due to India's restrictions of certain chinese products.
@LeoDas688
@LeoDas688 2 года назад
The first option of India using West to counter balance China is the best option,and that is were India is heading for
@Saiputera
@Saiputera 2 года назад
India and china and Russia have 2+bilion population total! That more then liberal Europe and USA lmao
@LeoDas688
@LeoDas688 2 года назад
@@Saiputera Population has nothing to do with diplomacy,and democracies will and should stand together
@Saiputera
@Saiputera 2 года назад
@@LeoDas688 nah! India may be democracies but they ain't no democrats USA puppet government
@sosoable
@sosoable 2 года назад
You India is just a tool used by the West.
@russalarya
@russalarya 2 года назад
India's military spending on Russian equipment has significantly come down under the Modi government, sitting around 40% right now.
@sweetballs4742
@sweetballs4742 2 года назад
Tbf, the Russian armor casualties in Ukraine is prolly the big factor there. Not to mention, CCP prolly knows how to counter all of it so they better change their arsenal from Russian to western. I would agree if they could just make a local tanks like the Arjun MBT but the sheer bureacracy is their main problem for it.
@user-op8fg3ny3j
@user-op8fg3ny3j 2 года назад
@@sweetballs4742 the actual hardware isn't really the problem. It's their poor tactics and maintenance. Even M1 Abrams given to Iraq have easily been destroyed by insurgents because their crew were poorly trained
@RedLancerMoto
@RedLancerMoto 2 года назад
@@user-op8fg3ny3j All bling no basics
@sweetballs4742
@sweetballs4742 2 года назад
@@user-op8fg3ny3j also that one too! I cannot imagine how poorly trained they are to those tanks when hostilities between them (India) and China will go on full escalation. Heck, their soldier's weapons are pretty much mixed between INSAS Rifle, Galil and AK-47 which can be a problem for their soldier's familiarity to each weapon.
@RedLancerMoto
@RedLancerMoto 2 года назад
@@sweetballs4742 China isn't to start buying military hardware from the west. That would be giving their rivals influence.
@MrMartinSchou
@MrMartinSchou 2 года назад
I think India is also looking at the Ukraine invasion and wondering if their investment in Russian military hardware was actually a good idea.
@syhuhjk
@syhuhjk 2 года назад
India is moving towards west .it's a fact.but not saying it publicly that's it .
@soumyajeetbanerjee654
@soumyajeetbanerjee654 2 года назад
T90 tanks failed but calibre cruise missiles working very well
@Snipsnop260
@Snipsnop260 2 года назад
Haha we're really not, perhaps diversifying and building our own. One thing for sure is that you don't get bang for the buck from the US or EU... India has seen a history of duplicity from the west whereas Russia has given unwavering support in the last 70 years especially for Indian interests at the UN security council
@user-op8fg3ny3j
@user-op8fg3ny3j 2 года назад
@@Snipsnop260 western "military grade" just means the bare minimum to charge the most amount as possible
@uglytoad285
@uglytoad285 2 года назад
Yea. But it's hard to do. Many army officials and arm brokers have deep ties with Russian arms lobby. Perhaps Ukraine war will break the lobby. In defence deal it's not the best product wins. It's the best politically correct one wins.
@Kushagra.j
@Kushagra.j 2 года назад
Arunachal Pradesh is not a disputed place. It's like if tomorrow Mexico says to US that Texas or California is disputed!
@jirachi-wishmaker9242
@jirachi-wishmaker9242 2 года назад
They claimed it when they felt they can choke India's Chicken's neck
@Chase1493
@Chase1493 2 года назад
I’ve got to hand it to India, they are very flexible from a diplomatic perspective. The US consistently missed the boat with them in my opinion. The worlds largest democracy and a former colony of the same previous overlord seems like a natural fit. Plus I don’t really see any major strategic interests that conflict between us. Why we chose to lean toward Pakistan in previous decades makes no sense to me at all. China won Pakistan in the end anyways.
@ChasmChaos
@ChasmChaos 2 года назад
Beats me as well. India and the US are very similar. Both countries have a few liberal cities/states with a large core of conservative, rural populace. Both countries have vast lands with massive natural beauty and diversity. The 2 countries are (somewhat pseudo) capitalistic. Of course, India is nowhere the economic powerhouse that the US is, but it's definitely a better fit than Pakistan.
@yuritardid7761
@yuritardid7761 2 года назад
Before the 90s India had a ton of socialist policies.. the founders of India Nehru, Gandhi, Chandra Bose were self proclaimed socialists where as Pakistan was strongly against socialism and communism because of their association with atheism and secularism. Since during the cold war all that mattered was your stance on capitalism and socialism and nothing else the US ignored Pakistan's undemocratic tendencies and chose to ally with them and in turn India grew closer to the Soviet Union for their own security. Edit : also the US wanted to seed deeper ties in the middle east and Pakistan is culturally and geographically closer to the middle east than India is
@bhavikmahanot2768
@bhavikmahanot2768 2 года назад
@@yuritardid7761 wait what? atheism and secularism in pakistan ?? Lol Pakistan is ISLAMIC country
@yuritardid7761
@yuritardid7761 2 года назад
@@bhavikmahanot2768 where did i say pakistan was atheist?
@Crysizz
@Crysizz 2 года назад
@@yuritardid7761 pakistan was secular for just 2-3 year from its independence after that it was Islamic country,it seems according to u being a Islamic country look like a secular one in front of USA ,I think that is why USA supported Bangladeshi people genocide
@Harshil2456
@Harshil2456 2 года назад
‘Few’ countries support India on Kashmir? India was ready to hold a plebiscite in 1948 as long as the conditions of the UN resolution were met. It was Pakistan which refused to abide by the UN resolution by which time Jammu and Kashmir had firmly and legally become Indian territory. Moreover, the founding principle of India was opposite to the founding principle behind Pakistan and Indians will NEVER let go off that founding principle (despite some religious disturbances seen in recent times).
@user-op8fg3ny3j
@user-op8fg3ny3j 2 года назад
Why did India reverse Kashmir's autonomy though which led to internal conflict?
@manitdoshi
@manitdoshi 2 года назад
@@user-op8fg3ny3j although i think it was too soon and I don't like modi at all, if the government changes it will be beneficial for kashmir because the old act was keeping it isolated from the rest of india. But sadly the ones to scrap this act were modi government
@tamberlame27
@tamberlame27 2 года назад
@@user-op8fg3ny3j because the autonomy was temporary by the constitution the previous governments vacilated on the reversal for political reasons
@osiris1309
@osiris1309 2 года назад
​@@user-op8fg3ny3jCause it is unfair to have a muslim only state in a secular nation. Not to mention Kasmiris didn't have to pay taxes on a national level and were allowed to move to any other part of the nation and buy property/invest. But the rest of us could not do the same in Kashmir. To a large degree they had autonomy to do what they want, other than military and foreign policy. Would you like to pay taxes of which a portion is given to a state that does not add to the tax themselves, wouldn't allow you to ever go there and settle/invest, and can do whatever they want with the money??? The Kashmiri autonomy this was stupid to begin with. At Least now they are being treated like every other state in the country. We are all equal, no special treatment.
@user-op8fg3ny3j
@user-op8fg3ny3j 2 года назад
@@osiris1309 wasn't them joining India dependent on this though? So now the circumstances have changed they want independence, right...
@coolguywithahat0127
@coolguywithahat0127 2 года назад
This reminds me of the tripartite pact before ww1 and the creation of the central powers. Germany was great allies with both Italy and Austria-Hungary, but fundamental disagreements and even border disputes between Italy and Austria-Hungary meant that the two hated each other. And despite how strong Italy and Germany’s alliance was, it was this disagreement between Germany’s allies which resulted in Italy joining the entente rather than the central powers. While in a potential 3rd World War I don’t see India ever going to war with Russia, I doubt they would ever join the war on the Sino-Russian side, and if anything might actually fight against China.
@sirlj4328
@sirlj4328 2 года назад
@otto Lincoln "USA has always supported India" lol the USA supported Pakistan in the 1971 war when they genocided Bangladesh, and planned on launching a naval barage of the Indian coast. The USA also sanctioned us when we did the Pokhran-2 tests
@jont2576
@jont2576 2 года назад
i feel like india is only siding with USA just to get on China's nerves. its not like China really pays that much attention to india when u look at china news.....but China seems to be occupying free real estate in india's minds. unfortunately china and india are always going to be at odds with each other due to racial differences...... yes we would like to respect india.....but unfortunately asia being asia.....for some reason, god or the powers that be made this continent the most racially diverse and antagonistic where practically nobody likes nobody.
@the_lonewonder95.mp47
@the_lonewonder95.mp47 2 года назад
@@sirlj4328 read
@fromfareast3070
@fromfareast3070 2 года назад
What makes you assume China would be on Russian side?
@jont2576
@jont2576 2 года назад
@@fromfareast3070 china loves karl marx.....and russia historically have always been on the side of the underdogs countries throughout history,oppressed by us and the west.
@idraote
@idraote 2 года назад
The elephant in the room is Tibet and Himalaya in general. Those areas, inhospitable and frozen, are going to become far more accessible with climate change and they have huge water reserves that both countries - with their inflated populations - desperatly need. The smaller countries inbetween - Nepal and Bhutan - will be mincemeat, I'm afraid.
@user-op8fg3ny3j
@user-op8fg3ny3j 2 года назад
They need their independence
@REDnBLACKnRED
@REDnBLACKnRED 2 года назад
Actually this is already an issue since the largest rivers that serve Northern India and Bangladesh start in the Himalayan parts that are in Tibet/China. India isn't in a good position. As a matter of fact, other rivers that serve several countries in South East Asia also originate in China.
@idraote
@idraote 2 года назад
@@REDnBLACKnRED And PRChina loves its dams... the huger the better...
@tinahalder8416
@tinahalder8416 2 года назад
Nepal and bhutan will be independent, they r really not the issue here
@none8149
@none8149 2 года назад
@@tinahalder8416 they are already independent ?? What do you mean will be
@ChildofWar2
@ChildofWar2 2 года назад
Small comment, your mic seem to give a bit of static, not a big issue but I atleast do notice small background noises a lot. And once again you guys have done a great job!
@miguellopes7627
@miguellopes7627 2 года назад
India: The friend of my friend in my enemy
@TugaThings
@TugaThings 2 года назад
This is not an alliance, its more like a truce. These 3 countries are rivals / future rivals.
@pranavingale6850
@pranavingale6850 5 месяцев назад
I don't know about russia but india and china are no friends
@yukimatsuda5400
@yukimatsuda5400 2 года назад
Usa pushes India towards Russia by not sharing technology moreover by announcing war on the country.....India allies with Russia (only country willing to help) which protected India and also supplies our defense ammunition. India is close to Russia USA and west: surprised Pikachu face
@jasastopar
@jasastopar 2 года назад
As they said, india is getting closer to the west and further from russia
@yukimatsuda5400
@yukimatsuda5400 2 года назад
@@jasastopar yes and that's a good thing to make strategic allies all over the world but USA or EU should not expect India to let go of its old ties now that we are allies, that's selfish
@davidmoss2576
@davidmoss2576 2 года назад
The US doesn't share military technology with any country, it only sells export version of certain systems.
@kimjong-un5570
@kimjong-un5570 2 года назад
@@davidmoss2576 Then why did Us didn’t sell India f16 and f35 , they sold f16s to even smaller countries why not to India
@debangmaity3972
@debangmaity3972 Год назад
@@davidmoss2576 sometimes u guys trust china more than us. How could china become a superpower without usa help? Still today most us companies are still reluctant to leave china at a point when china is surpassing usa. Move your companies away from china...if not india thsn go to vietnam, japan , korea , thailand or anywhere else. But weaken china in your own interests. Or china will cripple usa economically. They cant cripple us to that extent because our economy was mostly closed for decades. We are more dependent on internal market .
@ElectricalMonk3558
@ElectricalMonk3558 2 года назад
It's not in the United states best interest to lend technological expertise to india. As the U.S. fears that India will surpass it one day. So they have to rely on Russia for weapons.
@kamelkadri2843
@kamelkadri2843 2 года назад
US doesn't have a problem with countries surpassing it, since let's be honest most of it's allies has surpass the US in one area on other, However China doesn't want anyone on top but itself, China is a major threat that can not be ignored, It's not too late but it's getting late
@ElectricalMonk3558
@ElectricalMonk3558 2 года назад
@@kamelkadri2843 what about the Japanese and the plaza accord?
@ChasmChaos
@ChasmChaos 2 года назад
The US fears no such thing. India has not closed the gap between it and the US in any economic or military metric.
@sosoable
@sosoable 2 года назад
India is a beggar
@vinaygoswami5374
@vinaygoswami5374 2 года назад
@@ChasmChaos But that's for now, In about 50-60 years India will surpass US as China have done now.
@Steven-fv8xw
@Steven-fv8xw 2 года назад
will china ever recognize india's territorial integrity though? there has been military conflicts in the past years
@TheYrthenarc
@TheYrthenarc 2 года назад
Indian press seems to be pretty concerned about China/Pakistan using the situation to heat up the conflict on the border, so I don't really think there is room for an India-China alliance, even if it might look like a possibility from the outside.
@hobog
@hobog 2 года назад
And they can't ignore this if they invade tw
@Charvak-Atheist
@Charvak-Atheist 2 года назад
no. China and India are enemies.
@arfajob4246
@arfajob4246 2 года назад
@Steven The chinese communist regime can be likened to a flesh eating disease where sovereign boundaries are concerned. It's grasping for territorial wealth will never be satisfied & it will never stop it's corrosive intrusions ~ where ever it thinks it can get away with it. Do not be sucked in by the krokodil's guile.
@surajithalder9468
@surajithalder9468 2 года назад
If they don't India will make them.😉
@junko4166
@junko4166 2 года назад
Meanwhile, Brazil is getting away with playing both sides (again). Feels good to be "irrelevant".
@gastonlinares5593
@gastonlinares5593 2 года назад
Nice, we have done it for decades here in Argentina 😅 You can feel the cost of it... In war there are not 3 sides they said
@gastonlinares5593
@gastonlinares5593 2 года назад
@my super rich country pakistan Then pick a side and put your things together with China
@RedLancerMoto
@RedLancerMoto 2 года назад
Brazil isn't important enough for anybody to care.
@RedLancerMoto
@RedLancerMoto 2 года назад
@my super rich country pakistan indeed
@junko4166
@junko4166 2 года назад
@my super rich country pakistan Thank God for that 😂
@ionnanskilliorus6877
@ionnanskilliorus6877 2 года назад
Russia can't be relied upon for anything anymore, it's going down the toilet. India can use this to get better terms and trading relationships with the EU, UK and US. They would also much prefer India as a bigger competitor to China. So if India is smart, they can use this situation to become much, much more prosperous. Can't just do that right away though but as this goes on, you'll see them shift further to the Western position, while gaining a lot for themselves.
@user-op8fg3ny3j
@user-op8fg3ny3j 2 года назад
What about Pakistan being a western ally?
@sympathiser_of_Germans_in_40s
@sympathiser_of_Germans_in_40s 2 года назад
That's exactly what's happening. India recently signed FTA with Australia and UK and Europe are in negotiations. And we already hate China so its mutually beneficial for USA,Japan and India.
@sympathiser_of_Germans_in_40s
@sympathiser_of_Germans_in_40s 2 года назад
@@user-op8fg3ny3j they've gone way too far with China already.
@ionnanskilliorus6877
@ionnanskilliorus6877 2 года назад
@@user-op8fg3ny3j That partnership is strained to say the least. India is more worried about how friendly China is getting with Pakistan.
@eritafinds
@eritafinds 2 года назад
America leaving afganistan was a huge blow for India's security concern.. America should give solution not unamicable instruction
@Cosmoscontroller
@Cosmoscontroller 2 года назад
If a this alliance actually is formed then the US is fucked
@catbiscuits4424
@catbiscuits4424 2 года назад
Russia's conventional hardware is potato, India buys Russia's old potato hardware... The only nation there that could be a threat is China and China's mostly interested in money and the U.S has the best money.
@whitegoose2017
@whitegoose2017 2 года назад
It won't because there are too many feuds and hatreds between these three. Anyone with even a passing familiarity with the historical relations between these countries understand this is just delusional thinking. There is a current ongoing border skirmish and we see Chinese & Indian border guards literally killing each other over a disagreement. Besides China is a bad partner in terms of security. Any military needs to only stop on sea route and the Chinese economy collapses in a matter of weeks. China is a state that cannot survive without globalization.
@catateappleat_6am
@catateappleat_6am 2 года назад
@@catbiscuits4424 First of all , Russia's whole hardware is not patato , and secondly just imagine if this alliance develops . World's 2nd , 3rd and 4th most powerful militaries !!😎
@somethinglikethat2176
@somethinglikethat2176 2 года назад
If China and India got along it might be realistic.
@user-op8fg3ny3j
@user-op8fg3ny3j 2 года назад
@@catateappleat_6am these are the same people that have been paroting the tank concept is dead ever since WW1
@Jai_hind
@Jai_hind 2 года назад
The Europe is literally financing the war by buying Russian oil and made the rubble strong but only India is critized
@jacharvey8231
@jacharvey8231 2 года назад
The EU is set to ban Russian oil and the EU share of oil imports from Russia has actually dropped. The rouble only seems strong on the surface due to tight state controls. In reality russia will see its economy contract by 10-15% and the west will soon cut off all energy imports from Russia, meaning Russia will have less capital to maintain and build new pipelines to divert supplies to China and India, plus India and China wouldn’t be able to take any extra oil from Russia than it does now due to its own infrastructure limits. India is Criticised for sitting on the fence when even India know Russia is a unreliable partner
@joshuag.a287
@joshuag.a287 2 года назад
The choice is that or freezing and/or a recession? I appreciate Indias right to build up its strategic reserves, but that leaves you open to criticism. Russian oil as a portion of India energy imports was much smaller than Europes prewar. So yes, India is criticised but that criticism is justified.
@gamehacker2801
@gamehacker2801 2 года назад
@@joshuag.a287 criticize yourself for financing Russia not others.
@MLHunt
@MLHunt 2 года назад
@@gamehacker2801 it's not an either/or. Everyone is subject to some criticism.
@Jai_hind
@Jai_hind 2 года назад
@@joshuag.a287 the same goes for India its a choice between recession and hyperinflation . So Europe its self is open to be critized because it's Europe and US that have failed to negotiate with middle East to increase oil supply . Atleast we are not making profit by selling weapon .
@anixes
@anixes 2 года назад
This video seems off or rather forced, I couldn't find any conclusion.
@jholotanbest2688
@jholotanbest2688 2 года назад
There is often no conclusions in geopolitics. It is just a big mess and I think this video shed some light on India's position on the war.
@bramha9680
@bramha9680 2 года назад
Neither did I
@darthashpie3370
@darthashpie3370 2 года назад
Don't let this video distract you from the fact that Europe has been giving 1billion usd everyday to Russia even after the war started in Ukraine. And EU is indirectly funding the war . India will do whatever is best for India's interest.
@johkupohkuxd1697
@johkupohkuxd1697 2 года назад
And that is changing. Don't blame the West for Putin's actions.
@darthashpie3370
@darthashpie3370 2 года назад
@@johkupohkuxd1697 nah i am just pointing out the hypocrisy of west funding the war while blaming India that doesn't even buy 1% of its oil from Russia. And how everyone has forgotten about the people in Afghanistan, Libya and Syria and other countries that have been destroyed by Invasions from NATO or Russia.
@Saiputera
@Saiputera 2 года назад
@@johkupohkuxd1697 nobody trust the west anymore. This is why middle east, china etc... Are on the verge of dropping the USA currency
@smit17xp
@smit17xp 2 года назад
@@johkupohkuxd1697 dont panic when I tie my bulldogs infront of your door. If you harm my dogs then I wont be responsible
@ruevyvlogs3631
@ruevyvlogs3631 2 года назад
Great channel. Ive been watching you for a while now and I’m very happy you are doing well and that you keep improving your channel! Good to see your face too!
@Creative___Mind
@Creative___Mind 2 года назад
The largest reason for strained Indo-Chinese relations is because China sees India as a rival in the Indian Ocean. We aim to be a world leader one day and for a multipolar world, but China wants it's shot at global hegemony much like the US, and other western countries got. Therein lies the problem, China's diplomacy entails seeing the other nation as weaker than China while India in the Asian continent employs the 'big brother' diplomacy, always trying to be the supportive and encouraging big brother but one not hesitant to scold you for a mistake. China wants more and more power and influence over the world, while India wants to atleast save it's power and influence in the Indian subcontinent if not increase it's own influence. China would not mind India increasing it's own power and influence so long as it remained under Chinese influence and remained weaker than China. They would probably not mind a situation like the one with Japan and US. Problem is, India doesn't want to be under China's lead. We have never joined the western or the eastern bloc in the cold war, and now we don't want to join the Chinese block. China doesn't like that since it knows India is among the only nations that can truly counter it. Thus the clashes. China supports Pakistan to keep India in check, but considering Pakistan does not focus on economic competition but on spreading terrorism we don't like that at all. It is a general consensus among the public that India spends way too much on defense but it's a necessary expense. If China and Pakistan back off, we could spend billions more on development. So there is also that anger against China. Then there is tibet. Tibet and India have long and historical ties and there is much anger here for what China does in tibet. If China allowed Tibet to become an independent country then the relations could improve but that is less likely than Putin winning the 2024 US election. So overall, China is the one that will have to take serious steps in order to improve the relations, the least of which will be to stop the border disputes, give us back Aksai Chin and stop their support of Pakistan.
@widodoakrom3938
@widodoakrom3938 2 года назад
Pakistan zinabad 🇵🇰
@jxz107
@jxz107 2 года назад
As someone who is distrustful of China, claiming China’s approach to diplomacy one of strength and weakness and that India’s is that of a big brother is absolutely ludicrous. I find it extremely doubtful that India will act any better than China in that situation, only “playing nice” when the other country acts to its own interests and acknowledges India’s superiority and trying to bully them when that doesn’t happen.
@insolidusyt
@insolidusyt 2 года назад
@@jxz107 Your skepticism is warranted. But keep in mind that India, much like the US is a still a democracy albeit a waning one. So there is still potential for India's foreign policy to change depending on the ruling party. While the current government has chosen to be more bullish and agressive with it's foreign policy, previous governments were much more pacifistic in their approach. This will probably never be possible with China, sadly.
@leihtory7423
@leihtory7423 2 года назад
wth are you mad? China does not want conflict OR want India as a Rival. In fact China offers belt and road initiative to India. China has not dropped a single bomb, not a single airstrike in the last 30-40yrs. compare that to India which has been dropping bombs on Kashmir. Big brother diplomacy? Tibet is Chinas source of water for 1.4 billion people. India intentions for Tibet is clear, as a means to control Chinas water supply. China sees dams for Hydropower, India sees dams as a weapon of war. Seeing how Indian geopolitics talk about blowing up 3 groges dam. wow insanity. China has long history with Tibet. Tibet was part of Qing Empire? that's hundreds of years in relevant recent history. Are you ignoring that. China does not support Pakistan to threaten India. That's paranoia. India wants Pakistan economy to be crushed. China just wants its neighbors economies to prosper. Pakistan is a corridor for oil from the middle east. But I understand you. My country and countrymen talk like you. They just hate Chinese people, & in truth not because of who they are, but how they look.
@Kwippy
@Kwippy 2 года назад
By cynically supporting Putin's war, India has morally bankrupted itself.
@Nurg0
@Nurg0 2 года назад
"And they were fierce enemies, but then they signed the 'Love Love doki doki cottoncandy kiss on the lips happy friendship pact' in 1984"
@uzochiokeke4328
@uzochiokeke4328 2 года назад
I'm Indian and many of us may claim to support Russia but in reality we are morally, commercially and strategically much closer to Japan. USA and Australia. We aren't harshly criticizing Russia because we dont want china to have the russians under their complete control. The Russians dont really like the chinese either but due to their isolation from the West, they have no choice but to side with china.
@sosoable
@sosoable 2 года назад
Russia and Japan dislike low castes even more. China, Japan and Russia are civilized societies where men and women are equal. We don't eat with our fingers.
@SumitKumar-oi1bb
@SumitKumar-oi1bb 2 года назад
I think u r quite wrong and i can say that being Indian myself
@mangopudding5979
@mangopudding5979 2 года назад
Indians do support Russians, your opinion does not matter.
@Raviteja-xy8yi
@Raviteja-xy8yi Год назад
@@SumitKumar-oi1bb Nope he is right 💯
@AnimeShetPosting
@AnimeShetPosting Год назад
@@Raviteja-xy8yi he is wrong
@rohan8015
@rohan8015 2 года назад
👍👍on getting the map of India correct , most channels show the wrong map when it comes to J&K
@Nikhikniranjan
@Nikhikniranjan 2 года назад
Actually there is love for russia among indian citizen too.... Just because of a single incident that happened in indo pak war india was fighting for bangladesh independence america always supported pakistan so america and britain sent their naval fleet to attack on indian navy...obviously india was no match for them. That time them comes russia into picture who also sent their navy fleet in indian ocean before america and britain and also said to contain nuclear weapons which made western navy to retreat... Thanks to russia bangladesh become independent from pakistan and rightnow more prosperous than pakistan.
@AntiFurryJihad
@AntiFurryJihad 2 года назад
War breaks out India and China - **These is business** (buys more and cheap crude oil 🛢️)
@prasoonmishra8698
@prasoonmishra8698 2 года назад
Everyone knows in India why this war is raised.
@thebestevertherewas
@thebestevertherewas 2 года назад
EU buys much much more oil than India. In fact consumption of oil in the EU has increased since the invasion.
@hmmmm6685
@hmmmm6685 2 года назад
Man you don't know impact of oil price rise in nation like India.
@prasoonmishra8698
@prasoonmishra8698 2 года назад
Severely misguided and ignorant
@jirachi-wishmaker9242
@jirachi-wishmaker9242 2 года назад
China & India : fights war Continues trades close to $100B _This is business_
@gurhanweyrah3930
@gurhanweyrah3930 2 года назад
India would like have their cake and eat it too. They want to be closer to both the West and Russia but away from China 🇨🇳. It is probably good idea to stay neutral but the Ukraine 🇺🇦 has shifted the whole situation. I think India’s biggest challenge is from China 🇨🇳 so you either beat your enemy or submit and join him. If I was the Indian prime minister, I would be moving closer to the West while also occasionally flirting with China and Russia just to remind the West of my importance. Russia 🇷🇺 can give you cheap oil and weapons that are outdated and they give the same to China as well but They will not help you counter China 🇨🇳. I think the biggest worry for India from joining the West is that they feel the West is just using them to counter China 🇨🇳 rather than accepting India 🇮🇳 as an ally like they would accept countries like Australia. Either way it is good headache to have when people are fighting over you knowing all too well of your strategic importance unlike China 🇨🇳 who is doing everything to get allies to no avail.
@debapriyasahoo3817
@debapriyasahoo3817 2 года назад
Do you think we are expecting that the Russia will help us against China. We want Russia to be neutral. We have now 45% russian weapons which was once 80%. Honestly I don't believe that West will help us against China because history repeats itself. So we are preparing ourselves to counter China.
@gurhanweyrah3930
@gurhanweyrah3930 2 года назад
@@debapriyasahoo3817 You will stand no chance against China 🇨🇳 as long as you depend weapons from other countries and they economically crush you. India 🇮🇳 should focus on economic development and try to shift the West’s and India’s dependence on China 🇨🇳 by making use of its Cheap labour that will only be possible if they come up with a plan and get financial investment from Western financial institutions otherwise India cannot challenge and economic superpower like China 🇨🇳. You can’t an expensive war if you can’t feed your own people
@aiswaryabersan7983
@aiswaryabersan7983 2 года назад
@@gurhanweyrah3930 west has nothing to offer india except technology. India only depends on oil import other then that nothing
@Sneha-kl7xk
@Sneha-kl7xk 2 года назад
@@gurhanweyrah3930 We can feed our people or not don't bother about that, because in India even having little also we are happy not a materialistic people like you all...We have big hearts to share with each others , not like yours who still have colonial mindset and superiority complex calling us poor blah blah , time is already near your country is falling n it will for sure.
@BaljinderSingh-xy4ik
@BaljinderSingh-xy4ik 2 года назад
I think he is using your strategy lol
@hrishijagadees1234
@hrishijagadees1234 2 года назад
TLDR team during the brexit period used to analyse & scrutinize each event and come up with possible scenarios. It gave the channel 'not seen anywhere else' level of authenticity and quality. Now look at this half boiled egg video?! This is basically regurgitation of news reports and just glossing over hard facts. You are not even asking the basic questions: 1. What would Russia or China gain by having India in the alliance? 2. China being in excellent trade relations with the west would be interested in jeopardize that by being with Russia? 3. The whole fricking issue in Afghanistan (whose border is shared by 2 of these nations) where Taliban is back in business. What is impact?
@ChasmChaos
@ChasmChaos 2 года назад
Their strength is UK and EU news. They are still finding their footing with respect to world news, especially South and SE Asia.
@alameen8049
@alameen8049 2 года назад
Good luck with bringing china and India together.
@grimbutnotevil391
@grimbutnotevil391 2 года назад
I realy can't imagine China and India becoming close friends whilst there continue to be border conflicts. Chinese water appropriation, dam projects, military buildup, salami slicing of territory and anti-indian rhetoric mean there is a huge distrust of the Chinese government. India is alos anxious about China funding Pakistan and Sri Lankan debts to China. By contrast there really isn't any particular reason for friction with the US save for the US havng some form of relationship with Pakistan.
@sosoable
@sosoable 2 года назад
India will not be considered in the competition between China, the United States and Russia.
@moonlighmax
@moonlighmax 2 года назад
Why India is not taking sides in Ukraine-Russia conflicts? Because Russia has been neutral in Indo-China conflicts in last 30-40 years. And India wants same thing from Russia in future too. If India keep Russia in good relations than it can use it as proxy and China will always have fear that if any mistake happens then it may end up getting attacked from 3 sides (Japan, India, Russia). Because both Russia and Japan have territory conflicts with China too.
@kkkk25yearsago79
@kkkk25yearsago79 2 года назад
China and Russian ties are more stronger than India 😂😂 Stop dreaming BS😂
@moonlighmax
@moonlighmax 2 года назад
@@kkkk25yearsago79 Lol....you really have no idea how geopolitics works. Russia have never taken China sides in all 5 to 6 Indo-China conflicts.
@kkkk25yearsago79
@kkkk25yearsago79 2 года назад
@@moonlighmax i have better understanding than your 3 frontal Japan,Russ,India vs China delusion war
@moonlighmax
@moonlighmax 2 года назад
@@kkkk25yearsago79 It's time to stop living delusional life.
@kkkk25yearsago79
@kkkk25yearsago79 2 года назад
@@moonlighmax yes we all should stop it
@davidlubkowski7175
@davidlubkowski7175 2 года назад
would only maybe be a thing if Indias relations with US worsen by a ton, even then its more of a enemy of my enemy is an ally thing
@user-op8fg3ny3j
@user-op8fg3ny3j 2 года назад
In this case both of India's allies are friend with their enemies: west with Pakistan and Russia with China
@somethinglikethat2176
@somethinglikethat2176 2 года назад
@@user-op8fg3ny3j Pakistan and the west have been moving apart. Pakistan is closer to China these days.
@kurousagi8155
@kurousagi8155 2 года назад
@@user-op8fg3ny3j Pakistan is hardly a western ally anymore.
@cosmos1246
@cosmos1246 2 года назад
It will happen if us keep the same attitude of supermacy.
@kumarvivek1866
@kumarvivek1866 2 года назад
Cut ties with Pakistan and take action against terrorist then india will be your forever ally.
@maximcozirev2680
@maximcozirev2680 2 года назад
India almost doubled the import of petrol this year, the tldr: India is leaning towards eu lol
@akp3097
@akp3097 2 года назад
We just don’t want china to buy all…🤣 we don’t want Chinese vessel state… we want that Russia must hv option… we will make sure of it even if it cost us West( except france)
@kanekiken2002
@kanekiken2002 2 года назад
5:30 Shared concerns about China ? Nah, Not much. The main reason was America who had attacked us with its 7th fleet to support Pakistan in 1971 war when we were kicking out Pakistanis from Bangladesh because they were doing genocide on Bangladeshis. Also it's the very reason today we are so reliant on Soviet/Russian military equipments because Nixon kept supporting semi authoritarian Pakistan and authoritarian China over democratic India again and again and again. You are not doing your research properly nowadays, some of the previous videos of yours had this poor research issue, please look into this.
@user-op8fg3ny3j
@user-op8fg3ny3j 2 года назад
"it may be dangerous to be America's enemy, but to be America's friend is fatal."
@kishorkoti2300
@kishorkoti2300 2 года назад
This channel is so ill informed on indian foreign policy ,india will never joined this so called imaginary triangle
@MrARock001
@MrARock001 2 года назад
India: "We bought all our hardware from Russia." Russia: "We equipped most of that hardware with substandard parts from China." China: "...would you believe...?"
@christopherg2347
@christopherg2347 2 года назад
Except all the high tech parts - which are from the west and their allies. Honestly, if India produces knockoffs and just gets the parts from the West directly, it can propably keep the vehicles - and still be better off then China and Russia. Plus, a lot of the fuckups are doctrinal in nature. Not sure if India has the same inability to allow combined arms warfare or NCO style decisionmakers.
@abps9947
@abps9947 2 года назад
But Russian weapons have better quality compared to Chinese
@christopherg2347
@christopherg2347 2 года назад
@@abps9947 If that is the *better* quality, I shudder about the worse one. Will they just explode when you use the ignition or what? India should try to get licenses with export allowance. They can propably build the T-14 quicker them Russia without the sanctions.
@drunkcat1713
@drunkcat1713 2 года назад
This is what shallow knowledge do to a person India always ALWAYS upgrades its russian weapons with western or indian subsystems Our su30mki r superior than their stock su30
@fromfareast3070
@fromfareast3070 2 года назад
@@christopherg2347 The Javelin can destroy all the existing tank with a single hit.
@ems7623
@ems7623 2 года назад
This is a deeply stange notion. India has been historically non-aligned. They are NOT having good relations with China. They are not entirely happy with Putin's Russia, but they seem to at least think they need to continue their relationship with Russia. They do have a somewhat nascent and relatively new relationship with the USA. In other words, they are trying to stretch out their historical neutrality as far as they can - possibly beyond when it realistically can be maintained.
@akp3097
@akp3097 2 года назад
We don’t trust USA… we will never go against Russia… Russia was there with guns in hand when USA was asking china to attack india from north and USA will attack from EASTERN coast and UK from WESTERN…
@jholotanbest2688
@jholotanbest2688 2 года назад
I hate geopolitics. It is a big game were human suffering and death are worthless compared to strategic goals. Why do humans have to be like this?
@fgqgqlfqsfsffeff
@fgqgqlfqsfsffeff 2 года назад
It's what we're used to, after ww2, Europe managed to move away from this line of thinking a bit and prevent starting wars with each other. Unfortunately it looks like Russia wants everyone to be as paranoid as them and build up our armies again.
@prateekdhingra292
@prateekdhingra292 2 года назад
@@fgqgqlfqsfsffeff ye, conveniently blame it all on Russia.
@prateekdhingra292
@prateekdhingra292 2 года назад
Geopolitics is tough. It shows how humans are animals that live in tribes. Favouring ones own tribe is considered more important than right or wrong. Sad truth about human psyche
@carlosvalerochavez3045
@carlosvalerochavez3045 2 года назад
As long as there is more than one person on the world, there would always be conflict
@BaljinderSingh-xy4ik
@BaljinderSingh-xy4ik 2 года назад
Yah it's like a chess game.
@kundansah6701
@kundansah6701 2 года назад
The guy is acting like whole west stopped purchasing russian oil and lectureing India for buying russian oil
@aryanyadav3690
@aryanyadav3690 2 года назад
Most confusing analysis ever 💯 First this guy needs to understand INDIA's foreign policy 🇮🇳 Currently PM Modi visited Germany, Nordic Summit & France (not China, Russia) 👍 Plz watch S Jaishankar boy 😂
@sosoable
@sosoable 2 года назад
A real big country will not go to other countries to beg
@skagraw2
@skagraw2 2 года назад
PM Modi had extended to join hands with China. Started Asian Bank also jointly but China is penny wise pound foolish. It rather chose to attack India and chose supporting terrorism through Pakistan and chose supporting breaking India forces.
@infinityz7134
@infinityz7134 2 года назад
This is the closest to a BRICS military alliance we have ever been.
@aiswaryabersan7983
@aiswaryabersan7983 2 года назад
Brics is an economic alliance not military
@ananddarnal6702
@ananddarnal6702 2 года назад
@@aiswaryabersan7983 🤦
@whaikuratuhaka7029
@whaikuratuhaka7029 2 года назад
Topical Anglo Saxon telling other nations to correct their shared values
@eliotanderson6554
@eliotanderson6554 2 года назад
We did condemn the butch a killing and we always said we r against the conflict
@s.m.1354
@s.m.1354 2 года назад
“The domestic Chinese trust evolution”
@eswarsunder8051
@eswarsunder8051 2 года назад
US is not a good friend but with similar values and Russia is a great friend but a psychopath.. Making India self sufficient is the better way forward. Just concentrate on our own problems, helping countries in need with medicine, food, etc and improving in the right direction. ....ohmmmm....
@Fiddling_while_Rome_burns
@Fiddling_while_Rome_burns 2 года назад
India has the right idea, America doesn't have long term allies just countries that are useful for it at the present and dumps a little while later. The US simply sees India as a country they could use against China, like Australia. India neutrality has worked since its creation look at Pakistan's western leaning, how's that working out.
@franekkkkk
@franekkkkk 2 года назад
„India helping countries” Yeah right… You left the Ukrainians to get murdered by your „great friend” Russia, which is equally reliable as the US. Indians with their delusional nationalism. Just like most americans.
@Fiddling_while_Rome_burns
@Fiddling_while_Rome_burns 2 года назад
@Red Bull that's the point you don't have similar interests against China if you join with the US you will have US interests against China and if they get what they want paid for with your blood and money they will then drop you and say screw your interests, that's what the US does
@Ashish-yo8ci
@Ashish-yo8ci 2 года назад
Indian and Chinese positions are strategically polar opposite with a lot of conflicting interests. It's one of those strained relations which just can't be reconciled easily. I still feel India will rightfully pivot towards the West. It makes both pragmatic and moral sense. Though idk what the Indian govt wants to do really.
@AG-vb6vv
@AG-vb6vv 2 года назад
BJP wants what’s best for India, we are moving towards the West while still honouring our long-standing relations with and goodwill towards Russia
@arcane3464
@arcane3464 2 года назад
India has two options 1: side with a country (USA) which has a history of abandoning ally and friends. 2: stay neutral as India did in the past. India should also learn the way china advanced and try to replicate it.
@anontheshade
@anontheshade 2 года назад
Ew. China is hot garbage, why mimic them? Collapsing housing market, lack of fresh water, dangerous population isses, pollution... India is doing so much better than China in so many ways. Western democracies aren't really unfaithful allies, they just have fluctuating politics due to high leadership turnover.
@kurousagi8155
@kurousagi8155 2 года назад
Russia has a history of being incapable of directly supporting allies and friends.
@kagenlim5271
@kagenlim5271 2 года назад
China has advanced solely because of opening up to the west, a.k.a the singapore model
@hmmmm6685
@hmmmm6685 2 года назад
It will need western support.without west export market(which china used) it is impossible.by chipping away china manufacturing capacity we can grow and calm china agressive behaviour.war isn't a smart option. West will get their currency expansion from us as with our forex reserve grow it will be good euro and dollar demand and western nation could use cheap loan on govt. bonds
@Hhhh22222-w
@Hhhh22222-w 2 года назад
@@kagenlim5271 no lol, you westaboos always credit yourself
@ameyas7726
@ameyas7726 2 года назад
*India does not share a border with Russia* and hence Indo-Russian trade is already physically limited...Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi has come to India multiple times proposing a Russian pipeline through China to deliver oil/gas to India, who hasn't shown any interest because everyone knows China can just turn off the tap in conflict times...Same goes for a pipeline/trade through Pakistan who already regularly blocks any Indian trade...The route through Iran is being explored, but American-Israeli sanctions has made this very difficult for India...Which just leave the old European trade route through Suez Canal for any Indo-Russian trade..
@sosoable
@sosoable 2 года назад
That's impossible. Indians should not spread rumors. China has no such proposal. The logic of why oil should be provided to India doesn't make sense.
@marcusaureliusanonymous
@marcusaureliusanonymous 2 года назад
India is restraint bcoz majority of its military hardware is of Soviet/ Russian Origin and India already had many wars with Pakistan as well as China. India will be strategic partner of China, the day Russia becomes strategic partner of USA 😂
@Republic_Unbowed
@Republic_Unbowed 2 года назад
Indian cooperation with Russia dates back to her independence.
@franciscoflamenco
@franciscoflamenco 2 года назад
Given that Russia, China, the US, Europe, and US allies like Japan, Canada and South Korea have already picked sides at the moment, India and to a lesser extent ASEAN are in an interesting position as possible kingmakers.
@starwarzchik112
@starwarzchik112 2 года назад
Turkey as well. It’s still up in the air which side they will be on. Personally I think Turkey might go Axis and India might go Allied, but idk.
@itsmederek1
@itsmederek1 2 года назад
@@starwarzchik112 Axis?? You trollin lol
@davidmoss2576
@davidmoss2576 2 года назад
If the Idians side with the Eastern bloc they would at least gain influence in its region and allowed to develop at it's own pace. If it sides with the West it gains absolutely nothing and its progress will be hindered by the US once it reach a certain point. The US has done it to Japan, and now it's doing it with China. It's pretty obvious if it can't stay neutral there is only one choice
@franciscoflamenco
@franciscoflamenco 2 года назад
@bruce parka What is your problem?
@gp-1542
@gp-1542 2 года назад
India and China Ooooh that’s gonna be a rough “relationship”
@loganlabbe9767
@loganlabbe9767 2 года назад
India is the most populous Democracy in the world. It is the natural ally of the west. Autocracies make and break alliances, the Nazis fought the Soviets, but it is exceptionally rare for one Democracy to make war on another.
@sosoable
@sosoable 2 года назад
Low caste countries are not allies. Both China, the United States and Russia are civilized societies where men and women are equal
@JraghajivaAsraka
@JraghajivaAsraka 2 года назад
This is not a simple unilateral relationship, but a global industrial and trade chain adjustment based on the Russian-Ukrainian conflict (I prefer to call it the delayed Soviet civil war). It is an opportunity for any developing country - China, India, Iran, Pakistan, Saudi Arabia, Turkey, even Egypt, Algeria, and friends from Latin America. In fact, the relationship between China, India and Russia actually includes - Pakistan, Afghanistan, Iran, Turkey. This intricate mix of diplomatic interests makes it impossible to achieve a stable alliance, but it does not prevent developing countries from choosing their own profit points in the Western recession brought about by this conflict. In the next era, Asia, Africa and Latin America should no longer be the low-level processing and production sites of Europe and North America. Final statement: China is obviously unwilling to alert its neighbor India when it is playing a game with the United States - this is obviously common sense, otherwise it can only be China's overreach. The direction China is currently dealing with is East Asia and Southeast Asia, and there may be overlapping areas of power projection in Southeast Asia and India. I think China and India should consider solving each other's boundary and power projection range. Arunachal Pradesh is unrealistic for China, and Aksai Chin is the same for India. As leaders of developing countries (we cannot ignore this fact), China and India should not hesitate in the grand strategic direction of breaking through the old Western system. It should not be too short-sighted to invest too much on the Himalayan issue. ما نحتاجه ليس تدمير المجتمعات الغربية ، بل العلاقات الدولية المتبادلة. في الوقت نفسه ، لا نحتاج إلى المعونات المتفوقة من العالم الغربي ، الأمر الذي يجعل الأمر أكثر إثارة للاشمئزاز.
@johnkennedy2068
@johnkennedy2068 2 года назад
Because of the economic crisis and the rate of unemployment, now is the best time to invest and make money 💯
@marshallshaw8528
@marshallshaw8528 2 года назад
You can say that again
@m3lo544
@m3lo544 2 года назад
Stocks are good but Crypto is better
@benthomas2327
@benthomas2327 2 года назад
It won't bother you if you trade with a professional like Mr Ronald Dickson
@terrencekirk4802
@terrencekirk4802 2 года назад
How do i contact Mr Ronald ?
@terrencekirk4802
@terrencekirk4802 2 года назад
Wow....Thanks for his contact info, I'll get to him right away
@MenwithHill
@MenwithHill 2 года назад
Uhm, India and China, in an alliance ? Sound like a nonstarter.
@mangopudding5979
@mangopudding5979 2 года назад
Indians and Chinese are future friends.
@crazydrifter13
@crazydrifter13 2 года назад
Holup. Indian public has nothing to do with what Russia is doing in Ukraine 😂 what part of neutrality didn't you get? We lean a bit towards Russia due to past behaviour of West towards us but china? I'd pass
@Sujal9253
@Sujal9253 2 года назад
Exactly and USA doesn't care about India at all US should realise that oil sanctions on Russia would cripple the global economy and potentially cause a global recession. India has to look for their self interest first we don't have 100s of billions to leave and run away from Afghanistan.
@jholotanbest2688
@jholotanbest2688 2 года назад
Geopolitically it is advantageous for India to stay neutral so you can't blame them. But morally it is like staying neutral in WW2, you are basically saying that Hitler was equally to blame as the Poles for the war.
@Sujal9253
@Sujal9253 2 года назад
@@jholotanbest2688 That's what America did didn't they until they go attacked by the Japanese they were neutral.
@jholotanbest2688
@jholotanbest2688 2 года назад
@@Sujal9253 Yep, and it was pretty sound policy for US back then. Countries don't do the right thing but instead what is the most adventitious.
@fgqgqlfqsfsffeff
@fgqgqlfqsfsffeff 2 года назад
@@Sujal9253 The USA were neutral in WW2 before their involvement, but condemned Nazi Germany for the war and was sending aid and support to the Allies. Not really comparable to India not condemning Russia for the war and not choosing sides.
@moonsun5263
@moonsun5263 2 года назад
India is just an insignificant role.from China
@realfangplays
@realfangplays 2 года назад
I would advise fellow Indians to watch the video and not to react instinctively against it. Its pretty fair and balanced.
@pennyfarthing7332
@pennyfarthing7332 2 года назад
preach king
@ukraineisnotrussia6810
@ukraineisnotrussia6810 2 года назад
@ABZ becuse of ur balencing act 3 of my relatives are in terrotorial defence and are in danger of being killed by shells , so thank u :) , and dont visit my Ukraine ur are not welcome here
@Siience...s
@Siience...s 2 года назад
Yeah as an Indian I agree with you
@user-op8fg3ny3j
@user-op8fg3ny3j 2 года назад
@@ukraineisnotrussia6810 their balancing is listening to arnab goswami
@SafavidAfsharid3197
@SafavidAfsharid3197 2 года назад
@@ukraineisnotrussia6810 yes we won't visit. Sorry that we value our own defence and people more then that of Ukraine.
@nicolaasgrobler6063
@nicolaasgrobler6063 2 года назад
Please do some research on South Africa our government have also been suspiciously quiet and we're part of BRICS on top of that
@nellym46664
@nellym46664 2 года назад
SA doesn't hold a candle to any of those countries. We have nothing to do with this war nor can we do anything of significance so its best to keep quiet and focus on our own issues.
@uddishbagri9055
@uddishbagri9055 2 года назад
while I agree with most points in this video I am just sick of hearing about Indias oil imports from russia we import just 2% of our oil needs from russia and most indian refineries cant even process russian crude oil since it is heavier in its composition than the oil from the gulf , I dont want to even talk about european energy imports from russia
@whitegoose2017
@whitegoose2017 2 года назад
No one wants to talk about European energy imports, because everyone in Europe now recognize that it was a strategic mistake to rely on Russian supply.
@user-op8fg3ny3j
@user-op8fg3ny3j 2 года назад
Neutrality is being killed as everyone is being forced to pick a side.
@premojha979
@premojha979 2 года назад
@@whitegoose2017 Yes sure. But here’s the thing it’s not like the Europeans didn’t know this was a possibility. The annexation of Crimea happened 8 years ago and thus European nations could have easily pivoted away from Russian energy. Europe is the sole party to blame for this but generally Europe gets far less flak then India does on the internet regarding oil imports. Understandably, on one hand people will argue that even if Europe uses more Russian oil imports in a day then India does in an entire month, it is making a conscious effort to reduce this reliance unlike India which is seeking to increase their imports. But here in lies the problem, which western countries fail to acknowledge. India is a much poorer nation. This conflict in Ukraine has caused global prices of oil to rise more and more. India cannot afford to miss out on the cheap Russian oil. I live in Britain so I’ll speak using the pound, but convert to whichever currency you find more appropriate. The fuel prices jumping 50 pence is not as much of a big deal to the British as much as a 50 rupee increase in petrol prices in India. Whilst the increase may be the same in this instance the effect of the increase is disproportionately higher in India. In a country where hundreds of millions live in abject poverty (more then the entire population of a lot of European nations I’m sure) its hard to tell them to cut back on Russian oil and buy much more expensive oil from the Middle East because of a war where they need to punish a long time ally for invading a country, that has vehemently been against India, in an entirely different continent. Not to mention this wouldn’t be the first time America has tried to flex and bully India into changing its oil imports. When Trump sanctioned Iran and broke away from the nuclear deal, India was strong armed into stopping oil imports from Iran since Iran also offered oil at cheaper rates then other Middle Eastern countries. This led to increased oil imports from other sources such as Russia, but even moreso the US themselves. The US directly made a profit as it sold the oil at a much higher price then what Iran was selling it. A similar playbook was attempted here but India rightfully stood their ground. India if it is an ally it needs to be treated as such. The condescending tone that I hear from western articles and journalists to India’s position reeks of some sort of superiority complex at times and clearly they fail to understand India’s geopolitical and security concerns. If the west wants India to be a counterbalance to China, it needs to also extend a hand towards India.
@Midgardian360
@Midgardian360 2 года назад
@@premojha979 As an Indian i completely agree
@RedLancerMoto
@RedLancerMoto 2 года назад
@@premojha979 You're completely right. European leaders were too caught up in their idealistic view of the world and now they're paying the price.
@rockysage7760
@rockysage7760 2 года назад
You should mention that EU still buys oil from Russia. Despite the war.
@juancarlosalonso5664
@juancarlosalonso5664 2 года назад
We’re quickly changing that reliance, we’re not sitting on our asses.
@_loss_
@_loss_ 2 года назад
Every country but Hungary has a phasing out plan and an embargo is being discussed.
@smit17xp
@smit17xp 2 года назад
@@juancarlosalonso5664 until you do, pls dont bitch us to stop buying less than our 2% oil from Russia
@georgeaird4637
@georgeaird4637 2 года назад
I don't think India and China would agree on any notion that they are part of a "Straregic Triangle' with their counterparts. They are direct competitors and have a very long ongoing rivalry.
@kirannnnnn
@kirannnnnn 2 года назад
Who knows by 2030, if china gives what India wants everything is possible.
@skalderman
@skalderman 2 года назад
It is realistically possible China will sweep all the stakes in coming years
@rainbowpaillettes8404
@rainbowpaillettes8404 2 года назад
No india is not strategically involved with china and is backing off from Russia
@editorrbr2107
@editorrbr2107 2 года назад
Lol. Absolutely not. Don’t misunderstand “having to tread carefully in a bad neighborhood and discount buying from a failing state” for “strategic alliance.”…And least of all with India’s geopolitical archrival
@sosoable
@sosoable 2 года назад
India will not be considered in the competition between China, the United States and Russia.
@ameyas7726
@ameyas7726 2 года назад
@@sosoable If India is so insignificant, why is US pissed off at India buying little oil, weapons etc from Russia...I mean you guys have everything Russian, Chinese under control right!!?
@sosoable
@sosoable 2 года назад
@@ameyas7726 India is the supporting role, while China, the United States and Russia are the protagonists. Americans are often angry about small things. We are used to it.
@DrVictorVasconcelos
@DrVictorVasconcelos 2 года назад
Didn't you just say that Russia-China relations are falling apart as Russia's sphere of influence is basically dying, and China distances itself from the Ukraine war/has nothing to gain from Russia? Also China has a massive diplomatic issue with India. They fight over land that has been Indian for forever but makes China a lot easier to invade. Chiina wants that land because it's a natural wall of protection, being mountaineous. India is also challanging China's hegemony in Asia, and has steadily absorbed millions of previously Chinese manufacturing jobs as China fails to keep its currency undervalued (which makes it more expensive for foreign companies). Finally, we shouldn't take India's and China's refusal to criticize the war as an alliance. The thing is that both countries have claims to disputed territory and they don't want to make it seem like they oppose regional imperialism, lest they make it seem like they're not willing to do the same for the territories they claim. These territories are not going to capitulate if they feel no real threat to them. Don't get me wrong, I'm not saying there's nothing there. The countries have been allied for decades, including through BRICS (which included Brazil and South Africa), but conditions have changed a lot. Indeed, countries make alliances with "enemies" all the time; and countries/city-states/kingdoms/empires have done so for as long as they have existed. During the actual WW, Russia and Japan had a pact. More recently, China itself is in a such situation with Taiwan; they're technically still at war, yet Taiwan depends on Chinese minerals, and China depends on Taiwan's microchips. But they're not at all alliances like the US might have with Canada, or Western Europe among themselves. They're, as you put it, strategic, but not at all a "friendship". Just like the USSR declared war against Japan as soon as the Europe war was won, theses countries may turn themselves against one another at any time. For this reason, these alliances are not very productive, and many times amount to nothing. Like China having backtracked their "without limits" friendship with Russia within months, as soon as Russia screwed up with Ukraine. So, I mean, you're not wrong that there's a strategic triangle, but I think it would be productive to add to the title that it's an uneasy and unstable alliance.
@silverbird425
@silverbird425 2 года назад
It's not a Triangle. It's an angle. China and India are not allied, and Russia's in the middle.
@rescuemeal-4262
@rescuemeal-4262 2 года назад
Please make a video on a future america - Iran and northkorea alliance 😭😭😭😭😭please make that
@Emanon...
@Emanon... 2 года назад
Shameless clickbait title. There is no "strategic triangle" between these countries. Especially after the pariah role of Russia on the global scene. I'm tired of conjecture disguised as journalism. Unsubbed. Good luck.
@frenchempire9471
@frenchempire9471 2 года назад
Got an ad about stopping business with china before this due to atrocious genocides and crackdowns on hong cong democracy and tiawanese and Tibetan independence refuses. I almost feel that it was targeted at me for clicking this video
@liamr194
@liamr194 2 года назад
Add Brazil to this list. They all want to break the monopoly of the dollar and want a new mutual trade relationship of energy, tech, food and military. Ukraine is a microcosm of those four trying to conquer the existing world order. China NEEDS Ukrainian food and fertiliser to survive and also NEEDS Russian oil and gas, all of which has collapsed with the war. If Russia fail in Ukraine, it will be seriously interesting to see how China respond. IMO they may look to exploit Russia's weakness and explore land acquisition in Siberia.
@harmonyshorts
@harmonyshorts 2 года назад
There exists a alliance called BRICS
@harmonyshorts
@harmonyshorts 2 года назад
Brazil Russia India China South africa
@pf6797
@pf6797 2 года назад
“An ever more temperamental US”…? At least this guy takes a shower, brushes his hair and doesn’t wear a sweat suit on cam.
@pandabear4565
@pandabear4565 2 года назад
I want to see india become a steadfast ally of the west, as their interests as well as the wests are mutual. China is surrounding india. Sri lanka is indebted to china. Pakistan, Nepal, Bhutan and Bangladesh are friends to China. They are surrounded geo poltically. And they could serve as a replacement to china with their vast low cost labor pool. They could become the worlds factory with some proper economic management. And undermine chinas economy and economic strength to the west. Why they chose this course of action makes no sense to me. Do they not see their geopolitical position?
@ayushnayak4060
@ayushnayak4060 2 года назад
bhutan is pro india actually lol. And nepal too had huge indian influence till 1990s cuz culturally it is india. For nepal the scenarios changed when communists from india help communists in nepal to overthrow the pro india monarchy. Of course all those communists were controlled by china. Bangladesh india relations are becoming quite big now cuz india surrounds bangladesh in almost all 3 sides and bangladeshi leadership is very keen to increase trade cuz the region has peace now and getting back to some sort of economic movement. Bangladesh geography compels it to lean more towards india but chinese money still surpasses it. As the region gains prosperity it is a given that bangladesh will not be anti india for sure. But Coming to the people yea the relations arent good lol. Well U r right its time for india to get its shit together but the economy the law and order :/.... idk if india will grab the opportunity. its foolish but immediate cessation of russian relations will deal a blow actually. It might take 5 or 8 more years to see the pro west india.
@aiswaryabersan7983
@aiswaryabersan7983 2 года назад
Because usa and it's allies loves dictator's not Democratic countries usa made china rich it won't want to see another powerful nation from asia
@pandabear4565
@pandabear4565 2 года назад
@@ayushnayak4060 what i would like to see happen is america launch another trade war on china. But this time with incentives for companies to move their factories from china to india. Sort of like a reverse tarriff for thos companies that do so. America could invest in india to end its relaince on chinese manufacturing.
@pandabear4565
@pandabear4565 2 года назад
@@ayushnayak4060 as far as i know about Bhutan. China has been building infrastructure along their border and withen Bhutan, and theyve been relativly silent about it.
@olainvisiblekatattisaafkrn5047
@olainvisiblekatattisaafkrn5047 2 года назад
@@pandabear4565 lol he's talking about bhutan taking side of India and not about projects being built by china along bhutan border ... I guess you are late to school kid ... Have fun there!🙂
@theanglo-lithuanian1768
@theanglo-lithuanian1768 2 года назад
Pakistan: "Yo, what the fuc-"
@CrocodileWhispers
@CrocodileWhispers 2 года назад
This might be the most unstable and volatile alliance in history
@kumarvivek1866
@kumarvivek1866 2 года назад
Look into past and present of the relationship between America, India and Pakistan. You will get the answer. America funded china and Pakistan to harm India and now when they are harming USA then you need India suddenly. Atleast Russian never harmed us.
@CrocodileWhispers
@CrocodileWhispers 2 года назад
@@kumarvivek1866 you're complaining about the US funding Pakistan but don't realize the huge amount of Muslims in Russian federation and how he uses them in his army. I know your hatred of Muslims is the only thing fueling your comment here so here's where russia stands on it lol
@starwarzchik112
@starwarzchik112 2 года назад
Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact would like a word. Jainshakar-Wang Pact perhaps?
@bijoylaha7245
@bijoylaha7245 3 месяца назад
Russia india China joinventer further
@SimonNZ6969
@SimonNZ6969 2 года назад
India becoming another Authoritarian state would be a bloody nightmare. Here's hoping India doesn't go down that path.
@osiris1309
@osiris1309 2 года назад
Despite what western media would have you believe, India still has a strong democracy and the current PM cannot strong arm the populace and get whatever he wants (in the current regime multiple bills have been shelved due to citizens opposing it). If his performance falters or the opposition produces a strong enough opponent to topple him, then the PM will be replaced by way of elections.
@krapto3467
@krapto3467 2 года назад
Highly unlikely, We've been close to that long before in the 70s and 80s under leaders like Indira Gandhi than now. I don't see India becoming autocratic,The Party in power can seem autocratic and even though i dislike their ideology,their ideology is what is actually popular in India as of now so most of what they do is backed by public support. It also seems this way mostly because India's current primary opposition party,the INC is in a massive decline and under a poor (dynastic and extremely old)leadership which has made it a largely incompetent force. It's likely the current opposition may divide once again like in the past and re emerge or other recently formed parties like the AAP may grow into a competent opposition by the end of this decade.
@Justme-to6yu
@Justme-to6yu 2 года назад
In a sense, i believe india is more democratic than US and even some euro countries.
@osiris1309
@osiris1309 2 года назад
@@krapto3467 agreed, India is choosing the lesser of the devils. India needs a strong opposition which is sadly absent atm.
@krapto3467
@krapto3467 2 года назад
@aisha Maybe,but that doesn't change the possibility that if the Congress doesn't reform,then the party most likely to become the opposition party,would very likely be the AAP in the 2030s. Most other parties like the DMK,AIADMK,TMC and Shiv Sena have no road map let alone potential for expansion beyond their home state. Just an observation seeing current political trends.
@starwarzchik112
@starwarzchik112 2 года назад
India-China alliance giving me Molotov-Ribbentrop vibes.
@michaelthomas5433
@michaelthomas5433 2 года назад
This "alliance" looks impressive on a map, like the old Austro-Hungarian empire, and would wind up being just as effective.
@mathskafunda4383
@mathskafunda4383 2 года назад
Now Now, don't be as cocky as Imperial Germany, or you'll end up like them....
@michaelthomas5433
@michaelthomas5433 2 года назад
@@mathskafunda4383 Imperial Germany was stupid but still beat down Imperial Russia. For what it's worth. Also I wasn't making a WWI reference, but an Astro-Hungary one in general.
@umbrellacorporation5723
@umbrellacorporation5723 2 года назад
How about US imperialism. After decades of Geno cide and Invading iraq , Syria, Yemen ( which ia still on going) , Libya ( USA literally created a slave market in libya) , Afghanistan, Vietnam, Serbia, Yugoslavia, Panama, Nicaragua. west is now concern about Human rights in Ukraine 😂🤣😜
@michaelthomas5433
@michaelthomas5433 2 года назад
@@umbrellacorporation5723 Bad bot. Read better dumb bot.
@debater452
@debater452 2 года назад
@@umbrellacorporation5723 This might be the dumbest claim I have ever seen
@_-_-_-TRESPASSER
@_-_-_-TRESPASSER Год назад
U said Arunachal Pradesh AREA ADMINISTRATED BY INDIA Actually IT IS INDIAN STATE V HAVE ELECTED REPRESENTATIVES ITS NOT LIK PAKISTAN OCCUPIED KASHMIR R CHINES OCCUPIED LADAK TERRITORIES Instead ADMINISTRATED area , say INDIAN STATE Y NOT SAY chines ADMINISTRATED Xinjiang, Tibet Y can say Pakistan occupied Kashmir Thy r the ones occupying others by force
@prakyathkumar8618
@prakyathkumar8618 2 года назад
Give 10-15 years, India will say good bye to the partnership with Russia
@sosoable
@sosoable 2 года назад
Ten years ago, India was as poor as it is today. Ten years later, India is also poor.
@Gop101
@Gop101 2 года назад
@@sosoable It's a middle income country you fool which time line are you from?? wake up 😴⏰
@sosoable
@sosoable 2 года назад
@@Gop101 For countries that burn corpses with wood, the middle income is India's falsified GDP data. India's poor earn only 5 rupees a day, and India's hunger index ranks first in the world.
@kimjong-un5570
@kimjong-un5570 2 года назад
@@sosoable lol we recently crossed Uk gdp, we were lot better than 10 years ago
@afterought6275
@afterought6275 2 года назад
Do a video on Serbia's stance on Russian war. It's becoming more and more interesting over the time.
@huwenkai440
@huwenkai440 2 года назад
In my opinion from a Chinese Kiwi view, Russia’s consistent push for India and China to cooperate reveal the depth of Russian failure to understand the deeper history of Asian nations’ frictions. You have to note that Russia only teaches history when it is favourable to Russia or her supposed friends. Most Russians are absurdly having no knowledge about Indo-Chinese conflict, nor even hostilities between Vietnam and China or even as far as South Korea vs China. Unlike Russia, China understands the art of politics and will not behave naively like Putin, China will never trust its neighbours wholeheartedly except Pakistan due to the past, at least unless Xi does something stupid.
@uzochiokeke4328
@uzochiokeke4328 2 года назад
china doesnt trust pakistan either and vice versa. Why do think CPEC is stalled right now? china has not released all the allocated funds to pakistan because of huge corruption among pakistani elites who are just pocketing all the money. pakistan may claim to be best friends with china but the truth is that the pakistani politicians and generals all have family or land in USA and UK, not china. So they are purposely delaying chinese projects in pakistan.
@oo--7714
@oo--7714 2 года назад
This sounds like fanfiction based off of reading a few news articles and a ton of comments.
@huwenkai440
@huwenkai440 2 года назад
@@uzochiokeke4328 Arts of politics is very complicated. China is a very old nation and it understands so well what it is doing. Not blaming, China is very calculus and it knows very well how Indians remain passionate toward Russia and how to break it. And China has all means, unlike India, to handle.
@Priya-cm3tr
@Priya-cm3tr 2 года назад
@@huwenkai440 China is an old nation? Are you comparing it to? India? It's the world's oldest surviving civilization. West has never understood India nor will it ever.
@huwenkai440
@huwenkai440 2 года назад
@@an4rchy_yt We are talking about India, China and Russia. We will let the discussion about Western government later.
@justcurious7505
@justcurious7505 2 года назад
Haahaha india is actually very diplomatic now....they are with everyone but not with any1 ....they are what america is ....they learn from america and do whatever is necessary within boundaries
Далее
Why China-India Relations Have Fallen to New Lows
8:39
Why Egypt’s Economy Is (Still) Deteriorating
10:37
Просмотров 79 тыс.
Men Vs Women Survive The Wilderness For $500,000
31:48
Why Putin Couldn't Invade Finland - TLDR News
7:38
Просмотров 2,3 млн
India and Sri Lanka's violent fight over fish
13:03
Просмотров 3,7 млн
Why Russia and China Have Quietly Fallen Out
8:48
Просмотров 557 тыс.
China wants to form its own military alliance
14:56
Просмотров 1,6 млн
Why Egypt and Somalia are Teaming Up Against Ethiopia
10:50