Тёмный

The Seventh Amendment at the Supreme Court 

Wall Street Journal Opinion
Подписаться 79 тыс.
Просмотров 54 тыс.
50% 1

The Justices rule 6-3 in SEC v. Jarkesy that it violates the Constitution's right to a trial by jury for the securities agency to try fraud cases in internal proceedings.
0:00 The Seventh Amendment at the Supreme Court
8:17 Commercial Break
8:30 Trials by Jury and the Administrative State
Subscribe to WSJ Opinion: bit.ly/3PovNsz
More from WSJ Opinion:
On site: www.wsj.com/news/opinion
On Twitter: / wsjopinion
On Facebook: / wsjopinion
#WSJOpinion #WSJ

Опубликовано:

 

3 июл 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 51   
@AgeofCraccadilliaassent
@AgeofCraccadilliaassent 6 дней назад
We need the fed reserve and maritime law ended. Unconstitutional
@tucups1809
@tucups1809 5 дней назад
What’s unconstitutional about it?
@lameetcalice3845
@lameetcalice3845 5 дней назад
"[...] the Constitution [...] has either authorized such a government as we have had, or has been powerless to prevent it. In either case it is unfit to exist." - Lysander Spooner (No Treason: Constitution of No Authority - 1867) Malum In Se/Malum Prohibitum Nothing moral requires authority. Authority is the claim to the exclusive exemption to morality. It is a monopoly on violence. Violence is a violation because it is the initiation of aggression, not self-defense. Offense/defense are ontologically distinct. All crime has a legal equivalent (ie, taxation is extortion). Every government is founded on Ad Baculum. Petitio Principii can and will be used against you. Warren v. District of Columbia Town of Castle Rock v. Gonzales DeShaney v. Winnebago County Lozito v. New York City You are legally compelled via the logical fallacies Ad Populum, Ad Baculum and Ad Verecundiam to pay for protection that they are not legally obligated to provide. That's a mafia. The highest Abrahamic value is Ignorance of Good and Evil. It's right there in Genesis. They worship Yaldabaoth, God of the Scapegoaters: God blames Man; Man blames Woman; Woman blames Serpent; Serpent blames God, more accurately - the Serpent defines God. God Condones Child Rape No.s 31: 17-18 God Condones Rape Deut. 22: 28-29 God Condones Abortion No.s 5: 11-31 Unquestioning Obedience to Government Rom.s 13: 1-7 Ritualistic classifying surgery as a means of psychic castration, like circumcision and sub-incision, are hallmarks of patriarchal culture, a demonstration to the young that the venerable old ones still wield the all-powerful knife - and the beginning of transsexualism. Those who do not perform the cult's rite can never enjoy full social status. Symbols of the castrated member, the tie and bow-tie, are mandatory accoutrements of the political wardrobe and phallic monuments are erected to commemorate the minds conquered long ago. Brute force is no longer necessary. The capitalist priest class of Psychiatry, working in tandem with the State bureaucracy, regulates and polices the new Restriction and gelding of desire. Psychiatrists, along with other legal arbiters, help to obscure justice with grey areas of intentionality, mental state, etc. Some mistake this as a system of Liberty, ignorant of the fact that Psychiatric Control is a cornerstone of the perfected Totalitarian State. All modern illnesses come from the absurd and tragic struggle of man's inability to bridle Nature. This dogma echoes perpetually, omnisciently by understanding voices in self-help books, billboards, radio commercials and television talk shows to convince the public to practice continual self-suppression and hormonal restraint. Any deviation is an indication of something severely wrong with the individual. Perhaps Lycanthropic Transformation Rites are in some way a Psychic Preparation for the millennial calamities that are thought to lie ahead. Legalism is a Language of Equivocations, a process of assimilation to violence and illogic. Etymology: government Gubernare: to control Mens/Mentis: mind culture Colere: to inhabit, to till Cult: collective mind -ure: process of civilize, etc. Civitas: city -ize: to do/to make like police, policy, politics, polite Polis: city authority Auctor: master, father, creator -ity: quality of religion Religare: to bind fast, to place an obligation on -ion: noun-forming suffix uniform Uni-: one Form: shape They lump themselves into a group. They want all the collective praise and none of the collective blame (No True Scotsman). If they were truly concerned for their reputation they wouldn’t wear a uniform. Badges are just snowflakes. "Everything is metamorphosed into its opposite to perpetuate itself in its expurgated form. All the powers, all the institutions speak of themselves through denial, in order to attempt, by simulating death, to escape their real death throes. [...] For example: it would be interesting to see whether the repressive apparatus would not react more violently to a simulated holdup than to a real holdup. Because the latter does nothing but disturb the order of things, the right to property, whereas the former attacks the reality principle itself." - Jean Baudrillard (Simulacra & Simulation - 1981) "Our rulers, who rule our symbols, and so rule a symbolic class of life, impose their own infantilism on our instituitions, educational methods, and doctrines. This leads to maladjustment of the incoming generations which, being born into, are forced to develop under the un-natural (for man) semantic conditions imposed on them. In turn, they produce leaders afflicted with the old animalistic limitations. The vicious circle is completed; it results in a general state of human un-sanity, reflected again in our instituitions. And so it goes, on and on." - Alfred Korzybski (Science and Sanity: An Introduction to Non-Aristotelian Systems and General Semantics - 1933) "I am a cosmopolitan." - Diogenes "If I could not be Alexander, I should wish to be Diogenes." - Alexander the Great "A man is no less a slave because he is allowed to choose a new master once in a term of years." - Lysander Spooner (No Treason: Constitution of No Authority - 1867) "It is incredible how as soon as a people become subject, it promptly falls into such complete forgetfulness of its freedom that it can hardly be roused to the point of regaining it, obeying so easily and willingly that one is led to say that this people has not so much lost its liberty as won its enslavement." - Étienne de la Boétie (Discours de la servitude volontaire ou le Contr'un - 1577) "Leadership in government is political power, and political power is an official form of antagonizing the people. Politics are rules imposed upon the people. They have every man in a straight jacket and without a passport he cannot move a toe. In a free world, they violate the natural rights of every citizen. They have become the weapons of political despots and if you don't think as they think you're deprived of your passport." - Michael Chaplin as Rupert Macabee (A King in New York - 1957) "Imagine, if you will, a world filled only with criminals of whom there are two classes: those too honest to rationalize their crimes and the powerful who scapegoat them." - Rod Serling "Eye have no Moral Obligation to ask permission from the person to whom Eye Morally Object if Eye may exercise mEye Moral Objection." - Unknown %\}%}\%{{*#|{*~|€}||#^||
@lameetcalice3845
@lameetcalice3845 5 дней назад
"[...] the Constitution [...] has either authorized such a government as we have had, or has been powerless to prevent it. In either case it is unfit to exist." - Lysander Spooner (No Treason: Constitution of No Authority - 1867)
@lameetcalice3845
@lameetcalice3845 5 дней назад
Malum In Se/Malum Prohibitum Nothing moral requires authority. Authority is the claim to the exclusive exemption to morality. It is a monopoly on violence. Violence is a violation because it is the initiation of aggression, not self-defense. Offense/defense are ontologically distinct. All crime has a legal equivalent (ie, taxation is extortion). Every government is founded on Ad Baculum. Petitio Principii can and will be used against you. Warren v. District of Columbia Town of Castle Rock v. Gonzales DeShaney v. Winnebago County Lozito v. New York City You are legally compelled via the logical fallacies Ad Populum, Ad Baculum and Ad Verecundiam to pay for protection that they are not legally obligated to provide. That's a mafia. The highest Abrahamic value is Ignorance of Good and Evil. It's right there in Genesis. They worship Yaldabaoth, God of the Scapegoaters: God blames Man; Man blames Woman; Woman blames Serpent; Serpent blames God, more accurately - the Serpent defines God. God Condones Child Rape No.s 31: 17-18 God Condones Rape Deut. 22: 28-29 God Condones Abortion No.s 5: 11-31 Unquestioning Obedience to Government Rom.s 13: 1-7 Ritualistic classifying surgery as a means of psychic castration, like circumcision and sub-incision, are hallmarks of patriarchal culture, a demonstration to the young that the venerable old ones still wield the all-powerful knife - and the beginning of transsexualism. Those who do not perform the cult's rite can never enjoy full social status. Symbols of the castrated member, the tie and bow-tie, are mandatory accoutrements of the political wardrobe and phallic monuments are erected to commemorate the minds conquered long ago. Brute force is no longer necessary. The capitalist priest class of Psychiatry, working in tandem with the State bureaucracy, regulates and polices the new Restriction and gelding of desire. Psychiatrists, along with other legal arbiters, help to obscure justice with grey areas of intentionality, mental state, etc. Some mistake this as a system of Liberty, ignorant of the fact that Psychiatric Control is a cornerstone of the perfected Totalitarian State. All modern illnesses come from the absurd and tragic struggle of man's inability to bridle Nature. This dogma echoes perpetually, omnisciently by understanding voices in self-help books, billboards, radio commercials and television talk shows to convince the public to practice continual self-suppression and hormonal restraint. Any deviation is an indication of something severely wrong with the individual. Perhaps Lycanthropic Transformation Rites are in some way a Psychic Preparation for the millennial calamities that are thought to lie ahead. Legalism is a Language of Equivocations, a process of assimilation to violence and illogic. Etymology: government Gubernare: to control Mens/Mentis: mind culture Colere: to inhabit, to till Cult: collective mind -ure: process of civilize, etc. Civitas: city -ize: to do/to make like police, policy, politics, polite Polis: city authority Auctor: master, father, creator -ity: quality of religion Religare: to bind fast, to place an obligation on -ion: noun-forming suffix uniform Uni-: one Form: shape They lump themselves into a group. They want all the collective praise and none of the collective blame (No True Scotsman). If they were truly concerned for their reputation they wouldn’t wear a uniform. Badges are just snowflakes. "Everything is metamorphosed into its opposite to perpetuate itself in its expurgated form. All the powers, all the institutions speak of themselves through denial, in order to attempt, by simulating death, to escape their real death throes. [...] For example: it would be interesting to see whether the repressive apparatus would not react more violently to a simulated holdup than to a real holdup. Because the latter does nothing but disturb the order of things, the right to property, whereas the former attacks the reality principle itself." - Jean Baudrillard (Simulacra & Simulation - 1981) "Our rulers, who rule our symbols, and so rule a symbolic class of life, impose their own infantilism on our instituitions, educational methods, and doctrines. This leads to maladjustment of the incoming generations which, being born into, are forced to develop under the un-natural (for man) semantic conditions imposed on them. In turn, they produce leaders afflicted with the old animalistic limitations. The vicious circle is completed; it results in a general state of human un-sanity, reflected again in our instituitions. And so it goes, on and on." - Alfred Korzybski (Science and Sanity: An Introduction to Non-Aristotelian Systems and General Semantics - 1933) "I am a cosmopolitan." - Diogenes "If I could not be Alexander, I should wish to be Diogenes." - Alexander the Great "A man is no less a slave because he is allowed to choose a new master once in a term of years." - Lysander Spooner (No Treason: Constitution of No Authority - 1867) "It is incredible how as soon as a people become subject, it promptly falls into such complete forgetfulness of its freedom that it can hardly be roused to the point of regaining it, obeying so easily and willingly that one is led to say that this people has not so much lost its liberty as won its enslavement." - Étienne de la Boétie (Discours de la servitude volontaire ou le Contr'un - 1577) "Leadership in government is political power, and political power is an official form of antagonizing the people. Politics are rules imposed upon the people. They have every man in a straight jacket and without a passport he cannot move a toe. In a free world, they violate the natural rights of every citizen. They have become the weapons of political despots and if you don't think as they think you're deprived of your passport." - Michael Chaplin as Rupert Macabee (A King in New York - 1957) "Imagine, if you will, a world filled only with criminals of whom there are two classes: those too honest to rationalize their crimes and the powerful who scapegoat them." - Rod Serling "Eye have no Moral Obligation to ask permission from the person to whom Eye Morally Object if Eye may exercise mEye Moral Objection." - Unknown ^{|^~|^\
@johnflynn-pk2mk
@johnflynn-pk2mk 2 дня назад
Here is my two cents worth to your comments. SCOTUS ruling "Cooper vs. Aaron 1958a.d. No Legislators, executives or judicial officer "Can War against the U.S. Constitution, if you just swore an Oath to support it!" When you take public government to court or you send a letter to your county supervisors (bullies) and they are legally served (no lawsuit from me). Public officers holding public office will back down! 2A--The battle of Athens Tennessee 1946. WW 2 veterans took on a crooked Sheriff Cantrill with their Second Amendments and won.
@stevekristoff4365
@stevekristoff4365 6 дней назад
Very good decision by the court here against the SEC. Would really go against the entire premise of the separation of powers of the branches of government otherwise and that would erode the rights of the citizenry against the 'state'.
@SubjectUSAY
@SubjectUSAY 6 дней назад
They threaten me everyway.
@BeleteAlemu-c5e
@BeleteAlemu-c5e 5 дней назад
​11¹1¹¹1½¹
@sislertx
@sislertx 5 дней назад
After they destroyed the first admendment..
@sethward5136
@sethward5136 5 дней назад
How
@janetprice85
@janetprice85 6 дней назад
Interesting when NY has cases that precludes jury trials in xome cases.
@oldogre5999
@oldogre5999 5 дней назад
You mean like certain Presidents?....
@mason96575
@mason96575 6 дней назад
Hey… some of us have epilepsy… you guys should really consider us 😢
@lowerself6689
@lowerself6689 6 дней назад
Yep!!!
@thomasmarchese2808
@thomasmarchese2808 5 дней назад
Why are you watching the screen. It’s just audio spike. Put the phone down and do something while you listen. Victim mentality.
@jesseyoung4295
@jesseyoung4295 День назад
Sounds like the supreme court got it right. If applied to an individual. The question still remains, what rights ought corporations, a nonhuman entity.
@chriswertz1438
@chriswertz1438 5 дней назад
sec is dirty
@safaazizi-lv6vf
@safaazizi-lv6vf 5 дней назад
❤❤
@FarahnazRyahi
@FarahnazRyahi 5 дней назад
🎉
@DemonaeTV
@DemonaeTV 6 дней назад
wow, migraine and epilepsy alert with the flashing bar would be nice
@lowerself6689
@lowerself6689 6 дней назад
Agreed!!!
@MFWb00bi3s
@MFWb00bi3s 5 дней назад
Wow, I mean WOW.... I can't BELIEVE this giant media conglomerate doesn't pander to my disease that affects less than .014% of the global population. Just WOW 😡
@Bullionking21
@Bullionking21 6 дней назад
Sure are a lot of supreme court decisions being overturned or altered during the debate.
@ATeaNTea
@ATeaNTea 5 дней назад
People stay in their lane 😂they come get you hunt you down and haggle you down and don’t even tell you they a judge and even 😂have the audacity to try repeat history from the 80s ❤
@pzaqy76412
@pzaqy76412 5 дней назад
President Jake Sullivan
@qalinlecilmi947
@qalinlecilmi947 5 дней назад
Cadaalada waxan ks dalbanayaa xoriyadayda diintayda doonistayda ogaada wixii kabadalan qaadan maayo
@SubjectUSAY
@SubjectUSAY 6 дней назад
So im beeing Punished over n over. And uneliagable to cause reason
@charlespotts3995
@charlespotts3995 5 дней назад
What?
@karenwarner3343
@karenwarner3343 6 дней назад
My father thought a lot about the WSJ but I am sad. Requiring that everyone who is policed by the SEC must have a trial will have the long term effect of being unable to hold these fraudsters accountable. They don’t have the funding for a full jury trial because Congress doesn’t allow them enough funding. The American people will have much less protection from these mega rich hedge fund managers. The SEC Of s one of the only ways these arrogant bastards can be held accountable. Please check out the other side, people.😢
@markg4459
@markg4459 6 дней назад
That's not the opinion of the court. Not even close. Did you even listen to the discussion? Starting an argument with a demonstrably false straw man is a poor way to attempt to influence opinion.
@iangantner6976
@iangantner6976 6 дней назад
Wow. That’s definitely a take. I’ll give you mine, EVERY US citizen has the right to a trial when accused of a crime. The Constitution did not create the SEC or an SEC court/tribunal. Their power, at most, should be limited to oversight and consultation on legislation, never enforcement. As another point, where do you suppose the money from SEC fines goes? The SEC keeps a substantial amount of those billions. If they don’t have money to operate on the fine income alone, they should be thoroughly vetted and possibly disbanded. I also have a question, why the hate of “mega rich hedge fund managers”? Why does someone’s wealth affront you so? Warren Buffet has been managing money for DECADES.. He is also documented as the single biggest donor to charity in the US (maybe in the world). Do you hate him because he “works on Wall Street?” Jim Simons ran a hedge fund. Also, huge philanthropist. We can skip Soros and Bloomberg, because they are very political, BUT they donate A LOT OF MONEY, whether you like where they allocate it or not. The narrative that everyone who is rich is evil doesn’t match reality, and there is nothing inherently evil about making your money managing money for others. In fact, when done well it’s a win/win proposition. Most people can’t name a single hedge fund manager who is defrauding people without looking it up first. Sam Bankman Fraud is a possible exception, but a lot don’t know his name either. You may have to go back to 2009, Bernie Madoff, to find a name that many have heard. Does that suggest that there are vast numbers of evil “hedge fund managers” stealing money?? It happens, for sure, but there isn’t a parade of felons stealing money from grandma on a daily basis. Certainly, not enough to justify the SEC becoming its own branch of government.
@lindacrowe8428
@lindacrowe8428 6 дней назад
At 77 this is the worst court in my lifetime.
@jimmaag4274
@jimmaag4274 6 дней назад
That makes me very happy
@markg4459
@markg4459 6 дней назад
Worst because why? You, presumably want congress deferring greater power to federal agencies and are pleased with federal agencies not being challenged by those pesky due process rights the courts are concerned about? I find that baffling but feel free to be disappointed.
@Archaically
@Archaically 6 дней назад
@@markg4459any uniform court is bad though. There’s a reason that the US originally had the vice president be the one who lost the election. The Supreme Court currently is majorly republican with a 6-3 ratio. Even as someone with republican beliefs it doesn’t make sense for a two party country to have such a heavy majority in its Supreme Court. US govt is for the people if someone as large as SCOTUS isn’t representing half the country well it is not a good court.
@escaped1534
@escaped1534 6 дней назад
​@@ArchaicallyBS! It was FDR that threatened to "pack the court" to get the ILLEGAL Social Security "forced gambling AND insurance" passed! Which both are UNCONSTITUTIONAL!!!
@WilliamOfficeSupply9832
@WilliamOfficeSupply9832 5 дней назад
The right wing humans in the U.S. has been destroying the U.S. Constitution since 2001 and the 1980's. Madam President Hillary Clinton Won The Popular Votes by Landslides in 2000, 2008 and 2016. Madam President Hillary Clinton forewarned the citizens since the 1990's with Her Husband, President Clinton.
@lorinelson5383
@lorinelson5383 6 дней назад
I don't trust the unSupreme Court
@isagoes6156
@isagoes6156 6 дней назад
Not going to waste my time with this crap. Already have a great book to read.
@Bangkok-ik1fp
@Bangkok-ik1fp 6 дней назад
Read - The Creatute from Jekyll Island for a good look at America
@addictivecode
@addictivecode 6 дней назад
I just finished that Tuttle twins book last night. I also recommend.
@jenniferpennington8031
@jenniferpennington8031 5 дней назад
❤ Trump 2024
Далее
The Democrats Breaking Ranks on Joe Biden's Age
14:46
Просмотров 3,2 тыс.
The Night That Sank Joe Biden
24:26
Просмотров 57 тыс.
The exact moment Biden lost the debate | About That
13:09
Supreme Court Signals that HUGE TROUBLE is Coming
15:13