The Story In Your Eyes - The Moody Blues | College Students' FIRST TIME REACTION! 

“Question” is a masterpiece. Worth a listen just for the acoustic guitar part. The middle section is just beautiful.

Surprised not to see "Tuesday Afternoon" specifically called-out for the next reaction. I would think that was the most played Moody Blues song back in the day after "Nights in White Satin."

This is absolutely one of the greatest bands of the 60's-80's. They produce melancholy, haunting, rockin' great music. Don't call them "Moody" or "Blues" for nothing. Rock on guys.

Hi there, guys next up for the Moody Blues has to be “Question”! It shows all aspects of the band. You need to hear this “S” tier song . I know you will agree. Don’t wear socks, this song will knock them off.

If my mother was still alive, she'd say, "Look at those two nice boys listening to my favorite song" 💙

"Ride My Seesaw" is another banger from the Moodies that you guys will appreciate.

Moody Blues aren’t a weekend trip, they are a lifelong journey. So many incredible songs. Over 50 years of music.

‘Isn’t Life Strange’ is a must, beautiful melody and production

Okay. Nobody will suggest this one, but it’s superb. “Watching and Waiting” from To Our Children’s Children’s Children. You will cry. It’s so wonderful. ✌️

"Question" is a signature Moody Blues song that has all the musical and lyrical elements that define their unique sound and appeal! Gotta hit it, you won't be disappointed!

I always recommend "Question"--just an incredibly stellar song.

Question was the first Moody Blues song I ever heard and still a favorite! Saw 'em twice in concert--once in the late 70s, and once in the mid-80s.

“Legend of a Mind,” a trippy song that could only have emerged in the late 60s. Great time capsule piece.

don't stop here guys! "Ride My See-saw" and "Question" would be great reactions.Also, killer full album reactions

"Ride My See-Saw" and "Question" are also necessary MB songs from that late-60s/early-70s period; they set-up the wonderful 1986 'come-back' song "In Your Wildest Dreams".

So many great classic songs by The Moody Blues. Timeless songs by a timeless band!💙

Big Moody Blues fan since 1967!! Awesome tune!!

Saw these guys in concert, mid 90s. They had the entire Boston Philharmonic orchestra touring with them. Absolutely phenomenal show!

More & more I realize what a treasure trove radio was in my youth.

You know, these guys didn't make records. They made albums. It's almost criminal to listen to their works in terms of single songs. But two of my favorites: "Never Comes the Day" for bopalong, singalong hippie love song, or if you want to go on a mini-space journey, "Have You Heard/The Voyage/Have You Heard," both from the phenomenal LP, "On the Threshold of a Dream."

“I’m not Geddy Lee, don’t rush me!” 🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻 Since I know “Tuesday Afternoon” is already on your radar, I’m going to recommend “Question” for another Moody Blues reaction. Loved this, guys!

My first Moody Blues album in 1971. With headphones I would listen to the whole album over and over. So Good!

“Question” needs to be next, then “Tuesday Afternoon”. Both are in my top 10 favorite Moody Blues tunes… By the way the title of the album we just listen to Every Good Boy Deserves Favor is one of the mnemonic devices you use for learning musical scales. EGBDF

The Moody Blues, were existential... The lyrics of pure poetry, on a mental journey. As you listen, focus on what is said. The meaning of the words, magnify the appreciation.

The easy way to deal with is - just react to every Moody Blues song we suggest. Next I recommend Question followed by Ride My SeeSaw followed by Tuesday Afternoon.

No mention of the mellotron which for this band ,especially on the first seven LPs,is like the icing on the cake,I hope you guys listen to many more of this iconic band…and enjoy!

"QUESTION" from their sixth album (1970)

Those seven albums were meant to be listened to in their entirety. They take you on a musical journey that no other group of musicians achieved. It helped (for me) being a young teenager when they came out. That is the golden age for learning.

Melancholy Man. A masterpiece!

Andy's right. Moody Blues songs grow on you more and more as you immerse yourself in their message plus the journey is an entire album - not just one song.

The hard thing about the Moody Blues is that their entire albums are great and they have so many great albums.

They have 2 great songs from 1980. Gemini Dream and The Voice. Incredible production

“FOREVER AUTUMN” by Moody Blues lead singer and guitarist Justin Hayward. You’ll find it on a killer album WAR OF THE WORLDS - which you should really consider for a full album review!

If you want a great bass line, inventive drumming, superb acoustic guitar and amazing vocals, you have to go with 'Question', there is no doubt about it. In addition to the aforementioned, you will also hear wonderful strings, a relaxing interlude and a real race to the end. Go for it , guys! You know you want to!

The Story In Your Eyes has been my favorite since since 1972 and the album is my favorite album of all time. Thank you for choosing this song.

A&A, Their "Question" and "The Voice" are next for you!!

Hey guys - you absolutely picked the right song amongst all the recommendations. Love this as much as I'm Just a Singer in a Rock and Roll Band. Next try a great 1981 comeback song, The Voice. A is a fine rating on first listen. Andy-you're right, the rating will go up over time.

alright you guys - here's a hidden Moody Blues gem from a stereo boomer - we audiophiles in 1971 used to play the hell out of "The Best Way To Travel" off of the album "In Search Of The Lost Chord" on headphones to get the whole effect of the stereo mix - this was always accompanied by consumption of substances from that era

My girlfriend in college had a few older brothers and sisters and as such I got exposed to so many great bands like Jethro Tull, The Moody Blues and others I might not have otherwise heard. This was the first band where I went out and bought all of their CDs with zero hesitation. Hours and hours of enjoyment and I'm still never tired of any of their works.

Departure/Ride My See Saw is a spoken word followed by a great song- 1967 classic

The "strings" in so many Moody Blues songs are actually a Mellotron, a primitive sampling keyboard which used analog tape to record different sounds. The Beatles used a Mellotron on "Strawberry Fields" and some other things. Moodys keyboard player Mike Pinder was their secret weapon. They were never the same after he left the band.

The most disrespected group in rock history. Late 60's, early 70's, getting high & or tripping while listening to an album was akin to a religious experience. About damn time. Need much more!

The Moody Blues are a band that often blends and fades one song into another. "The Story in Your Eyes" is actually the second cut off the 'Every Good Boy Deserves Favour' released in 1971. The opener is a prog masterpiece, "Procession," which is kind of apocalyptic in theme. The album is #6 of the MB "classic 7" records released from 1967-72. The Moodies had FIVE songwriters and 4 LEAD vocalists (depending upon the composer of the song itself)!! Most of the well-known songs were written and sung by the guitarist, Justin Hayward (yeah, the guy who sung "Nights in White Satin). 💙💙💙💙💙🎸🎤🎼

This is such a top tier band and they are as good live as they are in studio. All these old bands had to be good to compete in a serious rock market. That voice is perfect and that driving guitar and drums just adds that rock element to the outstanding harmonies. The bass snaps it all together into a perfect package. Thank you for this, at least an A+ for me.

I'd go with the song "Question". Back in HS when I didn't have much money to spend on music, I did find enough to buy the 45 (single) of it. So on the basis that I once put my money where my mouth is, I recommend it!

Question, Ride my SeeSaw, Gypsy. So many awesome songs by the sometimes criminally underated band!

As a Gen Xer, my first acquaintance with Moody Blues was probably their '86 single Your Wildest Dreams. I can still remember the MTV video. The 80s were weird, discovering 60s classic rock artists via their middle-aged 80s sellout phase.

It was definitely an A+ song on the radio back then, and it's still an A+ song today. You'll get there Andy.

The thing about the Moody Blues of this era, for a string of seven concept albums in a row each song is tucked between other songs that flow so well together that, at a minimum, an album side is the only way to absorb the full flavor of the sauce.

Question is another great Moody Blues. It's got some great lyrics and some great tempo changes.

You would love "Tuesday Afternoon" and "It's Up To You". And dan is right, "Question" is a fantastic song. I never really understood why The Moody Blues weren't more popular. They were such a leader in the progressive rock movement.

Gypsy, watching and waiting, Tuesday afternoon…all a vibe and transport you in their own ways. The Moody Blues are my all time favorite and I grew upon The Rolling Stones and Zeppelin, both bands I also love…there’s just something about Justin Hayward’s poetic songwriting and voice.

Let's hear it for The Voice, from an album after their classic seven. Truly a beautiful song.

One of my favorite MB tunes, but they had so many - one of the few bands I literally love every album of.

Alternate choice: "For My Lady" from Seventh Sojourn. It is one of the most beautiful songs not written by Justin Hayward.

So many great songs but when I'm in the mood for Moody Blues I listen to Tuesday Afternoon most often.

Question, is another. There's a 1970 video of them on French TV, that's cool.

Thank you for highlighting The Moody Blues, they have so much great music. Hopefully more people from your generation discover them with your help.

For me the Moody Blues were the perfect segway between the Beatles and Pink Floyd.

I fell in love with The Moddy Blues in 1971 when I first heard “Question” late at night on the radio. Their repertoire is massive and their music is moving both lyrically and musically. I had the pleasure of meeting Justin Heyward in the Detroit Airport (nonetheless…go figure) around 96-97 (forget exactly when). He was a gentleman of the highest order. The Moodies were NOT just singers in a rock and roll band. Their music moved millions. They perfected an entire genre of music…Transcendental Rock…I like to call it. They certainly got me to think beyond the bounds of the norms of the day.

Seems I remember the keyboardist created the Melotron for their sound. Sonic geniuses.

The thing about the Moody Blues is this. The older I get, the more I enjoy the music. The lyrics are intelligent, the music has depth.

I understand your viewpoint, and why you are rating it an A for now. Have another listen, the song WILL grow on you. Very atmospheric, and thought provoking. Instrumentation is stellar. You gotta do their album "Days Of Future Passed" on Patreon. NEXT? "Question".

The Moody Blues are among the gods of Rock n' Roll.....no one or band has there style!!! Just Legendary!!! I saw them in concert!!!! AWESOME!!!!!

One of my most favorite bands of all time. I was lucky enough to see them in concert twice. They are artistically soo deep, the more you listen to them the more addicted to their music you will become. I consider their music a marvelous journey!

You never can go wrong playing the Moody Blues. Been listening to this band since the 60s.

Gotta hear Question and Ride My Seasaw. Their music does something to me that no other band does. They take me to a magical place. Oh yeah Forever Autumn is great as well.

Listen live…they are truly atmospheric in concert. Especially this song.

Great youv'e gettin'back to the moodies, but "Question" is their most famous song after "nights in white satin" and better!! Please do "question" next, it is from 1970 and was connected to how American youth was feeling about the Vietnam War!!

For an "atmosphere" song, "Melancholy Man" is the all time grand prizer!

Question should be next. One of my deep cut album favorites by them is also from "Question Of Balance" , the song " It's Up To You ". Anybody else like that one?

"Question" from the 1970 album A Question of Balance.

For me, The Moody Blues have the haunt factor in spades. I recommend: Tuesday Afternoon, Ride My See Saw, The Actor, A Simple Game, Lovely To See You, Dear Diary, Eyes Of A Child, Watching And Waiting, Question, And The Tide Rushes In, Melancholy Man, For My Lady, and Isn't Life Strange...all stone classics!

No one disliked the Moody Blues when I was growing up as a youth. They were universally admired and loved by all, including most other artists.

'Question' seems to be the overwhelming favorite, and there are a LOT you can't go wrong with. I'll throw one out there that's definitely one of their very best - 'You And Me'. It has an awesome intro and outro and the 'main song' is great as well. A great song off the last of the 'first seven' albums by them - their first album was the original incarnation of the band and was quite different. Justin Hayward and John Lodge replaced Denny Laine (who went on to be a member of Wings for their first several albums) and Clint Warwick in late 1966. They were originally a cover band more or less. playing the mid 60's, English version of R & B. With Hayward joining and Mike Pinder taking up the mellotron they became a completely different band. Whenever you hear 'horns' or 'strings' it's Pinder's mellotron (Days Of Future Passed had an orchestra playing music that was mostly in between their actual songs). The mellotron gave them a really unique sound and helped make them who they were. 'You And Me' - check it out!

You’re exactly right. I guarantee you this will be an A+ for you soon. I’ve been listening to this album for 40 years and it’s now Top 15 all time for me.

Graeme Edge, Ray Thomas, Mike Pinder, John Lodge, Justin Hayward (Most underrated guitarist) = the Moody Blues. I've been listening for 50 years and never get tired. You need to do "Legend of a Mind" I've been requesting it for a while. Hopefully the video version. Thanks for getting back to them😊🎵🎶🎵

I love the Moody Blues 💙 a sound that is completely their own. Pure genius 👍

Next up: "The Voice". Still sounds just soooo good.

"Question". Without question.

Yes! Finally getting back to the Moody Blues. Love these guys. I again remind you their Classic Seven albums are meant to be listened to front to back. Not all as conceptual as Days of Future Passed, but all have a noticeable theme. And they do vary styles, as each of them contributes lyrics and aings.

"I'm Just A Singer In A Rock and Roll Band" Pleeeease! Everything they've ever done is great, but I think you'll enjoy that one. I saw them in concert about 20 yrs ago, and they sounded the same as they did in the 70's.

Just a fine damn album! I've spent a lot of time with this one over the years, although not much lately. I must get reacquainted! You know you've got something when you have an oboe and cello player in your band! One of the absolute trippiest bands of all time!

Tuesday Afternoon, 4 songs in one. Must hear. It is like a full day in sections.

Question, Tuesday Afternoon more iconic Moody songs

"You Can Never Go Home" is another great one. Since nobody else is mentioning it, listen to it on your own...😉

I would do “Question” next

Andy's first impression is correct: this is an "A+" song...easy.

Pleasantly surprised to revisit this. I don’t remember it being such a banger!

“In your wildest dreams”is a must

Always a good day for this group. You guys really need to react to “Legend of a Mind.” With the Moody Blues, a full album reaction is definitely in order.

Grew up in the 80s, the song I heard the most on the radio by far, from them, was Ride My Seesaw. This song takes a very Queens of the Stoneage turn at the midpoint.

Highly recommend On The Threshold of a Dream from first song to last…classic

"GO NOW" quick single banger. Clear. Catchy. Everyone loves it.

"Legend Of A Mind" takes you on a psychedelic trip. One of their best album tracks.

There are a few requests for "Question". I concur. It's a majestic song!

Solid A+ for me bordering on S. Love that guitar tone, lyrics, atmosphere and melody.

This album and "to our children's children's children" are both classics, any tracks off these send me into nostalgia overload as my dad has both these on vinyl and played them all the time...

“Ride my see-saw” and “Question” are a must listen! Great seeing you guys diving into the Moodys! Most don’t react to anything other than Nights in White Satin.

So many good songs to choose from! My personal favorite is "The Voice."