Pretty solid list. I personally prefer St Anger to either Load (at least the songs are aggressive and not more radio rock.) And I’d switch the black album and Death Magnetic. But that’s me, your list is totally legit.
My Top: 1- Kill Em All Favorite: Seek & Destroy & The 4 Horsemen Underrated: Metal Militia & No Remorse Weak Song (for me): Hit The Lights 2- Ride The Lightning Favorite: Creeping Death & Fight Fire with Fire Underrated: Trapped Under Ice Weak Song + i hate: Escape 3- Master of Puppets Favorite: Battery Underrated: Damage Inc Weak Song: N/A 4- And Justice For All Favorite: Blackened & And Justice For All Underrated: To Live Is To Die Weak Song: N/A 5- Metallica (Black Album) Favorite: Enter Sandman, Wherever I May Roam, Of Wolf and Man, The God That Failed, My Friend of Misery & Nothing Else Matters Underrated: The God That Failed & My Friend of Misery Weak Song: Don't Tread On Me 6- Load Favorite: King Nothing, Until It Sleeps & The Outlaw Torn Underrated: The Outlaw Torn Weak Song & Bad Song: Poor Twisted Me & Thorn Within 7- Reload Favorite: The Unforgiven 2 Underrated: Fixxxer Weak & Bad song: Slither 8- Garage Inc. Favorite Song: Mercyful Fate (Medley) & Turn the Page Underrated: Mercyful Fate Weak Song: The More I See 9- St. Anger Favorite: Frantic Underrated: My Sweet Amber Bad song: Purifty & Shoot Me Again 10- Death Magnetic Favorite: All Nightmare Long Underrated: The Unforgiven 3 Weak Song: The Judas Kiss 11- Hardwired Favorite: Spit Out The Bone Underrated: Atlas Rise & Halo On Fire Bad song: Manukind & Am I Savage? 12- 72 Seasons Favorite: 72 Seasons & Inamorata Underrated: Inamorata Bad Song: Screaming S**
To be fair it's almost impossible to pick a "worst song" on Master of Puppets. Gun to head if I had to pick a worst song on MoP it would be between Disposable Heroes and Damage Inc. Don't get me wrong they are still great songs. Just the others are stronger IMO.
@midknightfalconfan Yeah, you're definitely right. MoP was the height of their career, and every single song on that track is a frigging banger. I would definitely agree with disposable heroes or damage Inc.
I might be a little bias considering I gained consciousness and grew up with my dad playing death magnetic, but man I think that album deserves so much more love. And Judas kiss is criminallyyyyy underrated, same with Kirk’s solo. That and Unforgiven III he really put out for the album. Some like end of the line and just your life solos I can live without, but man there’s some gems on that thing
Com certeza o melhor vídeo de ranking de álbuns do Metallica, eu só discordo sobre Metal Militia, pra mim é uma faixa bem legal e épica, mas isso não tira o crédito do vídeo
Are the song pieces you used on AJFA remixes? I can actually hear the bass. Edit: Why does everyone not like Don’t Tread on Me? I honestly love that song. The riff KILLS.
My personal ranking Kill Em All' - Least Favourite: Hit The Lights | Favourite: Phantom Lord Ride The Lightning - Least Favourite: Escape | Favourite: Fight Fire With Fire Master Of Puppets - Least Favourite: Battery (hot take) | Favourite: Damage Inc. ...And Justice For All - Least Favourite: Harvester Of Sorrow | Favourite: To Live Is To Die Black Album - Least Favourite: Don't Tread On Me | Favourite: Wherever I May Roam Load - Worst: Cure | Favourite: Bleeding Me ReLoad - Worst: Slither | Favourite: Fixxxer / Where The Wild Things Are / Unforgiven II (its really hard for me to decide) Garage Inc. - Least Favourite: The Small Hours | Favourite: Whiskey In The Jar St. Anger - Worst: My World | Favourite: The Unnamed Feeling Death Magnetic - Least Favourite: The Judas Kiss | Favourite: Suicide & Redemption / Cyanide Hardwired... To Self-Destruct - Least Favourite: Murder One | Favourite: Spit Out The Bone 72 Seasons - Least Favourite - Sleepwalk My Life Away | Favourite: 72 Seasons / Chasing Light
7:30 So I listen on Amazon music and it is perfectly fine for my ears, I definitely dont like the production but its not unlistenable, anyone else like this??
I am pretty sure that on the streaming services they don’t use the original master. I think a couple years after the release of this album, even iTunes did their own remaster since it sounded so bad. If you listen to the CD version it sounds way worse.
@@Ryu_Ake ranking the songs on ride the lightning putting it at number 7 considering it’s one of the best metal intros of all time and has an amazing guitar riff, that’s just my opinion though I guess
2:11, 4:23, 9:12 💯 Also all the people are calling this not a good list are trippin. Its opinions. Almost every list is a good list. There are just things that people disagree with and that will always happen
my ranking of the metallica albums i heard so far including my personal favorites and least favorites with ratings and why (i will uptade this) 1. self titled/the black album (i did not expect this to be my favorite metallica album honestly but here i am) favorite: wherever i may roam (the ending harmonies is my favorite part of this song everything else is also great same with the intro) least favorite: sad but true (despite what people say it is not the heaviest thing mankind has ever witnesed also ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-83aFdBaVAeE.html) 2. master of puppets (it had a good run i being my favorite metallica album but my don't get me wrong it's still awesome) favorite: welcome home (sanitarium) (i changed my mind the harmonies are so good in my opinion it has better harmonies than room of mirrors) least favorite: master of puppets (has grown on me but ) 3. ride the lightning (overrated as hell not saying it's bad it's just not the greatest thing created) favorite: ride the lightning (kirk's best solo hands down and one of dave's best riffs here ktulu used to be my favorite it's close though) least favorite: escape (yeah it's just... meh) 4. and justice for all (would have been their best album if it wasn't for the loud guitars and drums there's still bass but the rest is just too loud to hear) favorite: blackened (the best opening the band created and that god damn fill frayed ends of sanity has a better fill though) least favorite: the shortest straw (just weak compared to the rest) 5. kill 'em all (dave mustaine wrote some killer riffs here but the black album's production and the fact my favorite song is there makes me put this lower) favorite: no remorse (one riff inspired an entire video game which would later become a meme) least favorite: metal militia (pretty messy and confusing but still good) 6. hardwired... to self destruct (my favorite of their three modern albums) favorite: hardwired (this lords of summer and spit out the bone are my favorites but i prefer hardwired more) least favorite: am i savage (the only bad part about this in my opinion is the riff with the harmonics it just doesn't click for me the rest is good) = 7. death magnetic (the only thing keeping this from being my favorite of the three modern albums is the mixing but it's still awesome) favorite: that was just your life (it kinda reminds me of blackened and the riff reminds me of jump in the fire i don't know why) least favorite: end of the line (definitely grown on me alot) =7. 72 seasons (honestly their latest is not that bad to be honest but i think it's the worst of their three latest albums) favorite: inamorata (absolute masterpiece chasing light is a really close second) least favorite: if darkness had a son (kinda grown on me a bit but still weak) 9. load (really underrated album the only reason this is above reload it's because the hidden gems here are in my opinion better) favorite: the outlaw torn (i do not care if it's long it's a masterpiece and the pre-chorus is my favorite part absolute masterpiece) least favorite: poor twisted me (2 x 4 is a better blues song than this) 10. reload (like i said there are better hidden gems in load and overall this album is really good and really underrated) favorite: the unforgiven II (brazillian freaking supremancy) least favorite: slither (very generic, boring, badly made and just terrible overall) 11. st anger (i forgot to add st anger and uhhh yeah it's definitely their worst studio album still got some decent songs but the mixing is garbage) favorite: sweet amber (awesome breakdown and solid overrall for the album but not for metallica st anger is a close second) least favorite: purify (garbage lit it on fire burn it down to hell this is a disasterpiece it makes me want to puke) honorable mention: garage inc. (i will listen to this later on but i'll leave it here as a mention until it gets to the list i will also seperate it from the 2 discs) favorite of disc 1: whiskey in the jar (i am not irish this is a god damn vibe) least favorite from disc 1: die die my darling (it's not bad it's just weak compared to most i listened so far) favorite from disc 2: breadfan (didn't last long killing time got old but that riff is still awesome but yeah just breadfan am i evil is a close second) least favorite from disc 2: blitzkrieg (same thing as die die my darling not bad but weak compared to the rest) editing notes: IM NOT INCLUDING LULU THE MEME SPEAKS FOR ITSELF 72 seasons is tied with death magnetic because despite how good death magnetic is the mixing ruins it and 72 seasons has if darkness had a son
I do not like Of Wolf And Man. Easily my weakest choice from Black. I’m currently listening to all of Metallica’s studio albums and ranking the songs as I go. So far the only entries in S tier are One, Battery, Dyers Eve, Master of Puppets, and Unforgiven 3. So far Master and Justice are my 2 highest ranked albums, they have the most songs rated 9 or higher for me. 3rd and 4th so far are Death Magnetic and Black album. I like them both a lot but the quality is more sporadic on both imo. RTL is 5th and Load is 6th. I’ve yet to fully hear KEA, Reload, StAnger, Hardwired B-side, and 72Szns so definitely more to come
Justice>MOP in my opinion and I’ll tell you why. Justice was the peak of practically every member’s musical ability and creativity with their instruments, including unique song structure and the fricken pissed off attitude you can just feel. People tend to overlook Justice for a few pretty valid reasons but if you can get past the lack of bass, no Cliff, and the weird proggy elements it’s simply their best album. Also blackened is my favorite song as well.
@@Ryu_Ake yeah I totally get it, the mixing was pretty shit compared to the rest of the albums, It’s just something you have to get past to really appreciate it.
2:40 In addition to snare and bass, the ticking on the kick drum really bothers me. Not many albums have much of a worse tick Also you were using bass remixes right? Bass is very easy to hear inbthis
Honestly i dont know why those types of "real fans" hate everything after the black album so much like yeah load and reload have bad songs but they also have great ones
That breakdown riff is absolutely nuts on that song. But overall I’d agree that Halo on fire is the most overall underrated song. But his take on ManUnkind is shit. Very solid and underrated song.
I disagree with Room of Mirrors being underrated, thats all I hear people talk and post about from this album. I'd regard it as overrated in my opinion. The vocals are great but that's all for me. I find it super cheesy especially the music video for it, and also a bit generic. But thats just my humble opinion. But yet again I also think magnetic is miles better then the last 2 albums. If only it had the production they have now 😢
I watched a series of videos a couple years ago of becometheknight where he did 10 days of 10 of the worst Metallica songs. Poor twisted me was also on his list. And I absolutely fcking agree with it.
Sweet Amber is the most liked song on the album. It’s not underrated compared to anything else on that album (you probably only chose it because the underground ones deserve to be underground)
Bro thinks If Darkness Had a Son is too long, yet it's not even the longest song on the album. 💀 Bro likes Inamorata, but that's the longest on the album. 💀
Inomorata may be 11 minutes but has variety and is listenable all the way through. And has one of the best harmonies metallica has ever done. Also to many it feels like a closer of a trilogy to My friend of Misery and Fixxxer.
