The Warning - Disciple REACTION & REVIEW! FIRST TIME HEARING!

Подписаться 51 тыс.

Просмотров 13 тыс.

50% 1

The Warning Fans.....FEELIN' YOU!!! Tonight we're coming back to The Warning, with a song entitled "Disciple". How's this one gonna go? Only one way to find out...
Come on in, enjoy the show...I'll see you inside.
Scoring System Guide
10 = Perfection (Unobtainable)
9.0 - 9.9 = Awesome, Amazing
8.0 - 8.9 = Great
7.0 - 7.9 = Really Good
6.0 - 6.9 = Pretty Good
5.0 - 5.9 = O.k.
4.0 - 4.9 = Not So Good
3.0 - 3.9 = Pretty Bad
2.0 - 2.9 = Really Bad
1.0 - 1.9 = Horrible, Awful
0.0 - 0.9 = A Travesty, An Affront To Nature
Link to Original Video Here:
• The Warning - DISCIPLE
My Patreon Page, where you can MAKE REQUESTS (As a Bronze Tier Member or higher) as well as view ALL the videos I try to post that RU-vid is forced to block, can be found here: www.patreon.com/user?u=44053979
(Please note, you must be at least a Bronze Tier Member to be able to make fresh requests. All requests must be made on the Patreon page.)
My Twitter: / bassist4aw
My Instagram (I've just started learning how to use it): / davidheretic666
Our P.O. Box (yeah, we listened to you all and we got one):
P.O.Box #355
19360 Rinaldi St
Porter Ranch, CA. 91326
Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use. No copyright infringement intended. I have no intent on claiming this music for my own, I'm simply reacting to the video and giving my constructive criticism and feedback. ALL RIGHTS BELONG TO THEIR RESPECTIVE OWNERS

Развлечения

Опубликовано:

19 дек 2021

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 199

@ellaevansbolt 2 года назад

David, reactors are a dime a dozen. Then there's you! Your insight, technical knowledge and ability to dissect a song and then explain what you are hearing to your audience is second to none! You make your listener go back to a song that they have maybe heard many times and really LISTEN to it again. Thank you!

@THEDavidHeretic 2 года назад

FEELIN' YOU John!!! Thank you for the kind words, I really appreciate them. I'm glad you're enjoying the show, more great stuff coming soon.

@bradleyp3655 2 года назад

One reactor described Ale's on stage presence as a snake charmer.

@RandyTWA 2 года назад

Great reaction David! Speaking of their record deal, Lava was blown away that the negotiations took 7 months to hammer out. The girls and their team stood firm on two major points, 100% creative control and keeping their Patreon site. BTW, that is Pau singing the second verse, saw it live at Rockville last month.

@thancrow 2 года назад

I saw an interview with The Warning and the production team. The producer told them he didn't like one of the songs and they surrounded him and argued with him in Spanish. He gave in to them.

@Captain_Kirk116 2 года назад

The Warning Army jokingly refers to this song as Numberly Garfs cuz Dany thought that's what Pau was saying instead of nonbelievers when they were tracking the vocals lol! I'm going to the Mayday tour show in Pittsburgh, which will also be Pau's 20th b-day, so I'm stoked for that!

@christopherscottdempwolf5759 2 года назад

I can't unhear that now. Every time 🤣

@gmespia 2 года назад

I don't know why TW videos don't have millions of views, they're fantastic.

@aaronleesgbclieutenant 2 года назад

MAN I CANNOT WAIT for you to get to Animosity. And Z. Alé and her bass really shine on this LP. I have a really good feeling one of these two is going to be your new favorite.

@michaelcgn1090 2 года назад

I second that. "Animosity" is also for me the way better song with a lot of catchiness and surprises in. Unfortunately there is no good footage of a LIVE performance out on YT at the moment, which can prove our (subjective) statement. The official video is an Anime "only", but of highest artistic creativity (highly recommended to watch!) and the copy from their Daytona Festival performance is of poor sound quality - not only from the recording. The latter is not fun to "listen" but only to "watch" Dany, Pau and Little Geenie acting on a bigger stage. So probably, David, you should wait until we see better LIVE footage of "Animosity" here on YT from their upcoming US Tour starting in January. Probably you will attend to one of their shows, but if so, you cannot state with good conscience any longer, not to know or to remember this song. YOU WILL, because it is soo outstanding......... And as "Disciple" is a 9.3, how will you give justice to "Animosity" then?

@bigfan007 2 года назад

Animosity is the most sonically interesting track on their Mayday EP, IMHO.

@aaronleesgbclieutenant 2 года назад

@@bigfan007 agreed

@christopherscottdempwolf5759 2 года назад

Sometimes I wonder if Ale secretly controls everything 🤔

@leekovalskyj9218 3 месяца назад

@@christopherscottdempwolf5759 Time-wise she does. Ale's the human metronome.

@davidmoreno7873 2 года назад

Pau once said that Ale has a built-in metronome in her head. If she ever feels off she looks to Ale.

@professorg9424 2 года назад

I like Evolve because it's just good old in-your-face rock. This song is probably more interesting, but Animosity is absolutely stuck in my head. Of course, this one gets extra points just for having Ale say: "2, 3, GO!"

@agustinmanyari 2 года назад

😁🤘🏻

@LaredoIsntSoBad 2 года назад

I honestly think the ending fit the song very well. It was like the band saying they've had enough. "You shall remain, inside your space...of IGNORANCE!" Like saying we already warned you, do what you want then, end of story! :) It was very abrupt and unexpected but it fit the whole message of the song perfectly. Just my 2 cents worth!...No, no, I don't care! Its my opinion....if I wanna say it ill say it. :) Great reaction nonetheless as usual Dave!

@TheUnderdogDe 2 года назад

I saw what you did there! 😄

@aaronleesgbclieutenant 2 года назад

And yes that is Pau singing the second verse

@Transgressorassessor 2 года назад

2 3 GO!

@torresilk4277 2 года назад

I believe David Bendeth encouraged Dany with her vocal when they were in the studio. Dany was 20 when they recorded. Looking forward to seeing Kelli reaction 😁 I’m sure they’ll do the whole Mayday EP over the course of their gigs on the tour.

@NoSmokingDogs 2 года назад

Hoping they'll also do the new Enter Sandman. I'll see for myself on Feb 2.

@AntonioGraell 2 года назад

You've been waiting hehehe, but it's never too late to listen to your analysis ;) thank you very much ;) I agree with what you said about doing the three choruses with variations, as for the way the song ends... I think it's very brave of them, but after listening to it a few times and looking at the lyrics I realised that it makes all the sense in the world. The phrase he says the previous times is "You shall remain Inside your space" but on this last occasion the phrase is "You shall remain Inside your space of ignorance" and it's just when he says "Ignorance" where it cuts out all at once. For me it's like giving us a slap in the face so that we come out of our ostracism and start to think and reason for ourselves instead of believing everything we read on social networks. The three of them keep proving that they haven't got to where they are for free, they have done it through hard work as you have said, even if many people find it hard to recognise ;) By the way, the one who sings the second verse really is Pau ;) Greetings from Spain ;) (Translated automatically by software)

@johndreessen7335 2 года назад

Good reaction. Pau-erfull 😉 song. Certainly worth your score. Well composed. Great video. My favorite song of them at this moment. Just above “Evolve”. Love this band. They getting better and better. Thank you for this reaction.

@terrahawk1977 2 года назад

Finally 👍👍and u named me 😂😂😂 cheers David h

@bradleyp3655 2 года назад

If you want a guitar solo I would recommend the official audio of Z.

@ClavisRa 2 года назад

Funny how incredibly natural the ending sounds to me now, makes so much sense. But I love how every reactor is surprised by it, brings me joy! Trust me when I say, after you spend some time with this you wont another note added to the end. 😂

@ethernityfire3786 2 года назад

They're masters at writing a two or three second part that grabs your attention. In this song the music stops and Pau sings "disciple in the making" in "when I'm alone," at the end of the first chorus Dany sings "When I'm Alone," without instrumentation but after the end of the second chorus she doesn't sing the words and it leaves the listener wanting it. Then near the end of the song Dany sings it and the listener eats it like candy

@TessT101 2 года назад

What a way to wake up in the morning! My favorite reactor, reacting to The Warning. This is going to be a good day 🌟🤘❤️

@THEDavidHeretic 2 года назад

FEELIN' YOU Teri!!! Have a great day for sure.

@robertkrawitz8237 2 года назад

Nice review, with the traditional DH attention to detail (I'm an engineer, so "attention to detail" is a good thing). A few things: * Interesting that this is now your second favorite to XXICB, as the themes are very similar. I don't have the exact words Pau used in front of me, but she described it as being about the hate spreading in social media and how it so easily lets people stay in their bubbles. It's almost a follow-on to XXICB in that regard. * The split vocal lead is such a staple of their sound, isn't it? A big strength of theirs relative to most other bands. * Dany's vocal range and power really jumped out at me the first time I heard Choke, and the difference is night and day compared to QoTMS and before. Not that her vocals were weak, just that her work on Mayday jumps her way up into real rock diva status. And Pau showed some pretty interesting vocal chops herself, particularly in the breakdown. * I cannot believe that you missed Ale's "2, 3, GO!" lead line. You watch your ass! * Since you're Ale Battalion, I'll tell you that you are going to like Animosity and Z.

@NoSmokingDogs 2 года назад

I'm waiting for the day that there's a three way vocal split, something they've only done on that Katy Perry cover of Roar oh so long ago.

@leekovalskyj9218 3 месяца назад

...also live versions of 'Choke' and 'More'. (The OMVs don't show Ale singing her actual parts.)

@bigfan007 2 года назад

The sharp ending help punctuates the final line, a line that was teased multiple times early in the song but only completed in the last line. Great analysis David.

@gill2105 2 года назад

Excellent reaction/review, Ale is definitely bringing more sound and style on this whole EP and I love it. Have fun at the Troubadour ! I'll be catching the Austin show. Pretty certain they'll play all the songs on the EP on every show. Thanks David for that fine breakdown and fun !

@NoSmokingDogs 2 года назад

Do you think they'll play the new Enter Sandman on this tour?

@gill2105 2 года назад

@@NoSmokingDogs I kind of doubt it, but who knows they're full of surprises if so it might be a special appearance by Alessia Cara in a Canada show.. wild assumption

@NoSmokingDogs 2 года назад

@@gill2105 More likely she could show up to the Flint show, she live's in Toronto. If I knew that was happening, I'd drive the 6 hours to see that. Then again, passport or border crossing issues might make it easier for her to go to Vancouver. The more likely scenario would be a late night talk show having them both appear when TW is in New York. Wish Lava could arrange that.

@jeccoo 2 года назад

Yess!! I didn’t even watched this. Starting now 😂 End of reaction notes: - I was really waiting for a reaction at the end of the song. And it is delivered 😂 -Pau is singing lead on the 3rd verse, and the one before the breakdown as in the video.

@carlnietoweise4653 2 года назад

Good reaction David, thanks, these ladies just keep getting better and better and it's all through their work ethic and dedication to their craft. Like you Ale the Thunder girl is my favorite for the reasons you gave. I wish I could make it to the Troubadour not only to see the girls but to shake the hand of my favorite reactor.

@THEDavidHeretic 2 года назад

If you manage to make it out, make sure to find me and hopefully Mrs. Heretic. We'd love to meet you and shake hands.

@carlnietoweise4653 2 года назад

@@THEDavidHeretic Agoraphobic retiree living in Florida....yeah nah, don't think that'll happen any time soon...lol!

@jeccoo 2 года назад

Wow! Great reaction David! I was waiting for this for so long. I had watery eyes from laughing as I see your reaction at the end of the song 😂 I think it is one of the best cliffhangers in rock music. If not the best 🤘 If you didn’t do a reaction already at this point, I think you can find that guitar solo in “Z”. Also “Animosity” is incredible. They are on fire no doubt. I hope you will do one with your wife too. Previous one was the best ever 🤘

@robertshort5950 2 года назад

As usual David. A excellent reaction (as per all your reaction’s) Always enjoy your analysis..

@donaldkirk1850 2 года назад

Me and my son will be there and we will say hi . Great reaction. I have seen this live and they both share the vocals. Where Pau is singing it is her singing.

@THEDavidHeretic 2 года назад

Awesome, can't wait to meet you and your son.

@purpleraventd3 2 года назад

Again, another great reaction. It is a great song! You want more solos, they're coming! Anxious to see you do Z and Animosity. I'm anxious to hear the rest of the album, because what we've gotten so far is superb! XXI Century Blood is one of my favorites too!

@bradleyp3655 2 года назад

From what I understand this video was financed by their Patreon supporters. The extras in the video are all local fans known as The Warning Army are all volunteers.

@danw1955 2 года назад

24:29 - I absolutely agree with you on that!! I suffered through 13 years of a drummer that couldn't keep time.😡 Only because we're in a small town and there was *NOBODY* else we could call on to do it.🙄 Pau's drumming is like clockwork and she always keeps it fresh with new fills and techniques! That said, this is also currently my favorite from them! This is sort of a natural progression from XXI Century Blood, and the whole production is just off the charts! They once again had a perfect location for shooting this (the Blast Furnace Museum in Monterrey), and included a bunch of people from The Warning Army for 'the masses'. Gotta love 'em for that!!😁 Great review David, and definitely worthy of that 9.3 rating!😍 🤘😎🤘

@pilotosh70 2 года назад

They are in the path to greatness! Impossible not to love them!

@aaronleesgbclieutenant 2 года назад

Referring to your review, oh the rewards of having creative control of your music 😁. I wont be at the troubador show, but i will be at the machine shop on february 4th!

@Highrider_Phil_C 2 года назад

Love this one, Ale's bass playing has really matured in all of the Mayday songs, especially her bass slide, it has awesome riffs, killer drums, and the duel lead vocals really make this one a winner in my book. I love the energetic attitude they all have in this video, I truly can't wait to see what they bring us next, they're amazing. Next for you, try "Animosity", "Z", or "Martirio", to be honest, any of them will do, let's rock!

@markjames8664 2 года назад

On repeated listens I’ve noticed more bass tricks throughout the album. But I’m sure what she’s doing on this album is only a preview of what she will do - when she tracked bass in the studio she hadn’t even turned 16 yet.

@Highrider_Phil_C 2 года назад

@@markjames8664 I know, the future of the Warning looks very promising, I can't wait to see what they do next.

@ryankieth1675 2 года назад

Looking forward to meeting you at the Troubadour!

@THEDavidHeretic 2 года назад

Definitely, make sure to find me and hopefully Mrs. Heretic as well.

@jeffvolpe4117 2 года назад

Great critique, insight, and reaction as usual. Saw them at Rockville and there was a lot of buzz and new fans they generated from that performance! When they sang this, Animosity, Evolve, and Z that is when the energy at the concert went through the roof! Can’t wait to see them again on the 22nd when I believe you’ll be there! 🔥🔥🔥🤘🤘🤘

@THEDavidHeretic 2 года назад

I will definitely be there, if we can get a 2nd ticket for that night Mrs. Heretic will be there too.

@jeffvolpe4117 2 года назад

@@THEDavidHeretic DPA said they had some extras so I will message them on Patreon and check if anyone else has an extra. That would be perfect if she could be there with you!

@jeffvolpe4117 2 года назад

Remind me which night you are going?

@THEDavidHeretic 2 года назад

@@jeffvolpe4117 That would be great, we just need one for Saturday the 22nd. I already have one, but Mrs. Heretic could use one if anyone wouldn't mind.

@THEDavidHeretic 2 года назад

@@jeffvolpe4117 I'll be there both on the 20th and the 22nd. We only were able to get a ticket for Mrs. Heretic for the 20th. If we can get one more for her for the 22nd that would be awesome.

@krash66 2 года назад

Great Reaction David! I am also torn between this and Evolve as my favorite from the Mayday EP. But, all the rest are a very close second. LOL.. As for the vocals in the second verse. It is indeed Pau singing the second verse. As a matter of fact, you can watch her do it live at the Welcome to Rockville Festival that they just played at Daytona Speedway. Also, Ale's bass playing and bass parts on this new EP are just amazing. She is a bigger part of the song structure now and is more forward in the mix. This allows Dany to do more lead riffs instead of rhythm guitar to make the songs more interesting. Just great songwriting all the way around. Future Legends!

@mt4design2 2 года назад

Great reaction. It is Pau in.the second verse (is it actually the third)? They’ve performed this live a couple times. Have a great time at the show!

@anthonyfisher1670 2 года назад

David you're not feeding those hogs enough , haha . Great reaction and nuances as usual .I wasn't sure about the ending when i first heard it , but what a genius ending really , they always surprise us which is the most important thing .

@saidja-marques 2 года назад

The reaction I was waiting lol

@SteelSeoul 2 года назад

As others have said, can't wait to see your reaction to Animosity and Z. Both great songs that show how far the band has come.

@AchimE 2 года назад

David, love your reviews! They are more surprising than ever, right? They surprise even you… different pre-chorusses, this sudden ending… Cannot wait for the 2nd half of the new album, Mayday is just 50%… Thanks for your analysis, greetings from Germany 👍⚡️🤘

@robertkrawitz8237 2 года назад

That's one of the things I like so much about the song, the twists and turns. They are absolutely brilliant in their writing and arranging skills. I know that Dany was taking an online class in production that Alan Parsons created. That's going to be really scary.

@gerhard7157 2 года назад

Great reactions. Always enjoy your analysis.. If they come to europe one day, I would buy tickets immediately to see them live. The first in a long, long time. Greetings from Germany.

@THEDavidHeretic 2 года назад

I'm sure Lava will send them out to Europe once there's a big enough market...it's just a matter of time.

@bradleyp3655 2 года назад

XXICB and Disciple complement each other. XXICB show societies obsession with technology while Disciple show how social media is used to influence society all for money.

@reactionsaccount3955 2 года назад

They ended the song this way to emphasize the addition of the words 'of ignorance' at the end, as it is extremely important to clarify the message of the lyrics.

@sdi2587 2 года назад

Thank you, I love all the technical data that you mention in your reactions and that I do not see when listening to the songs, after seeing you I can appreciate the songs more deeply and I thank you for that, The Warning is my favorite band.

@BadCowboy67 2 года назад

I agree with you almost 100% David. This is by far my favorite song on the Mayday EP and right there with 21st Century Blood in my top 5 only because of my introduction to The Warning being Servive, Escape The Mind, and Free Falling. Those 3 songs mean more to me because of what I was going through at the time, with the amputation of my leg. Those 5 songs are great and on any given day the order flip flops around with my mood like the Oklahoma weather. I was surprised that you didn't say anything on Ale's 2, 3, GO!! line. Oh Ale just turned 17 on the 13th of December, Dany will be 22 on the 30th of January and, Pau will be 20 on the 5th of February. So 16, 19, and 21 when this was recorded.

@morthnadic1 2 года назад

They finished recording this over a year ago; so they were all a year younger than the ages you posted. ✌🤓 Edit: you are correct as to when the video was recorded.

@billybob5250 2 года назад

Great reaction, David! I did not like this song when it was first released, but I like it now. I learned a lot from your reaction.

@aaronleesgbclieutenant 2 года назад

YES! FINALLY! HARUMPH!!

@torresilk4277 2 года назад

Harrumph! 😁

@THEDavidHeretic 2 года назад

HARRUMPH!!!

@NoSmokingDogs 2 года назад

A two pig-noise rewind song! That might be a first but I certainly haven't heard every review to be sure. When you see them live you will see who sings what part. That is if you can take your eyes off of Ale for a moment. EDIT: I checked Ghost Love Score and yes he did rewind twice on that one. So not a first, but then again that song is 3x longer than this one.

@KansaSCaymanS 2 года назад

He did 4 or 5 rewinds during just the intro to Rondo of Nightmare by Baby Metal - suspect that might be a record, but I haven’t watched all of his reactions either.

@NoSmokingDogs 2 года назад

@@KansaSCaymanS I'll have to watch that one to what peaked his interest.

@amb3466 2 года назад

Just another great reaction. Thanks again

@conrad98gtp 2 года назад

Hey David! Thanks for this one! As you say XXI Century Blood is your favorite, this follows along with that one in terms of its topic, and what it's saying about the control of Social Media, and what it's doing to society. As far as the abrupt ending, I LOVE It because it leaves you with the message... "You shall remain inside your space of (ignorance)" And they leave you with the "obeying" crowd of (ignorant) Disciples. They are the "Swimming Fishes that will drown" And if you become a Disciple, you will too. Genius.... By the way, that was ABSOLUTELY Pau singing the second verse. Her vocals 100% This song is everything about the message, as most of their songs, actually.

@glengibbs1949 2 года назад

Hey David! I think you will be impressed the next-level quality of the entire Mayday EP! Of the six songs though, "Disciple" and its video are (perhaps?) my favorite. IMHO, not since "Sinister Smiles" have we been assaulted so completely by the entire arsenal at TW's disposal!

@peluchingamarra3127 2 года назад

Your reactions never disappoint. Love your honest, respectful review full of these technical details that gives us a new perspective of the song. Love the crying pigs too :D. Happy Holidays sir!

@kathleenandbruce 2 года назад

Great reaction btw.

@Nas_Khan 2 года назад

Hey David feelin you. Sorry but I’m always looking at Dany like you are looking at Ale. Love Ale but Dany’s definitely my girl. Yes Dany might not be able to move around on stage as much coz she is stuck to the microphone but Dany’s passion & facial expressions is unmatched by anyone in my opinion. Disciple is my no 6 among the 6 new songs, would love to see your reaction to Animosity & Z. Personally for me Animosity is sooo good and Z is a total banger with a sick bass line and a killer guitar solo. Be well mate 🔥🔥

@pablosartor6715 2 года назад

Great analysis! They are insanely talented!! This EPIC song has a powerful message! They did a superb job! Viva The Warning !! ⚡⚡⚡

@roccomartin 2 года назад

Thanks, David! You have to look to the lyrics to understand why they cut the song so abruptly. Each time they do the chorus they change the end. The first time is "...in your place....two three go!". The second time is "...in your place..." followed by Pau's disciple pledge. Finally, "...in your place of IGNORANCE!" The girls never do anything without a strong reason...it's just not always obvious.

@morthnadic1 2 года назад

It's "inside your space", not "in your place". ✌🤓

@pissingelk 2 года назад

Great reaction brother! 🔥💖🤘🖤

@michaelbrooks742 2 года назад

I absolutely love how sudden the song ends abruptly on the word ignorance.

@joaquinantoniogarciagonzal3395 2 года назад

EXCELENTE REACCIÓN DAVID , CONGRATULACIONES Y SIGUE APOYANDO Y VALORANDO JUSTAMENTE A LAS REVOLUCIONARIAS DEL ROCK DEL SIGLO XXI. ¡¡THE WARNING!!

@markjames8664 2 года назад

Fun fact: this is one of the most physically demanding songs for Pau, a lot of singing and a lot of intense drums. I think she specifically mentioned the last pre-chorus where she’s singing over the drum buildup. And it will be a pretty intense tour - for instance Flint, Pittsburgh, Philadelphia and Boston four straight days. It’s good that they are young!

@svenveader7755 2 года назад

This needs to be the opening song on the Mayday 2022 tour

@artefakto.9yearsago301 2 года назад

Followed by Evolve maybe?

@demonhoopa 2 года назад

Dany’s range has always been sick. No one else in the group has ever been CLOSE in that department

@jamesgreen5431 2 года назад

Oops LA is sold out but San Diego looks open still for the 18th. I'll be there just got tickets this morning. So Cal you still got a chance

@adamtrombino106 2 года назад

That song is s super roller coaster ride of craziness! When I 1st saw it, I was just in awe. So much, almost too much to take in at once! I had to watch it over and over just to get over the visual effects, THEN just listen. That Pau breakdown, followed by a smooth, subtle bluesy guitar solo is my fav part of the song.Great reaction! And yes, they definitely leave u wanting more with that ending. No one saw that coming!

@jonathanspahn7308 3 месяца назад

Shades of Rush. I'm so excited for this group 🤘

@abjbusti8586 2 года назад

Excellent reaction as usual. Hope to meet you and your wife at The Troubadour…my daughter and I will be attending the second show on 22nd. Harrumph! 🤘😎🔥🔥🔥

@THEDavidHeretic 2 года назад

Awesome, I will be there on the 22nd for sure. If we can get another ticket for that night, Mrs. Heretic will be with me. Either way, make sure to find me/us and I'll/we'll be happy to meet you.

@TimberWolf762 2 года назад

@@THEDavidHeretic General admission or VIP?

@THEDavidHeretic 2 года назад

@@TimberWolf762 Just general, that's what I have.

@rebpgh 2 месяца назад

Best reaction to the end of Disciple I've seen. Most folks wait to see what's next, so it's dead air for 5-6 seconds, but you saw it was the end immediately and enjoyed that surprise. I'd give that ending reaction a 9.1.

@jimijamessegoviafeerick1355 2 года назад

👏 Thanks David Good info and great analysis as usual. Few reactors come even close to what you can discern with your experienced ear. I'm sure you will have a fun evening meeting DPA and many of us at the Constellation room in Santa Ana or the Troubadour in LA.

@Ian-Cognito 2 года назад

Great reaction as always. Can't wait for your reactions to Z and Anomosity. You are in for a treat! 🤘😎⚠️

@josephbel7532 2 года назад

Hi David, nice to see you with the girls again, everyone has said everything, Great reaction. Do not stray so far David, you are still missing some that I think you will like.

@bloodybutunbowed291 2 года назад

Great reaction DH!!! It's really too bad these record companies make it hard for you reactors to do your thing...I mean really!...they are so short-sighted about these videos...can't they remember in the '50s? When they were all involved in the "payola" scandal? They all got in trouble because they were willing to travel the country, paying radio stations so they would pay their artists' music to get them on the air...now 60yrs later they're complaining when literally hundreds of people are doing these reactions, singing their praises, and getting their music out to the public for free??!! Instead of sitting back and just saying "Thank you", they cry foul and throw up a block!!! Makes no sense! (ok...rant over)

@THEDavidHeretic 2 года назад

Couldn't possibly agree more. By the way, that practice is still happening with record companies paying radio stations....they just do it covertly now.

@kathleenandbruce 2 года назад

Okay so now you've done tons of The Warning and Band Maid now try an American all girl band Plush. Their single Hate made it to #24 on the rock charts. Give them a listen please.

@agustinmanyari 2 года назад

Thanks for the recommendation 🤘🏻

@doomsdaycun_lmh9341 2 года назад

Ale said in a recent interview that she knows Pau can´t do a lot of moves behind the drums and Dany either because she have to sing, then she have to fill the space with her moves. Funny thing you mentioned XXI Century Blood, because for some people this song it´s like the second part. This is the song of the #NumberlyGarfs, in a vlog Dany said why and once you ear the reazon you can´t stop listening that way every time you ear the song. Great reaction as always.

@vanlepthien6768 2 года назад

They work to make sure that what they do in the video is what they can do live. Pau discussed how she worked to get the vocals to work while she was drumming. Not something that's an issue if you are just recording tracks to be layered.

@pedrometal1597 2 года назад

Super reaction 🤟

@kevenbridges9433 7 месяцев назад

By this time they had gone though the David Bendeth boot camp in post pro. Before he started the production of the album. They have said that he showed them how the play in time and together. And that it was like learning to play all over. The improvement shows in the songs. The Warning always work on evolving and improving all aspects of there craft. I'm writing this a year after this reaction. Around The Warnings 10 year to gather. And tthey have come a long way in just that one year.

@morthnadic1 2 года назад

Great to see you again David Heretic! Superb breakdown/analysis. You are spot on in every detail except; it is actually Pau's voice on the 2nd verse that begins at the 10:35 mark in your uploaded video. This sounds like this is a calling to break free from our addictive reliance on information presented on screens that feed us whatever the algorithms decide for us to consume. (update) From The Warning's drummer Paulina's 10-9-21 Instagram LIVE Pau Day stream- "Disciple is a song about social media... right?... and how opinions are bought in social media and are fed to us in a way that we don't even know... and how by like feeding ignorance and cultivating hate... like people gain a lot of power and money... so, that's what Disciple is about." Thank you so much for all your support. 🗣 See you at The Troubadour! 👋🤠

@THEDavidHeretic 2 года назад

Absolutely, make sure you come and find me, or if it's the 20th find Mrs. Heretic and myself.

@morthnadic1 2 года назад

No worries... I'm going to both shows @@THEDavidHeretic 🤠👍

@user-tl4rn7mp5b Месяц назад

I am Ale’s biggest fan. Her playing is miraculous. Her stage presence mesmerizing.

@Aussie.Brad0 2 года назад

ill say your my fav review reactor cos you tell it how it is ya know what your talking about

@THEDavidHeretic 2 года назад

FEELIN' YOU Brad!!!

@timothytyree8057 2 года назад

I feel instead of saying Lava records did this or that, You need to give Producer David Bendeth his props, and David will tell you that the girls were adamant about what they wanted, but David brought their vision to life...#DPAFOREVER...and no, when you see Pau, as you say "mouthing it" it is Pau.

@markjames8664 2 года назад

One particularly smart thing Bendeth did: he had them drastically speed up Evolve over their demos. I think that really made the song grab the listener.

@EdwardRLyons Год назад

I love the way The Warning end their songs -- especially this one. You know what they say about always leaving the crowd wanting more -- and this song ends exactly that way. Just brilliant!

@pbrooks4040 2 года назад

gotta love ‘em, eh?

@Zealdave2223 Год назад

The ending in the 80's was known as the DJ killer as they had no warning that the song was about to end. They would then get caught with dead air, as they were away from the mic queeing up something or talking to a producer etc. I love it and TW.

@edintx 2 года назад

I know you’re not lyric-focused but as you mentioned XXI Century Blood, lyrically this is the follow up to it IMLTHO. XXI Century Blood was about devices and Internet worship. Now we have the army of the indoctrinated with eyes bleeding from staring at the screen. 🔥🤘#NumberlyGarfs

@TimberWolf762 2 года назад

See you and wifey at the Troub!

@THEDavidHeretic 2 года назад

Awesome we'll be there, make sure to find us and introduce yourself.

@jluisg622 2 года назад

IT IS ONE OF THE BEST ROCK GROUPS OF 2021, A GROUP THAT HAS ACHIEVED GREAT TOPICS WITH A LOT OF WORK SINCE GIRLS, NOTHING IS A CASUALITY IT IS DAILY WORK FROM THE TALENT, 3 GREAT THEMES FROM THE NEW ROCK

@somedude5414 2 года назад

Pau sang the 2nd verse live when they played at Rockville.

@DonKelleyMusic Год назад

One thing the warnign is is extremely honest. If you see them singing in a music video, then they were singing in the song at that point. Pau does sing the second verse lead. She can sound kind of like Dany at times if she chooses to... it's bizarre. And if you ever get to hear Ale sing lead with a microphone that is actually loud enough (live engineers often used to keep her vocal mic too quiet in live concerts I guess because of some rule about backup vocalists, or because she simply sings less loudly than her sisters).... but Ale sounds kind of like Dany but with a richer tone and less edge.

@tigre_2023 6 месяцев назад

Excellent comments David, I'm starting to follow you thanks to The Warnink

@dannycox6375 2 года назад

Ale's bass line is just sick. She just keeps getting better.

@RussInCanada 6 месяцев назад

The ending of this reminds me of the ending of Savoy Brown's 'Hellbound Train'.

@jimijamessegoviafeerick1355 2 года назад

David your reactions are always insightful, spot on and fun. This one was no exception. It was an interesting analysis. I understand completely how you loved and hated the ending of Disciple at the same time. 😆 It's great that you're going to see TW at the Troubadour. I've got tickets for Reading and Philly and had plans for flying to the left coast to jam with my old lead guitarist in Redondo Beach LA pbut they fell apart. I would have loved to meet you and your wife. I'm sure you both will have a fantastic time meeting DPA and chatting with them. Are you going to be going to the sound check as well? You will meet a lot of nice people, have a memorable night and it will be a blast. 💥 All the best Jim 🎸(Segovia)😂

@THEDavidHeretic 2 года назад

I dunno anything about the sound check, but Mrs. Heretic and I are really looking forward to meeting as many members of The Fanbase as possible at the show.

@jimijamessegoviafeerick1355 2 года назад

@@THEDavidHeretic Nice! I hope you let us all know how the the whole event went. I'm going to have to ask Dany if they're planning to open sound checks to people other than their Ultimate patreon tier as I am bringing my friend girl. I'm sure my friend doesn't want to wait two or three hours while I'm at the soundcheck. I'll shoot you a message what I find out what they decide. You have a nice holiday

@a.j.pinckney88 Год назад

The ending is genius.

@alexking5013 2 года назад

WARNING ARMY UNITE

@zamdrist 2 года назад

That abrupt ending I used to find annoying, now I realize, it's purposeful to make you want to play the song over again lol. Sneaky!

@IAMBatKat 2 года назад

I love your analysis of songs. I know like a song or not, but your ear and breakdown shows me why I like or just think parts are just 'meh' (most of the time). Most reaction youtubers don't have near your talent for breaking songs down or they don't even bother to try. Sometimes you are long winded, but then you are doing you, and that's okay 🙂

@THEDavidHeretic 2 года назад

Oh trust me, I know I'm long-winded. I try not to be, but I just can't help it.

@noebrunn6242 2 года назад

I🖤TW🤘

@edtcrandall Год назад

but the lyrics resolved at the ending - the chorus added one vital word, ignorance, and the song ended. The most recent live video on the warning website does this perfect because not only does the song end but all the lights go out on "ignorance"