This YouTuber has gone INSANE -- (What if Alt Hist DEBUNKED) 

Subscribe to my Patreon so that, together, we can fend off the inevitable Incel Revolution: www.patreon.com/WhatWhyHow Join my Discord to join the What Why How Revolutionary Clique: discord.com/invite/XB7MWEemeW

It's so funny to see people put Russia and Iran on the "left", when both have very clear conservative agendas.

He's actually remarkably progressive considering the books he reads and the friends he has.

Every time I hear WhatifAltHist speak, it reminds me of a quote. "The whole problem with the world is that fools and fanatics are always so certain of themselves, and wiser people so full of doubts." Bertrand Russell

He is literally the type of guy to look at all the evidence of the armenian genocide and say “That didn’t happen, but if it did it was deserved”

Thank god more people are tuning into the fact that Whatifalthist is quickly slipping into madness

He is way too young and unread to make the claims that he does. He wants to be seen as a genius.

The thing that annoyed me most in his video is when he cited the Haiti as an example for failed nations that gained independence by revolt of the slaves completely forgetting that Haiti was immediately in deep debt to France and had almost no way to pay it back because they lacked even the most basic infrastructure which practically forced them into staying in the hands of France

A very debunk of Whatifalthist's statement about women is to simply consider, who spearheaded the women's sufferage movement?

Nice to see that more and more people start noticing his takes. I remember watching his "myths" video how he went on rant how bible actually invented morality and such and how this guy created a bit of echo chamber. Writing this comment mostly to hopefully pump up the algorithm a bit!

Whatifalthist has famously said he doesnt like reading academic books past like the 1950s

If sucks that whatifalthist turns from a semi-interesting Alt hist channel to a backwater political channel. Where’s the old him?

RU-vid took him down not because of his rhetoric but because if his horrible vocal style

He also totally ignores the existence of brothel matrons. lol

"The problem with building a coalition of everyone that wasnt part of the previous coalition is that it just doesnt make sense" Ah yes, it makes no sense for say, 13 states to form a coalition against an empire that they were a colony of. I'm sure nothing like that has happened before in history.

I laughed at the part about women, like WIAH clearly never talks to women lol. Basically the meme of the "red pill nerd" who talks about "well ackshully the feeeemale psychology has evolved..."

Turns out he’s a grifter begging for money

something I don't like about the whole "academia is LEFT" is that the people who say that always only mean stuff like artistic faculties and such (who knew art was about opinions). Universities also output stuff like physicists, engineers and chemists, and they don't get taught any opinions on societal issues. So if a chemist happens to be an avid communist, does that mean that academia did that to him? Does the same count if a geologist is a raving libertarian?

14:34 To be fair, if a political party was in complete power behind the scenes, it would be advantageous to create the impression that there is a cycle of elections in which they occasionally lose. That way, if things don't get better, they can blame it on the party having been the face of the government for the past term when they re-enter the spotlight. This also works for policies. If you don't solve an issue, you can campaign next election on the same issue.

The rich move forward by making the poor fight left and right.

If you are looking for a loser channel, remember of a channel that is mostly forgotten and only earn more views when it tries to mock other channels.

whatifalthist has turned into a lolcow lmao

Love the plea to conservatives to not be grifted upon. lol that wont work though

I used to enjoy whatifathist until he started going on and on spirals

This is the kind of discouse that is craved for by the thinking man engulphed by the increasingly bi-partisan content available in the mainstream. Just because we do not agree with somebody( us being univocally baised tribal creatures) should not mean we demolish the town square debates upon which the entirity of our civillization is predicated(both eastern and western). Appreciate you taking time out to furnish carefully thought out agruements. Upon seeeing opinions that we disagree with we shouldnt run,neither should we immolate the ideas;rather we should test our ideas out in debate and let the flame of Galileo burn through our actions. Cheers!

The best thing about the Trump classified docs thing is both Pence and Biden found documents and then immediately cooperated and handled it properly

I used to realt like althist. I think my departure happened when he made a video of nazis winning ww2 and what the world would look like afterward without any actual mention of the holocaust or how the mass extinction of the Jews or Slavs would affect history.

Always came off as a weird guy.

Aside from the other ridiculous claims he is right about the far left causing the rise of the far right. It’s inevitable to happen when a government/society turns too far and steps over the line a certain way politically/socially, people are going to react the opposite. Look at 1920’s Germany and Berlin. Very liberal and far left at the time a little too liberal for my liking at least. Which is one of the many factors that caused the Austrian painter to rise in popularity and power. Doesn’t matter what political ideology, people will react opposite. I’m fact I would blame Republicans and their power and thirst for war as the cause of Democrats becoming more far left over the years. Then they gained more power, pushing their ideologies into law and causing people to react opposite. People need to relax and calm down before it gets out of hand which I’m afraid History is going to repeat it’s self within the next decade or so.

great video! you argued in a effective, respectful, and also comedic way that was exciting to watch

"The left is the establishment" such a rich narrative coming fron equally established, equally privileged conservatives to get people on board is so hilarious

Appalachia video when

imo *irony* will always be present in any historical event, you'll probably see a backlash within different communities which causes cross pollination between different subgroups from those communities.

7:44 Sadly your advice won't help, even us right wingers, who WERE pro Trump in 2016-2020 but after different reasons stopped supporting him, we are still called "fake" and so on and so forth.

"The things he says are racist and wrong, because the people he cites are racist and wrong" Where's the debunking?

I think you’ve given the single best reaction to a whatifalthist video that I’ve ever seen. I don’t necessarily agree that some of your arguments really disprove much, and I think sometimes you take a talking point to be a “fact”, but still I really respect what you’ve put together here.

I used to watch this Goober when I was younger, his channel is basically a conservative propaganda channel nowadays

15:12 That's a dumb claim. College education does not make you more "experienced" in life nor does it give away the left as "better" because people with degrees vote them which is implied here. Politics are not just some belief on how to achieve a better society, politics also favor certain groups of people over others in their policies. This can cause voters to get the "don't shoot yourself in the foot" syndrome. I'll provide an example, i don't know about American policies because I'm an Argentinian but i've seen many people vote for Massa (which was "the left" in Argentina) instead of Javier Milei ("the right") even though their views on how to tackle the Argentinian problem were more in line with Milei's because they were beneficiaries of some social plan. The last holds true in state workers too, if you were to take a sample from state workers, you would have seen that is HEAVILY skewed towards Massa and way off the national avarage, why? because their job was in danger!.

I think its quite nuts watching him overtime for alt history and seeing him decend into this weird amalgamation of ideological radicalization. Stopped watching him after his "Republican v Democrat Civil War" video. But keep up the good work on raising the flag about his videos.

Whatifalthist reminds me of one scene from the simpsons where there's a fox news helicopter and on the side it says "Not racist, but #1 with racists"

This video came up when i searched for break dancing jew and im not even surprised

i don’t think the right wing has moved any more on interracial marriage than the left wing over the last 100 years.. wilson was far more racist than his peers. and presidents like coolidge and TR were pretty progressive on race relations.

The reason he makes alternate history videos is because he has an alternative view of history. He's basically just a ranting crybaby captured by his own audience.

I'm not a big fan of Jordan Peterson, and I hate that I have to say that out front but my government literally made him go to a reeducation course and then he was still bullied out of his job

Peak redditor responses, keep crying bro

Ooh I liked his alternate history stuff even I didn't align with his beliefs, but now he's became a full on incel philosopher and it makes me sad. I hope he finds some inner peace and see the world in a less twisted way.

Great video, could you make a video about the channel History Debunked?

hes not saying some races are better than others hes saying some cultures are better than others which happen to be completely homogenous ethnically based off geography. you are being obtuse on that one

After I watched this video I unsubscribed from him so quick without hesitation 😭 Didn’t realize how clueless, arrogant and ignorant he was. He claims ofc to be right wing and he also claims to not be an extremist but I HIGHLY doubt that.

Whatifalthist is basicly the geopolitics version of Chuck Mcgill

Bruh I just watched Althistory's video and was just dumbfounded by it so seeing your video after has been a blessing. Keep the good shit up :D

I generally like a lot of his stuff, but at the end of the day he’s basically a poor man’s Spengler or Toynbee.

26:16 Number 4 is covered by number 3 is a blatant lie

Great video, it's unfortunate that people unironically subscribe to what if Alt Hist's brain rot.

“Blind thrashing”

A good video overall, but you miss his point about equality. He’s pushing back on equity (equal outcomes) as opposed to equality (equal opportunity). I don’t think the RU-vid comments section is a great place to hash this issue out, but I think it’s a very complex issue with a lot of room for opinion that doesn’t involve becoming radicalized.

Wow! How did that channel get so terrible?

Who’s worse? Whatifalthist or PragerU?

As a Conservative i agree with you 100%

glad that you managed to critique him better than some other videos i’ve seen that miss the point and end up losing its meaning good job

Great video. But, I think putting Dresden in the same category as the other stuff mentioned at 26:36 is unfair. Unlike the other things mentioned, Dresden was hit for a reason. It was a major railroad artery that supplied German forces in the east. Dresden wasn't a war crime, It was Germans completely failing to defend one of there cities.

Half this video is you getting hung up on what left wing means lol. Sure they would be considered right wing leaning economically wise but USA democratic party is fairly hardcore left wing socially. How is that not obvious? Your point about him flipflopping on his claims about the intelligence of the left are spot on though. I noticed that in my watch through of the video.

It is valid to claim that certain sects of Hollywood have agendas leaning towards the left wing. Otherwise, we would not have race swapped characters, and especially not ones in stories which are written to be derogatory to certain groups, case in point Velma. This is clearly not all of Hollywood though. Pushes have been made to make stories about women and people of color. Some are good, and some really suck. At the end of the day, there are no bad characters, only bad writing, and the movies with bad writing are failing at the box office.

Although i agree with almost everything and is left-leaning myself, i do find it untrue to argue that Hollywood and entertainment in general has not become more leftist, at least in its preaching and with things like forced token characters instead of representing natural diversity in the storytelling.

Maybe could have pushed slightly harder against his historical determinism

talking about communist larpers and then citing CPUSA numbers right afterwards completely straight-faced got a nice loud "HAH" out of me, so congrats for that

you can see it in his alternative history. a lot of people within alt history have a usual meme where usually the Confederates win or the Germans win ww2. it is never the Dog-Meat General winning ww2.

One of the things I hate about his videos besides being wrong on so many levels is how he doesn’t know how to stick to a thesis. He goes on so many tangents that seem to serve no purpose other than giving more time to preach his own philosophical doctrines. I think Fredda was right on the money when he described Whatifalthist as someone whose priorities aren’t understanding history, but being a thought leader. A “cool kids’ philosopher” he probably considers himself

Jordan Peterson is the only one that I think really has good intentions. Eventhough I disagree with many of his ideia.

It's funny how opinion on citations can go from: "wow, WIAH, 19 century again? Can you cite something after 1950?" To: "Jesus, WIAH, can you please go back to citing 19 century Germans?"

Universities being left is due to them being smarter and more learned. Except for when they weren't? Before the 60s.

Man, I watched this guy back when he did alt-hist, but slowly got bored of his newer stuff. Especially future predictions, which are just silly ideas overall. It’s sad to see he’s a far-right fella now, but I can’t say I didn’t see it coming. His newer video’s definitely were right to begin with

He's not wrong about wars, but his reasoning is wrong. Over time culture and demographics change. Also in the break up of nations like the USSR, the break up was not clean and people belonging to one nation end up becoming discriminated minorities in another. As much as we want to solve these issues peacefully very rarely does a nation give up land peacefully. Even if some sort of political reorganization would be healthier for the survival of the nation. The US for example needs to redraw all of the states, but the Federal Government wont push for it and the State Governments in many places are too corrupt to give up their human cattle. This will eventually spell doom on a Austro-Hungarian or Yugoslav Scale.

I used to use his vids as background noise and stuff and one day i actually sat down and listened to it and i was like "some of this makes a bit of sense but the majority is like...huh??"

A lot name calling and unproven assumptions without much thought.

If you want to anger Curt Doolittle, just ask him who his daughter married.

Nothing says fear like a tiki torch

He’s right, there is no left wing equivalent to the individual attacks on Peterson, Tate or Trump. You literally described them using the same individual attacks. Js

what he said starting 21:38 is merely stating the magnitude of social shifts. he may hold many of these to be wrong, but that's not what he's saying here. he's not defending wars and empire building, he's merely stating that it was a major social shift. this is the biggest blindspot of the uploader of this video

Whatifaltist puts out garbage content and is an edgy kid, but not because of his political views. He just has the worldview of a simpleton and so his analysis of the world at large is just bound to be wrong.

I feel bad for him, I feel bad that he have gotten such points of view and have become stuck in an echo chamber. I will pray for him, for we shall pray even for those who we disagree with, for those who despise us and persecutes us and hates us, not that this guy has to hate us, but still.

Another amazing video! Love to see the citations! How do you feel about possibly making a video on monsieur z or josh sullivan history? (he makes videos for monsieur z's channel) I would love to see your perspective on their videos. Also i see you don't use many tags in your videos. Tags help a lot in the youtube algorithm so make sure to fill them up! TubeBuddy & VidIQ are some chrome extensions that will help you make better tags if you want

This guy's fanbase seems like a cult.

9:35 do you still feel like there's no Democrat equivalent to Trump as far as criminal activity?

Thanks for all people who brigaded this video to dislike it and thus made it show up in my recommendations :) Great video keep up the work.

I wanted to say I enjoyed your video however I want to mention a major criqtiue that I have where you have completly missed the point. At about the 15 min mark you said that univeritys and colleges are left leaning. This is true. You then state that this is becuase they read and understand more about the world. Finanly you say about how in general younger people are on the whole more left wing. When saying this did you not consider that young people are more left wing becuase it is what they are taught at a young age in school and not becuase they read more. If you are born into a system that teaches you one side is good you will support that side. This is much like what the nazis did. Saying that young people who go to college and university are smarter and therefore left wing is a just utterly wrong point

"Step 1: It's not really happening Step 2: Yeah, it's happening, but it's not a big deal Step 3: It's a good thing, actually Step 4: People freaking out about it are the real problem" The video.

I would still thank Whatalthist for bringing up these topics in the first place for discussion

About movies and shit being woke. No, it's not about more women and POC. No, no, no. There were plenty of great movies with diverse casts back in the day and a few today. The problem is that actual SJW cult propaganda is so prevalent and the simutaneous decline of actual story quality. The fact that there are more women and POC is just the shallow shield for how shitty movies and shows are now. Then simple minded people like this creator can claim that anti-woke criticism of modern entertainment is just sexist and racist. To sum up, NO. The stories are much more shallow and the leftist propaganda is thick. That's what us anti-woke people don't like. Give me a great story without a heavy political bias, featuring all female POC and I'll love it just as much as any other great story.

The fact you called Tate a 'failed kickboxer' while he was literally the world champion at one point just shows incredible bad faith and makes me not want to watch the video, congrats.

Arranged marriages and polygamy are directly associated with political instability, while monogamy is strongly associated with social and political stability, because it gives a much larger percentage of men a reasonable chance at being pro-social and productive members of society. If you're a poor guy in southern Sudan, Chad etc there's no reason for you not to become a raider, since you'll never be able to afford brides.

This isn't aging well lol Its being covered far more in the news. Most recently I believe the Economist released an article today confirming many of the points that he laid out coming up on a year ago.

I'd like to address a few things in your video. 1) By men and women or races not being equal he more or less by the context means that they are not the same which is a valid point but nowhere does he specify that they should be treated badly or repressed and the like. 2) When you talk left you speak of economic left(socialism) but when he speaks left he speaks about the LGBTQ+ radicals,kill all men feminists and the white men bad people. I'd recommend you see Thomas Sowell to get a grasp on what he's saying more easily. 3)By Hollywood woke he means movies and shows like woman king or Velma which are problems of their own. Woman King - Historically inaccurate and many blacks hate it Most recent star wars - They threw in useless love,protag too op and dat liea's son is a weaksauce villan and randomly palpatine appears and it's weird and unentertaining writing overall. 4)He does have a sort of a point that white men are a big fat demographic of US and hating against them is quite a recipe for disaster that too with a coalition of many small minority groups(still small amount of ppl together nonetheless). In this part racism against whites by the wokes(leftists) is being told not some socialists. 5)Men will continue to dominate the military for some time till drone tech and the like is used to replaced with men as soliders and that's not anytime soon. It's in everyone's self interest to not let them go berserk and rampage for something that could be provided. This is simple reality and can't be changed. I do think as a outside observer that these wokes are dooming themselves to big backlash but I think the response will be tame and simple for they are a vocal minority I think people are getting tired of.

What if Alt Hist DEBUNKED

The thing is most of media with ''the message'' as Critical Drinker would say are tanking horribly, so even if they make them, they fail and they will not make them in future... so it's not like they are big happenings in media. Like the Velma show, that was showed here, who remembers that now? Or She-Hulk...

44:25 bro this graph has been debunked. It was cherry picked just go and research it pls. I'm also getting the impression you may lean a bit more Marxist by the way you describe modern problems.

Great video bro

Funny note, i know a guy who is in CPUSA. He was pretty hush hush about it, and i dont blame him. Everyone at the place we worked at was blaming the socialists for causing the pandemic.

16:50 The most successful movie Hollywood ever made had a female protagonist, and it wasn't Force Awakens. When are people going to realize movie gross numbers are meaningless if you don't adjust for inflation? You might as well say the latest Iranian movie is the best selling because it made billions of rial.

Great video!