I wish I could get all my music like this, not processed, not tampered with to try and make sound better, but raw, real, and filled with this much emotion.
It shows true musicianship to be able to strip down a song like this and still have it resonate so strongly with the audience. These guys are by far my favourite band - thrice
And still today... I sit and remember the Pictures I've esen on Tv that Day... I sat in Tears with my mom in front of a fucking Tv for hours. Well, my mom is up there with you now. Bet she loves to hear all their storys.
If anyone has any doubts about this song, read the liner notes on the album. Dustin cites a book "The 9/11 Commission Report: Omissions And Distortions" as something that opened his eyes to the events of the day in an interview as well.
I was talking about "The Earth Will Shake" on its RU-vid page with a guy who insisted it was about some event that happened in the new scripture. I told him almost exactly what you said, it might be their inspiration, but the song can be interpreted in many ways. Some interpretations with more general meaning that anyone can relate to in their own lives. Nice to agree with someone on RU-vid for a change :)
i believe it is because they are humbled by the acceptance. and most artists with any kind of talent lack some kind of social skills. its a typical trait.
I had to start watching these videos because they took all of ThriceX3's Videos down :-( I hope they don't take these too. I watch them a few times everyday!
i need an acoustic album from thrice. imagine? dustin kensrue's stuff is nice, but the stuff he plays with thrice is IMO a lot better. dustin, we want an acoustic album!!!
teppi is a christian i go to the same church as him i play guitar in the mars hill church and have played with dustin and teppi.... they may claim a christian band but with there lyrics and meaning behind most of the songs yes they are. any band using bible quotes in lyrics in multiple some is christian.... and dont say if u are a true fan, ive been a fan since the first impressions album, way back at chain reaction where they started before they were famous
i have to admit that it's one of the only songs from the index with lyrics that don't really move me. love the song, but dustin wrote some soooooo stronger lyrics
I've always thought about these lyrics. Does Dustin believe in a 9/11 conspiracy or does he just mean that we knew but did nothing? Interesting lyrics.
@IcarianxComplex7 i know this comment is froma while ago , but its them who brought themselves to the music career ... why thank god ... he neither exist or did anything ......
@DavidAMIs I can see that. I hadn't heard major/minor until just recently. It's great freaking music, and a great record. It does seem more preachy, and less subliminal about the quotes and verses, but i still can't just see them as a Christian band. I dislike Christian bands too much to ever admit that Thrice could be one, haha.
Is it so important to label music. Is it so important to give music a name-tag. I think the only reason music should be name-tagged is to make it easier to reference, instead of everyone saying "that song" or "that band". Stop trying to label music beyond a point of reference. Please. You are not helping anyone. Listen to music. You don't need to call Thrice a label like "Christian band" or "Alternative band with Christian themes". Thrice is FINE being just Thrice. Thrice can easily be referenced by the name "Thrice" when you wish you speak about them. You don't need to reference Thrice as "that christian band" or "that alternative band with Christian themes". Perhaps you seek to label things because you can not accept them for what they are. Perhaps this stems from your own view of yourself. Do you seek to label yourself? Do you not accept yourself as you truly are?
Well said, This isn't meant to be a slight to people who buy Christian Rock, but I think it is a good question for debate. (I Feel) That if a mediocre band labels itself "Christian Rock" and signs with a Christian Rock label, they will immediately get followers - not based on quality of music, but based on quality of worship. Some people may call this 'sheep like behavior' but I disagree. Now if you take a band that has GREAT talent, and they sign with a 'normal' religion-neutral label, and they become big - I think that says more.
maybe an unpopular opinon but if Thrice labelled themselves through christianity.. i may not have 'found them'.. and now i am one of the thousands die hards that exist for anything Thrice, with passion.
@derekmyers7 You can be a Christian, and incorporate the feelings and inspiration you get from your beliefs, and not be a Christian band. A Christian band intends to show listeners the glory and grace of God. Their primary message is to spread their faith. Thrice does not intend to convert people, nor do they intend to spread Christian beliefs. They are artists. They use everything around them to create great music. It's the life lesson, not the belief behind it, that they preach.
@BlackBalverin I won't start arguing with you because I'm very hard nosed and tend to win an argument when debating. However, I will leave you with a link to a video. If you can HONESTLY tell me that Thrice isn't a Christian based secular band, then a) you're delirious or b) you will see that Dustin Kensrue has a true heart for God. "Grow up and start to look behind the image, thrice is much more than a dump 'christian-band"-- that's quite nonsensical; Christian bands can easily be MORE amazing!
@DanteValentine16 he thanks god, Thrice thank to whatever they want. I'm pretty sure Dustin thanks god, because he's all religious and devoted. Not that I believe in God, though. Human's religion should be humanity. Humans should be taught humanity instead of christianity or muslimities.
I believe Dustin is the Christian among them... but a lot of their songs are based on Christian values, and stories/passages from the bible. Christianity is obviously one of Dustin's greatest inspirations.
I'm a christian but man seriously who the fuck cares?! Why do you say it?! For what?! What does it matter?! Last year I have met with Dustin after the London gig and we have agreed on the fact the christian music sucks... Thrice is not a christian band so fuck off man!
You can quote and incorporate Scripture into your music without being a Christian band. It all has to do with the meaning that they're trying to convey. Thrice isn't a christian band. They probably know more about the bible than most Christians though.