@@DaneOrschlovsky It breaks my heart as a disabled veteran to see illegals get better treatment than many veterans that have served this country and came home injured physically or psychologically but still work 60 hours a week and pay their taxes.
I feel the exact same thing. I watched this movie when it was relased in Europe many years ago, and this scene is still haunting me. I can't believe how cruel humans can be. This is really really sad, so heart breaking, and unfortunately still exists.
I promiss I'm not trying to be edgy this movie is tragic but when me and my brother first saw this in theaters we both died laughing, to be fair my brother wasn't laughing but I laughed so loud he couldn't help but laugh too.
It was kinda funny tho , imagine going upto a person in a wheelchair expecting him to stand up and then get angry because of his inability to do so lol , this scene gave me a good laugh
@@nickybluechips7567 More like the Franco-Prussian War, lol. That guy was like 80 years old. This is 1940, so WW1 ended 22 years ago. People who served in that war would have been around 40-45 years old.
@@bowser_56_56 Yeah, have some respect for the fake atrocity movies meant to distract you from the fact the "victims" are the perpetrators of all real atrocities!
@@user-nk6fh6hn1p it's very good. It's a true story about a man who was a very well known pianist. Movie shows how he was saved and a Germsn officer befriended him .
“When good men fail to act” Good men couldn’t act because of both the soviets and the Germans. Poland is an example of bad geography during ww2 being in between the Soviet Union and Nazi Germany
@@Zionist654Nah, it's more a way to explain that it's good men in Germany, and Russia who did allow such horrifying things to happen. We have stopped today. But maybe we should restart considering that, including in authoritarian governments, the populations have a responsability towards the horrors their governments are doing. Including by having kept them in power.
esa frase ..para que el mal triunfe solo se necesita que los hombres buenos no hagan nada esta muy equivocada ..debes usar su mismo salvajismo para erradicarlos frase de wiston churchil primer ministro. la inteligencia britanica recurrio a la mentira engaño a asesinos estafadores para atacar a los alemanes el mal vence al mal
Malheureusement ou heureusement l'enfer n'existe pas. Ce qui est dit dans la bible c'est une destruction totale qui veut dire qu'il n'y aura pas de résurrection pour certaines personnes mais pas de souffrance éternelle 🚫 non
No u must watch more RU-vid shorts where the holocaust is exaggerated to make Jewish suffering seem worse. Do not question the holocaust data. Ur an antisemite. We should make children watch this instead of cartoons.
No no no, that's white people dying. We need people to see how bad the holocaust was even if it's not accurate one bit. Then we can move on to worshiping warcrimes by showing Inglorious Bastards.
The first time I saw this scene, I froze. I was paralyzed in shock and felt my heart stop for a second. Years later, it still disturbs me. Without the necessity of blood, this is one of the heaviest scenes I ever watched.
Because it makes pressure on our hearts. As normal human beings, born in a period of peace, educated to love and respect others, seeing a poor man, who probably was wounded during ww1, thrown out like trash, is a tragedy. It makes pressure on our hearts, also because, deep down, you think "hey, that could be my grandpa... poor soul". It's movie like this that remember us why we don't want those evil things to happen again. Human minds easily forget bad things far in time. Better see those things, and wound our hearts every time, than letting those things really happen.
but they thought they were the good guys, the Communists they were fighting murdered the entire royal family of Russia, like bruh the Soviets murdered princesses
Exactly. Being neutral you dont do nothing, you fail to help someone in need. So you help the oppressor. This is universal truth, this is what heppens now in Ukraine.
Yup just how no one is doing nothing about Israel killing thousands of Palestinian women and children specifically targeting civilian homes….. funny how the oppressed become the oppressors.
@@CodyFaceX That's a misattribution, Burke wrote a much longer piece which talks of when men understand each other they can see and resist evil, when seperate they get picked off one at a time, in highly "diverse" societies with differing mores and languages there is that weakened state.
Nazis doesn't want weak people in there country but in this case they properly did this because they can, Nazis just don't want disabled or weak people when THEY ARE BORN so if you got shot or something and become disabled you are fine but if you are born with it..well unlucky stats try again.
I remember seeing this scene for the first time as a kid. To think the Jews were actually treated like this is insane. I don’t understand how anyone could do such horrible things too innocent people and then sleep at night.
They may have been confused as to what they were doing. May have been a deer in headlights situation. They are also surrounded by soldiers with guns. There are obvious explanations that make more sense than "they didnt care." Stupid comment.
The tragic part is how they can clearly see the old dude is in a wheelchair; they knew he probably couldn't stand up if he wanted to, yet they still demanded he do it and murdered him when he "didn't comply". Absolutely monstrous.
@@janruudschutrups9382 nazi-sympathizers have been becoming extremely common in america the anti-semitism, homophobia and xenophobia that are essential to american conservatism finally came back around and has begun manifesting into naziism
My grand grand dad was severly beaten by Germans because he didn't take his hat off to greet them. His hands were occupied because he was holding horses. Living in Poland occupied by Germans was only about avoiding death, slowly starvation and humiliation on daily basis
My polish grandfather was beaten by russian soldiers as a boy because they wanted food. Then most of my family that didnt get out starved under soviet rule. If your point is that it was a brutal time i will fully agree. If your point is all germans were evil i completely disagree. I had family on both sides of the war german and polish. Funny that im the product of those two peoples.
@@crystllclr3743 If you so curious, than yes, every German was evil, because those good ones were killed by nazis before the war. Some just follow the orders like mindless zombie, some were eager with following that. The worst were the German neighbours, because they couldn't wait to seize his Polish neighbours belongings. My family was pushed to swap the farm with some poor German from the same village, because it couldn't be in Nazi Germany that Polish subhuman have better farm than German. They were ordered to left every private belongings. The peak humanity that German police officer that managing this swap could achieve was to allow to take a milk for infant and a dog, because my 5yo uncle was crying about the dog the most. You want to hear more stories? More disturbing stories?
Yep.What about those Two UK police officers who confronted an elderly one legged disabled man in a wheelchair with dementia at a care home by using a Taser, baton and incapacitant spray have been handed gross misconduct notices and are under investigation for manslaughter.
@@user-kw4rn1ov9x all my apologies if that part was misswriten, I meant the fact of all watching together these pieces of art via youtube shorts. I'm the first one who cried and was shocked as hell watching The Pianist and loved the movie as well. Again, my apologies if you understood it that way, I think most of the people who liked the comment are people like me, we love getting new shorts every day in chronological order allowing us to watch a movie via shorts.
@@marcgomez2412 I got what you meant and agree with you wholeheartedly. I saw schindlers list when it came out of the cinema 4 million years ago and I have seen it countless times since - so I was really shocked about how many commentors hadn't seen it. And yet I have never seen the Pianist 😖. So let's watch this together 🤗.
According to 90% of sources I can find, the 14th waffen ss division did, in fact, partake in the most horrific parts of the war crimes, alongside the most brutal units.
True there is a new Nazi cult in Canada and they are trying to get power it’s essentially just like in Germany where the Nazi invaded Germany first. Now same thing is happening in Canada. Just look up the political parties of Canada and you will see them.
@@chase4086 well just because you don’t want to know is the reason shit like this is allowed to happen people just didn’t want to bother with the reality they were faced with till it was their time To be taken.
Most of the scenes in that movie are faithful copies of reality. My neighbor who already died was Polish and Jewish, he said that he joined the Russian army and at the end of the war he worked in concentration camps for German POWs and he felt very happy when the Germans cried like little girls.
He was only human but the lesson of this should rather be not to let hate or resentment get into your heart. People are fooling themselves when they think Germans were especially devilish or inhumane to follow such a regimes will. They learned to resent Jews and when the time came people where manipulated into hating the scapegoat. This should be a lesson of history for all societies to be tolerant of people who are different, to not look down on other people as inferior and to watch carefully those who use populism and manipulation for their own ascension to power.
There's a reason for it. Our political landscape has changed and communism is on the rise. If something doesn't change, we may be facing this sooner than later. Be careful who you vote for.
There's plenty of those in the US! Sadly! Nobody wants to admit to it or talk about it....humanity is lost for some folks and that is scary bcuz that hateful seed gets planted, it grows and it spreads! It has already begun
@@Joe_blow121 I'm weird because people being murdered in the most cruel ways doesn't make me laugh? Go and look into the mirror, come back and tell me who's weird.
I’ve shed some tears throughout the whole movie but couldn’t restrain myself from laughing at that scene, the way they just lift him up in that wheelchair looks hilarious. Forgive me for being a bad person..
It's mostly from the complete lack of reaction from the old man. He doesn't talk at all, And doesn't even show facial expression, The German soldiers just wheel him out and throw him off the balcony all whilst the old man just stares into space
Mannn I thought it was a joke and he was looking at them when they were pushing him but then when they threw him out i was like woooow that bad and man A deep fall Jesus
@@vidfuel12There would have to be a lord to be able to take his name in vain my friend. Not everyone buys into fairytales and if we don't nobody has any right to bark at us and tell us what we can and can not say... I mean jesus christ man as long as nobody's being hateful they can talk however they please. Please enjoy the rest of your day.
This is what Biden and the Democrats would like to do to Republicans, just like the gestapo you see here. Well, they will face the wrath of 100 million armed American patriots if they keep up the fascist rhetoric.
What makes this scene even more realistic is the fact the family is shocked by the unimaginable monstrocity that they were in total disblief and couldn't even react until seconds before it actually happened.
That scream never ceases to make me laugh. Editting makes you think it's the guy who screams, which makes this fall pure comedy, even if darkest possible.
“ HIS BLOOD BE ON US AND OUR CHILDREN “ Matthew 27:24-25 His people killed the Son of God , the true Christ , that’s what they get for punishment .a 2000 year old punishment that hopefully continues until the end of days .
@@ernestoA.1999- Wrong answer! We - every member of the human race - from the First Adam to the last of Adam's children - we killed Jesus Christ! Yes, the Jews were a catalyst, but every evil one of us estimated 117 billion souls who've walked this planet sent Jesus to the cross. "Father, forgive them - for they know not what they do" is on all of us.
Но мне кажется никакая война не сравнится с этим это настолько бесчеловечно относиться к людям и что вытворяли немцы тех лет это просто не передать словами я просто не могу понять как человек может это сделать
I strive to wonder and or understand just how evil humanity can be without any remorse whatsoever. But I don't think anyone will ever understand what these poor people went through.
I think it boils down to whom do you serve? GOD or the devil. GOD is love and goodness. The devil is death and destruction. All the evil and hate in the world it could happen again.
@@saustin5554This is an absolutely ridiculous take "god" and the "devil" are characters in a fiction book. In truth the abillity to do great or horrible things lie in the hearts of every man and its their job to choose to do what is right for the betterment of their fellow man. I mean just look at history and see how much death, suffering, and war were all done in gods name.
You realize most people didn't have money for firearms right? Y'all always talk about this bullshit and it makes no sense nor has a place in these comments.
